Blurred Lines - Part 7 (Patreon)
Content
With each beat, my heart nervously calls,In the echo, my fear of rejection falls.A secret desire, a hidden flame,In my heart’s chamber, it softly came.
I stared at the text message from Mitch.
You still want to go on that date?
To say that I was surprised would be an understatement. We hadn’t spoken since we hooked up almost a week ago. I figured that he might need some time to process what had happened between us, but I’d begun to give up hope of salvaging our friendship.
I’d been playing our hookup over and over in my head trying to figure out if I’d done something wrong. He’d started things, right? I guess I had placed my hand on his leg, but that was something that friends do.
He had kissed me.
I thought back to the kiss. His lips had locked on to mine with unbridled passion. His tongue found its way into my mouth before I had even really registered what was going on. He hadn’t tasted like alcohol, so he wasn’t drunk. Sober Mitch had decided to kiss me.
I tried to play back what happened next. He had taken off my hoodie, right? I clearly remembered the cool night air against my skin as I fumbled with the buttons on his shirt. While I was doing that, I remembered him sliding his hands down the back of my pants and grabbing my ass.
Him reaching in my pants was what caused me to go for his dick. The more I thought about it, the more I was sure that I hadn’t instigated what had happened between us. Either way, he was still inviting me to go on the double date with him. Sure, it was originally proposed as a sort of joke. But after what happened between us, was it a real date now?
My finger hovered over my phone screen. Mitch’s bitmoji was sitting there waiting for my reply. Yeah, I’d love to. I hesitated. Was ‘love’ too strong to use? I didn’t want to come across too strong and scare him away. Yeah, I’d really like that. That was better, right? It sounded a little corny, but it was the safer option. I hit send before I could change my mind.
Meet outside my dorm at 7 tomorrow?
I suddenly got butterflies in my stomach. It probably sounds silly since Mitch and I had already hooked up. But hooking up didn’t seem as serious as going on a date. We were going out to dinner… with witnesses.
I desperately wanted to message him to ask if it was a real date or if we were just pretending to be together while hanging out with Justice and her girlfriend. I didn’t dare to though. Mainly because I was scared his answer would be that it wasn’t a real date.
I tossed and turned for almost an hour before I finally fell asleep. I didn’t want to get out of bed when my alarm went off. Luckily classes were a breeze. By 5pm I was sitting nervously on my bed staring at my phone. I wanted to confirm things with Mitch, but I was scared. What if I texted him and he replied that the date was canceled? I’d be devastated. Then an idea popped into my head.
Hey, what should I wear?
He hadn’t told me where we were going so it was only logical that I ask him how I should dress. As soon as I hit the send button I remembered what he’d said that night under the stars when I’d pretended to be worried about what I would wear on our date.
“The main reason for taking a guy on a date is so that I don’t have to deal with that.”
I was about to delete the message when he replied. Nothing fancy, we are going to Little Tokyo.
I sighed in relief. He didn’t mind that I’d asked.
He quickly added. Shit, do you like sushi?
Yup!
I quickly debated what to wear. I suspected that Mitch would just wear what he usually wore. I grabbed a pair of jeans, a t-shirt and a button up. I spent the better part of an hour getting ready. I wanted to make a good impression. After getting dressed I put on some cologne and inspected myself in the mirror. Not half bad.
I still had some time to kill before meeting Mitch. I hopped on Spotify and pulled up Mitch’s public playlists. I spent an hour on a musical journey. He had such great taste. I hadn’t heard of any of the songs on most of the playlists but they were all amazing. I favorited a few and headed out.
As I approached Mitch’s dorm I started to get nervous. What if I embarrassed myself? What if this was all some elaborate joke to get me to out myself? What if it's a real date but Mitch decides he doesn’t like me?
As Mitch’s dorm came into view, I saw him standing outside. He looked as nervous as I felt. A realization hit me like a ton of bricks. What if the reason he’d been ghosting me wasn’t because he was upset about what happened but because he enjoyed what happened so much it scared him?
I gave him a nod and his face broke out into a smile.
“Hey!” He stepped towards me and awkwardness hit us. He looked like he wanted to hug me but stopped. I almost reached my hand out to give him a fist bump out of instinct but managed to stop myself. I opened my arms and he looked relieved. He gave me a quick but tight hug. “You smell nice.” He said as he stepped back. As soon as he realized what he’d said, he blushed.
“Thanks… you always smell nice.” I bit my lip nervously. Flirting with my friend was going to take some getting used to. If he even enjoyed me flirting with him that was.
“I told the girls we’d meet them there.” He explained. We fell into step beside one another as we walked towards the restaurant.
For the first few minutes, neither of us said anything. We did however glance at one another a few times. Each time we locked eyes we both smiled bashfully and looked back down. This had to be a good sign right?
I was about to ask if this was a real date when Mitch finally broke the silence. “How was your day?” I couldn’t help but smirk at his awkward opener.
“It kinda flew by honestly. I was looking forward to tonight.” I wanted to try to make it obvious that I was treating this like a real date without blatantly saying it.
“Yeah. Me too.” Mitch glanced at me as he said it. I tried to read his face. He seemed just as nervous as I was.
I was trying my best to not get too excited, but it was a losing battle. I was walking next to Mitch on our way to a date. My first date with a guy… and it was with the hottest guy I knew.
As the restaurant came into sight I began to panic a bit. I was running out of time to find out if this was a real date or just some joke. I broke out in a sweat even though the night air was cool. As Mitch grabbed the handle on the door I knew that it was too late. I was going into this blind. He pulled the door open and held it for me. As I stepped through the doorway, he placed his hand on the small of my back.
My face instantly flushed. This was a real date.
Justice was in a corner booth with another girl. She waved us over with a smile. She slid out and greeted Mitch with a hug. “Mitch, this is Kara.” She introduced him to her girlfriend. Kara looked like she was a lot of fun. She had bright purple hair, freckles and a huge smile. Kara gave Mitch a hug. Mitch turned to me. He locked eyes with me and we both realized at the same moment that he needed to introduce me. I could see the panic in his eyes. What was he going to introduce me as?
“Uhh Justice, this is… Lucas.” The girls both gave me hugs. I tried to hide the fact that I was disappointed that he hadn’t introduced me as his boyfriend. I knew it was unrealistic. We hadn’t even discussed things. We’d hooked up once. Mitch asked me on a date, but he hadn’t asked me to be his boyfriend. Keep it real Lucas. Don’t get carried away.
Mitch and I slid onto the opposite side of the booth from the girls. They were excitedly discussing what they wanted to order. Mitch glanced at me. I met his gaze. He gave me a little smile. I cautiously placed a hand on his knee and gave it a squeeze. He put his hand over mine. His thumb slowly caressed my hand. I searched his eyes, trying to read his mind.
The waiter interrupted us. We all gave him our orders. Justice settled back and met the pair of us with an inquisitive stare. “So how long have you two been together?”
I felt Mitch tense up beside me. I had no clue what to say so I was relying on Mitch.
“Uh, it’s kinda a new thing.” Mitch shifted awkwardly.
“Well you are adorable together.” Justice said confidently. Kara nodded in agreement.
“How did you know about me?” Mitch blurted out. It was so sudden that it caught Justice off guard. She recovered quickly though.
“Call it a hunch.” She shrugged.
Dinner was great. We fell into comfortable conversation. I understood why Mitch enjoyed spending time with Justice. It really was like hanging out with the guys. At one point Justice pulled out her phone and took a selfie of the four of us. Mitch asked her to send him a copy.
As the waiter was clearing our plates he asked how he should split the bill. “The two of us on one check.” Justice pointed to Kara.
“The two of us on another.” I pointed to Mitch. He thanked me with a smile. I wondered if he remembered me saying that I’d pick up the bill the other night.
Mitch invited us back to his room for a little concert and we all gladly accepted. The walk back to his room was very different from the walk to the restaurant. The awkwardness was gone. Mitch wrapped his arm around my waist for most of the walk. As we neared campus, his hand slipped into my back pocket. I gave him a surprised look and he raised one eyebrow and smiled.
My bulge started to grow a bit. I had to concentrate to keep it in check. Luckily he pulled his hand out as soon as we got to a more crowded area of campus. I suddenly got a little nervous. What if we walked by someone we knew? It was painfully obvious that we were acting like a couple. Mitch must have been thinking the same thing because he took a step away from me.
Justice must have noticed. “Wait, are you guys not out?”
Mitch looked back at her and shook his head ‘no’.
She stayed quiet the rest of the way to Mitch’s room. His single was actually fairly large. The centerpiece was a massive bean bag chair. There was always a fight over who got to sit in it anytime we were hanging out in his room.
The girls quickly jumped on the bean bag leaving Mitch and I to sit on his bed.
“So why aren’t you guys out yet?” Justice seemed genuinely curious.
Mitch shot me a nervous glance before answering. “When I said it was kinda a new thing, that was an understatement.”
“How new?” Kara asked, now as intrigued as her girlfriend.
“That was actually our first date…” Mitch said, his voice almost a whisper. The girls looked at us in shock.
“Tonight was your first date?” Justice asked. I nodded.
“Have either of you dated a guy before?” Kara chimed in.
I looked at Mitch. I suddenly realized that I wasn’t sure if he’d dated a guy before. Sure, he’d expressed interest in girls but he could have dated a guy in high school or something.
We both shook our heads ‘no’. The girls both exploded in excited energy. They showered us with hugs and congratulations. I was surprised when they stopped asking questions. Perhaps they realized that we didn’t really know the answers to them yet.
Mitch got Kyle out and played a few songs. His eyes lit up when I sang along with a few of them. Listening to his Spotify playlists had been a good idea. Justice and Kara excused themselves fairly early. I think they wanted to give us some time alone.
As soon as the door closed behind them, an awkward silence fell over the room. Mitch and I glanced at each other. He gave me a nervous smile.
I decided to break the ice. “I had a really great time tonight.”
“I did too.” He put Kyle back into his case.
I couldn’t tell if I should offer to head out for the night or if he wanted me to stay and talk. “Would you be interested in going on another date?” My voice wavered a bit. Why were my palms clammy all of a sudden?
Mitch looked at me and sat down on the bed next to me. He put his head in his hands. I couldn’t tell if he was upset or angry. I slid away from him a bit.
“Why do you have to be so fucking sweet?” He sounded frustrated. I couldn’t tell if it was a rhetorical question. I decided to answer just in case it wasn’t.
“I don’t know. Why do you have to be so damned perfect?” My voice was practically a whisper. Mitch heard me though because he turned his head to look at me. His eyes were bloodshot. Had he been crying?
“I’m not perfect…” He said snidely.
“Well you had me fucking fooled. You’re super talented playing guitar. You’re intelligent and basically an encyclopedia when it comes to musical knowledge. You’re the hottest guy I know. You’re kind. You’re compassionate. You’re kinda mysterious and intriguing. And you smell good.”
The corner of his mouth turned upward a bit. “I smell good?” A tiny grin formed on his face.
“Yes, you smell good.”
“When have you smelled me?” The tiny grin was growing in size.
“Dude, any time I’m sitting near you. When you hug me it's like…” I stopped before I said too much.
“It’s like what?” He pressed me.
“It does things to me.” I could feel my face get red.
“What kind of things?” His voice had changed its tone. He was becoming the Mitch from our night under the stars.
“Naughty things.” We locked eyes. I resisted the urge to make the first move. I still wasn’t entirely sure what was going on between us and I didn’t want to misread signs.
After what felt like an eternity, Mitch finally asked, “Would you want to spend the night?”
Did it suddenly get warm in the room? I broke out in a sweat. “Yeah, I’d like that.” I tried to downplay how excited I was. I don’t think I did a very good job.
Mitch didn’t waste any time. He flipped off the light and started getting undressed. I wasn’t entirely sure what was going on. Was this him asking me to have sex? It would be super fucking awkward if I tried to hook up with him and he just meant to go to sleep. He left his boxers on and slid under the covers.
I followed his lead and stripped down to my boxers and slid next to him. His bed was a typical dorm bed. There was barely enough room for one person, let alone two. My shoulder was wedged against Mitch’s.
“Are you gay?” He blurted it out so suddenly I flinched.
I almost laughed at his question. No Mitch, I’m straight. That’s why I swallowed your dick the other night and went on a date with you tonight. “I’m certainly not straight…” I wasn’t quite ready to put a label on myself, but I knew that my answer would suffice. He was just making sure I was into guys.
I waited for what seemed like a small eternity for him to respond. I assumed he would automatically reply that he wasn’t straight either. As the seconds ticked by I began to get more and more worried. Was he about to claw his way back into the closet?
Maybe he wanted me to ask? “What about you?”
I heard him let out a sigh in the darkness. “Can I be honest with you?” He sounded like he was trying to hold back a flood of emotions.
“Of course, I want us to be totally honest with one another.” I rolled over on my side to face him, even though I couldn’t see him in the inky darkness.
“I’m not fucking sure what I am.” His voice wavered and he let out a little sob at the end.
I placed a hand on his chest. “Mitch, I don’t know what I am either. I just know that I like you… in a not straight way.”
“I think I like you that way too.” He sounded nervous but his emotions seemed to be under control.
“Well there is no rush to figure things out. We just need to make sure we’re both on the same page, right?” I was slowly caressing his chest.
“Yeah. I’m sorry about the way I acted that night. I…” He took a deep breath. I could sense him trying to gain courage to open up. “I’ve always felt a connection to you. At first I thought it was just me being drawn to you as a friend because you're such an interesting person.”
I was tempted to interrupt him to tell him that I’m not really that interesting, but I opted to stay quiet.
“But as time went on I kept wanting to spend more time with you. And I kept wanting our time together to be just the two of us.” He was speaking more quickly now. “I wanted to know more and more about you. I wanted to be close to you. Not just close as in our friendship, like physically close to you.” The floodgates were starting to open. “I found myself thinking about you as I was laying in bed at night. I started to daydream about what it would be like if we became roommates. It might sound stupid but even with all of that I was in denial about it being…” he stumbled for a second trying to find the right word. “a romantic interest. I was trying to put other labels on it. I wanted us to be besties or have a bromance or anything I could think of to deny that I wanted to be with you.”
I was shocked. I’d always felt a little spark with Mitch but just wrote it off as his flirtatious nature. How the hell did I miss him being into me for so long?
“That night when you showed up to listen to me play, something just snapped in me and I stopped trying to hold back. I basically threw myself at you and even though you seemed to be into it too, I didn’t know how to fucking process what just happened. I wanted to show up at your room and confess my feelings for you but I was terrified that you were going to say that you were just experimenting or something and that you weren’t interested in me like that.”
He paused to catch his breath.
“Mitch, I’m interested in you like that too.” I reassured him.
“This probably sounds crazy but that scares me almost as much as if you’d said you weren’t interested. Because now I have to admit all these feelings. To myself, to you, to… our friends maybe.”
Oh shit, he was already thinking about coming out. I traced up his chest with my hand and placed a finger on his lips.
“We have all the time we need to figure all that out Mitch.” I replaced my finger with my lips. He turned towards me and wrapped an arm around me. I melted into him. His soft lips caressed mine. His warm wet tongue met mine. He reached up and ran his fingers through my hair. I was beginning to get lost in the moment when he suddenly stopped.
“Would it be okay if I turned on my lamp?” His voice was nervous again.
“Sure?”
He leaned over me and clicked on his bedside lamp. Its soft glow seemed unnaturally bright after being in darkness for so long.
“I can’t believe it's you in my bed with me. I want to be able to see you.” He blushed and broke eye contact.
Emotion erupted inside me. “Mitch, you can look at any part of me that you want to.” His eyes snapped back up to mine. A grin spread across his face. He leaned back in and kissed me. His kiss was brief and as he pulled back he gently bit my bottom lip. He took my chin in his hand and turned my head away from him. He ran his lips along my cheek and nibbled on my ear. My back arched in excitement.
Mitch ran his tongue down my neck. He paused to suck on my neck for a second. A small moan escaped from my lips. I reached up and ran my fingers through his soft hair. His lips traced their way down to my chest. He paused to flick my nipple with his tongue. I could feel the inside of my boxers getting coated in precum.
Mitch took my hand in his. He inspected my hand, flipping it over a few times. He kissed my knuckles before flipping my hand over to kiss my palm. He ran his lips up my forearm. He kissed my bicep and gently bit my muscle. He guided my hand up behind my head, exposing my armpit. He licked down my arm and brushed his lips over my armpit hair. It tickled but I managed to suppress the urge to push him away. He ran his nose up and down my armpit inhaling my scent.
He moved his way back down to my chest. He licked my abs on his way to my belly button. He flicked it with his tongue for a bit. My dick was aching for him. He ran his tongue down my thin happy trail. When he reached my boxers he wrapped his fingers around the waistband. He looked up at me for permission. I nodded and lifted my hips, allowing him to slip them off.
My dick slapped against my stomach, spraying a bit of precum on me. Mitch slid down next to my dick. He gently wrapped his hand around it. I was pulsing in anticipation. He gave it a slow stroke, watching the skin slide up and down. He ran his thumb over my circumcision scar feeling the difference in texture. He leaned down and ran his lips over the head briefly. He pulled back a bit and licked the precum off his lips. I could see him thinking about the taste. He glanced up at me. We locked eyes. His gaze was intense. Without breaking eye contact he slowly leaned down and took me into his mouth. His lips wrapped around my head. The wet warmth of his mouth sent a shiver of excitement through my body. I reached down and caressed the side of his face.
He kept eye contact as he swirled his tongue around my head. I let out an excited gasp. His eyes gleamed. He slowly slid down, taking me deeper inside him. He reached up with his free hand and pinched my nipple. The sensation caused my back to arch again. He pushed my dick deeper into his throat, planting his nose in my pubic hair. He held it there for a second before sliding it out. He finally broke eye contact to look at my now glistening dick. I was so hard that it hurt. He gave it a few quick strokes before attacking it again with his mouth.
I felt my orgasm beginning to build. He used his hand along with his mouth to pleasure the full length of my dick. The orgasm was building quickly. “I’m going to cum…” I warned him. Mitch didn’t slow his pace and he kept me in his mouth. I put my hands on his head as my abs flexed.
I erupted with a loud moan. Mitch kept his lips locked around my head as I unloaded. His tongue caressed my dick as I let the final shot into his mouth. He spent a moment cleaning me up with his mouth before looking back up at me.
His face was a mix of emotions. I could see the excitement mixing with a bit of fear and apprehension. I pulled him up to me and planted my lips on his. As we kissed I tasted myself, adding to the excitement.
He finally pulled his face off mine. I grinned. “My turn.”