Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Content

click here for reaction!

i mean i guess donna's back but AT WHAT COST Y'ALL????this was crazy 😭😭😭

Files

Comments

niall no chill

as you can already tell, DONNA IS SO PEAK

Dai Bowie

There she is the birthday girl! Can’t wait to see this episode hope you grabbed your tissues for this 😂❤️🫶🎉🥳🍾

Todd Burroughs

Crazy?!? HA! This season hasn't BEGUN to be that..... :)

Reina Veroft

Well I would say Dr Who was already very known in the UK with classic Who and that kinda continued with New Who but I would definitely say that kinda S1-4(5) are known as the Golden Era of Dr Who. It was absolutely massive especially in the UK and towards more of the end of the Tennant era it became internationally also more populair. But it was genuinely so big in the UK. Im not even from there and I always heard about it.

Todd Burroughs

P.P.S. My opinions/thoughts on your pre-reaction question: Tennant and the Doctor who follows him are considered the most popular ones--30s!!!! (Is there anybody here from the UK who remembers some of this mania? If so, do you remember the poll that wanted to put Tennant's face on money? LOLOL Do you remember when folks in Scotland were trying to convince him to openly push for secession from the UK during a key and close vote on the issue?) In America, where I'm from and where we discovered the original show on public television in the late '70s-early '80s, as well as in Marvel Comics [!], Tennant is best known for Doctor Who and for Killgrave (The Purple Man) on Marvel's "Jessica Jones" (and maybe now, in 2026, in "Rivals?"). IIRC, the Space Titanic Christmas Special is the top-rated Who episode. Seasons 4 and 9 of Nu Who (a nickname for the Who you are watching, as opposed to the 1963-1989 Classic Who) are considered peak by many, many Whovians.

dyffryn

The part you're on right now is considered to be the beginning of the peak of popularity, going from like S3/4 to about 7. Its popularity has actually waned a bit since the late 2000s. If it's a 10 now, it was like a 25 then!

Bradley

This is an episode you’re going to want to remember! Just fyi.

Captain Cardboard

Domi, you had a pop at the Doctor's navigating at the start, but you'll find that the Tardis doesn't always take him where he wants to go!

Captain Cardboard

Do you know, it was only yesterday that I rewatched Kinda, where the Doctor learned his trick 🪙👂!

Todd Burroughs

P.P.P.S. Keep watching and one day you will find out why the Doctor "gets things wrong" and is "not good at his job" when it comes to steering the TARDIS.

dwp

To answer your question at the start, the show 'peaked' at series 4 for views. Voyage of the Damned was the most watched episode, and series 4 as a whole was the most anticipated series with the return of Donna. Series 5 onwards did well but the slow decline started from series 7-13 - but that would happen with any show running for 10+ series

Johnny Guitar

Series 4 was probably when Doctor Who was at its most mainstream in the UK, I feel like it built and built each season. Series 5 is when it blew up in the US, as there was a big push for BBC America. It was also around the time you had super-who-lock on tumblr which popularised it more. So I guess to answer your question of when it was at its biggest within mainstream pop culture, it depends on the audience/locale.

Sean Ellingham

Regarding the length of the episodes - there are no adverts on the BBC, so a one hour show will be a lot closer to an hour than a US show. There's probably some consideration of the need for adverts for shows that are made with the intent of marketing internationally by the commercial arm of the BBC, but on the whole it's not likely to be a priority

Nat' (Evilbean)

I would say in terms of views/ratings and popularity DW peaked around series 3-4-5? smth like that. So you're right in the middle of the crazy years. I feel like if today is a 10 to you, this was like a 45 LOL

D.M. Lipkin

Was anyone able to follow what Domi was trying to say in the intro while talking about previous episodes? Didn't make a lick of sense to me.

Helen

This was an emotionally devastating one for Donna's first real trip in the Tardis. 'Not him. Don't save him!' What did poor Caecilius do to deserve that? 😂 Admittedly, he is a bit of a buffoon... It was beautiful that they managed to save the whole family. Happy birthday!!

Jonathan Giles

Massive Peter Capaldi fan. Love how Doctor Who brings in incredible actors for one off episodes. Loving S4 so far

Jamie Revell

I agree with others that the modern show was a hit from S1 here in the UK - I remember overhearing schoolchildren talking about it on the bus at the time. My impression is that it surged in popularity with S2 internationally, and perhaps again with S5, but people outside the UK may know more about that than I do. It's hard to compare popularity against the classic show, since the TV landscape was so different then - it's easy to get a large share of the total audience when there are only three channels. But that was very popular starting with the second story of S1, and, while it didn't always remain that way (or they wouldn't have eventually cancelled it) it was always well known.

Michael Jones

In regards to your questions about "The Girl In the Fireplace" and why Madame Du Pompadour died when she was only 37, well, that's because she was a real world historical figure, and that is how old the real Madame Du Pompadour was when she died. She passed of tuberculosis.

Tuckgrr

Lucius and Quintus Caecilius were real historical figures from Pompeii. It's believed Lucius died around 62 AD, and then there's loose and incomplete history surrounding Quintus. So that leaves plenty of room for Doctor Who to fill in some blanks!

Cotubug

To save you from confusion, BBC has no ads, hence why Doctor Who could vary in length

Cotubug

Doctor Who was always an iconic show since the 1960s, but season 2 with David Tennant was watched by the, like, the nation. Basically everyone watched (your friends, kids, parents, grandparents) and anyone who didn’t would still a) know it and b) know David Tennant was the Doctor.

StealthMomo

It's alright that you think this would be enough to deter Donna. You don't know her very well yet. ¯\_(ツ)_/¯

Steven

It's not your imagination, the intro music has been changed since Voyage of the Damned. It's a lot more rock heavy, it's easier to tell it's different if you listen to them back to back

Steven

The Ood were in The Impossible Planet/The Satan Pit from Series 2, which is actually getting an extended cut cinema rerelease in the UK next month!

Fr. Brench

If the show now is a 10, I'd say Doctor Who was at an 8 or 9 by season 4 in terms of popularity and recognizability. Maybe season 5 is when it became "normal" to watch in the U.S. too? (This is my best memory as a prior Classic Who fan who grew up in America; others' results may vary.)

Matt E.

So BBC episode lengths are pretty different from shows on other networks, because they're govt owned they don't have to build their time slots around advertising

ITPalg

In case you didn't know, one of the soothsayer ladies was played by the sexy red headed actress Karen Gillan (Jumanji, Marvel MCU - Nebula...)

ITPalg

FYI in case you haven't checked, when you speak, the video volume drowns you out. If you can't fix the video and mic channels, pause the video if you must speak.

FPDD

And nothing else!

FPDD

Yea especially in the UK in the 60s and 70s it was famous for kids “hiding behind the sofa” because they were so scared of the daleks

FPDD

In this episode the Doctor mentions the fire that burned down Rome and that he might have been the cause of that. Not gonna spoil anything, just gonna say if you ever do a classic Who tour The Romans from 1964 is one of the First Doctor’s best

Captain Cardboard

The High Priestess was played by Victoria Wicks.

BassoSovietico1987

Just for cool trivia information. BBC is a public broadcaster hence - no adverts during the show.

aiusepsi

Caecilius, as well as being an actual historical person, was the main character in a popular textbook used to teach Latin. Lots of people have fond memories of being introduced to Latin with sentences like “Caecilius est in horto” (Caecilius is in the garden). In my school days the Latin department did a school trip to Italy, and one of the places we went was Caecilius’s house, which felt like a bit of a pilgrimage. Long time ago; that trip was right after the first episode of season 7 of Buffy aired for the first time!

AppEyes

This is why we love Donna. Her empathy, compassion and humanity mixed with an attitude that can challenge The Doctor.

Josh

Doctor Who episodes at this point were generally around 45 minutes. Bear in mind it airs with no adverts so no advert breaks which is probably why it’s 45 not 42 - with 45 minute TV slots not hour long ones.

Josh

In terms of popularity - I was 7-8 when this episode came out. Rose’s departure in series 2 is seared into the minds of my generation. When I was a little younger playing Doctor who on the school playground was the thing. Everyone had toys from the show even if they weren’t massive fans. It was MASSIVE at this point in the show.

Joe Cleveland

The way we watch tv and what "tv" is has changed so much that I think it is really difficult to talk about "peaks". It's really difficult to compare 21st-century Who with 20th-century Who. It is even difficult to compare 2005-2010 with 2015-2020 -- with the pandemic years, with the most recent years of the show. How people watch tv is so different now. The show definitely waxes and wanes in the public consciousness, but just what that means is also difficult to say with how siloed we've all become.