Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Content

There are still quite a few "big and important" board games I've never played. I think this is especially true for Euro-style games post-Splendor, but it's also true for some older games, and for some adventure-style games.

Believe it or not, I've never played Settlers of Catan, and not for any particular reason. It just so happened that no one in the various gaming groups I've ever played with owned. it. Same goes for Ticket to Ride (although I have played Airlines Europe, and I love that game).

One adventure-style game I've never played is Robinson Crusoe, and so this weekend I've decided to correct this.

I've always had the suspicion that I'd love Robinson Crusoe. It's got a bunch of random encounters on cards, fast combat, meaningful exploration, and tons of one-off scenarios with different play styles. It's also a game that creates memorable moments and stories, and that's something super important to me.

Over the last few years I've been slowing buying stuff for the game. First the base game, then the expansion Mystery Tales, which adds campaign play and some more supernatural elements, then the Treasure Chest expansion which collects all of the various promo and mini expansions, and finally the recently-released Adventure Book, which is overflowing with different scenarios.

It can be a somewhat difficult game to learn, but I'm finding that it's not overly complex. As a matter of fact, the 2nd edition rule book does a great job teaching the game. The most difficult thing about the game is how challenging it is to win, and a lot of that has to do with the strict timer, which is something that has kept me from wanting to leap head first into the experience.

I don't typically enjoy ultra-strict timers in board games, as they often prevent me from exploring and getting lost in a game's world of adventure. But for Robinson Crusoe I've decided to just embrace the mechanisms, and approach it in a thematic way.

I've enjoyed my time with the game these last couple of days, and I'm looking forward to getting more out of it.

Do you all have any board game blindspots you want to get rectified?

Comments

blair black

oh la la... it's Robinson Crusoe!!

Doug Cooley

My blind spot is when a crowdfunded game is a huge disappointment for me. Biggest one recently was, of course, Robinson Crusoe. I had the old ZMan version that was so buggy that it should just have been thrown out, so I bought what seemed to be an update only to find out that it was an update to the rereleased game. The collectors box was a disaster and I ended up printing an organizer that actually did the job. I still can’t get those three enormous theme decks in the box, though. In all. I have no desire to play this game now. Let’s not even discuss how badly the CF was managed. Dungeon Crusade is on the lip after a far too sensitive designer crashed and burned on this project (the box came smashed up and the designer promised to replace it and that’s never happened, and when so many people tiptoe around a designer like every content creator has for DC, that’s a bad sign). These are good games, but my overdeveloped sense of right and wrong gives me the icky when I even look at them. This is a hobby where many extraneous things are present, and game designers/publishers need to wake up and realize they are in a business and act accordingly. Hundreds of dollars for these games, and the act of getting them and asking for remedy has made me never want to play them.

The Dungeon Dive

I never tip toed around Dungeon Crusade. It's one of my favorite games of all time, but my super detailed review is literally called "An Uphill Battle to Greatness." But those aren't really blindspots - those are just complaints about a couple of very specific games! :D