Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Videos

  • 395337024.mp4

Downloads

Content

Surprise!

Youtube mirror

Files

Comments

juji

TWO CAKES!!!!

Es

It’s a Christmas miracle

Le-Ki

Jenny I was literally just cleaning my house desperately looking for a video to put on so I don’t go Christmas crazy making things look nice and you have truly gifted me exactly what I wished for this day. Have a great holiday

Hel

Merry xmas Jenny!

Ivy Cass

JENNY I LOVE YOU

Hue-An Tran

An hour of Jenny for Christmas Eve???? Let's GOOOOOOOOOOO

EN NAM ^.^

Jennyyy Ur so awesome ty for feeding us well this Christmas Season❤️

Cece Z

merry christmas jenny!!

B Hair

😱😱😱😱 Thank you so much for a bonus video!!?

emchovy

Santa came early!

Ivannia Aguirre Santander

Omg yay Jenny!!!! I celebrate with my family tomorrow, today I clean and roll meatballs while tipsy 😂😂 and now this?!?? ❤️❤️

Nadine S

Merry Christmas!

Ethan Olson

this puts the ominous and terrifying end of the mean girls video into a much more cheery holiday context

melty

Knew there'd be something like this after the end of the last video!!! Happy christmas everyone!!!

Ivy Cass

Okay but for real, Jenny, thank you so much for providing us with wonderful content. Trying not to be parasocial but it means a lot to me that you care so much for your patrons. Hope you have some happy holidays and I can't wait to see everything you have for us in 2025!

Day

omg it IS a holly jolly christmas after all!

Curtis B

Two videos in two days!! It’s a Christmas miracle! 😆

emmett dupree

THANK U JENNY MERRY XMAS ❤️🎄

Fluorite

Who needs Santa when Jenny is putting beautifully wrapped videos under our tree 🌲

Katie E

I'm a little embarrassed that I didn't suspect anything at the end of the last video hahaha

highclass_lady

Oh my gosh thank you so much! Merry Christmas & Happy Holidays! 🎄✨

Taytay

this explains why the end of the mean girls vid was so ominous 😭

Silky

Wow I thought you were definitely done with videos for the year! No more videos coming for sure! Thank you for this Christmas gift Jenny, I'll watch it right now while I do my Christmas nails :)

Charlie

This dropped right after midnight for christmas day in Australia. About to listen on my drive home. Merry Christmas, Jenny!

James Ryan

it genuinely warms my heart that Jenny did this bonus video for us

mugmouse

I actually got so excited to see this notification omg

Patrick R.

Who's the best Patreon creator? Jenny is, dammit

CJ The X

aw hell yeah

Mac Francini

It’s a Christmas Eve miracle 🎄

bovaque

Omg this instantly reminded me of watching Annabelle's Wish in first grade, which wasn't at all traumatic watching a baby cow who wants to become a reindeer DIE in order to be reborn as a reindeer

gannonic

This brought back so many repressed memories and I have fully realised I did have the first one on vhs as a child. Thank you Jenny

Vsevolod Kozlov

Thank you Jenny! Merry Christmas & Happy New Year 🎁🎄⭐️

Eulalie

Me when I anger Jenny and I happen to have eyes : 🙈

Ammy K

Lmao every time they presented a covered dish and Jenny wanted it to be severed heads

Steven Clark

Wow, I actually recognize the Fairytale Christmas movie. It was sold as "Braver" to capitalize on Pixar's Brave, with a blatantly misleading DVD case.

Alice Parkin

Thank you so much for all the rambles and bonus content this year Jenny, it's been a great first year to be a Patreon (I'm a little behind AND *still* catching up on old content)!! Hope you have a wonderful festive season and all the best for 2025!

Raye

Thank you for the gift Jenny! I became a patron this year after the Star Wars hotel video and I don't regret it one bit. Happy Holidays and New Year to everyone!

Tyler Singer

HAPPY HOLIDAYS ONE AND ALL 😖💕😍😍

Alice

thank you jenny i am sick, all i can do is watch videos and nap and you are feeding me rn <3

Luis

omg we don't deserve you Jenny 😢

apelsindipp

omg !!! merry christmas eve from sweden!

Isaac Jordan

Thank you Jenny. I feel sufficiently distracted from the horrors

Zwoozy

You stopped at a video store LAST YEAR? Does your family live in 2005?

Neil B

You are the best!

Ronnie Lauth

I JUST SCREAMED THANK YOU (and merry christmas jenny!!!!)

Carson McNamara

Omg thank you so much! Does anyone know where the backing image of the round/stuffed looking reindeer is from? I’m obsessed and I must know more

Kimberly

ok the second one is definitely tradwife propaganda. i was sus when they pulled out the apron but "moving to the country to be closer to god but not knowing how to chop wood" sends it over the edge.

William McCarthy

It can scratch and gouge out their poorly drawn eyes, then rip out their jaws and tear off their external genitalia! Wheeeee!

Kimberly

ahhhhh "the most important work we do - family work" i'm dead. deceased. merry xmas!

Tony Pepperoni

“And what did Santa bring you for Christmas??” “MOAR JENNY NICHOLSON!!1!”

Clara Greenez

I was happy that mean girls won but kinda disappointed this one didn’t make it since it’s so fitting for the season/it was so close. Thank you Jenny!!! Happy holidays !

Deanna

Thank you queen Jenny for Christmas joy

John Alonzo

Jenny, you're the best! We always watch for the holidays, Santa Claus conquers the Martians and Santa and the 3 bears. You know what they should make? A Hallmark DIY Christmas special starring Nicole and Lauren, with special guest star Queen Thea! Merry Christmas Jenny and thanks. :)

Silky

So that last movie is set like 30 years after the story of the lamb? Imagine the possibilities... "And what happened to the baby?" "Well, he was actually painfully executed recently. Sorry."

Lece

yay what a wonderful surprise!! :)

Beat

who could have seen this coming!

Ellie

yayyyy

David Bleek

such a fantastic christmas eve surprise!!! thanks so much and Happy Holidays!!

Ian Means

Yeah I'm getting a very Mormon vibe looking at the writer's other work

JG

It’s a Christmas miracle!!!

fiskehund

Prayers: Answered. If you'll excuse me i have some vows of silence & pilgrimages to follow through on

Betsy

Thank you for this Christmas gift, Jenny!

Emma Sunnyduck

One of my new favourite videos. I had to stop drinking my coffee as I was laughing so much. Thanks Jenny. Merry Christmas to you and yours 💛

Tom Palmer

SHOCKED!!! thank you JENNY!🤩😍

S G Matthews

The whole video I was on edge waiting to see if she’d acknowledge “Braver” 😂

Jack Fahey

If we didn't just get a new kitten, this would be the best xmas miracle I could ask for.

e

omg that thumbnail just rocketed me through a nostalgia wormhole, I used to rent that VHS all the time from the church library 😭

Stahlhart

OK so I feel like the Christmas Apron movie has like so little to do with the Apron it's hilarious? Like there's an Apron there, and they like it, but it doesn't forward the plot in any way it's just an unrelated thing. Amazing

a.s.

prefab shed with thatched roof is my new favorite recurring jennyverse character

Aaron Reese

You spoil us, Jenny!!! Merry Christmas!

Markus D

I'm totally with you on child actors who are too young to have any sense of enunciation and pronunciation that they're just incomprehensible, but people give them a pass for being cute. NO, GRANDMA! I HAVE NO IDEA WHAT THAT CHILD SAID!

e

oh god skipped to that portion of the video and unforch the lamb story still very much makes me cry omg

zliz

thank you jenny! i was just getting on the road to go up north <3

Natan Cohen

Enjoy a bloodthirsty (eyethirsty?) Jenny

Lola

Me watching A Fairytale Christmas: "My liege! He means you harm!"

Hannah Luke

This made me go try to find the obscure Christmas specials from my childhood and someone on reddit figured out one of them within like 12 minutes of me posting on r/tipofmytongue. Crazy. It’s called Christmas in cartoontown

Rozzettes

Oh my god I remember that first one from an old IHE video LMAO I think the Disney Knockoffs.

Gary

Sorry Jenny but they ate the lamb that night and fed his withered leg to the dogs. Remember that these are the inkeepers who made a woman give birth in the animal pen rather than just making some space inside.

Shiny Skunk

Absolutely lost my mind at "GOD HAS FORGOTTEN ME." Thank you for the christmas gift, Jenny!

Ryan Chin

Yay for the 🎁

Tony M Parker

Voting for ties makes patrons feel powerful

Markus D

"This apron... It's the last thing to be seen by those who we love..." "What!?" "...when we wave good-bye from the porch." "Oh..." I had the exact same reaction 🤣. Grandma was talking like the apron was the old-fashioned euthanasia method.

CatLadyDimitrescu

"I learned a valuable lesson..." Well I didn't, and I'm the Audience!

Vossen Art

I like how Jenny gets jumpscared every time they say the c word

Gio Borrani

Yay this will get me through my morning working from home! Merry Chrysanthemum 🎄

Markus D

Honestly, I was kind of surprised that the girl was allowed to dance and that she wasn't just forced into being a housewife.

Aaron Claus

I'd assumed the one thing a Christmas special would get right would at least be its moral or message but 2/3 of these fail at that which shocked me and made me cackle

John Thomas

Just putting it out there that I think a violently upbeat Jenny is the best version...

Jennibean

Oh my gosh I just had a flood of resurgent memories from the lamb movie from when I was a kid and my babysitter only allowed religious television and this was the go to Christmas movie. I'd forgotten it existed. Also nick and Pete is the best little known Christmas special movie

Markus D

"See, God fucked up your leg for your whole life just so you could make his kid warm! Isn't he great!?"

Samantha Ansley

This is one of your funniest videos - thank you for a bonus video!

Dante Ellis

Jenny cooked us Christmas dinner!

Louis Z

Solution to the voting for ties problem: Set a specific date and time when the poll ends. When the deadline is reached if the margin of victory is ten or more declare a winner. If the margin is less then ten have a runoff in a new poll open to all tiers. There would no longer be any incentive to vote for a tie.

soph

Dude the Crippled Lamb is by this popular Christian children's book author named Max Lucado, a preacher from Texas who's books haunted my childhood with deeply confusing themes. My parents would read me his book "You are Special" a lot, a book in which the MC is sad that he was born disabled and God is like "That's okay, I made you that way." And that's... that's the whole book.

Lee

A Christmas surprise!! Yaaay thank you :D

Ted Koutz

I like that The Christmas Apron is all-in on aprons, like they came up with an odd Christmas story and they're going to get as much mileage as they can out of the concept

Brendan Trosper

I sort of appreciate the attempt to address it since I feel like so much US Christianity is so ableist (think muscular Christianity), but yeah, that's really not helpful... My brother is disabled now and I don't think he's been able to believe since he became so....

Brendan Trosper

Right?! "Instead of contriving a way for a warm blanket to be left behind, the Almighty has ruined your body for this one evening. Congrats."

Brendan Trosper

This was the BEST surprise and made me so happy! Now to cleanse my palate with a Muppet Christmas Carol (the best version-apologies to Bill Murray)

risa kim

haha this is such a cute drop right after your very subtle closing of the mean girls video. let us rejoice, for it was not the last drop of the year!

depress.io

best christmas gift ever!!!!!!!!!

Ham

Jenny, could you take a shot at the Fairy Tale Christmas girl's eye makeup? What's going on with that lower lid?

Aragog's 7th leg

YESSSSS thank you for bonus content! Merry Christmas! ⛄️

Mike Carpenter

The one I always think of when I think of an obscure Christmas special is 1948’s “Santa in Animal Land.” It is extremely terrifying, although I don’t think it’s supposed to be.

Jower

Jenny lowkey obsessed with scratching out eyes.

Mike Carpenter

Apparently this began airing on TCM a few years ago, although I had originally seen it from a VHS anthology called Hector’s Christmas

Magistrissa

Weirdly the part about not shopping or decorating (or talking about how you don't have the money to do that) until Christmas Eve is the most period-accurate part of that movie. At least for my grandparents, it seems like it was typical to buy and decorate the tree on Christmas Eve, though usually you'd be buying/making presents before that. Or go out and chop the tree down yourself the day of, if you lived in a forested rural area.

Kelly Evans

I love Jenny but you can tell she didn't grow up poor. Many Christmases my presents weren't bought until Xmas eve. Maybe that is payday

Magistrissa

I know this is against the spirit of the movie, but I keep comparing Josie, the uprooted city girl turned pioneer, to anecdotes I've heard about women out on the prairie who suffered breakdowns from the isolation and the hardships and the unending sound of the howling wind. Did the Christmas apron stuff up the holes in her sod house so the screaming wind couldn't reach her?

Chess on Ice

When I started watching this video, I didn't expect to see a lamb saying he was forgotten by God...IN BETHLEHEM

jillb

I completely forgot that we had a Joshua the lamb picture book that was always read to us when we were little! I was one of those kids in a super religious household who got in trouble for asking questions like "why did God make the lamb hurt forever instead of just giving Mary a blanket." Oops

Ham

How come the king is back in the castle at the end when the whole point was to keep him out somewhere looking for his daughter forever

i see stars but how

this video will become MY obscure christmas special. obscure christmasception

Keith Hasperg

I am watching one called Olive the Other Reindeer. Michael Stipe from R.E.M. is the voice of one of the reindeer. I can’t wait to watch your video!

TJ Guiney

I’m so glad this christmas I was able to learn what aprons are for. I’d been confused for so long!

Alphonse

Oh gott, now i have homework?? well I suppose if i must. I will report back with my review of whatever strange christmas special I end up with.

Markus D

That's one of my big problems with those "God did this for a reason" movies; they always try to reframe unfortunately coincidences as "good, actually". There are several religious movies where someone dies or almost dies with the reason being that the protagonist needed to be lead back to God by their sacrifice or something like knowledge of Heaven due to a near-death-experience. I tend to not like Christian movies anyway (besides being overly religious, they're usually bad movies in their own right), but that's a really gross message.

Magistrissa

Jenny reacts with fear at the lion but I'm just delighted to hear Mark Hamil hamming it up as a villain.

Markus D

I get what you're saying, but I think the really weird thing about the scene was the way that it was framed like they hadn't talked about how they might not have money for Christmas presents before then. Surely they would've planned something earlier? Also, if you're going to find and pick up someone's piano, you probably need longer than like... a day? That kid hung up the piano wish pretty late, right?

Markus D

"Maybe life is more difficult for you than someone without your disability, but at least God did it on purpose!"

Magistrissa

The other animals ask the camel what happened to the baby and he's like "he got crucified! but that's a story for another day! Merry Christmas!"

Oakoka

I’m just a dad folding my kids clothes over here on Christmas Eve and hearing about how family work is the work that says I love you almost has me in tears. lol. 🥲

Emilie Han

My favorite Christmas movie no one has ever heard of is Nester the Christmas donkey

JessJeverage

Strong CD-i Zelda energy in this animation...

tapioca

I straight up thought the credits after The Christmas Apron would reveal that the whole thing was produced by an apron company as an ad

ChapelBailey

And the lambs wool was used to make a Christmas apron.

Alphonse

Returning. So, when I hit random on the christmas speciasl wiki I ended up with DAVE FOLEY's "The True Meaning Of Christmas Specials" I feel like it might not be quite in the spirit of the challenge because its a christmas special thats also a parody of christmas specials. it was. interesting. the humor was definitely 2002.

Nicholas Bauer

I saw the Bible story coming as soon as I saw the hay bale in a barn.

Luis

I clapped when Jenny's Christmas tree hand came out of the box :D Also what's the reindeer in her background image? I know I've seen it before but can't remember where.

GlitteredLights

bonus jenny content, its a christmas miracle!!

Luis

Oh it's Rodney I should've read the replies. Anyway I heard the cr××pled lamb got turned into the Christmas Apron 😔

Emily Dahl

That first villain song went hard.

Louis Z

The lamb video was obviously influenced by Rudolph but I think there are some Tarantino influences as well. His journey to the manger reminded me a lot of Butch’s odyssey to retrieve the gold watch except this time Zed was a lion and didn’t own a pawn shop.

Emily Dahl

But they can’t tax EVERYTHING.

Aria

Surprise Jenny christmas present!!

Maya

Not enough Christmas movies use the “going for the eyes” trope

AerynMikhail

I think my favorite obscure christmas movies are the life and adventures of Santa claus where it's just a dude in the woods carving toys and there's randomly fairies and then olive the other reindeer lol

Shred Cadmium

Ramble: Jenny's uncompromising condemnation of That Kid's Acting

Alice Lastname

Both Jenny and Luca Guadagnino have surprised me with releasing things I didn’t expected from them so soon. First Guadagnino follows Challengers with Queer within the same year, which gave me whiplash, now Jenny does a double ramble. Thank you very much for the very hard work and dedication into the awesome videos this year, it’s been really exciting. I don’t regret signing onto the Patreon ever since I did! Keep up the good work, and happy holidays!

Markus D

I spent the whole time trying to figure out what animal he was. I was certain that he wasn't a lion due to the lack of mane and clearly adult size, but I guess NOT! Also, love the stock tiger roar sound effect, because everyone thinks that's what lions sound like now. /s

Alexander Moore-

GO FOR THE EYES GO FOR THE EYES Nothing more festive than a little holiday bloodlust

Deb Fine

A very unexpected Christmas gift! Thank you, Jenny! Merry Christmas to you🎄

Geraint

But it’s my first month on Patreon and I’ve had 3 new vids. Am I cheating?

Dylan Clarke

everybody: Jenny: SCRATCH THEIR EYES OUT

Aria Maryn

Yay!! So excited for this 🎄 Merry Christmas everyone ☃️

Robert Sebastian

"Four legged beasts do pretty well without one of their legs" can confirm: we have a tripod cat and while she isn't winning any agility contests she gets around just fine.

Rufus May

Sometimes an apron is just an apron.

Guilla Monster

Wow, the Christmas Prince would vibe hard with this king. “Governance doesn’t matter; it’s Christmas!” #ThisFraudulantChristmasPrince ADDENDUM: This lamb rules. I wanna be friends with this lamb.

Sarah Lawrie

Thank you for the early Christmas gift, Jenny!

Ophelia

Christmas Apron felt like a psyop to convince girls of the value of domestic labor

Zoe Blank

Thank you for the bonus vid! I had a one year and could not afford to re-up, but hopefully my YT premium will still support you making your videos.

Eric MacMillan

I love that the two new videos have different colored background lights to match the themes of the videos

wwwww

I would absolutely recommend Anabelle's Wish. It's an animated 90s straight-to-vhs movie about a cow that wants to be a reindeer and a boy stuck in a custody battle. It's narrated by Randy Travis and the voice cast includes Cloris Leachman, Jim Varney, and Jerry Van Dyke. Also the voice actress for Ducky from the Land Before Time plays one of the main characters. I make all my friends watch it lol

Monica McFadden

The horse neigh at 46:42 was used in the 90s computer game Daggerfall, which I played day and night back in the day. Just had to give it a shoutout because it turns out it's a very common stock sound and I'm always excited to notice it in a show.

Kinetics Video

More Jenny than we're contractually obligated to?! It's a Christmas miracle!

Rosie

Not me and Jenny both saying out loud “this is very Anastasia” at almost the exact same time 😂

Jenny Nicholson

Esp when they told her she might have a christmas apron of her own one day, like there's already one in the family so I feel like the idea of her having "her own" could only have been referring to children

Leif Thomas

Can we have a new Buff Rats patreon tier?

Xander

Thank you for making this I really needed an extra boost this year

IguanaDon

Jenny, you seem very invested the ability of tiny little birds to do meaningful violence.

Violet Moon (edited)

Comment edits

2026-10-07 10:00 My wife suggested that you should declare in the rules that if there's a tie or it's close you'll choose the one you like the best. I say if you have a tie you should go for the third one, disqualifying the ties. Either might help you prevent people from trying to get you to do two videos.
2024-12-24 22:39

Kinetics Video

Lamb got upstaged in his own movie like Jyn Erso

Patar

I knew the ending of the last video was suspicious, well played cooler Jenny

Kyle Williams

Is it possible to make a religious film that isn't terrible? I feel like someone could make a well written and acted film that has a religious message, but I've yet to come across one.

Jenny Nicholson

The bird's character conflict was worrying they were useless but I would argue there was one skill set they weren't taking advantage of

Louis Z

Ben Hur! And Lord of the Rings is largely a religious parable.

Louis Z

The three scariest words ever: Jennifer Nicholson, Optometrist

SoldierHawk

The Narnia stories are pretty good!

Idol Thoughts

Thanks for the bonus treat Jenny :) Have a nice christmas x

Declan

This video is your villain arc.

Ada Kolodziejska

Woahhh I’d completely forgotten about the existence of A Fairytale Christmas! It used to be one of my favourite films as a kid (alongside some other obscure terrible-good faves like Toyland and The Christmas Dinosaur).

Jenny Nicholson

As a christmas princess you sometimes have to make an example of your enemies

Dr. Chunk

RE: The Christmas Apron, given the "Covenant Communications" card at the beginning, I'd put money on it being tradwife propaganda that was intended to be used as a teaching tool for Christmas sermons. It probably felt like the summary of a plot because that's all they needed. It would also explain the full DVD release. I wouldn't be surprised if you could find a discussion booklet like they made for that Kirk Cameron movie Fireproof.

Declan

Mean Girls angred you so much you've lost all appreciation for extremely low effort Christmas whimsy. I welcome this. Merry Christmas.

Monssef Burezah

So you didn’t stop recording after Mean Girls! You‘re like HBomberguy! You say „This is the end of the video“, and then go on for another hour. Spectacular!!!

Charred Newt

You can tell that last special is going to get into biblical territory the moment when the camel patriarch shows up. Camels don't get many good non-Bible roles in animated movies.

PurpleIsDebeste (edited)

Comment edits

2026-10-07 10:00 I'm gonna vote for ties but not because i think you'll do 2 videos and want that to happen, just because I like the chaos created by trying to cause a tie
2024-12-25 00:02

Steve Ray

Be sensible, Markus. If girls can't go dance, they'll never have families. And to your point, Kimberly, we do our best work when we have a *plan*, and yes, that definitely includes family work! Your grandma used *her* apron to make sure her family never had too many mouths to feed.. I was the youngest for EIGHT years, can you imagine? But even when grandpa hadn't worked all summer and the harvests were thin, I never heard a baby cry from hunger.

Steve Ray

There's a chain called Family Video Store in North Texas that was still running last year, I think.

Zwoozy

Jealous. They were in Ohio as well, but disappeared over 10 years ago.

Fiona V

I don’t think they even scouted an old house for The Christmas Apron because that house is cavernous by 1940s standards. I think it’s a modern McMansion decorated to look vintage. Furniture might be real antiques.

Steve Ray

Make that Princess Optometrist! "Good evening, Chancellor Winthrop... the way you stare at my father's throne is troubling to me... so let us discuss how your *vision* can be corrected, just you, and I, and my assistant, Nurse Chirpy!"

Fiona V

It’s traditional in Germany to put the tree up on Christmas Eve!

Steve Ray

Some have said the feeling of power from influencing a Ramble poll is too intoxicating and intense to resist, so with your rule, Violet, the temptation would simply spread to third-ranked rivals trying to force the front-runners into a tie.

Steve Ray

A worse message than "Tragedy is meaningless; it sucks to be you"?

Louis Z

You sure you want to anger Jenny when she’s in Christmas eye gouging mode?

Bruce Climas

"We shall name our child....Crippled Lamb, after that crippled lamb over there."

RiaJaize

I like how in the first story, Angela sings about how every girl wants to be a princess, so she guesses she's "just like every other girl." And the point of the story is that SHE'S NOT LIKE OTHER GIRLS!

Louis Z

There are a lot of ways to resolve a tie. Letting Jenny pick is a good idea. My suggestion was a runoff with a larger electorate. A coin flip would also work. I think the best option would be trial by combat. Put the contenders in a pit with like battle axes or something.

Callum Moore

Everyone drop the obscure Christmas specials you're watching that you found from the wiki list below! I'm watching 'A Young Pioneer's Christmas', which so far has been a lot of talk about railroads and land and marriages, but at 38 minutes in, no mention of Christmas

Eleanor MacDougall

yessss I love Nestor. It came in a box set of dvds we had when i was a kid. I loved it because it was such a bummer and I was a maudlin little shit, and also because my siblings hated it. I also loved cricket on the hearth, which came on the same dvd. It was also kind of dark and weird, but less overtly religious. It had an absurd plot and featured a song called "smiles go with tears" that just randomly gets stuck in my head sometimes.

cake_007

YAHOOO Christmas miracle

Markus D

I mean, that's just the way it is. Sometimes bad things don't happen for any real reason. Though you wouldn't make a movie about how it "sucks to be you". It's a much better to have a lesson like "you're not alone" and "your disability isn't everything that you are". Like, the story in the lamb movie isn't great, because the way that it's framed makes it feel like the ONLY reason he existed was because he got to keep Jesus warm for a bit and that after that he's just going to continue suffering, but it doesn't matter, because Yahweh got to use him for something, and that's the only thing that's important. It doesn't even really feel like the lesson was "it's okay, because God loves you" as much as it's "you're not useless, you can be used for this one thing" which isn't a great message for anyone who might have a disability; it's a very utilitarian view of existence.

Markus D

That movie is very much a period-piece-by-assertion. At no point was I convinced that it was the 1940s. In my mind, it was always the 2000s, and occasionally I'd just be pulled kicking and screaming back into "OH YEAH, THERE'S SUPPOSED TO BE A WORLD WAR GOING ON!"

Markus D

I feel like Jenny is begging for people to not cause chaos in the polls...

Ishrat

Nice video but I don't understand the point of the Christmas Apron. Isn't it just to keep clothes clean when cooking? What's so special about that?

Markus D

I think that Tolkien would be insulted by you calling Lord of the Rings a "religious parable". He was pretty clear on it not just being an allegory like C. S. Lewis' books were.

Markus D

It's EVERYWHERE. I think it was even in the Wicked movie and I was offended that they had a real horse on set yet they used the most generic stock horse noise!

Fiona V

Yep, definitely the least committed period piece I’ve ever seen. I thought the ballet studio scene was stock footage until they started talking.

Eric MacMillan

Hey Joe, Jenny’s video got me in the Christmas spirit, so I’d love to gift you another year’s membership, but Id need a way to send you the gift code. Would you be comfortable dropping your email so I can send it to you, or is there another way I can message you, it seems Patreon doesn’t allow users to direct message each other.

Ted Koutz

Watched The Fourth King (1977) an animated film where animals select a lion King (original idea do not steal) to visit baby Jesus. He has nothing to offer Jesus except for a song from a bird who accompanies him, despite the lion singing for most of the film. This only aired once due to poor quality.

Ted Koutz

I looked into this and they're an LDS book publisher who also distributes religious and family films not specifically made by them. They also distribute The Christmas Dress, Christmas Oranges and My Broken Horse Christmas along with many others.

JAV1028

Is Christmas Apron supposed to be Christian tradwife propaganda cause that's the vibe I'm getting from it a little bit

coyote

thank you for the bonus video jenny i will love and cherish it forever. happy Christmas!!

Setheus

I can't stop hearing the lamb's upset, congested little "god has forgotten me..."

Setheus

Prince of Egypt!

Lilia Kat

Honestly the fact that the first movie crammed in so many songs into 40 minutes is lowkey commendable like I love that there was actual effort put into the soundtrack of a movie that was otherwise a modge podge of Disney ripoffs

christian skisonic

An enchanted jingle bell is a Christmas special basis just waiting to be produced

Derick Gadd

Nobody: Jenny: "GO FOR THE EYES"

seahorse advisor

Have you seen Jim Henson's The Christmas Toy? I feel like you'd like the cat toy character. Toy Story is very similar (sometimes suspiciously so, but living toys isn't a new concept so idk 🤷‍♀️)

Maddie Arnautov

The Chosen, it’s a crowd funded tv series about Jesus’s ministry and his 12 disciples. It’s actually insane how good it is ❤️💚 Merry Christmas!

Leah H

seeing the second notification on your patreon was a TRUE christmas miracle !

a.g.

The angry little lamb was lowkey giving jayfeather warrior cats but also I did get teary when he warmed the baby

Tony Pepperoni

Thank you for the reminder of Rodney the Reindeer plush. Mega nostalgia win for Xmas Eve 🎄

Ontario Traffic Man

Jenny's enthusiasm about the topic correlates more to my enjoyment of a video than than my interest in the topic. So my vote is for Jenny to rule the topic selection as a ruthless dictator

Ontario Traffic Man

The Christmas colours are green and red, and there were already evergreens...

Ontario Traffic Man

Then the evil guy went and invented Goods and Services Tax

elijah

Nothing says Christmas like a cartoon bird scratching out everyone’s eyes!

Nerdy Bird

It’s a Christmas miracle!

Amy Cooper

I gasped when I saw the thumbnail! I grew up with the lamb movie (a gift from my very religious grandma), and even as a kid felt very much that the “reward” really didn’t match his “sacrifice.” Lol. If anyone wants another great unheard of Christmas movie choice, I recommend Annabelle’s Wish.

MW

how you spoil us jenny. i love how bloodthirsty you wanted the cartoon animals to be

Mathieu B. Lafrenière

If the framing narrative for the Lamb story was set 30 years after the birth of Jesus, that means while Benjamin the goat is being told the story of his birth, Jesus is actively being crucified... Amazing lore

Zoe Blank

Oh wow! That's very generous of you. Thank you so much!

Eric MacMillan

Sure, id just need an email or some way to message you elsewhere to send you the gift code!

ottokas

You see, its not just an apron. You can wipe tears with it and carry puppies and it also reminds you that your place is in the kitchen...

Eric MacMillan

Ok its sent let me know if you got it and it works!

Natalie Arnold

Yep definitely want the sequel to that last one. Set at easter. Where the lamb uh. Is somehow there.

Zoe Blank

Thanks again and Merry Christmas!

Alex Hoffer

Jesus Christ Superstar! Or Joseph and the Amazing Technicolor Dreamcoat! OFC Superstar is better and fairly neutral on whether it is religious or not, despite being pretty much a literal passion play. Dreamcoat is more earnestly religious and decently entertaining even if it’s a juvenile work.

Varga Andras

Happy Holidays Jenny! hope all is well with you

David A Behlman

Now all I can think about is that RLM video when they watched the self-defense guy say “gorge his eyes!”.

Jenny Nicholson

I also had purchased a dvd of Christmas Oranges and we watched them back to back and were shocked to discover most of the cast were the same

Birthe_bird

A surprise, but a welcome one

Porge

You spoil us!

Guildhall Games

Goal for tomorrow, work the phrase "Christmas is like an apron" into the conversation.

Jenny Nicholson

Like surely an all powerful and all knowing god could have contrived a different reason for the lamb to be in the barn that one night other than permanently injuring one of his legs right

David A Behlman

I got a little choked up when the sister said she used her wish for her. Just one of those little emotional moments that works despite the rest of the nonsense. Glad I’m not alone in this!

Callum Moore

As solidly one of the top 5 Lion King fans, I kinda feel like I have to watch that next

Abigail Graham

In the first one that evil guys brother didn't even use the money he was bribed with... he just kept the bags in a box in his cupboard!! (at 19:03)

Louis Z

You’re right, Markus. Tolkien was much less direct about it than Lewis. The exception is the resurrection of Gandalf. That’s as direct as a Church Play presentation. I wonder why they haven’t done Lord of the Rings. Maybe it’s too on point or maybe it wasn’t pop culture current enough when they started making them.

Silky

... Santa?

Louis Z

Shouldn’t laying on Jesus have cured the lamb?

Markus D

I cry at bloody everything. I was very proud of myself for not getting emotional at any of these.

Markus D

Who, Church of the Rock? Might be that none of them are into the genre. Otherwise, I can fully believe that some Evangelical Christians don't like due to a general problem with magic in media; ONLY THEIR GUY CAN DO MAGIC—I MEAN, MIRACLES!

Sanja Ramic

Merry Christmas Jenny, hope you and your family have a lovely holiday. Thank you for a wonderful year of thoughtful and engaging video essays and rambles. I’m sure I’m not the only one who is grateful for the respite!

Rudy Gardea

I was just about to type it, and she said “she looks like me so I should stop”. I had to acknowledge it.

Louis Z

I keep forgetting that’s their name. I think of them as Church Play for the same reason Jenny calls Galaxy’s Edge Star Wars Land.

Louis Z

Eliminating the middle tier is unlikely but we’ll probably end up with a version of “Jenny’s Choice”. When the next seesaw vote inevitably happens she’ll pick the topic she wants to make more. This will cause resentment among the other topic’s submitter and voters, which is why she banned “Jenny’s Choice” in the first place. A runoff would be fairer. Even if the runoff happened in the middle tier it would still be a disincentive to have a seesaw vote. If a seesaw vote means the possibility of two rambles 😃 people will do it. If all it means is a runoff vote 🥱 they won’t do it.

Adam Cohen

And it's not just for that. It's also for carrying puppies and wiping tears! It has so many uses!

John Alonzo

Merry Christmas Jenny and to all of us here on Patreon. Hope everyone has a wonderful holiday. :)

Mady, you know, from TV

Annabelle's Wish!!! I forgot about that movie but oh my god yes, we watched that at our grandparents house as kids every year. I have to go dig that up again.....

Mady, you know, from TV

Okay, random Christmas Special I saw as a kid was the one from Mickey's House of Mouse? It was a movie based on the cartoon and they were snowed in and they showed clips of old mickey holiday bits I think. House of Mouse must not have had the reach I always thought it did because no one ever knows what I mean, but the Mickeys House of Villains spinoff movie was a structural building block of my childhood

Junior

Oh my god! I missed this drop. Merry Christmas to me (us)!

JAV1028

That moment when you realize that mountain lion was voiced by Mark Hamill...

Shane

Did I expect I would spend Christmas morning watching Jenny react to Christmas tradwife propaganda? No. Am I upset about it? Also no.

Joe Vahlenkamp

“And she died! A miracle!” The apron can be used to carry puppies in from the yard, wave to people, and strangle whoever gets in the way of a Christmas wish.

wolfbeas

The light Evermore shade in this video is hilarious

Dave Ruff

Jenny's glee at the first evil song gives me life.

Amy Cooper

Truly, He works in mysterrrrious ways.

Monica McFadden

Yeah, "God played 3D chess with your genetics so you'd be trapped in the barn so his son would be kept warm" doesn't really benefit the lamb.

Katicorn

Manifesting that Jenny gets a costume design Oscar nomination for the Christmas tree hand

Angelica Sather Hodgetts

So glad someone else thought the phrase “tradwife propaganda” because I came here to type that exact thing. Jenny is like “why would someone make this!” And I’m like “…I think we know why…”

Luis

Okay just got done watching Nosferatu so let me pick a Christmas special from the wiki. Hmm clicked on random special and got...Nestor, the Long-Eared Christmas Donkey (1977) 👀 welp I'll be back in 24 minutes.

Asha Stasia

The first film, if you gave it Disney level animation, it would do well in theaters. Also, a crippled lamb would be perfect for tender meat as it wouldn't be very active.

Angelica Sather Hodgetts

The most telling line imo was about how the young married couple went out into the middle of nowhere to be closer to “god and to each other”

Luis

The stop motion animals were great and the songs were good, but the constant bullying Nestor received for his long ears cut me deep 😔 7/10 Christmas special.

DaisyMaisy

The main character grew up to be the ballerina farm tiktok tradwife lady I assume

Mike Metzler

I noticed you said you found the second movie in a video store. They still have those?

MillieWays42

Oh my god, I was in shock at how ableist the crippled lamb one was (also, I'm disabled, that is a slur, thank you for not saying it, I appreciate it :)

Rhys Parry-George

The first movie reminded me of that weird Christian version of The Princess and The Pea that came out a while ago

Pterranodon

I'm just imagining in the final movie, when the animals asked "So what happened to the baby?" The camel just goes, "Nyehehe, he was CRUCIFIED."

mikeymad

Thanks - I watched - Mr Stink... cheers

Kier

I SERIOUSLY thought that in the Christmas Apron one, it would be revealed that the parents intentionally staged fake arguments about money to lower their expectations for Christmas and generally keep them in line. When the grand piano was revealed the only conclusion I had was "oh, they were lying."

Markus D

Typically they aren't allowed to go dance, because dancing is for harlots. They get forced into marriages with older men who they have to slave for. I don't know what your weird pseudo-poetry was all about. You seem lost.

Neil Dutton

Scratching my eyes out in gratitude for a bonus video.

Neil Dutton

Chad Lamb invents the hot water bottle out of spite.

Erica McMillan

LOTR was not an allegory, but Tolkien did call LOTR a “fundamentally religious and Catholic work.”.

Erica McMillan

I think you’re thinking of FLDS, which is its own whole thing. I’m not LDS but LDS people are mostly pretty normal

christian skisonic

Oh no, my mom got me an apron for xmas and ill never know what it means

DrearyTina

"With that attitude, you might get a Christmas apron of your own one day," sounds like a threat.

Garga Lenoir

King of the first movie: Rejoince my subjects! The excessive taxes will be lifted and reimbursed now! Peasants: Awesome! King: However, my daughter just discovered and proved that animals are all thinking, sentient, talking beings, so we can't really eat them anymore. Sooo good luck with the whole "eating in winter" thing... Sorry...

Bullseye

Why do they have a pig in Bethlehem?

Louis Z

I take back everything I said about the voting problems. The whole thing is 100% Patreon’s fault. If they would just allow Jenny to hide the vote count during the voting period it would fix everything. It’s not normal for vote counts to be visible while voting is occurring. It’s not how presidents are elected; it’s not how popes are elected; it’s not how best supporting actresses are elected. Hiding the vote count during voting prevents all sorts of election shenanigans and makes the process of voting equal for everyone no matter when they vote. Yet Patreon won’t add the simple feature of letting account owners hide the vote count if they want to. Patreon, if you can read this, I want you to know I blame you for everything. I hope a cute little bird scratches your eyes out. Even though there are other, less horrifying ways to resolve the matter this is the way I have chosen! Incredibly enough, I’m willing to say so out loud and even repeat it several times to make sure everyone gets the message.

David Timm

it's the heads of the guards

Novus

"You see, it's a GOOD thing you were born a cripple and in pain your whole life. For other people got to use you one time. And that makes your pain all worth it!"

Markus D

How was Nosferatu?

Luis

Not bad. Very creepy but kinda long. My one major complaint is *SPOILERS* Nosferatu's big bushy mustache and bald head made him look exactly like Dr Robotnik from Sonic 😬

Eric MacMillan

Jenny said she likes that we can see the votes because if we are currently voting for a topic that isn’t in contention, we can come back and add a vote to one of the frontrunners. So I think she said even if Patreon allowed votes to be hidden she probably wouldn’t want to do it.

Louis Z

Usually I think Jenny is wiser than Yoda and Marcus Aurelius combined but if that’s her position I disagree with her. I would agree if we only had one vote each. Since we can vote for multiple topics the first decision voters have to make is how many votes to cast. That decision shouldn’t be influenced by earlier voters. If it is then the earlier voters are having a disproportionate influence on the outcome compared to the later voters. How many topics a voter votes for should be based on how many topics they think are worthy of a vote instead of how earlier voters made that decision. It’s academic anyway because Patreon doesn’t allow hiding the vote count. Also Jenny is totally, totally wrong about roller coasters.

VermiciousKnid

I feel like these videos need more apron content.

Natalie Stromberg

Am I the only one that thought baby Jesus was healing the lamb when he pet him? Like I was like whoa, the baby Jesus made him whole with his healing touch! Oh wait no, he’s still disabled.

Natalie Stromberg

One of the main kids in the Christmas Oranges movie is the real life son of the Dad in Christmas Apron. They used to be my neighbors

Alice Lastname

Am I cruel hearted for being so annoyed by the characters of Christmas Apron that I just wanna let loose a whole army of chickens into their household? Am I monster for wanting to fill every corner of that household with so many chickens that there won’t be enough Christmas Aprons in the world to save them? And when they try to shoo away some of the chickens, I’ll pump in more?

Zoe Cosmic

In a Christmas book I had as a kid, there’s a story kinda similar to the lamb special called the littlest angel. The littlest angel wants to get to Bethlehem before all the big angels do when Jesus is born. She gets starflowers to give him and then flies away. She stops and helps a baby bird in the nest, and a starflower falls. She cures a sick baby and a starflower falls. She goes to help a lamb with a broken leg and she doesn’t know how and all her starflowers fall out and she can’t get them back cause her wings are really tiny and she can’t fly fast. She walks to the stable and she’s sorry that she doesn’t have anything to give Jesus but Mary says that a creature in need is the best gift of all. Baby Jesus cures the lamb and the littlest angel visits every year on Christmas and brings music to good people. Different cause it’s not really about the lamb and also the lamb isn’t like born with a broken leg, it just happened.

Zoe Cosmic

Also the lamb got cured. I know that’s like a dicey topic because I know there are many disabled people who don’t feel they need to be cured because they’re living full, wonderful lives. And I fully respect that, there’s nothing wrong with that. But this little lamb says verbally he wants to be like the others and also is in constant pain. So maybe Jesus could have done him a solid like in the littlest angel.

Jack

In practice, seeing the vote totals encourages people to vote for ties. Either they switch their vote from an underperforming topic to 1 of the top 2/3, or they vote for 1 of the top 2/3.

Louis Z

Exactly, Jack, which is why I think if Jenny actually had a switch she could flip to hide the vote count that switch would get flipped. The seesaw votes put Jenny in an awful position. Either she’s forced to make two rambles or she’s forced to participate in the topic selection process by picking one. She’s very committed to not participating in topic selection but the seesaw votes force her to.

ashton

Surprised to hear a horse girl say that four legged animals do fine with only three legs. How many three-legged horses have you met? Hoofed animals are different than cats and dogs. What I'm saying is that if this inn-keeper were a caring owner he would have humanely euthanized the disabled lamb, and then Jesus would have frozen to death because Joseph and Mary were too stupid to wrap the baby up in their own voluminous clothing.

Jenny Nicholson

With horses the issue is more that their size makes them notoriously hard patients. They're big and strong and hard to control, hard to convince to rest, used to living their lives standing, and also any level of stress can cause digestive problems that can be fatal. The reasons you don't see a lot of 3-legged horses is: if a leg's been amputated that means there's been a surgery, which horses don't recover easily from. If a horse isn't useful to be ridden from birth or otherwise, most people aren't willing to finance their lives, which usually means euthanasia. Compare to something like a dog, are usually just companion animals and aren't expected to do very physical jobs, lower to the ground and aren't carrying a human so it matters less if they occasionally fall, easier patients because they're small enough to be controlled, usually easier temperament about lying down for a lot of the day tl;dr the reason you don't usually see horses with 3 legs is pretty horse-specific and also related to human culture. A lamb with human intelligence and a leg that's not functional but is intact with no risk of infection could survive fine and even probably jump over puddles with his 3 other legs

Matthew Filla

I wish that when they had Christmas dinner at the end of the first movie , it turned out they were having venison for dinner and the deer was horrified.

Monssef Burezah

I want to propose a future bonus video „Jenny talks about her life and views as a horsegirl“. That state of the fandom video a couple of years ago was super duper 🙌

Mina K

"And Jed made it just in time to wrap their newborn baby in the apron" The one that's been outside for hours in a blizzard? 😅

Gian Balangue

I did not expect this year's Doctor Who Christmas Special to share some elements with an obscure low budget animated Christmas special from 2000 lol

resident_shevil

"She has metronome trauma" literally made me lol

KateArcade

Man, I hope they washed that apron

Fiona V

I thought the same as nomchonks at first but I googled it and everything said sheep do pretty well with 3 legs.

Devin M

She’s literally not being forced to do anything. What are you even on about? This kind of thing happens occasionally and she doesn’t make two videos. She does - some times - because she wants to. Usually if she makes two videos I assume it’s because of exactly the reason she stated here - because she doesn’t particularly like the topic that won and had hoped the other would win instead, so she makes both.

Luigi

I love how Evermore is so foundational to Jenny's world that it can be peppered into all the content and we nod along when it's referenced.

Bear

As a German, I feel so seen by wanting birds to do violence in a fairy tale.

Louis Z

I didn’t say she was forced to make two rambles. I said she was forced to either make two rambles or arbitrarily choose a winner. Mean Girls was ahead half the time and Christmas Specials was ahead half the time. Saying Mean Girls “won” isn’t really accurate. You could just as easily say Christmas Specials “won”. She might not have been forced to make both but she was certainly pressured to. In this case she was okay with it because she knew Christmas Specials would be more entertaining than Mean Girls so she made Mean Girls the opening act and Christmas Specials the headliner. I agree with you that any discussion about hiding the vote count is pointless because Patreon won’t let her do it. It did give me an opportunity to make an eye gouging joke and that’s never pointless. I think the seesaw voting is annoying and ridiculous and it’s clear Jenny doesn’t like it either. I know she’s discussed the best way to conduct the election in the past but I think it’s still a work in progress. Most voters would be happy to see the seesaw voting stop but I guarantee Jenny asking for it to stop won’t work.

Holly

Me, a IHE veteran: A Fairytale Christmas? 🚬 I haven't heard that name in years 🚬

Khurasan Miniatures

Just in case Jenny is reading the comments, have you seen Skeleton Crew on Disney plus? I know you don’t watch much tv. Some of the scenes look like they may have been shot in the Star Wars hotel.

Adam!

Jenny have you heard about the Disney tv show Evermoor

Miles Proctor

Some guy at the inn is trying to start the tradition of calling pork short mutton so you can sell it to British tourists for breakfast.

Kat Farmer

i like the that the animators decided to make a majority of the bird and the walls of the exterior AND interior castle the exact same color

Gemma

I wonder if they could use the Christmas apron to carry in puppies from the yard?

Brooklyn Elise

I didnt think they could make an even lower budget knockoff of swan princess christmas but here we are

kelly m

she looks so cute in this hair and makeup 🫶

Author

Horses prior to human selection originally looked closer to Przewalski's horses. Shorter, sturdier, and with legs that didn't snap like twigs. Modern horse's fragility is a byproduct of human selection for horses that could be ridden.

Louis Z

British tourists would arrive at the inn a millennium later. They were called Crusaders and made a mess of their room. Another millennium later more British tourists would arrive. They were called The Who and also made a mess of their room.

Cece Z

theres no way that apron movie isn’t some kind of bizarre evangelical/tradwife propoganda. “the most important work of all” oh im sure also since they say “30 years ago” in the beginning of the lamb movie it would be both very funny and biblically accurate to respond to “what happened to jesus” with “oh he’s dead”

Fiona

Right before the little girl’s sister unwrapped the metronome I was like “a metronome! A metronome! To reminder her how she can’t play the piano!” I laughed so hard I teared up when it was actually a metronome

Ann Parker

True although I feel like a good solution to that is a second, runoff vote system once there's a clear two or thee frontrunners

Jen Canary

100% the reason it’s so terrible and shallow is that it’s basically just evangelical clap trap - all little girls should dance beautifully and dream of having an apron of their own!

Louis Z

I completely agree, Ann. Plurality with runoff has several advantages over plurality as a voting system. First, and most importantly in this context, ties are impossible. There is no reason to vote for a tie in either round of voting. In the extremely unlikely scenario of a tie between the two topics in the second round Jenny could just flip a coin. The only people who would try to make the vote a tie are those with a particular fondness for coin flipping. While I’m sure such people exist they’re not a significant percentage of the population. The second advantage is everyone gets to vote for one of the top two contenders, a voting feature Jenny has said she likes. The third advantage is the winning topic is guaranteed to be popular with a majority of voters. In plurality voting a topic can win even if 80% of voters never voted for it. In plurality with runoff it’s guaranteed that each month most voters will see a topic they voted for win. It’s not as if using a voting system that produces a clear winner would stop Jenny from making bonus rambles. She could still pick a lucky loser and make a bonus ramble about it just because she wants to. She could make a bonus ramble about what she had for breakfast if she wanted to and I would absolutely watch that.

Aaron Pringle

I was more "ooo, an obelisk. No one has ever given me an obelisk for Christmas" because my friends and family have failed me.

J B

Ty Jenny for this Christmas bounty of content. I hope your holidays are excellent. I love your ramble outfits. I get way too excited by a different outfit, the first video I ever caught was dear Evan Hanson and I didn't realize for way too long that you were Evan haha I thought that was just you, living your best life. Also I almost died laughing when you were prompting that bird to go for the eyes!

Fantome Sauvage

You will never know how much this helped me tonight. Just having your parasocial company at the right moment. And I have no idea why this helps so much, it just does.

KP Lim

I think all the wacky micro expressions were a product of cheap, primitive computer generated tweening.

KP Lim

That first special: literally how the Carolingians seized power from the Merovingians

Sewing Savage

You hit the nail on the head, you look just like the princess hahaha

Cheeseborne

Highly recommend “Annabelle’s Wish.” It’s about a cow who dreams of becoming a reindeer. No joke, my favorite animated Christmas movie that no one has heard of. :p

R C

the singing lamb is the voice of Lefou, so technically it is the Gaston of lambs

Rushka Unverricht

Those Christmas Tree mittens are great lol. Thanks for another year of rambles/videos Jenny!

Joe

It's all fun and games...

Anna Gae

love how the sneaky guy has to overhear a father telling his daughter that hed be lost without her in order to scheme. like id just assume most parents would be really upset if anything happened to their kid

Jenna Stoddard

They waited way too long to reveal the dad in the Christmas Apron was disabled, I was way too annoyed at him being a draft dodger 😂

Danielle Schatten

I love how here for violence Jenny is in that first video

Danielle Schatten

game theory: the reason the family was able to afford a piano in "A Christmas Apron," despite not having a penny to their name, and the fact that Father wears a suit despite working at "the factory," is that this is still set in 1942 but in the world of Philip K. Dick's The Man in the High Castle and the gifts have come from the home of Widow Anderson who has been reported to the occupying government, explaining the bizarre reliance on the importance of "women needing aprons to be domestic partners" and just like the entire vibe

Jackson K

I worked at a bookstore where we sold The Christmas Apron when it came out. The reason the apron was so generic in the movie was because we had stacks of generic aprons that resembled it which were meant to be sold along with the video.

Danielle Schatten

"Asa, what happened to the baby?" "He was executed by the government for spreading anti-capitalist propaganda, why?"

Emilio Bustamante

I was shocked Jesus didnt cure the little lamb, honestly what a rip-off

Dane Roberts

I was really scared the disabled lamb was going to be the one that Abraham burned alive as a sacrifice in the place of his son

Aly

Why did the villian provide a fake princess when the whole point was to keep the king looking for her?????? would that not foil his own evil plan

pizmeyre

Is it just me, or did the princess's hair, from behind, look like a wiener? Almost a nod to the Disney hidden wieners?

Sleepy Lillie

Jenny’s thirst for violence in the first movie is so friendship is witchcraft coded

Feiyuan

Happy new year (from NL 🤣

Adam Ryan

The Christmas Apron isn't just an apron, it's also an apron that we wear on Christmas. It's also a metaphor. For aprons.

Jessica

The lamb story is based on a children’s book, and I know this because, incredibly coincidentally, I was jump scared by this book while working at my library job (I did not know it existed until then). In the book he is shorn for his wool to keep baby Jesus warm, so the moral becomes “God has a plan for you, and all your hardship is so you can sacrifice things for your Lord and Savior.” Interesting to see they cut that part out, and not any of the other questionable material. You can still find the book for purchase online since it is still being published, and no: the title has not changed. (Also this is an original story from the late 90’s so it’s also not very old! Yikes!)

Elyse

I FORGOT ABOUT ANNABELLE'S WISH I watched that so much as a kid!!

MyNameIsGrundle

I kept hoping one of them would be Noel (the happy Christmas ornament). Random forgotten animated special from the early 90's that's so much up Jenny's alley that I honestly can't believe she's never mentioned it. Guess there's always next year

Thomas Degroat

She was like 8 when she got kidnapped. How did she just "forget" she was a princess?

Markus D

I mean... most religious people seem/are normal until you get into their beliefs.

LilacSunflower6

As a disabled viewer, thank you for being mindful about the archaic title for the last film.

Mina K

I assumed the bottle of magic vapor made her forget. They could've explained it better for sure

Sara Jane Webster

You too can carry puppies in your very own Christmas Apron^tm

Becca Yaga

During the Christmas Apron, Jenny said that the parents being like "we haven't a penny for Christmas" is very Evermore-esque. Funny story, Covenant Communications is also a Utah- and Mormon-based company lmao

Becca Yaga

Also the mom in the christmas apron stars in "beauty and the beast: a latter-day tale" which is equally terrible

Pacmantis

I assumed whatever gas went up her nose messed up her brain.

Eric Houge

I'm sure this has already been mentioned, but the one about the lamb is basically a reworking of Don Bluth's "Small One". That was a XMas special (yes I am trying to take the Christ out of Christmas, I declare war on the holiday) about a kid trying to sell a donkey. Said donkey was too small to be of any real use and nobody wants it. Then finally a guy named Joseph buys it to transport his pregnant wife Mary, can you guess the name of the baby she's about to have?!!? Pretty much the same message: that thing you think is a flaw has a divine purpose after all. In fairness, I suspect there are a LOT of Christian stories where the twist is, "But then Jesus."

August Filbert

Was the Christmas Apron set in 1942 solely because that's near to when A Christmas Story was set? It kind of seems like there was no particular reason for it to be a period piece otherwise.

Mars

the lamb movie title had me thinking, doesn’t the shepherd break the lambs legs and then carry it around his neck to teach it not to run away in the bible story? so yea that was somehow even more random than i thought

Ronja Jonasson

No, you see, dad can't be off in the war, because that means mom works in the factory, and that goes against the whole family values tradwife propaganda thing they have going on.

gal fieri

how did they have a whole lamb Jesus movie & not drop the ‘lamb of god’ phrase (assuming it wasn’t in a part you cut)

Remi P

Not sure if anyone else has noticed but I have it on good authority the entire monologue from The Christmas Apron is plagiarized from a sentimental Facebook caption I see shared by grandmas/nostalgia pages all the time. You can find the whole thing by searching “history of the apron”, the most recent one when I went to find it today was posted 2 hours ago but the earliest I can find with a quick glance is a post from 2008. It’s so bad that the emotional peak of the film is literally lifted from old lady email chain nostalgia bait, where the wording was waaaay more saccharine/effective. Will post a chunk of the most relevant bit below for anyone who’s interested!

Remi P

“I don't think most kids today know what an apron is. The principle use of Mom's or Grandma's apron was to protect the dress underneath because she only had a few. It was also because it was easier to wash aprons than dresses and aprons used less material. But along with that, it served as a potholder for removing hot pans from the oven. It was wonderful for drying children's tears, and on occasion was even used for cleaning out dirty ears. From the chicken coop, the apron was used for carrying eggs, fussy chicks, and sometimes half-hatched eggs to be finished in the warming oven. When company came, those aprons were ideal hiding places for shy kids.. And when the weather was cold, she wrapped it around her arms. Those big old aprons wiped many a perspiring brow, bent over the hot wood stove. Chips and kindling wood were brought into the kitchen in that apron. From the garden, it carried all sorts of vegetables. After the peas had been shelled, it carried out the hulls. In the fall, the apron was used to bring in apples that had fallen from the trees. When unexpected company drove up the road, it was surprising how much furniture that old apron could dust in a matter of seconds. When dinner was ready, she walked out onto the porch, waved her apron, and the men folk knew it was time to come in from the fields to dinner. They would go crazy now trying to figure out how many germs were on that apron. I don't think I ever caught anything from an apron - but love.” - source lost to the ages?

notgerardway

maybe even wipe away some tears as well

notgerardway

yea ik i was tickled to see some different scenes that he had left out of his video haha, i used to watch IHE all time time as a teen

Leah Vaughn

I crochet & watched this while making a new santa hat for a friend (she changed her hair so the size of the hat needed to change as well :) ) & I was thrilled to see the tree hat & gloves - now I may make myself something for once

Mars

ah, looking back at my upbringing that makes a lot of sense

Markus D

I know about that movie, but specifically because the guys on God Awful Movies covered it.

Bear

This was top tier commentary. I played this on my second monitor and I just kept snorting every thirty seconds.

Rob Fitzsimmons

Right out the gate with "Your Grace, he means you harm!"

Arthur

I took a shot every time someone said Christmas apron and now I’m the Ghost of Christmas Apron Past.

Iris

So, I think I know why they made The Christmas Apron. I think some Evangelical businesswoman wanted to sell aprons at Cracker Barrel, and this was supposed to be the beginning of a new cultural trend.

Rob Fitzsimmons

Did they sell? Did The Christmas Apron move numbers?

Jackson K

Come to think of it we sold those aprons every year as a holiday fixture, and they generally sold well (they were only like a few dollars, if I remember) so maybe the movie was produced in response to that.

Callie Bagley

Hey I hope you are safe and evacuated, idk where you would update or if you would but here's to you and your family 🙏🏼🫶🏼

Madeline

I know you said no adding Patreon vids to playlists but I wondered if adding them to private ones was okay or if that’s still a problem thanks in advance

Orlando Correa

You really don't wanna be wiping your kid's eyes with the same thing you picky up poopy chicken feet in 😅

Lindsey

I kept waiting for Jenny to mention the whole thing with A Fairy Tale Christmas being repackaged as a ripoff of Brave called “Braver” even though it had nothing in common with that move, but it never happened

Lillian Ward

I guess they didn't want to talk about Easter.

Jamesusmusic-inputsignwave

The Christmas apron ! Jesus why do I feel like this was made as is bait for trad wives. “ aprons they help us do the most important work there is.. family work” .. Jenny if you were a better wife you would already know the significance of the sacred relationship between a woman and her apron, oh you’re not married! Your poor lost soul, Of course not dear. Because you don’t understand about the aprons. Dear Jesus help this poor stray woman without an apron, or a man, find the courage to turn to the true path put on the scared Apron and have many many children, and do the most important work that you in your wise and most magnificent apron put women folk upon this earth to do… this we pray I’m Aprons name.. arapron. Amen 🙏 .

LKB

My grandmother was born in 1909 and you know what she used to remove hot pans from the oven? Potholders, they were already in use even then. And you’d burn yourself trying to use an apron on a hot pans from because the fabric is too thin to protect you from the heat. I have dozens of vintage & antique aprons, and even a few vintage/antique potholders. I actually use them, so I know what I’m talking about here. And trust me, dish cloths, dish towels, and scrap rags are what women used for those dirty, germy jobs, not their aprons LMFAO

Gabby

Apron doesn’t even sound like a word anymore at this point

EndoGladry

i've seen better embarrassing trad wife christmas propaganda- i mean specials than whatever that apron movie abomination was lol

HBirdy

The x lamb was a really beautifully illustrated picture book I loved as a child. It was not plot heavy but was a family staple. I feel like the show version didn’t do it justice but it could just be my own nostalgia. I still like the idea that the lamb didn’t have to prove himself in any way to get the special favor from God. I think that was the whole point.

Steve Ray

As a native speaker of English, mad props to you Germans for calling dragonflies "the Devil's sewing needles."

Steve Ray

To sell to visiting Romans.

Steve Ray

Could you throw together an elevator pitch for a surprise crossover hit, "Nestoratu"?

Bear

Well, TIL... (not to wholly disappoint you, I looked that up and it seems to be an archaic/regional name, but the standard term is just a shortened Latin word for 'little (carpenter's) level')

Selina

the call backs to the Mean Girls musical are too funny XD

Facu López Fraga

Definitly will start to use "you're gonna have a christmas apron of your own one day with that attitude" in a derogative way

Echo Cian

The Christmas Apron being a tv show episode length but sold as a movie as so funny. You thought we were going somewhere with this? lol, lmao, it's somehow even more trite than what you expected and that's the twist But I did learn that aprons are for wiping children's tears, and waving goodbye to people, and carrying puppies, and shooing away geese, and waving hello to people, and swaddling babies, and wiping children's tears, and shooing away geese, and carrying puppies, and shooing away geese, and wiping children's tears, and waving help get me out of this cave to people, and carrying puppies, and when you're disabled the only value you have is what you do for others, possibly to the point of saving someone's life, and nobody will remember your contribution except as inspiration porn to tell other people their lives are fine actually merry kwithtmusth

Ginger Jones

We also had one of those when I was a kid… she started out with four legs but then one night she dragged herself home with only 3 functional legs and a giant gaping wound across her shoulder, I didn’t see it but my dad swears there was exposed bone… anyway she made a full recovery, went around dragging the dead leg for a while, went back to the vet to have it amputated and was much happier after that. She lived for many more years and never had another incident like that. All our cats were outdoor cats back then but I know better now lol

Wes

Brian Cummings and Jim Cummings aren't related, they can just both do the Pete voice for some reason

Laura Robinson

Jenny I think I know what happened to Joshua's parents. Lambs with chronic injuries can't be sacrificed for Passover. I think he's the only one left because the rest of his family got eaten for Passover sacrifices. Isaac's days are numbered.

Laura Robinson

There's some interesting Bible references in C Lamb. A lamb with an injury can't be sacrificed for Passover. That's why Joshua is still alive when his parents aren't, lol. Also Isaac in Jewish lore is the name of the sheep that Abraham sacrificed in Isaac's place on Mount Moriah -- they had the same name because Abraham named his bellweather for his son. Anyway, sometimes my PhD in religious studies comes in handy but not often lol

Ben-K

Jenny bopping along to a villain song about greed and joyfully going “What a show!”, love it

Fifi

I’m so glad I went back to the comments after rewatching because I’m CHO KING

Siobhan is On

I had wonder why you left the credits playing at the beginning of TCL instead of ending after you spoke - Chekhov's Brian Cummings.

Molly K

Watching the CL while knowing that the mean/perfect lamb is eligible to be sacrificed under the law but spotted lambs were excluded from it had me losing my mind watching it like dw Joshua pookie they’re gonna kill your enemy for being too pretty

Molly K

no fr I thought the arrogant lamb who coincidentally had no spot or blemish was about to get sacrificed the whole time

Shay Olin Parker

Jenny's impression of the princess was way too good. I genuinely thought the "it's almost Christmas," was a line that was mistakenly looped

Maddie Moreland

Oh my god the third movie was legitimately one of my sister’s favorite Christmas movies. She was a huge talking animal movie kid growing up. If you’re looking for a really sad one, Nestor the long-eared Christmas donkey is another winner. 1000/10 childhood trauma!

RainyMeadows

"God has forgotten me" is such a raw line

Landon J

"Let's be real...no way did they make a sequel to that." LOL (literally)! Roasted 🤣

Maryella

I’m thinking that the Christmas apron may have originally been out of something like “chicken soup for the soul”, a collection of short wholesome stories, and then somebody decided to make a movie out of it, but they didn’t have much of a budget, and they didn’t realize that since it’s a short story, there isn’t much story to tell.

Glammer Hammer

That first one made Jenny so bloodthirsty! Beware this woman at Christmas time

Parfait

oh my god the girl's head from behind in the first one has a very, VERY unfortunate design

Cass

I can't believe both The C L and Rapsittie Street Kids managed to bag Jodi Benson for random side characters. A gig is a gig but man, her Christmas Special repertoire is...something.

Gabby

The thing about pointe shoes is that they need to be replaced constantly and are very expensiveeee

Danielle Schatten

"and so you see, children, that lamb would go on to become the lead vocalist for pioneering alt-metal band System of a Down."

Aaron Smith

Man they are REALLY pushing to get young women excited about aprons!

Kevin Morris

Intro: I thought it would be fun to get in the holiday spirit 🥰 Video: I hope that child actor’s eyes get gouged out by birds

lsaddy

Tradfolks and evangelicals inserting ballet into historical stuff like this is particularly weird, because ballet barely existed in the US before WWII- the first american ballet company wasn't even founded until like 1938. No, little mormon girls in utah small towns in the 1940s weren't studying ballet.

lsaddy

Not to mention the fact that ballet barely had a foothold in the US until after the second world war, the first american ballet company wasn't even founded until 1936.

Brooke Shirts

It’s based on a novella from a small Christian press. Super short, basically like a picture book with no illustrations. The kind of thing your mom gives a neighbor or friend for Christmas.

Rosemary

I just gasped with shock when i realized that I have seen The Christmas Apron! I was like 8 and we saw it at my grandmas house. I can confirm my grandma cried at the ending and thought the child actors were super cute. No one else really liked it lol

Kendra Doyon

I went to a catholic school as a child as we absolutely watched that last movie more than once. For whatever reason Mary's voice saying 'this little lamb...will keep him warm' is burned into my memory

Becca Yaga

Opening my own animation studio to produce "The Chad Lamb's Christmas Apron"

Becca Yaga

Wait no, "The Chad Lamb at the Crucifixion"

Ella M

That, and they also need to be specially fitted. Hers also look pretty dead already. I hope it would have cut forward to when she first puts them on. Her sounds of agony would have perfectly mirrored the lamb's.

Knox

"This is such an Evermore house!" got me cackling

Knox

Mark Hamill really threw his whole chest into that mountain lion role, and I'm here for it

HAWKGUY2012

i’ve been trying to bust out of an anxiety attack for like thirty minutes this video did it thank you jenny

karen canan

Theres a folk song about wearing your apron low, and this guy getting you pregnant, and then you wear your apron high, so ashamed.

kelly m

"she's been drafted" kills me