Finding My Soulmate - Part 2 (Patreon)
Content
That night was amazing. After washing one another in the shower, we returned to the bed. Henry slipped under the covers nude and I followed his lead. He wrapped an arm around me and pulled me back against him, planting a single long kiss on the back of my neck. “Good night Drew, I love you.” he whispered in my ear. I drifted off to sleep with his nude body wedged against mine.
I woke up to him laying on my chest. I leaned down and gave him a kiss on the top of his head. His hair was almost unnaturally soft. He turned his head around to look up at me and gave me a smile. “Morning.” he said before laying back down on my chest. Neither of us were really morning people so lounging around in bed had become typical for us.
“So…” I started. “What now?”
“Coffee.” he mumbled.
I laughed. “Yeah I assumed you wanted a coffee. I meant what now with us?”
“Oh.” He thought for a few moments. “Nothing’s really changed except we do this now.” He reached his hand down and gently grabbed my dick.
“That’s kinda a big change…” I pointed out.
“Well. It’s not THAT big.” he ran his hand up and down the length of my shaft.
“Okay, firstly that’s RUDE.” I poked his side and he squirmed and let out a little laugh. “And secondly, it changes so much.”
“What though?” he asked. “We were always planning on living together right?” he explained.
“Yeah.”
“We’ve been basically acting like a couple since I broke up with Sara. Just minus the sex.”
“True.” I admitted.
“Now it’s just not minus the sex anymore.” he made it sound like the simplest thing in the world.
“Henry… as far as I knew, you were straight yesterday morning.” I had to make him understand things from my point of view.
“Fuck dude. You’re right, I’m sorry. I had always just been looking at this knowing deep down that we would probably end up together some day. I was scared to talk to you about it because I didn’t want to get your hopes up if something changed for me.”
I understood where he was coming from. “Have you talked to anyone else about not being straight?” I was cautious with the label because I wasn’t entirely sure how he identified yet.
“I got kinda drunk one night a couple of months ago and told Ron I wasn’t sure what sexuality meant to me.” Ron was his best friend on the west coast.
“Are we going to tell people?”
Henry thought about it for a while. “I’m not sure I’m ready for that yet.”
I understood his hesitation. Not only was the thought of coming out scary, but there was the issue of being judged for being together. He was already being judged by friends and family for having been kicked out of school and suddenly becoming a drug addict. If he was suddenly in a gay relationship with the person who took him in, it would look super suspicious. People would immediately assume we were in the relationship for all the wrong reasons.
“Yeah, I get it. Do you think we can keep people from figuring it out?” I asked.
“Dude. We can do anything we put our minds to.” He had a point. We had both managed to keep our sexuality secret from everyone in our lives. This wouldn’t be much harder.
I felt his dick begin to twitch against my leg. I flipped Henry onto his back and slid down. I wanted to see his monster up close. He had a smile plastered to his face. His dick had to be at least 9 inches. I grabbed it with both hands and began to lick the tip. He let out a soft moan. I eased it into my mouth. It was so long that I could only get halfway down it before gagging.
“I’ve dreamed about you doing this to me for a long time.” he whispered.
I stopped what I was doing and looked up at him. “Seriously? Why the fuck did it take you so long to let me play with this monster then?” I put on a fake angry face.
He laughed. The sound of his laughter always made me smile.
I went back to pleasuring him with my mouth. The smell of his dick drove me wild. I used my mouth and right hand to pleasure his cock and slipped a finger of my left hand into his tight ass. I began to massage his prostate as I sucked him off. It only took a few moments before his balls tensed up. The first shot was massive. It practically filled my mouth. I swallowed it just as the second and third hit me. He tasted delicious. A delicate mixture of salty and sweet. His orgasm subsided and I removed the finger from his ass, but I kept his dick in my mouth. I didn’t want to let go of the prize I’d dreamed of for so long.
Even after he was completely soft again I kept it in my mouth. “You’re going to look pretty fucking silly going out to get us coffee with my dick in your mouth.” he said. I couldn’t help but laugh.
“Fine, I’ll be back in a minute.”. I tossed on clothes and ran across the street to Dunkin. I knew his order by heart, large cold brew, three pumps of caramel, cream and a turbo shot. I don’t know how he even managed to drink it, but he seemed to love it.
I returned to the room to find him in the shower. “Got your coffee.”
“Sweet, get in here and let me wash you.” he didn’t need to tell me twice. I climbed into the shower expecting him to go after my dick. Instead, he began to shampoo my hair. He then carefully washed every inch of my body with delicate care. As innocent as his touch was, being tended to like this aroused me even more than if he had been playing with my dick.
After washing me, he turned off the water and grabbed a towel. “Step out.” I did as he instructed and he dried me tenderly. My eyes shifted between his piercing blue eyes and his huge soft dick. After drying me off he quickly dried himself and slipped on his boxer briefs. He grabbed his coffee, “Mmmm”.
I smiled at him. “I don’t know how you enjoy that monstrosity of a coffee.” I got dressed. He opted to remain in his underwear. He was clearly enjoying me eyeing him.
“Can I admit something to you?” Henry asked. He looked a little nervous which was unlike him.
“Of course dude.”
“So that wasn’t technically my first time bottoming.” his statement caught me completely off guard.
“You’ve been with other guys?” even though I had no right to be, I was suddenly extremely jealous.
“No no. I bought a toy a few months ago.” he quickly explained.
“Oh…” I tried to hide my relief. “I was kinda wondering why it wasn’t super painful for you.”
“It still hurt. You are bigger than the dildo that I bought.”
“You really know how to boost a guy’s ego, ya know?” I smiled at him.
“So, yeah…” he trailed off. I realized that he wanted to talk more about the subject but was having difficulty.
“So why did you buy a toy?”
“I guess I suspected that I might enjoy bottoming and wanted to try it out.”
“And I take it that you’re a fan based on the noises you were making last night?”
“Have you ever tried it?” he seemed embarrassed for asking.
“No, you know that I was a virgin until…” I paused as my mind wandered back to the ecstasy of his tight ass wrapped around my cock. “Last night.”
“Yeah, I just wasn’t sure if maybe you tried using a toy before.”
“To be honest, the thought of bottoming doesn’t really appeal to me.” I shrugged.
“Yeah I didn’t think I’d enjoy it for the longest time. Then I got curious. And then I tried it. Holy shit, it is amazing.” he admitted.
“I’m hungry. What’s it going to be, breakfast or buttsex?” I asked with a grin.
“Why not both?” Henry replied with a smirk.
He slipped off his boxers and dragged me over to the bed by my waistband. He slid my shorts down and pulled me onto the bed on top of him. Our lips met. His lips were surprisingly soft and there was the smallest amount of stubble on his face. I gave him a deep passionate kiss and he whispered into my mouth, “I want you to fuck me.” He didn’t have to ask me twice.
I grabbed the lube off of the nightstand and lifted his legs onto my shoulders. Giving me access to his tight hairless hole. I rubbed some lube on my dick and then slowly stuck a lubed up finger inside him. It was tight at first, but his ass allowed it to slip inside. Once he looked comfortable, I slipped a second and then a third into him. He was ready. I teased his ass with my rock hard cock, sliding it up and down between his firm cheeks. I could tell how badly he wanted it by the look on his face. Finally he couldn’t take it anymore. “...please I need you inside me.”
I slowly slid the head into him. His eyes rolled back in his head and he inhaled sharply. “All the way.” I slowly slid the rest of my 7 inches into him as he arched his back in painful bliss. “Fuck your cock feels good in me.”
I slowly began pumping. I let his moans set the tone at first, but then began to pick up the pace. He began to stroke his drooling cock. “I want you to cum on me.”
My mind was reeling. I am fucking my formerly straight best friend Henry while he is jerking off his massive erect dick and he wants me to cum on him. “Where?”
“Anywhere you want.” he bit his lip for a second as a wave of pleasure rocked his thin frame. “Surprise me.”
As much as I wanted to last for an hour, after only a few minutes Henry’s ass suddenly tightened up and he began to shoot arcs of cum onto his chest. The sight pushed me to the point of no return. I pulled my dick out of him and moved beside him. I took aim and unloaded 5 glistening ropes of cum onto his face.
As I began to come back down to Earth I suddenly felt bad about my choice. “Fuck dude, I’m sorry. Let me wipe that off.” I grabbed a towel to wipe off his face.
“No! Leave it.” he said sternly. I stopped what I was doing. “It’s fucking hot.” he slid some of my cum into his mouth with his finger. It was all I could do to keep my dick from springing back to life. “Another shower?” he asked.
“Another shower.” I pulled him up to his feet and led the way back to the bathroom.
Getting Comfortable
The next few weeks flew by. Our comfort level with one another grew. We had already been extremely close, so becoming truly physically intimate with one another came naturally. We began sleeping nude, even on nights when we weren’t planning on fooling around, not that there were many nights like that…
We settled on secrecy for now. Friends and family weren’t to find out that we were gay or together. We decided against any forms of PDA unless we were out of town where absolutely nobody knew us. But behind closed doors, Henry had become a voracious power bottom. He wanted to go for at least 3 hours each night.
It wasn’t uncommon for him to send me to the shower to clean up and recharge 2 or 3 times a night. We began going through a list of all the things that he and I wanted to try. We tried every possible position. We tried different types of toys. We tried bondage. We turned the bedroom into a video studio to record some of our antics. Eventually we started to run out of things to try.
As we lay in bed one night, spent from hours of lovemaking, Henry snuggled up on my chest and shot me an adorable smile. He put his eyes in puppy dog mode. “Dude, I’ve cum 3 times tonight. I can’t go again.”
“No, no, not that. I was wondering if there is something else you’d be down to try.” he asked.
I shrugged, “What do you have in mind.”
“Okay, so don’t get mad. You know I love you, right?” he asked nervously.
“Yeah… what the hell do you want to try?” I was worried now.
“I really really want to try sucking a dick while you fuck me.” We had tried giving him the sensation of that by having him fuck himself with his toy while he sucked my dick, but it clearly wasn’t the same.
“Okay.” I said warily.
“I promise it's just a one time thing. Nothing is going to come between us.” his electric blue eyes locked on to mine. I nodded.
We agreed that we both had to approve of the 3rd and that it was a one time thing unless the two of us enjoyed it enough to do it again.
Henry installed Grindr on his phone and added a shirtless pic of himself. Within minutes his phone was flooded. We got comfortable and put on a movie while we looked through the options. Eventually we stumbled onto Thomas. Thomas was nineteen years old and had a Mediterranean complexion. He looked to be one of those guys who could be both adorable and sexy at the same time. We both agreed that we would be okay with having him as a 3rd.
After chatting for a bit, Thomas agreed to hang out with Henry and I the next afternoon to see if we hit it off and felt comfortable enough with each other to fool around.
The next morning I started to get apprehensive. What if Henry ended up liking Thomas more than he liked me. I’m not usually jealous by nature, but I didn’t want anything to mess up what Henry and I had.
I pushed all the fears aside and when afternoon rolled around, Henry and I hopped in the car to go pick up Thomas. On the drive there I started laughing.
“What’s so funny?” Henry asked.
“Dude, if you had told me a few months ago that I’d be in the car with you going to pick up a twink that we found on Grindr for a threesome, I’d have thought you were insane.”
He gave me a goofy grin. “I know. Sometimes life takes you to a place you didn’t expect.”
I nodded at his words. GPS was taking us out of town on a series of backroads. We pulled up to an old farmhouse. “I hope he is as hot as his picture made him look.” Henry said quietly.
The door opened and Thomas jogged over and jumped in the backseat. Henry shot me a sly smile. He was hotter than his pictures made him look. “Hey, I’m Thomas.” a hand shot between the front seats. Henry shook his hand and introduced us to him. I let them talk for a bit as we drove to a restaurant to grab some food.
Thomas seemed oddly relaxed for someone who had just jumped into a car with two strangers he met on Grindr. I glanced back at him. He had a couple of tattoos visible and his knuckles looked like they had seen a fight or two. I guessed that he was perfectly capable of taking care of himself.
As we sat down in the restaurant, a second of awkward silence hit us. I decided the best way to break the ice was for me to simply strike up a conversation with Henry. As we started talking about a new album that he had been listening to earlier, Thomas excitedly jumped into the conversation. Turns out he was a music lover too. By the time the food arrived, it was like we were three old friends.
The conversation was effortless. Thomas began to get a feel for Henry and I. I could tell that it wasn’t what he was expecting… in a good way. After eating we decided to drive around for a while and talk.
Thomas had a rough childhood. He had been in an advanced math and science school up until high school, but then he started suffering from anger issues. His parents had just gone through a hard divorce and he had ended up with his mom instead of his dad like he wanted. She had gotten the state involved when he started acting up and the next thing he knew he was a ward of the state and in a program that sounded like a prison with high school classes.
He had signed himself out of the program on his 18th birthday and was living with his dad while he tried to get his life back together. He seemed surprised and relieved that neither Henry nor I responded negatively to his story. He clearly had become used to people judging him for his past.
We ended up driving around and talking for 4 hours before I finally drove him back to his place. “Now that we’ve met each other, if you still want to do what we talked about, hit me up tomorrow.” Henry said to him as he was getting out of the car.
Thomas’ eyes darted back and forth between the two of us. “Yeah, I’m still down.” he waved goodbye as we pulled out of his driveway.
Henry and I were silent for a few minutes as we drove home.
“Did we just find a bad boy twink with tats that has a heart of gold?” he asked.
“Yeah I think we did…”
“That’s kinda hot right?” he asked cautiously.
“Yeah it is.” I admitted.
The Talk
It was well after midnight by the time we crawled into bed. It had been a hot day and as Henry snuggled up next to me I inhaled his sweet aroma. He was an oddity. He sweated a ton but he didn’t stink at all. There was a really subtle spicy musk but that was it. I could tell that it was loaded with pheromones though because my brain craved his smell. Whenever I was having a hard day, he would just push my face in his armpit because he knew it would instantly relax me.
“We should go over ground rules about what is off limits with him.” Henry said. Even though I was hesitant about bringing Thomas into our bed, Henry was truly the jealous one in the relationship. He didn’t like sharing me. Even when it was with a straight friend that I got along well with. I found his jealousy adorable.
“Okay, what’s off limits?” I asked.
He licked his way up my neck, over my chin and then kissed me deeply. “No kissing him.”
“Agreed.”
Henry slipped down and pulled out my dick. He held it for a moment, inspecting it closely. He then slipped it into his mouth. A soft moan crept out of my lips. “This is mine.” He squeezed my dick. “He’s not allowed to touch it.”
“And what about this?” I reached up and grabbed his massive cock through his boxer briefs.
“That’s yours. Not his.” Just then, Henry’s phone dinged. He grabbed it. “He just texted me. He’s excited for tomorrow.”
“You should probably warn him about the rules we just made.” I pointed out.
“Good point.” Henry typed furiously for a minute. There was a short pause and then he got a response. He tossed his phone on the bed. “He’s fine with that. Now where were we.”
I slid my hand into his boxers. “We were talking about how much I wanted your huge cock in my mouth.”
He smiled. “We were?”
“Yup, we were.” I flipped him off of me onto his back and slid his boxers off. His dick was pulsing with anticipation. He hadn’t trimmed his pubes since he arrived and they were at the length that I liked… long enough to run your hands over and they felt soft not prickly, but not so long that they got in your mouth when you’re sucking his dick.
I ran my tongue from the bottom of his sack up to the tip of his dick. I licked the precum off the tip before slipping it into my mouth. “I fucking love you.” he said to me.
I slipped his dick out of my mouth long enough to ask, “Are you just saying that because I have your dick in my mouth?”
“No you dipshit.” he gave me a playful smack on the head. “I…” his voice cracked slightly, taking me by surprise. I looked up at him. “I just want you to know how much you mean to me. This is a forever thing for me.”
I understood immediately what he meant. We’d already planned on spending our lives together as straight friends, and now we could do that as best friends and lovers. “It is for me too. I love you with my whole heart Henry.” I slid up and kissed him. Seconds turned into minutes as we became lost in each other.
I came up for air and looked into his pale blue eyes. He looked back at me, unblinking. Neither of us broke the gaze. The seconds ticked away. It suddenly dawned on me that I’d never looked into a guy’s eyes for this long before. His eyes were a mixture of emotion. It started as pure love. Then there was a glimmer of lust. The complexity of our relationship could be read in his eyes as he looked at me. We laid there for at least 10 minutes just staring into one another’s eyes, not saying a word. Words would have been useless, they couldn’t even begin to describe the conversation that we were having with our souls.
I pulled him in close and held him. No ‘goodnight’ was said, it wasn’t needed.