Thoughts on AI Art - an outline / thoughts for a video (Patreon)
Content
Hey all! I think it's time for me to make a video addressing the use of AI art in games. I've seen enough questions / comments about it in previous videos, and I want to make sure my thoughts are known before I inadvertently praise something that I had no idea was made using AI things. It's bound to happen, and it might have already happened.
I think my take is nuanced, and it might rub some people the wrong way simply because I am not 100% against the use of AI in the creative process, however I am 100% FOR artists and creators getting paid and thriving with their craft.
With that said, I wanted to run my outline by all of you, because I value your input.
This is not for grammar / writing review - this is simply an outline I might use to discuss the topic.
********
Thoughts on AI art
I know it’s not actually “Artificial Intelligence.” But I will use this phrase throughout.
Addressing this topic because I see more and more questions / comments about “is that AI? Did this use AI?” and so on.
I don’t have the time, nor frankly the desire, to research every game I cover to make sure that no AI at all was used at all in writing / art. I barely have enough time to do what I’m doing now, and adding that kind of researching task on top of that is not something I am interested in doing.
And to what extent do I look?
Photoshop – other manipulating software that uses AI? Spell checkers? Grammer checkers? Grammerly? Suggested sentences from clippy? How far do I go in the research process – it would add hours to the pre-production of every video, and would require honest access to every creator, and that's something I cannot rely on.
I will also not be participating in the AI witch hunts. I’ve already seen this on toxic facebook groups – an artist is accused of using AI and then they have to defend themselves by showing their sketch books and WIPs – without any proof at all.
A lot of modern digital art looks AI because the AI process is using those as part of its thing.
It also just so happens to happen to minority creators more for some reason…I have a feeling that the ETHICS IN GAMES JOURNALISM people are using this tactic as another way to attack women and POC in the industry (both times I saw it happen were in connection with the new D&D books, and the anti-AI crowd was also complaining about the art being "woke" ).
Policing the use of AI is not the role nor the point of the Dungeon Dive, and I know for a fact that at some point I will inadvertently cover and maybe even love something that used AI in the creative process.
That is absolutely something that is going to happen.
Not because I want to, but because the technology will improve so much that it will become impossible to tell unless the creator specifically states it.
I will not deny myself a useful tool just because it used AI in the creation process.
Mythos tool as an example.
AI as a tool for the disabled – losing your ability to illustrate doesn’t destroy your desire to create.
If I lost my ability to use my hands to create music, I would not lose my desire to, and I would definitely seek out alternative ways to create audio art.
My favorite board game artist of all time lost his ability to illustrate because of a medical condition. He started dabbling in generative art to help satisfy his desire to create visual things.
Art assets are very expensive – the single most expensive part of game design from what I’ve been told by designers. Can cost many hundreds of dollars per unique image.
What is an indie designer who can’t afford art supposed to do? What about someone just making a little project to put out there?
Artists getting paid before designers because they get paid up front. I know of a couple of indie projects where the artists got paid and the designer did not – Designer actually lost money once the product went to market.
I’d prefer it if all parties associated with the development of a project get paid! I want the things I enjoy to be financially successful so that more things that I enjoy are created.
Using art asset packages – the same art gets used for multiple games (League of Dungeoneers and 4AD)
Using art by dead people – the same art gets used for multiple games (Mork Born things)
If AI is used, be honest about it – be clear about it – don’t hide it
Plunderphonics – uncleared samples in music. Generative music software employed by artists like Brian Eno. Collage art. There are legit forms of art that use derivative means to create.
THIS is super important:
Ultimately - I want all creators to be honest and clear about how / what was used if any AI was used so that the customers can make their decisions.
I wish there was a way to list the things used in the generative process – a clear list of samples and influences. What work by what artists were used? What prompts were used? Could create a reference document using meta data.
I will always prefer and praise human created things – it’s so stupid that I even have to say that! however, I know there will come a time when I praise something and it ends up being AI assisted. That is going to happen. It might have already happened.
I am, however, not going to say things like AI art is soulless, because people said the exact same thing about synth based music and electronic music, and we all know that’s total BS. Human’s have made incredibly moving music using electronic things and samples, just like there will probably be human’s who make moving things with assistance from AI.
It can be a tool to be used like any kind of technology.
But there needs to be a system in place to control it – artists should have a say in their art being used to train machines / AI.
Regulation is important.
I want people to get fairly compensated for their work – in all industries. And I vote and take actions to make sure that happens. I support unions, union workers, and want not a living wage for all, but a thriving wage. And these are not “leftist” ideas. These are humanist ideas – these are the ideas that make countries and industries and, most importantly, PEOPLE thrive.
I want artists to thrive.
AI art as stolen / IP theft
I am a HUGE proponent of paying for the things we like. I still buy albums (digitally). I buy 90% of my TT games (some games sent to me to cover). I buy ALL of my video games and movies. I spend 30+ hours a week covering games that I like, and a lot of them are from small designers, and I don’t charge them for it – never will. I never take financial compensation for my coverage.
I used to pirate stuff in my 20s and 30s. But I don’t any more, and I don’t like that I did. It’s easy to make excuses – I couldn’t afford it, pirating was easier, corporations suck etc., but the fact of the matter is I deprived an artist of their fair compensation for something I enjoyed.
Financially supporting the art we love and the artists who make it is crucial – it tells the creators and the producers what we want, and that we are willing to pay for it. I say all this to encourage you to do the same, and to point out one glaring hypocrisy I’ve seen from some of the Anti AI people I am acquainted with – I know for a fact that at lest some of them have no issues at all pirating movies, music, books, and videos games, all while preaching about how unethical and terrible AI generated art is.
To me, that’s a little weird.