Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Content

A war movie unlike any war movie that I've seen before. I'm glad to have seen it. Thanks for watching with me and I'm looking forward to your thoughts below! Thank you Sam for putting this one on my radar. 😊

Direct Link Here

Files

The Wind That Shakes The Barley (2006) | Full-Length Watchalong Reaction

Comments

Sam Ferguson (edited)

Comment edits

2026-09-06 22:00 I'm so very glad that you watched this! You certainly weren't obligated to, but I appreciate it very much. It's a heavy film, but it's one of my favorites of all time. It's unlike any war movie that I've seen too, and I've seen lots. For starters, it's an unflinchingly realistic portrayal of the Irish War of Independence, and subsequent Irish Civil War. These were complicated conflicts, as evidenced by the fact that the strife continued throughout most of the 20th Century. What is the value of a revolution if the society doesn't become more just as a result? At what cost does peace become too expensive? What happens when a movement that was united in war becomes fractured in peace? What happens when some of the revolutionaries don't want to stop revolting? These questions pop up in almost every war of liberation in human history. 'The Wind that Shakes the Barley' explores them in a way I've never seen another piece of media do, ever. It's also fascinating to see a film come out in 2006 that captures the spirit of the socialist movements of Europe in the early 20th Century. In the United States, where I live, the very word became tainted by its association with totalitarian communism during the Cold War. But democratic socialist movements sprung up all over Europe in the years between World War I and World War II, often coupled with labor rights movements and liberation movements throughout the constituent territorial possessions of Old Europe. This movie doesn't shy away from those politics. I've been fascinated with themes of rebellion, revolution, resistance, etc., since I was young. As I got older, I became particularly taken with stories that examined the human cost of those movements — the burdens borne by the people who undertake them. Very few dramatized portrayals of revolution so carefully and considerately depict the ugliness of conflicts that many reasonable people would consider justified, or even necessary. Violence, even when committed in service of a greater good, destroys our humanity. The depiction of the tragic revolutionary, the person who sacrifices every shred of who they are because they feel like it's what the moment in history demands, are always more complicated and less heroic than we want them to be. Damien O'Donovan is one of my favorite fictional characters of all time. You can feel what the war cost him. Cillian Murphy's performance puts it on full display, and won't let you look away. Even Teddy, who I think is ultimately less sympathetic than Damien, is nonetheless both sympathetic and tragic. In his own way, even if we as the audience may disagree with his ultimate choices, he's also a man destroyed by the violence he's committed in service of a cause in which he believes. As Damien said in his letter to Sinead: He's already dead inside. Another of my favorite fictional characters of all time is Luthen Rael from 'Andor', for very similar reasons. In his case, he was far more calculating and analytical in his very intentional decision to shoulder the moral burden of revolution — whereas Damien sort of stumbles his way to conviction with his feelings. But the end result is the same: Luthen's humanity is destroyed by the things he does in the service of his cause, just as Damien's is. I was so very fond of your reactions to 'Andor', and I'm happy that you were able to see this film as well. It's powerful, and important, and contains valuable insights from which we can learn in the 21st Century. And of course it's also just terrifically, devastatingly, tragically beautiful. And not enough people have seen it, in my opinion. If you'd like to see a film about this same period in Irish history, I recommend 'Michael Collins'. I don't want to spoil the story, although you may have read about some if it already if you've been reading up on Irish history. It's got a more star-studded cast, and is a little more "Hollywood", but it's still quite good. If you'd like to see another Cillian Murphy film that I don't think a lot of people have seen, check out 'Anthropoid'. He's more of a co-star than the star-star in that, but it's incredibly good. It's also quite heavy though, so maybe give yourself a break before checking it out :) Thank you again for watching this! I'm glad you liked it.
2026-07-20 07:05 I'm so very glad that you watched this! You certainly weren't obligated to, but I appreciate it very much. It's a heavy film, but it's one of my favorites of all time. It's unlike any war movie that I've seen too, and I've seen lots. For starters, it's an unflinchingly realistic portrayal of the Irish War of Independence, and subsequent Irish Civil War. These were complicated conflicts, as evidenced by the fact that the strife continued throughout most of the 20th Century. What is the value of a revolution if the society doesn't become more just as a result? At what cost does peace become too expensive? What happens when a movement that was united in war becomes fractured in peace? What happens when some of the revolutionaries don't want to stop revolting? These questions pop up in almost every war of liberation in human history. 'The Wind that Shakes the Barley' explores them in a way I've never seen another piece of media do, ever. It's also fascinating to see a film come out in 2006 that captures the spirit of the socialist movements of Europe in the early 20th Century. In the United States, where I live, the very word became tainted by its association with totalitarian communism during the Cold War. But democratic socialist movements sprung up all over Europe in the years between World War I and World War II, often coupled with labor rights movements and liberation movements throughout the constituent territorial possessions of Old Europe. This movie doesn't shy away from those politics. I've been fascinated with themes of rebellion, revolution, resistance, etc., since I was young. As I got older, I became particularly taken with stories that examined the human cost of those movements — the burdens borne by the people who undertake them. Very few dramatized portrayals of revolution so carefully and considerately depict the ugliness of conflicts that many reasonable people would consider justified, or even necessary. Violence, even when committed in service of a greater good, destroys our humanity. The depiction of the tragic revolutionary, the person who sacrifices every shred of who they are because they feel like it's what the moment in history demands. They're are always more complicated and less heroic than we want them to be. Damien O'Donovan is one of my favorite fictional characters of all time. You can feel what the war cost him. Cillian Murphy's performance puts it on full display, and won't let you look away. Even Teddy, who I think is ultimately less sympathetic than Damien, is nonetheless both sympathetic and tragic. In his own way, even if we as the audience may disagree with his ultimate choices, he's also a man destroyed by the violence he's committed in service of a cause in which he believes. As Damien said in his letter to Sinead: He's already dead inside. Another of my favorite fictional characters of all time is Luthen Rael from 'Andor', for very similar reasons. In his case, he was far more calculating and analytical in his very intentional decision to shoulder the moral burden of revolution — whereas Damien sort of stumbles his way to conviction with his feelings. But the end result is the same: Luthen's humanity is destroyed by the things he does in the service of his cause, just as Damien's is. I was so very fond of your reactions to 'Andor', and I'm happy that you were able to see this film as well. It's powerful, and important, and contains valuable insights from which we can learn in the 21st Century. And of course it's also just terrifically, devastatingly, tragically beautiful. And not enough people have seen it, in my opinion. If you'd like to see a film about this same period in Irish history, I recommend 'Michael Collins'. I don't want to spoil the story, although you may have read about some of it already if you've been reading up on Irish history. It's got a more star-studded cast, and is a little more "Hollywood", but it's still quite good. If you'd like to see another Cillian Murphy film that I don't think a lot of people have seen, check out 'Anthropoid'. He's more of a co-star than the star-star in that, but it's incredibly good. It's also quite heavy though, so maybe give yourself a break before checking it out :) Thank you again for watching this! I'm glad you liked it.

I'm so very glad that you watched this! You certainly weren't obligated to, but I appreciate it very much. It's a heavy film, but it's one of my favorites of all time. It's unlike any war movie that I've seen too, and I've seen lots. For starters, it's an unflinchingly realistic portrayal of the Irish War of Independence, and subsequent Irish Civil War. These were complicated conflicts, as evidenced by the fact that the strife continued throughout most of the 20th Century. What is the value of a revolution if the society doesn't become more just as a result? At what cost does peace become too expensive? What happens when a movement that was united in war becomes fractured in peace? What happens when some of the revolutionaries don't want to stop revolting? These questions pop up in almost every war of liberation in human history. 'The Wind that Shakes the Barley' explores them in a way I've never seen another piece of media do, ever. It's also fascinating to see a film come out in 2006 that captures the spirit of the socialist movements of Europe in the early 20th Century. In the United States, where I live, the very word became tainted by its association with totalitarian communism during the Cold War. But democratic socialist movements sprung up all over Europe in the years between World War I and World War II, often coupled with labor rights movements and liberation movements throughout the constituent territorial possessions of Old Europe. This movie doesn't shy away from those politics. I've been fascinated with themes of rebellion, revolution, resistance, etc., since I was young. As I got older, I became particularly taken with stories that examined the human cost of those movements — the burdens borne by the people who undertake them. Very few dramatized portrayals of revolution so carefully and considerately depict the ugliness of conflicts that many reasonable people would consider justified, or even necessary. Violence, even when committed in service of a greater good, destroys our humanity. The depiction of the tragic revolutionary, the person who sacrifices every shred of who they are because they feel like it's what the moment in history demands. They're are always more complicated and less heroic than we want them to be. Damien O'Donovan is one of my favorite fictional characters of all time. You can feel what the war cost him. Cillian Murphy's performance puts it on full display, and won't let you look away. Even Teddy, who I think is ultimately less sympathetic than Damien, is nonetheless both sympathetic and tragic. In his own way, even if we as the audience may disagree with his ultimate choices, he's also a man destroyed by the violence he's committed in service of a cause in which he believes. As Damien said in his letter to Sinead: He's already dead inside. Another of my favorite fictional characters of all time is Luthen Rael from 'Andor', for very similar reasons. In his case, he was far more calculating and analytical in his very intentional decision to shoulder the moral burden of revolution — whereas Damien sort of stumbles his way to conviction with his feelings. But the end result is the same: Luthen's humanity is destroyed by the things he does in the service of his cause, just as Damien's is. I was so very fond of your reactions to 'Andor', and I'm happy that you were able to see this film as well. It's powerful, and important, and contains valuable insights from which we can learn in the 21st Century. And of course it's also just terrifically, devastatingly, tragically beautiful. And not enough people have seen it, in my opinion. If you'd like to see a film about this same period in Irish history, I recommend 'Michael Collins'. I don't want to spoil the story, although you may have read about some of it already if you've been reading up on Irish history. It's got a more star-studded cast, and is a little more "Hollywood", but it's still quite good. If you'd like to see another Cillian Murphy film that I don't think a lot of people have seen, check out 'Anthropoid'. He's more of a co-star than the star-star in that, but it's incredibly good. It's also quite heavy though, so maybe give yourself a break before checking it out :) Thank you again for watching this! I'm glad you liked it.