The Eye of the Beholder (Patreon)
Content

Before I get into this brief topic, a quick update on the Ironsworn giveaway. Last week my wife was super busy, and then she went out of town for 4 days, so she hasn't had the chance to read the prompts yet. She will this week, and I'll announce the winner after that.
But now onto a topic on which I am sure everyone will agree with everyone and there won't be any arguing at all - art!
No one ever disagrees about art!
I've been working on putting together my Top 10 list of the games with the best art, and let me tell you....it's been an arduous task. There are so many amazing artists out there, and so many games with so much great art! I look at my shelves and they're overflowing with great looking games.
And there are SO MANY styles. It's almost silly to compare The Gloom of Kilforth -

to Escape the Dark Castle-

but I like the art in both of these games. Could there be a bigger difference in styles?
There is also the powerful draw of nostalgia. My love of nostalgia has been well documented on the Dungeon Dive, and one of the most powerful forces driving that nostalgia is the art. I am, of course, specifically thinking of artists like Gary Chalk, and other artists who worked on those earlier Games Workshop games. It's very hard to divorce my feelings on the art from my feelings of how the art makes me long for days when my life was simpler.

And then there are the very modern styles like the art found in the Arkham files games, which, IMO, constitutes one of the best libraries of art assets ever compiled. The draw here isn't nostalgia, it's more of a pure visceral reaction.

But still, there is that pesky thing called subjectivity. Is a top 10 games with the best art even a topic worthy of devoting time to? I mean, the art in a game feels like it's exponentially the single most subjective element of a game!
As much as I love the art in Dungeon Degenerates, there are people that absolutely hate it. And I get that opinion. This game provokes strong opinions at polar opposite ends of the spectrum. I think it's the best looking game ever made, and I know people who say it physically makes them sick. We're both being hyperbolic here, but still...it's the perfect example of what I'm talking about.

So I am curious. What do you all look for in a game when you say a game has "good art?" Are you looking for something bold and unique? Are you looking for something classical and iconic? Do you prefer bright colors or black & white? A sketchy or painterly style? Something a little sexy? Perhaps you prefer gruesome. Maybe you like sexy and gruesome combine, in which case there is Kingdom Death Monster!
I think for me, when I'm looking at a game's art, I want the art to help embolden the theme, setting, and overall vibe of the game, and that can be accomplished in a huge number of ways.
But I'm curious about what you all think. What are some of your favorites?