Seducing My Homophobic Friends - Part 6 (Patreon)
Content
Seducing Hayden
I waited almost a week after my experience with Dylan to decide on who I was going to go after next. I eventually settled on my friend Hayden. I had technically known him since we were in diapers. Our parents used to live next door to one another and the two of us grew up together. When we were in 6th grade his parents ended up moving to a nicer part of town and we ended up growing a little bit apart. He was still a member of the circle of friends, but he didn’t hang out with us as much as the others did.
Hayden’s personality is rather hard to describe. In front of other people he acts like a total asshole. He tries to show-off and doesn’t hesitate to put people down, including his friends. One-on-one however he is a totally different person. He’s kind and considerate and will gladly go out of his way for you. It really didn’t make sense and we called him out on it often but he never changed.
The thing that worried me the most about Hayden was that he was unpredictable. If I sucked his dick, he’s the type of guy that might just blurt that out in front of our friends if I refused to do him a favor or something. I had to make sure that whatever happened, it wasn’t something he was going to admit in front of people. I didn’t want to let the cat out of the bag before I moved away.
I messaged him after dinner and invited him over for the night. He had mentioned that we should hang out as much as we could before I moved so I knew that he would take me up on the offer. He responded almost immediately that he was on his way and that he was going to bring some pizzas for later. We had a bad habit of staying up all night playing video games when he came over.
Hayden spent a few minutes chatting with my parents when he arrived. It still boggled my mind that he was so polite when he wasn’t hanging out with a group of people. I suspected it was due to some sort of insecurity that he had, but as often as I brought it up with him, he had no interest in changing his ways.
After spending a little time with my parents, we retired to my room. I still hadn’t planned out how I was going to make my move on Hayden. I really didn’t want it to backfire and was nervous about simply going for his dick. He made himself comfortable on my bed and grabbed a controller.
“Mind if I fire up 2k?” he asked.
“Nah go for it.” I made myself comfortable on the other side of the bed. It only took Hayden a few minutes to get completely engrossed in the game. I decided to test the waters and pulled out my phone. I opened PornHub and picked a lesbian video. A few seconds after it started, the audio caught Hayden’s attention and he paused the game.
“What the fuck are you watching?” he leaned over to look. “You’re just going to casually watch porn while I play 2k?”
“Do you mind?” I asked.
“Nah man. Have at it.” he unpaused the game and went back to playing.
“Do you think that chicks watch videos of two dudes fucking?” I asked.
He paused the game again and looked at me like I had 3 heads. “What?”
“We always watch lesbian porn. So do you think that chicks watch gay porn?”
“You’ve been smoking a knockoff dab pen haven’t you?” Hayden unpaused the game and went back to playing.
Well that plan hadn’t worked. I grabbed the second controller and played 2k with him for a while.
“Want me to go grab some of that pizza?” I offered. Hayden nodded vigorously. I grabbed us each a couple slices and we ate and played video games for another half hour before I took my second swing at him.
“Dude I did something and fucked up a muscle near my shoulder blade.” I feigned some pain as I tried to reach my upper back.
Hayden paused the game and tossed the controller on the bed. “Turn around. I got you.” I turned around and he started giving me an aggressive shoulder massage.
“Dude that feels so fucking good.” I admitted.
“I’ve been telling you that I give good massages. You just never believed me.”
“It’s not that I didn’t believe you… I just know that I can give a better massage.” I shot back.
“And that sir, is bullshit.” Hayden stopped massaging my shoulders and turned around. “C’mon… let’s see it.” He looked over his shoulder expectantly.
“Fine, take your shirt off and lay down.” he did as I instructed. I began rubbing his shoulders. They were broader than my own and covered with a number of freckles. Hayden had a bit more muscle than I did and a very low body fat percentage, which made him look even more jacked. I ran my thumbs deep into his muscles.
“Don’t be afraid to get rough. I can take it.” he said, his face buried in my pillow. I did my best to stifle a laugh.
After working his broad shoulders for a few minutes I began working his right bicep. It wasn’t as large as Tyler’s but it was bigger than mine. I suddenly wondered why I hadn’t started giving my friends massages sooner.
“Can you get way up in my shoulder? I pulled something a few days ago getting my dirtbike off the back of the truck.”
“Yeah. Tell me when I hit the right spot.” I began probing deep into his shoulder. He let out a sudden hiss when my finger found its mark.
“Yup right there.” his voice was still muffled by my pillow. I worked the muscle gently at first, slowly growing in intensity. “Yeah, it's feeling better now.”
I continued my probing, circling around the shoulder until my thumb was in his armpit. “That doesn’t tickle does it?” I asked.
“Nope you’re good. It’s sore right where you just pushed.” I saw his shoulders tense a bit. I pushed my thumb in on the muscle and began to work it. Hayden was in the habit of trimming down his armpit hair which I always thought looked a bit silly, but it made massaging in his armpit easier. My thumb was wet with his sweat as I moved my way down to his forearm. I began working it with both hands. “Can you go harder?” he asked.
“Yeah just shout if it hurts.”
“Oh don’t worry… you can’t hurt me.”
After finishing his forearm I moved down to his hand, massaging each finger and the palm. “Dude that legit feels awesome. Can you get in between my thumb and pointer finger some more?” I did what he asked before moving over to his left arm.
Next I started working his back. “My back is always pretty fucked.” he warned me. As I worked my hands into his mid-back, I was met with a number of loud cracks. “Holy shit that felt good.” he groaned into the pillow. I moved down to his lower back.
“Ouuuuuch. My lower back is messed up.” Hayden tensed up as I probed his lower back. I got to work loosening the muscles. As I worked my way down his lower back, I lowered his boxer waistband to the point where the top of his ass was visible. He didn’t protest. I kneaded the top of his glutes. “Yeah that’s where it’s coming from.” he inhaled sharply.
I smiled, it was game on. I began digging deep into his glutes. He began making sounds of pleasure mixed with sounds of pain. I grabbed the waistband of his shorts. “These are in the way.” he lifted himself up and let me slide them off. He was still wearing a pair of Lacoste boxer briefs. They were black and skin tight. I set my hands on his ass cheeks. I squeezed them gently before beginning to massage them. He didn’t complain about my touch. His ass was firm and what I would qualify as a bubble butt. I briefly considered letting one of my fingers get close to his asshole, but I didn’t think that he would be into that sort of thing so I steered clear of it. I suddenly realized that I’d been massaging his ass for over ten minutes. I regretfully moved my way down his legs.
He made no comments about sore muscles there. After moving down both legs, I reached his feet. I had no interest in feet but I knew that most people saw foot rubs as erotic. I hesitantly lifted his foot. He happily complied. Hayden had fairly large feet. Size 12. I dug my thumbs into the soles of his foot. “Mmm damn you’re good at this.” he said. I didn’t bother responding. I cracked each of his toes which he seemed to enjoy.
Time to see where this was going. “Flip over so that I can get your knees.” Hayden rolled over. There was a significant bulge in his Lacoste's. I bent his right leg up so that I could massage his calf. I spent a few minutes working on his knee. Hayden reached down to scratch himself. I caught him repositioning his bulge out of the corner of my eye. The bulge wasn’t so much a bulge anymore as it was a hard shaft.
I reminded myself that I had to let Hayden make the move. I wanted this to be an experience that was his doing.
I moved up to his thigh. “Mmmm” Hayden was clearly enjoying this. There was a dark stain on his boxers that proved it. As I moved my hands closer to it, I saw his dick pulse under the tight black cloth.
“Is there a happy ending with this massage?” his voice was strangely meek.
“Do you want there to be?”
“Seems like you want there to be…” He was trying to put it on me.
“I’m just giving you a massage. You’re the one with a leaking dick.” I figured I’d let him know that I noticed.
"Only because you've been rubbing my ass like you were hoping a genie was going to pop out of my asshole." I could tell that as soon as those words came out of his mouth he wished he could take them back.
“You said it was sore.” I wasn’t crazy about being combative, but I wasn’t going to let him pin the encounter on me. He had to own his involvement.
He reached down and stroked his dick through his boxers. He was clearly rock hard.
“Rub whatever you want.” he let go of his dick and it slapped back against his stomach.
“I’m only going to rub what YOU want me to rub.”
“Just fucking rub my dick already.” he laughed a bit as he said it. He was well aware of the chess match that was being played and his erection was tired of waiting.
I slipped my shorts and boxers onto the floor. My dick sprang to life instantly. I was standing next to the bed and my dick was inches from his. I stood there waiting for a few moments. Hayden slipped his boxers off, revealing his erect and drooling dick. It was about the same length as mine although the head was a bit girthier. It wasn’t a bad looking dick, but the proportions of it seemed a little odd compared to the other guys’.
He had clearly trimmed his pubes a while back but they had grown back part way. It honestly wasn’t a bad look for him. His bush was quite large… forming a sizable triangle above his cock and wrapping all around it down to his balls. Trimmed down it still looked masculine as fuck but his cock stood proud out of it.
I stood inspecting him. “Well are you going to rub it or what?” he didn’t sound upset, just confused.
“Well mine isn’t going to rub itself.” I countered.
“How did I know you were going to say that?” He reached toward my dick and hesitated for a moment before cautiously grabbing it. I followed suit and took his in my hand. He gave my dick a gentle squeeze. I did the same. He gave it a slow stroke. I mirrored his action.
A grin spread over his face. He saw what was going on. Soon we were stroking each other's cocks with intensity. Hayden began to pant. “Chase… man… I honestly don’t give a shit if you’re gay or whatever. I’m so fucking horny right now I really want you to suck my dick and I’m pretty sure you kinda want to. But I… I just can’t suck yours first. That would just be too weird for me.”
I hadn’t expected him to openly say any of that. We both paused. I thought about his words for a moment.
“How about if I just lick it for a minute?” He understood that this was a game of give and take. If we had each other’s cocks in our mouths, neither would spill the beans.
I nodded and stepped towards him. He took a deep breath and slowly licked up the shaft of my dick as if he expected it to taste ‘gay’. He licked around the head for a moment and then stopped. “Weird. You can totally notice the difference in skin texture between the shaft and head with your tongue even though you don’t notice it with your hand.” I just smiled and nodded at his revelation.
“You already knew that?” he smirked. The fucker got me. Well played Hayden.
“Yeah, Kelsey told me.” she was a girl that I had hooked up with a few months ago.
“Sure she did.” he didn’t buy it but acknowledged my parry.
“Just suck it for a second. You know you are curious.”
“Tell no one.” he instructed.
I gave him the Boy Scout salute to let him know that I promised.
“Yeah… real fitting to use the Boy Scout salute in a promise not to tell anyone about gay sex that is about to occur. Nice Carter.” he rolled his eyes at me.
I just smiled as he slowly stuck the head of my dick in his mouth. I felt his tongue cautiously explore the head before he removed it from his mouth. “Okay that’s not nearly as bad as I thought it was going to be.”
I laughed at his realization.
“For real though, that’s the end of my comfort zone, okay?”
“Hayden, I’m impressed by your honesty and your open-mindedness.” I climbed onto the bed and positioned myself between his legs. “Get comfortable and enjoy this.”
I grabbed his dick and slid it all the way down my throat. My nose got buried in his bush and one of the hairs tickled my nostril a bit. The musky aroma was interesting but I didn’t find it as intoxicating as Tyler’s had been. I wondered if I just enjoyed Tyler’s more because I had become emotionally attached to him and my brain connected that smell to him, or if there was something in the chemical makeup of his smell that my brain enjoyed.
Hayden’s surprised moan brought me back to the moment. “Dude!”
I slipped his dick out of my mouth, “Yeah?”
“You are fucking good at this.” he was clearly impressed.
“Oh just wait.” I slid back down on his cock and took his balls in my hand. He moaned as I worked on his rock hard cock. I could tell that this wasn’t going to last very long and he didn’t seem overly interested in drawing it out so I went for it. I began deepthroating him as rapidly as I could. My finger crept down from his balls to his hairy asshole. I didn’t think he would enjoy it if I slipped it in without warning so I settled for simply teasing it with my finger.
“Fuuuuuck, yeah man do whatever feels good.” he lifted both arms up and put them behind his head. This was clearly an amazing experience for him.
I quickly licked my finger and then slowly slid it into his tight asshole. He clenched at first but then relaxed and let me inside. As I began to massage his prostate while sucking on his cock he began to whimper. He had become putty in my hands (and mouth). Less than 30 seconds later I felt his entire body tense up. He erupted into my mouth with such ferocity that I was afraid it would wake the neighbors. Jet after jet filled my mouth. I swallowed it all and then cleaned up his still hard cock. He tasted interesting. Quite different than the other guys. I thought for a moment. You kinda taste like Brie dude.
He lay on the bed panting as he pondered my words. “Yeah thanks for fucking ruining my favorite cheese asshole.” I laughed at him and he smiled. “Dude, that was… mind blowing.”
Thanks I replied. I grabbed my phone from my desk and lifted his still glistening dick.
“Woah there Ansel Adams. What are you doing?” he asked.
“Just something to remember this by.” I shrugged.
“Fuck it, fine but don’t show anyone.” I nodded and snapped a pic of his slowly softening dick.
Suddenly there was the sound of footsteps coming up the stairs. “Fuck!” I tossed Hayden his shorts from the floor and slid mine back on. I had just tossed him the controller when my mom knocked on the door and let herself in.
“Is everything okay? I heard someone scream…” she had a look of concern on her face.
“Yeah mom, Hayden just stepped on a Lego.” I threw out the first thing that came to mind.
“Oh, well I keep telling you to clean up this room.” She looked around at the mess and shook her head before closing the door and heading downstairs.
Hayden stifled a laugh, “Stepped on a Lego? Seriously?”
I started to crack up. “It was the best I could come up with on short notice. I just thought of the most painful thing in the world and went with it.”
“Do you even have any fucking Legos?” He scanned the room.
“No…” we both cracked up.
“That was NOT your first time doing that.” he looked me in the eye.
“I never claimed that it was.” I shrugged.
“Please tell me you’re not hooking up with married 50 year-olds you met on Grindr.” I could tell he wasn’t being judgmental by the tone of his voice. “Because you’re better than that.”
“Nah dude. I’ve never used Grindr.”
“Okay good.” he thought for a moment. “Ten bucks says it’s Jack.”