Seducing My Homophobic Friends - Part 2 (Patreon)
Content
Seducing Jack
Jack was a bit of a man-whore. He would gladly have sex with any girl that was willing and he was the type of guy who loved to share all the details about his conquests. He was also the type of guy who loved to show off the gift that God had given him. He was the shortest guy in the friend group, probably 5’6” or so and was rather skinny. But you know what they say about the skinny friend. They aren’t lying… he was packing. His dick was a solid 5 inches soft. He was clearly really proud of it because he found an excuse to pull it out almost every night that we hung out together.
I made plans with him to go running one morning when I knew that my parents were going to be out of the house all day. I knew that he wouldn’t pass up the opportunity to go running so that part of the plan didn’t worry me. I just had to figure out how to get him back to my place after.
I again went with another one of his weaknesses. During the run I offered to make him some cold brewed coffee back at my place after our run. I’m very picky when it comes to coffee and all of my friends love the way that I make cold brew. He gladly accepted and before I knew it, we were running up my driveway and into my house.
“Why don’t you go hop in my shower while I’m making your coffee.” I offered as I headed to the kitchen. Jack nodded and headed towards my bedroom. We often showered at one another’s houses so he wasn’t the least bit suspicious. I quickly made a coffee for him in a travel mug and put my plan into action. I headed to my bathroom. Jack was in the shower singing along to a song that was playing on his phone. I stripped off my sweaty clothes and stepped into the shower with him.
“The fuck you doing?” he asked me. There was a smile on his face so I clearly hadn’t crossed any lines yet.
“Just figured I’d deliver you your coffee.” I handed him the travel mug. He gladly accepted it and took a sip. “You didn’t need to get in the shower to do that dipshit.”
“Maybe I just wanted to check that thing out.” I nodded down at his dick. It was flaccid but still almost as big as lots of guys are when hard.
He laughed, “Well I can’t say that I blame you. It is rather impressive.” I knew that he would welcome the opportunity to show off, even if it was to a guy. He was by far the most sexually liberated of my friend group so I didn’t hesitate with the next statement.
“How big is it hard?” I glanced up at his face quickly to gauge his reaction.
He didn’t even flinch. “A little over 8.”
“No fucking way.” I shot him a disbelieving smile.
“Seriously dude.” He set the coffee down on the side of the tub and was soaping himself up.
“Prove it.” As soon as I said it, his expression changed. There was a quick look of shock followed by a curious raise of an eyebrow. I also noticed his dick spring to life ever so slightly. I met his stare with an unwavering one of my own.
“You really want me to get hard right now?” his voice sounded unsure but not offended.
“Yeah, I do.” Although I was trying my best to stay calm, my voice sounded a little excited. This was by far the gayest thing I’d ever done and my mind was beginning to get excited about where things might go.
“You first…” The tone in his voice made it seem like he was trying to call my bluff. He clearly thought that I was just trying to see if he’d do something gay and then I’d hurriedly go tell the rest of our friends.
I didn’t bother responding. I simply started jerking off slowly while looking at his wet soapy body. Jack didn’t have much muscle but he made up for it with almost zero body fat. His swimmer build was hot when he was dry and gorgeous when wet and soapy. His mother was half African American so his skin was naturally much more tanned than me and the rest of our friends. He trimmed down all of his body hair because he claimed that his many female conquests preferred it that way. It made his dick look even larger.
It only took a few seconds for my dick to spring to life. I was a solid 7 inches so I didn’t have anything to be ashamed about.
Jack looked down at my hard dick with a look of surprise and confusion. There was clearly a hint of excitement in his eyes though. He reached down and gave his dick a few twirls. It swung around spraying soapy water on me. The sound it made smacking his swollen balls made me even harder than I already was.
He looked down at his still soft dick. “Doesn’t seem to be working, maybe you should help?” There was the invitation that I’d been hoping for. I wasted no time in taking a step closer and reaching out for his dick. He didn’t flinch when I took it in my hand and slowly began to rub it. I could feel it start to pulse as it swelled and began to get hard. I got down on my knees and began to rub his semi against my cheeks. “Fuck dude, you really want it don’t you?”
I didn’t bother answering his question. He was now rock hard and it was just as big as he’d claimed. He had at least an inch on me if not more. He was cut like I was, but his head was a bit larger and shaped a little differently than mine. I rubbed the drop of precum that had escaped his dick slowly around the head with my thumb. I reached up with my other hand and began to caress his balls. They were much larger than mine and were bulging as if he hadn’t cum in a while.
A soft moan escaped Jack’s lips. He began to slowly thrust into my hand. I positioned his pulsing dick against my lips and looked up at him.
He still had a look of shock and confusion in his eyes. “You aren’t actually going to…” His voice was low and in a tone unlike I’d ever heard him use before.
I responded by slowly opening my mouth and he slid himself in. It was the first time I’d ever had a dick in my mouth and I was a bit underwhelmed by the sensation. I had always expected sucking a dick to feel like ‘sex’, but it simply felt like sucking on a really large salty thumb. That was, until Jack reached down and grabbed my head.
“Yeah, suck that huge dick.” His fingers ran through my long hair as he slowly thrust himself into my mouth. Suddenly it felt like ‘sex’. I was trying my best to get as much of him into my throat as I could but it was just too big. I gagged slightly. “Gag on that shit dude, you know you want to.”
Jack was clearly way more into this than I had expected. I decided to push the boundaries and reached up and rubbed my middle finger against his asshole. A louder moan escaped him as he opened up and let my finger slip inside him. I knew enough to massage his prostate and his body twitched in pleasure. “Shove another one up there.” he instructed. I eased my ring finger into him as well. His thrusting was getting a bit more frenzied and my jaw was beginning to hurt.
I slipped him out of my mouth, intending to take over with my hand but was surprised when Jack spun around. He bent over and reached back and grabbed my dick. Before I even knew what was happening he had guided me into his tight asshole. I began to slowly thrust. He had his arms outstretched in front of him and one leg up on the side of the tub to give me better access to his tight hairless hole.
I squeezed his firm ass and leaned forward, whispering into his ear, “You like that? You like me fucking you?”
He simply nodded his head and whimpered. He either didn’t notice or didn’t care when I reached over and grabbed my phone off the side of the tub and began filming.
I had never done anal with any of the girls that I had been with so the sensation of fucking someone’s ass was new to me and the tightness felt amazing. I stopped recording and set my phone down and reached around and grabbed Jack’s dick. It was still hard as a rock and I began to slowly jerk him off.
“Oh my fucking god that feels so good…” he said between gasps. I began to pick up my pace a bit and felt his dick tense up. The thought of him about to erupt sent me over the edge and I thrust deep as my dick erupted cum inside of him. His dick erupted moments after mine and I felt the warm cum dripping down my fingers. I put my hands on his hips and stayed planted deep in his ass. He ground back against me as the throws of ecstasy slowly began to fade.
I slowly pulled out of him, not entirely sure what to expect. He let out a little whimper when my dick popped out.
In my mind I had played through dozens of potential scenarios when I decided to try to seduce Jack and none of them had ended with me fucking him.
“I love it when girls finger me as they are sucking my dick, but that was a whole other level.”
“I just fucked you.” I said in a state of disbelief.
Jack was silent for a moment. “You aren’t planning on telling anyone are you?” His voice was still ragged in between breaths.
“No…” he was still bent over in front of me and I ran my hands over his firm hairless ass.
“You recorded it didn’t you?” he didn’t sound upset. It sounded like a sincere question.
“Yeah.” I said, expecting him to immediately demand that I delete it.
“Send that to me and never show another living soul.” Apparently he wanted to keep a copy to jerk off to as well.
The part of the plan that I hadn’t figured out ahead of time was what to say afterwards if I was successful in my conquest. I had toyed with the idea of calling him out for fooling around with a dude, but after what had happened, that seemed inappropriate. I had fucked my friend Jack and we had both enjoyed it. I decided to leave it at that.
I grabbed the soap and began to lather up his ass. I figured it was the least I could do for him after what had just happened. He laughed nervously. “Is it a mess back there?”
“Nah it actually isn’t bad at all. I busted in you and none came out with my dick.”
He jumped out of the shower and sat on the toilet. “I wasn’t planning on letting you nut in me. I guess I got carried away.”
“Yeah man, that was… intense.” I admitted.
He stood up and looked in the toilet. “Dude… I just shit out your cum.” He let out a laugh.
“That’s something I never thought I’d hear you say to me.” I shook my head in disbelief.
Jack jumped back in the shower and we spent the next 10 minutes washing up in semi-awkward silence.
“So was that your first time with a guy?” he finally asked me.
“Yeah, you?”
“Yeah.”
“Did you enjoy it?” I asked. I already knew damned well that he had, but I was curious if he’d admit it.
“I’m not like gay or anything but yeah that felt amazing.” he responded timidly.
“Yeah, not to sound gay but your ass felt fucking awesome. Way better than any pussy I’ve had.” I admitted.
He shot me a grin. “Thanks I guess?”
And that was how I lost my guy virginity to my supposedly straight friend Jack.