Thirst Trap - Chapter 20 (Patreon)
Content
All characters engaged in sexual activity are 18 or older.
Jude
"What would make you happy? Ya know, in life."
Quinn's eyes snapped to mine.
We both knew the answer. It was sitting right there between us, obvious as the legs I had draped across his lap, obvious as the way his hand had been resting on my leg for the past hour like it belonged there. The answer was you. The answer was this. And I was looking at him, waiting to see if he'd say it.
He didn't.
"I don't know." His gaze slid away from mine, back to the window, the city lights, the safe neutral distance of the Seattle skyline. "Stability, I guess. Feeling like I belong somewhere. Having someone to come home to."
Someone.
Not you.
Close enough to make my chest tight. Not close enough to mean anything.
We'd been on this couch for hours. After the whole "just being you" thing, after I'd stood there like an idiot with nothing to say, Quinn had just... waited. Hadn't pushed. Hadn't made it weird. Eventually I'd put my shirt back on and sat down next to him, and then my legs had ended up across his lap, and then we'd started talking.
Real talking. Not flirting, not content strategy, not any of the bullshit I usually hid behind.
He'd told me about growing up in Connecticut. Private schools, parents who loved him but didn't know him, the suffocating pressure of being the kid who had everything and still felt empty. I'd asked what it was like, having money. He'd said it was weird. That people assumed it made everything easier, but it just made different things hard. That he'd spent most of his childhood performing for his parents' friends, being the smart one, the polite one, the one who'd go to a good college and get a good job and make everyone proud.
"Did you? Make them proud?"
"I guess. I don't know. I did everything right. Good school, good grades, good job. But I'm still..." He'd trailed off.
"Still what?"
"Alone in Seattle. Not talking to them about anything that matters. Still performing, just in a different way."
That had hit me harder than I expected.
I'd told him about Tanner and Ashlyn leaving, about the way my friend group had evaporated overnight, about scrolling through their college posts and feeling like I was watching life happen to everyone except me. He'd asked if I was jealous. I'd said no at first, then admitted yeah, kind of. Not of the college stuff. I wasn't built for more school. But of the having-somewhere-to-be. The belonging.
He'd asked about my mom. I'd deflected. Said we didn't get along. He'd nodded like he understood, hadn't pushed, and I'd been grateful and guilty at the same time. Grateful he didn't make me explain. Guilty because the truth was so much worse than "we don't get along."
He'd told me about coming out to himself. Not to anyone else, just to himself, alone in his college dorm room at two in the morning, finally letting himself think the word gay without flinching. He'd said it was like his whole body exhaled.
I'd listened and tried not to think too hard about why that story made my throat tight.
We'd talked about Seattle. About Texas. About what it felt like to want more than you had, to know you were missing a piece but not know which one. We'd talked about loneliness and ambition and the exhausting work of pretending to be okay. We'd talked until my legs fell asleep against his thighs.
And now he was telling me he wanted someone to come home to, and his hand was warm on my ankle, and this was our last night.
Tomorrow I'd be on a plane back to Houston. Back to my shitty apartment and my shitty job and my mom who probably hadn't noticed I was gone. Back to filming TikToks against the one presentable wall in my bedroom and pretending my life was something it wasn't.
I didn't want to go.
The thought hit me harder than I expected. I didn't want to leave this apartment, this city, this couch. I didn't want to stop feeling his hand on my skin. I didn't want to go back to being alone.
I didn't want to leave him.
"We should probably head to bed." Quinn's voice was quiet.
The words were a door closing.
"Yeah." I pulled my legs off his lap, immediately missing the warmth of his hand. "Probably should."
We stood up. Stretched. The apartment felt different at night. Darker, quieter, more intimate. I followed him down the hallway toward the bedrooms, hyperaware of how close we were walking, how easy it would be to reach out and touch him.
We stopped between our two doors. His room on the left. The guest room on the right.
"So."
"So."
He wasn't looking at me. He was looking at his door, his hand on the handle, like he was working up the courage to go through it.
"If you want, I could... sleep in your room."
Quinn went still.
"Not like... I mean, just sleep. If you wanted. Company." I was rambling. Why was I rambling? "It's our last night and I just thought... I don't know. Forget it. It's stupid."
"It's not stupid."
"It's kind of stupid."
"Jude." He finally looked at me. His eyes were dark, serious, and there was a rawness in them that made my breath catch. "I can't."
"Okay."
"It's not that I don't want..." He stopped. Took a breath. "I don't trust myself to behave. If you were in my bed. I don't think I could..."
"Okay. It's fine. I get it."
I opened my mouth.
Who said you have to behave?
The words were right there. Right on the tip of my tongue. All I had to do was say them and everything would change. He'd look at me differently. He'd touch me differently. The line we'd been dancing around all weekend would disappear and we'd be somewhere new, somewhere I'd never been, somewhere that terrified me.
I closed my mouth.
"Goodnight, Quinn."
"Goodnight, Jude."
I went into the guest room. Closed the door. Leaned against it and let out a breath I didn't know I'd been holding.
What the fuck was I doing?
I couldn't sleep.
The sheets smelled like Quinn's laundry detergent. The pillow was too soft. The bed was too big and too empty and I kept thinking about him on the other side of the wall, probably lying awake too, probably thinking about...
My phone buzzed.
I grabbed it off the nightstand. Squinted at the screen.
Quinn: Can't sleep
I smiled in the dark.
Jude: same
Jude: you were serious when you told me I'd be safe here with you
Three dots. Disappearing. Reappearing.
Quinn: You made it really hard
Jude: behaving or your dick?
A second of silence. Then I heard him laugh through the wall. Loud.
I grinned.
Quinn: Both
Quinn: You're not like most straight guys I've met
My thumb hovered over the keyboard. I'm not straight sat on my fingertips, but I couldn't type it. Couldn't let those words exist in writing, where they'd be real, where I'd have to look at them.
Jude: Should I be offended?
Quinn: Jury's still out...
I laughed. Softer than his laugh, but I wondered if he heard it too.
Jude: wow rude
Quinn: I'm kidding
Quinn: Mostly
Jude: MOSTLY?
Quinn: Okay fine it's a compliment
Quinn: A big one
I stared at those words. A compliment. A big one. My chest got tight.
Quinn: Seriously though, you make it so hard to not embarrass myself
Jude: what do you mean?
Quinn: When you're flirting like that...
Jude: why would that embarrass you?
The dots appeared. Disappeared. Appeared again. He was typing something, deleting it, trying again.
Quinn: Because... you realize I'm into you, right?
I stared at the screen.
We'd been dancing around it all weekend. The flirting, the touches, the way he looked at me when he thought I wasn't paying attention. But seeing it typed out like that made it real in a way it hadn't been before. You realize I'm into you, right?
Jude: yeah...
I didn't know what else to say. Yeah, I knew. Yeah, I'd been using it. Yeah, I'd been pushing his buttons because I liked the way he reacted, liked the way his face got red, liked the way his voice went rough when I got too close.
Yeah, I knew.
Quinn: Well it's really hard to not get carried away when you're flirting like that. you're like...
The message cut off. Dots appeared.
Jude: what?
A long pause. Longer than any of the others. I could picture him on the other side of the wall, staring at his phone, trying to decide whether to hit send.
Quinn: Perfect...
My heart stopped.
Jude: I'm not perfect
Quinn: Well you've got me fooled
I put the phone down.
I couldn't look at it anymore. Couldn't look at those words. You've got me fooled. Because they were true. They were so fucking true and he didn't even know it.
I had fooled him.
I lay there, the phone face-down on my chest, and felt the weight of every lie I'd ever told pressing down on me.
Every smile. Every joke. Every confident thirst trap. Every time I'd acted like I knew what I was doing, like I had my shit together, like I was the secure-in-my-masculinity straight guy who just happened to be comfortable flirting with dudes for content. Every single piece of it was a performance.
Lunarlad wasn't me. Lunarlad was a character I'd invented because the real Jude wasn't interesting enough, wasn't confident enough, wasn't enough. The real Jude was scared and lonely and had no idea what he was doing. The real Jude lived in a shitty apartment with a mom who didn't give a shit about him. The real Jude worked a job he hated and spent every night wondering if this TikTok thing was ever going to pay off or if he was just wasting his time pretending to be someone worth watching.
The real Jude wasn't straight. Or... he didn't know what he was. The real Jude had spent two days grinding on a guy and holding his hand and falling asleep breathing him in and hadn't once felt like he was pretending.
The real Jude wasn't perfect. The real Jude was a mess.
And Quinn had no idea.
He thought he was falling for someone confident and funny and secure. Someone who flirted because he wanted to, not because he was confused and scared and didn't know any other way to connect. Someone who had his life together, who had a plan, who knew what he wanted.
You've got me fooled.
Yeah. I did. I'd fooled him completely.
And now he was lying in his bed on the other side of this wall thinking I was perfect, thinking I was worth his time, thinking he was lucky I'd shown up in his life. And I was lying in mine knowing I was a fraud. Knowing that the person he liked didn't really exist. Knowing that if he ever met the real me, the scared, lonely, confused me, he'd probably be disappointed.
The guilt sat heavy in my chest.
I'd lied to plenty of people. On TikTok, to my followers, to my mom, to myself. Lying was basically my whole job. I curated a fake life and posted it for strangers and let them believe whatever they wanted to believe. That was the game. That was how this worked.
So why did lying to Quinn feel so much worse?
Because he'd been honest with me.
That was it. That was the thing that made this different.
He'd cried on a ferris wheel and told me he'd never been kissed. He'd admitted his parents didn't know he was gay. He'd said he was lonely, that he didn't know how to date, that he'd spent years making excuses because he was scared. He'd told me he was into me. Flat out, no games, just typed the words and hit send like it was easy even though I knew it wasn't.
He'd asked me for one thing. A video where you're just being you. And I hadn't been able to give it to him.
He'd been vulnerable with me over and over again. And I'd given him a performance.
I was still giving him a performance. Right now. Lying in this bed, not responding to his message, letting him think I was just tired or distracted when really I was sick with the guilt of knowing I didn't deserve any of this.
I didn't deserve him thinking I was perfect.
I didn't deserve him at all.
I lay there in the dark feeling like the biggest piece of shit in the world.
My phone buzzed again.
Quinn: You still there?
I didn't answer.
Quinn: Sorry if that was too much
Quinn: I didn't mean to make it weird
Quinn: Goodnight Jude
The messages sat there on my screen, glowing in the dark, and I couldn't bring myself to respond. What would I even say? No, you didn't make it weird, I'm just having a crisis because you think I'm perfect and I'm actually a fraud? Sorry, I'm too busy feeling guilty to type?
I think I might like you too and it's scaring the shit out of me?
I put the phone on the nightstand. Rolled over. Stared at the wall. The wall that separated my room from his.
He was right there. Fifteen feet away. Probably staring at his phone, wondering why I'd gone silent, wondering if he'd fucked up.
He hadn't fucked up. He'd been honest. And that was the problem.
I closed my eyes and tried to sleep. Tried to let my brain shut up for five minutes. Tried to stop thinking about him on the other side of that wall, tried to stop thinking about his hand on my ankle and his laugh through the wall and the way he'd looked at me on the ferris wheel like I was worth his tears.
It didn't work.
I kept thinking about what he'd said on the couch. About coming out to himself. About putting down the weight he'd been carrying and finally letting himself exhale.
I was carrying weight too. Had been for years. And I was so fucking tired.
I wanted to put it down.
I wanted...
I sat up in bed.
My heart was pounding. My hands were shaking. I didn't know what I was doing, but I knew I couldn't stay in this room, couldn't keep lying here pretending I was fine, couldn't keep performing even when there was no one watching.
I wanted Quinn to know me. The real me. Not Lunarlad, not the thirst trap guy, not the confident performer who had all the answers. Just Jude. Scared, lonely, fucked-up Jude, who didn't know what he was doing and was terrified of being found out.
I wanted to show him that person.
And I wanted him to not run away.
I wanted to feel wanted. Not for the body or the jokes or the content. For me. Whoever the fuck that was.
I wanted to feel loved.
I wanted to feel safe.
My feet hit the cold hardwood floor. The guest room was dark except for the glow of the city through the window. I stood there for a second, just breathing, trying to work up the courage to do what I knew I needed to do.
This was crazy. This was insane. I was about to walk into Quinn's room in the middle of the night and... what? Tell him everything? Admit that I'd been lying? That my life was a mess, that I was scared, that I didn't know who I was or what I wanted?
That terrified me.
But staying in this room, keeping up the performance, pretending I was perfect when I was falling apart inside. That terrified me more.
I opened the door.
The hallway was dark. Quinn's door was closed, but there was a thin line of light visible underneath. He was still awake. Still probably looking at his phone. Still waiting for a response I hadn't sent.
I walked down the hall. My footsteps were silent on the hardwood. My heart was beating so loud I could hear it in my ears.
I stopped in front of his door.
I raised my hand to knock.
Then I just opened it.