Blurred Lines - Part 9 (Patreon)
Content
At the dawn of affection, a new tale begins,Two hearts converging in the dance of destiny,In shared smiles and whispers, a bond takes root,The birth of love, a symphony in serendipity.
Silence seemed to descend over the room. I glanced nervously at Mitch. I could see the color drain out of his face.
“Yeah, Justice and Kara are a blast to hang out with.” I tried to sound casual. If he knew them, there was no point in trying to pretend. Hopefully he’d just assume Mitch and I went out to dinner with them as friends, not as a double date. Mitch glanced over at me. I could see terror in his eyes.
I wished that I could silently tell him not to worry. At least two of the guys in the room with us weren’t straight. And the other two seemed to be allies. Thinking about Ethan and Ollie only made me feel worse. I wanted to be honest with Mitch about what had happened between me and the two of them, but I was scared. What if he was upset that I’d fooled around with other guys in the group? What if he broke things off?
If Mitch and I got serious, would that make things awkward with the two of us and Ethan and Ollie? Would it mean the end of nights like this? It suddenly felt like the walls were closing in on me. My skin started to tingle. It was getting hard to breathe.
“That reminds me. I volunteered us to help out at the Gay / Straight Alliance bake sale.” Aiden said casually, his attention still on the ridiculous scene unfolding on the TV screen.
“Dammit, why did you have to do that?” Caleb looked upset.
I could feel Mitch tense up. This conversation was quickly going downhill.
“You know how much I hate working at bake sales. I end up buying a ton of junk food and then have to starve myself after.” Caleb continued. “Next time promise me it’ll be a walk-a-thon and not a bake sale.”
“How many calories are in each of these chalupas?” Ollie asked, holding one up and inspecting it.
“Do NOT answer that question!” Caleb practically shouted as he finished his fourth one and gave Ollie a good-natured glare.
“What did you say you made for dessert?” Ollie asked Ethan. He gave Caleb a mischievous smile.
“Tres leches cake.” Ethan was clearly enjoying teasing Caleb as much as Ollie was.
“Oh fuck you… that’s not even funny.” Caleb looked genuinely upset. “You know how much I fucking love his tres leches.” He mumbled, crossing his arms like an upset child.
Luckily the conversation drifted to other topics and nobody else brought up the ‘date’ that Aiden had referred to. After a half hour or so, Mitch made an excuse of having to study for a test and got up to leave.
“I should really go home and study too.” I lied. I hoped that it didn’t seem too suspicious. I gave Ethan a big hug and Venmoed him for the food. As soon as Mitch and I got outside he grabbed my hand.
My mind flew through a series of emotions. At first I was elated that Mitch was holding my hand. Then I was nervous that someone would see us. But once I felt how tightly he was holding my hand, those feelings disappeared and my only concern was for him. I squeezed his hand and began walking back towards campus.
“He knows…” Mitch whispered. His voice was bordering on panic.
“So what if he does? It’s not like he cares. He signed us up for the bake sale.” I wanted to try to calm Mitch down without having to share what I knew about Ethan and Ollie. I wasn’t ready to have that conversation with him yet.
His grip relaxed a bit as he thought things over. The cool night air sent a chill up my spine. I shivered and moved in closer to Mitch. He glanced over at me and a small smile crept onto his face for the first time since Aiden brought up seeing us.
“I don’t think I’m ready for the guys to know yet.” His voice was quiet and he glanced around nervously as if he was worried that someone might overhear us.
“I mean, what would we even tell them? That we went on one date?” I pointed out. I didn’t want to sound like I was fishing for a label, but I was kinda fishing for a label.
Mitch squeezed my hand. “Yeah, it's not even like we’re official or anything.” He glanced up at me for confirmation.
I could tell by the tone of his voice that he was hoping that I would offer to make it official. Butterflies swarmed my stomach. Did I like Mitch? Absolutely. Was I ready to have an actual boyfriend? I wasn’t sure.
If I had a boyfriend then that would mean that I was gay. Or at least bi. Sure, I’d hooked up with a couple guys and that pretty much meant I wasn’t straight, but admitting that to other people was a big step.
Just thinking about the conversations that I was going to have to have with friends and family terrified me. Why the fuck did it have to be so difficult, just because Mitch was a guy and not a girl? It wasn’t fair. If he was a girl I could just be like, ‘yeah we’re an item’ and nobody would bat an eye.
But instead I had to figure out if my desire to be with Mitch was worth the most embarrassing conversation I’d probably ever have with my parents.
Mitch was worth it though. I took a deep breath. “Do you want to make it official?” My mouth was suddenly dry. I could feel a cold sweat forming under my hoodie. My heart thudded in my ears. The seconds ticked by as I waited for an answer. Mitch was looking down and avoiding eye contact.
The fear of rejection began to rush through me. This wasn’t typical rejection though. I’d asked a girl out my freshman year of high school and she told me that I wasn’t her type. Even though it stung a bit, I couldn’t fault her. She just wasn’t into me.
But I knew that Mitch was into me. He was REALLY into me. He’d told me so in bed last night. The question was, is he into me enough to come out to be with me. Every second I waited, I was beginning to doubt it more and more.
He suddenly stopped walking. I froze beside him. The silence was overwhelming.
He finally looked up at me. Tears were running down his face. His lip was trembling. “I want it more than you can imagine. I’m just terrified.” His voice cracked with emotion.
Tears had started to roll down my face. “I’m terrified too.” I squeezed his hand. “But we’ll have each other.”
His face lit up and his trembling lip was replaced by the start of a smile. “C’mon.” He started to run and pulled me along with him. We raced towards his dorm, laughing like children. Nothing else mattered in that moment. Nothing scared me.
Mitch didn’t let go of my hand as we made our way across campus. People were still out but I didn’t care if they saw. I was holding Mitch’s hand. And he was my boyfriend.
The door to his room hadn’t fully closed before he began to tear off my clothes. All of my other experiences had been slow drawn out encounters. But with Mitch it was different. The passion took control and we were like a whirlwind of hormones. I managed to get Mitch out of all his clothes and tossed him down on the bed. I got a little carried away and threw him with a bit more force than anticipated. He bounced on the bed and his eyes got wild with surprise. I was about to apologize when he grabbed me and pulled me on top of him.
Our lips explored one another. Unlike the past two times, there were no inhibitions. Mitch was my boyfriend. I was allowed to touch him, to taste him. He rolled me over so that I was underneath him. He began to lick my neck as he straddled me. My dick was rubbing against his ass.
I ached for him. My body developed a mind of its own. I began to thrust against him. I wanted Mitch. I wanted to be inside him. My hands found their way onto his hips. He began to rub himself against me.
The reality of the situation suddenly hit me. Even though I’d been thinking about dating Mitch non-stop for the past 24 hours, it hadn’t dawned on me that we’d eventually have actual sex.
Mitch reached under the bed. The view made my dick pulse. Naked sweaty Mitch was straddling me and leaning over the edge of the bed. My eyes soaked up the view. I wanted to frame it in my mind so that I could see it forever and always.
The view was fleeting though. He was holding a condom and lube. The fear and excitement on his face mirrored my own. I had no clue what I was doing. Which one of us was going to wear the condom? I was hoping that he wanted me to. At least I’d have a clue what to do in that case.
I let out a little sigh of relief when he put the condom on me and began to lube it up. We kept shooting each other nervous glances.
“I’ve never done this before.” I warned him. The last thing I wanted to do was to disappoint him.
“Me neither.” His voice was wild with emotion. Nothing else needed to be said. We were headed into uncharted waters together.
He lubed himself up and got back on top of me. He looked slightly terrified. I pulled him in for a kiss. As our tongues got to know one another, my dick began to press against his hole.
It was tight, but as we made out I felt the head slowly start to work its way inside him. He pushed back against me and my head popped in. Mitch moaned into my mouth. His eyes locked onto mine.
“You ok?” I whispered. He nodded excitedly. I could tell that he was clearly enjoying it. We went slow and over the next few minutes more and more of me made its way inside Mitch until I finally bottomed out. He was panting. Sweat was dripping off of him onto me. His tight warmth had me close to orgasm even though we weren’t moving.
“Fuck me.” Mitch whispered, his eyes locking onto mine. We held eye contact as I slowly slid back and then thrust into him. His eyes got wide as I slid back in. He bit his bottom lip. I thrust again and his eyelids fluttered. The sensation of being inside him was more amazing than I had ever imagined.
I began to pick up my pace. I slapped against his firm ass. My hand wrapped around his dick and I began to stroke him. Mitch began to moan. He was so loud that I momentarily considered trying to shush him so people in the dorm didn’t hear, but with my next thrust I stopped caring. Let them hear. Let them hear Mitch moan as I fucked his brains out.
My thrusts became faster. Mitch’s moans became louder. My orgasm was already beginning to build. I began to stroke his dick faster. It was fully coated in his precum. I was about to warn him that I was going to cum when his eyes rolled back in his head and he shouted ‘fuck’. His first shot landed on my cheek, catching me by surprise. As he continued to unload onto my chest, my balls tightened and with a few quick thrusts I erupted inside him. My toes curled and my entire body spasmed for a few seconds in the most intense orgasm of my life.
Mitch collapsed onto me. I was still inside him. “That was amazing.” I panted.
“I felt your dick spasm inside me. It felt amazing.” Mitch was breathless.
We laid like that for almost an hour. Our bodies fused into one.