Seducing My Homophobic Friends - Part 10 (Patreon)
Content
Jack's Afterglow
After fucking Jack in the shower, I was a wild mixture of emotion. I was excited by what had happened, shocked that he went as far as he had, proud of myself for being able to hook up with a straight guy, and confused by the unexpected flood of feelings.
Let me explain my history of relationships. I had two serious girlfriends in high school. The first one was a terrible relationship. We weren’t good for one another. I brought out the worst in her and she brought out the worst in me. We spent more time fighting than enjoying one another’s company. She ended up cheating on me. I think she did it mainly to pay me back for accusing her of cheating on me when she hadn’t.
After her, I had a series of meaningless flings, some of which were fun, some of which I regretted. Eventually I found a girl that was a good match. We had fun together. We smiled. We laughed. We were good for one another. But, I always found myself thinking back to my first girlfriend. I was constantly comparing my new girl to my old girl in my mind. Every time we had fun together, I secretly thought it would have been more fun with my old girlfriend.
I realized that I wasn’t giving her what she deserved as a boyfriend and told her that we should break up. She was confused and surprised at first, but I explained that I was messed up and not ready for a relationship yet. She understood and we remained friends.
When I decided to make a move on Jack I was fairly certain something would happen. I fully wanted to hook up with him. I was prepared for what that meant.
I wasn’t prepared when later that night I picked up my phone to text him to see what he was up to and found myself blushing. There were butterflies in my stomach. What the fuck? Honestly, Jack wasn’t even my type. I was all about the sweet, tender, caring people. Not the players.
I set my phone down. I wasn’t going to text him. There would be no catching feels for my friends. ‘Ding!’ my phone lit up.
I grabbed it. One new message from Jack. Hey, what’s up?
The butterflies came back. NMU
Just making sure we’re on the same page about keeping that between us.
I should have seen it coming, but I’d be lying if I said it didn’t make my heart sink a little.
Yeah dude. Not looking for people to know about that shit. It was the truth. I didn’t want everyone to know about me, at least not yet.
There was a long pause. I hadn’t expected the conversation to end so quickly. I guess he didn’t feel like chatting, just wanted to make sure I wasn’t going to tell the guys.
‘Ding!’ Cool. LMK when you want to try taking it.
I read it a few times to make sure I was understanding what he was saying. Like when I want to have you to fuck me?
Yeah…
My heart started racing. I had no intention on bottoming, but just knowing that Jack wanted to fuck me got my mind racing yet again.
It took all my willpower not to text him the following night asking him to come over and fool around. I know that he would have probably said yes, but I really wanted to keep focused on the task at hand. If I kept hooking up with Jack every night, I wouldn’t get around to fooling around with anyone else.
Late one night a week or so after hooking up with Jack for the first time, I get a text as I’m playing video games. Hey man, can I come spend the night maybe?
I knew instantly what he had on his mind. Yeah dude but just so you know, I’m not gonna bottom. There was a long pause.
Fine. Be over in 10. I unlocked the door so he could sneak in quietly because it was already 1:30 in the morning.
Now that I had Tyler and Dylan under my belt I wasn’t quite as hooked on Jack. Yeah, his dick was amazing. But I was secretly hoping for a late night message from Tyler instead of Jack.
Jack quickly slipped into my room and closed the door behind him. “Hey.” he smiled at me.
“Hey dude, what’s up?” I acted as if I didn’t know damned well what was up.
“Just wanted to spend some time with you before you left.” he reached into his bag and pulled out a large Yeti travel mug.
“And what do we have in there?” I asked with a grin.
“Just thought I’d bring refreshments.” He handed it to me and I took a sip. It was mostly vodka with a bit of cranberry juice in it.
“Jesus dude. Are you trying to get me drunk?” I asked with a laugh.
“Maybe…” he said with a devilish grin.
“Jack, you don’t need to get me drunk.” I sat down on my bed and took a big sip.
“I know…” he sighed and grabbed it from me and took a few gulps. “It just. It makes it easier for me.”
“What do you mean?” I suspected I knew, but I wanted to be sure.
“There’s like this wall.” He took another sip. “I know that I can do stuff with a guy and not be ‘gay’... I just enjoy it because it feels good. I don’t lay awake at night thinking about buying a dude flowers or anything.”
I grabbed the bottle from him, took a sip and handed it back.
“And even though I know it’s not gay, I still have a hard time with it.”
I thought about what he said for a minute. “Dude. I’m not trying to sabotage my chances of having fun tonight. And the last thing that I want to do is fuck with your head, but if you have sex with me it is by definition ‘gay’. It would be ‘gay sex’.” I reached out for the mug and he handed it to me. I took a much smaller sip than he had. He snatched it back and took another long sip.
“I’m not gay though.” his voice was quiet.
“I didn’t say you were gay. I said you’ve had gay sex. Those are two different things.” I explained.
“Are they though?” he blurted out.
I thought about it. I always considered being gay as being romantically attracted to men. But I guess one could argue that someone who enjoyed gay sex is technically gay, or bi or one of the many other labels I didn’t fully understand.
“Are you going to settle down with a girl one day and be happy?” I asked him.
“Yeah.” he said it without hesitation and I believed him.
“Then fuck labels. You’re on a journey between now and then and it doesn’t matter what label other people may want to stick on you. They don’t define you.”
He thought about my words for a moment. “Can we get in bed?”
“Sure dude.” I turned off the lights and locked my bedroom door, unsure of where the night was going. Out of the corner of my eye I saw Jack slip out of his clothes and crawl into bed nude. Looked like things were going to get interesting after all. I followed his lead and climbed into bed beside him. The cool crisp sheets felt good against my skin.
“Can I…” he stopped.
“Can you what?” I asked. Both excited and nervous at the same time.
“Can I spoon you?” he was clearly uncomfortable asking.
I was surprised with how tame his question was. “Of course you can. You want to be the big spoon or little spoon?”
“Big.”
I rolled over facing away from him. He draped his arm over me and slid in behind me. I immediately felt his dick press against my ass. I tensed up.
He pulled his groin away from me. “Sorry, was that okay?”
“Yeah, my ass is exit only though.” I reminded him.
“I promise not to try to stick it in.” he laughed as he said it.
I relaxed and he pressed back up against me. His dick was now semi hard and he rested it between my ass cheeks. He ran his hand up and down my chest. It eventually found its way to my dick. I was already fully hard and twitching with excitement.
He simply held my dick, gently squeezing it. I ached for him to start stroking it. His dick was now rock hard. I began to move my ass up and down, stroking his cock with my cheeks.
“Fuuuuuuck” he moaned in my ear. His hot breath tickled on my neck. He began to stroke my cock, matching the pace that I was moving my ass. I was surprised when I felt myself get close. We had only been fooling around for a few minutes. The throbbing dick rubbing against my ass clearly excited me.
Jack reached down and angled his dick towards my hole. The precum on his dick made my ass slippery. I felt his head poke against me. He wiggled it against my hole, clearly looking for approval. As much as the concept of bottoming troubled me, the sensation of him rubbing against my hole was intoxicating.
He wrapped both his arms around me and repositioned my body so he had better access to my ass. “Trust me okay?” he whispered to me.
I shook my head. I wasn’t sure what he was about to do but I knew that if I said stop, he would. He slid his drooling dick between my legs right under my ass. He began to slowly thrust. The feeling was strange. It was as if I was getting fucked without actually being fucked. Every once in a while he pulled back too far and his dick rubbed against my ass on its way back in. For a second I almost gave him the go ahead to stick it in, but changed my mind. He reached around and began to jerk me off. I was close but I could tell by his urgent thrusting that he was too. I held back for as long as I could. I erupted into his hand. He quickened his pace for a few seconds and then tensed up and moaned as he shot a massive load between my legs. I could feel the warm stickiness running along the back of my balls.
Jack pulled his dick out and slowly rubbed it against my hole. I could feel the cum cover me. “Was that… okay?” he asked.
“Yeah dude.”
“I just really wanted to fuck you.” he admitted.
“I know, I’m just not ready for that. Sorry.” I felt bad about my apprehension. If Jack could take it like a trooper, I should be able to too. But I just wasn’t ready for that step.
“Jesus we made a mess.” Jack pulled away from me, revealing a massive sweat and cum stain on my sheets.
I grabbed a clean set of sheets from my closet and remade the bed. “So are you ok with what just happened?” I asked.
“This probably won’t make sense, but I’m so okay with it that I’m not okay with it.” he climbed back into bed nude.
“I think I get what you mean… it doesn’t bother you at all that we just had gay sex. But you’re bothered by the fact that you’re not bothered by having gay sex?” I climbed back in beside him.
“Yes, that is exactly what I meant.” he snuggled backwards against me making himself the little spoon. My dick was resting against his firm ass. My mind wandered back to the shower. I felt my dick pulse slightly. “I felt that.” he laughed at me.
“Sorry, my dick just really likes you.” I admitted.
“Your dick has good taste.” he smiled at me.
“My dick tastes good?” I grinned back at him. I was shocked when he rolled over and slid down. He slipped my dick into his mouth for a second then went back to being little spoon.
“Yeah it tastes fine.” He laughed at the look of shock on my face. “We should do this more often.”