Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Videos

  • 444772991.mp4

Downloads

Content

Time to go to the mattresses...

Youtube mirror currently under dispute!

Files

Comments

Richard R.

This is going to be good

Miranda

Oh shit can’t wait to settle in with this tonight!!

griff bourne

This feels like a gift from heaven incredible timing Jenny

Olivia Smith

As someone whose favourite movie is You've Got Mail, I am both excited and nervous to watch this

Grace Cowie

I love rom coms and I've gotten out the popcorn

Lady horse

Perfect timing! I have 4 pages due and need something long to listen to.

Steven

Worst couple is Vampire Diaries and China Beach

Trace

I needed this right now.

Cinthia M

That pony is magnificent what’s her name? Oh its frillyfrocks ? So cute

Mady, you know, from TV

That pony looks a lot like the Pegasus (from Disney Hercules) that I won in a coloring contest as a child. I could basically "ride" him and I suspect he is still in a basement somewhere. Excited for this video!

L Woods

The state of Romcom is terrible on Netflix. It's so upsetting!

Skylin.

GIANT PONY PLUSH KYAAAA

Monica McFadden

the gasp I gave when I saw giant Frilly Frocks

Ella M

Jenny, please know that that giant pony is as mesmerizing to me as Jaystation's sarcophagus, and I dearly hope you end the video galloping off screen on its back.

Ella M

Um, I think you misspelled best

Alyssa Ricks

REMEMBER ME?!?!?!?!? SBSBSVGSHSJSBSBSBBSB

Steven

Not with that age gap

Kate Bryan

You’ve Got Mail is also a favorite with my family!

melannie monoceros

return to me was a repeat watch that no one has ever seen

Bethany Hanks

RETURN TO ME MENTION!! They’re always my go-to for a good romcom couple that will absolutely last and NO ONE has seen it. Love that they made the list!

kelly m

honestly tubi is one of the better streaming services for romcoms

Jamie

I'm with you on Runway Bride. Leaving someone at the altar is my least favorite trope. How do you spend all the time and money and energy that wedding planning takes and not end it before the altar. Just such a selfish way to end a relationship, I have a hard time rooting for that person in a movie

William Palmer

Gorilla magic is truly the best kind of magic

Roman Xavier

love transcends organ donation

Ki Sun

Sleepless in Seattle walked so You've Got Mail could run

Ella M

Fair

Emma

I can't remember the exact timeline so I can't remember if she technically cheats, but per that point, Meg Ryan's original fiance in Sleepless in Seattle commits the crime of....having allergies.

Li Speaks

you’ve got mail is one of my favorite movies of all time and i was SO tickled to hear it brought up. and positively too!!!! i learned how to use a VHS player at age 2 because of that movie

Lianne Lairmore

i also can repeat every line of you've got mail and sometimes get the instrument christmas song stuck in my head (the clarinet, the clarinet, goes dooly dooly det)

Brett Buttle

Random question: Has Jenny ever talked about The Last Unicorn? I just watched it over the weekend with my kid, and it seems like the kind of thing that Jenny would have a strong opinion on lol

Katy M.

Omg Li Speaks!! I love your videos so much

Aurora H.

As someone going through a history (and by requirement, war) reading phase, yes you can just be in the army—we tend to use it colloquially to mean the entire military, but it technically only refers to the ground troops branch of the military

Tbing34

I've been here 6 years and I've never seen the giant pony!!

Audrey Eley

Omg! Frilly Frocks! Love the g3 rep 💖

richa i.

the fact that jenny likes you’ve got mail and notting hill (both of which i hated) and hates my best friend’s wedding (which i love)….. ur hot takes are so valuable queen, they keep ur fans on our toes

Dalton

I haven’t seen Runaway Bride so I don’t know if this is contradicted by some major part of the script, but wouldn’t the obvious choice be that she did it one time but it was a really high profile case? Like she was engaged to a celebrity or something? Which is why a journalist might want to cover her story? Having this be serial offense is so deranged and inexplicable.

Austin F

I REMEMBER THOSE AIRPLANE MOVIES. i traveled a lot when i was a young kid, back when portable video games didn't have rechargable batteries, so if my Game Boy Advance ran out of battery (or it was nighttime, because they also didn't have backlights), i would be stuck with the in-flight movies, and i always would come in right in the middle of the movie and have 0 idea what was going on. it made me so mad when i was 8

Anna F.

Hi Jenny, not sure if you already know, but an event called The brandywine Festival presented by Bretschneider (!!!) & Middle-earth enterprise is going to happen in Kentucky in october. They are making a kickstarter and selling tickets until april. Well, it aaaaaaall seems very interesting!

Chelle

I’ve seen 27 dresses way too many times, and the impression I get from the MC is that the brides are like acquaintances, and she’s always chosen to be a bridesmaid/MOH because she’s so good at it and has this reputation of being basically a free wedding planner. but you’re not wrong, she is obsessed with weddings lol. I also thought she was going into the direction of ‘let me leave my unsatisfying job with my boss that doesn’t love or appreciate me and pursue my passion of wedding planning’ but alas they did not ask us.

Meggie

Kate and Leopold is truly so unbelievable but I can't get enough of it

colbyfromage

I just returned from Paris and fell into a deep depression because I miss the boulangeries

Xelayxes

Insane that this movie starts with tom hanks killing that cop.

Anemone Plenary

“You don’t throw away a good heart.” Jennnnnnnyyyyy <3

Baie Berry

Made of Honour was my You've Got Mail, rewatched as an adult and boy howdy

Alexis Turner

Return to Me is one of my favorite RomComs of all time. No one I know has ever heard of it!

Moonie Bonzo

I remember reading somewhere that was the intent of the screenwriter, but 2000's execs basically told them to cut it and focus on just the romance.

jamezilla

I never watched Made of Honor... but I DO remember it!

B Hair

Idk man, it's bleak out there 2025's official slogan 😂

Austin F

her #1 pop song randomly being about the military and being performed at some kind of alt festival has the same energy as TI's huge hit "live your life" starting with a dedication to the soldiers in iraq and then sampling the numa numa song

L Woods

Jenny, your Vaguely Threatening Cockney English Accent is magnificently horrible and I would like you to do an entire video in that style, just because it makes me laugh.

ash

Wow that jumbo classic looking mlp plush is delightful and looks so well made

emchovy

as someone who loves weddings; the fanciness, the high-stakes/low-stakes nature, the theming, the drama BUT likely won't ever get married myself, I find myself relating uncomfortably hard to the main character of 27 Dresses. If I had the outgoing nature and natural duplicitousness required to be a bride-seeking missile and befriend them in order to watch them try on elaborate dresses and walk through venues saying stuff like "Beautiful natural light in here!", I can't lie and say the temptation wouldn't be there. Because weddings are SO FUN.

zliz

the heart transplant soul mates that always find each other sounds like an old tumblr idea and i kinda love it

jamezilla

But there are liberals in the military too... What a dumb premise.

Renee

It's not really secret since it made it onto a Netflix show, but your question reminded me of football player Kirk Cousins, who at first blush looks like the most generic Midwest guy ever, but with his millions of dollars legitimately made a secret passage in his house for all his sports memorabilia

LW

Finally some love for You’ve Got Mail

jamezilla

I forgot that in your country people aren't just entitled to vital, life saving medicine.

kelly m

i really appreciate the patreon uploads! they can be listened to like podcasts and don't have ads ^^

E B

In my secret room is a series of gifts for my friends and family. I’m planning a big party where I thank everyone for supporting me in my basketball career, and I’ve picked out personal presents for everyone. Also I’ve got some spare furniture in there.

G

My secret room would be a recreation of Its a Small World with animatronics (but soundproofed so no one could hear them from the outside)

Chelle

I never saw Purple Hearts but I saw people talking about it, and dropping iconic one liners like ‘this one is for the girlies with racist boyfriends’

Tash

Being shown Jennys indoor foam tree forest: wow how whimsical and magical Stumbling across Jenny’s SECRET indoor foam tree forest: this is definitely were she dresses people up as mascot animals and hunts them for sport

Aaron M. Carpenter

I love Julia Stiles. But, never saw The Prince & Me. Apparently, Netflix's 2005 mail order algorithm never suggested it to me. Will definitely check it out, it sounds too bad to be true. Great overall list.

kelly m

heart transplants do have some kind of bizarre side effects... there was an interesting study in 2020 called "personality changes following heart transplantation" that you can read for more

Terraform23

Fingers crossed that Fifty First Dates and When Harry Met Sally are not mentioned here

Andrea Cervantes

I saw Purple Hearts when I was staying at my friend's Airbnb. One of her friends chose it and I had a hard time not to make fun of it omg, it's so bad.

Kingdon Radio Hour

My secret room is the American girl doll collection room of my childhood dreams. I assume most people would find it incredibly creepy though

Alex Andra

I remember you’ve got mail!! My cool older cousins introduced it to me on VHS. I remember being annoyed she ended up with Tom Hanks because I was emotionally invested in the fate of the shop around the corner and I didn’t like that he could kill her bookstore and still win her love. But I have fond memories of watching it with my cousins.

Sgt Sweetcheeks

My secret room is i think sort of just one giant bed that fills the room with built in blanket fort abilities and a movie screen on a wall. I want a secret room that is sort of just purpose built for bad movie sleep overs

Chelle

My secret room is a fully functional frozen yogurt/ice cream shop. It’s secret so I don’t have to share with anyone. Frozen treats for ONLY me.

Chelle

Sounds about right but also would have been so easy to include anyway. At the end when she’s doing her little voiceover, she could say she finally had her dream job along with the man of her dreams or whatever, and the newspaper clipping could advertise her services. But noOOO

Mady, you know, from TV

Thanks for the question Jenny, my secret room is one of those rooms where sound doesn't exist anymore. An anechoic chamber. I am a passionate believer in screaming as an emotional release but I don't want anyone to call the cops and I don't drive so I can't do it on the highway. I am aware that this would be very scary for a housemate to find but I don't want to share my screaming room.

Catherine

honestly I consider myself “one of those girls who doesn’t date military guys.” I just know that we wouldn’t align in core values.

disco shrimp

my rich person secret room would be dungeon-esque. not a sex dungeon though, it would essentially just be a room where i watch movies and play animal crossing but it will have theme park level decorations. i’m talking torch lights, prop skulls, lots of dark greys and reds, an iron maiden, Salvatore house type furniture and rugs, organ music on standby, and best of all- a draw bridge style door that opens slowly and ominously to reveal a closet full of dvds, board games, and snacks.

Aivi

Hilariously, I would want a bridesmaid like the one in 27 Dresses… you’re doing everything for me AND want MY wedding to be a dream? Hell yeah girl

Cherry B.

I'm EA Hanks, and I co-sign that it was, in fact, a garnish.

Gilded Lady

If they cheat with you, they'll cheat on you. I agree those relationships won't last. Can't ever deny gorilla magic though, they'll celebrate 50 years before you know it and then die a day apart because the 2nd dies of a broken heart.

Aidan

Think this is truly one of the all-timers for ramble vids, thoroughly enjoyed every moment

Betsy

My secret room would be a home theater. But since I would be a rich and famous basketball player, I would have two home theaters: one that's available to my friends and family, and a secret, soundproofed home theater that's just for me so I can sneak off to watch my favorite movies and shows without interruption. It would have a popcorn machine, a Coca-Cola Freestyle machine, a very comfy recliner with cupholders, a throw blanket, and a couple of snuggly plushies. Hmm, OK, now I am starting to see how my secret home theater could be misinterpreted.

Gabrielle Fullam

NEED to know if you think Vanessa Hudgens and the beast made it

Chris Oakley

my secret room would be a mini muppets museum, i'd have spent hundreds of thousands of dollars to get archival versions of all the characters, especially the miss piggy from muppets take manhattan with her custom vivienne westwood wedding dress. i'd also have to do a buzzy-esque caper to steal the statler and waldorf animatronics from muppetvision 3d of course. plus old obscure merch, behind the scenes photos, etc. i think this would be creepy but i also think it's the least creepy version of "secret room in mansion filled with old puppets" you could possibly make.

Ro the Lion

Now I just want a secret forest room, that sounds incredible... If there were no logic barriers in place, I'd say I want a mini-holodeck, like the suites in DS9, it doesn't have to be able to turn into more than like a regular bedroom's amount of space, but I could use it as a full sensory immersion room for writing, and actually punch the scenes into the room's comm to test out the dialogue on the characters. Or if that's too fancy, I'd get a room that's almost totally filled with a sen-dep pod, to entirely de-stress my nervous system in the water and darkness. So kind of opposite rooms, actually.

Guilla Monster

Gorilla magic! Soul magic! Meg Ryan’s Revenge! This video has it all!

codifierbehemoth

My secret room would either be an exact replica of the room you walk into the secret room from, or a hammock room with nothing but hammocks, fake palm trees, and a drink cooler

Alex Andra

I believe all movies fall into four quadrants: I like it and it’s good, I like it and it’s bad, I don’t like it and it’s good, I don’t like it and it’s bad. The Prince & Me falls into the 2nd category for me. It’s so so bad and yet you can’t make me dislike it.

Lexi Lily

My rich person secret room is a small subway train that runs under my enormous basketball mansion and has stops around the property. Soundproofed, of course.

Bugbear OrMiss

My secret room would be this incredibly immersive DnD room with a bar and 3d surround sound speakers and greenscreens capable of simulating any environment! But also, like, theres this painted over hidden door that leads to a maze filled with at least 13 terrifying lifesized hyperrealistic Bugbear robots that stalk the halls and hunt down whoever enters.

Jenny Nicholson

Need a fake husband with shattered legs for that and also might still go to jail

Mike Carpenter

“Getting married without being in love to scam the government” is itself such an “11-year-old on Wattpad” concept to begin with because, like, love marriages are historically something considered lucky or privileged to be a part of; why would it be intrinsically tied to the legal construct of marriage as established in the 18th century? What’s more, arranged marriages still happen including in the US, are those scams? College students sometimes marry for the sole purpose of financial aid, since parents’ income is considered in that even if they’re estranged, unless you are married, and this is not generally viewed as scamming anyone but rather an unfortunate thing that the law inadvertently requires some people to do to make an education obtainable. And what about all those boomer couples who stayed married “for the kids” despite hating each other but are now too old and codependent to get a divorce? Are they scamming the government because they file taxes as married? It’s one of those “have you ever left your house even one time” sorts of conflicts you see with amateur writers who lack both life experience and motivation to look up information they don’t already know, i.e. children writing fanfiction.

AE

I used to work at an escape room. One time, one of the rooms got phased out and replaced. It wasn't just our location, the company that owned our chain removed this specific room from all locations because it wasn't booking enough. We were instructed to tear down the old one and throw away basically everything, because it couldn't be reused. A lot of people kept mementos from the room since we were throwing them out anyway, and most people took like these framed pictures on the walls or stuff like that. You know, stuff that could easily go up on the wall in your house and then you'd have a fun story to tell people about how you got it. One guy took almost everything, including bulky stuff that you couldn't realistically use. Like furniture that was gutted for escape room purposes, pieces of a puzzle that you had to assemble, this phone operator switch board, just all this stuff that I didn't think anyone would want. His explanation for why he wanted it was that it was becoming "lost media" and he wanted to preserve it. So now I'm imagining this guy just recreating this entire old escape room in a secret room in his house, which would be pretty creepy because it was themed around escaping a serial killer's lair.

BoPod Horsecast

Could not agree more about How To Lose A Guy In 10 Days. I watched it for the first time in college during a sports team movie night. Everyone around me loved it and I felt like I was going insane.

Alex McKelvey

My secret room would be an unreasonable amount of guinea pigs and lots of things for them to do

rowenna

My secret room would probably resemble droomvlucht from de efteling so it would need layers and Id replace the cart with a slide. I would leave out all the puppets though cause as much as I like them in the actual ride, I don't think I would feel at ease in my hide out with a bunch of trolls hanging around as well. The space castle area would be a sick spot for watching movies and falling asleep.

MaxMin

That swapping hearts into a younger person to live forever is how the villain in Kingdom Hearts lives.

Anaya Morrison

Stop! As a southern Californian that lives next to a base, trust AND believe there is a no army dating policy lol

Brando

I feel like your foam forest secret room is an excuse to have somewhere to display your Apple Pie Tree. Perhaps as a centerpiece of worship.

Hollow Rhythm

Idk what would be in my secret room but I would want it to be behind a painting or a bookshelf or something. It just sounds like so much fun! Then I’d keep signed books and paintings in there or whatever, buuuut I would love some soundproofing so I can shamelessly sing very poorly at the top of my lungs

Anastasi

Okay my secret room is definitely a massive personal library/cozy reading nook. Which is all well and good except I have a huge collection of horror lit. Like, I own a few hundred books, and about half are horror fiction.

MacP

I would like to officially start a petition to rename "Seasonal allergies" to "Meg Ryan's Revenge"

Jamesusmusic-inputsignwave

Gorilla magic ! I think that heart hopping premise has actually been used in a horror film. I’m sure it was great

Jodi Hoffman

It is so funny that your list of pet rom coms is randomly the same ones my mom always had on lol I love those movies

Johnson Dunn

We watch You've Got Mail every year and even sing the horn song with the whole family at Christmas time 😅

Laura Ann

matthew mcconaughey is a dreadful romantic lead, even tho he's a a pretty good actor. i have no idea why he got cast in a romcom. i get that he's good looking & has a six pack or whatever, but he comes across extremely sinister & only works for me as sinister characters e.g. i thought he was really good in 'killer joe'

Mak

Boring answer but my secret room would be floor to ceiling bookshelves and a super comfy plush bed with lots of soft blankets and plush. A reading / napping nook. I enjoy simple pleasures.

Becky Gimple

My family named our dog Brinkley after Tom Hanks' dog in You've Got Mail.

Thomasin Lockwood

Please do a full video on The Prince and Me! It was one of the first rom coms I watched as a kid and I feel like no one remembers it except me

GabWoof

My secret room would be a Bottleman arena filled with Bottleman toys and bottlecaps. I would want a vending machine but it's Bottleman toys alongside their soda counterparts.

Jack Avalon

I think my secret room would be like a Victorian Christmas village set with little store windows and warm lights and fluffy fake snow

Tina R

I found it hilarious that to make Kathryn Heigl less “hot” than her sister they dye her hair a slightly darker blonde. Still blonde! Still hot! But slightly LESS blonde and therefore unworthy of notice.

diet goth

My secret room would 100% be an arcade. I'll work on restoring old cabinets and setting them up to play. There will be bad pizza, overpriced candy, and dollar store prizes in exchange for tickets. But the ticket dispenser will always be broken so you can never afford a prize. It will be the authentic experience.

Allison Furlong

Bold of you to assume I’m not already a millionaire basketball player with a secret room… (My secret room is just a large collection of hourglasses)

Sam

My secret room would contain Matthew mcconaughey and it would also be soundproof

AshFerraz

Runaway bride was shot in my hometown!

Maya Mint

After you planned a wedding irl or have a close person in that process the trope of leaving someone at the altar seems bonkers. And it's a fairly common trope.

Haley Hansen

I understand the appeal of a secret room entirely. I’ve wanted a secret library for years. I wouldn’t keep it from my partner, not because I’d be willing to share my secret library, but because I wouldn’t be able to stop myself from talking about my very cool secret library.

Zlo M

In my secret room, there are many dolls, some displayed on the shelf but changed, mutated from their original form into creations of madness. Other dolls are lying around the room in various states of undress, some missing hands, some missing other body parts, and most missing a face. Scattered in between them are sharp tools like scissors, needles, and a small saw. So maybe a lil bit creepy?

Kay W

The plush collection continues to be elite. I need to somehow craft a secret room that my cats don't know about so I can eat dinner in peace.

Jodi Hoffman

Omg wait Jenny you need to rewatch 27 dresses, the sister is the villain

Tara Foster

San Diego has a lot of military guys and they are not great to date lmao

zanna

i don't know if you saw prop culture before they took it off disney plus but my secret room would literally be that one guy who had the room full of all the narnia props. that's my dream secret room. i open the door and there's just an improbable amount of swords and animal plushies and armor and niche merch from 2005. it would be beautiful. OR. a room with floor to ceiling breyer horses.

Aivi

My secret room would be a fully functional Auntie M’s Pretzels stall at the mall. With crew and an opening for people to buy pretzels as their hearts desire. It isn’t a secret at all, but the fact that it’s attached to my home is.

Kelly Michals

Oh god that Remember Me callback, I laughed so hard my cat got up and left the room

Alex Andra

My secret room is a perfect replica of the wing of the castle that Belle is forbidden from going to in Beauty & the Beast. Scratched portrait, overturned furniture, glowing rose, everything. People who know me would probably assume that if I was going to design a perfect replica of anything from Beauty & the Beast, it would be the amazing library, and I think it would be unsettling for people to discover I’ve inexplicably created the forbidden wing with no discernible purpose or function.

Art By Howie

Jenny your secret room is enviable if I owned it but absolutely terrifying if I happened upon it as someone’s secret room. If I was that rich I would have an art room since I am an artist, but I don’t see the need to keep that a secret, and probably would brag about it. If I am trying to think of a secret room I would like but on purpose creepy to other people it would be an indoor pool/lazy river (basically pool back rooms but usable) maybe with some water slides

Lawrence

secret room of dozens of paintings of myself that I've commissioned in various styles. they're all in very ornate frames and there are so many that you can barely see any of the wall between them

Jamesusmusic-inputsignwave

The reformed rake trope: I always thought it was going for: he / she is so damaged because they where hurt and so they don’t have relationships and sleep around but the power of love and a real relationship with this ‘friend’ women / man .shatters there’s narrisitic amour to reveal the gooey vulnerable/ heart of gold centre.. and they completely reform and basically get what takes a life time of therapy to accomplish. The power of love baby. Also the trope is often successful narrsisitic men that treat women as objects suddenly being cartoonishly vulnerable and clutsy ( much like the clip you showed) which is actually often a trope I quote enjoy just cause it usually gives the performers some fun scenario’s to play with. Also something this is new vulnerability is often crescendoed with a embarrassing act in-front of a crowed ( often wedding goes for someone else wedding ) where he/ she proves there love and reformed ways by embarrassingly and inappropriately to situation declaring their most intimate feelings. But it’s all ok, because love has made them a better person. Even if they are interrupting someone else wedding.. its love so it’s cool

Alex Andra

Barbie video mention! 😍

Jacob Scheyder

Thank you so much for raising awareness about Return to Me!

Sophia Blue

My secret room would be Jenny's indoor forest that I stole piece by piece.

Maddie Arnautov

My secret room is a library so no one can borrow and subsequently ruin my books. Not inherently creepy but I’ll give it a gothic set dressing and put several dusty ancient bloodstained tomes with big rusty locks on them in there for ya, just for fun 🩷

Jamie

My sister in law was in the airforce and she didn't realize she was paid a married salary instead of single. The military contacted her and told her, and then shorted her checks for like 2 years until the extra money was paid back. This was after she fell off a jet she was working on and broke her back.

Regan Plunkett

My secret room is a video game room. It's a secret so no one can watch me fail miserably at the objectively easy games I play.

Pystoria

Nice concept!

bug

I think you’ve got mail feels older because it’s based on The Shop Around the Corner. It’s my second favourite Meg Ryan Tom Hanks romcom, which still puts it pretty high on my list of fav romance movies. I think it’s interesting that they had so much success riffing on old films together in the 90s.

Jamie

Your forest room sounds so cute but if it was secret I would immediately think it was only for weird forest sex lol

Jet Puff

Purple Hearts section was so good. Peak Jenny is just her talking about a truly bad movie.

Akechis Mom

i'm ill so forgive the lack of imagination but yk that scene in Romeo + Juliet where she's fake dead (spoilers) and in like the cool chapel with all those neon crucifixes and flowers and catholic stuff? I want that, minus the fake dead girl. Or a jungle gym

Daniel Metrejean

having to navigate to patreon dot com on my computer instead of clicking youtube mirror and opening up history on my desktop… :( the things i do for jenny

Ryan

Please post when the YT mirror is up or I will forget to watch!

Jet Puff

My secret room btw would just have a stand up Donkey Kong arcade cabinet. I’ve wanted one since King of Kong came out and it would need to be secret because I’m very bad it. Not ready to show the world until months of training…

Christopher Reedman

Secret room question: Currently I have a room that’s 1/2 bookshelves filled with marvel and DC omnibuses. And 1/2 tabletop board games with a gaming table and lots of painted minis in cases. My dream secret room would be a replica of a fantasy dungeon room (stone walls, LED torches light, jail cell, chains on the walls, a stone table and throne. ) I would need a much bigger house to pull this off.

Arrant

Is the audio out of sync for anyone else?

Mal

Great video! Solid discussion, fun, with well explored points that totally delivers on the topic suggestion. All that being said, best part was Jenny's English accent "look at this big ham. what's wrong darling, i'm slicing you some ham" For a secret room. I like to play guitar and sing. But these days I literally never do unless I'm the only one home. It's not that it's bad, sometimes I'm pretty good. But I tend to play what I'm feeling, so if I'm feeling down I'd play something that resonates. Totally see the appeal of having some place secret and private to do that... That's all it is, oh the soundproofing, that's for the singing. oh, and the drain in the middle of the floor, is for um ... the accoustics.

Alyssa Pearl

Oooh, my secret billionaire room would definitely be like the size of a warehouse with a GIGANTIC forest that physically dwarfs you in size, making you a wingless fairy of sorts! HUGE mushrooms and flowers that you can make life-size fairy houses out of! I know you've seen Fairytopia bc of the barbie video you're making, so you know exactly what to picture lol

Katrina Kaufman

My super secret room would be a classical speakeasy. I know what you're thinking, how could it be a classical speakeasy when alcohol is very much not illegal anymore? Well, I would still have the big burly door guard (preferably a gorilla a la Who Framed Roger Rabbit) and the only people allowed inside would have to know the secret knock and password, both of which wouldn't really matter because the truth is I'm the only one allowed inside. This would keep any family or housemates from being able to figure out either secret knock or password. I'm not even much of a drinker, so I most likely wouldn't even drink in there. I guess I just want the aesthetics of the speakeasy to maintain the super secret room. I'd probably just read in there. (Really liked the You've Got Mail rep, I feel like that's an underappreciated Meg Ryan romcom. Entirely built on the strength of the chemistry between Meg Ryan and Tom Hanks, and the individual charm of each, but I DON'T CARE, I think they're cute.)

Samantha Ansley

I’m devastated by how many of these I have seen, but generally agree with the list of points, excluding You’ve Got Mail. The only movie w somewhat happy couples imo was Playing By Heart, but nearly all rom coms are bad bc they are rarely taken seriously by those making it which translates to the message.

Eleanor Hughes

my secret room is an indoor hedge maze. the room has no overhead lights so as you go deeper into the maze the glow from the doorway fades away and you are shrouded in darkness. by completing the hedge maze you find yourself in the middle of a tiny cul-de-sac of doll houses illuminated by little street lamps and and tiny chandeliers. inside you see immaculately decorated homes full of calico critter families living mundane lives.

Suzy

Agreed, I can't put my finger on it but I just cannot see him in a romantic role at all. He's good at playing total assholes lol. I thought he was good in Interstellar also. But I don't buy him as a romcom guy

Forrest

I think I would have a secret basement library, kind of similar to the one in season 1 of You (for strictly archival purposes, of course). But I would also have it double as a reptile sanctuary. I feel like they’re very similar in that both need to be kept dry, so it will probably work out.

Carrie L.

Hand to god for a single moment I thought you were going to say the gorilla got the heart transplant

Andrew van Baarsen

Non scary secret rooms: A painting room where I paint still-life images or fruit and other innocuous objects. It's secret because I'm still learning and I'm very insecure about my artistic ability. A room full of like DC comics or something. It's a secret because I don't want people to know I'm a huge geek, it's just a really big collection. A room that used to be my late husband's at-home office and I left it how he left it because he died in a really tragic way and I haven't moved on. A room where I am harboring someone on the run from the police for killing a really musky CEO or something.

Ted Koutz

Mine would be a recreation of a cool but now defunct coffee shop that I remember that let you go on the roof, so I'd have to simulate that, possibly in a giant basement. Since this involves food service I'd probably have to do something along the lines of I Am Legend where Will Smith recreates stuff from his previous, non-zombie-apocalypse life

Katie Luke

My secret room is empty except for a photo negative Mickey suit full of gore

Steven Clark

I remember watching Kate and Leopold for a Cracked article that I was editing, where the original article was a complete mess, and I knew I would basically have to rewrite it from scratch, and then the movie didn't even end up fitting the theme of the article at all, and it was just really bad and bland on top of that. So, I still kind of hold a grudge against the movie for wasting my time. When the Secret Room prompt came up, I started thinking about what could possibly be a non-creepy secret room, and I think the clear answer is if it was spy stuff. Not hidden camera monitors or anything, but just a bunch of those cheesy spy gadgets that they used to sell in comic book ads and in the back of karate magazines. Camera pens and ninja climbing spikes and stuff like that. So, now I really want a room like that, and I guess that's my answer.

bug

It took me three reads to realize you meant military guys and not Jenny re: core values. I was like wait what happens later in this video?

Ben Leitner

My secret room would be a doll room, I have a ton of dolls displayed now which people think are creepy even if it isn’t a secret, so my billionaire Barbie bunker might not go over well especially if I am a famous male basketball player hiding them from a woman I love

Eleanor Robinson

Made of honor is a play on Maid of Honor! I think it's meant to be ironic. Terrible film regardless of puns

Melanie Magnon

My secret room would be some sort of fake Dracula crypt, which would definitely seem like a scary thing, but is more nerdy and LARPy than that. There's a Phantom of the Opera adaptation starring Charles Dance where he has a secret fake forest room! It's weird and spooky, but also kind of funny and whimsical.

Gigi

i’m devastated that you dislike how to lose a guy in 10 days. one of the BEST romcoms ever made. kate hudson literally deserves an oscar for that role lmao

Joseph Genser

“Gorilla magic” is now a phrase that will live rent-free in my head

Larkin Blau

YAYAYAYAYAYAYAYAY ITS JENNNNNYYYYY🩷🩷🩷

Euphrasie Cullen

My secret room would be one of those rain rooms they have at fancy spas that simulate a thunderstorm. It would have real plants growing and use forced perspective to look bigger than it is, and maybe have a mechanically rocking rowboat in the middle that you could lie in and pretend to be drifting out to sea in the rain. The reason it’s secret is because it has a live tesla coil for lightning a la Maelstrom which is probably against some safety regulations

Louis Z

A character directly saying “Marines” is perhaps a subtle clue about which branch of the military he’s in 🤔. Needless to say the only thing that shocks me more than the revelation of Jenny’s fondness for plush forests is the revelation that Jenny has never been in the military. If you want to see a very funny movie about the shenanigans that would ensue if she were to enlist watch Private Benjamin!

Marcus Merrell

My secret room: Full Tiki bar, with lighting effects, a starfield sky that animates twinkling, and fish tanks behind portholes.

Megan Sharp

I would have a room with a giant round bed in the middle, it would be sunk in the floor and covered in pillows and plushies. It would have a canopy covering the bed and the ceiling would be painted to look like the night sky with little twinkling stars. The walls would be covered in tapestry. I would use it as a secret nap room, nothing else, just naps

VermiciousKnid

My secret room is a rain room. Sprinklers on the ceiling, metal grating with drains on the floor. I flip a switch and thunder and lightning sounds play from hidden speakers while I enjoy a cool shower , I day dream about this on hot summer days.

Blair Johnson

My secret room would be a collection of scale replicas of video game things. I’m not talking about the giant Lego kits (even tho those are cool) I’m talking about life sized models of ships, cars, fantasy swords, and even the characters. Specifically, I would love to have the life sized model of Link from the Legend of Zelda they had traveling around for the release of Tears of the Kingdom. All of these thing would be arranged like a museum but I could obviously sit in the vehicles and take the swords off the wall whenever I want.

Arrant

if I were mega ultra rich, I would have a large greenhouse, and that greenhouse would be a full on tropical rainforest that’s climate controlled, has all the appropriate trees and plants, is kept at the correct humidity, and has a sprinkler system set up at the top to rain at the appropriate times while also ambient rainforest sounds get played by a loud speaker on a constant loop. The secret room would be a a safari cabin inside the rainforest but impossible to see from the outside. Think the Tarzan treehouse at Disneyland but more livable and on the ground. This cabin would be the secret rainforest “study.” A place to get away from regular civilization and pretend like I’m out in the Amazon without the threat of snakes and animals

lydinair

my secret room would absolutely be a spooky haunted room. very haunted mansion-esque. complete with secret doors and entrances...

fivelgoesnuts

Secret room would be a miniatures landscape, assembled on a huge table in the center like a train set. but it would be all creepy haunted house (giant, with each room all decked out in creepy dilapidated style ala Grey Gardens) and like a spooky bog and neighboring creepy village with like monster characters (vampires, witch, zombies). Basically like Halloween tiny town? I actually think this would be the least creepy because it’s already inherantly spooky which would just go with the vibe of a secret room!

Jey

You just explained the KH franchise better than both the fandom and the creators.

fivelgoesnuts

Oh no! That’s the scariest one yet

bug

I feel like I’ve got loads of ideas slash blue sky plans for Mostly secret rooms, but if it has to be secret from everyone including my live in girlfriend? I’d have a room somehow themed to a beach in Australia, so that I’d have a warm sunny place to hang out in the bleak winter and a cold space to take a break from the summer heat and maybe use as cold storage :)

Magicalbunbun

My secret room would be full of plushies of anthro animal characters

Matt Calazans

No one enters my E.T. ride secret room!

Kavi Montanaro

My main problem with Runaway Bride is that the editor cranks the color saturation like they never realized they had a knob for that before

T. Fazekas

Worse RomCom couple. Jenny and Guy That Likes Traditional-Sized Plushes I bet you just love that Mr Darcy and your sentimental heart beats wildly wondering if he’ll end up with what’s her name. (Sorry couldn’t help it)

genevieve but cooler

oh man if i'm a non creepy basketball player i've got a packed schedule and a lot of friends which is why i need my secret gift-wrapping room. it has all the crafty supplies necessary to custom wrap delightful gifts as well as a robust stock of gift options for when i just don't have the time to shop. because of masculine norms and expectations all the gifts are assumed to be the doings of my personal assistant but i have a deep secret love of gift giving

Mike Metzler

I think the only good reason to have a secret room would be a secret laboratory, like Victor von Frankenstein or Dexter's Laboratory, which no one can see because the genius of your work is universally misunderstood. Ideally though the entrance to the lab should only be accessible through a secret door activated by the proper book being pulled from a bookcase rather than just a locked door that you tell everyone is off limits.

mango

my secret room would definitely be a private theater a la 18th century french royalty. i pay actors to put on elaborate performances purely for my enjoyment (and make them sign strict NDAs of course because the room is a SECRET)

David A Behlman

I adore how each mention the indoor forest gets more and more details and they all are so perfectly peak. My secret room would be a salt water aquarium that’s also a swimming pool. I’ve thought about this a lot and really the entire house would need to built around it. Ideally it wouldn’t be secret so I’m just leveraging the thought experiment to mention this idea. I also love inside-outside spaces, so maybe one where it’s always snowing?

Willsun

Secret room: Replica of Bag End aka Bilbo and Frodo's hobbit house in The Lord of the Rings, complete with life-size Samwise Gamgee plush hiding underneath the window so I can bop him with my wizard staff and drag him out like Gandalf and yell "CONFOUND IT ALL SAMWISE GAMGEE HAVE YOU BEEN EAVESDROPPING??"

Markus D

I know what you mean by the guy in Purple Hearts looking "English". He has this same kind of... softer, rounder features that I feel is more common in if not English men, at least English movie stars. One reason I didn't believe Eddie Redmayne as Marius in Les Misérables was actually because "I think he looks too English".

Willsun

There's an account on Instagram that's fun to follow because they're slowly building their own large greenhouse with accurate flora and fauna like a rainforest. It's "a.life.exotic" if you want to live vicariously through them.

Megan Wood

secret room would I think just be my 15 year old bedroom just recreated exactly- every embarrassing poster exactly in place, so I could just go down there, listen to one direction and be totally free from cringe

John Thomas

I could see myself having a secret Titanic room (about the actual ship, not the movie). Which is probably more nerdy than creepy, although still somewhat weird. Also, I kept picturing Buffalo Bill when thinking of someone with a secret room. I wonder how it would've altered audiences perception of him had he been framed as a "normal" guy up until his encounter with Clarice, instead of us already knowing he was a psycho...

Girafarig

My secret room would be filled with every single sylvanian family and sylvanian family house and building and decoration. Set up as a giant diorama.

Arrant

I’ll definitely give it a look. Like a decade ago there was a blog post about someone who also built an accurate rainforest in their backyard greenhouse and even created a guide for it since they lived in a colder climate

Buddy Crotty

I've lived in San Diego (home of US Marine boot camp and Navy SEAL training) my whole life and not dating Marines is kind of the default type here.....but it is so oddly specific that will only be relatable in a couple places in the country, possibly the world, lol.

Willsun

I also want to say that a lot of Asian families suffer from Paris syndrome because decades of pastry and snack marketing really played up this fanciful and idyllic imagery of what cafés and bakeries look like over there, and they're crestfallen when they discover a lot of Parisians are rude to tourists and no one likes to pick up their dog poop on the streets there.

Smallpotato

My secret room would just be the Living with the Land ride except the boat is a comfortable lounge for me to nap on

Markus D

As someone who pretty much never watches romcoms, the role I most remember Hugh Grant for is when he played the initial love interest in Maurice. That's a really great gay movie. More people should watch it. It's a solid tear-down of how class systems make you an asshole and discourage you from being your true self. Also, older and historical gay movie that's not a tragedy? Yes please.

Terence Digan

My secret room: I’m the kind of person who would build this massive mystery around having a secret room and then, all it really is is just a single room with a bucket of cheese puffs on a plinth and a single poster of the first random celebrity that came to my mind while shopping for the cheese puffs. And then I’d tell people I don’t really come into the secret room often.

Holly Lau

I definitely remember You’ve Got Mail! I loved that movie and watched it all the time. It’s so cozy.

Luis

ngl I've never seen any of these movies but the way Jenny described The Prince & Me and that last Netflix one make me really want to see them lol. Anyway my secret room would be the Squishmallows human claw machine nothing creepy about that :D

L G

My secret room would be an old, edwardian looking parlor filled with a doll collection, hundreds of them, I’m talking everything from vintage Barbies, to American Girls, to BJDs, to bisque dolls, plus accessories and playsets. The centerpiece would be a huge, beautiful, handmade dollhouse built by me full of miniatures and decorations.

RichterCa

Jenny, when you added the ADR to the Army-guy movie, about Cassie's career being ended by the guy admitting to scamming the Army, you should have added in shots of you on a jog resting at an overpass, or shots where we couldn't see your mouth moving.

Markus D

It also proposes the better solution of a plot like "The Prince and Me"—Have the person in power learn that that status isn't worth it, and instead they want to live a life more in line with their lower-class lover. Of course, that prince sounds like a stone-cold dumbass with no personal motivations, so I can imagine that he would have no way of supporting himself if he wasn't royalty.

Ian

If anyone enjoys You've Got Mail it's a sort of remake of The Shop Around the Corner! 1940s rom com about pen pals

Michael Apgar

My secret room is unfortunately very creepy because it is... an Olive Garden. Soda fountain, a full fridge stocked with salads and those takeaway meals that come with heating instructions. A tiny kitchen in the corner and an Olive Garden style dining room. It would be a secret because I know that Olive Garden is not very good, but I love it anyway and I never get to eat it because my its too embarrassing to try to convince other grown adults that we should go to Olive Garden. I don't even love the decor but it somehow seems weirder to do this and not fully commit though so I'd have to go full tilt.

Thomas Degroat

I thought she was a professional bridesmaid. Like she was hired by the brides to make sure all the bridesmaid/maid-of-honor stuff got done. Am I mistaken?

Zhed

I've become fixated on the tiny green rectangular thing to the right of the frame. It's got, like, sunglasses on? What the heck is that thing?

Markus D

I don't know if it's a plush or something, but it's definitely the Pokémon Charjabug.

Zhed

Ah! I didn't know about this pokemon. Thanks!

Li Speaks

my secret room would be a perfect recreation of lain's computer-ified bedroom from serial experiments lain. but the computer at the center of it all would just a normal desktop computer with zero unusual or advanced capabilities

Scott DePouw

My secret room would be a replica of my bedroom from my childhood.

Totesnotasheep

Omg they did the secret room thing on the show Psych!! Freddie Prinze Jr.'s character was a nerd in high school who ends up a jock with a hot wife, and he has a secret room in his office. I think it ends up being ok because she's also a nerd, but it stuck with me cuz that's so creepy!!! I don't think she even knew about the room!!!

Madeleine G

My secret room would be a replica Build-a-Bear workshop from before their minimalist redesign. I would just occasionally emerge from the mystery door with a fully-dressed (and recently fluff-bathed) plush that no one had seen before. Where did she get that snow leopard with the cool bubble shirt, bedazzled sunglasses, and official WWF medallion (wow!)? Has she always had that monkey in the marabou-trimmed pop star outfit and PRINCESS t-shirt? Why does it sound like she’s always hopping up and down on one foot in there?

nlinzer

Absolutely a stuffed animal room. All in easy snuggle range

Magistrissa

The best moment for me is that when Jenny was describing the basketball player's secret room, my first thought was Bluebeard, and immediately Jenny said she'd be like Bluebeard's wife, compelled to find out what's inside.

Stephanie Cumings

You’ve Got Mail is a classic! I feel like it’s very well remembered but maybe that’s just what my internet bubble is telling me 😂

Jet Puff

Some people have those stuff animal nets in the corner of their rooms and they can turn into spider nests. Sorry for the new fear but if you ever get to make a secret room this could save your life.

Carolimes

When I saw the title and description of the video, my first thought was "Aw man, she's gonna drag You've Got Mail?" As someone who randomly says "That caviar is a *garnish*!" as a complaint, I'm glad I was wrong. 😂

Siobhan is On

Omg can't believe the Purple Hearts lead wearing her hair inside her sweaters the whole movie never came up lol

jamezilla

No you don't. There are plenty of decent, even liberal people in the military.

Siobhan is On

My secret room would be a lavish decked out sun porch for my bunnies. I would have a herd (all spayed ofc) with hutches everywhere, tiny fake picket fences in front of them and fake minature wooden furniture (for them to chew to their hearts' content). There would be large litterboxes in every corner and a big bale of hay in the middle, with plenty of room to binky around on real grass. And naturally in rich secret room fashion, it would be at the top of a spiral staircase in my tower room.

Miranda Lewis

secret room where everything is scaled super large so I can run around like a mouse. Would have to be a really big room

Lindsey

I shall be the San Diego correspondent in regard to the discussion of Purple Hearts. San Diego county has a pretty large military population due to having a Navy base, Marine Corps air station, and Camp Pendleton, a Marine Corps base right by Oceanside, where the movie is set. As such, it is completely normal to have a “no soldier” dating policy here, especially if you live in one of the San Diego areas near a military base. And yes, you are completely correct that many people in the military get married primarily for the benefits. I’ve heard first hand about how “not being married in the military sucks.” Purple Hearts is such a strange and bad movie but it’s not wrong about the strong military presence in San Diego

MW

Very boring I think but my secret room I would like to be a ferret room with 2-4 pet ferrets. Secret from my housemates because they are 3 cats and a dog all of whom would eat the ferrets, and secret from my friends and family because I keep saying I won't get any more animals

MW

Also, my rom com couple I cannot root for is 50 first dates. Maybe this is defying Jenny's principle of accept the premise but to me the ending is a horror movie for Drew Barrymore's character

Markus D

I think my ideal secret room would be like a big aquarium. I really love being in those aquariums where it's all dark except for in the tanks. It would be really relaxing.

OctopusGrift

Nice try but you won't be getting the contents of my secret room.

zozo's bizarre adventure

I considered having my secret room be a fun little plushie habitat for all my stuffed animals, but I would feel too bad leaving them alone in there. I think my secret room would probably be a craft room, made 100000000x creepier by the fact that I’ve been learning how to make custom dolls which are insanely creepy to have lying around your house

Yana

I only ever see 65% of any rom com because my cringe threshold is so low

worm

my secret room is a jellyfish aquarium, I feel like there's no way that'd be weird

Austin P. Smith

My secret room would have a model of a city, where the skyscrapers are like chest height and the roads are just wide enough to walk on. Like a Godzilla movie set but no cameras or equipment.

Captain Langosta AKA The Yellow Dart AKA Kyle

I had a moment of panic as Jenny started to describe the plot of "Return to Me" (which I knew nothing about) by saying the man's wife 1.) works with gorillas at a zoo and 2.) dies in a car accident. I was very worried the plot was going to be that her soul returns in one of the gorillas and the man falls in love with a gorilla and there is a movie out there about a human/gorilla romance not directed by Peter Jackson. I cannot tell you how relieved I was to hear about the heart transplant (into another human whom I assume is not a gorilla). Also, my secret room would be a Gundam cockpit so I could pilot my house.

Z The Cat

Why the heck is it weird for adults to like Olive Garden? haha like I've heard people make fun of it as a location for a date, but I didn't know it was that embarrassing to just go there with friends. Also, it's still my go-to location for dates Lol I don't wanna date an Olive Garden hater

carly rage epson

ummm I would recreate Fox Books in my secret room filled with screen-used fake merch but I wouldn't know anything about the books in there because I'm a corporate megastore hack

Stephen

My secret room would be an interior replica of a late 19th century private railroad carriage with hidden speakers to play ambient train sounds and HD screens behind the windows to show passing scenery. Come to think of it, a rich person wanting to LARP as a robber baron would probably be creepier if they did NOT keep it a secret.

Lou Yang

Every time Jenny talks about her plush indoor forest room I'm haunted by memories of Krtek ve městě (Little Mole in the City), a 1980s Czech children's show about a little mole and his friends who get displaced due to deforestation and the big City Man rebuilds them a plush indoor forest as compensation and they hate it. Timestamped at the beginning of the room build, for more realism: https://youtu.be/D6u8MZti8FU?feature=shared&t=717

Smurfette

2 weeks notice is a top 2 romcom for me. I would say it's my pet romcom but that's actually Monte Carlo starring Selena Gomez and Leighton Meester. It is funny to notice how cheating is kind of a prevelant plot point in romcoms. I recommend the romcom 'the baxter' which coins a term (baxter) for the guy that the girl leaves to be with the love interest. It's a solid romcom thats also very aware of the tropes of romcoms. And the supporting cast is pretty great for laughs (Paul rudd, Elizabeth banks, and also a brief appearance of peter dinklage hilariously playing a gay wedding planner!). My secret room would either be a sick vinyl and cd collection or a cat grooming space :)

Emily Durkee

I had to stop the video to watch you've got mail

October :3

With all respect, your indoor forest idea is so weird and offputting to me 😅. Like I'm not even an outdoorsy person but like... whats wrong with real forests? The idea of having this plasticy sanitised version of nature, that just smells like rubber and the foam would get scuffed up and stained... thats like a squid-game-esque surreal horror environment to me. Lowkey sideeying you for dreaming about this instead of just going outside ngl 🤣

Scott Carter

My secret room would be a to-scale recreation of Bomb-omb battlefield from Super Mario 64.

Ontario Traffic Man

We get the "Maid of Honor" part of the pun, the question is what the second part is supposed to be. The past tense of Make? What does that have to do with anything?

Bullseye

Would you have a Godzilla costume to go with it?

Bullseye

"you are completely correct that many people in the military get married primarily for the benefits" It's super weird to me that Jenny knows that but also thinks the Navy is part of the Army.

John Williams

This was so much fun! I want more of Jenny’s thoughts on more Romcoms. How about a selection of some of the more memorable Hallmark movies.

Elena Shuvaeva

I like (by which I mean I hate) that the military guy saying let's go kill some Ayrabs! is characterized as just "problematic" by the annoying horrible lib character bc it's implying the whole group of Ayrabs should be killed (rather than just some who deserve it). And that is just a horrible downer for everyone's mood to imply this sentiment is slightly problematic.

Audrey

What do people think about the decoy bride?

Stephanie Oehmen

i remember you got mail. if he wasn't tom hanks i would hate him lol

Lauren N

My secret room would just be filled roof to floor with unfinished projects that I swear I'll complete one day but I'm also embarrassed that I even started them and thus they are a secret. You would not be able to walk in, it's more a swim through scenario. Cross your fingers there's no knitting needles or scissors nearby but the papercuts are inevitable.

MaxMin

If Jenny ever makes the Apple Pie tree 1 mil subs video, my guess is it's in the indoor forest she describes

Bullseye

A picture of Jenny in her porg costume.

Laura Elizabeth

That army movie is even funnier knowing most soldiers are actually backend ops gamer nerds or anime weebs haha

Bullseye

Would this be an accurately sized Bag End, or scaled up so you can fit?

Ash Gabrielle

Crazy watching this on my 20th anniversary. Especially with some of Jenny's comments, since my wife and I started dating in high school, and we started dating with my now-wife cheating on her physically abusive girlfriend with me. Pretty wild! (Not saying Jenny is WRONG about anything she says in her disclaimers, those are both definitely bad signs for a relationship's longevity--I just thought it was a weird/funny coincidence) Also, everyone always is so harsh on 27 Dresses. I actually think it's a perfectly fine romantic comedy, personally, but I am a very sappy person and love rom coms, so maybe I just have more TRULY awful ones I've seen to compare it to than a lot of folks do (except Jenny, who appears to have a vast library of godawful movies she's seen).

Captain Langosta AKA The Yellow Dart AKA Kyle

Yeah, hearing Jenny recount her horrible inflight movie experience made me flash back to a Manila-to-LAX flight where the only two options were Will Smith's Hitch and Vin Diesel's The Pacifier.

Ontario Traffic Man

I know someone whose house actually has two secret rooms. One is behind a mirror in a closet where if you push on the floor length mirror it pops open and you can walk into the secret room, which is a saferoom I guess. As in it's empty apart from a safe. Another one is at the back of a different closet where you open a panel and there's another closet bigger than the first closet. But they don't use the secret closet because the decoy closet was already a normal closet size Actually it's just a weird house overall, the only way directly into the garage from the house is through the closet in one of the bedrooms. I guess the original owner was just really into closets idk

Thom Kitimat

I actually had part of my bedroom set up as a Sylvanian village till 2019, at which point I was 30. I only don't now because I needed the space for various animal figures I've bought in different countries.

Madeleine

This is why these Patreon comments are my favorite social media platform

Madeleine

I like how squishy it is

Bullseye

I want to see that movie, and I want it to be a musical.

Willsun

I am tempted to bump my head like Gandalf in a Hobbit-sized house, but I would have to make it human-sized to enjoy it.

Willsun

I hope you hire someone to be the racing Koopa Troopa.

Willsun

I would assume you have a religion/cult that involves getting stung as a rite of passage a la the Bob's Burgers episode involving "Aquaticism."

Kiki

The army guy thing had me cackling lol. Why would he say that about her butt. Why would he say that about pronouns. This is insane lmao. I really did not like Julia Roberts’s character in Notting Hill, which is sad bc I love Julia Roberts. She felt really mean and I was so confused as to why Hugh Grant’s character would want to hang out with her. But I do see how the story you spun could happen lolol. If you want to watch a truly terrible rom-com, watch Easy Virtue starring Jessica Biel. It’s based on a play, but it’s so baffling bad. Does upset the rom-com formula by *spoiler* having the main character run away with her husband’s dad

VeggieBrah

The room contains the Godzilla suit. That is all.

Thom Kitimat

No matter how effectively you think you've hidden it, one day you'll come in and there'll just be a cat sleeping in it, which will simultaneously be under your feet.

Madeleine

My secret room would be a dark ride that takes you through a sunken city, and then you arrive at a three-story ghost ship. Then you get off the boat, which is one of the things my secret room will do that Disney didn't — in Pirates of the Caribbean, you can't go run around and explore, but in my secret room, you're going to get off the boat and you're going to go explore three decks of a haunted ghost ship. Then you get back in the boat, and the boat takes you through haunted pirate caves, and then you see a giant, animatronic sea serpent.

Thom Kitimat

When you think about it, the idea of Rust from True Detective season 1 as a romantic lead is...erm, not convincing, especially if on the first date he starts talking about time being a flat circle.

Brian Danger Hicks

I suspect you're putting more thought into the title of Made of Honor than the people who came up with the title did.

Samuel Roberts

Your inability to differentiate between branches of the military is a) an extremely funny bit I’m jealous of, and 2) totally justified given that in that clip they turn out to be marines, by far the most confusing of the branches.

Ash Gabrielle

I've been wondering if that was still going to be a thing!

DiscoDame

I love You've Got Mail. I redrew the "Shop Around The Corner" sign and printed a copy for my wall.

Jane Mahoney

I don't know anything about Snorri but I find his design so charming that I spent half this video just staring at him on that blue thing next to you like ":D"

Thom Kitimat

I remember the one time I've been to the US, coming back the system was set up so the whole set of films couldn't restart till the longest film had finished. As a result, combined with my fairly severe fear of flying meaning I couldn't sleep and needed distractions, I watched the last twenty minute of The Boat That Rocked at least 2-3 times. That was September 2009 and I have not been on a plane since.

A Tsuboi

My secret room would low-key be the portals to different holidays from The Nightmare Before Christmas .

Ol' Willy B

For Purple Hearts, I'm pretty sure that you don't have to be "in love" to get married. Like, there's no legal requirement at all around how "real" the marriage is... It's just a legal contract. Like, they could live in different houses and never see each other and the marriage is still legally valid. I don't know why they're so worried about it lol

Thom Kitimat

My house actually has a secret room, which is sufficiently secret that no one has been it since the early 2000s. Namely, we have an attic, only accessible by a fairly tenuous ladder that has to be positioned right above the stairs, onto which it might very well decide to fall. Between this and my parents' age/my desire not to fall into the trap the ladder spirit set all those years ago, no one has been up there since about 2001. We think it may contain squirrels, or possibly things that have evolved from squirrels. I can see into it through the hole in my bedroom ceiling I can see from my bed, and I am awaiting the day I look up and something looks back.

KT

Purple Hearts is so nightmarish; no character was written to be capable of empathy

Krolmeister Sisters

My secret room: A fiber art studio with equipment for dying fiber and spinning it, but it's fashioned to look like an old alchemy lab.

Cat Fallon

LOVE the frilly frocks plush, i had her and her little house when i was a kid!

Kiki

oh and my secret room is a greenhouse and the reason it’s a secret is because I’m not that good at taking care of plants and I would be embarrassed to show people my dying plants that I can’t even save with my basketball money

Adamanus

Oh, he's the guy who plays the quarterback in Bottoms. Yeah, I see it.

Rhiannon Held

My secret room: wrap-around, multi-level Playmobil dioramas with all the fantasy sets. Maybe the Old West too. Oh, and dinosaurs! Basically, all the best sets and not the ones that are just sports cars or whatever.

Rey

IM SO HAPPY SOMEONE ELSE LOVES YOUVE GOT MAIL!!!!!! You've got Mail was always so special to my family - it was the movie my mom saw almost every day when she was pregnant, I watched it almost every other day growing up, I can practically quote it verbatim and im so happy someone else knows about it that makes me so happy!!!!!!!! :))))))))

nezkah

Gonna start calling all my dust-induced sneezing fits 'Meg Ryan's Revenge' from now on, thanks Jenny!

Callum Phillpott

Just saying, the last person I heard about having a secret room that they didn’t want their partner to see was Bluebeard.

snaids

My secret room would just be an extended version of my actual room, so just like mountains of sanrio plushies, dolls and yaoi.

Alex Novak(they/them) 🏳️‍🌈🏳️‍⚧️🇨🇿

The one about the playboy prince running away to Wisconsin sent me into orbit as someone who was born and raised in Wisconsin. Why did the writers think “hmm a place where girls do risqué things” and thought of Wisconsin of all places is just very funny to me

Tabby

I love Two Weeks' Notice, because it takes all that Hugh Grant quippy smarminess and makes it work for the character. Lucy's entire job is to manage all of his nonsense and find the sincerity in it, while also having her own nonsense that he needs to sift through. Also I am a complete sucker for that little moment where they're having lunch together and silently trading the bits of food they don't like; that alone sold me on their level of comfort and familiarity with each other.

Alice Lastname

Sean Baker totally took inspiration from The Prince and I when writing Mark Eydelshteyn's character from Anora.

M

The secret room discussion unlocked a memory of my wife telling me about how when her family moved into her childhood home and started fixing it up, her father deliberately put in secret doors in the backs of closets to make i think two separate secret rooms? I remember being completely bamboozled by this and her just being like "yeah it was kinda weird. Whatever." And not understanding why I was so interested in what were inside the rooms or why her father would single handedly diy two plaster walls in his house while also raising two small children and working multiple jobs. Apparently everyone else knew about the doors and used those rooms like they were normal rooms but I am still a little bit shocked by this and it's been ten years. Also, since then her family have lived in like four large houses and never has he built another secret room. I guess two was enough. Or maybe I'm just not let in on the secret....

scoves

I grew up watching “you’ve got mail” sooooo many times with my mom that I also feel like its importance/notoriety is overly inflated in my minds eye too. also, if your nora ephron hat is the “a film by nora ephron” super yaki one, I have the sweatshirt version. s-tier merch

Adventuress

Oh gosh I HATED "How to lose a guy in 10 days" because the movie tries to give the lady the moral high ground because the guy made a bet about dating someone, yet she purposefully sabotaged and PUBLISHED what she'd done at his expense! No one gets a pass in that horrible, horrible story

Lauren

finally representation for "made of honour" haters. I despise that movie. And I married my male best friend!

Stranger Kate

With Purple Hearts, it seems like she probably turns into a pop star because becoming a big commercial success is one of the ways the left gains any respect from the right, because you are valid if you can make money. Which is hilarious that the sham marriage is still a plot point after her monetary success when it's like, if their marriage was a sham for money still, then why didn't she just grab that bag and get gone after achieving stardom? And ALSO, how many army marriages would survive a formal sham investigation?? Kinda sounds like the plot of Gone Girl, tbh. Like, no, technically you didn't kill your wife, technically your marriage isn't a sham, but you're such a crap husband, we believe you could've and it could be!

Bryce Zubriski

If you dislike Matthew McConaughey as a romantic lead and hate the reformed rake trope you should check out Ghosts of Girlfriends Past. It’s a mess.

Julian Wren

Why did he make the same noise as the dinosaur 😂

Natalie

The thing that makes the wedding planner work is it being framed from her pov. The initial attraction when she thinks he's single. The fighting it every step of the way after she finds out he's not. She said I will not be cheating and you need to get yourself together.

MillieWays42

I also want the plush forest, I am so 100% sold on that; but my secret room would be an indoor forest but also with an integrated real large swimming pool, and there would be a hidden invisible closet where I keep my elf ears and mermaid tails and whimsical time period agnostic fantasy clothes

Joe McClory

First thing I thought of for secret room, because I was still watching your video was black market animatronics, the center piece being buzzy. But honestly it would probably be a room of lego sets that I love building but would feel childish having displayed, like I would feel embarrassed that I was wasting my time on that

SamaLamaDama

"You've Got Mail" was my comfort movie, I've seen it so many times. Problematic fave. ;)

Miles Nerenberg

My secret room would be a karaoke room with a full stage complete with extending catwalk and a mini arena setup, like maybe only about 30-40 seats but still in multiple tiers, fully operational lighting, a concession stand and merch booth, etc.

Jenny Nicholson

For legal purposes we actually have no idea which kinds of sports players could have buzzy

Alice Lastname

The doorway to my secret room will be small enough that you have to crawl in on all fours. When you enter, what you'll find is a Smithsonian museum-esque exhibit of artifacts, replicas, and creatures that are unrecognizable from any of the kind you'll ever see in real life. A lot of what you read on the placards will be devoid of any context and will leave you with an ominous feeling. Once you already feel like you're in a dream and think it's time for you to leave, you notice another small doorway in the righthand corner of the room. Upon crawling into this new doorway, you find yourself facing a tall, ornate crystal with a light bright enough to light the entire room. Engraved on the crystal will be the words, "You can always light up the dark!"

Alex S

My secret room would be empty except for a 500 gallon aquarium with a single aquatic snail living in it. No other fish, barely any rocks and plants and shit, just an aquarium snail.

Sasha Belmont

i think my secret room would be some kind of like... basement cafe set-up. a cute table or two, a full espresso bar, maybe some fake windows with screens emulating "rainy day city street views" or something. i really enjoyed being a barista for a bit and wish i could have a nice espresso machine to play with, so in the spirit of the prompt, may as well go all out with it.

Lunar-glitch

i would have a full Ultraman style city miniature to stomp and make kaiju noises in when I'm stressed. I dunno if i'd be able to keep it secret though. I'd probably get the local youth to playfight in it and record it and upload it to youtube anonymously and everybody would be wondering where this mysterious handmade tokusatsu comes from....

Axel HV

My secret room would be just a normal room full of pictures of other rooms...other secret rooms. And shelves full of VHS tapes and DVDs. And if you play them in the sole flat screen in the middle of the room, it would be footage of other rooms. Other secret rooms. Every single secret room ever build. And NO, you would never knew or figure out how I came into posession of that footage or the pictures on the wall. How I entered every single secret room in the world. It's my secret.

Louis Z

Only basketball players would be tall enough to remove him from his pedestal without a ladder

Garrett Gilchrist

Jenny hasn't seen Doctor Who, in previous video. Jenny reviews The Runaway Bride, in this video. The irony. I've always wanted to see deleted scenes from You've Got Mail. They shot a lot of stuff, including Meg getting sexually harassed by Michael Palin. Some reviewer stated that Tom Hanks and Meg Ryan's current romantic partners were "easily sloughed off" here, like a layer of dead snake skin. That's always stuck with me.

David Kirk

My secret room would be like Barbra Streisands mall but the shops would be a 1990s uk Woolworths with a pick and mix and lots of c d singles, an old fashioned model shop selling air fix models of planes and ships and a 1960s Greenwich village coffee shop with fake unfiltered cigarette smell.

Justin Ray

Just go full Tammy and the T-Rex 🦖

Justin Ray

Secret room: my own pizza restaurant with a working replica of the Rockafire Explosion

Shawn (AKA ShabeRaven)

My secret room is LEGO. What makes it even creepier is elsewhere in the mansion I have a non secret LEGO room. What makes the LEGO in the secret room so secret? I can't tell you, it's a secret.

David Kirk

I always have problems with you got mail. It’s loosely based on the 1940 movie The Shop Around The Corner. But in that they are co workers at the same shop who clash heads but are sending each other letters on the back of a classified ad. It’s a lot more about the shop that’s filled with other characters and story arcs than it is about the letters. Whereas I think you got mail is too much about the email and not enough about the shops. It would be truly devastating to Meg Ryan that book shop shutting. But she kind of shrugs it off.

Markus D

It reminds me of the kind of casual racism that I see occasionally from my some of my (white) family, which essentially boils down to "it's okay to tell an offensive joke because the people it would offend aren't hearing me say it".

Markus D

I said something like this the first time she mentioned the idea in a different video. I think that the kind of coziness and how you can't get hurt are part of it. But I definitely feel the same in that my environmentalist and naturalist heart can't take it and I'd rather just be in a real forest.

Markus D

Lol, that threw me off too. I'm guessing she's seen articles about "sham military marriages" or something.

Eric MacMillan

R.I.P L. J. Smith :( Plush Chao garden secret room. While I think the SA2 garden is cooler, the SA1 garden is more practical to make into a secret room.

Jes

why are you twirling, meg ryan? stop your twirling! >:(

Garrett Gilchrist

I would have a room in the west wing, a private study with an enchanted mirror and a single enchanted rose, to which my fate is bound. Also a complete DVD set of "The West Wing."

Garrett Gilchrist

"Enchanted" is the rare romcom that has a sequel so we actually know how that worked out. Also, last year I was involved in editing an extended version of the movie featuring Idina Menzel's cut song.

Simon Rodriguez

I was listening to this with my eyes closed and thought the drug dealer character at 1:04:42 was Jensen Ackles

Ruth Jepson

My secret room would just be a windowless fully padded room with a shit tonne of blankets and pillows where I can just lay down and relax and read and sleep. And the lights are adjustable from full brightness to complete, true darkness. Yes, I want a comic book asylum room. Yes I know how that sounds. Yes I still really want one x

PJ

27 dresses and Run Away Bride could be combined into a great movie about a woman who only loves weddings and runs at the alter. Can have a whole montage of her doing different styles of weddings all to collect wedding dresses like Thanos collecting infinity stones

Benjamin A.

I just want to recommend The Baxter, a great twist on the Groom left at the alter trope with a wonderful cast. Quirky and sweet.

Aramis Calcutt

I believe you have mentioned the plush forest fantasy before. It sounds familiar anyway.

Alice Parkin

Thanks for the ramble, Jenny!! You unearthed a memory of being made to watch Kate and Leopold by friends at uni and finding it completely baffling basically for the reasons you mention. I'm so torn about my secret room but I feel like it would end up being a perfect 1:1 replica of some part of Minas Tirith (from the Jackson films) but with, like, a big area for building Lego. And that combo DOES kind of sound oddly creepy even before you make it secret. Someone opens the door and I'm just sat there on the Steward's throne with a Lego AT-AT on my lap.

S G Matthews

When I was a kid, this was my plan for a secret room: its actually in the house next door, which I also own, but you can only get to it through a tunnel in my house. And you have to swim through the tunnel. And when you emerge from the water, its into a model city that scales well with most toys, but also you can just go full Godzilla if you so choose.

daphne

I want to say my secret room would be some type of animal room, probably a sanctuary for an orangutan family where extreme circumstances somehow makes it ethically fine, like they're sick or disabled and couldn't be rehabilitated to the wild and also they were bullied by the other apes and the zoo or whatever was going to put them down. That way, the fact that it's illegal also warrants it being a secret room. The room is obviously very big and have a hidden outdoors area because it's on a roof. I'm sure this would still be terrifying to Jenny since she doesn

Hannah Gs

Gross, her main platform...

Jambli

When you were talking about Return to Me, I genuinely thought you were gonna say the wife's heart is somehow transplanted into a gorilla and she is reincarnated as the gorilla

Bi Zuko

My secret room would probably be essentially a Godzilla shrine. Merchandise and memorabilia, all the movies, every book & comic, etc. etc. Probably a big TV with surround sound.

Bi Zuko

*Excellent* choice.

Rhiannon Tripp

I’ve seen You’ve Got Mail so many times and I feel like most people who criticise it completely ignore that at the beginning Kathleen is expressing dissatisfaction with her life (‘what is it that I…do exactly?’), and while that doesn’t justify her shop closing it’s not like Joe Fox destroyed her whole life. Also I work in a bookshop and believe that I am Kathleen Kelly so

John Alonzo

Jenny, did you hear, Evermore just got bought by Disney? It's going to be opening soon! What's the date today??

Emily Gelderloos

She has! In one of her earlier vids, I'm just now catching up on her backlog - I don't remember which one tho

Grace Fusco

British artist Florence Welch actually did have a pro US army opening act when I saw her.

haley kaufeldt

I want that pony in the background omg so cute

Kendel Murrant

Return To Me is maybe the only rom com I truly like. 🩷

jerry

lmao the scene from the Army movie was awful, "yeah if my friend wasn't an awful racist psychopath you'd be getting raped by the Taliban RIGHT NOW, checkmate lib." Also I know in my heart they cast a black guy in the dickhead role specifically to deflect accusations of racism.

zach spencer

Double Proxy marriage is legal in Montana for residents and active duty military. As someone who worked in the Montana Vital Records Office for a couple of years I had to enter marriage certificate data into our database and I can confirm that we got dozens/hundreds of marriages per month from usually very young military people who were located halfway around the world from each other. It was hard not to believe that the incentives provided by the military did not play a significant factor when you see a 19 year old in Germany marry a 18 year old in San Diego.

Curwhibble

I had to log in just to comment how much I love Return to Me XD

Lenin Cat

My secret room would be items denoting how much I actually hate basketball but only do so because it makes me enough money to have a secret "I Hate Basketball" room.

Kay W

You're so right. It would be an exercise in futility lol

PamperYamper

My room would be the imaginarium from Community

Lately Fashionable

Return To Me is so special to me! I do love that it's just a boring, uncomplicated, slice-of-life narrative, and the supporting cast gets to shine. I feel like we fall in love with the characters because the people in their lives love them, and we get to see it. It's such s comfort movie.

Bailey Price

my secret room would probably be some kind of sewing/ craft closet which has the potential to be a creepy killer room, but i asked my fiancé and he said he would make his own sensory deprivation float tank room which is might higher serial killer potential imo

carissa

I thought in 27 Dresses she was a for-pay bridesmaid?? Is she not??? That’s so crazy lol!

Louis Z

I heard Disney will replace Dreamfinder and Figment with Eric Idle! Oh wait. I heard Disney will spend a fortune on a Star Wars attraction then turn it into an office building! Oh wait. Disney doesn’t celebrate April Fool’s Day on one particular day. It’s been every day for the last thirty years of their corporate history.

Nani

I was so sure Jenny’s secret room would be a full-on My Little Pony shrine/museum completely staffed and filled with the rarest items and a mini rollercoaster. I guess the foam forest tracks too. My secret room would be painted by that doodle guy that doodles on everything and it would look a lot like his doodled house, except I would include a table and some chairs with a harsh lamp on the side. My own doodled insanity-inducing interrogation room.

Wolfman Jack

You've Got Mail has one of the best insults I've ever heard. "I love Patricia. I love Patricia! Patricia. Makes. Coffee. Nervous."

Jackie

As someone who has lived in both Oahu and San Diego, I too have a no military bf policy lol (I also have cousins in the military that advised me to have this policy so please don’t come for me)

M

Oh, I'm excited to watch this -- I just saw Something Borrowed for the first time, and they're all on my Worst Characters and Worst Couples list

Jack

14:41 Haha I just watched one of those

Nolan McBride

My secret room would either be a Bionicle/Transformers/whatever other action figures I wanted to show off or play with room, or a custom video game space with a giant TV. I would want to copy the blockbuster idea for that

Eileen Nguyen

I always get Made of Honor confused with Sleeping With Other People. I think I saw them each once when they came out and neither stuck with me much. Also I don't think I realized Patrick Dempsey made so many movies, he's got three appearances on this list?

Mac Monkeyhat

My secret room would be filled with wall to wall pictures and fan art of the couple from Purple Hearts

Ezra

she talks about when she’s talking about being a Saw apprentice lol

soph

My mom loves romcoms, so Patrick Dempsey was one of the only actors who's name I knew as a kid. Even now, when I think of "generic hot guy" Patrick Dempsey is the first thing that comes to mind 🤣

Shiny Skunk

Omg I'm loving that Charjabug plushie

Scott Carter

I have a regular rotation of people to race

Jose Luis Casillas

Japan secret room, you can only speak Japanese inside although it's just me talking to myself. Gachapons, claw machines, little toriis, cherry blossoms and red leaves made from paper, 7/11 food of plastic

Amélie Roubert

I expected the Purple Hearts snippets to have those cringe "own the libs" humor, but the whole dinner scene got me so genuinely shell shocked (pun intended) I gasped.

Amélie Roubert

Also, in a very boring fashion, my secret room would be a gamer room with Pokémon plushies, a TV to play the switch, a gaming pc (with also writing softwares) and stuff like that. And for the record, if I was in a relationship with an uber rich basketball player, I would be creeped out to discover that the "super secret forbidden room" is just a gamer room.

Thom Kitimat

Would you eat various foods in a really gross manner a la Denethor?

VermiciousKnid

No, but I'm in the bay area, I will have to check it out, thanks!

Birthe_bird

I guess it's ok if you hide people from the government in there, I'd be like: I get it, that had to be a secret

Kevin

This being released the day after I saw Heart Eyes feels appropriate

Belle Taylor

I feel that an indoor forest room would be like something Jenny could fully realize slowly over time. Like probably not that you could climb satisyingly. But one can build the framework for a plush tree with just 2x4s from Home Depot. And I've seen enough videos where people do upholstery to know that it's mostly done with a staple gun...so like wrap the 2x4s in quilt batting and foam, and then cover them in brown minky fabric using a staple gun...and they sell rugs that look like a moss forest floor! One of my buddies has a real big one in his bedroom. I feel this is an attainable goal, and I just want to mak a whole plan of how to do it. Theres this lady on tiktok that makes fun chandeliers in this same vein, and i'm always like "a cloud chandelier would be perfect for the indoor forest." Some handtools and a dream. Now I want an indoor forest room. My crafting audacity says it can be done.

Sonya

i would keep a secret room dedicated to the hangnails i peel off and dedicated to the process of doing that so i can pick at my fingers in peace.

Belle Taylor

I have a friend who crafts giant foam animals. Like a life-size raptor bursting out of a wall, and stuff like that for his wife's classroom. She's a middle school science teacher. And like he just does it for love of the game in his garage. I feel like plush trees are less technically difficult that a foam raptor. I want a series of videos where Jenny just attempts to make the indoor forest of her dreams.

Wolfman Jack

My secret room would be a murder room. I know, I know, I'm basic. But, like... A nice murder room, ya know? Artisanal. Tasteful.

Oceanic

My secret room would be my secret dinosaur collection (if not for the moral problems of keeping a private collection) so maybe only replicas and molds.

Dean

You’ve Got Mail feels old not just because it’s from the 90’s but also because it’s a remake of like 3 other movies from the 1940’s

Cassidy RC

lol oceanside CA definitely has a high incidence of army guys . my friend moved there and every single person she's met is either army guy or army wife or army worker

Kimberly

It’s hard to choose a secret room— a lot of private room ideas, but what room would I feel needs to be secret? Maybe a giant Calico Critter collection— like a whole world for them.

Scrum Diddely Umptious

My "secret room" would realistically be more of a "panic room" for my "crippling anxiety"... But if I could have anything, I would like a Mary Poppin's bag situation so that as a 30-something in a nightmare economy I can finally have both material posessions and a tidy living space. The dream.

Emily Osler

My secret room would be a Lego room. My Lego studio would be in the house proper, but every time I finished something I'd bring it to the Lego room. I'd aim to make it like my own little Legoland, covered completely with intricate Lego creations. I'd even pump in the soundtrack from Legoland and, if I really have all the time in the world, maybe even build myself a little dakride.

Star Laura

Jenny — I want to reassure you— it is not just you and your family who love You’ve Got Mail! I introduced it to my daughter in her mid teens (she is 23) and we watch it as a family all the time. Big Tom Hanks/Meg Ryan fans!! (I’m only 8min into your video, sorry, but have you seen Joe vs the Volcano ? Very quirky but such a good movie.)

Star Laura

Omg that is the BEST line. I love Patricia. “Ugh where are my tic tacs!”

Shay Olin Parker

Jenny, please make a full video on The Prince and Me

maddo

Rom com cheating is such a pet peeve for me! It’s not ok no matter how lame the current partner is. It’s not romantically gratifying to watch someone cheat rather than dumping their partner

Morgan Nyhan

My secret room would be a Chuck E Cheese. Cute and wholesome until you think of randomly happening upon lifeless animatronics in the a cold and sterile mansions ( i presume as a famous basketball played I'd have the same generically bland but extraordinarily bland mansions most famous people have)

Dean

Motion for Jenny to explore terribly blatantly Right Wing versions of common media genres (comedy, romcom, drama, horror). Bonus if it is hyper Christian propaganda

Dean

My Secret Room: a mechanical bull room where I practice riding a mechanical bull away from prying eyes until I get good enough that I feel confident that I can faultlessly do it in public

Chelle

I refuse to participate in forced Olive Garden hate. This is a based answer.

Jami Creager

“You’ve Got Mail” is an updated version of “The Shop Around the Corner”, a 1940 Jimmy Stewart -Margaret Sullavan rom-com. This is why it feels, as Jenny said, “older than it is”. And, yes, I am fully onboard with Hanks as a Stewart stand-in. It is a compliment to T.H. that you can swap him in for Stewart and hardly notice

Vee Vee

It’s so funny to me that the issue with 27 dresses was her and not the mess they gave her as a male lead 😭

Emily Brown

You should go to the Museum of Jurassic Technology

Jenny Nicholson

All I can think is the writers assume the viewers are pretending it's them in the movie, and are accounting for the fact that many of them might not all be single. Like, "Even if you have a boyfriend, it's not too late for you to live this fantasy. We'll take care of him..."

Rebecca Michelson

also in her video about immersive hotel concepts she talks about liking faux inside forests

Riley

I so agree about legally blonde! Also love how her name is Elle Woods and his is Emmett Forrest. I think stuff like that is cute

codifierbehemoth

I would like to change my answer, my secret room would be a map room, where the floor is a detailed map of the local region my home is in, and there's wall-to-wall shelving with more maps on one side of the room, and then like framed maps and hanging tapestry maps of all sorts of places in the world, and there's a bookshelf that's just a big collection of atlases in there too. I think that would come across as simultaneously whimsical and terrifying, and also i like maps in real life so now i want that unironically.

SourInk

Is the you-tube link still down? I prefer to watch on there

David A Behlman

What if your whole house was secretly built of Lego?! Is that spooky?

Magistrissa

The Littlefoot's Grandpa bit killed me

Dave Ruff

Just waiting for the YT link, because Patreon video refuses to work

Dan Kane

My secret room would be a perfect recreation of the Baily Bugle office from 2001's Spider-Man. Right at the entrance is a closet with a suit, tie, fake mustache and cigar so that I can pretend to be J. Jonah Jameson. Also because this is my fantasy secret room I have Tobey Maguire on retainer to play Peter Parker. He doesn't want to be there but the money is too good to pass up. "Bring me pictures of SPIDER-MAN!" I would scream into the night as my live in girlfriend wonders where I've gone.

Magistrissa

It's funny, because I love Ernst Lubitsch and James Stewart but Shop Around the Corner never quite works for me. I think it's that Margaret Sullivan's character doesn't click- I'm not sure if it's how she's written, or if she's not gelling with Stewart (I think he definitely sells his attraction to her at least) or if it's that she's acting the character as very fluttery and above it all in a way that comes off as annoying to me. Mostly it's her voice being very falsetto and trilly when she's being snide- I'd rather she just bark back like Carole Lombard in To Be or Not to Be or Rosalind Russell in His Girl Friday. There's something very cozy about the setting and some of the side characters that makes me want to see an alternate universe version where all the pieces click. It's the rare movie I'd be down to see remade as a period piece.

Javiera Scarratt

Yeah can confirm a 'no military guys' dating policy is extremely normal if you live in a town near a military base/school, those guys can be fine on their own if you meet them out in the world but en masse they're freaks and should be avoided at all costs

Darsy Smith

Return to Me bugs me because the conflict is she doesn't think anyone should love her because she has the scars on her chest from the surgery (at least that was my prevailing memory of it!!)

irene

I had a mandela effect moment because i used to love legally blonde and have watched it multiple times, and I specifically remembered the ending being empowering because it was about how she didn't need a man and instead it was her friendships with vivian and paulette that were emphasized as the important relationships in her life. I didn't remember "emmett" at all, or their love arc being a part of the movie. I guess it's been a long time since i've watched it and i misremembered the events, but it has an entirely different meaning for me with the ending being different. Maybe my memory changed to the ending i would have preferred...

Eric

Also San Diego has a lot of marines because it's one of the big navy bases. And it looks like the movie is set near there.

Neil Dutton

"Don't make me gun you man! With my gun!! I...have a gun."

Rob Fitzsimmons

Secret library, because it would simultaneously feel like I'm a Cold War spy, a cool rebel punk, *and* a boy wizard with surreptitious access to the restricted section. Second answer, with mostly the same reasoning: pirate radio station studio. Surely I'm not the only one who remembers Radio Free Roscoe (or Pump Up The Jam, I guess). Both of these are good and cool secret rooms to have.

LKB

I see 0% romcoms because my cringe threshold is so low lmao

Rob Fitzsimmons

That's true for anywhere right next to a military base.

Victoria

I know most people hate 27 Dresses but it's My Romcom in the way Jenny says You've Got Mail is for her so it always makes me sad when other people don't like it

Cammie

My pet romcom is Moonstruck. In my mind Loretta and Ronny are gonna make it. :) And my secret room would be a recreation of Arrietty’s bedroom from the Studio Ghibli Borrowers movie! Oversized fake flowers everywhere!

AmWa

my secret room would be a replica of the former Fry's in my neighborhood. it was sci-fi themed and had three old cadillac type cars turned into seating for a faux drive-in theater. there were alien props and dope neon signage. all i want is to go back there and watch a B movie! but i'd share it with others and wouldn't keep it a secret!

Deadbirdkitsch

My favorite classic romcom is While You Were Sleeping, the premise of which is very offputting and bonkers but I just liked Sandra Bullock as a child.

Deadbirdkitsch

My secret room would be a maze-like warren of endless construction like in that episode of Over The Garden Wall. Each new room would be decorated in some over the top style; baroque, dark academia, atomic futurism. The house looks like a normal house from the outside, so you're not even sure exactly where it goes but it does eventually butt into somebody else's house.

Sean Kernan

I was trying to think of something wholesome but it's impossible. My first thought was a room where I have painstakingly recreated my childhood bedroom with every toy and poster and so on in place. But then I thought, if someone found this they would just think, why does this creep have a child's bedroom hidden in the basement that I am told not to go into.

Purple Giraffe

It would be a secret library. Not really a particularly special library with a fireplace and a some really soft reading chairs. Also a spot for my cat to sleep, there would also be a swinging latter à la beauty and the beast. It would be magical and also, I would not tell anyone of its existence. For me its a secret room where its a room that no one knows it exists not a room I tell people exists but they can't go in or know whats in it.

Mady, you know, from TV

Excellent shoutout to Legally Blonde as having a convincing and healthy romantic relationship! I have seen nearly every romcom you discuss, so this was very fun and I appreciate the Watsonian criticsms. My more recent pet romcom is The Lost City. I don't know why I believe in the staying power of this Sandra Bullock / Channing Tatum combo, but by the end of the movie they got me good.

.RAWRfile

I wish Jenny kept listing different kinds of secret rooms, just countless kinds of rooms, and how they'd be scary if they were secret, and it just kept going until it the audio and what was happening on the screen slowly faded out and the video was abruptly over.

.RAWRfile

My secret room would be the promised ghost ship and five part Haunt from Evermore's pitch.

Jackalri

My secret room would be massive replicas of animals(NOT TAXIDERMY,) just like the ones you get in animal crossing. human-sized replicas of animals and cool bugs.

Elijah O M

as somebody who loves 27 dresses I love considering how bizarre the main character and the plot is if you reflect on it at all lmao

Clara

I actually think a secret library would be the least creepy. Like it would be a bit ominous, and very mysterious, but because you know nothing too crazy is happening in a library, you'd probably just figure they were some super secret books, maybe some spells or something

Gavin

Off topic but what Stella Believix doll is that?

RainSnail

As a kid I loved loved swimming and imagined having this flooded mansion with a secret underwater tunnel you could swim through to get to some secret base or other. I would have absolutely drowned.

Birthe_bird

I think my secret room would have like the Tardis Console in there... I wouldnt know what to do with it but just embarrassingly go in there and larp sometimes I guess... by myself

Austin F

my conspiracy theory is that 27 dresses is actually a prequel to runaway bride. a villain origin story.

Cece

I’ve given this a lot of thought, my secret room would be an indoor waterfall/nature area. I’d want a fully functioning waterfall with the ability to heat the water so that you can sit in it like a shower. There would also be real trees and plants surrounding the waterfall. Idk if it would be a secret though, I’d spend any and every free moment in that room.

Jenny Nicholson

She's lovix! And I put gamer headphones from another set on her because they matched

Fifi

Yeah as someone who lives in San Diego, definitely looked like it was set there, and also almost everyone I know has a no military guys rule lol.

Interloper of Puny

I think my secret room would just be a like a perfect bathroom. Shower has a towel heater (is that a thing? it will be), decked out potty that... I dunno, nobody else uses and is really good, cabinets are unobtrusive but roomy... I think that's it.

Ricm

Secret basketball room, just to massively confuse anyone who sneaks in as to why I had to keep it a secret.

Pterranodon

My dorm in college had a towel heater and it was the most magical thing I've ever experienced

Reed

You'll want heated floors. When my wife told me that she was going to have heated floors installed in our bathroom, I thought it was a joke. Nope, they're real, and they're the most amazing thing that I never knew I needed. Also a heated toilet seat. It turns out that extra gentle heat is just a really great feature of many bathroom fixtures. If you're going to dream, dream heated.

Pterranodon

What if Christmas Apron... But more Edit: Wait, I would love to see her talk about the romance movie about the guy who refuses to be alone with a woman unless they were married. No dating, just straight to marriage.

Pterranodon

Yeah, unless it's a fraught situation, I'm never going to root for someone cheating instead of just BREAKING UP. Christmas romcoms are especially bad for that for the "snobby city bf back home" trope.

Emma Bloodworth

Idk if anyone has said this yet, but every time you talk about your forest room I think of Meow Wolf, Convergence Station. It’s not exactly what your looking for, but it has a very elaborate 3 story forest room with trees you can go into. No ball pit or squishy floors though unfortunately.

Kristen

My secret room is a secret broadway room, with a little stage and a kareoke machine set up so I can pretend I am on Broadway. And of course I keep it secret because my fatal flaw is that I am horrendously embarassed about most things I hold dear, as if some cartoon high school bully will tease me if I am discovered, and my husband will leave me, and my kids will think I'm lame (my kids already think I'm lame, tbf)

Spliffy

Just a room full of way too many kittens. With cat trees everywhere, cat shelves and cat beds screwed into all the walls from floor to ceiling. When you open the door, all the kittens turn to look at you, just cute kitten faces from every angle with too-big eyes staring directly into your soul.

minohoonoo

my secret room would be storage for all the hobbies and crafts I've started and abandoned. it's a secret because I'm ashamed of my lack of follow-through, not for scary reasons

Griffin

Ok so I’m going to have to soundproof my secret room but it’d be fun to have a studio do practice singing,music, and other vocal stuff. 😂 I also don’t like working out in front of people so maybe I could squeeze a home gym in there.

Id Ridian

my secret room would be a room designed to look like an environment from the horror video game SOMA (2015). probably with life-sized replicas of the monsters and characters and everything. and obviously a computer on which to play SOMA (you can do nothing else on this computer. it only has SOMA on it). this is the secret room where i play SOMA

ts_babyjane

because im trans if my basketball husband had a secret room id be so pissed like i would be convinced he was cross dressing in there.

Bryan Sutton

I would collect all the props from that AI Willy Wonka experience thing and store them in my secret room

Ellen Kaluza

I fully thought as you explained the plot to Return to Me that you were going to say the gorilla received the wife's heart and I was imagining the scenario where the husband fell in love with a gorilla.

elaina c

I have a collection of furbies. Like different generations and different furby related products like happy meal toys, etc. Right now they’re all on shelves in my room. But historically, this has frightened men that I invite over. So, maybe it actually would make sense to have a secret room that I keep my furbies in. And I could even make little environments for them to live in.

caroline

my secret room will be like the barbie 12 dancing princesses floor and it will be like magical ballet studio garden with a pond I can swim in and and and those cakes that bibble eats in mermaidia and and closet from life in the dream house and everytime I go to it I act all mysterious to where people think I'm some kind of vigilante. but it's just barbie room. idk something like that i guess.

dafna peretz

"Marry Me" with Jlo and Owen Wilson is the worst couple iv'e seen ever. Iv'e seen better chemistry in cartoons.

Анастасія Кохановська

My secret room would be a bunch of fossils and rocks and dried plants and it would have an animatronic scientifically accurate dinosaur. I just realised I'm the old guy from Jurassic World 2

Pterranodon

I feel like the “reformed rake” trope in the modern day suffers bc the only way they know how to translate him to modern day it's just making him a “lovable misogynist”? Films then tries to “both sides” things except the writers are too cowardly to completely condemn the male lead. So there's this stank of “yeah, maybe what he's doing isn't great but also… isn't he kinda cool? Also WOMEN amiright?” Regarding the “no soldiers” I'm guessing it's probably the reason many people have a “no cops” rule. Little to no recourse in cases of DV with an extra danger of backlash from their “friends” should you try to leave or press charges. For the secret room. I was REALLY into the aesthetics of the Secret Garden when I was younger. I like the idea of a secret courtyard right in the center of the house? Forgetting all the logistics of maintaining a garden, I'd have a grand tree peeking over the roof as a bit of intrigue. There's the scent of flowers everywhere, but how? There are no flowers to be seen. I was thinking about multiple secret entrances as well out of the courtyard but I think that's getting too close into creepy The Boy territory.

Pterranodon

I had the exact opposite thought where she would get a gorilla heart transplant and become part gorilla 🤣

a.s.

it's genuinely so beautiful that this is the second time scamming the army for money has come up on jenny's patreon channel

Pterranodon

Real rancid "calling someone racist is worse than being racist" vibes

Aramis Calcutt

I think we have figured out why Jenny hasn’t gone “full furry” yet. It’s because plush forest cultivation is her real interest.

Wren Stryker

My secret room would be wunderkammer of natural specimen collection! A lifetime of collecting bones, shells, terrariums full of healthy fat salamanders.. all in ambient warm light and with windows which look out into the garden. God willing!

Anna Ploegman

Return to Me is a pet fav of mine from when I was a kid because Christian kids are allowed to watch it. It’s boring and also sad and sweet and also I like Bonnie Hunt in it 😂

Leah Riley

I totally though Jenny was going to mention the cheating in Enchanted when it came up - that whole deal soured the movie for me.

Jacob Wismer

I'd argue "no military types" makes sense as a service worker for a business in close proximity to a military base, lol. Lots of dealing with grunts on their off hours.

Roobyfreakinrooo

I unwisely decided to take a shot every time Jenny said "army" and now I'm dead. (But seriously it became such a Sideshow Bob rake gag that it just kept getting funnier and funnier to me)

Tyler Svedin

My secret room would almost certainly be a cozy library full of both books and too many legos. But also… it wouldn’t be fully secret.

Ames Stevens

“Let me show you my secret room,” I say, a twinkle in my eye. You follow, unsure, but your burning curiosity overtakes rational thought. I pull a key from a secret compartment inside my famous basketball player gym shorts. “This is the key to my success,” I say solemnly. You wait with bated breath as I turn the heavy lock. The door slowly swings open, revealing an empty room containing a single basketball with a smiley face drawn on it, Castaway-style. I smile, as it dawns on you that I have scammed the NBA, nay, the world. For the basketball was the true soldier, and I but a sham wife.

Julia Malonson

My boyfriend said his secret room would be a gift-wrapping room “because what else do I have to keep a secret?” Does that pass the non-creepy test?

Semilocon

That army romcom made me think about how a lot of US american movies are funded by the US military. I wonder if that happened here as well and the US army thought that they need this PR in romcoms for some reason.

Occa Americana

I've been trying to finish a song im writing for months, and somehow youre yapping proved to be the perfect background for me to focus in and finish it

Rachel Cook

I feel like an underrated romcom couple that’s gonna make it are Toula and Ian from My Big Fat Greek wedding. The sequels were atrocious but the first one is such lightning in a bottle. Ian is the sweetest guy, masculine but not toxic, never judges her background and embraces it. There’s not much conflict BECAUSE he’s so dang supportive, but it’s still a really great comfort watch.

Sûs

My secret room would probably be a storage room of shame: Furniture that I've outgrown and KNOW I should sell on Craigslist but can't be assed, impulsive amazon purchases I didn't return in time, clothes I'll never fit in again or looked SO CUTE in the store but now I can't find an appropriate occasion for them, etc. Nothing malicious, but if another human laid eyes on the horrifically large stockpile of obsolescence I may well wither away and die of embarrassment, so this door remains locked at all times, and only I may have the key. (I'm thinking a custom skeleton key with pretty engraving I can wear on a chain around my neck for maximum drama and aesthetic.)

Leah Riley

My secret room - I saw this picture once of an indoor pool that had a tiled bottom that looked like a fancy rug and I just so desperately want that in any form that that would be my secret room - though I guess someone else would have to know about it because there's no way I'm cleaning a pool because I have to spend all my time basketballing for money.

Markus D

I think that you could do a reformed rake nowadays by just making him a guy who likes sex, but respects women. Like a guy who sleeps around for fun and hasn't met anyone he wants to be really committed to. This also made me think that we need some romcoms that end in polyamory.

Markus D

I think Tom Hanks is a lot less classically handsome.

Markus D

As a long-time God Awful Movies listener, I can say that it's a pretty reliable guess that a conservative movie will have a singular Black person in it for exactly that reason. Like, a lot of the time, they'll have the Black person say "[conservative issue, like not wanting to wear masks] is just like slavery!"

Darren Michael Boyd

My snake room is absolutely real... only a secret from my neighbours though.

Occa Americana

in the fifth grade we had a house fire and we had to live in a rental for a few months while it was rebuilt and everything .... months into living in the rental we found a completely bare secret room in-between bedrooms. Super weird, had different flooring than the rest of the house, accessed by sliding back the back of the closet.

Pterranodon

When I visited my grandparents in Korea they had installed heated floors throughout the entire upstairs AND they had a heated bidet. Let me tell you, when facing 30 below wet and icy weather, nothing beat just knocking out on the floor

Audrey

“These are my awards mother. From army”

Broeken Gläsz

This makes me think of the Snail Assassin/Immortal Snail thought experiment, in which you get to be basically immortal but you can be killed only if one particular also immortal snail manages to touch you. You can live wherever you want but it will always be coming for you, albeit very slowly. You can't stay in the same place forever. You almost never have to actually worry about it. But at the same time you will never be truly safe. Your secret room sounds like you've decided to take matters into your own hands and trap the snail so you know where it is at all times. It also makes sense that you'd keep it a secret, because your enemies would have the perfect weapon and also how embarrassing would it be to explain to someone that you're not fully immortal because of a SNAIL? This way you can keep an eye on your only threat until one day an earthquake loosens the screws to the aquarium and cage walls or something and it slips into your bedroom while you're sleeping...

DechAmim

The only decent rake male lead I can think of is the journalist from Girl with the Dragon Tattoo, but then again it's not exactly a romcom lol

DechAmim

For what it's worth, I'd be delighted if I entered into a woman's room and found shelves of furbies, that's a badass collection

DechAmim

My secret room (i.e. random corner of the basement) is filled with my brother's old gym equipment + a metric ton of Transformers toys: the former because I still convince myself that I'll use them one day, the latter because I already have shelves of Transformers and I don't want to reveal the depths my problem to my housemates

DechAmim

That's insane, was it a full-size room, or just like a crawlspace?

DechAmim

Also this is a top-notch ramble, I know literally nothing about romcoms but was glued to the screen. Honestly still reeling about the plot of Runaway Bride, couldn't they have just made the main character call off a bunch of previous engagements instead? It would have made her seem 10x less unhinged, would keep the tension in the wedding scene ("she wouldn't call it off this late...right!?"), and would even let them preserve the title of "runaway bride"

anya k

I have a soft spot for two weeks notice because my mother told me the guy reminds her of my dad lol

Nick R

Not that it really matters, but I will point out that San diego is a place in southern california that actually does have a really high concentration of military people and I actually have heard the sentiment of not wanting to date them expressed in real life lol

Mojo Jojo

100% that's why I refuse to watch it lol

anya k

i think a secret room is always creepy (even the secret forest room, which would absolutely terrify me). therefore, i also think if you’re going to have a creepy secret room then it might as well be a sex dungeon because you should at least live up to the hype

anya k

the whole time she was recapping purple hearts I kept thinking about buster

anya k

this is how I feel about 50 first dates

anya k

i used to have a furby and my parents had to put it away because it gave me nightmares. this is bone chilling

Wendy Comet

I'm not subtle enough about most of my interests to have a secret room of them... if I had an elaborate model-train-esque table set-up for my Schleich models or a dollhouse scaled for my smaller Transformers toys, as two completely random examples, I would not be able to keep a lid on it. Every time someone new entered my home I'd be like, "Check out how I've arranged my plastic dinosaurs so the theropods are in a flock together," or "Right now in Decepticon Manor, Soundwave is doing the gardening while Starscream slacks off and drinks lemonade." That said, I do think my secret room would be some sort of personal reading nook, ideally very small and full of pillows, with very cozy lighting and maybe a stained glass skylight, themed to books or plants or something? The room would be angled such that you could read in the sunlight if you wanted or stay in a shaded area, and it would have amazing heating/cooling so it's never too hot or too cold. I feel like a specifically cozy-themed stained glass window would do a lot to make a space less creepy.

Pterranodon

A dedicated froyo room without having to worry about maintenance / clean-up is one of those childhood wishes that still applies as an adult 😭

Isabel

As a sidenote, there's a huge military presence in San Diego bc there are a lot of military bases here (don't ask me which ones. I, too, know nothing about the military) so it's not too surprising that it would take place in southern california. My sister has a strict no-military dating policy for that reason 😂

Clara Greenez

When you accidentally said Remember Me I BURST out laughing because I was NOT expecting you to say that💀💀💀

daffidazey

san diegan here- we have hella military bases, specifically naval. marines train all over socal, and some of the aircraft carriers are based here!

David A Behlman

It looks like thats where the movie takes place. There was even a bridge that said Oceanside.

Steve Ray

29 Palms has the largest Marine base in America, and it's close enough to San Diego for folks on leave to make a lasting impression.

Steve Ray

"But the Grumplins very mean / To the Monchiichiis / Every day they tease / Try to catch and squeeze / So back up in the trees / Go the Monchiichiis... / 'Monchiichii' means 'Happiness'!" (HOPEFULLY those timeless words can bridge any illusory psychological gaps that may still exist between the concepts of "indoor plush forest" and "sex dungeon," and thus synthesize a shadowy space where everyone can disappear from view with joy.)

Steve Ray

Having a romcom end with everyone in a polycule would feel like the ending of A Cure For Wellness... even if everyone involved keeps feeling perfectly happy...forever... everyone who's encountered such a Peculiar Institution will instinctively flee, in hopes of avoiding The Look.

Steve Ray

It's worse than you think...he's actually dressing up... ...as an NJ Nets super-fan!

Steve Ray

I think all the MW installations have indoor forests.

Natalie Arnold

I read this and wondered for several minutes what could be so eldritch about his gift wrapping technique that it needs to be secret, before realizing he probably just wants to keep the gift a surprise

Alice Parkin

Yes, but all of the food is also somehow Lego, animated like it's in the Lego Movie

Alice Parkin

Also in the corner of the room is a Lego model of the room we're in but the model in the corner in THAT room is not made of Lego but "real" stuff like a dolls house

Charlotte

I know that this is facetious to a degree, but, according to available evidence, it is in fact not true that people who cheated and got together with the person they cheated with, they'll very likely cheat again. This is a myth not borne out by evidence we have on how people actually behave.

Charlotte

Notting Hill is my nostalgic romcom that I always watched with my mum. I love it so much. <3 (Oh, and Julia Roberts' character is pregnant at the end of the film, so they'll have at least one child together.)

Roxanne13579

I think if I were to have a secret room, I'd initially be very lost on what I'd do with it. There's not really a lot of things I'd want to hide away in such a place but if I had to pick. Maybe I would just decorate my secret room to make it look like Bag End, or the Batcave or something. Just a one-to-one replica of a place from a movie or video game

Lupus Cairo

My secret room would probably be just a large practice room for practicing Kpop choreographies bc theres nothing more embarassing than learning them in your own room and someone enters it while you're doing your silly little dances.

portraitinflesh

I had no idea "Dreams" by the Cranberries was in You've Got Mail! I associate that song so strongly with Derry Girls, especially the ending montage in the finale, that it's weird to see it pop up in a frothy, turn-of-the-millennium Hollywood romcom. It's not even that profound of a song, in itself, but my brain permanently has it pigeonholed alongside "bittersweet memories of the Troubles in Northern Ireland".

Kibriya Mehrban

The thing that really struck me when I watched Runnaway Bride as an adult was how dangerous the whole situation was. This journalist is obsessed with her enough to write a hit piece on her and then loses his job bc of her letter to the editor. Then he stalks her, moves to her town and ingratiates himself with her friends and family and none of them are scared for her safety?? That one ex gives him naked photos of her??? Hello????

Libby

Jenny saying she’s never known anyone to have a strong dating stance pro/anti army is so funny to me. I’m the child of two veterans and I never ever ever ever ever ever EVER would date a man in the military and strongly caution all women against it. I’m also from an area with a lot of military bases and I’ve known a lot of girls who are specifically seeking out men in the military (though I think this is a huge mistake and I don’t typically get along with those girls due to stark personality differences)

Libby

There are a lot of things that aren’t corroborated by hard research but are corroborated by consistent anecdotal evidence. Also it’s not like she’s doling out medical advice it’s just a common saying cautioning people against overlooking an agreed-upon unacceptable behavior.

Libby

North Florida where I’m from is the same (three huge bases all within an hour of one another) and I used to have “no military” in my dating app bios

Emma Bloodworth

Oh I’ve only been to the one, thanks for letting me know !

Danielle Schatten

"the hell does Jenny mean 'a british face?'" *clip comes on* "ohhhh this man caused the irish genocide and doesn't put salt on his beans on toast"

Danielle Schatten

also omfg the positioning of "They realize that even though they don't like each other, they both have financial troubles and decide to have a sham marriage" makes it sound like Jenny means THE ARMY GUY AND THE DRUG DEALER which I would watch

Danielle Schatten

holy shit the military gave him a medal for killing a buncha A-rab men, but put him in bad boy scammer jail for six months with no legs for loving one woman in like a slightly wrong way

Danielle Schatten

and the CLIP omfg i didn't realize it was a POV shot from the PLANES

Danielle Schatten

You finally work up the courage to enter my secret room, after years of speculating on what I did with my basketball money and why I have been so insistently covert. Finally, curiosity has overtaken your terror, and you break the lock. To your confusion, it's simply... an empty room. There is a window, four walls, the door leading in, the carpeted floor, and nothing else; it is bare, save for a tape measure laying against one wall. Frustrated with me and annoyed, you prepare to chastise me for this prank, before measuring the floor out of boredom. The room, impossibly, extends two inches outside of the house's walls. This is not detectable from outside my basketball mansion. Somewhere, deep in the labyrinthine halls, things that should not have slammed are jamming. Am I coming home? Was I ever home?

matt pierce

I just finished this and then my TV's home screen advertised The Prince & Me

Jenny Nicholson

Maybe that's the original plot they edited out with ADR

Alice Lastname

Had to look it up, but now I’ll have to keep my eye on it!

Markus D

Is it 'cause they're usually pretty toxic guys? I imagine that being the case if someone actively wants to join the U.S. military for any reason besides "I literally can't afford to so any other job".

Kate Shannon

You've Got Mail was a huge part of my childhood. We had the soundtrack, and my parents told us if they ever played The Puppy Song in the car it meant we were on our way to get a dog (my dad was severely allergic). Years later on a "trip to visit grandma and grandpa" they played it, and the van went WILD. Came home with two standard poodle puppies, Merry and Pippin. ❤ Also Parker Posey's whiney "where are my tic tacs" is a common quote when we can't find something.

fizzledlines

My secret room would just be an art room where I can draw and paint without anyone looking over my shoulder or commenting on half finished stuff. I really can’t think of anything else that wouldn’t be creepy as a secret room though…. This episode was a lot of fun!! I’m very curious about your Pokémon video, I loved the live Pokémon musical one :)

Markus D

50 First Dates is so bad, because Adam Sandler's character spends almost the whole movie being an uncaring bastard.

Markus D

As a trans man, I'm very confused as to why you would think this.

emmett dupree

RETURN TO ME MENTIONED !!!! have never met anyone else who's seen it!! i also had a lot of niche rom-coms in my upbringing. going to continue watching but return to me excited me so much i had to comment :-)

Libby

There’s that and there’s the fact that I was not about to move somewhere every three years for the rest of my life. Sometimes you luck out and they send you to California or Florida or somewhere amazing. Sometimes they send you to North Dakota. Not a risk I’m running.

Jane Mulcahy

okay funny story I made a youtube video about Purple Hearts a few years ago and it led to me getting in contact with the ghostwriter of the BOOK Purple Hearts was adapted from, which was actually the result of book packaging by ALLOY ENTERTAINMENT!!!! the author's real name is Lara Avery and she's actually very nice and cool. my impression is that the book is a little more nuanced and less 'conservative guy tames liberal shrew' vibes than the movie

Louis Z

My secret room is where I invited the Charmin bears to sample my cask of Amontillado. And my toilet paper. I had to make it an offer they couldn’t refuse and I wasn’t sure if they were into wine.

John Earnest

If Jenny discovered that a housemate's closely-guarded "secret room" was in fact her fantasy artificial indoor forest, would it still be a terrifying discovery? Has there ever been a romantic comedy involving two people who have identical secret rooms?

Gwen Walsh

I’d definitely fill my secret room with weird puppets which is 100% scary and would freak anyone out, but I do think that’s better than my current arrangement (puppets just in my house in otherwise normal rooms)

Sisi 77

unrelated but I'm already looking forward to Jenny's review of the Disneyland 70th anniversary stuff a year from now lol (some of the merch is... questionable from what I've seen)

Ivy Clark

My secret room would be the same as Jenny’s indoor forest but all real, not fake plants.

Adamanus

Have you seen Palm Springs? I wonder how the main couple in that movie will fair.

TheDumbestGenius

My secret room would also be a fake outdoor area, but instead of a forest, it'd be a few different mini-biomes populated by those big, expensive pokemon plushes. Like, I'd have a little fake lake and have that huge Lapras plush in there, put the big Clodsire by the lake shore, and then the giant Snorlax plush on a fake grassland and so on. And I'd just go in there to either hug/flop on the plushies or indulge my lifelong fantasy of being a pokemon trainer.

Lazlo Nibble

If I wrote for Netflix I would be constantly pitching remakes of highly-popular romcoms where all the terrible behavior from the originals has the kind of consequences it would actually have in real life. They would feature a lot of personal trauma and jail time.

Lazlo Nibble

Oooh, how about two people who discover that their secret rooms are actually secretly connected to the other person’s secret rooms?

Steve Ray

Have you posted pics anywhere of your puppet roommates?

Khurasan Miniatures

Any update on the YouTube mirror? I can’t really watch things on Patreon

Steve Ray

Her friends and family are clearly engaged in stochastic stalking, crossing their fingers and hoping against hope that a cruel God has finally sent a new psychotic monster to rid them of the psychotic monster that keeps forcing them to visit Williams-Sonoma.

Trevor Atwood

I feel like I'd just go with a model train room. I feel like if you discover someone who is known to like trains has a secret train room the reaction would just be "oh, yeah, that tracks". If they don't like trains though? Terrifying. Also, a shoutout to one of my favorite romcom couples - Ewan McGregor and Renee Zellweger in Down With Love. They're one of those couples that requires you to buy in to the insanity of the world they live in, but holy cow do they have a great romance - complete with a three minute one-take monologue.

BeeTee

Have you watched Fire Island? Not trying to spoil anything but maybe give it a watch if you haven't because of reasons!

violet.jpeg

My rich person secret room would just contain a computer and all the Sims games, including the worst of the Sims 4 DLC. Nobody gets to know I spent money on that stuff.

Louis Z

If the app isn’t working you should be able to watch it by logging in on any browser on any device. If that isn’t working either it’s one of the weird bugs that happen on Patreon. The good news is Patreon support is great and can definitely fix it. If you’re on an iPhone tap on your profile picture in the upper right and Support will be on the menu. It might take them a few days to answer but they’ll fix it.

Charlotte

I just think having a cartoon idea of cheaters is thoroughly unhelpful when it comes to understanding how and why cheating happens (and thus how to avoid it).

Jenny Nicholson

I go back and forth between a forest populated by real creatures, like those beautiful life size hansa plush, or a pokemon forest. Perhaps it could be seasonal

Jenny Nicholson

Unfortunately it's under a 30 day hold that's unlikely to be released early (they almost never are). I could try deleting and reuploading in case it doesn't flag again but if it does flag this would mean resetting the clock. (I can't leave both up concurrently since youtube blocks reuploading same/similar videos). Another option would be to remove movie clips but that might make it make less sense/be less good. Unfortunately a drawback of watching on youtube. In the meantime have you tried support to troubleshoot the patreon player issues? What happens when you try to play?

myth

ugh, I can't word my thoughts in internet-friendly short paragraphs. lemme try again. I find it super odd how emotional intelligence and psychological growth or healing or whatever this and that and healthy communicative intimate friend and relationships as an entire concept sorta gets thrown out when this topic comes up.

COTF Creative

My issue with watching on Patreon is just that they keep removing the chromecast option and I just prefer to watch on my tv. Looks like Im waiting 30 days 😂

Louis Z

Jenny, there’s no actual reason to put yourself through the stress every month of trying to bang the square Patreon peg into the round YouTube hole. The YouTube mirror is a pointless redundancy. If you don’t feel like fighting with them for 30 days you could just delete this ramble from YouTube now and not upload them there anymore.

Khurasan Miniatures

Thanks for the update. Certainly not suggesting you re-edit! I’ll wait until the appeal goes through. It gives me headaches to watch more than a few minutes of video on a phone. But this means for me a double barrel blast of ramble goodness in May! 🕺🏻🕺🏻

Paperkin

The guy in Purple Hearts has a bunch of bad movies, i liked the hip hop violin dance one and the Harry Styles wattpad fanfic one

Louis Z

It’s really easy to stream Patreon videos from an iPhone to a Roku. I have the cheapest Roku (like $30) and it works great. You have to do it directly from the video. Start playing it, pause, tap on the little rectangle over triangle thing, and voila you’re watching Jenny on the big screen in all her Randy Moore trashing glory. I don’t know if this works on Androids.

Nicole Knapp

I actually did give a speech at my wedding. It was mainly ruthlessly ranking my bridesmaids in an internet-friendly numbered list.

Emma Holt

Personally the only time I can stand cheating in a romantic movie is if it's set in the past and the couple we root for is a gay couple.

Emma Holt

I think that that is like the only time that cheating is like understandable. Like its set in a time when gay people couldn't be out or open so most end up in heterosexual marriages. I would still prefer there to not be cheating but, ya know. Also normally set in a time where no fault divorce didn't exist.

Ginger Jones

He’s also in a kind of goofy TV series about English royalty in I think the 16th century which I’m enjoying bc the premise is basically “dude’s conniving social-climbing mother pimps him out to bisexual king”

Brooklyn

This wouldn’t be my secret room, but the least creepy secret room I could think of is like if a loved one passed away, and in your grieving, you want to leave their room untouched, and then you don’t want to talk ab it bc it’s painful to talk ab the loss

Sploinklet Lawson

I'll dedicate my secret room to obvious stuff like Naruto AMVs or a silly hat collection. Then they won't suspect I have a secret, SECRET room with sick and twisted-type stuff for freakazoids.

Giselle

I think the obvious secret room is my astral witch room, where I have a beautiful prismatic glass observatory on top of my house and practice my star magic there. It’s not visible looking at the house from the outside because of a spell on the glass, and the reason it’s secret it because I can’t have anyone find out about my cool magic, or my neighbors would never leave me alone.

Claire Stump

My secret room would be a recreation of a Roman bath house.

Ginger Jones

Yeah the American military at least does still have a reputation as a huge bastion of toxic masculinity which leads me to not want to date anyone who’s part of it as well as the fact that I’m kind of a huge hippie and there’s that part of my brain that just automatically goes OH NO THE BAD EVIL FASCIST CORPORATE WAR MACHINE!! however all the people I’ve ever met who were veterans or otherwise affiliated with the US military were very… for lack of a better word, normal. Empathetic, down-to-earth, nice to be around. I guess what I’m trying to say is it’s complicated

Konni

that military movie is so obviously just bootlicking it's insane

Ky

I'd love to know if Jenny has seen French Kiss with meg ryan & kevin kline, it's my favorite romcom! also i'd be interested in her takes on When Harry met Sally if she's seen, maybe we can get another romance movie video someday :)

Stahlhart

My secret room would be a Pokemon stadium, complete with holograms of the pokemon, pre recorded announcers, and a constantly cheering crowd sound effect that plays forever

Ginger Jones

This is the best idea tbh… since it’s a secret, mine would have exclusively fish that are illegal to own in the US like Asian arowana and… idk… an oarfish somehow

Neil Dutton

Jenny pulls a huge lever that releases the Spring Badgers

Ginger Jones

As an American now I feel like I dodged a bullet by already knowing those things lol (also if I’m being honest, Paris isn’t at the top of my list of places to visit, even within France)

Markus D

A lot of the time, at least when it came to higher-class people, it seems like it was reasonably common for people who were gay to get married and then have what's essentially an "open relationship" where they and their partner just agreed that they could both have relationships with whoever they wanted despite the marriage.

Ginger Jones

I’ve always kind of figured that the English and the French mostly shared the same gene pool but now that I actually think about it maybe that would only be true for their royal families… also, that actor (Nicholas Galitzine) is half Greek but (as someone who has a lot of half-to-fully Greek relatives lol) I wouldn’t say he looks like it at all! Anyway genetics is weird

Markus D

I definitely don't think of the English and the French generally being all that genetically similar, considering all the wars they had. The royalty in Europe is all over the place. Like a lot of them used to be Spanish, there was a point in time when they were almost all Hapsburgs because that family wanted to essentially have a power monopoly...

Ginger Jones

Apparently that actor has a Greek mom but it looks like her genes were just OBLITERATED by British Dad’s

Morgan Ashwin

My secret room is a second more secret bedroom so I can take naps without judgment. it would be so so so extremely cozy and dark and quite. Terrifyingly.

Ian

Return to Me is on Tubi for free right now (April 2025)

Monssef Burezah

Is that VPD ™-baseballcap a hint? Are you bracing yourself for a The Originals ™ marathon?

Dylan Swain

Secret room, eh? Well, I actually DO have a secret room. Except it's not really a secret, but we'll pretend it is. I'm a hobbyist woodworker who specializes in making pens. I call it The Pen Den (not fiction: ThePenDenShop.etsy.com, if you need a fancy pen or something fun). It could certainly be made creepy - I have many tools and implements that, if the lighting was right and there was ominous music, could be very sinister indeed. And, you know, John Wick killed some guys with a pen, and so did Martin Blank, so there's that.

The Weekly Planet

My secret room is a woodworking shop (it is ridiculously soundproofed). I spend every evening an weekend in there. I occasionally bring out a wooden toy for my children to fiddle with, or I drag out a gorgeous piece of handmade furniture for my wife to admire. My children and wife are also made out of wood.

Forrest

You’re kind of right? There’s technically a small romance with Emmett but it only gets confirmed in text as a “where are they now” kind of thing after the movie ends. The musical adaptation makes emmet a much more important character and centers their romance more (I have mixed feelings about this)

Elle

My secret room is an elaborate indoor playground for me to run around and climb things in

Jenny Nicholson

That's true, I think it's true in general for many period pieces where divorce is not actually an option

Steve Ray

If you ever get *really* rich, I hope you upgrade it to connect to a CCTV'ed housing development full of real people who get to live there for free, so long as they faithfully obey all of the Sims-style commands you can beam to them at any moment (or that are generated by the computer by default). Also, they may only read and speak Singlish.

William Peirson

A room devoted to completing Jigsaw puzzles. You know, multiple trays for sorting pieces, high tables so you could easily stand while solving, big tv as a second screen for semi-watching as you play. Easy ways to wrap, glue, and store completed puzzles. Special lighting. But, let's be real, as fun as it would make playing a jigsaw puzzle, all that at once would come across to a normal person as my personal room for "Dexter" auditions.

Michelle Jones

Yep I’m from San Diego and had a rule of not dating marines. I was cautious about other military too but I knew a lot of girls in abusive relationships with marines specifically :/

Steve Ray

I wonder if that's what got her the part in White Lotus Season 3's "Where are my lorazepams?"

Markus D

@Libby I totally forgot that that was an aspect of the U.S. military. Hell, I have relatives in the Canadian military and I think THEY have had to move around a bit...

Markus D

@Ginger Jones I DO think there's a difference between how toxic people in active duty tend to be versus veterans. I'm at least familiar with some leftist veterans, like Joe Kassabian and some people he associates with. A lot of the time they end up in the military due to poverty and the job being relatively high-paying, plus free education.

Markus D

I never really liked Furbies because as a kid I didn't like how much of them were hard plastic. Plus, their mechanical movements were so noisy!

lily zacheis

as someone in so cal who’s dated both a woman in the army and a man who went into the marines, I very much do have a “no dating people in the armed forces” policy and uh. especially marines.

Louis Z

You refer to both jigsaw puzzles and Jigsaw puzzles. Those are very different things. Solving jigsaw puzzles involves connecting cardboard pieces to see a pastoral landscape. Solving Jigsaw puzzles involves connecting severed body parts to see who was mildly rude to John Kramer.

Will Donahue

my secret room would be completely empty except for a bolted safe. and that part is staying secret.

Willsun

This room can be called "On the Road to Viridian City." You might meet your friends along the way, if you've got a badge and the power to play.

Dahlia Bassig

my secret room would be a one-to-one replica of the comically large wardrobe room from barbie life in the dream house and all the clothes that come with it!!! as a 7 foot tall basketball hotshot this would be borderline incriminating but I literally don't care

Quinn

Omg Frilly Frocks again! Weirdly I’ve never seen her for sale in Australia

bella lugosi

my secret room would be a doll collection and it would almost ensure i’d be alone forever because of the secret doll room

Asmodeus

"Remember Me." How could I forget such a bizarre movie.

Danielle Schatten

me putting together my fifth cardboard puzzle of the night: "Okay are any of these NOT someone dying in the Reverse Bear Trap?"

Danielle Schatten

you are the only person here qualified to have a basketball mansion

retronymph

My secret room would be just a little coffee den. Not sure why it would be secret, because I'd probably want to share it with my partner, but I don't know. Maybe a 3d printing farm? Not sure why that would be secret either but my partner probably wouldn't have any interest in it so it may as well be a secret.

Sophie

no beastly mention makes me sad but also you did do an entire video about it before (it still makes me laugh so much)

Helena Young

sorry obsessed w the giant mlp in the background omggg

Jasmine The Great

My secret room would be a clown room. Just to give me an excuse to collect the clown dolls that I see at thrift stores. I'd never go in there, of course. I just want a reason to collect clowns, but I don't actually want to see the clowns.

anya k

Yeah but he's so hot though

Ontario Traffic Man

You could also plug a computer into the TV and just go to the Patreon website

Krista Brenholt

Jenny shrine! No unfortunately I am boring and my secret room would just be a gym so no one can see me work out because I’m self conscious

Matthew Hernandez

My secret room would be hinted at by a mysteriously tinted window that you can see from outside the house on an upper floor. But when you go inside there just doesn't seem to be a way to access that window. In fact it doesn't even seem like there's enough space for a room there. "What...what room does that window belong to??" It grows from curiosity to a full-blown paranoid obsession. Time to act. You keep me occupied in the kitchen by leaving an ice cream sandwich on the table. Idk why it was so effective since it just came from my own freezer. You take a sledgehammer to the wall that the tinted window's on. I'm too busy living my best life with that ice cream sandwich to intervene. Doesn't take much time to completely smash through the wall, shattering the tinted window from the inside. I finally come up to investigate after my 3rd ice cream sandwich. There's a new hole in my home. It's drafty. "I thought that wall looked really plain from the outside so I stuck a window on there. I should probably just grow climbing vines there or something." Anyway, I would probably want a music room with a ton of rare and silly instruments. It would be really hard to even *want* to keep it a secret though, tbh.

xo

my secret room would be a full-on waifu shrine to my favorite anime guys. such things are best kept locked away from the eyes of the public

Swashbutler

My secret room would be an Arthurian den, like Merlin's Crystal Cave with a sword in the stone, and there'd be shelves upon shelves of Arthurian lore and big Warhammer-esque tables with terrain where I can re-enact the big battles of Arthuriana with minis. It would be all too intense and there'd be a weird Merlin costume from 'Excalibur' with a shiny skullcap

Derick Gadd

For some reason, I saw You've Got Mail in movie theaters, and I am 100% convinced I was there alone. It was 1998 so I would have been 12. I know my own tenuous grasp of this memory is all that is left of it. My parents would not remember that I saw it, or be able to explain why. I can only assume it was because I was really excited about the internet.

Derick Gadd

Also, I had never heard of "Return To Me" and I was only half listening while painting and was like "yeah, the wife's heart gets donated to a Gorilla, right?.... oh ok yeah of course not.."

Jacki Schaefer

My secret room would be a napping room, with all kinds of sleep setups. Giant bed from the internet with all the built in features, hammock, little cave, pile of pillows and blankets, etc. I’d keep it secret so no one would think to come wake me up!

Echolalia

My secret room is Cranium Command. I STOLE BUZZY

PurpleIsDebeste

Sorry Jenny, you have accidentally sold me on 27 dresses, i think the idea of a woman with a Wedding Special Interest who just adores going to weddings and goes out of her way to be a bridesmaid as often as possible, sometimes 2 at once, and makes new friends specifically to attend their weddings is Adorable, actually! Anyway my secret room would be a perfect copy of my bedroom but its a second secret one for when i want to be alone

Martin G

Tuesday September II, Z00I

Danielle Schatten

anyway if any studio execs are Jenny fans the script for "House of LeaBron" is 50% done and I will let you put product placement in it if I can cast Danny DeVito as the female lead

Steve Ray

Like with vintage fixtures and chutes reclaimed from H. H. Holmes' Chicago-World's-Fair hotel?

Steve Ray

In-the-know commentators would be forever dropping hints like, "...and they're tied up, 101-all at the end of the fourth quarter!... four seconds left...he shoots from half-court!... 2...1...he scores and WINS it for the home crowd... another classic Buzzy-beater!"

Steve Ray

And ends up cheating on his partner, too...rust-red flag!

Louis Z

There are multiple ways to easily watch Patreon videos on any television made in the last fifteen years

Aiden

this is great timing for this discussion prompt because literally yesterday I was at the zoo with my friend in the aviary and I was like "if I got really wealthy I would get a room like this in my house." just a big greenhouse type room with live plants and birds flying around and waterfalls and stuff. I would just have to also have a separate smaller atrium situation for my cat because if I had free-roaming birds obviously he couldn't go in there lol. always a big fan of jenny's play/plush forest idea too-- I went to the "SMALAND" play area in ikea a couple of times as a kid and that would go crazy now as an adult. there's an indoor part of a zoo I've been to a few times that has different plush animals in the fake trees and I'm a huge fan of that too. so I see the Vision :)

Skylin.

My secret room would totally be a pony room, but like, highly decorated and themed so it's like the ponies are running through a felt dream world and are set up in little scenes and tableau.

rachel

Late to the discussion but maybe one valid secret room (at least, secret from guests, still weird to keep from ppl living with you) is if you had some sort of semi-anonymous internet fame tied to that room? Like maybe if you were a popular vtuber streamer or furry or something. I could see someone wanting to keep that under wraps for non-nefarious purposes

Brian Weidemann

“What would you like us to go do, teach em pronouns???” No? I just said maybe cheering about how you’re going to go hunt down “ay-rabs” is bad? Racist even?

Keiko

that tracks lol

ts_babyjane

@markus as a trans woman, who dates men, a lot of chasers will come on very hypermasculine and then after they think they have you they are like “i want to wear yr underwear”. im not into that, and i wouldn’t normally shame anyone for their desires, but for a lot of men like that its more insidious. its not out of a gender identity, its because they think being AMAB and feminine is degrading and shameful. they assume that ur cool with it because they think your a man pretending to be a woman who has a kink like theres. or they dont care what a trans woman thinks of them because yr disposable and should be happy that anyone wants to be with you. most prominent example of this is anti-trans grifter Josh Seiter. cant stress enough how many times a dude has done this. so now im paranoid and making a joke about it

sweet chao

your hair looks so pretty :0

Rozzettes

I'm gonna be completely honest with you Jenny, my secret room is one with a bunch of fake plants from Pandora and a small replica of the Tree of Souls with hanging light strips and ambient forest sounds. And if I'm deep in the fantasy of this secret room, I would have an animatronic head and neck of an ikran that moved around that I could pet. The other decor would be a bunch of green plush pillows, blankets, and carpet for lounging, with a ton of decorative glowing plants and flowers, and maybe a small water feature. The light sources in the room, besides the Tree of Souls and "bioluminescent" plants would be some warm light lamps that flicker as if they're lit by glowing insects or flame, so I could hang out in there and read.

well anyway

My secret room would be full of my taxes, medical documents, and other important records. I'd try to find as much personally identifiable information I could find about myself and store it there so I can easily find it. I'd also submit just a ton of FOIAs to government agencies for stuff I find interesting, and store it there so if I ever need sensitive personally identifiable information, or any important document, I can go find it in the room. By doing this, I circumvent the creep factor. If anyone enters my secret room to find out what dark mystery I've stashed there, they'll very quickly learn why the room is secret. If I ever showed it to someone, I could say "the room is secret because it contains a bunch of sensitive information." And most people would say "I wish you had just told me instead of being evasive, but I can understand not wanting people to know where all your important documents are"

Jesse Walker-McGraw

Honestly I had the exact same thought and I was VERY CONCERNED about where the romantic comedy element would come in based on that premise

Jennifer

At first I thought my secret room would just be boring because it'd pretty similar to my real "office", just with larger quantities (I already have tons of yarn and nail polish, I'd just get a lot more if I were super rich). But you're so right that making it a secret makes it creepy. What nefarious things could I potentially be using the yarn and nail polish for if it has to be kept a secret?

Jesse Walker-McGraw

I would use a secret room to store a bunch of animatronics from obscure animatronic shows of the past. Like, ones that only had one or two versions and don't exist anywhere any more. I'd be working to make a big animatronic show where they all interact, but it would be secret for now because I'd still be work shopping it.

Anna O.

I'd probably go for a secret American Girl doll collection room where I could have all my AG stuff out, and have space to actually collect some of the playsets, and could just go hide and play with dolls. Kind of quirky if it's not secret, but absolutely creepy if it was.

Anna O.

I love "Return to Me." I think partly because it's like, yeah, this is weird, but also, the relationship makes sense. I also love just how wacky Gracie's family is. Just like how "You've Got Mail" has all those goofy side characters who are far more interesting to me than the main characters.

James Cézanne-Taipale

My secret room would be an indoor lawn with flower gardens and two real trees that I’ve kept short but are big enough to support a hammock with 500lbs on it. It would always be 63F and slightly humid, and the only way to get in is to open the secret panel in the back of a wardrobe. The wardrobe is located in my home dungeon though.

Natalie Arnold

No it's not. Patreon literally doesnt work for many of us.

Natalie Arnold

Website doesn't work for me. It just stays on a black box forever.

Maddy

(im sure someone else has already pointed this out) as someone who has known people in san diego trying to date men, the "military guys" comment from that one movie with the military guys is a pretty accurate sentiment for some people there

Pterranodon

Romance movie about that one tiktok woman who's making a giant tunnel in her backyard and accidentally breaches a doomsday prepper's most impenetrable bunker: his heart

Pterranodon

I could've sworn there was a movie where the totally Politically Neutral main character was like, "Sure I signed a petition to ban gay marriage but... isn't that MY freedom to choose?" Then they had the wise Old Black Woman say, "Yes, I remember the times where ppl like me weren't allowed onto buses and theaters... Freedom IS important." I swore they were going to add a line about "Fighting for what's right, just like Rosa Parks," but even the filmmakers thought that was pushing it,

Lednik

I assume at some point the copious amounts of plushes and merch of media I like and bought with lots of basketball dollars would warrant concern if I stuffed them all into a room I never let anyone in, because now the discoverer has to ponder if I'm normal about any of those fandoms or if I'm clearly unhinged. That would also be where the fursuit is because a secret room fursuit is going to terrify so many people even if its clearly average and next to like, completely normal convention photos and art

Louis Z

You need to file a request with Patreon support. On the app tap on your profile picture and it’ll be on the menu. If you’re only using Patreon through a web browser search for Patreon Help Center. For some reason, unlike on the app, this can’t be done on your account page. You have to search for Patreon Help Center directly on your browser.

Louis Z

You’re having a technical problem that they can fix. They should make it easier to find Patreon Support on the web but they’ll fix the problem with the video player within a few days after you file the support request.

Kylie

secret room idea: escape room. it’d be themed (not sure which theme but i’m picturing it in a library behind a bookshelf, where you pull a book and it opens). terrifying for someone to accidentally get trapped in there, but I think all the clues would be pieces of a mysterious story and you’d uncover the story as you went through. it’d also have some fantasy/sci-fi elements like an indoor glowing treehouse. there will be a door with a glowing red exit sign on it that takes a little bit of searching (but not much) to avoid any true anxiety or trapped feeling

Alexandria Ritz

I lived in a Navy town growing up, STRICT no military dating stance here

Jennifer Marten

Literally just started the video but THAT FRILLY FROCKS PLUSH IS AMAZING 😍

Alphonse

Seconding this. Completely AWED by the amazing trickets Jenny has as PER USUAL

Trystan

That Purple Hearts movie is buck wild. Romcom military propaganda. I'm not really sure who the target audience would be. It feels like it's more for the actual military men who want to feel good dying for a country that doesn't care about them than any woman. For my secret room it'd just be a nerd room, but the joke would be that there is nobody who knows me that thinks I am NOT a nerd so it would be wholly unnecessarily secret, which I think adds a layer of uncannyness since they'd wonder why I would keep it secret.

Eric Cheung

And Justin Tranter, who is gender non-conforming and uses they/them/theirs pronouns, wrote songs for the movie. Sucks that they had to take that gig only to have the concept of chosen pronouns be belittled.

Magical Elfman

It's just the room where I keep my collection of memorabilia and merchandise related to the women's deodorant brand, Secret. Turns out this was just one of those hilarious misunderstandings and you could have gone in there any time, so actually it's not creepy or scary at all.

Jaz Mei Luo

He's no longer in jail and she's a pop star. Can I make it any more obvious?

run_away

If I had a house, and if that house had a secret room, it would be a tiny replica of the entire neighborhood complete with little neighborhood people in it. It would have wiring and light up. I'd make phone recordings of my neighbors saying things and then have their dolls have a pull string and voicebox so they could say the stuff that their humans say. So nothing creepy.

JG

Sabrina Stern

I don't know if anyone already said this about Purple Heart, but the movie is set in San Diego, and San Diego is a military town. I live in San Diego and have a strict no dating military policy. Top Gun is also set in San Diego.

Milkweed

My secret room would have a thick rope spider web that is strong enough and big enough for a fully grown human to sit on comfortably. I would then lounge on the life size spider web and engage in various activities like reading.

Delphine

I'm actually sorta in the process of building a secret room?? In our main bedroom there is a little hallway in the back (with our closets coming off the hallway) leading to a loft, all of which is separate from the rest of the house. I love the idea of feeling like a tiny person and collect oversized items to pretend like I'm three inches tall 😂 In the loft area I'm specifically adding giant flowers and mushrooms and things so that I can feel like a fairy, and then I'd love to paint the walls for not just more giant grass or whatever, but for the little hallway to be this magnified brick wall with a fake crack in it (aka my closet) and then to fill the closet with giant items like buttons and spools of threads to make it look like a borrower hidey hole 🤭 My husband does know about all this, but our kids are still young toddlers and we like having our own space, so they never get into our bedroom/loft area. If I really go all out with this, they may one day see this secret room and lose their lil minds 😅

Ana

It’s a pun in the word “maid”. And it is supposed to suggest that he is made of honor lol wild, I know

DemonKingMidas0011

My secret room would be a stereotypical, dimly lit home library with a fireplace, a comfy chair, and one of those slidey ladders for the bookshelves.

Alphonse

Agreed with you on the Wedding Planner, its 100% a cheating movie and it was miserable to watch. Also I won't lie, I WAS metaphorically looking at you when I heard the name Penny Nicholson... lol I actually never watch rom-coms on purpose, but my friend and I bought a box of 50 random assorted dvds and blu-rays and are forcing ourselves to watch all of them... and damn are there a lot of rom coms. "Theres Something About Mary" was the most vile and unpleasant watching experience I've possibly ever had? So like whoever is reading this check that out if u want a terrible time. Its a horror movie concept disguised as a rom-com and also the sense of humor is all around disgusting. As for my secret room.... Hmm.. So in real life I have several specific rooms, most notably a dedicated clown room, but those aren't a secret... I think my secret room would be like, an irl fantasy D&D set that looks like the underdark. I want giant animatronic spiders, flumphs, and atleast 1 full size illithid.

Danielle Schatten

you're offending me by acting like these murderers-for-hire are legitimate parts of society and their made-up cosplay names are justification for blowing up infants but ok

spider jen

If you're in a sham marriage for military benefits but it's only a sham on one side isn't that just... Tricking someone who actually loves you into marriage for ulterior motives? Is that even a crime?? Also if a marriage is genuine on one side how does it not meet all the criteria for a real marriage?? Your partner is living with you, committed to you, and sharing legal and financial responsibilities. I think at that point all you're guilty of is being an awful person which you surely can't be thrown into military jail for

Trystan

There's an irony to being careful about offending people that signed up to a job they chose to do, using nomenclature nobody outside of that profession should need to know, and who are often of the 'no snowflakes, freedom of speech, you can't say anything anymore' crowd. It's way more fun calling them the wrong thing and then asking them if they're triggered when they get upset.

Adam Ryan

Shout-out to 'You've Got Mail'.

tumbleweed🍂

My uncreepy secret room: indoor plush forest with climbable foam structures and trees with faces. It must remain secret so that nobody can trademark and exploit my very original idea. DAMMIT I WAS WRITING THIS BEFORE THE VIDEO WAS OVER AND SHE JUST SAID IT

Adrian

i want to steal the indoor forest now!

Markus D

It sounded like she got that, but she didn't get why it would be suggested that he's "made [composed] of honor", so she dismissed it as ridiculous.

Markus D

I think you missed a point that some people aren't going to get, but is an important distinction. Army is ground guys, Navy is boat guys, air force is plane guys. Marines are technically part of the Navy (that's why they have that name), but they don't only do water stuff. They were cool in the Second World War and still think they're hot shit for some reason. Also, coast guards seem pretty chill. I've never heard them be called "guardians".

a.s.

coming back to this after days of deliberation, my secret room would be like a pleasant version of a padded cell where the entire floor is a cushion with gorgeous quilted wall hangings and a couple big windows, an astonishing variety of throw pillows and a little tea set. ultimate hangout spot for me and the cat

a.s.

dude i forget about how cool being an adult is bc you can actually do whatever you want thats so sick

JG

“guardians” is space force. but yeah i don’t think most people are expected to know what the different branches do beyond the absolute basics, my actual point is just that marines don’t like being called soldiers or being confused with the army

Tim Goodman

It kind of cracked me up how many times Jenny said “army” and “soldier” even after playing the clip of them saying they’re marines. (I realize the clip is probably edited in after everything else is recorded.)

Can & Dari

A fully functioning replica of both the Godzilla and Jet Jaguar suits from Godzilla VS Megalon. Probably on a fiberglass stage landscape with trees and rocks and things. Maybe two dummies shaped like Megalon and Gigan for me and bae to fight.

bluewolfie

my secret room is absolutely, 100%, a cat room. not like, a room where my cats hang out that can only be accessed through a cat door. more like... nobody knows I am fostering 18 cats, they're all in this spacious luxurious room. I literally have a Pinterest board about this, I would absolutely foster more cats if I had a larger space, but I feel like I already accept fosters too quickly, so I absolutely would accept them and just neglect to tell people in my life

KatyW

I think I would want a mini city that i could stomp around in and destroy like godzilla

Abigail

My secret room would be a replica of the secret foam play room at my local aquarium. It was tucked away in a room separate from the main building so most people didn't know it was there. It had a bunch of animals - whale shark, turtle, octopus, starfish, fish, stingray - and some regular rocks. They were set up so that you could jump from one to the other without ever touching the floor. It would be creepy though!

Andrew Wertz

my secret room would be a dimly lit, fully stocked saloon which plays 50s and 60s old cowboy songs that I've never heard by Marty Robins or something. It has a pool table, darts, and a table in the corner wreathed in shadow where you can light up a cigar like a mysterious stranger. You can sit at the bar with your comically large hat pulled low over your eyes, sipping your whisky on the rocks, and just feel real lonesome when you need to. Everyone sometimes get lonesome.

Alice Blehart

My secret room is just all of my empty prescription bottles and boxes. I want to see all of the powerful chemicals I've imbued in order to combat crippling clinical depression and OCD.

Tim Goodman

I'm tempted to say my secret room would just be a completely nondescript living room, just for irony. And I guess just to mess with whoever went snooping and found it.

Sophie Cleverly

My secret room would be a basement pool with cave vibes and low lighting. It would be like a spa but also have slides. I can only imagine this would be terrifying (like the Pools game where you walk around liminal empty pools)

Pepe Silvia

My roommate has a very, very chatty bird; a secret noise proof room to play piano in would be heavenly

Maria

My ideal secret room is my own indoor theme park. Which is both wildly unrealistic and extremely creepy to find as the live in girlfriend. I've always had dreams of being in a mall or theme park alone and they've always been really comforting to me, but not sure it translates to irl at all 😅

Sara Escobar

My secret room would be a pond room where i can swim and float with little fish and shrimps and snails

Trans WRONGS

my secret room would be an inside-outside (outside-inside?) room like yours, but I want a little porch scene with dusk lighting and fake fireflies on the walls. and in the middle is an industrial strength swing bench for swinging with as much velocity as possible. that’s all the room is for.

Julia

re purple hearts san diego absolutely has a high enough density of army guys for a blanket policy against dating them lol

Lauren Woodring

My secret room would be like a small town main street, with a gazebo, swing benches, water fountain, and fake grass. All the little shops would have functioning stuff inside, like a 6 person movie theater + concession stand, the craft store would store all my supplies, a tiny bar with a karoake stage, an arcade with pin ball machines, etc. The crown jewel of this room being a loft that encircles the space, thats a go cart track. And since we're going all out here, it's all designed and decorated by meow wolf collective artists. The creep factor is both, what is this town? And, the betrayal you'd feel finding out I've been hoarding such opulent fun all to myself.

Penny

I'm sure it's already been mentioned, but there's a Marine base around San Diego, so the Purple Hearts setting does make sense. Apparently the rest of the plot doesn't tho, lol. Also, I was DYING when you revealed that the "army" guy was in the marines, but you kept calling him an army guy. I can't tell how much of it was for the bit and how much you just genuinely didn't know, but just in case, some people get very touchy about that, fyi. Also, I saw How to Lose a Guy in 10 Days in theaters, and I have mercifully forgotten almost all of it; that singing clip was painful.

Juni Koh

Living in San Diego, the “no military” thing is legit

beau!

just started watching and i’m so jealous of your awesome giant pony plush

John Alonzo

Just wondering, does it usually take a long time to resolve a Youtube dispute?

Sunny

My secret room would be a doll customizing room where I take apart dolls and create new, cool dolls. I already have that now and it already scares people. It's in my closet, which I call my cloffice. (Closet + office.) There are a lot of doll parts all over the place. It doesn't need to be secret to be scary, but that would up the creepiness by a lot.

Noah Pittrof

my ideal secret room would be something like what kim possible has or hannah montana or lane in gilmore girls, where you flip a cupboard and then there's a whole other set up. It would be like a cool secret ghost and folklore and kim possible esque, buffy vibe of a library and myth busting layer but like *tasteful* :')

Louis Z

Thirty days minimum and that’s assuming she actually wins the dispute. If the Patreon video player isn’t working you should file a tech support request. On the app tap on your profile picture in the upper right and Support will be on the menu. It might take them a few days to respond.

Alx Windsar

i fuckin LOVE you've got mail

Alx Windsar

My secret room is a single gaming chair and a laptop on an ikea table. Like, might as well lean into the creepiness, right?

Lanceeee

Hmmm secret room maybe WOULD be all those snake terrariums? I have one snake but having more would be cool. Or a big play room for a different kind of pet, like a few rats.

Greta

As someone who lives in San Diego— I can vouch for people saying they don’t date military

Jay

My wife's secret room: fish. No further explanation provided. My secret room: a catio jungle gym as a dedicated play space for our 4 cats. Secret because it would be filled with an inordinate amount of fancy cat trees and expensive furniture that would be too embarrassing to show a guest.

IBBTTTYE

My hidden room would probably be like a VR Vtuber studio

michael

My hidden room would be full of pokemon plushies (specifically every single one from the sitting cuties line)

noam schwarz

My secret room would be a room for crafting sewing and knitting/crochet. It would have a comfy couch for knitting/crochet, and a really good set up for my sewing machine. But really, the main thing would be a lot of shelves and storage for all my yarn and fabrics. And because this is a secret room and no one else is allowed entrance (and in this scenario I am rich), then I can accumulate all the amazing fabrics and yarn I find, and will totally use for some project some day, with out being judged by my family for not using them and mostly just storing them, and occasionally pulling them out to think of all the lovely projects I will make with them some day.

Iris

You've Got Mail is such a good litmus test because it's infuriating to gay women and anyone healthy enough to say no to a terrible man, but it makes women like me go, "it do be like that sometimes." It was like that for Nora Ephron- the shit she had to put up with. And we're socialized to put up with it! If that movie infuriates you, you're lucky.

Emma

Jenny, you need to watch the 1990 television version of the Phantom of the Opera with Charles Dance and Teri Polo - the phantom has a huge, secret, underground forest room with stuffed animals!! Maybe just... know that it's still creepy. Sweet, but creepy.

Amy Cadence

i love romcoms and i love this video thank you

Amy Cadence

oh i just got to the part about the inside forest and i love that too but could we please also have like a lazy river or some kind of water in addition to the ball pit ponds

Amy Cadence

hmm ok i think my secret room would be like a climate controlled plant room, like near my house there is this plant store, and they have something called “the desert room” and i love going in there so i think i want to put that in my house and make it secret for no reason

Aishinn

My secret room would just be a planetarium room. Star Projector, dark blue walls, big bean bag chairs, and random glow-in-the-dark items.

Blck 7

The $2 a month I spend on this Patreon might be the best value of my entire life so far.

anya k

i just really can’t take him seriously as a romantic lead lol the only sandler/barrymore rom com I like is blended and that’s supposed to be a comedy. pretty sure he takes her to hooters on their first date? that, I buy coming from adam sandler

anya k

it’s something about his voice too idk like he’ll do some big speech and I can’t help laughing like this is the turkey song guy

Brendan Krafty

Hi Jenny, please go to Fyre Fest 2 so you can tell us all about it thanks ♥️

Medianox_Astrum

My secret room would be covered in paper, floor to ceiling, and be full of art supplies. The point of the secret art room is not to make good art, but fun art. You can’t be too messy with paint, clay, charcoal, etc, because the room is protected by the paper which can be swapped out or even used as a canvas itself. It’s kind of a sensory play room mixed with a vent space if that makes sense. Though, similar to the piano problem, I don’t know how to keep it a secret when I always leave the room covered in smudges of dirt and random colors.

Cos★Atlantic

Jenny Praising You've got Mail, my personal soft childhood obsession gives me so much joy <3 There's something so realistic, yet forgiving and friendly about the film that really feels spectrum friendly and nice <3

ChaseH

“I hope the groom brings a big dog catchers net” ah yes, just like in Stuck on a Blizzard with Jennifer Lawrence

Johan Hultcrantz

My secret room would be terrarriums with lizards

ChaseH

I don’t know what I’d put in a secret room, but my requirement is that it is a little door, that isn’t easily noticed, and requires an ornate key to open (similar to Coraline)

Marki Writes

The door to what I claim is my "secret room" leads to another hallway in my sprawling manor. The decor changes, no longer the Edwardian furnishings I seem to prefer but to a delicate French Racoco. After wandering some time you, my house guest, discover a strange woman you've never seen before. At first you think she's a ghost, but after going back you discover she is in fact my business competitor (in basketball.) Our manors are so large they are connected, unbeknownst to either of us. You fall in love with her, in a surprise twist the romcom is actually a thriller as you team up to plot my basketball demise. (I don't know how sports work)

Hannah Costanzo

My secret room would be an indoor pool with a hot tub. Like you would find at a hotel.

Andrew Godzak

My secret room would be a stingray pit. Just a giant hole with some stingrays and other aquatic life. The water will have loop de loops so the stingways will have some stimulation but I want to amass my own pet stingray.

Kelly Stiver

I’d be really curious if it worked at all with another male star.

Joe

I don't know that I would have a secret room that I actually used. But I might have one with a door that I would tell people not to open. There would, however, be clues scattered around the house with hints about how to open it. The curious and observant amongst my guests might pick up on those clues and decide to try their luck at seeing what was inside. Those that successfully pieced together the puzzle would unlock the door, opening it to see a tiny room with a few artificial skeletons inside. I would then come up behind them, exclaiming, "You got me!" And then everyone would laugh. Good times.

Riley M

Impeccable

Tricia

I haven’t put much thought into what my secret room would be but as a kid I always liked the hideaway in Out of the Box, so definitely something that was bigger on the inside

Gender_Pirate

My secret room is my Warhammer painting room, its obvious why it would be a secret :)

Alejandro De Anda

Patrick dempsey was in two of the movies discussed and the lead of one yet she wouldnt say his name. Shes got beef with mcdreamy

Alejandro De Anda

There are several bases in socal i think. Thus why people living near them may have rules like that for themselves? Idk

Nomnaut

Pinball Parlor. I don't know how creepy that would be.

Doom Spiraling

The ending of Kate and Leopold always left me with existential dread.

Alex the Naysayer

My secret room contains a model of the house with little stick figures representing who is in the house at that time

Alex the Naysayer

Does anyone remember the video where she talks about why she doesn’t like Bugs Bunny? Idk why it makes me laugh lol

Eric MacMillan

1 hour 40 minutes 12 seconds into the "Abandoned Animatronics" ramble

Big Z

Yesss I was thinking during that whole time that it was so SD coded

Sofia Fuentes

RETURN TO ME IS MY FAVORITE ROM COM IN THE WHOLE WORLD. THIS MADE MY DAY LMAO

Diana.H.

Secret room: Historical and Fantasy Weapons. You enter and it's like the knife display in Knives Out, with swords and rapiers and axes. Some of them are real antiques, some are based on movies. And in a corner, there's a bunch of mannequins with missing limbs, stab wounds, and disembodied heads.

Alex the Naysayer

Thanks for the exact time stamp! Had myself a laugh again.

Shay Olin Parker

This is insanely creepy regardless if it is a secret or not. I'm imagining the doll house in the Haunting of Bly Manor and the figures moving around on their own

ItsTommieBoi

Idk if this makes it better or worse but my secret room would be a bdsm dungeon with play space for little space and a little movie fort setup

ItsTommieBoi

🎵I think I've seen this film before 🎶

Mimi

mine would be indoor ninja warrior room complete with the lake of water underneath that you fall into, I think they would be a little scared at first but no one can resist an obstacle course

Mechelle Adams

My secret room would be a replica of one of those cave holes you fall into in Ocarina of Time. Complete with the spiders, chest, and a whole cow. You can hear the cow from the outside of the room but if anyone asks I deny the cow noise.

Pleiades

I keep seeing this video of a secret Minecraft room pop up on my Instagram and I think that's pretty cool but wouldn't work for me practically because I'm a grown adult with poor role-playing skills so what would I even do in there? Anyways I would keep a secret live-in artist who's like really famous which is why it's a secret and they only paint and sculpt me and maybe my bf if I'm feeling generous. Also Walt Disney's frozen head is in there cause why not

Hilary

27 Dresses - Wedding Vampire is my favorite take

Hilary

I love your secret room. That is my favorite secret room and I want it to exist so bad. I feel like my answer doesn't count maybe, but like a reading room behind a bookcase door, so like the existence of the room itself would be secret.

WestCoastSpy

I was waiting for 50 first dates to end up in this list, that movie is weird and so is that relationship

Darren Pierce

My secret room would be re-creation of the Horizons boarding queue. With the music playing 24x7. And if you turned that final corner, it would just lead to a black hallway that went nowhere. Or maybe there would be a David Lynch statue standing at the end of it. Nope, nobody would think I'm insane.

Jenny Nicholson

It's so funny to build that instead of building even one scene in the actual ride. Come on build the space kitchen or something

Darren Pierce

But there's the perpetual association of coming out of the Florida oven into the blasting air conditioning and being the only one in line (on most days). And picking one ride scene would be like picking a favorite child. (It's the faux undersea station.)

Jenny Nicholson

A rich basketball player whose whole house is rooms from Horizons but his secret room is from some shameful ride like the Jimmy Fallon one

Dr Bananas DDS

I’m just now watching last months video and right off the bat you also mention a faux-forest saw trap to kill Evan Hansen, and now I have more questions about your secret room 😧

Kimberly

somebody needs to write that heart-hopping scifi fan fiction. it's like the opposite of Never Let Me Go.

John Alonzo

Happy Easter Jenny! Also, all the Jennyites!

Wife of Horse Husband

My secret room is a giant bathroom. But like the most luxurious and fantastic bathroom I can think of, and I can’t think very well, but I would like moss and vines and fairy lights and a giant bathtub that’s a spiral that you walk into to get to the center that gets warmer as you go into the center so you don’t have to deal with the temperature too-hot-too-cold hot potato dance. Also a reclining chair and a huge vanity and many fancy makeup and stuff to put on (I don’t wear or know how to use makeup btw). I would like some rats/ small animals that would not mind living there with me and I can also try to build an ecosystem that allows them to thrive but not overpopulate without me, so meaning maybe I would need like a fox or two, but yeah. That’s my secret room and I think it’s actually quite viable, and I think if my husband or kids find it, other than being perplexed that they never found this room before, they would be like, “Ah actually this makes sense for her”, so I think I’m safe on the creepy factor.

Tricia

I’d say Princess and the Frog is a good execution of the ladykiller falling in love trope, there’s probably some animes that pull it off too

Kyran

that giant gen 3 mlp is insane i love her so much

Gregory Dyke

When I saw the title of the video, I was hoping "You've got mail" would get the thrashing it deserves and I was sadly disappointed. Tom hanks spends at least 2/3 of the movie lying to Meg Ryan and her first reaction on finding out is essentially "I really hoped you were lying to me the whole time"? That relationship is going to spectacularly go up in flames (and they will lowkey both deserve it)

wheeliescoot

this being like the third video in a row where you mention the faux-forest is taking me out

Merglo Mclaughlin

Losing over the army propaganda movie "Yes my friend is racist but hes also saving you personally so its fine that he's racist. So shut up." And shes like "so true i will right a pro army song now"

Natalie Arnold

This sounds like my actual animal crossing house's bathroom, weirdly enough

Allison

still no luck on the youtube mirror?

mike evans

I want Jenny to rank Disney animated couples based on how likely they'll last more than ten years together 🤣

Sam

My secret room is another smaller house. One of those mini houses Where everything is an arms width away and things fold up to make everything fit. It has a small lawn so you can appreciate the compact construction of it as you approach, and a skylight.

Kael

my secret room is a Belle library that somehow doesn't allow for technology like cell phones to work. Which is creepy and scary inherently but it would be to force me to concentrate on reading and writing without distractions. Also I am a horror writer so I think my secret writing room being a little scary would be to my benefit. And if I died in there, I think even my loved ones would appreciate the lore of it.

Kael

btw as kids we did find a real secret room. It was in an attic crawlspace that only a child could have found. You took off a vent thing in a bathroom and crawled along a dark narrow passage and all of a sudden it opened up to a little room with a chair and a rug and some sort of painting of something like a chicken. I wanted to keep it a secret from the adults but my sister immediately snitched. I still was able to hide there once when my Mom was losing her mind at me.

Thomas Watanabe

I've also been waiting for ages, but today I gave up and am just watching with the Patreon player lol You win (?) this time, YouTube

Tony Aiello

In the context of the question - I would have a secret room that is Jabba's Throne Room exact in every detail. And there would be mist and everything would be or seem to be slightly grimy in some way. That probably seems pretty normal except for the actors chained in there. Did I say that? There's actors dressed up and chained in there for when I'm on a basketball break. And I don't even dress as Jabba. I'd be one of those characters that super fans create entire histories about but you never hear them say anything or see them ever again and Wookiepedia calls out a specific Star Wars year and talks about how they were in Jabba's Throne Room for some reason.

Nico

Any update on the YouTube mirror? :O

Devin M.

YouTube mirror?

Eva Thurston

My secret room would be a small cozy pillow fort that is very well hidden, like with a hatch under a bed that you need to open with a coin or something... or just a pillow fort under a table or something. I think the least creepy secret room would be full of some valuable thing, because then its kinda just a shitty vault. Like if I found a secret room that was full of gold, I wouldnt be freaked out... just jealous LOL

Pelin C

My secret room would be a room full of knitting/weaving/etc. machines that i tinker and buy expensive parts for. There's also a lot of yarn hanging everywhere so it looks like it's the secret room of a radioactive spider. Very little garment comes out of the room, i frog almost everything, it's purely because i like to think about machines and fibers. Like a perpetual giga project.

TalkieSoundBox

My secret room would be full of thrifted scavenged junk I'm in the process of cleaning and repairing. I have this secret room. It is very messy. That's why it's secret.

Dana Stoof

It was really funny going from this video into the ramble from the previous month (I'm behind okay), because that video starts with a foam forest scenario. It's the Jenny foam forest cinematic universe spanning both space and time.

win

so the runaway bride - was julia roberts roped into that with some sneaky underhanded contract, or blackmail? because the plot sounds like a julia roberts biopic, including her ditching the groom keiffer surherland and running off with the best man jason patric. if only i had the motivation to go look up the timeline of when the movie was released and compare to her relationships.

Nimnul

I feel so validated to hear you talking about 'You've got Mail'. I was a teenager when my mom brought it home as our first ever film on DVD and the whole family watched it. And now, in the modern day, my brother and I joke about how today Tom Hanks' chain store would be cast as the victim of Amazon.

Neal Chauhan

Is the YouTube link still down?

Kelly Evans

Does anyone know the story of how she got that giant pony? 😍 is it new??

Jenny Nicholson

Yes, it actually received new claims on a couple other clips which also have to be disputed. Which concerns me because I was planning to upload a Barbie preview and the next ramble this week and having 3 struck videos at once can jeopardize a small channel. I'm considering removing it and trying a new upload, or I could give up putting clips in the new ramble

Rachell Hayes

We appreciate you working on it for us. Sorry you’re having to deal with all that just to put out something fun.

Danny Hilzenrath

I want my secret room to be an outside area. The door will open to a secret secluded outside area. It is actually an exit

Lucia Pacciola

My secret room would be a storage unit full of childhood memorabilia and family heirlooms that I don't have much use for, but would break my mom's heart if I actually got rid of it all. It's a secret because how do you explain that to someone?

Louis Z

It wandered in from the plush forest that surrounds Jenny’s house

Tessa

Oh my god. Your how to lose a guy in 10 days airplane movie rant just brought back a core memory for me. Funnily enough flying from Australia to the US - my channel I got in a delirious loop on was the Johnny Depp Willy Wonka film, and I would wake up from shockingly bad sleep at the same toothpaste factory moment every single time. I felt like I was going insane.

Timothy Nelson

Anyway I'm sure someone has said this but my secret room would be a plain room filled only with the Buzzy animatronic.

Alysha Troxell

My secret room would be an elaborate bathroom. Huge comfy tub, a fridge, big TV, all of the bubble baths and bath bombs and salts. Candles everywhere. Led lights to change the mood. It would have to be secret because I'm a basket ball man and my teammates would make fun of me for my elaborate self care room. They would know about my love for being submerged in hot water though

John Alonzo

My secret room would hold the executive in charge of Youtube disputes hostage until he approves Jenny's video. That's legal, right? : /

Sunny Hornbaker

13:59 i wish i was kidding, that is the exact plot of the DC comics couple Hawk Man & Hawk girl, they have reincarnations dating back to egypt, they're always fated to meet and die horribly

Jana

Some of my favourite rom-coms are 'Keeping the Faith', 'Saving Face', and 'Practical Magic' (if that counts?). But I wondered if you've seen "Jenny's Wedding" (if that counts?!) because it's a really bad movie. My secret room would probably be considered creepy and worrying in terms of Health & Safety as I kind of just want a fun gym with climbing walls, a trampoline, and indoor parkour training set-up.

Quality Street

My secret room would be a collection room of everything I consider a guilty pleasure and wish I was ashamed of, so no one would know about: CDs of music I like, mangas I love but are too weird to talk about, books I have read and reread whose cover I can't display in my house, my ice cream plastic spoon collection... That's not very original but it would be really scary for my partner to find.

Emma Burgess

The being against dating military guys is absolutely a thing near bases. I should know I was of that opinion in the puget sound my whole life lol

Rebecca Starling

my secret room would be a room full of all the clown memorabilia i can find from second hand shops, because there's been at least one clown thing in like 80% of the second hand shops i've visited. I'd buy them all, and store them lovingly in my secret room.

Echo Cian

My secret room is my craft room, and it's soundproofed because I have misophonia and I want to go in there and not need my headphones on the entire time Or if I'm rich enough to have a secret room I'm rich enough to also have a bunch of my little ponies, plushies, and music boxes. I show this to guests with all the appropriate acting about it being a secret, but I show it to like everyone so it's purely for the aesthetics and fun of having a secret room

Maddie Moreland

My secret room would have floor-to-ceiling shelves stuffed with my plushie collection and cosplay stuff. I’d like to have at least one full-size human mannequin, ideally either sitting at a tea party or behind a desk in a “we’ve been expecting you” type pose. Edit: I’m going to double down on the mannequins and deck my plushie/cosplay secret room with at least eight of them, each decorated in beautiful costumes from various eras of fashion in completely innocuous poses like fancy ladies at high tea. The Tea Room.

RainyMeadows

My rich guy secret room would be a gaming room with bookshelves full not only with games, but also with anime DVDs, manga and light volume novels and figurines. However, contrary to the weirdo otaku stereotype, all the figurines would be of either male characters or wholly unsexualised female characters, and a dartboard with Sasuke Uchiha's face on it.

May

I do want to say that it's bizarre to realize that the current president of the US, who nowadays is a notorious fascist who openly desires the genocide of me and many of my friends, just sort of used to show up in a load of movies for no reason other than that he was rich and famous. Isn't that kind of strange? Like if a normal society was possible, it probably wouldn't do that right?

Benjamin Cruzat

I'm so sorry, my rich guy space would be a spacious soundproof room with a concert grand piano. You cant play the piano at odd hours, even an electronic keyboard with headphones can cause a racket with the physical sound of the keys being pressed. A room where I can just go and play whenever I need or want sounds amazing. Walking into the basement of an otherwise normal house to find a recreation of a blockbuster store might force me out of the house. The liminal vibes might kill me.

Eric Houge

This has probably been noted already, but the twist Jenny imagines for 27 Dresses where the heroine ends the movie single and appreciating herself without needing a romance to "complete" her is basically the ending for Muriel's Wedding. Great movie, amazing performance by Toni Collette.

Nicole Williams

In Purple Heart her name should have been Valorie and they could have called her stolen Valerie

Callie Bagley

I love to find other people and especially other families who have an extreme appreciation of you've got mail, it's like the official movie of every woman in my family, we LOVE IT

Claudia

Its so funny watching this when the current topic winning during may is "remember every movie you've ever seen." Like she warned us!

Claudia

Okay one more thing. I almost married for health insurance so I spent a long time looking into it and its not illegal, it's not a scam, even in military situations. The government does NOT legislate whether or not you are in love - unless immigration is involved, you can get married for any reason

Mary Kelly

i think i actually would want a soundproof room for singing, playing instruments, and doing voices. because i enjoy all those things, but i am also extremely embarrassed to be witnessed practicing something before i am good at it. if i was mega rich, I'd probably see a therapist about that, but in the meantime a soundproof room would be perfect.

Hodgkin LeBlanc

"I think that's the most offensive part of the movie, is the title."

Wild Wesley

I WILL NEVER FORGET MADE OF HONOR!!! My mom dragged me and my best friend to see that movie with her and her friend, who also brought her 4 year old daughter. We were both 12 and didn’t want to be there and the theater was empty other than us, so we sat far away from my mom and loudly reacted to the movie the whole time. I’ll never forget my friend yelling, “OH NO! HER COINS!” when the female lead dropped a bowl of coins when they kissed. I’m also pretty sure that I learned about anal beads from that movie… It’s one of my favorite movie theater experiences ever, but I never had the urge to revisit the movie itself, but it started a tradition of my best friend and I deliberately picking bad movies to see in theaters because we could loudly react in an empty theater and make ourselves laugh.

Kush Melwani

All this Jane Nichols slander. God forbid a woman have a multicultural wedding hobby...

Eskana Kana

I love "27 Dresses"! It's my favorite romcom. I think it works, but I get her criticism. On the other hand, I can't stand "You've Got Mail" because I always hated that he ruined her business and all she's got in the end is a corner in his store. The original, "Shop Around the Corner," is a lot better

Eskana Kana

My secret room would be a secret garden with a pond that has goldfish, and if I couldn't have real plants and trees I would have fake ones. I'd paint the walls to look like the rest of the garden.

Ayples

Dang I love How to Lose a Guy in 10 Days and My Best Friend's Wedding; spicy takes. I love an impromptu singalong. But my secret room would be a replica of the Pokemon Channel bedroom. With a replica themed tv, like maybe the Hoppip one hooked up with the game on Gamecube. The cards, the Plush. A sliding door to a fake backyard. My childish smeagle masterpieces. Sigh.

Ava Boo

Silver Linings Playbook is one of the couples that work out I think. That movie rules.

LizardHats

When you were describing the one about the gorilla keeper, for a moment I thought you were going to say “she dies in a car accident and her heart gets donated to one of the gorillas” and that the movie was about a guy trying to come to terms with the fact that his wife was reincarnated into a gorilla. I can imagine why that relationship wouldn’t work out.

Tracy Christenson

Not surprised to learn that you don't like Matthew McConaughey as a romantic lead. After all, you did turn him into a spider once.

Tracy Christenson

My secret room: It's a library, but it's a library of all the books that I like to read or want to read but I think people would tease me for reading - every children's book that I'm still deeply attached to, the cheesiest manga/light novels in existence, books that I like to make jokes about because they're corny but are still funny/fun to read. I just need a place to put all this stuff that I don't want every casual visitor to see and make jokes about but I still can't stand to get rid off because I get so attached to books in general. The chairs are a variety of things that are really comfy to sit in, including bean bag chairs, but nothing matches. There's no aesthetic involved, just a bunch of stuff I like. All the wall space that doesn't have bookshelves has a bunch of drawings that I've done but they're not great, so I don't want to show them off to anybody.

Tracy Christenson

After thinking it over some more, I think I'd also include a mini kitchenette or snack station so I can hang out there for small meals and snacks. That's where I'd keep all the food I like that either nobody else likes or things I just don't want to share with anybody. I also want two desks or work tables for art projects and writing projects, and while I'm at it, I'll throw in a sewing area! This is just a space for all the things I want to do that I don't want anybody interfering with, projects that may or may not work out, and books and hobbies that I enjoy but other people would find weird or laughable.

Milo

I so badly want to say that my secret room would be something nice like an indoor garden or something, or a nice room for my trinkets, but I know myself. I know it would be figurines, and I know there would be 1000 Hatsune Miku figures, and I know it would be a secret because I would be mortified if anyone saw

Bailey M

My secret room would be one of those liminal town scenes that you'll occasionally stumble on in museums. Like, it would just be a quaint little American main street with a faux sky that transitions from day to night and plays constant looping sounds of horse clopping, cricket chirps, and the occasional firework. I've always found these types of scenes equal parts unnerving and peaceful. The only caveat to this secret room is that I probably wouldn't be able to keep it secret for very long, because I'm too much of a chicken to populate the shops with mannequins and, knowing me, I'd get too lonely after a while. How long does it have to stay secret? Can I only let my basketball boyfriend inside, or can I let in more people as time goes on? I want to host movies for the little league team in the cinema and have pie eating contests in the town square, both of which aren't solo activities.

Audrey Lopata

The worst part of “the Prince and Me” is when she takes of her shoes to dance barefoot with a broom across the floor of the dingy dark dive bar where she works. Though possibly this shows she was meant to be a princess all along… impervious to vomit and crushed up peanut shells when overcome by the need to prance about.

Markus D

I think that movie is "Accidental Activist"? At least that's what it sounds like.

Alice Lastname

That sounds like an awesome library!

mia

Avalon Green

The power of money and notoriety is frankly terrifying

MachoLangelo

Thank you for explaining the pony. New member here.

Joshua Billie

isn't "Julia Roberts" fully pregnant at the end of Notting HIll?

Danielle Schatten

in fairness! he's only president because he was fully purchased by a white south african nepo baby billionaire who at the time wasn't eligible for the role under what little law was left in this joke of a nation!

Danielle Schatten

i know this is probably you indulging your love for stingrays and their enrichment but I am picturing you as an extremely odd Bond villain from one of the lower-ranked Roger Moore movies

Janiebe

Agreed that Hugh Grant is at his best in rom coms when he is in shy, hesitant, nerdy depressed mode, rather than cocky “charmer”. Two other movies where he has that persona that I like, though neither is a traditional rom com: The Englishman Who Went Up a Hill and Came Down a Mountain, and Sense & Sensibility

Nate Rehkopf

Mine would probably be a private movie theater, with a collection of all the movies I could possibly want, but in their most collectable version like steelbooks, criterion collection etc.

Jimbo

Hugh Grant also plays against type in Bridget Jones, because he actually DOES cheat on her. I pray you one day do a video on what i call the Mungoverse (hugh grant cinematic universe) bc looking at his entire filmography set against each other is insane the guy has like maybe three distinct modes of acting but they slap every time

a simple rabbit

58:06 i went to university in a city with a major military school in it and i did in fact have a 'no military' dating policy

Ali Tucker

My secret room would be an indoor, peaceful (i.e. childfree and probably sound proof) oasis. There would be some kind of water - a pond, waterfall or both - with a designated reading area as well as a separate listening area with a lot of my headphone/audio equipment collection safely stored but easily accessible. Plus a mini fridge with drinks and snacks. So far, so normal - right? Then the room would be adorned with my favorite succulents and carnivorous plants….and I’d have attractive, but species-appropriate, habitats for some of my favorite reptiles and invertebrates. Also a high quality sound system to set the ambiance. Anyone who found my secret room would know a lot more about me but be left with an infinite number of questions. 🤷‍♀️

Ali Tucker

I had not heard of this, but it looks amaaaazing! I live in southern Ohio so I will definitely be keeping an eye on this!

Ali Tucker

Let me clarify - I am not a child-hater. I actually have 7 kids (two sets of twins - we never planned to have this many). I am used to being smothered with love, so a super-secret, quiet adult place would be exactly what my exhausted 36yo soul needs! 🤣

Lupa Wick

At the risk of sounding a bit stupid, this is such a main character memory. Man, I wish I had memories like that. But Idk how to find movies that are bad enough to warrant an empty theatre, or how to get one of my friends to go like in the middle of a weekday to avoid crowds

Jack Dees

You've Got Mail is a remake of a 1930s movie called Little Shop Around the Corner. It starred Jimmy Stewart.

Jack Dees

Sleepless in Seattle is the best Tom Hanks/Meg Ryan pairing. The soundtrack is awesome.

Thornsilver Hollysong

I have a non-secret piano room in my house, which coincidentally is also my housemate's non-secret sewing room. I hope they don't find out about me.

Rigmarole

I always thought it would be fun to have a secret room behind a giant bookcase, where you pull a book to rotate the bookcase into a room of - more bookcases. There's a comfy chair and it's just a nice peaceful reading nook.

mink

My secret room would be a murder basement

Rocky Raccoon

My secret room is full of Funko Pops

Soup j

That military rom com you talked about sounded like the most genuinely abhorrent movie ever

Elle

Not netflix producing a US Army propaganda romcom

La_campanella_

The plot of Purple Heart kills me because I’ve met people in the army who got married for mutually beneficial reasons and were just roommates lmao. Like it’s one of the more stable military marriage types I’ve seen.

Lucia Pacciola

"Through gorilla magic, and also soul magic."

Al Mayhugh

REMEMBER ME MENTIONED I LOVE THAT MOVIE. I love the surprise jumpscare 9/11

rainbowchewynuggets

I’m late to the party and have a very typical answer, but i’d want a secret miniatures room. Train sets. Tiny farms with tiny animals. Theme parks and city blocks with working electricity. Swing-open dollhouses. Maybe even fantasy sets that require some thought to make structurally possible. Real-life minecraft/sim game room basically.

Cammi Kemonochu

I have two secret rooms I’d want.. a mirror collection room cuz I love mirrors, and a human sized cat tree room/hamster tube room where I could climb into comfy cubbies and nap… presumably I could combine the rooms… would need at least a skylight window cuz I hate the idea of spending a long period of time in a room without windows or natural light of any kind.

Mackenzie Nicholson

You've Got Mail is also my pet romcom lol. Have you seen The Shop Around the Corner, the Jimmy Stewart movie it's based on? It's very fun, highly recommend.

Taylor Garcia

Runaway Bride is a bad concept for a romcom but a great concept for a character study centering on loneliness in the modern era

Taylor Garcia

I understand what you mean but I do think it’s possible to be a very, very social butterfly with friends from different periods of life (your college friends vs. your work friends vs. your childhood friends) also my interpretation is just that she has horrible horrible boundaries so she said yes to both weddings but she wanted to preserve the magic of both weddings so she devised the whole scheme

Taylor Garcia

Oh god the couple in Jenny’s Wedding is ABSOLUTELY breaking up

randa

love this video! is the youtube mirror still under dispute?

Molly

I think I did watch You've Got Mail maybe when we used to rent movies from the video store growing up. But when I was in college studying musical theater in the early 2010s someone introduced me to the musical She Loves Me, and described it as adapted from the same source material as You've Got Mail. Like as though of course I'd have heard of this famous movie even if I didn't know the musical. So it's interesting that it's considered obscure itself.

sophia

Secret pool with jungle theming omfg

Kerry Lynn

It’s not an obscure film. It made $250 million in 1998. It’s a certified blockbuster.

Stew

I’ve actually been avoiding watching this one because EVERYONE trashes You’ve Got Mail and it’s one of my all time favorite comfort movies. So hearing that you also like it and quote it endlessly with family was a huge relief, although I was willing to hear your hot takes on it if you didn’t like it haha! I made a video of random stuff my mom and I quote for a Mother’s Day gift and a HUGE chunk of it was stuff from this movie alone, it’s a household classic

Bkasmokiog2020

Wait as a native San Diegan it low-key is a big military town...

Faith King

I will say you can just be in the army - it's so funny to hear people talk about the military when they didn't grow up in it. All of the branches are called The Armed Forces and the brances are the Army, the Air Force, the Navy, the Marines, the Coast Guard, and more recently the Space Force.

Enjelika Ana

As much as I absolutely LOVE sleepless in Seattle and have watched it multiple times - Meg Ryan’s character is suspect in it. Legit having an emotional affair stalking another man who isn’t her boyfriend

Randy Alvarado

Secret room has a tunnel with rail-like vehicle that takes me far away to an underground, air conditioned room, where i can observe wildlife in the local woods that's mostly focused around a large pond. The room has a large glass panel that's half submerged in the water so I can see all the underwater creatures but is mirrored or something on the other side so the animals can't see me and be sacred away.

Emma

Honestly, same! Sorry Jenny but a soundproofed room in my house where I can play music and not disturb anyone else sounds awesome.

Emma

I’m so against people saying You’ve Got Mail is a toxic relationship! It’s never a secret that they are in competition as retailers, and although her store goes out of business eventually it’s not because he is such an evil predatory corporate shark who decides to take her down specifically and then feels guilty later. It’s just…capitalism. And they do genuinely become real friends afterwards so she already forgave him before they become romantically involved. And the secret pen pal thing is the romcom premise part so I agree with Jenny that it gets a pass through suspension of disbelief.

Emma

I agree! I am (and I think the movie is too) way more judgemental of the brides who seem to be asking this woman they don’t know all that well to be their bridesmaid just because she’s so fantastic at wedding planning. Like why would she be at the cake tasting with you? That’s so unreasonable to ask.

Maddie

the newspaper version of women posting their L's made me laugh

Cova Brouwer Gentry

My dream for a house someday is actually to have a dedicated snake/reptile room. I felt so seen when you mentioned a snake room in your video because that’s my perfect DREAM. But how could I make it a secret?? I would desperately want to show EVERYONE all of my snakes whenever they came over!!

Cova Brouwer Gentry

Can we be friends? This is way cooler than my snake room

Cova Brouwer Gentry

Well it won’t be a secret to the people taken down and murdered in there, so in a way it’s nice you’ll be forced to share it with someone

mink

So true and there’s no way they can tell anyone my secret either

liminalspaces

Jenny: I don't know anything about the army. Me: Yeah, me neither! *Jenny talks about "the army"* Me: Oh my god, she REALLY doesn't know anything about the army.

NuriCarmen

58:36 "So we're good enough to fight for your ass [etc]" just made me inadvertently blurt an all-caps "EW" in the middle of a crowded skytrain. (Update: "aye-rab" just got a second "EW;" this dialogue is so gross lol). Can we track down whoever is responsible for Purple Heart and try them at the Hague? Dozens of strangers staring at you at 9am feels like it ought to be a war crime. Also, this movie is rated 69% 'fresh' by audience members on Rotten Tomatoes, which makes me genuinely feel like I have more in common with my cats than I do with several members of my own species. This day is turning out to be bleaker and more uncomfortable than I was anticipating.

NuriCarmen

Speaking of being uncomfortable, my secret room would contain all the terrible decor items I want to own, but know people will judge me for having. These include: enormous artisanal German meat plushies, a functional lamp that is also a taxidermy chicken with a lightbulb in its butt, unsettling Mascots of Yore, and any item of furniture that either looks like food but isn't, or has teeth and/or udders, but shouldn't. Full disclosure, this secret room is something I've already made plans for irl, since many of these items are affordable enough for me to own, but - hypocritically - if I went to someone's house and they had even a few of them just sitting out like it was normal, I would assume that person was a serial killer.

Madi Sheppard

Owen Hunt jumpscare warning for Made of Honor

Ellis Richburg

I can’t wait until I get through law school so I can follow some rich asshole around while he goes shopping 😂

Aubrey P.

Unfortunately my secret room would be full of Hatsune Miku figures

Katherine Harrison

I assumed the secret room would be like a 50 shades of gray kink playroom type thing. Which I think is actually the least creepy type of secret room you can have, because if it's a sex thing at least I immediately understand why it's a secret

Silky

I've been told by people more familiar with the US military than I am that it's a common joke that if you're a woman visiting a base, you'll be married by the time you leave because all the soldiers want those sweet benefits. It's crazy that the movie portrays this as such a huge deal that everyone has qualms about. I mean the movie just seems awful over all, that scene where they harrass the poor waitress at the bar just immediately wiped any romantic potential in my eyes. Just awful. Clearly whoever wrote this just loves the military and wanted to fantasize about taming a shrew or whatever.

Lindoriell

If it could be a large basement space, theoretically because I have ALL the money, or maybe even better a huge attic space, my dream would be to divide it into four room, each one being themed on The Lord of the Rings (using the movie aesthetic). First room would be a cosy Hobbit/Bag End themed reading nook, with the big fire and the wood panelling and beams and the comfy cushioned chairs and lots of little cozy knicknacks filling the space. Second would be a big Elven Rivendell inspired bathroom, with a massive infinity pool-like tub that fills with water from a beautiful Elven statue (like the Greek ones of a woman holding a big jug that pours endless water) and all that good Art Nouveau styling and twinning plants and a fainting couch I can lounge about on like Arwen as I dramatically lose my mortality. Third would be a Dwarven style crafting room, so I can pretend to forge the One ring in a dark cavernous space lit by torchlight and just randomly hammer stuff to hear it eacho off the walls. And the last would be a Rohirrim style room, very Anglo-Saxon in style, to hold one woman banquets and loudly toast to myself as I tear into roasted boar legs and swill ale and mead. This room would also have a crown, because you obviously have to wear that while swilling mead. Actually, now that I think about it, if I had the money I'd just do this to my actual house, each room LOTR themed and I'd be telling everyone around it. I have no shame.

Ham

100% up for The Wedding Vampire being a real movie

Tom

Non-creepy secret room idea: secret political or criminal conspiracy. So, like, The Ladykillers, or what Leonard Leo and the Federalist Society have been doing for 40 years. Whatever else it is, it's not creepy.

Ham

"Stop crying. I'm the one who has to walk out of here alone..."

Ham

My brother designed one of these for a an office he worked at. The actual hidden space was just an unfinished loft area you had to climb a funky ladder to get to, but the secret-book latch really worked.

Ham

I thought about this, but I'd want to use it to show movies to other people.

Ham

I'm just gonna say, you have no idea

Jaymes Valentine Walker

I think a secret room that's just a study/library that you enter through a bookshelf would not be creepy cause you'd go through and be like "oh yeah, this is what a secret room is obviously, this is whimsical and fun and mysterious but not scary

Kat

I think that the main character of 27 Dresses isn't obsessed with weddings so much as she is just a big pushover. That's her major character flaw, which is why she goes along with everything her sister was doing, and why she said yes to two weddings on the same night. She does love weddings, the opening scene of her as a kid establishes that. But it's more about her saving the day and wanting to be seen as helpful and kind. Even if that means putting other people's wants and needs ahead of her own.

Miss Moxie

I love the Charjabug. I just can’t figure out what it’s made of. Paper? Clay?

Jenny Nicholson

It is a (probably bootleg) deck box! So it's fabric on the outside and probably cardboard underneath keeping the shape

greedlikes

in my secret room: from wall to wall pictures pasted onto it of roxy lalonde from homestuck. in the middle of the room will be several life sized, quarter sized, and half sized sculptures and 3D custom models of roxy lalonde from homestuck. nu pastel portraits of roxy lalonde from homestuck will be displayed all around the room done by me cuz thats my fav traditional medium. idk do u get the vibe? roxy lalonde room. pretty obvious. possible creep factor is realism portraits of what i think roxy would look like irl so maybe youd just think i have a weird obsession with an individual in my life idk

Nomascus gabrielli

I think it would be to cool to have a home version of the technology that Disney uses for O Canada. A circlevision experience. Where I could lay on comfy furniture in the middle of the room and turn on the Amazon rainforest or the Alps or a forest or the Sonoran Desert or Cairo or wherever. Not a traveling through the space, but just projecting it so I can feel like I'm sitting on a terrace overlooking the sea on Santorini or whatever I want.

Patricia

Wait! I always thought that in 27 dresses she became a wedding planner and she wanted to support the first bride up until the first dance/reception and had to rush to her next bride! I watched as a kid, it IS kinda weird if she was just chasing weddings

Evan Bobrow

Jane Mulcahy has a good video about Purple Hearts which I recommend to anyone who’s interested in it, that movie is truly insane

Fishfacee

literally the only room that wouldn’t be bad to conceal is a weed farm, because its understandable to want to keep secret

Luke La Vasseur

@JennyNicholson as a a Luke who was in the Army….and by Army, I mean Navy; you nailed the explanation! Also how do you know enough about Military culture to know frivolous marriages are a thing, but not know the difference between the Army and Marines? I know this comment sounds really sarcastic, but I didn’t mean it that way…Love your videos!!!!

beeps

my secret room would be a fully decorated fantasy wizard's greenhouse with lots of light and plants and various orbs to ponder and real oil paintings i've commissioned, but the main aspect would be a pristine roller rink.... don't enter my secret roller derby druid attic!!!!!!!!!!!!! just dont do it!!!!!!!!!!!!!

Tabitha Griffin

I want a secret animatronic room. I already have animatronics all over my house but hiding them in a room like behind a bookcase that reveals itself in a cool way sounds fun

Ari

My secret room would be the McDonald’s playroom with a whole bunch of tunnels that seem never ending

GundamBradley

Hmm, maybe a big room full of 1/12 dioramas and dollhouses.

Dane Roberts

The fact that Matthew McConaughey’s criticism of Kate Hudson is “you took me to a Celine Dion concert” 😂 and you’re MAD about that??

angel equus

did the youtube mirror of this one ever pass the dispute? i love to watch on tv 🙏

Elyse

Exactly. This aspect of her personality is backed up by her over-investment at work and bending over backwards for her boss despite being secretly in love with him

Eva

adding overboard to this list for my own sanity (one of my all time faves but the betrayal seems so insane i can’t stand by that pair)

Lindsay M.H.

I feel like Purple Hearts guy probably could have just gotten a loan as a military service member and paid the drug dealer back without mentioning his marriage scam.

Madeline

DUDE The Wedding Planner is so horrific hahahaha and nobody I know has seen it

Wild Wesley

It’s a bit easier to do nowadays after the pandemic and the rise of streaming since people don’t go to theaters as often. I often end up in theaters by myself or near alone. It also depends on what day of the week and what time you go as well as how populated a place you live. The last crazy fun theater experiences I had were seeing anime movies or going on a day off in the middle of the week during the daytime. I saw the Haikyuu (the volleyball anime) movie in theaters and lucked out that the only other people there were other super fans of the anime who were in cosplay so we were treating it like we were at an actual sports event and jumping and cheering together.

Absoludicrous Blog

My secret room would obviously be my huge massive g1 my little pony collection lovingly arranged on shelves in a beautiful and aesthetic way

Scrum Diddely Umptious

Omg I just for no reason remembered that as a child when I couldn't sleep I used to imagine how I could install a secret panic compartment in my bed because I was so terrified of the dark (and also I think burglers, lol). Do all kids just experience so much random anxiety all the time or was it just me?? Jeez

Patrick Windrose

My pro-baller secret room in my mansion would be comprised of a tight Escheresque maze that holds books and snacks. Little nooks sequestered everywhere so that when you find a book you want to enjoy, you have only to roll a couple feet to find your butt in a perfectly molded literary womb. But you need to pay $10 each time you want to leave the room, for any reason. Judge me.

ruupert

My secret room would be a display/storage space for all the crafting projects I get inspired to make but ultimately have no use for. Just this morning I saw a tiktok of a massive crochet crocodile plush. It's so big that it takes over a whole three seater couch. It would be so cool to make that and have it but also so inconvenient. I would love to have a secret room for that kind of stuff.

kelly m

this video is such a good and cozy vibe. one of my fav patreon videos for sure ❤️❤️

EaselEar

Burglars specifically were a big one for me as a kid, I've never felt so seen

Dakota Rolfe

My secret room is definitely like a Power Rangers armory-style room, where I have screen used and replica props, suits, and ideally, some of the vehicles 😬

Danielle Schatten

capitalism is a toxicity on human existence and its relationship to our species has been abusive since we entered it so there's that

Emily Freedman

my secret room would be my own personal disney world recreated with all the best iterations of old attractions

Jules B.

it's crazy how literally anything that shows the military in even a vaguely positive light can't hide how bloodthirsty and racist the average us soldier is

Faux Moe

I am so glad you mentioned the prince and me. As a Danish person I am particularly baffled by that movie. Why does the prince have to be from Denmark if they're just gonna make up everything about the country instead of like, a vaguely European fictional country like they did in princess diaries? Why do they all have british accents if they're danish? Why add the stupid conflict that the prince can't marry non royalty or whatever when that clearly happened with Frederik and Mary and everyone was cool with it and it was totally fine?

CosmicSharkGal

My secret room would be full of Legend of Zelda, G4 MLP, Final Fantasy and Homestuck merch. It’d be like half gamer set up but also like a chamber bedroom a princess would sleep in. I’d also have a huge trans flag over my bed,

Sarah B

My favourite rom couple hands down is Evelyn and Rick from The Mummy. I'm not sure if it's considered a romcom though, it's more rom adventure

Nina Elms

Yes, a "no military"/active duty military/first responders dating policy is a thing some people have irl. I come from a family with a long history of military service, and I've heard some of the women in my family talk about not wanting relationships with service members or first responders (unless they've transitioned to desk work) because of the all worry they saw their mothers go through. I think having strong feelings about that (one way or the other) is more of a thing Army/Marine/etc brats go through though specifically because of their upbringing

ItAllComesBackToTheWall

I really love that Jenny said “Army” every time instead of “Marines” because it’s the branch most likely to get mad about the distinction, AND this is behind a paywall so they can’t even oorah in the comments without having paid to do so

BedWords

i am wondering the same thing! i basically can't watch on the patreon app

Rachel

"Hunting brown people for sport is bad, but not as bad as harshing the vibe at a party" is a fascinating take to find in a romantic comedy, not least of all because the prince from Red White & Royal Blue is saying it to the daughter of Snow White's evil queen.

Ev

So it's January, but my secret room would be a very well organized cleaning closet with vacuums lining the walls, buckets, mops, different chemicals and one set of yellow rubber gloves...

Lord Atlan

My secret room would be a giant walk-in aquarium, like one of the tunnels you'd walk through at the Georgia or Virginia Aquariums. But at the same time, that *couldn't* be a secret room, because I'd need to hire at least one other person to help me take care of it. I guess an actual secret room I'd have might be a big Lego city display

alex

the concept of a grown man professional basketball player who's probably 7 feet tall playing in his hidden indoor forest room

Zebulon Pike

Clearly, Jenny didn't watch the incest cut of Kate and Leopold, where (really) the guy Meg Ryan is dating in the beginning turns out to be her grandson after she gets together with Hugh Jackman in the past.

Succulent Creams

Mine is filled with ever conceivable kind of Pokémon merchandise

Raegan Garlitz

I love that she started with you've got mail, because I don't love many romcoms, but I love you've got mail

frawgs

i hope the youtube mirror gets posted one day i love this ramble

Frankie Gallagher

Ok but what if it was a slide room? Then you could explain "oh it's my princess peach room, please don't go in" and then you're like "oh i get it, like Super Mario 64, Princess peach's secret slide okay"

Brielle Soto

Jenny, did you know You've Got Mail is originally based on the 1940's The Shop Around The Corner? It's such a heartwarming, romantic and cozy wintertime movie that I highly recommend :)

Fake Name

Screw you Youtube, and also screw you Patreon, for your crappy interface that makes everyone want Youtube mirrors, which I say with no anger toward Jenny herself, of whom I am a huge fan! >:( Grrrrr, grrrr I say, with a degree of anger that is reasonable for this minor issue!!!

The Alienated Librarian

My Harry Potter collection goes in the secret room. Plus probably holiday decorations because why waste the storage space.

Mady, you know, from TV

I have returned to this ramble several times and today what I am deeply enjoying is Jenny's take on 27 Dresses. I enjoyed that movie well enough and don't really share Jenny's perspective on the main character HOWEVER I think Jenny's perspective is a much funnier way to watch the movie. Wedding Vampire indeed. Also I have heard brides give speeches at weddings! Usually just a version of "thank you all for coming", sometimes co-delivered with the groom. At least one speech did feature each member of the wedding party being thanked (briefly) one by one, but aside from maybe calling out specific parents I don't think I've heard one that was like "thanks for coming, thanks to our wedding party for their help, but HUGE shoutout to my bff Jane who did all the work" LOL.

shai

the liberal character in purple heart is so bad for my blood pressure lol like girl you could be so much meaner please.....

KJ NE

Im not a wedding enthusiast like the 27 Dresses lady, but my job requires me to be at a lot of them, and I can confirm that brides do give speeches pretty regularly.

jess

I remember adoring 27 dresses when i was in grade seven? (I was wee) and for the longest time I thought that she ~was~ a wedding planner and now that you've shone the light, I'm just sitting here like ".. oh."

Cassidy Sinclair

My dream room is a secret witchy library. Big part of the dream is in fact keeping it a secret behind a bookcase door and disappearing for hours without anybody knowing where I’ve gone until one day my theoretical kids are given a key for their 13th birthday or something to mark their transition into teenagedom.

Rainy

I'm obviously late as hell but I think a no-military dating policy makes sense, even if you aren't near a military base. Me and my sisters wouldn't date people in the military for the same reasons we wouldn't date cops. Support of either isn't consistent with our views of the systems that surround both. It also is def influenced from our father being a veteran. I remember once he told us that if we ever join or associate with the military then he's somehow failed in the crucial role of guiding and advising us as he should.

J P

charjabug...

StuPot

I appreciate your existence.

marissa

my mom is a youve got mail mega fan she felt like she was the only one too lol! i watched it a lot with her as a kid

NeonMoonie

I was raised on You've Got Mail, it was one of my favorite movies as a kid and still is, and I can't help but agree that it feels as though every person ever forgot that movie existed even though it's peak.

Ginger Jones

This makes me respect it more as a work of art, tbh (I also enjoy that Hugh Jackman’s character is basically being pimped out by his evil uncle at the beginning, I feel like we don’t see enough of those types of plot lines with male main characters)

Mali Gray-Coyte

makes total sense to rule out dating guys whose entire occupation is "murder people"

mikeymasciola

this is me realizing that chain from 27 dresses wasn't a wedding planner, IDK I guess it just made it up

mikeymasciola

I do feel like it explains a lot like I didn't question why she went to 27 weddings

a.s.

based

Qui-Gon Slut

Huh!!??? you got a runaway bride cousin???

quanza

i love the hard stance they take on not scamming the military in purple hearts when she literally Might Have Died from healthcare funding being funneled into the military

notgerardway

my secret room would probably just be an empty room with one cardboard cutout of me i mean- not me. gerard way. a cardboard cutout of gerard way. not me. i am not gerard way.

Magistrissa

Malla and the Brain in My Adventures with Superman, kind of

a.s.

we win so much we're tired of winning

Pterranodon

Beastly is just Purple Hearts if the girl was charmed with the guy being a racist asshole and he just kinda stopped being one on his own. So I think those crazy kids are gonna do just fine ☺️

Gee

That just seems like actual torture

Alexandra Falk

I also have weirdly fond memories of You've Got Mail.

untenwelt

hello from 2026 where luke from purple hearts/ the army movie is in "the sheep detectives" and "he-man"!!! :D

LW

I can't believe any other person has seen Return to Me, the movie that made me want to become a large animal vet for a few years

Rose Clearwater

All the other romcoms just feel like classic dumb rom com tropes where it’s like I should be mad at the characters but we’re in such a magical cozy land of make believe where if you turn off your brain you don’t really care… but the last army propaganda movie started to make my blood boil it was such a hard launch from cozy problematic old movies to such blatant conservative propaganda. Idk the actual political beliefs of the British guy but how he did both this movie and Red, White, and Royal blue astounds me, like is this a greed, fire your agent, or no thoughts head empty problem? I would want my not suspicious at all secret room of infinite wealth to be like a really elaborate indoor jungle gym that has a rock climbing wall and like a trapeze set, like I can just scale stuff and be whimsical without social anxiety taking over lol a sudden burst of adrenaline and boom I’m climbing all over the place. Of course it being a secret room stumbling upon it ppl would probably think I’m training to hunt down people or something

Ev

While listening to the 27 dresses segment, it dawned on me that the movie would be much better as a thriller or a horror movie... Maybe the majority of romcoms would be 😆

a.s.

🎶through the mirror of my mind🎶

a.s.

vibes of this thing are so crazy swag

a.s.

''the hallway leads to another manor, my house is built funny''

a.s.

lmfao fr uw partying is crazy but not that crazy

anya k

Wonder Woman and the IDF lol

Magistrissa

27 Dresses easily could've ended with the protagonist becoming a wedding planner, with all her friends giving testimonials in her portfolio. And then maybe she doesn't get married, she can still be in a relationship, just like "nah, not for me, at least not yet." Or like, getting married at city hall.

Bec Benepla

I feel like if I were in the Netflix Propaganda department I would simply not add a scene where a black guy talks about killing Arabs and giving them pronouns. I feel like that made the Marines look like psychos.

Aimee W

how to lose a guy in 10 days needed to be gay so badly

Tabbyfeathers

Jennys secret room sounds fuckin epic btw

Alex Novak(they/them) 🏳️‍🌈🏳️‍⚧️🇨🇿

i think my secret room would be like a sanctuary for me to escape from reality. Maybe like a underground bunker but modeled after my childhood home with fake windows where i can change the weather to whatever i want (I would be fall or winter all the time) and this underground bunker has a never ending supply of all my favorite foods and drinks and i can forget the world and just exist in my safe little childhood nostalgia cocoon and also time in the bunker is forever in the early to mid 2000s