Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Content

All characters engaged in sexual activity are 18 or older.

Whit

We didn't get up right away.

The tent was warm. The sleeping bag was around both of us. Marsh was on his back and I was against his side. My head was on his chest, my hand tracing the edge of the gauze on his shoulder. His arm was around me. Heavy. His fingers were in my hair, moving slow. Not petting, just touching.

The light through the tent walls was pale gold. Early. The forest was quiet except for the creek and a bird I'd learned to recognize. Steller's jay, loud and obnoxious, screaming from the trees like it had an opinion about everything. Camp robber. Marsh's word. I'd never known what a Steller's jay was before this week.

"What time do you think it is?" I asked.

"Early. Seven maybe."

"We don't have to rush?"

"No."

His fingers kept moving in my hair. My hand kept tracing the gauze. We were stalling and we both knew it. Every minute in the tent was a minute we weren't walking toward the endpoint. Every minute we weren't walking was a minute we still had together.

I turned my face into his chest. Breathed him in. The smell I'd been chasing since the lake. Warm skin, clean sweat, the pheromone layer I'd become addicted to. It was Marsh. It was my favorite smell in the world and after today I wouldn't have it anymore.

My mouth was against his skin. "Your heart's going fast."

His chest vibrated. A laugh, almost. "Yeah."

I lifted my head. Looked at him. His face in the morning light. The freckles, the green eyes, the scar through his eyebrow. The bite mark on his shoulder was fading. In a few days it would be gone. The only proof that my mouth had been there.

He looked at me. His hand moved from my hair to my jaw. His thumb traced my cheekbone. Slow. The way you touch something you're trying to memorize.

"We should probably get going." Quiet. Not moving.

"Probably."

Neither of us moved.

We packed up slow. Everything coming down for the last time. I rolled the sleeping bags. Both of them, mine and his dad's, and strapped them to my pack. Took down the tent. Footprint, poles, fly, stakes. The motions were automatic now. My hands knew the steps the way they knew how to tie a bowline or build a fire. Five days ago I couldn't get a pole into a grommet. Now I was breaking camp like I'd been doing it for years.

Marsh watched from the log. His shoulder was better but I didn't let him carry anything extra. He didn't argue. That was new too. Marsh not arguing about carrying his own weight. Somewhere in the last few days he'd stopped fighting me on it.

The campsite looked empty when we were done. Just dirt and rocks and the circle of the fire pit and the two trees where the tarp had been. No sign we'd been here. No sign that anything had happened in this spot. No sign that this is where I'd lost my virginity last night.

I pulled the map out of my pack and did my best to figure out exactly where we were. I put a small dot on the map. Marsh raised an eyebrow for a second before he realized what I was doing. He stepped next to me and rested his head against mine for a moment. Then we shouldered our packs. Marsh checked the compass. Set a bearing. Started walking.

I followed him into the trees for the last time.

The hike was easy. Flat ground, open forest, the terrain descending gently through bigleaf maples and moss-covered nurse logs. We covered ground fast. Faster than any day of hiking because the bushwhacking was over. The forest was practically rolling out a carpet for us.

We hit the maintained trail around mid-morning. An actual trail. Graded. Wide enough for two. Boot prints in the mud that weren't ours. A trail marker nailed to a tree. Orange diamond, reflective, the most civilized thing I'd seen in five days.

I stopped and stared at it. A piece of plastic nailed to a tree. It shouldn't have felt like anything. But it felt like the end.

"Weird, right?" Marsh was looking at it too.

"Yeah."

We walked. Side by side now. The trail was wide enough. Our arms brushed. The pack straps clicked against each other when we walked close.

"What are you looking forward to most?" I asked.

"Hot shower."

"God, yes."

"Real food. Like... a burger. A real burger. Not something from a pouch."

"With fries?"

"Obviously with fries. What kind of question is that?"

I smiled. "I want coffee. Real coffee. From an actual machine. Not a Jetboil."

"You have fancy espresso shit at home?"

"I have fancy espresso shit. Yes."

He grinned. I grinned. And underneath the grins we were both doing the thing where you talk about what you're looking forward to because talking about what you're losing is too hard.

The trail curved south. The trees were thinning. I could see more sky than I'd seen in days. Pale blue through the gaps, a few clouds. The endpoint was ahead. A mile, maybe two.

"So what happens when you get back?" I asked. Casual. Like it was a normal question and not me trying my best to not get emotional.

"Work. The dock." He stepped over a root. "Check on Benji. Make sure the apartment's still standing. Start making money again. As long as nobody realized we were missing."

"They didn't."

"I hope." He looked at me. "What about you?"

"My dad's got a college picked out. I don't know which of the ones it is that I got accepted to. He hasn't told me yet." I kicked a rock off the trail. "I'll go home. Back to the house. Back to the shitty guys I hang out with. Back to Dr. Pratt on Tuesdays and Thursdays."

"You going to tell Pratt about this?"

I looked at the trail. The boot prints. The orange diamond markers appearing every hundred yards now like breadcrumbs leading back to the real world.

"I don't know. Probably. He's the only person I'd tell."

"About going off the trail?"

"About you."

Marsh was quiet for a few steps. His jaw worked. Not an angry clench.

"You could text me," he offered. To the trail. Not to me. Nervous.

"Yeah?"

"I have a phone. It's shitty but it works."

"Okay."

"Okay."

We walked. The endpoint was close. I could feel it. The trail getting wider, the forest pulling back, the sense of space opening up ahead.

We found the convergence area about an hour before anyone else showed up.

A clearing. Wide. A fire pit in the center, log benches, a trail sign marking the junction of the two routes. North and south. At the far side was a Jeep parked along the tree line. The clearing was empty. Just us and the silence.

We sat in the tree line. Twenty feet back from the clearing, behind a fallen log covered in ferns. Close enough to see the trail signs. Far enough that nobody walking in would see us.

Marsh set his pack down. I set mine down. We sat on the log side by side. Our shoulders touching. The forest was quiet around us.

"What are you going to do?" I asked. "After. Like... with your life. Not just the dock."

He picked up a stick. Turned it in his hands. "I don't know. Nobody's ever asked me that."

"I'm asking."

"I know." He snapped the stick. Tossed the pieces. "I'd like to... I don't know. Maybe something with the outdoors. Forestry. Trail maintenance. Something where I'm outside and using my hands." He shook his head. "Doesn't matter. Can't afford school. Can't leave Benji."

"It matters."

"Whit."

"It does."

He looked at me. Long. His green eyes in the filtered light. The freckles. The jaw. The face I'd been looking at for five days and wasn't ready to stop looking at.

"What about you?" he asked. "If you could do anything. Not your dad's plan. Yours."

"Fragrance chemistry." No hesitation. First time I'd ever said it without qualifying it or making a joke. "I want to make perfume. I want to study how scent works. The molecules, the combinations, why certain things make people feel certain ways. I want to understand why..." I stopped.

"Why what?"

"Why you smell the way you do."

He stared at me. Then he laughed. "That's your dream? Figuring out why I stink?"

"You don't stink. You haven't stunk since the lake." I picked at the bark on the log. "You smell like... I can't describe it. I've tried. I've been trying for three days. I know the vocabulary for every cologne in the world and I can't find words for what you smell like." I glanced at him, nervous. "Can I?" My eyes darted to his armpit.

He grinned and nodded, lifting his arm up. I leaned in and smelled him. Musk. Anamalic. But also... sandalwood? Burnt pine? The notes escaped still. My head came to rest on his shoulder.

He was quiet. His hand found mine on the log. Our fingers laced together. Loose. Easy. Like we'd been doing it for years instead of days.

We sat there. The tree line. The empty clearing. His thumb rubbing the back of my hand.

"I don't want to go back."

"I know."

"Not to the program. To... everything. Mercer Island. The house. Being the guy I was before."

"You're not the guy you were before."

"Everyone else thinks I am."

His fingers tightened around mine. We sat with that for a while. The clearing was still empty but the world was still coming whether we wanted it to or not.

Voices. Faint. Coming from the north trail.

My stomach dropped. Marsh's hand squeezed mine once and then let go. The sudden absence hurt physically. I lifted my head off his shoulder.

We sat in the ferns and watched the tree line across the clearing. The voices got louder. I could hear Dario before I saw him. His voice carrying through the trees, talking at full volume about something, same as always. Then figures. Packs. The north group emerging from the trail into the clearing.

Torres was in front. Dario behind him. Then Vadim. Then Pace and the others, strung out along the trail. They walked into the clearing, dropped their packs and stood there blinking in the open air.

My heart was hammering. Marsh was next to me, still, watching. Waiting.

The south group came in ten minutes later. Wade leading, his beanie pushed back, clipboard in hand. Perry. Lachlan. The others. They walked into the clearing from the other trail and the two groups merged and suddenly there were people everywhere. Guys talking, packs hitting the ground, Wade talking to Dario, Torres standing off to the side.

Lachlan said something to Vadim. A second later Lachlan was on the ground holding his face. Torres was moving fast towards him.

Chaos. Wade rushing over. Voices shouting. Perry pulling Lachlan back to his feet. Torres had Vadim by the arm, walking him away from the group, his voice low and steady. Dario was standing between the groups with his hands up like a traffic cop. Everyone was looking at Vadim. Nobody was looking at the tree line.

Marsh grabbed my arm. "Now."

We grabbed our packs. Walked out of the trees. Across the clearing. Into the cluster of guys like we'd been there the whole time. I shrugged my pack off next to Perry's. Marsh dropped his next to Dario's. We didn't look at each other. Didn't speak. Just became two guys in a group of guys who'd finished a hike.

My hands were shaking. I shoved them in my pockets.

Nobody looked at us. Nobody asked where we'd been. The chaos was still churning. Torres walking Vadim toward the Jeep, Lachlan sitting on a log with his hand over his eye, Wade flipping through his clipboard trying to restore order.

I stood in the clearing with my pack at my feet and my hands in my pockets and tried to look casual.

Marsh was standing next to Dario, nodding at whatever Dario was saying. His face was neutral. Relaxed. The guy from the loading dock. The guy who didn't give a shit. Nobody looking at him would see anything different.

I wondered what people saw when they looked at me. Did they see a guy who had just finished a wilderness program? Or did they see a guy who had just fallen in love and lost his virginity in the forest to the guy standing ten feet away.

I looked at him across the group. He looked at me. One second. The whole trail in that one second. The tent, the river, the lake, the fire, his mouth, his hands, him inside me, his arm across my chest in the dark. All of it. Right there. And nobody saw it.

Nobody would ever see it.

The biggest thing that had ever happened to me was a secret I was carrying deep inside me. And the guy who shared it was ten feet away pretending we were strangers.

I looked at the dirt. Bit my thumbnail. Tasted blood.

Files

Comments

Chris

Well done! The scuffle was a very clever way to have them sneak back into the group without drawing attention. Those in group A will just assume as they have been for days, that they were part of group B. And vice versa. Its sad that they seem to think this is the end of their relationship. They must find a way. I have faith in GG. Should I?

Davide

Whit marking on the map the place him and Marsh lost their virginity to each other was too sweet. Unsurprisingly, they don't think they can remain together once they return to their lives. We're going to need a second season for them to work something out, because one more chapter isn't enough and we need a happy ending.

Jon

It has to come out that they weren’t with either group. This is a court ordered thing to clear their record right? This whole program wasn’t just about the A and B groups on the trail. Torres and Wade have to compare notes and opinions on each of the campers and submit reports to the court. When they don’t have any info on Whit and Marsh on the trail, questions will be asked.

Sascha-Niklas

That was more than I was hoping for but far less than they both deserve. We really need a season 2!

BayAreaSooner

"I don't want to go back." "I know." "Not to the program. To... everything. Mercer Island. The house. Being the guy I was before." "You're not the guy you were before." "Everyone else thinks I am ———————————————— This is sad, this is their reality. Can they remove the influences in their lives in order to change their reality? One more chapter cannot answer these and all the other questions. We have to a season 2. I will write a strongly worded letter to my congressman if that is what it takes (no clue who my congressman is).

Jules

Yes, that’s the next biggest mystery to solve!!

Jules

We didn’t expect season 2 of The Crease and it just fell in our laps. But this time … it’d be a crime to stop it after just one more chapter, unless that chapter is 20 chapters long 😂

Sascha-Niklas

I am absolutely not ready to let them go.

Sascha-Niklas

Oh, go away. 🤣 This is not the time for any realism.

Devin

But they were getting check marks for everything they accomplished. So what happens when both counselors ask about these two?

Devin

Exactly! You get it!

Devin

Neither of them talked about how far they lived from one another. Just texting. One thing they haven’t figured out. This is a court appointed program. Something has to be sent to the courts. These guys received a checkmark for everything. So what happens now? How do they get their approvals?

Chris

Jedi mind trick?

Jules

👋 “These are not the wilderness lovers you’re looking for.” 👋

Michael Kupperberg

This was way too close to the bone. Granted, nothing the same or similar situation, but the wilds of different states and people. At each stopping point, I had to do something minor to hold back the memories. Good Bye is the saddest song to sing. These two have something, something that being eighteen doesn’t cover. They are not too young to be together, to continue as one. Maybe Marsh’s dad gets early release, maybe Whit’s mom decides enough is enough and leaves her husband. The Universe can and does offer an infinite number of ways, may Whit and Marsh find at least one.

Tony

🌲💔 CHAPTER NINETEEN — “THE WORLD WAS STILL COMING.” An imagined session with Dr. Pratt I think this chapter deserves something different. Not jokes. Not predictions scattered throughout. Not even a normal psychological summation. Because Chapter Nineteen feels like grief. Nothing terrible actually happens. Marsh doesn't reject Whit. Nobody discovers them. They don't even say goodbye. And somehow that makes it hurt more. So I imagine Whit back home, sitting in that familiar chair across from Dr. Pratt on Tuesday. And for the first time in five years of therapy, Dr. Pratt is about to meet the Whit who came back from the woods. DR. PRATT: You look different. WHIT: Everybody keeps saying things like that. DR. PRATT: I didn't say you look different. I said you are different. Whit looks toward the window. WHIT: I met someone. Dr. Pratt waits. Whit laughs nervously. WHIT: See? That's exactly what Marsh does. DR. PRATT: Who's Marsh? And suddenly Whit's eyes fill. Because there's the question. Who's Marsh? How do you explain five days that changed your entire understanding of yourself? “We didn't get up right away.” WHIT: On our last morning, we knew we had to leave. DR. PRATT: But you didn't. WHIT: Not right away. DR. PRATT: Why? WHIT: Because every minute we stayed in that tent was another minute before it ended. That's the first heartbreak of this chapter. They aren't lazy. They're stalling time. Marsh's fingers move through Whit's hair. Whit traces Marsh's bandage. Neither says please don't make this end. They don't have to. Every minute they don't move is another minute where they're still them. WHIT: I memorized him. DR. PRATT: What do you mean? WHIT: His face. His freckles. His scar. His smell. Even the bite mark on his shoulder was disappearing. DR. PRATT: And that bothered you? WHIT: It was proof I'd been there. Silence. DR. PRATT: Whit… were you afraid of losing Marsh? WHIT: I was afraid of losing proof that any of it happened. 💔 Because that's what Whit does throughout this chapter. He puts a dot on the map where their campsite was. There's no sign left in the forest that anything happened there. So Whit marks it. This happened here. We happened here. 🌲 And then they find the trail. WHIT: It was just an orange plastic marker. DR. PRATT: But? WHIT: It felt like the end. For an entire story called Off-Trail, this moment is enormous. They've finally found the trail. And neither one wants it. The trail represents everything waiting outside those woods: Marsh's dock, Benji, bills, Whit's father, college, Mercer Island, friends who don't really know him. And notice something beautiful. The trail is finally wide enough for two. So they walk side by side. They started this journey as two boys who could barely tolerate each other. They leave the wilderness walking beside each other... talking about burgers and coffee because talking about goodbye would hurt too much. 📱 “You could text me.” DR. PRATT: Did you make plans to see each other? Whit looks down. WHIT: He said I could text him. DR. PRATT: How did he say it? WHIT: To the trail. He couldn't look at me. DR. PRATT: And what did you say? WHIT: Okay. DR. PRATT: That's it? WHIT: He said okay too. Dr. Pratt smiles slightly. DR. PRATT: Two remarkably articulate young men. 😂💔 But for Marsh? “You could text me” is enormous. Marsh doesn't make promises he doesn't know how to keep. He doesn't say forever. He doesn't say, boyfriend. He simply creates a bridge between the woods and the real world. This doesn't have to end here. And Whit tells Marsh something equally enormous. When Marsh asks whether he'll tell Dr. Pratt about leaving the trail, Whit says: “About you.” Marsh has become important enough to enter the one place Whit has always kept his deepest self. ❤️ Then they finally talk about dreams. This part broke me. Whit asks Marsh what he wants from his life. And Marsh answers: “Nobody's ever asked me that.” Of course they haven't. Everyone needs something from Marsh. His mother needs help. Benji needs protection. The dock needs his labor. Life needs money. Marsh has spent so long answering “What needs to be done?” that nobody bothered asking: “What do you want?” Maybe forestry. Trail maintenance. Working outside. And Whit says two simple words: “It matters.” God. Maybe nobody has ever told Marsh that his dreams matter because Marsh himself has never been allowed the luxury of treating them as important. Then Marsh asks Whit the same question. Not his father's plan. His. And Whit finally says it without embarrassment: Fragrance chemistry. These two boys aren't only learning who the other is. They're beginning to imagine who the other could become. 🥹 “I don't want to go back.” Then Whit finally says what the entire chapter has been saying. WHIT: I told him I didn't want to go back. DR. PRATT: To the program? WHIT: No. To being who I was before. DR. PRATT: What did Marsh say? Whit swallows. WHIT: “You're not the guy you were before.” And I think that's one of the most important things Marsh has ever said to him. Whit answers: “Everyone else thinks I am.” Marsh squeezes his hand. Because Marsh understands. The frightening part isn't changing. It's going home to people who still expect the old version of you. 💔 And then the world arrives. Voices. The other boys. The counselors. The clearing fills. Marsh squeezes Whit's hand once... and lets go. That physical absence hurts Whit. Then they walk into the group and perform the versions of themselves everyone recognizes. Marsh becomes Loading-Dock Marsh again. Whit becomes whatever everyone expects Whit Hale to be. Ten feet apart. Strangers. And nobody notices. DR. PRATT: What hurt most? Whit doesn't answer immediately. WHIT: Nobody knew. DR. PRATT: Knew what? WHIT: That the biggest thing that ever happened to me had just happened. His voice breaks. WHIT: Marsh was standing ten feet away. DR. PRATT: Did he look at you? WHIT: Once. DR. PRATT: And? WHIT: Everything was there. The tent. The river. The lake. The fire. Everything they'd told each other. Everything they'd become. One second. And nobody else could see any of it. DR. PRATT: Whit, you said nobody could see it. WHIT: They couldn't. DR. PRATT: Marsh could. Silence. DR. PRATT: And you could. Whit looks up. DR. PRATT: Something doesn't become less real simply because it belongs only to two people. 🥹❤️ 🌲 And now… Chapter Twenty. Waiting for Marsh's POV It has to be Marsh. Because Whit has given us the grief of leaving. Now I want to know what happens inside Marsh when he goes home. Back to the dock. Back to checking whether Benji ate. Back to his mother. Back to carrying things. Back to the same apartment, the same responsibilities, the same life he had before. Except Marsh isn't the same person returning to it. And somewhere else, Whit goes back to Mercer Island. His father. College plans. Dr. Pratt. His espresso machine. His fragrances. Two completely different worlds again. But this time there's a phone. 📱❤️ And that's why I don't think Chapter Twenty needs some enormous declaration of love. I think it needs something much smaller. Marsh looking at Whit's name on his phone. Thinking about the guy who carried his father's sleeping bag. The guy who cleaned his wounds. The guy who asked what Marsh wanted from life when apparently nobody ever had. And then Marsh has to make one final choice. Because in the wilderness, circumstances kept them together. At home, nothing will. If Marsh texts Whit now, it won't be because they're sharing a tent. It won't be because they're lost. It won't be because they need each other to navigate. It will simply mean: I came home. I went back to my life. And I still choose you. 🥹❤️🌲 And THAT is why I need Season Two. Because Chapter Twenty can tell us whether they stay connected. But another season could tell us whether two boys who found each other off-trail can build a life together once the trail splits in two. ❤️

Tony

Harsh!

Tony

Michael, this one hurt. ❤️ And I think “Goodbye is the saddest song to sing” captures the entire chapter. What makes it worse is that Whit and Marsh aren't really saying goodbye—they're desperately avoiding saying it. 🥹 Burgers, coffee, work, college… anything except “What happens to us?” And I completely agree about eighteen: they may be young, but what happened between them wasn't shallow. They saw parts of each other that nobody else bothered to see. ❤️ I love your last thought most—the universe doesn't need to give them an easy road, just one road that still leads back to each other. 🌲❤️

Tony

Devin, THAT is the little administrative grenade nobody is talking about. 😂📋 They basically disappeared from a court-ordered wilderness program for five days, successfully slipped back into the group during the Vadim/Lachlan chaos, and apparently collected their checkmarks like two innocent Boy Scouts. 🤣 But you're right—somebody presumably has to submit a completion report to the court. So either they pulled off the greatest wilderness-program heist in history… or GG still has one very uncomfortable surprise waiting in Chapter 20. 😳🌲 And the distance question is huge too: “You can text me” is adorable, boys, but eventually Google Maps is going to enter this relationship. 😂❤️

Tony

John, “Everyone else thinks I am” absolutely destroyed me. 😭❤️ That may be one of the saddest lines in the entire story because Whit knows he has changed, Marsh knows he has changed—but they're walking straight back into lives that expect them to become their old selves again. And THAT is the real question: can they protect the people they became in the woods once all those outside influences come rushing back? 🌲💔 One chapter cannot possibly answer that. So yes, John, FIND YOUR CONGRESSMAN. 😂📬 I don't care if this is outside his jurisdiction—we need federal intervention and an emergency authorization for Season Two. 🤣❤️

Tony

Sascha-Niklas: EXACTLY. 😭❤️ It somehow gave us so much and nowhere near enough. These boys have only just figured out how to be themselves with each other, and now we're supposed to watch them walk back into separate lives and say, “Well, that was lovely!” ABSOLUTELY NOT. 😂🌲 I am not ready to let them go either. Season Two or we riot politely. 🤣❤️

Tony

Jules: 😂😂 YES! The Crease taught us that GG is perfectly capable of dropping a Season Two on us, so unfortunately we now know precedent exists. ⚖️🤣 And I completely agree: ending Off-Trail after one more chapter would be a literary crime unless Chapter 20 begins “Chapter One of Twenty.” 😂❤️🌲 I need Marsh at the dock, Whit with Dr. Pratt, the first text, the first visit, Benji meeting Whit, Whit entering Marsh's world, Marsh entering Whit's—and approximately 19 additional chapters for emotional damages. 😭🤣❤️

Tony

Jon, I think you're right. 😂📋 The Great Wilderness Heist cannot possibly survive the paperwork. Torres thinks Marsh was with Wade, Wade presumably thinks Whit was with Torres, and eventually those two have to compare notes for the court and realize, “Wait… you didn’t have them either?!” 😳🤣 Five days with no counselor observations is a pretty enormous hole in a court-ordered program. So either GG has one hell of a surprise waiting in Chapter 20… or we just found another reason Season Two is legally required. ⚖️😂🌲❤️

Tony

Davide, that little dot on the map absolutely got me. 🥹❤️ The campsite disappeared without leaving any evidence, so Whit basically said, “Nope. This happened. WE happened. I’m marking it.” 🌲📍😭 And I agree—one chapter cannot possibly resolve what happens when two boys from completely different worlds go home. We didn't spend 19 chapters falling in love with these two just to get “Thanks for hiking with us!” 😂 Absolutely not. Season Two—and yes, GG, we are demanding the happy ending. ❤️🤣

Tony

Chris, the scuffle was BRILLIANT. 😂 While everyone is dealing with Vadim and Lachlan, Whit and Marsh casually stroll back in like, “What? We’ve been here the whole time.” 🤣🌲 But that last question—should we have faith in GG? Chris, I'm reminded of Agatha Christie: when an author has spent this long carefully placing clues, you assume every tiny detail is there for a reason. 😂🔎 GG has spent 19 chapters giving us the map, the compass, the sleeping bag, “let it breathe,” the headlamp, the damn armpit 🤣❤️—there is NO WAY all those emotional clues lead to “Anyway, have a nice life.” So yes, I have faith in GG… but I'm keeping my attorney and therapist on standby until Chapter 20 drops. 😂😭❤️

Tony

Dev, good point!

Devin

Well Tony, I think when the counselors discover that neither one had them with them and they were supposed to be supervised, they will pass them with flying colors. It was the counselors that are liable. Remember, Marsh left with no food. Only granola bars and some other bar. It was Whit that saved the day with the food. Marsh was good with setting up, but food is an essential and he’s not quite Daniel Boone yet. The counselors need these boys to pass. I think FaceTime may have to suffice until they get a weekend off somewhere.

Davide

Whit and Marsh's time together on the trail is about to end. That's why they don't get up right away, they moment they do it will feel the start of walking towards the end of what happened between them. Whit notices the physical reminders of this are disappearing, the bite mark of Marsh shoulder and any sign that they were camped in that spot. So he marks the place where they lost their virginities on the map, but it's not about the sex. It's about doing it with the person they like and wish they could be together, not a random hookup. The mentions of Whit having fancy espresso shit at home and Marsh having a shitty phone are a reminder to the readers of the different lives they have, which makes it difficult for them to stay together. But they'll at least stay in touch, Marsh suggests texting. And he can't even look at Whit while he says it, the thought of being limited to that is too painful. I trust in their ability to find a way to become boyfriends, but it's not going to be easy. Achieving that and dealing whatever will come from it requires a whole season, which GG needs to write. They talk about the future and no one has asked that to Marsh, he's in a world where people do whatever they need to get by, not what they wish they could do. But Whit says that what he wants matters, and Marsh reciprocates that what Whit wants also matters, not just his father's plan. Season needs to make both dreams a reality. Marsh wants something involving the forest and trails, Whit wants fragrance chemistry, and they're both perfect fits for them. Whit wanting to figure out how to assemble Eau de Marsh is funny and sweet. I'm not sure which of them says "You're not the guy you were before.", with the other one replying "Everyone else thinks I am.", but it doesn't matter because it's true for both. The time they spent together on the trail has changed them, but they're going back to a world where people don't know that and they'll be expected to act like their old selves. We saw how this being a secret is already hurting Whit and that's only among guys he barely knows, it's going to hurt both of them more when they're back home and no one knows about them. Using the chaos of the fight to join the group and act like they've been there the whole time was a great plan. But surely this can't fool Torres and Wade for long, they've been keeping track of their performances and they'll see that neither of them has entries for Whit and Marsh. But they'll know that they did it in hard mode, with no support from counsellors and no actual trail, and still arrived in time. Maybe that will lead them to conclude they showed they have all the skill the program is about and say that they achieve the court mandate.

Davide

You captured very well how painful the return to their regular lives will be for Whit and Marsh. Which is why we need a season two, we can't have a happy ending without it.

Tony

I thought it was going to be Sasquatch. But is there really a difference? In any case, I'm sure he will be delicious 😋

Tony

Season 2?

Tony

💯 Devin!

Tony

Thanks 😊... likewise sir!

Tony

💯 Davide... we won't know what everything looks like until that last chapter... 😕 but unless Sasquatch or Bigfoot eats them both, we need a season 2.

Tony

Davide, I think you nailed the sadness of this chapter. 🥹❤️ That dot on the map wasn't really marking where they had sex—it was Whit refusing to let the place where they became them simply disappear. 📍🌲 And I LOVE the contrast between fancy espresso shit and a shitty phone 😂 because GG keeps reminding us that leaving the woods means returning to two completely different realities. That “You’re not the guy you were before / Everyone else thinks I am” exchange may actually apply perfectly to BOTH of them. They changed together, but everyone waiting at home still knows the old Whit and old Marsh. That's why I think Season Two practically writes itself: can they protect these new versions of themselves when the world starts demanding the old ones back? ❤️ And I'm REALLY curious about Torres and Wade. 😂 Their brilliant little Group A/Group B scam may survive the boys, but paperwork has a longer memory. Once those counselors compare notes, somebody is going to discover five days of mysteriously blank Marsh-and-Whit documentation. 🤣📋 But I love your possibility: instead of automatically destroying their completion, maybe the counselors realize these two accidentally completed the program on EXTREME MODE—no trail, no counselors, injured shoulder, and somehow they still navigated themselves to the endpoint. 😂🌲 Whatever happens, GG has one chapter to deal with all this, which is precisely why I am once again submitting my completely unbiased professional diagnosis: SEASON TWO REQUIRED. ❤️😂

Jules

Why put a dot on the map if you’re not going back there someday?? And a hint of a Star Wars reference … “I don’t want go back.” (“I love you.”) “I know.”

Sascha-Niklas

Exactly, but I'm not sure we'd manage to stay polite.

Sascha-Niklas

YES! I see a whole book!🤣 Several seasons. 😜