Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Downloads

Content

Phew, this one is a bit later than usual due to a slew technical issues, including ultimately having to rerecord a chunk! Hopefully it gels okay in the end.

As for main channel content, I'm undecided as to which video to commit to next. I had liked the idea of picking up another short one in the queue (I had that furry-adjacent one underway) because I liked the idea of breaking the pattern and maybe getting a couple out without a large gap in between. But also people seemed kind of disappointed to get a video that was "just" 90 minutes, so I might need to consider another topic. Maybe Europa Park?

(A lot of people keep asking about Barbie, which kind of threw me because I felt like when I was working on it people kept saying they weren't interested lol. I don't really know if I'm prepared to aim for that for the next video, I'm still pretty burnt out by the scale of it)

Files

Ramble: Revisiting Old Fandoms

Comments

Neal Chauhan

is this an April fools prank

Chloe

❤️

Lxmony

thanks jenny great stuff

Patricia

Yes divaaa !!!! You never disappoint and you posted on youtube this month too??? Omggg thank youu

Patricia

I KNEW I COULD COUNT ON YA TO POST TODAY

Austin S

15 minutes before deadline. College project type timing

Josh

Do what you can and take your time, but for what it's worth my partner and I can't wait for the barbie video. That said we enjoy almost everything you put out so don't stress too bad.

mome_raths_outgrabe

Please continue Barbie! You've worked so hard and I know I've been patiently waiting! Take your time though, just know atleast I'm still interested in what it is!

Brandon

I LOVED your Incubus video and excited to dive into this ramble. Thank you for sharing!!

Odahcama

Real ones will appreciate your main channel videos whether they are 90 minutes or 4 hours!!

Min Yoo

pls don’t feel like you have to find a topic that you can speak to length about though. the ‘shorter’ length was what i liked a lot about the last video!!

Eric MacMillan

Europa Park video would be a dream come true!

Hannah Cohen

A Europa park video would be super cool! I have fond memories of going there while I lived in Switzerland. I was also super pumped at the idea of the Barbie video. I hope we can see it one day!

Marjorie Hakala

I thought getting a 1-2 hour video was great--I sat down and watched it on Saturday night with some popcorn like it was a feature film.

A P

I would love to watch a furry fandom video from you, I really want to know what you think about fursuit.

Tyson Graham

My mum always said 'you'll get what you get, and don't get upset'. I'm happy for whatever you put out because it's always excellent.

faeriedusk

I’m happy to see any content at all, I love having your epic multi hour videos, but saying a video is “just” 90 minutes is nuts to me. That’s still a lot of content and a lot of effort!!! I love both kinds!

A S

Thanks for posting Jenny. Fwiw I don’t care what you post, I like your videos because they expose me to new topics. I don’t know if I’m hallucinating but I think you mentioned a FNAF video and I would like you to see that

Chloe Weldon

i never fell off neopets its cool too see some light on our dwindling community

src-img

For what it's worth, I thought 90 minutes was a shockingly long runtime. Your main channel backlog tends to average out at 20 minutes before the last few ones, and to me, that's still what a main channel video is. An hour plus video is a pleasant surprise, but by no means a disappointment. I'd hate to see you run yourself ragged just because expectations have ballooned--it was only a decade ago when creators were mocked for stretching videos out to the ten minute mark.

Michelle Garcia

Don’t feel bad about leaving the Barbie video behind. It really is interesting to me, I grew up on them and I’m excited to hear your thoughts on them, but please don’t feel pressured to work on it further. You rock, Jenny!

Furene

I just want to add my voice to the conversation and say that I vastly prefer your shorter videos and would love for you to post more often! It feels like every one of my favorite YouTubers is sliding into the same hole of putting out a giant video and then vanishing for years, and as someone who generally likes shorter and more focused content, I would really love it for someone to buck that trend even a little bit.

gossipgoose

I would love if you broke the pattern because I love every main channel video. I will never complain about something being ‘just’ 90mins esp bc some of my favs (church plays, spiderquest, hallmark, etc) are shorter vids

mountain loon

I LOVED your latest main channel video! An instant Jenny Nicholson classic, imo.

Misha Davids

Thanks for the new video! As for future videos... There still isn't an Efteling video (except for the merch haul). Or did I miss something?

Dakota Mace

Every main channel video vibrates on the same frequency as my heart and soul regardless of if it’s 5 minutes or 5 hours. I just love hearing your analyses and conversations about ANYTHING!!! #internetfan #good morning star shine the earth says “hello”!

Jake Doubleyoo

I think your youtube audience would be happier to see you upload more frequently, even if the videos are "short". Setting 2+ hours as a standard would just create unnecessary pressure for yourself, and make for more protracted hiatuses.

Lola

From the font I'm guessing we're talking Neopets which I literally could not be more excited for!!

Anna Wegener

My vote for the next main channel video is whichever one you feel strongest about, regardless of length. Listen, I love your 3+ hour videos, but i sometimes need something a little shorter to watch. I will watch whatever you put out, regardless of length, and want you to also feel fulfilled in your process as the artist!

Corbi

I think both Europa Park and the furry video will be super interesting, but I would have to skip the park one because I want to visit it spoiler free! So I prefer the furry one. Really not interested in the Barbie one tho, especially when it would be only about the movies. But I also don't want you to force yourself to do a video when your heart's not in it.

a.g.

I thought you were joking about people not liking your mlp content and then I slowly realized it wasn’t a joke 😢 I don’t know a lot about mlp but looooove the cute old ponies and love whenever you talk about any mlp topic

Daphne Rouge

Girl u could make a 15 minute video talking about different kinds of salt and i would watch that on repeat

Orissa Meyrink

i’m very hopeful for the eventual barbie video, but i hope you work on whatever interests you at the time! no fun to work on something that’s not appealing to you in the moment

Sebastian Payne

Nyeehh how dreadfully dastardly of you, most decidedly devious

Lo

“Just” 90 minutes? Oh nooo, one of my favorite creators made a video essay the length of a movie… my lobster is too buttery, my steak too juicy… For real though, a main channel video over like, 45 minutes is more than what I personally expect; 2+ hour behemoths are a privilege, not a right. Europa park sounds like an awesome topic.

Terence Digan

Jenny, don’t worry about your main channel videos. At this point, I’d watch a two hour video of you reading the dictionary.

DPG

Jenny, I love your long videos on the main channel, but I would also love to see more of your internet rabbitholes like Queen Nicole of House Hallmark.

Jenny Nicholson

I plan to do Efteling but feel like I have to stagger the theme park content with other topics, and between Europa Park and Efteling I feel like Europa Park has the stronger hook despite liking Efteling more as a destination

Erin Baezner

I love everything you talk about. But I agree that something similar to the hallmark episode or ghost hunting inspector would be awesome. Something lowkey.

elijah

sorry but “only 90 minutes” for a well-written and produced video is crazy, and still so much better than a lot of the stuff on YouTube these days which is clearly lengthened just to please the YouTube algorithm overlords. I saw (pun not intended) the same sentiment about contrapoints’s most recent video and Idk I understand wanting more but it’s not like every topic warrants 4+ hours… and also I can only imagine how draining those large videos can be. I’ll watch anything you put out, Your Dastardliness!

Audrey Eley

I personally like the idea of having another "shorter" video next with a little less time between uploads. Different topics require different video lengths, so I don't understand people being disappointed just because of video length. I really enjoyed the Incubus video and thought it was just the right length to cover the topic well <3

jay butler

Im a incubus fan because of you now

six triceratops

thank you for this blessing o jennied one 🙏🏽

Jenny Nicholson

Yes hence the second channel trap everyone is landing in, myself included. It's a vicious cycle of, scale increases > expectation increases > second-guess topics and discard them more often, stalling progress > time between videos increases > pressure for large project increases to justify the wait between videos > suddenly no video feels adequate anymore

Amber L.

Exactly, there's a weird level of entitlement for people to demand 4-5 hour documentaries 😂

Neil Dutton

I'm always shocked/horrified whenever Jenny says that Lots Of People Said X Content Was Boring. Is this on twitter? Show yourselves cowards!!

Kyle Perry

I’ve watched the Barbie previews so many times so I’m hyped as for the Barbie video, it’s like a smorgasbord of interesting insights into a huge part of popular culture. But supportive of your need to take a break! But am so excited for it.

PurpleIsDebeste

there’s something i really dislike about people complaining about shorter videos. like first of all, 90 minutes is really long. but also its pretty unappreciative of the work you put into the longer videos and how they cant just be churned out at the same pace either way i wouldnt worry, the evan hansen and church play videos are both beloved and they’re around the 90 minute mark

Arbys on McKnight Road

I have a yearly ritual of logging in to my ancient neopets account in order to feed my starving pets and check up on the pet I gave up for adoption in sixth grade, which have felt guilt over ever since haha

Honeyhailey

Neopets font I’m locked in

Amber L.

Follow whatever your interests are for whatever length of vid!💃💃 we'll be excited to see em

six triceratops

yknow this is also making me realize that i.. have also never been in a 'fandom.' like, there's things ive liked, been a big fan of, recommended to people, engaged with, but never in, like, a "sit around on the internet talking to other people and presumably getting in fights about it or i guess just... repeating 'hey you remember when X happened' or 'i really like Y'" like, yeah? duh? is... are... can we do something constructuve?

Katherine Robinson

I'm stoked for Barbie, but I'm more than happy for you to work on it at your own pace. I will be here whenever it's ready! Whatever topics you feel most energized/excited about will always make the best content anyway. And I loveee the shorter videos. I watch the spider reviews video whenever I'm sad lol

RabidKelp

Any video that you are most drawn to rn seems like the best choice! I hope haters don't keep you from Barbie though if you still want to do it -- I and many of my friends would be ✨extremely✨ excited if you decide to complete/release it 🥹

Lump’s Moms

I’m sorry people complain about your pony videos. I have no personal interest in MLP but I love hearing you talk about your interests because that’s what makes the best content. I wish more people understood that. Also I think it is very entitled to complaint about the main channel video being “only” 90 minutes. I would personally love more shorter main channel videos in the vein of opposite worlds and ghost hunters in between larger projects. I rewatch both of those videos all the time.

PurpleIsDebeste

*disgruntled grandpa voice* they could never make the 19 minute hallmark video today

Cristina Anderson

to be honest i am one of those people eagerly waiting for the barbie video and love your multihour videos but i will love any thing you work on!

Sonamy1231000

I don’t want you to do it if ur feeling burnt out or anything but girl, the barbie video is probs gonna be super hella popular. I promise to watch it atleast 7 times

superb lobster

I keep getting the message "Sign in to confirm you’re not a bot" when I try to watch the video. I am logged in, both on here obviously, and on Youtube. Tried logging out and in again, still doesn't work. Never had this happen before. I hope this doesn't become a regular occurrence because Jenny didn't upload it directly to Patreon and didn't post the direct Youtube link either, so now there's no way for me to watch the video!

Rob Fitzsimmons

Is the Beanie Babies video fully retired? I remember Jenny saying she felt discouraged/scooped by the HBO doc a few years ago but, I mean, they're still on the door...

Sonamy1231000

Same as someone who couldn’t care less about Star Wars or Disney I found that video to be so entertaining

The Latter Day Autist

Maybe the Pokemon plush bounced for whatever reason? They wrote your address wrong or insufficient postage. I hate to think he deliberately ripped you off.

funkypenguin3000

I would absolutely love to hear a furry adjacent tale no matter how "short"

Joel Eblin

Everyone needs to apologize to Jenny about making her feel bad about talking about MLP.

Sierra Clibourne

HASEE BOUNCE!! You have the best taste in neopets games

Maureen

Yes the coveted beanie baby video, every time it's mentioned I get curious.

Christopher Reedman

I still want to see the Barbie video. Or go back to your roots in Star Wars videos and do a deep dive review on the entire andor series. That video would do huge numbers.

Furene

Lolll the Hallmark video is probably still my favorite on the channel, and lowkey one of my all-time fave youtube videos in general. I totally get the pressure cycle Jenny is talking about (especially after producing multiple 3-hour essays in a row) but there’s a real kind of magic in tackling these tiny niche subjects!!! I’m glad it’s not just me though, since some others here seem to feel the same

Fiona V

I’m pro short videos! Not that I don’t like long ones, but I’ll never be disappointed by a short one!

TheHumbleOscar

Mae sure you’re not connected to a vpn, patreon will give that message when that happens lol

Beet

oh haha, yeah i'm in the pokemon collectors livejournal in its current form, which would be discord servers! almost all of the livejournal users have moved over to them, though they aren't official servers for the livejournal group. i was never part of the livejournal since i only started collecting physical pokemon goods much later in my life, and to my understanding they have a different mod team running them. but the livejournal group is frequently referenced within the servers! i'm in two, one for plush and one for other pokemon goods, both ran by a sort of overlapping team, but only the plush discord is public facing. that one has over 7k users at this point

Dree

For what it’s worth, I was hyped for the Barbie video. And if I recall, maybe I imagined this, a beanie babie video was mentioned at one point. Those are the top interests by far for me.

Gavin

I could watch you talk about anything and be happy do whatever you think feels right 🙂‍↕️ I wish we could watch you play pokopia I can’t get the game and I wanna watch someone play lol

Aramis Calcutt

90 minutes is fine! Do the furry adjacent video! Please don’t make us wait two years for the next one. 🙏

bluewolfie

I would LOVE to see another theme park vid. I was less disappointed by the length and more the lack of theme parkiness. But I’d love any of these 3 videos!!! Just keep killing it Jenny!

Darcie

Even though I do love love love the multi hour ones, I enjoy and watch any length videos! My vote is for whatever you feel passionate about and want to work on next for main channel.

bluewolfie

Hear me out: DONT STAGGER IT I live for it

bluewolfie

Church plays my BELOVEDDD

James Best

I'm sure others have said this, but for me it's less about the topic of your videos and more about the interesting ways you engage with and present the information. Like I have very little knowledge of/interest in the world of Barbie but will gladly watch an hours-long video on it because you tend to make a subject come alive and find cool ways of approaching things.

Edmond Ho

Count me as another vote for, "Follow your interests! The video is as long or short as it needs to be." I still regularly watch "Where's Buzzy" (our boy!) and "Rating every porg."

Custard

Not sure if it helps or hurts but I’m pretty excited for the Barbie video when it gets released

Alpz

Follow your heart, but I'd love to see the "furry-adjacent" vid!

Erin Lee

I love hearing your thoughts on MLP, I still think about that pitch you had where rarity is goth but glows in the dark so she can't do a proper emo wallow and teenie tiny flutters would be so cute

AstroEden

I LOVEEE WHEN YOU TALK PONIES don't listen to the neigh-sayers

Xela

Just got into grundo's cafe, so that title card activated something in the back of my brain

Es

Probably in the minority here from seeing the general vibe of the comments, but I love the really short vids! The fur-bearing trout asmr is a guilty pleasure of mine, and I’d definitely welcome more weirdo stuff like that. Short or long, whatever you end up going with will be great nonetheless, though! :)))

Nola

people love to spam that "great to see you experimenting with short form content" bit. I loved the video, 90 minutes is huge, anything beyond that is amazing but I just love to see you put out anything you're passionate about. I think Barbie would get a lot of traction, but take however much time you need on that, I'm excited to see whatever you're excited to work on. Always love theme park stuff. Also have to mention that I love your travel vlog-type videos that include cool lore and would enjoy more of that on the main channel, the spider quest video is a favorite of mine

Jamminonjay

*Skims video like a fool* oh... She's not gonna know all engines go got cancelled and she's gonna talk about it like it's ongoing and it's gonna drive me insane

Bryan Sutton

I like your idea of putting out another "short" video and I don't think you'll get too many complaints about the length if it goes out relatively quick enough. It'll be like the classic jenny schedule. just my two cents, bear in mind I don't know anything youtube or algorithms.

Jemm

I’m definitely pro doing whatever brings you the most joy and inspiration. Burnout is tough, better to follow your current interests and energy levels. Any topic or video length is enjoyable with how you present information—it’s your respect for your topics and ability to explain niche content that is so fun and engaging

kelly m

i just wanna say i've been revising my budget and i cut out spotify hulu and hbo but i still have your patreon lol

angel equus

i just started the vid, but wanted to mention i LOVE when you post pony videos!! they're definitely my favorites to rewatch. i'm sorry people are so rude about that, and also 'not being long enough'. i think people got it in their heads that the unusually long videos people youtubers make are now the standard instead of extraordinary projects that take a longggg time to produce. they don't see the months/years of work beforehand, or see that the youtubers who make those videos only come out with them max a couple times a year. and - this isn't meant to be a dig at anyone in particular, but a LOT of the longer videos that popped up after it got trendy to make them are lower quality and lack a structure, thesis, interesting ideas, etc.. they're basically just vaguely structured rambles a lot of the time. actual video essays should only take as long as they need to to cover the topic, and shouldn't be insanely long just for the sake of being long. i love your shorter vids too, which give an opportunity to explore really fun things that wouldn't be suitable for longform. you can't exactly produce 4 hours of spider reviews (though i certainly would watch it), but that doesn't mean it's not a worthy and entertaining 20 min video - especially bc that kind of content is less 'intensive' both to watch and to produce. i think truly visionary youtubers, like you, defunctland, etc. should produce videos at whatever the hell pace you want and whatever length or topic, because your passion and sincerity is what makes it worthwhile, nothing else!

Colin Coltrera

Just chiming in to say do whatever fills your bucket. I’d definitely enjoyed the Barbie preview we got, and I’m excited for more if it ever feels like the right time to pick it back up

Gavin

Oh you’re feeding us as always so blessed 🙂‍↕️🙂‍↕️🙂‍↕️

MK

Same! Super curious about that one.

angel equus

also re: ponies - i especially love when you talk ponies bc you have a different perspective on MLP and bronydom as a whole than basically all other creators. usually it's just outsiders, and rarely bronies, but not people who just care about MLP as a concept. i love FIM, but there's so much magic and fun in the older gens that i wish was appreciated. it's an old vid but i would kill for a 4 hour long pony restoration video LOL.

Gavin

Also side note people thinking 90 min is “short” is insane to me I used to think your 20 min videos were long and engaging every video feels like an extra long treat!

superb lobster

OK, the issue seems to have resolved itself, knock on wood. I initially went into Settings > Accounts and connected my Youtube account there. But when that didn't solve it, I unlinked it again...but about 5 minutes later videos started working. Go figure.

James Ryan

it’s wild if anyone was disappointed by the length of incubus - 90 minutes is movie length!! i’m much more interested in how entertaining content is than how long it is

ジェット

I don't think people (who are not just being a-holes) were actually disappointed by the 90 minute runtime, just maybe surprised and hopeful that it meant there would be another upload sooner. I hope you stick to the shorter-but-more-frequent vision, personally!

Halli Gomberg

For the record- I think Jenny is a genius creator and have seen all of her videos (most at least 3 times). She finds cool topics I've never ever known existed- heck I watch the Pony videos! I just think Barbie isn't as special as her time merits. That being said OF COURSE I will watch and appreciate whatever she makes.

Kyle Young

I will eat whatever you cook mother!

Katherine Robinson

I also think it's possible people who were surprised/disappointed by a 90 minute video assumed that it was all you had been working on since Starcruiser. Which would also be fine because it's your channel and random people aren't entitled to greater and greater quantities of your labor, but it might confuse some people if they interpreted it as a huge drop off in production because they don't know how you rotate between projects. IMO if you put out shorter videos without the long gaps people would not be "disappointed."

Mitch P

Identify what you have the best hats for and go from there. The hats will show you the way.

Jenny Nicholson

The discord is also implicated in the sandshrew incident, like a school built on cursed land

Claraby

There will always be a talkative but limited contingent of people who don't like any given topic. The Incubus video was great, and not short at all (lol)

emast

At this point you have to make tier ranking fish as your next main channel video. It’s been so close too many times LOL😭

MK

I see a Jenny video, I watch a Jenny video. Post whatever is calling to you!

Richard Wilson

I lowkey gave you some NC items when you last showed your account. I may send you some extra wigs I have because I spend SOOO much on Neopets. It’s bad.

emast

“I thought Thomas was grown because he was voiced by a grown man” ntm on Ringo Starr

L.

Don't let a few vocal people determine your videos - or your mood! The Incubus video was awesome and the right length for the topic! If someone isn't interested in Barbie they can just not watch it, so many other people would love it!

Aleks Howes

The segment where Jenny watched the rantsona crossover about the Thomas the Tank Engine show was surreal, I loved it. Also, I was also a big Thomas the Tank Engine kid growing up, this was a fun look at where that fandom is now.

A. Ortiz

The style of the new Thomas cartoon is so adorable whaaat??

Andrew Gale

Feel the need to say I love all the pony content, particularly the non “brony” stuff. I love hearing about the retro ponies and the old school pony fandom.

L.

By the way, I am typing this from a themed suite in the Efteling 😁

six triceratops

yeahhh this thomas fandom stuff feels nigh voyeuristic. good for them, having fun, like, it's cute, but i dont know how to feel about the fact that we saw it

Ronia Peterson

I am really really looking forward to Barbie, but I think you should just work on whatever you're excited to work on next!

Sarah V

I’m so curious about what is furry adjacent

onthemoon

I didn't realise there was negative feedback for the Barbie video... lowk assuming that's from the male audience lol. I loved the two previews and Barbie is my childhood, I wouldn't trust a review of it to any other ytber! I cannot wait to see it whenever it's ready <333

Maddy

oh my god i made the same noise as jenny when that starcatcher plush showed up on screen. i swear the biggest pro for me being a patron at this point is to get notified/recommendations of niche plush that exist that i need to have. the other one was the plush of the beautiful sea creatures from king tritons carousel in a previous video

Tojo

Commenting on the video Jenny when you were reading the TTRPG rules for the neopets rules. the whole "Sessions 0" and "gender sexuality" thing has been stock standard in the vast majority of rulebooks since the early 2010s, i get your point that a lot of this stuff goes without saying, buuuut, some DMs who are decent people and also tend to not think of these things, the book offers a gentle reminder for those people, which is who these rules try to reach. The homophobic friend group already complains modern DnD is took woke and definitely doesnt care but its for those people who dont remember and have thoughts like "i think its cool if i throw sex at my players in a game cuz we're all adults and sex is a real part of this world" but then forget to ask for permission from said friends if its okay to get explicit. That being said, its inclusion in a neopets book is hilarious and misguided. Maybe. dont put it in a book meant for like 12 year olds lmao (the gender thing though could stay i imagine)

Landon J

I am very much excited for that furry adjacent video, whatever it is! People complaining that a video of yours is "only" 90 minutes sounds nuts to me -- your videos are great (and rewatchable!) regardless of length.

onthemoon

Also please don't count the loud (probably) minority for these things. If you ran a poll asking if we would like more MLP vids with the option of yes/no/idc, i don't think "no" would be the winner. I love your MLP vids, I still rewatch The Applejack Problem, it's so cosy

S.R. Harper

One of the most memorable "scams" of my childhood was a kid traded me a fake sandshrew Pokemon card. He knew it was fake and naive kid-me didn't even consider there could be pokemon cards that were "not real" and I think I traded it for something really special to me like a bulbasaur or something because Sandshrew was my favourite and I wanted a card so bad. All this to say I really related to Jenny's sandshrew tale

Eve Miller

i hope people get over the negativity of a "shorter" video! 90 minutes is still LONG. i think if you started putting out more "shorter" videos people would get used to it and stop complaining. hopefully. :/ ultimately your nastiness its your call, but i, for one, welcome the new era.

Rosemary

I would happily watch you watch paint dry. :) I just like seeing you discuss whatever strikes your fancy because you make it feel fancy when you talk about it.

ashlen 💫

“only” 90 minutes is ridiculous !! 90 awesome minutes !! watch it twice if that’s too short :-/

Tardsmat

I'd love an Europa-Park Video!

Rob Fitzsimmons

*Trains*? In a *theme park*!? Can you even imagine something so ridiculous? My suspension of disbelief is shattered.

L.

Raveleijn suite! Feeling like a real knight ⚔️🐎

PowdarrKeg

This is my best patreon subscription by far I swear

Heath

I'm going thru a sinister move and your videos are perfect to pack to, just when I'd run out I see this!

Captain Langosta AKA The Yellow Dart AKA Kyle

Me, a mere mortal, seeing that Thomas OC nightmare parade: I want to crawl all the way out of my skin then burn the skin I am cringing so hard. Jenny, her power unrivaled: S U B S C R I B E D

demonsita

Those Neopet games are so nostalgic, I can’t believe they still have the same ones! I used to play in like 2005. Seeing Hassee Bounce literally made me want to create a new account just to play again

Lauren

I personally am very excited for the Barbie video and am very interested whenever you do pony content. Would be here for pony doll clean up and styling content as well - it's really fun! Loved the Incubus video too!

merricat

I'm sure a lot of people are joking when they say "what, ONLY an hour and a half ??" - personally I was interested in the Barbie video but I'd also love shorter content. I think most of your audience is happy with whatever you are most enthusiastic doing.

Kotah

I would love a Europa Park video. Or even better an Efteling video??

A Gay Crow

your pony videos have made me stare into the dark abyss that is collecting ponies. I literally don't have room rn bc I have so many Barbies but I've seriously considered getting a pony shelf because the way you talk about them makes them feel so magical and special! Obviously I'm also into the barbie video I have most of the movies on DVD and have covetted the Princess and the Pauper Barbies for a long time (so cool you have them!)

Emilia

I loved the latest video! I have been dying to watch the Barbie one for a long time, so I would be super happy with that, but don’t force yourself - I’d enjoy anything you post

Gothshark

I will never be tired of hearing about ponies

Quinn

Nooooo I love the pony videos! I’m always hoping we will see more of your collection, it was actually how I found your channel! I was looking for pony cleaning videos 🥲 that was nearly 10 years ago! I also never find anything you make boring because the topic is always secondary to your commentary and insights.

Aleksandr Popovic

The park I visited growing up was Europa Park, so please picture me loudly whooping and cheering at that option — it gets so little attention from the big theme park channels, and I would love to hear your thoughts on it!!

mink

I only like unintellectual properties. I like my properties dumb.

Stephanie Guzman

Definitely still very interested in the Barbie video, but happy to wait as long as it takes. I'm not going anywhere :)

Antonina Vanchurin

I am so sorry to hear that people are dissapointed that the Incubus video was just 90 minutes long. All of the topics sound wonderful. I personally am a big fan of your theme park videos, so a Europa Park vid will be very welcomed, but the furry vid and a Barbie vid still sound very interesting. I hope you will find some project that works for you

LunchBoxGhost

I am so mad about the Sandshrew now.

Julia Marostica

I continue to look forward to the barbie video but will happily wait as long as it takes! and both of the other topics sound interesting and great! I was not at all disappointed with the length of the incubus video, for the record

Ally McKenna

I will watch and enjoy anything you post!

Crabby Patty Formula

I've personally really been looking forward to the furry-adjacent video! Maybe I'm misreading it, but you and Contra both posted 'shorter' videos and the comments I saw were like 'great to see them experiment with shorter form content' as a joke - I can't believe anyone actually thinks that's too short, especially if it means they'll get a main channel video sooner... at least that's how I'd feel :)

Crabby Patty Formula

That being said, another theme park video is always a banger too! Europa Park sounds cool, but also consider checking out Eftheling (they have a tree with a face)

Jeremie

I really enjoyed the shorter vid format. It felt really old school. Always happy for theme park vids!

Sgt Sweetcheeks

Nothing has *ever* shocked me as much as you saying people hate the pony rambles, I go back and rewatch the one of you showing your collection minimum at least once every couple of months!

Bag of Tricks

A lot of children's properties could be improved by having Tobey Maguire's evil Spider-Man show up and snark at characters we don't like. A lot of media properties, period.

a.s.

''an all-very-online-people project'' is such an efficient and powerful read, it immediately entrenched itself into my psyche in the way only jenny's lines can

laurathejones

Respectfully, shhh. It's her channel and if a certain video doesn't interest you just don't watch it?

Ryan Chin

I love pony rambles they really help me sleep

Paul

Topic suggester here! Better than I could have hoped. Also despised Dragon Tales: I remember groaning every time it came on.

demonsita

Jenny you’re one of the few creators I could watch talk about anything! I’m always really excited when there’s an overlap with a niche (or maybe not so niche) interest of mine. But your content is just as enjoyable even when it’s something I know nothing about - I think that happens for a lot of is with your videos. So please make whatever you feel like making and when you feel like it! Take care of yourself and have fun creating/researching/yapping, I think most of us will still be here

demonsita

Also Avatar:The Way of Waterpark and the Dear Evan Hansen videos are my comfort go-to either for sleeping or just to have a giggle while they play in the background (mentioning to add to the point others are making as well that we all have our faves)

Carlos

this video feels like it starts dissolving halfway through. 10/10 watch

demonsita

The guilt is so real! I lost access to my account, but for years I’d check up on the one I gave up for adoption with so much regret (can’t remember type, just that I got a Hissee from the pound on one of those searches)

Olivia

I would absolutely love a Europa Park video!

phoebe c

When I was a kid I was scammed buying a copy of Tokyo Mew Mew on eBay probably close to 20 years ago at this point. I was so mad I still remember the name of the seller. Watch out Cashew's Clearance Outlet, I haven't forgotten what you did!

RandySalacious

Show your work - she watched every land before time and it banged, what is so toxic about barbie to you?

hendery

As someone who also got scammed from a lj sale and was told by community mods who were friends with the seller to get over it (for me it was anime merch)--can I just say your rant is cathartic. Also unrelated but how you avoid the neostock market is literally how i approach all mobile games: i literally can't stress enough how happy I am to hear I'm not the only one who doesn't mid/max every single thing...

Louise Litchee

I'm French and I was sort of hoping for a France video since I saw you visited a bunch of stuff a while back, but maybe that's a pipe dream! Otherwise I'd love any main channel video from you, although it's true I'm partial to very long ones which I rewatch obsessively. I honestly think subject matter isn't that important when it comes to your content because the way you approach things tends to make everything interesting to me, regardless of whether I was interested in the first place.

RandySalacious

Crazy that there is apparently a whole subset of people who enjoy jenny's taste in media enough to give her money regularly and avidly watch a 90 minute ramble about neopets, dragon tales, and the immaturity of the latest Thomas the tank engine animated kids show but also seem to frequently hate her choices for video topics so much they feel entitled to vocally inform her of their disapproval of her interests to the point it negatively impacts her mood and creative muse, i can scarcely imagine one person being that paradoxical let alone so many it is noticeable to her amongst the 43,000 paying members of this patreon. Don't listen to them jenny! make whatever videos your heart desires! Viva la Barbie!

Eva Graversen

I had never seen this poorly-synched goblin avatar who talks about kids' shows before, but now both you and Big Joel used clips of him within 2 weeks.

Arrant

The neopets stuff really hit me hard in the nostalgia bone. I remember first discovering it in 2000 at the summer day program I was sent to at the Boys & Girls Club when an older kid showed me. And oddly he gave me his password and info so I could use his account, though eventually I made my own… then several because as a kid I kept forgetting my emails and passwords and had a new KOL email constantly. Fast forward to 2007 and I had a permanent email I did not forget and the neopets account that still exists today. I was awful at it(I checked and my pets are still level 2 despite being 19 years old) but I had a blast playing a lot of the mini games. Even finding that my account was still active is insane, as a kid my favorite flash game was the taxi one made to promote the firefly cellphone(remember that? My little cousin had one but I never did.) though it also brought up tragedy that yahoo erases old emails, so that dormant yahoo account is now missing 20+ years of emails and memories. Rip

sappho's scullery maid

I really liked the length of the new video! it felt like a throwback to all your bad movie reviews, the beastly video is one of my favourites of all time and this one felt like that but elevated with your more modern extreme research sensiblity (so best of both worlds really!)

hwe

I feel like people aren't actually disappointed by the video's length, they just want to comment on how 'epically long' your other videos are. Furry video plz

Yarrow

I really don't want to re-open an old wound, but I know someone who avidly plays Neopets and when I was recently getting back into Neopets, she insisted to me that I could recover my ancient childhood Neopets account from 23 years ago if I still had access to the email address associated with it. I didn't want to ask my brother if he still had access to that old email (we shared an account as kids) and, regardless, I preferred to let my childhood account rest and play with a new one. Anyway, just wanted to share this information just in case...

scubaghost

every subsequent topic in this vid feels like i'm slipping deeper into a fever dream. yes, after discussing the face tree market of neopets i gather my team of edgy rantsonas to do a constructed tear down of how unrealistic the thomas the train engine show for babies has become, only to have a hypnotic goblin sidetrack me by simultaneously telling me the exact plot of an episode of dragon tales at the exact moment as i'm trying to watch it and also jenny is there trying to provoke the dragons to start killing each other. then i wake up in such a massive pool of sweat that it's soaked all the way through my comforter

gothcosmos

90 minutes is plenty long! Thank you Jenny 💯

gothcosmos

with that being said one of my favorite videos of yours is the >25 minute fur bearing trout video

Sen

Hail her most supreme putrescence! Such a fun walk down memory lane seeing Neopets. Glad they managed to preserve some of those old flash games! As for the people complaining about video lengths, you can never make everyone happy. Personally, I will watch all of your videos, regardless of length. What I enjoy is when you are passionate about the topic and having a good time. I know you do this for a living and have to worry about what gets views. So do what you feel you gotta do, but just know the real ones will support you no matter what!

Kyle

I'm always down to learn about ponies. I legit enjoyed hearing about the weird ways the plastic ages and opinions on brushable versus non-brushable hair. I just like all the insights into stuff I wouldn't find out about otherwise.

Silky

Jenny I LOVE when you talk about MLP! And I've never watched the show or collected the ponies or anything. But I've watched and rewatched the pony-related rambles, I think they're so fun and interesting. I have an old pony somewhere that I found out through your videos must be a My Little Pony, I never knew that as a kid but I'm gonna dig it up some time when I'm visiting my parents and try to diagnose what kind it is, just for the fun of it :)

Ted Koutz

I for one would like to see the furry-adjacent video.

Qui-Gon Slut

this is an INSTANT classic!!! I'll revisit this ramble many times in the future. love love love the watch along segments near the end. was great to watch dragon tales along with you. also, I have never played Neopets before but... now I genuinely might.

Qui-Gon Slut

I love your pony content! MLP, horse girl, figures, doesn't matter to me, I love it allllllll!!!

Obi W.

My impression was that people were joking around, taking a piss about the video "only" being 90 minutes. Even if they were actually complaining, you will never please everyone so just make the content you want. The majority of us will watch and enjoy regardless if video length.

karch

i could listen to u talk ponies for literally ever. please defy the haters

Silky

Did anyone else here play Howrse? I think it still exists, I played it as a kid. It's a site where you'd own horses, train and feed them every day, enter tournaments, breed them... It was fun! There was also a huge pay-to-win aspect where you'd buy in-game currency to access items to make your horses better and give them cool skins and stuff. And this was where the game totally exploited me as a child: one way you could get in-game currency was to simply call a number on the phone. And I, being a child, knowing that our landline didn't pay per call but was on a flatrate plan – I thought this wouldn't cost my parents money! Months later, my parents looked over their phone & wifi bill and it had like 200 extra dollars on it. They asked me if I'd done anything weird on the internet, like downloaded a movie or something? I had not, and I had no idea how that could have happened. I put it together years later... I should see if my old account still exists. My rare horse skins should be worth so much right now.

Qui-Gon Slut

my favorite thing about your content is, and has always been the passion you express in the creation and performance of your videos. your enthusiasm is infectious, admirable, and deeply entertaining. you could talk about something I've never heard of in my life, or even something I don't like or have no interest in, and I would still love the video. I can only imagine how straining it can be to have so many opinions on you, the topics you cover, and how you cover them. I'm sorry you have to deal with that. I will enjoy anything you choose to talk about, especially when you truly want to talk about it. to me, and many others, it doesn't matter what you make a video about, just that it is you who makes the video. not sure you'll see this but, from a long time fan, I love what you do, and I sincerely hope you're doing well :)

Hardy Roach Games

I really like having more videos, so if you wanted to do a couple of shorter ones I'd be happy about it. I think being disappointed by a vid that's "just" 90 mins is very silly, personally.

Yuke Weiß

I for one welcome the furry adjacent video for various reasons :). I will watch the heckies out of it.

hom

i think the mlp dislikers are just a more vocal minority, please never stop horsing around in rambles! as somepony who grew up watching g4, your videos are what taught me g1-3 ball

Blue

I tried to check in on my old account last year but they've started deleting accounts for inactivity, so it's almost certainly gone 😭 But yeah, I really wish there was a non-PTW version of Howrse, it's such a fun concept.

Aragog's 7th leg

Your horribleness, the furry adjacent video would be awesome as a next drop! Still dying to know what the topic is. Europa park would be really fun too! I would love for the Barbie video to eventually see the light of day, but I totally get the burnout from it. I’d be happy with anything you put out next, I just hope you’re able to work on whatever makes you happiest/feels the least bad to work on.

Cat

I’m only at the beginning but I LOVE hearing you talk about ponies! It’s one of my favourite topics you do rambles on!!!!! 100% supporter of any more early pony generation rambles or even sections of rambles 🦄

Yarrow

This video had me dying laughing. I loved Jenny making funny of the cartoon avatar's jiggling talking animation. 😆

alexa

I've been pretty excited for the barbie vid! But I totally get that it's a lot, so I'm still happy about the previews you've shared.

Kevin Morris

Yeah I didn’t dig suuuuper far into the YT comments but I got the impression most people who brought up the length were just joking about it compared to the last few behemoths and not genuinely disappointed. I always think a video that’s appropriately long for the topic is better than one that’s arbitrarily long. Another popular channel in Jenny’s realm got praised for a couple really long videos and now all their videos are really long and I do not think the content in those videos warrants it!

Kevin Morris

Based on your Supernatural video I am 100% confident you could DM a D&D game.

Delphine

Just wanted to put my voice out there that I have zero qualms with you talking about ponies, I love it 😊 But then again I'm happy to listen to you ramble about pretty much whatever 💖

Silky

Is that Dragon Tales recap video AI? The flat intonation with no breaks between sentences sounds like it, and I think videos that just tell you the plot of something with no added commentary and a clickbaity title ("Darkest Episode") are a whole genre

UwUwizard

Jenny patiently smiling through outsider art YouTube channels is absolutely iconic, I live for these silent reactions. In my mind, we are all silently appraised by Jenny Nicholson reactions.

Austin F

"sandshrew was one of my favorite pokemon" incredible taste, 10/10. sandshrew is literally the definition of "just a little guy"

Ella M

I worry the Thomas the Tank Engine Avengers clip might have altered my brain chemistry irreparably. Like, whenever I ask my patients how they spend their time and they tell me "on the computer", this is what I will imagine them doing. It is really funny though.

Anna Beliuchenko

I find the feedback on a 1:40 video being too short so weird, I thought it was great and I wouldn't even call it bite sized, it's a length of a movie!

Austin F

oh also jenny, have you gotten pokopia? i've been playing it and having fun and it seems kinda up your alley

Lambda34Delta

I feel the need to chime in specifically because I hugely adore all the Barbie movies, and all Barbie things in general, but especially the movies, have watched every single one of them, and was beyond hype when you announced the video. Because while I was beyond hyped, I also just instantly started thinking about the scale of it and what a huge undertaking it's going to be because it's so many goddamn movies and I can't even imagine actually going through each of these, one by one, giving them an equal amount of attention and effort and time to write eloquently about and then film and edit that. Cause like, yeah people have made Barbie videos, some of them only 2 or so hours instead of four, but it also necessarily means they skim over some of the entries in the list and do some serious corner cutting and maybe don't put in as much research and effort as you might want to or don't really go in depth with some of them. It's just a really challenging thing to tackle, especially when watching the Land Before Time movies, of which there are, you know, 14, was already a big undertaking, it seemed like a huge jump to do a similar video with fifty whole movies instead. I guess what I'm saying is, speaking personally, as just one audience member, but also as probably the 1# target audience for your Barbie video: if you drop it at this point because you're burnt out and overwhelmed, yeah I'm 10000% okay with that and understand that, like, I can't emphasize enough how much it's understandable to me, that's just an inherent feature of the topic. The only way out I can imagine to make it work is if you do the aforementioned corner cutting, skim it down and gloss over some of the more boring movies (I straight up slept through most of Barbie & Her Sisters in a Puppy Chase, there are like three things of note in the entire thing), but whether that's something you'd want to do is another question, since it means sacrificing some things to reduce the scale of it. Also, tangentially related, I'm very interested in and curious about the furry-adjacent video, and I'm also extremely in favor of you breaking up the pattern and doing some shorter videos without the huge gaps. As much as I enjoy your multihour masterpieces, you can't make every single video a multihour masterpiece, it just isn't sustainable, it means every single video release comes with the insane pressure of living up to your previous huge releases and it's just not a fair standard to hold anyone to.

Emily Ibison

Way back when Barbie was first brought up as a video topic, I wasn’t super interested because I never watched the Barbie movies growing up. But now I have a 3 year old who likes them and I’m DYING to get Jenny’s take because these movies are wild. We have the book versions of a Mermaids Tale, Pearl Princess and whatever the one is where they go to the Fairy realm… wtf are these plots? So much weird stuff going on, so much to unpack. But I’d be thrilled for the furry-adjacent shorter vid OR a Europa park longer vid.

Tabby

It's also worth noting that "gender and sexuality have no mechanical effect on gameplay" became a boilerplate statement because for the first few generations of TTRPGs -- and, hell, for some modern ones still -- it *did.* The original D&D was created by some wildly sexist dudes, and they baked their biases into the rules. D&D itself has moved past that in later years, but not every game has.

Boris

I think many of the comments are joking too, and even if they weren't another 'shorter' video without a long wait is definitely a win in everyone's books.

Mady, you know, from TV

I super get the wax and wane interest in things and I enjoy having something I can circle back to sometimes. I'm back on an ACNH kick and it's fun to catch up on all the new stuff - maybe I should get back to neopets after like 20 years away! 😆 I don't think I ever got hacked but I can't imagine I can access my old account (which was probably broke anyways LOL). Also in re: pony talk and Barbie, etc., I have never disliked anything Jenny has made! I have favourites of course, but someone invested in what they are saying who can talk about it in a compelling, funny, way, will always be worth watching. I hope Jenny makes whatever video brings her the most joy to work on next - I feel like it shines through when Jenny is having fun with something and that makes her videos even more enjoyable to watch 🙂

Boris

Also I don't get these complaints when the video is so quality, I was dying at Incubus it's top tier content lmao

Alice Fay

This is just my two cents.. but I love hearing about ponies, theme parks, etc. Would love to see the Barbie vid, too. I like hearing about topics you're particularly interested in.

Cat

Same!!!

Rebecca

I personally would rather get more, “shorter” videos than wait a few years between. Also while I think a Barbie video would be amazing, I have notice several other big YouTubers have also done Barbie movie videos recently! Idk man I could listen to Jenny talk about paint drying. Also justice for the ponies!!

Rice G.

Personally i would take 2-3 90 minute videos a year over a single 2-4 hour video once a year. Although I think no matter what you do someone is going to complain lol. It might be more helpful to do a poll than rely on comments, because people who like a topic (like me) might not feel the need to encourage you because youre already working on it, but people who don't like a topic are more likely to speak up. That might be how the disconnect on interest for the barbie video happened. I was definitely looking forward to it and still am but tbh i was a little more interested in the beanie baby video. Although i would be jist as happy if you picked some random third topic lol.

Blaberid

I just about had a heart attack when you mentioned being on pkmncollectors cuz I was very invested in the community way back in its early days (I'm the Electrode person, if that rings any bells! My Electrode collection is still going strong! Banpresto just released an Electrode plush roughly a foot in diameter and I've never been happier!) but ended up falling out with... most of the higher ups in the community over the years. Go figure. (fwiw I had no idea about what happened with your Sandshrew plush and I'm sorry.) Can I also say that I reeeaaally love it when you talk about ponies, especially vintage ponies. I'm also an MLP collector. The patreon video where you revisit old websites is one of my all-time favorites.

Tara Foster

Jenny, I love anything you talk about. Your pony rambles are some of the best bc the passion shines through

Lukadarkwater

Dying at you trying to get into Thomas the Train Engine drama and ending up on this wild channel with all these OCs. Just cinema.

Ariel Ash

I’m soooooo interested in the Barbie video! I loved the short clips you shared with us!

Elise

Honestly speaking for myself I don't care about the length of the video. One of my favorite recent video of yours is the Dear Evan Hansen one and it's considered "short" (although I don't see it that way). I know why people have started to think a three hours long video is the norm now but I don't think it should be. It either leads to rambling essays with a lot of repetitions and poor editing or to youtubers burning out because they're expected to produce Gone With the Wind length unique documentaries every year. Louis Theroux's Inside the Manosphere is like an hour and a half! Like with the Redlettermedia crew I would watch you talk about Barbie or the Beanie Babies or Bomberman because you make everything sound entertaining and you have a unique voice. The topic or the length of the video matter way less.

Katie Schultz

Anyone complaining about the length of your videos needs to rethink a couple of things

Sarianna Sallinen

The pony collection video is one of my favourites. :)

Brittany

As a current player, I love the second feature of neopets, thanks for the dive into the gallery and everything!! I hope you get your rainbow brain tree plush some day!

Joe Trickey

I agree with the comments here saying that anyone complaining about a video being 'only' 90 minutes shouldn't be taken seriously, and more, shorter videos would be better, especially if that's what you wanted to do anyway

S G Matthews

I don’t know who the people were that said they weren’t interested in Barbie, but I wasn’t one of them 😊. I’ve been very eager to be able to watch the whole thing with my sister.

Wayrocket

Eagerly awaiting your Cassie the pink dragon revenge fanfic.

Nickel Brady

Haven't watched this just yet but wanted to echo the sentiment of shorter, more frequent videos! I love all of your content genuinely but the 45-90 minute videos a la Beastly and Incubus are a fun sweet spot to me! :) At the end of the day though listen to your gut and intuition -- we love the channel because you've got a really unique and original flair and perspective; the ideas that you're organically interested in exploring are gonna be the best just by virtue of having the most genuine passion in them! :) idk if that's well explained lol but good luck <3!

Meagan Dieckelt

Just wanting to add to the other comments, to not listen to people complaining about “90 mins being too short”. I’m happy with any content you come out with no matter the length!

Sarah Krishef

I loved the 90 minute video! It’s an easy chill thing to relisten to many times and put on to sleep. It gives me nostalgia for the Trigger Warning era, actually. I love relistening to your videos, but the longest ones are more rarely watched because they feel like a big commitment :,)

S G Matthews

I actually bought a Sandshrew plushie at that scale earlier this year! I’d been waiting and waiting for the Aron plushie to be available on the Pokemon Center again, and when I came up I felt like I needed to buy a second plushie to justify shipping and after much debate, I went with an Alolan Sandshrew!

Fade Johanssen

I loved the 90m video! Long or "short" it's really enjoyable, so I think the quality is way more important than the length. I will say I have been looking forward to getting the Barbie video someday, but I don't think you should push yourself if you're still burnt out on it. If you were enjoying the idea of breaking the cycle of long gaps then I think you should go for it!

Jack Fahey

Hamtaro fans were ROBBED!

TheAnyButton

I would enjoy more frequent videos! I love how in-depth the documentaries are but I also like learning about media that I'm not familiar with and a lot of the older main channel videos provided that.

Saoirse Cox

I do love incredibly long videos, sure, but I also really like shorter videos!! It’s all good stuff!

CosmicSharkGal

Can’t comprehend why a cis person would want a Starchaser plush but you do you ig

hayden

90 minutes was a really good length. it was in depth and entertaining and used all of its time well. i’d prefer more videos at a shorter length :)

Aiden

I was (and still am, I guess) in the livejournal pkmncollecfors group lol. the community has largely migrated to discord nowadays (it's not the same group, so different mods and stuff, just a lot of the same folks). I did have an experience basically exactly like jenny said she thought happened, where I bought a couple of plush, a couple of weeks passed without any update, so I messaged the person and they were like "oh I set those aside for you and completely forgot to actually ship them out, my bad". then I did get the plush and it was fine. but that person actually was banned later for failing to fulfill a lot of orders, so... makes you wonder.

hayden

also we LOVE ponyposting! friendship is witchcraft retrospective now! we’d all love to hear how applejack won the war 2!

CosmicSharkGal

It’s funny hearing Jenny talk about G4 cause I wasn’t a fan during its run but I am now and that fandom seems as alive if not more than most other things I’m into

mayakoolwhip

I wish the haters would let her talk about ponies 😔💔

minohoonoo

90 minutes is definitely not "too short"! i loved the incubus video. will throw my hat in the ring for barbie as well, but i'll happily listen to you talk about anything

VeganSquid

A video on Europa Park would be amazing! Make whatever video you want to and I will watch it.

sister puke

You've inspired me to make a new account. I was playing heavily a few years ago but ended up losing my account because the email I used to make it doesn't exist anymore. It crushed me quite honestly. But I think it's time! Starting over fresh sounds fun. I had a pirate Aisha named Sega_Dreamcast 😢

lemon di lesbian

also anyone who is complaining about a feature film-length video is incredibly annoying lmao. "oh no my steak is too juicy my lobster is too buttery"-esque. im looking forward to the barbie video but work on whatever you're passionate about! i'm genuinely so excited to hear about all of these topics

Kira Zee

re:main channel, I truly enjoy everything you put out and I hope you don't take other viewers' "disappointment" to heart too much. The only videos I want to see from you are ones that you really enjoyed making, however long or short they are!

lemon di lesbian

ok got the video to work and everyone is severely pissing me off cuz why are people complaining about JENNY NICHOLSON talking about PONIES. do you not come to jenny nicholson patreon to hear about ponies and theme parks what is wrong with our cruel and twisted society

Sean Underwood

I completely agree. You can’t make everyone happy, anyway.

Ly Montesino

I gobble up anything you put out icon

Alex Herter

It's wild me to how entitled people are--I enjoy your videos because I think you have good ideas that you share in interesting ways and a really excellent balance of being kind and thoughtful but not mincing words or shying away from your own opinions about things. Some of my favorite videos of yours were ones about stuff I had never heard of before. Make what you are excited to make, your true fans will enjoy the passion and perspective.

Sqand

All these BULLIES who complain about ponies better check themselves or they'll get the Cassie treatment

Brett Buttle

Would genuinely love another smaller video next for the main channel

Abby Dech

I would love a video on disneys pleasure island! I need to know the lore. but maybe that’s a patreon topic

Riley Loria

Would love literally anything you decide to put out next

Kosmos

Whatever you feel like working on gets my vote. I think people talking about being disappointed about a 90 minute must be joking or are confused and think its the only thing you were working on between now and the last video.

Maddie Arnautov

That Starcatcher plush got me like 🤩 then the price got me like 😧. Anyway, now I really need a Starcatcher plush and I won’t rest until I find one, so that’s cool!

Sheren

genuinely i dont know who says you talking about ponies is boring?? its literally the thing i want to hear you talk more about but also i feel like it shouldnt matter what those ppl say you should talk about what you want to or what the topic is bc there is an audience who do care and the ppl that dont are lame and can watch one of the disney/star/evermore wars rambles again.

Amanda Kay

Yes, a fellow Dragon Tales hater! That show was insufferable to me.

Originalname37

phantom fandoms (haven't listened yet. sorry if that's not appropriate)

Alex Ellenberger

I loved your shorter video! There was plenty of depth and it reminded me of the vampire tv show video. I’m also relieved you’re not just trying to make more content that gets the NYT involved or something. You’re doing you! That’s what I’m here for.

juju

its so insane that people consider 90 minutes a short video LOL but i'm always excited to watch one of your videos no matter the length or topic!

sam

so excited to watch this one!! re: main channel content, i'm personally one of the folks who's hype for the barbie video, but i'd rather you work on it when you're feeling inspired/not burned out on it!! :) i think the furry-adjacent one sounds like another fun shorter video (and might help people adjust to the idea that not all your vids need to be 4+ hours, but that's just my take haha)

Tom Kluber

I'm a fan of 90 minute videos. I'm a fan of 4 hour videos. I'm a fan of 20 minute videos. As long as the content is good, I don't mind the length

Spiky Ditto

re: a Neopets TTRPG, I think what you talk about with it being light and open to a lot of different type of adventures and experiences is what people had in mind. The issue with using the OGL D&D rules is that that's notoriously the path of D&D-knockoff shovelware. It's passe at this point and you're fighting against a lot of established skepticism in the community, which the Neopets TTRPG playtest rules did nothing to overcome. That's always been an off and on problem with D&D being the dominant presence in TTRPG game dev spaces. Like if almost everyone in video game development was trying to make every game in Bethesda's Skyrim modding system. If the term "a Skyrim game" was a term more well-known and functionally synonymous with "video game" as a term/concept. A timeline where everyone asked why you weren't modding this into Skyrim? And why instead you opted to make a whole new game from the ground-up? Because they'd learned how to mod Skyrim and play it well and didn't want to start from scratch learning how to play a new video game. This isn't a perfect 1:1 thing because like you pointed out, TTRPGs do often come with big rulebooks and there's this implication that there's "homework" involved in committing that analog system to memory when a video game does it all for you. So it's much easier to get people to jump to a new video game vs a TTRPG. That overhead is also on the TTRPG game dev side, so there's kind of a self-feeding cycle where if you know the game well it's also easier to just make your new game using the same rules. And neopets as a setting has always had a D&D furry adventurer aspect, so that's also easy and requires minimal effort to pitch. But not really what I think most nostalgic lapsed players or prospective kickstarters want.

Jason Knight

Thirty, fourty-five, or ninety minutes.. no matter the length of your videos end up being, your content, personal flairs on presenting information and scope of analysis never ceases to entertain and keep me trained on the next video drop. Love your work!

aphajime

noooo jenny as a fellow mlp fan i loooove when you talk about mlp. your aj video is one of my favorites. im sorry you feel pressured into not calling about it :(

zanna

IGNORE THE PONY HATERS i like hearing about ponies i don't think the ponies are boring

Allen Irizarry

Because she likes it? What kind of comment is this...

Becca Yaga

"I really like when they have hair." -Jenny about neopets specifically but also I feel like she would've been able to tell Marnie's bald dad and Marnie's bald uncle apart if they had little cartoon wigs

Allen Irizarry

That second video about Thomas the tank engine is so early 2000s coded where people weren't afraid to be cringe. I love love love love love love love it!!!

Erin G

I love the pony vids!!! I frequently rewatch the old patreon vid where you tour your pony collection. I cannot BELIEVE I'm in the minority here. If you made a separate patreon tier called "pony content only" and charged more than any of the others, I'd join it. Ik I'm just one person, but I say talk about ponies anytime you want!

Alexandra Falk

A 90 minute video is absolutely fine! I have to imagine a large portion of the people expressing disappointment were speaking in jest and the rest are puds. I would love to see more (shorter!) videos on a schedule easier on you.

Seemly Tablespoon

I also love the pony content! But I have a small g1 collection so I'm probably biased.

Jet Puff

This video brings up the fear I have every time I buy something on the Peepy Trading Discord.

Fake Name

I really feel like it's a vocal minority of people who complain about the topic or length of whatever you post. You get millions of views and most of those people don't comment. Most of us are just happy to see you post about anything.

~Ash~

I really liked the new video! A faster shorter one or a longer behemoth as the next option both sound fun! I would say to do whatever you will enjoy working on and what wont burn you out 😁

Spurkle

I’m actually sooooo sad that pony vids/rambles are disqualified (I’m mainly referring to the toys but I think any content with it is great.) People obviously like it because the topics win??

robbie robbins

do you think there would be any way to experiment with a system where you vet the topics to prioritize ones you think you would have something to say/are interested in talking about? it's gotten a bit frustrating because i feel like whenever i click on a ramble video to watch it, it starts with something along the lines of "i had no idea what to do with this topic and havent seen this show and don't have any opinions on it". like, in the new poll, i would be interested to hear about the starcruiser convention! but, if i vote for it, and the video would start with "i didn't keep up with this and had no idea there was a starcrusier convention and i had to struggle to find out about it after the fact and it seems like it was mostly uneventful", and the video about the geese horsegirl movie was one of jenny's favorite weird movies that she's loved for years and could talk about easily, i would have rather voted for that one despite the fact the starcruiser stuff is more in my immediate interest, because it's more interesting to get ramble videos about stuff that jenny cares about! (and less time consuming if she doesnt have to do a bunch of research or watch a movie in order to have an opinion on something she doesn't know about)

Katie E

The tiny plush pet carrier is so cute 😭

Rio Picollo

Please don't let comments about the latest video being "short" make you pivot from the project you're passionate about making. Not only is that an absurd take, they don't speak for the majority of fans who are just excited to get new content (however long it is / takes)

Natalie

I always want to watch whatever you WANT to make. If you're interested and passionate and enjoying making it, it's going to be the best video. Whatever length. Whatever topic. If you're making something to appease people, why make it at all?

aphajime

also god you reminded me of dragon tales. I used to be TERRIFIED of it because I watched one episode where there was a magic stone??? or something that made a dragon invisible + disappear from everyone’s memory. the idea of me waking up and everyone forgetting who I was made me so scared of this show. im like 90% sure that was not the plot point at all though and my hyperactive imagination implanted that in there LOL

Rubén Vincent

Re: Barbie, I guess I sometimes take for granted that everyone else will pick up the slack when I don't comment, so... for the record, I'm among the interested lol. I still revisit the previews you shared in the past, it's so much fun to me. But please, take your time (or let it go, if you have to; I definitely understand what a MASSIVE undertaking it is). I'm not just blowing smoke when I say I always love whatever you put out, either way.

Maggie Knight

i hate that people are mad that they "just" got an 1.5 hr video😭

Vee Thorn

I think absolutely you should do what brings you the most joy. I pay for Patreon because I love hearing you talk about things, and I have watched most of the main channel videos several times.

Vee Thorn

For real! People who complain will always complain. Go with the joy.

Vee Thorn

(Also yes pls talk about ponies!)

Velocipastor

yeah especially considering 99% of them are watching it for FREE and those are aren't pay like $2 a month :/ I'm really disappointed in people for being so entitled. Do they complain when their favourite director "only" makes a 1.5 hr movie and forces them to drive to a theatre and pay $20 to see??

Becca Yaga

She's been talking about it on twitter!

Velocipastor

I can't believe the entitlement of ppl :/ finding a youtuber who talks about her lifelong interests and then going "I don't find this interesting therefore YOU should change what you talk about" ???

Patron Skeleton

I enjoy listening to you talk about what you’re most interested in or excited about. Much of what you discuss is often outside my own particular interests, but it’s the genuine enthusiasm or excitement you have for a particular thing that makes your videos fun.

Andrew Frisina

The Neopets example with Pokemon is so dumb. That's literally a thing alluded to in the universe- intimidation to glean information. There are multiple Pokemon explicitly geared for this level of torture while also healing them to continue the torture.

Louis Z

Maybe the Neopets TTRPG company didn’t actually air all their dirty laundry online. Maybe it’s an iceberg and 90% of the dysfunction is hidden.

Jesús G

I do not mind the pony or theme park videos at all. Honestly, the more invested you are in the topic, the better the video is

Oliver Eldredge

jenny dont listen to what anyone else says i love when you talk about ponys

Alice Lastname

Rewatching that Dragon Tales episode really informed me why there are other PBS shows I remember more fondly!

Jay Green-Sneer

90 minutes is more than cool/fine! But.. Europa Park? Nice! I hope one day you may make a video about Efteling, the Netherlands. It's a fairytale, that's sure! If you *ever* going to visit said fairytale, I may be of service to guide you around the most beautiful, exquisite, infrastructural pleasing, loveliest park of all Europe!

Kelly Michals

I'll take any video on any topic at any length! It was just a bit amusing though, I saw the Incubus video in my feed and the 1hr40m was like, oh a brisk one! Clicked right away, probably watched it 4 times already. Later I saw a 30 minute tom scott video and had to look at my watch and wonder if I wanted to sit though that

Sophie Hallen

I get what you mean, even though in this one she specifically said she thought she would have more to say, but then only figured out when going into the details. I would also like it more like it is on the main channel where Jenny knows exactly what to talk about, but for that I think she would have to get rid of the suggestion system and propose topics herself. I think I am trying to defend her a bit because I could see myself having a similar problem of "Oh, only when actually doing it, I see that it did not make as much sense as it did in my head", which looks a bit silly on the outside. :)

Sophie Hallen

Very topical user name for the silent majority

Polly Flores

Does anyone have recommendations for videos or pages explaining Neopets lore? I remember there being a lot but the death of flash makes it hard to independently research

Tama Hero

I definitely also traded on Pkmncollectors livejournal! I believe the same core group still exists, they moved off of livejournal for the most part (because livejournal declined) and onto reddit and then discord. I still use the discord from time to time when I'm looking for something really specific.

Aurora H.

Anyone complaining abt a video just being 90 minutes will never be satisfied

Sophie Hallen

I loved your reaction to first the my little pony plush and then to all the OCs - you are so excited! Reacting to this stuff could be a main channel video, except that you would probably put too much unwanted potentially mean attention to some very niche channels. It was also hilarious how you went from "this dragon show was so bad" to being really invested in how mean Spike is.

TepigTurtwig

As a diehard TTRPG fan, I can maybe shed a bit more light on the criticism of the neopets thing (as someone who kind of half-heard about it through rpg forums). Specifically, you kind of get to the heart of this by talking about not wanting lots of dense rules --- and that's I think the exact agreement fans had looking at the drama. DnD is a very 'crunchy' game (ie, has lots of just procedural, dense rules), in part due to its baggage of best simulating trekking through a dungeon and then having complicated strategic battles in that dungeon against monsters. If you're going to be spending 4 hours a week (usually for at least a year on end) trekking through dungeons and fighting monsters, that added weight kind of gives it a sense of consistency and fairness. To put it in terms of maybe a more recognizable hobby to this patreon, I'd maybe think of, say, the new Universal or Disney themed lands, which have both general atmosphere, but also specific e-tickets and special attractions. It's fun to just go around a good theme park and soak up the ambience (maybe do some more simple activities), but the rides provide these curated experiences meant to amp that up and punctuate the experience. But on the other hand, these ARE a lot of rules to remember. And if they're not central to the experience, it does start to feel lazy of TRPG designers to chuck them in, and they'll just get in the way of the stuff you want to do. To go back to the theme park analogy, it would be like if the people designing the land allocated half the space to those 'sit in a vehicle and look at a screen while we shake it' rides. That's taking up space where just more ambience would be preferred, and in doing so also impacting the lines and traversal experience around it. Idk if that maybe helps explain the drama to people outside the community a bit better, or if it just comes off needlessly rambly.

Aine

we had to same reaction in sync to that starcatcher 😭 she was one of my faves as a kid

dustjackett

In a similar vein to the furry art thing, feet are enough of a nightmare to draw correctly that the only people who generally care about getting them right in their art REALLY care about it.

Rebecca Chang

100%!! I don’t know anything about my little ponies besides what Jenny has said in her videos, but it’s still really interesting to hear about! It’s genuinely fun to listen to people talk about things they know really well and are interested in.

nico

hearing you say people hate when you talk about ponies made me so sad, those are always my favorite rambles / sections of rambles 😭😭

Gracie Torrez

I actually can’t believe people complain about the pony videos. They’re some of my favorites….

Mike Kelley

Another vote for Barbie. Always go with whatever entertains you and your audience will follow suit. Lead me to the promised land of another fandom I initially had no interest in but will now enjoy again and again on YouTube 🤓

Trina Mercado

"Remember when crashes MEANT something?" took me tf out

Noah Smith

For what it's worth I love when you talk about ponies! The pony videos are definitely among my favorites on here. It's a very comforting, nostalgic topic and your enthusiasm makes them a delight to watch!

Alex

I will watch anything you post

Rian Bolger

I thought the new video was epic, would've been worth the wait if it was half the length!

Rian Bolger

I also dig the MLP stuff and I have zero interest in MLP normally. T You make the minutia of collecting and restoring items very interesting!

sister puke

never stop talking about ponies, jenny! we need your voice of reason amongst the chaff.

Raven

As an avid tween/teen neopets user, I do feel betrayed by the sheer amount of money the site is now constantly trying to extract from players. Like I know they were always trying to make a profit, it was never pure, but it seems so outrageous these days. Or idk. Maybe I'm just old now and can actually recognize product placement for what it is lmao

Raven

Anyway I loved seeing your pets!! They're so cute :)

Sophie!

I love any topic you are passionate about!

Pzombo

Thank you for showing a clip of the dragon train!! The music alone unlocked a memory I completely forgot, that episode was so sick

Priscilla Rapp

To speak to your point about the reuse of the Dnd ruleset, I think it's disingenuous to sell a "new" system that's essentially a reskin of a free, public domain ruleset. Because you're totally right, any experienced DM or group could do a neopets themed campaign. Selling universes and "reskins" for Dnd is already a genre of content on its own - they could've marketed their project without claiming to be a new game. Thought I would chime in and offer my take as a ttrpg player :)

Roni

I'm perfectly happy with shorter videos, and the furry-adjacent one has my curiousity! Something like Europa Park might be fun in the future, but ultimately I think you should go with what makes you happy. I'll watch you talk about anything! (Also, I'm happy to hear about MLP! G3 was a huge part of my childhood, and so it's nice when people acknowledge and enjoy other ones outside of G4.)

Julia Marostica

already left a comment but wanted to add that I love hearing about ponies! also my four-year-old nephew just started watching friendship is magic, and he calls it "unicorns playing tricks"

Joseph Genser

You should 100% DM a TTRPG!!!! And maybe film it for your Patreon? 😊😊

Ello Asty

Even if not every topic is my thing, I'd prefer for you to keep working on topics you believe in rather than adjusting based on complainers. Sometimes I don't know what content I'm going to like until you deliver it.

Gwen Stearns

I had to pause the video because I was laughing so hard when the guy complained that 'realism has been thrown out the window'... in Thomas the Tank Engine...

Raven

Actually the entire trip through neopia was such a wonderful nostalgic time!! Truly thrilling to see the galleries and watch you play all these games I remember so well lol

LW

Stop, it’s the same YouTuber from the Big Joel bonus episode!

Raven

Homophobia??!! LMAO

sinraccoon

pls dont listen to the haters about the ponies i LOVE your pony talk!!!

KTDSpain

I LOVE hearing about ponies!! I had G3 ponies as a kid and was inspired to buy and restore some from Ebay from your videos cleaning ponies! I think anything you're excited about makes a good video because you draw people in and make them excited with you :)

Isabelle Muren

ahhh i wish you would've been able to talk about the neopets battledome tcg!!!

Gutsber

People who don’t like your pony rambles just have evil in their heart

Raven

God I love niche fandom drama lol

KI FI

omg the thomas & friends intro avengers are so legendary I love that some of them also included their fictional gfs

Nate Ford

Ignore everyone. Except for me. People will love whatever you do

M

I love big Joel, did they collaborate on some way?

Pixel-davis

Strangely enough, the most recent ramble of yours that I watched was the one where you used neopets as an excuse to order a smoothie. Because I watched that one and then immediately watched this one next, I figured you must talk about Neopets and/or Jamba Juice all the time in your backcatalog.

MagicalGirlShame

Did US audience's have a US voice actor for the Thomas Narrator ? We had The Ringo Starr.

MagicalGirlShame

I love the fact that the Neopets Web Devs basically cobbled together the Neopets site and every update could make or break the site!

Snek

I think coming out with more often "shorter" (90 minutes is still crazy long!!) videos those disappointed comments will start to filter out and then the next Mega video will be a pleasant surprise.

Jay

“Everyone hates when I talk about the ponies” listen my wife and I did not engage at all with MLP as a property or fandom and we’re captivated by your tales. Continue enthralling us with all sorts of shenanigans Jenny.

Rubra

Also, If it really is just a straight rip of D&D (I assume 5e), it calls into question why anyone would pay for that. It may not be illegal, but it's not worth paying for and feels wrong to market as a new TTRPG system.

cilantro

love this video!! i just wanted to say, the people who complain when you talk about mlp are totally crazy. your video going through and explaining your pony collection is one of my all time faves!! i can't understand not liking it.. it's just so interesting and fun :)

Natasha Thompson

I actually love love love when you talk about mlp, idk who’s complaining but they’re wrong

Neil Dutton

I'm glad Jenny could work through her regret about not murdering more bullies in elementary school.

Fledershrew

It might have been years ago now? But I feel like I recall mention of a Once Upon a Time video in development, similar in format to the VPD video? I would be love to see that! 👉👈

Megan Allen

If you're curious, you should check out the "Jenny's Choice" voice where she shows her MLP collection. Around 8 minutes in she talks about Star Catcher and why she likes her :)

Kempson Bellington

I'd be interested in a Barbie video. And I don't know anything about Barbie, but I'm curious.

Leif Thomas

I choose to believe they put the bell in Spike’s yoyo so they can track his movements more easily. Don’t want the bully sneaking up on you.

Nicole Knapp

This is a good reminder that I need to be more vocal if I like something. I love all your videos, Jenny! I want that Barbie video so bad, but if it’s going to burn you out then do whatever video you want! “Short” videos are just as good as long videos. 🩷🩷 I also voted for this topic because I was kinda hoping you’d talk about MLP. I get why you didn’t, but know that a lot of your viewers wants to listen to you talk about ponies!

Ethan S

Hamtaro mentioned 😖🫶🏻

robbie robbins

no that's true, i was referring mainly to past videos, for example the action park ramble where she begins it by saying 'this is already a defunctland video and i have nothing more to add and its making me anxious to have to make a repeat of his video'. i actually did end up really liking this ramble, i was just frustrated to tab in to another one that seemed to start the same way. i think there have been some topics in the past, for example the action park one, that maybe should have been veto'd because she could tell they were a bad idea from the start, while in between topics like this are more fine and can produce good rambles

Emily Leeper

that really is the thing with hasee bounce

Emily Leeper

also, time to log into my OG neopets account ty 🫡

L Woods

I love your MLP content, I was a child of the early 90s and it is extremely my jam.

John Thomas

Shining Time Station was the American version of Thomas, loved that show when I was a kid. Ringo and then George Carlin were the conductors (narrators). Your comments during the dragon show at the end were hilarious. Your 90 min vids can be seen as EP's vs the 3-4hr full albums. I'm old.

psycheDahlia

Like unless I missed something, girlie wasn’t suicidal, her whole character is that she’s a really shy and nervous dragon who shrinks down really small when she gets scared. Did they somehow mistake her shrinking and hiding to be a suicide attempt?!

psycheDahlia

I was on Jenny’s side about the package never showing up, and the seller was for sure rude about it - but I was trying to give the seller the benefit of the doubt, thinking that maybe they did send it and it got lost in the mail, BUT THEN she got to the part about the seller relisting the exact same plush later?! 😭 That’s deeply messed up!! I’m so mad on Jenny’s behalf!

cilantro

i also like the idea of the next main channel video being a shorter one :) it seems like it would be a lot easier on you, and it would be nice for people who aren't patreon subscribers. i say don't listen to the people complaining / being disappointed abt the new video being "only" 90 mins, they don’t understand all the effort and time that goes into your videos!

LL

I'm only a few minutes in but I love hearing you talk about Ponies! Jenny's Choice is a comfort watch for me...and might be the reason why I have several of my G2 (yes I know but that's my nostalgia) ponies back on my shelf looking down on me. I'm happier for it!

Wendy Comet

I love it when you talk about ponies! I think it's so fun and relaxing.

Ella Taran

ur nastiness is looking especially adorable ahem! i mean wicked and disgraceful this video

Sophie Hallen

For video length: I enjoyed the Incubus one just as much as the longer ones. I have the feeling that videos just become the length of what you feel is needed for the topic and that is what makes them good, so I will enjoy it. Sidenote: I am one of the people that would be interested in the barbie video, but in the end, I would much rather have you be more happy at what you work on. Maybe after releasing a few "shorter" ones (1.5h is not really short by normal YT standards), you will actually feel like working on a longer one. I think it goes to show that there is always a silent majority that are happy with what you are doing and only speak up a bit when you mention that you get discouraged by a vocal minority :)

MW

just nodding along to Jenny's rant about neocash because that's also when I stopped playing in middle school

Bulu

100% second this, I really admire your content as it feels like you make what you want when you want (which is really refreshing). To me you being a creator who makes things their passionate about without having to stick to a specific schedule, niche or set of expectations makes the content you do put out absolutely wonderful. I think this comment is totally right about the silent majority vs the vocal minority.

Luis

What a perfectly cozy ramble for this cold and rainy day in the bay area!

Evan Chappelear

I am so enchanted that there’s a Thomas the Tank Engine fandom that’s like “😡 We demand realism in our Thomas the Tank Engine cartoons!”

Ella Taran

of course your neopet has blue hair pronouns and explicit tabletop sex

David Lemonds

(just my 2 cents personally) If you're overwhelmed by the scale of the barbie one then don't do it just yet. You can't drive yourself mad for a paycheck. (Not trying to insinuate there's nothing to it for you but the "job" portion, just recognizing it's your career and that does mean it carries certain weight) I think most people were just thrown off by the "relatively shorter vid" because the pattern was broken from what had been seen for the last few years, I would try not to read too much into it if you can manage it mental health wise. You have a unique talent, that millions recognize, and while there's going to be some folks who are always expecting a 4 hour epic there are plenty who are just happy to see you still posting

Zero Trick Pony

For what it's worth I love your work and I don't evaluate you on a per-minute basis! I trust you to make a video that's worth its watch time, regardless of whether that's 30 minutes or 300. I want the runtime to be about what you feel is worth saying, not hit a target. Whiners are gonna whine! Keep up the great work! <3

Joy

Something about the Barbie video seems especially fun now and I’m totally interested! But whatever you are interested in driving into is the best. Also I am no longer fazed at all by the length of anyone’s video. I’m happy we get quality niche stuff when we can. Thanks Jenny! :)

pablo.picassno

personally i love all of your pony content and can’t even comprehend that people find it boring!!

Kierra Sauder

Honestly, I love everything you put out no matter the length. I will also admit that I've been excited about the potential Barbie video since it was first mentioned!

skellbörg

Jenny your pony videos are my absolute favorites!!! I have rewatched every pony video so many times, they are the most soothing and comforting videos on the internet to me.

Laurellala

It makes me so sad to hear that you get such backlash for just following your heart. Like what you said about people hating when you talk about ponies- I personally love it because it’s so genuine and you. I still love well researched videos, but when you talk about your own experiences in fandom spaces or from childhood, that’s something uniquely you that nobody else could be talking about, and I see a lot of value in it personally. Similarly with the bad feedback you said you received with a shorter video, I really hope you don’t take it to heart. Making a video long does not intrinsically give it more value, and I think we’re entering an interesting age of the internet where people will make multi hour long videos that are so nothing JUST to be someone who makes long videos. Your videos do a good job of conveying your point tastefully, no matter their length. And I would hate it if you felt you had to avoid talking about interesting topics just because you don’t have 4 hours worth of things to say about them. I know it must be tricky to ignore critique because your livelihood literally is dependent on an audience. But I think throughout your time online you have always been able to gain an audience by being your authentic self, first with friendship is witchcraft and then with starting your more recent channel. Personally I trust your taste level and I think that whatever YOU are most interested in pursuing will make for the best videos! Again, totally understand the algorithm is a beast that must be fed, but whatever video that keeps your cup full and puts you in a head space where you enjoy creating and can keep yourself from burning out is the one I want to see.

LL

I jumped to the screen when Jenny mentioned Hamtaro and let out a little wail when we immediately skipped passed it. My kingdom! My kingdom for a Jenny Ramble about Hamtaro! The Cartoon Network site with the voice clips and the Leaf Trampoline mini game! Ham Ham Heartbreak! The fansites! I think Ham Ham Paradise is still going even. The surprisingly intense shipping wars. The weirdly specific hatedoms you'd get for individual characters even unrelated to the shipping stuff.

Skylark

Your love of ponies (of every generation! So rare!) and the way you expertly articulate yourself and your points is what initially drew me to your content a few years back! I adore every single time you chat about ponies (G1 Baby Snookums is one of my all time favorites. So stupid looking.) and your time at the conventions purchasing the old toys, me and my friends used to frantically participate in online auctions to get the ponies we were obsessed with when we were young teenagers. My personal favorite video of yours is the pony cleaning you posted and few years ago. I just recently became a patron and I am a huge fan of your works (FiW included), I really appreciate your attitude and the general outlook you have on past and present media. Not to mention the cohesive composition of your thoughts and obscure topics which is refreshing and absolutely delightful! Keep talking about your passions! They are so interesting!! 🩷🐴🎠

Seessie

Me too! When I made another account recently I was astounded that you could just buy the clothes with neopoints now!

LL

Between the Sandshrew incident, the Neocash story, and the cursing of Spike the Dragon, my takeaway from this video is that I hope I never or never have unknowningly earned Jenny's wrath. Living obliviously untill the moment her benevolence and mercy runs out.

Ellie

I can't believe there are pony haters. Minty didnt die for this- pony content forever

Jacob Crowe

The guy talking about Dragon Tales cadence was like he was about to start rapping.

Monica McFadden

I absolutely love your Cassie monologue. Justice for Cassie.

Paperkin

Did you watch Wishbone, it was my fav show on PBS

Cammie

I remember liking Dragon Tales as a kid but omg that episode was lowkey awful. You’re so right about how children should be taught that Spike’s cruelty is not an acceptable outlet for his unhappiness. Also let Cassie choose violence lol

swervegriffin

I know in a video a while ago you said you didn’t like Buffy but like it’s so good have you revisited

Holden S

totally get the burnout from the barbie video, but it would be amazing. i always think back to when you said that you might make a video on Once Upon a Time and i’ve always longed for it, though i know that would probably take a million years to do as well😭 europa park would be fun!! always welcome new theme park jenny content🩷

Alpz

i'm sure you have a lot of fans who, like me, became fans because of your MLP fan content. we love your pony rambles!

JoshuaMartian

The words every girl (Jenny) wants to hear: “Welcome! I’m a living tree!”

Rhiannon Held

I will say, however long you've known a group of friends, assuming you know exactly what their comfort level is with any fraught subject seems risky. Might as well communicate and discuss!

AshFerraz

Your pony content literally led me to start collecting vintage ponies lol. Whoever finds it boring is wrong

Charnel

That Anthrocon you went to was 2024 and ever since you got bed bugs i've been anticipating some sorta furry-adjacent video. even if its not on the scale of brony autopsy, just a vlog or something.

reina

i understand audience opinion will always carry some influence but tbh im here for whatever interests you the most & whatever type of content feels good to work on

a.s.

GET THE STARCATCHER PLUSH JENNY, I NEED YOU TO USE MY PATREON MONEY FOR THIS

Papa Q. Bear

I would LOVE to hear more about ponies!

Rebecca B

I started laughing so hard when the avengers of Thomas the train engine began appearing in the intro.

a.s.

''remember when crashes MEANT SOMETHING?'' and ''THREE months of SCUM!!!'' are effervescent to me together edit: TRAINS ADVOCATE <<<<<333333 🚅🚄🏳️‍⚧️🏳️‍⚧️🏳️‍⚧️🚅🚄🚅🚄🚅 edit 2: you said mac and cheese kid cuisine and i said ''with the corn and the little brownie 🙂‍↕️🙂‍↕️🙂‍↕️'' and you immediately also said that. this video steals the crown for most autistic ramble from the anti-jenny awards and i wouldn't have it any other way. 10000/10

michael

The Thomas section is giving me SO much nostalgia. I hadn’t thought about that dragon train in so long!! I had the little toy that would tilt its head when you pressed down on the tail, it was a superstar in my room too!

bones

I was very excited to hear about ponies…

Blake

neopets part feels like 2007 when you would go over to your friends house and do computer together

Will S

As a big TTRPG nerd I'll provide my two cents on some things brought up in the section on the Neopets TTRPG On the discussion about whether or not it was 'okay' that it was essentially a reskinned D&D - I think the underlying issue is moreso that the framework of D&D (being a relatively crunchy/rules-heavy/combat-focused TTRPG) sort of was tonally mismatched with Neopets as a brand. There are a lot lighter, open-source system frameworks that I imagine might suit neopets more. 51:38 you are truly opening up a can of worms relating to TTRPG discourse, i'm not kidding when i say this is probably one of the biggest ongoing debates in the TTRPG space over the last few years lmao As of recently a lot of games started including in the rules about discussing boundaries and establishing guidelines for triggers and all this stuff and half of the response is 'this is a great guideline to introduce this will be great at preventing uncomfortable or awkward scenarios!' and the other half is 'this is uncomfortable and awkward to do in the first place, this type of stuff usually doesn't even have to be discussed if you're playing with friends' (and then a 500+ comment reddit thread ensues) The failure of the kickstarter also is wildly in-line with most other failed TTRPG kickstarters also.

mark

my ears perked up so quick when you mentioned Hamtaro! i've never met anyone who knows who they are! I have many sets of the figure and play houses

Tyson Graham

As an Australian, it's wild watching the Thomas section and seeing clips of old episodes and them not be voiced by Ringo Starr. As for the animated series, the best part about the og series was that they were real things and not animated. I felt the same watching the new Thunderbirds and Captain Scarlet stuff. The puppets, even though they had quirks, were such a huge part of why I loved the originals. Another great video, as always.

Roxanne13579

My goodness, the Thomas the Tank Engine avenger squad absolutely killed me xD Also Hamtaro mention! loved it so much and I remember being so upset when they decided to only air Hamtaro during the little little kids section of Jetix, which aired while I was at school. I still have a Hamtaro and a Bijou plush, and three of the Hamtaro games.

TheQuietOne

Reaching in my skin. These wounds, they will not heal.

Jelly

I have been to Thomas Land in Fuji Q, Japan, and it was the single most haunting experience of my life. We went on a rainy day, close to closing time, and fog was rolling in. The trains had pupils that swung from side to side and gave the impression they were following you around the empty plaza...

Wife of Horse Husband

Looking at the thumbnail I KNEW it was gonna be Neopets… I freaking love Neopets and am not ashamed to say as a 35 year old girl that I was playing it last year as well. My OG account got purged as well (RIP lilystrawberry my beautiful yellow Acara) and I made another one during college. Losing Flash killed it, but the lack of plots and new content also didn’t help either. I would definitely listen for a Neopet only ramble

Wife of Horse Husband

Oh also 1. Yes, Your Nastiness, (lol came from the witches video) put whatever you feel like on your main channel, I still go back to your 10-20 mins videos because they’re hilarious and fun and 2. Who dares not love pony content??

DJ

As a boy who grew up banned from girl things, I want to hear about the ponies.

fun on the internet

i’d Love to hear about europa park, but i’d never say no to shorter content. more jennie is always good for the health

violetta

please don’t listen to the people who are ‘disappointed’ by the 90 minute video! real jenny fans love anything you post no matter the length. plus if they need more content they can become patrons :) also i’m planning a trip to europa park and i would LOVE a video about it

Octomew

I hate to say it, but covering bigotry and sex scenes in rules is common fair with these sort of games because sometimes people with... less then stellar social skills might put together an inappropriately explicit or hateful game. The rules are there to move gently nudge people into, like, basic consideration of other people and making it clear the game designers don't endorse this behaviour. In the rules for a *Neopets* TTRPG though? A bit strange 🤔

Octomew

Also the Thomas the Tank Engine fandom seemed so silly at first, but they seem to be such good friends I got jealous 😭 I'll never have my PNG avatar in a video with all my pals

Martin Hobson

Jenny, while I've heard that constructive criticism can be a "gift", with regard to your topics, I say sod that & just follow your heart. I had zero interest in/ awareness of MLP, Neopets, theme park lore or even China Beach prior to finding your channel. It's your passion & insight into these topics that make the videos so watchable. I know it's easy to focus on the negative as those comments & thoughts cut through much sharper, but from what I'm seeing here, most of your Patrons want you to do you & we're ready for whatever you serve up. Personally, give me a "short" vid, Barbie, whatever; as long as it's what you feel like doing. Also, excellent seething rage coming through whilst threatening that dragon bully. Hilarious.

TalysAlankil

WHO is tired of hearing you talk about ponies. who in this comment section is doing it.

Regular Pepsi

Ugh! I love your 14 minute videos. I rewatch the Hallmark ladies more than I care to admit! And I love your super long videos! I just love your content! Please post whatever you have!

Jacob Crowe

America got both Ringo Starr episodes and George Carlin. I believe the only real difference between American Thomas and Commonwealth countries is that America never uses the name "the Fat Controller" and only referred to him as Sir Topham Hatt

kels!

whoever told jenny they didn’t want to hear about ponies i will find you and i will torture you horribly

Fiona Westphal

I personally love hearing Jenny talk about mlp, it’s the reason I support on Patreon in the first place + why I started collecting ponies myself :,(

Meggy

So crazy to see you go to equestria daily. that was my homepage back in the day lmao it definitely was less horny, not completely without nsfw but less.

Meggy

"its if kylo ren had a trainsona" thanks jenny going to be thinking about that one a lot lmao

xLine

I don't really care about topic or length. I've watched many videos where the thumb nail had me reluctant and then they were one of my favourites anyway. I think the biggest determinator for a quality video is the creators inspiration and motivation.

god’s favorite sacrificial lamb

the modern thomas the tank engine criticism videos are giving me such strong flashbacks to religiously watching “how disney ruined club penguin” videos as a kid. except those were made by other kids and set to like, switchfoot songs whereas these are adult men.

xLine

the hallmark video is honestly perfect. i love those microcosms jenny finds and how she presents them.

Malcolm Cooke

Stuff like the Thomas the Tank engine fandom section is why I pay $2 every month. Actually amazing.

Sarah B

Am I dumb? I genuinely like All Engines Go lol My son (4) and I watch it most mornings.

Sarah B

Feels to me like that was included in the Neopets TTRFP purely because it would have been in the D&D rule book and they were basically lift and landing that game with Neopets skinning

MaxMin

I love the pony talks! I go back to that Jenny's Choice where you go through your ponies often

Angelica Sather Hodgetts

I want to see what the furry adjacent video is because time I think “hmm I wonder what Jenny is going to do next” the words “furry adjacent” come to my mind and it’s just been a floating two word phrase affixed to nothing! I think people would be happy to see another video sooner this time even if it’s not “as long” …then maybe a longer one could follow that.

David Bleek

Im sorry Jenny, I think your greatest youtuber crown has been usurped by whoever was behind that insane Thomas the tank engine critique 😭

Minkopi

Barbie. 💕

MaxMin

Love the neopets talk! I fear this will get me back into playing regularly lol. I would do the thing with the scalping from shops and selling yourself and eventually thought I was good enough at it to do the shops where the hardcore players played, like the stamp shop, and I could to get anything. Very humbling moment lol

Mike Carpenter

Unfortunately while I understand and agree with the concept of “these shouldn’t be in the TTRPG rule book because the group playing should organically be able to have these conversations with respect if they come up at all,” it is unfortunately very much the case that players will push boundaries and make an entire table very uncomfortable, and it’s not unheard of for those people to not stop that behavior unless there is an explicit rule in the rule book about it. While I agree the content should probably be unnecessary to mention for a Neopets banded TTRPG and a game like D&D is more likely to encounter the issue due to being inherently more adult and (most likely) more prone to being played with strangers than among friends, they are in there (or wherever they copied it from) for a reason

PurpleIsDebeste

yeah thats a trend in indie ttrpgs the past decade. i do agree with jenny that i dont think they accomplish much, but its not unique to neopets or strange of them to include it

Octomew

Oh dear, did no one actually read what they were putting in there?

Elle

I recently found a g3 pony at the thrift and I've been longingly browsing g1-3 pony listings on ebay ever since. Personally, I'd love to have more pony content from you, especially regarding the old fandom and collecting!

shai

the tone of disappointment people have if your videos are a bit shorter is probably partly bc they expect the development time between your projects to be long. if you feel drawn to making another shorter video you should. imo your creative flow is more important than keeping it consistent for the sake of meeting expectations or managing algorithms.

Becca Yaga

The video where she creates a day at Disney for her worst enemy and addresses the viewer as the enemy still chills my blood.

JP

That Thomas review intro gave me such insane Channel Awesome energy, it's so cringe, lol. Also, that Thomas show really doesn't look that bad? All the critiques of it we see here seem to boil down to "it's a different interpretation of the thing I grew up with so I hate it."

aaaaaah!!!!!!

I'm biased because I love theme park content, but a Europa park video would be great!

Suzie Lloyd

This was such a good ramble vid, definitely going to going my rewatch rotation! Also, I'm in full agreement with a lot of other comments, and I'm more than happy for you to follow where your creativity and passion leads you! I love when you talk about theme parks and MLP! I couldn't care less about the length of main channel videos because I trust that you'll make the video as long or as short as it needs to be for a given topic! I'm excited for whatever project you personally want to focus on next ✨️

Brynn

would love to see the furry adjacent one- personally i really like the shorter ones

Kayah

I personally enjoy hearing about ponies.

Austin F

also i can't fully explain why but i laughed really hard at "get it together cassie"

Austin F

i love hamtaro!!! i used to watch the hamtaro show at the earliest time slot on toonami (it was like 4pm i think?) my favorite was always cappy 🥺

Beatriz

I personally was always excited about the barbie video!

Nora

As far as the mattel Park in Arizona goes, I live in Phoenix and drive past the construction site pretty frequently. There's definitely progress (you can see the rollercoaster gradually being put together!!) but it absolutely does not look ready lol

se.mo

Do whatever you want for videos! As long as you're passionate about the topic I am just along for the ride~

Nora

So it definitely is actively happening but it doesn't look like it'll open for a couple years at least

Nora

"why creepypasta sucks" is a comfort watch for me!! As is your long form content lol but I agree, the shorter videos were so funny too!!

Samantha Chapman

I think you basically got the problems with the TTRPG lol... Stuff like the romance/sex guidelines is entirely normal in an RPG that isn't a licensed kids' product. It looks very much like it was lifted straight out of another project. Although I'm genuinely surprised to see someone changed enough words to specifically describe a femme male neopet but didn't question having that section at all.

Eddie Farmer

Omg there's another youtube guy whose 'rantsona' is Tamatoa? Someone tell Schaffrillas immedately.

Spencer Hastings

When will there be a neopets movie where they battle webkinz?

Allie

Omg I can’t believe you mentioned the Matel park in AZ. I feel so seen <3 It’s been such a joke for phoenix residents that the park will never be finished

Cat Brooks

I was on pkmncollectors! 100% certain I did not sell anyone a Sandshrew though. I collected a bunch of different guys but I still have my Magnemite collection, my favorite little guy

Sophiaaa

I think if people were disappointed by the 90 minute video length it's likely because they think there will be another long wait. And if you're thinking of changing that pattern anyway I think another 90 minute or so video delivered sooner than they expected will be very positively received. But on that note I should add I've really enjoyed reading the comments on the incubus video and most were just happy you had posted and engaging with the content of the video. So...I wouldn't worry? You do you? And I was definitely excited for the Barbie video. And the furry one. It's all good you know.

Luis

Just rewatched Let's Fix Some Ponies, A Critical Brony Analysis of My Little Pony: The Movie, The Applejack Problem and next up is The Last Bronycon: a fandom autopsy because there's nothing better than listening to someone talk about what they're passionate about!

Landon J

I already commented that I'm looking fwd to the furry adjacent video, but I wanted to add that I'd also love to hear you talk about MLP (your takes on the show and fandom were fun!) or rank the Barbie movies.

SD

I pay good money for pony content!

Sarah P

I was also inundated with Usuki swag bag emails from geekify 😭 had to verify my address multiple times because I moved in that time. the most painful thing was that the usuki dress-up magnet was not magnetized! Did not stay on my fridge!

Regular Pepsi

I rewatch it all the time. It brings me joy

Isaiah Gaines

Yes I was going to comment similar thoughts but you put it perfectly. I'm always in support of the artist driving the boat and don't think there's a need to fully switch to exclusively 2 hour plus videos. Personally I think a couple shorter ones sounds exciting!

Billy Campelo

Watching this made me remember how my neopets would have to eat at the soup kitchen because I’d lose all of my neopoints gambling on roo island

GundamBradley

I am glad that you learned your lesson, and are not giving Neopets 10 dollars. Not after Sandshrew.

Roobyfreakinrooo

1:17:00 "Today I'm talking about Dragon Tales" 😂 I'm dead

Stigcrafter

I assume most the people who were complaining/joking about ‘just’ 90 minutes are just casuals who are only familiar with the last big video or two, I don’t think the vast majority of people care about the length and are just hype for a new video :)

jaime

even when i saw the plush was $1400 i still expected jenny to buy it right then and there 😭

tumbleweed🍂

My american mind is enraptured by the loads of pumpkins in the Pumpkin Pavilion

Smore

If you don't already know it, JellyNeo's Book of Ages is pretty comprehensive https://bookofages.jellyneo.net/ Jenny went through some of it in her last ramble where she talked about neopets, #83. I think the youtube channel "Neopian Lore" is fun. I also like seeing old player speculations about events, and there are some forums still around DailyNeopets, NTWF, etc, but they are far fewer now (literally right now is how I found out Jellyneo doesn't have forums anymore lol) There are a lot of Petpages out there too with lore and/or peak 2000's internet. I'm not super familiar with how to navigate those, but I think some people have directories or lists of them.

Jenny Nicholson

I still have all my little hamsters too! I wanted to add to my collection as an adult, esp get Harmony and Spat from the Gameboy game, but they're so expensive, it's like $20 a hamster

marissa

the amusement park we already have in arizona (castles and coasters/golf n stuff) is proof that they dont belong there 😭

Cammie

Very Realmtown of the RPG developers to ask the public for ideas, and very Evermore of them to air out their internal drama in public too

tumbleweed🍂

Comment what YOU think we should name our $400,000 tabletop game

Emma H

In the Dragon Tales video, I recognized the goblinsona and realized that the same person made a video that Big Joel talked about in a recent patreon/nebula video. I wonder if it's just a coincidence or if Jenny saw that and it lead to the Dragon Tales one

Ontario Traffic Man

For the next main channel video, please pick whichever topic you're most excited about, regardless of the length of the resulting video. People will complain about the length no matter how long or short it is.

tumbleweed🍂

I'll break their favorite yo-yo while showing off my super cool circle trick

Ontario Traffic Man

Exactly. I thought the whole point of Patreon was to make it financially unnecessary to chase the algorithm or popular topics or whatever

tumbleweed🍂

Yeah joel recently did a patreon video with lindsay ellis and they accidentally revealed this guy writes all his scripts with AI

Ontario Traffic Man

And what happened to the Efteling footage? Wasn't that going to become something?

OKC

I will never tire of hearing about ponies. I mean come on.

Ontario Traffic Man

Well said. I certainly didn't start watching Jenny videos because I had a pre-existing passion for the Hallmark YouTube channel

Reina Warnert

I got really deep into the Incubus stuff and read basically all of the comments and tracked down all of the reddit forums talking about it so I could figure out the drama with the unnamed vampire-- and the general consensus I got was 1) absolute joy that you had posted on the main feed again in these trying times and 2) a couple good-humored jokes about "short form content" because the video was still. so. long! Anyhow, if anyone is truly upset about it being a little shorter than the last one they can go suck eggs, but that's not the vibe I was getting. I don't know if you'll ever see this, but I love all you're doing, would greatly enjoy the Barbie deep-dive when you're up for it, and would enjoy anything you decide to get into. Really honestly, the Incubus video brought me so much joy because it reminded me of all the weird creative stuff I did in my youth and to keep being unapologetically weird and creative.

Scrum Diddely Umptious

With regards to your eeevil video plans... literally don't listen to any of us your ghastlyness. In particular wrt your patreon- we are so spoiled and well taken care of that any complaints end up coming across like those small dogs that pretend they hurt their paw so you carry them and they dont have to touch wet grass. You are the most considerate you could possibly be about your Patrons and providing value all the time, at least it seems that way to me. Your instincts and artistic vision are what lead this here ship, and if you decide to take 3 years off to make a video on a topic i dont even end up liking, so be it! I signed up because I like the cut of your jib lol

ox

just wanna put on the record that your mlp collection video is an all time fave for me and probably the ramble i have rewatched the most!

LunchBoxGhost

Jenny teaching us all how to be restockers, I live. Also, Jenny, Food Club can make you so many Neopoints! Try betting with Nsheng beginner or JK Scrolling Down!

Natalie Arnold

THANK YOU. I knew I recognised that avatar from somewhere. It was driving me nuts because that channel was nowhere in my history.

hazelandcats

keep talking about ponies!!! I love the pony videos!! I'm literally drawing Princess Tiffany right now!!

Mads

The Thomas the Train section had me crying. I, too, love a unique OC commentary video. The group OC video was such a gem

Mr. Morrison

There's something very funny to me about bitter, gatekeep-y adult fans of Thomas the Tank Engine.

Danielle Windram

I supported the Geekify kickstarter for The Last Unicorn plush around 3 years ago and never got anything. Not even the pins that were apart of the pledge that they currently sell 😭 I think they will continue to fumble niche ips sadly

Kay

Your Supreme Malevolence, Queen of All Trees With Faces, if I may be perfectly honest: those that dare to criticize you are insolent fools, and utterly unworthy of your attention. Firstly, while I've seen people jokingly complain about 90 minute videos being too short, if anyone is serious about it... that's ridiculous. I do enjoy your longer videos, but I know they're a lot of work, and videos don't have to be hours long to be good. Secondly, I personally love hearing about the ponies. As someone who's only into the cartoons, it's interesting to hear from the toy collecting side of the fandom. I personally don't collect toys or go to theme parks, but I find it interesting to hear about these things I don't know anything about. Finally... I will say that while I would not dare to impose upon Your Sinistrocity with petty video requests, I am - respectfully and patiently - really looking forward to your eventual Barbie video. I'm happy to wait as long as it takes, and I'd even understand if it was too much, but I am definitely interested. I really liked your Patreon video on the Tinkerbell movies, and I just find it really interesting to give attention to these pieces of media that people see as disposable; I've never been into Barbie, and I'm really curious what's there to be found. (Wild to me that people said they weren't interested, even aside from the rudeness.) May the trees with faces forever speak of how cool you are, Your Spookiness!

Kingdon Radio Hour

I’m sorry you’ve gotten hate for talking about pony’s- those are easily my favorite videos of yours. I love ponies too

Adam!

I wonder if Jenny ever played poptropica

softnsquishy

the kissing princess Luna part has me giggling out loud at my work desk omg 😭😭😭😭

Azrael Macool

Oh just to clarify about the complaint about the rules copying from D&D… the issue wasn’t that the rules are open source. Having different games sharing the same rule set is fairly common. The issue is that they promised a bespoke rpg that was built around the kind of gameplay that Neopets would offer. Instead they just put out a D&D clone. And a lot of games are essentially D&D clones, that’s even sorta fine, but D&D is built around combat primarily, and it just felt a weird fit. D&D is also pretty mechanic heavy, and some people felt a more rules lite game would be more appropriate. Off top my head, if I were making a Neopets TTRPG, and wanted to base it on something existing that’s also open source, id do maybe Fate. Essentially you define a few facts about your character, these can be things like your job or what kind of creature you are or even like a quote, these are your aspects. In a scene, you can invoke an aspect to either just do a thing or give you a bonus. So if your aspect is “I’m the belle at the ball!” And the scene involves dancing at a party, you can basically say “I want to invoke my aspect to do [whatever]” and the gm will usually allow it so long as it fits. There are more complexities if you want them but it’s basically that simple

Maggy Symanski

no jenny, please work on some shorter videos, people are gonna complain no matter what and its not like longer videos mean more content. thats a bad way to put it, but your video efficiency remains constant, so its really just a question of delayed gratification, depending on how your effort is spread over time. some people like it, some people don't, but if you're already working on something short pls keep working on it 😭

Spublii

I'm sorry you got scammed

Danielle Windram

I have a long email chain from the past 3 or more years since it started where every once in a while I go “please tell me anything”. I emailed today and they claimed they will be receiving The Last Unicorn plush at the end of the month??? What a weird company man 😭

Forrest C.

Personally I'm excited for this furry-adjacent video and really hope it's next in line!

Brenna

As a former low-level member of pkmncollectors, I wish I could go back in time and get you that Sandshrew... I had positive experiences in that community and still have some of my collection today. PSST ITS NOT THE 2001 LIFESIZE CHIKORITA BUT THERE IS A NEW VERSION AVAILABLE VIA THE USA/NA POKEMON CENTER AND I HAVE IT AND ITS LOVELY. Its face is so cute and the leaf is so big; 10/10 chiko ... i also have one of the 2001 Takara Tomy versions and hope you find one too (shoutout to Legendary Japanese Imports where I bought mine for a fair price last year, although i'm not sure if they'll find another soon). I loved the rest of the video and agree with everyone saying to make whatever length videos you want about whatever topics. I haven't watched the newest psuedo-Twilight one because I want to watch the movie with my Twilight-bestie first, so tbh that 1 video was worth 2 lol. Cheers!

TG

Red Rooster is a rotisserie chicken fast food place. And it's wonderful

heyitzmae

there’s something so beautiful about encountering what i like to call unbridled autistic joy online. we’re all so jaded now so i’m glad people like this still exist

kelly m

it's so the videos can't be added to people's public playlists

mark

oh my gosh i know!!! ridiculously overpriced!!!!

akri s

Your mlp video made me a believer and why I'm here for the next year

Brandon Carr

YES I came to the comments for this! BOCBOCBOCBOC🗣️

金城優海

i love the thomas the tank engine critique video that has all those people with their ocs who are all obviously probably autistic hanging out together in think its really cool

金城優海

haha I was the quiet girl always put with the evil boys

Miraflorina

Do you recall on what basis she disliked it?

swervegriffin

I think she said her family watched it and she tried to keep up reading synopses on the fan sites but when rewatching it later thought it wasn’t as good as Vampire Diaries/ was overrated because of whedon

COTF Creative

I was one of the lucky ones whose original Neopets avoided being purged. Someone tried to hack my account a year or two ago which brought me back into the fold of playing daily, with my Neopets who are now over 9000 days old 😂 There was just a video games exhibit in Melbourne which had Neopets in it, but I missed it by a day when I went there. I got some merch though - including a Neopets cookbook to cook all those desserts! And now I need that blue Kacheek beanie, since my first Neopet was a blue Kacheek.

IndigoRen

I definitely don't understand people pooh-poohing the idea of the Barbie video. The concept feels similar to the Land Before Time video, which I've watched several times.

Rhiannon Shaw

the way you named Trellamina is EXACTLY how I named my own neopets. Off the top of my head, Loomiana (?). Also, I cannot access my original neopets account because I was under 13 when I made it and I made up a birthday that I thought sounded cool, and now you need your birthday to login. Thanks for the nostalgia Jenny <3

Asja Dally

I love Europa Park! That would be so cool if you didn't video on that.

Madi Stoller

From 2003 to 2006 I was homeschooled and spent all the time on my computer. I would code people’s neopets pages (their shops?) in exchange for valuable items. I had a paintbrush collection and a ridiculous about of neopoints. Tried to get into the account years later, but I couldn’t get in and never made a new one.

Art By Howie

If there is one Barbie video fan, then it is me, if there are none then I am dead. I remember trying to go on neopets as a kid with a McDonald’s toy cause I thought it worked like webkinz and not being able to figure anything out bhfhjkhghk. Loved the recent video and look forward to whatever you decide to put out next <3

Sanica Rao

bring back the eight minute furry fish plushy sewing videos! i personally don’t mind if ur videos are any particular length lol

Jimini

The way I waited to make an annoying comment about how you've talked about Neopets before entirely because I just knew that you would eventually bring up Jamba Juice and *that* would be the moment you put the pieces together

Bel

Just wanted to say that I loved this ramble, as always! I’m not a MLP fan, but I love hearing you talk about it, as I find it fun whenever people talk about something they are passionate about. It may not be helpful to say it, but I’m excited about whatever video you decide to put out next on the Main Channel. Doesn’t matter the length or content, I’ll be excited to watch it! I trust your instincts, and I know I’m not the only one, so I hope that eases some of the worries you might have.

Katie Bertola

I too considered myself too uncool for Limited Too. I think most of us were. 😂

Zoe Konigsberg

Jenny!! I love that you talked about Neopets again!!!! When I saw the neopets font on the title card I got so hyped. Your gallery tour was amazing and you’re so creative with your themes. you’re also completely correct that brown is the best uni color. It was cool to hear you comment about how the website today compares with the Neopets of your childhood. The Neopets economy has changed so much with the introduction of the daily quest log, Trudy’s, rare prize pool items in events, etc. As you noted it used to be that you had to play the stocks or do food club bets to even have the hope of affording something luxurious, there was no way flash games were gonna cut it no matter how good you are at playing them (also Hassee Bounces rules). I know opinion is split on the new difficulty curve, but I like the way that the site is moving. There’s more monetization but there’s also more merch and I do like the premium benefits. I think that more neopoints in circulation simply makes the game more fun. when you know that even really lofty goals are possible to achieve, it encourages players to interact with things like foot club bets or feeding kads because now spending that kind of money doesn’t put you into a financial neohole. I never used to care about stamp collecting but now I do. Maybe I’ll never be able to fill the pages completely, but it’s POSSIBLE now where it literally wasn’t before. All that to say: It was a complete pipe dream of my youth to have a Maraquan Aisha and now I have one! Hooray! I’m glad you’re also getting to fulfill some Neopets goals and having fun with your shop. I’m sure you’ve seen it, but if you’re ever interested there are some good neo-legal userscripts in the wiki of r/neopets that are very helpful for restocking and price comparison. Thanks for taking about neopets again. Next time if it comes up in the poll I would love to hear your thoughts about the Void Within plot. I know you must have opinions about the art. Wow this comment got away from me. I love that website. Also if it wouldn’t be weird I have a ton of cool wigs in my SDB I could send you. Thank you for another great video your nastiness!

blank

I pity North Americans for their ringo star-less Thomas the tank childhood. Definitely going to have nightmares tonight about the dragon train I'd repressed for 30 odd years...

William M Wassmann

James from Thomas the Tank Engine as "The Knuckles" of the Thomas-verse is the wildest take and it is so spot on imho wow.

DechAmim

I swear that TVO in Canada had the original Ringo in Thomas, because listening to the George Carlin version sounds oddly unfamiliar

Josh B

Not to be too much of a Thomas head, but Ringo was actually the narrator of the first two Thomas seasons in North America. He even did a North American specific dub so he didn't use British-specific terms that would confuse kids (e.g. in Britain they call freight cars trucks and call trucks lorries)

Claire Stump

Jenny I just want to let you know that I LOVE it when you talk about ponies!

Rachel Lauren

I almost never comment on these videos but I needed to say on this one how appalled I am to hear that so-called fans are being so rude to you???? We love hearing you talk about ponies………what are people TALKING ABOUT……… Anyway that made me so so so sad to hear and I wanted you to know, if you see this comment, that those people might be loud but they are the minority. I really enjoy hearing you speak on your areas of expertise regardless of my own knowledge of or interest in the subject. You present information in such a fun and interesting way! I love learning new things! 💜💜💜

Mertag 770

I too was hoping the train commentary intro as going to be a Too Many Cooks situation

Claire Stump

never in my life have I heard that Thomas the tank engine looks thug like

Tali

I am constantly having to restrain myself for remaking a neopets account, and this video did not help! I loved you gallery! And your pets outfits. Honestly it's only my avatar collection (and stamp collection) that I spent years on but could never replace that stops me.

Clarisse Carlson

That last video was literally just a recap of the full episode and nothing else? Where was the commentary? Also how was that their “darkest episode”

emily

i love when you talk about ponies please never stop

Scezumin

wow, fuck that sandshrew guy and his shitty mod friends (i haven't finished the video yet)

Mak

For what it's worth I find your pony videos extremely entertaining. I know nothing about ponies and I love learning about different niches. Some people are just meanies and I'm sorry they make you feel bad about your interests 😔

blank

Thats really interesting! It was just an assumption based on the clip in the vid. I'm always surprised when they decide to export what I'd consider to be very British (or, more specifically, very English) shows to the US. I would imagine Canada got a lot more? It's cool NA got their own dub but they should have kept the British lingo in - my child brain had to learn soda, sidewalk etc. lol

Aly

If you try taking feedback for your video chronology and content you will never win, just fulfill your interests and creativity and the right audience will follow!

Austin F

i honestly love seeing jenny find intense amusement in the strangest places, especially when she finds something totally absurd. some of my most rewatched are the hallmark video, lifetime movie review, spider reviews, and the youtuber apologies

Austin F

oh my god i played hamham heartbreak SO much as a kid

Austin F

lmao when I was into hamtaro i wasn't Online yet (because i was like 10 years old), so i didn't join shipping fandom or even consciously know what shipping was, and now i'm kinda curious what wars were happening....(in retrospect, i think 10 year old me did want cappy and panda to hold hands. or claws i guess)

Zhen

Oh god that little dragon girl's voice is awful

MK

As a kid I'd keep myself poor on purpose so I could just go to the soup kitchen instead of buying food for my Neopets. 😭 I should not have had custody.

MK

Never say never!

Kyle Redford

Are you still planning on doing the Five Nights at Freddy's video?

Boops

WHO the hell is saying they're not interested in pony content and why don't they have any love in their hearts

Bryce Zubriski

This video is a great example of how Jenny & I diverge. Jenny finds the OC’s charming and enjoys the content. I find it all unbearably cringy and pathetic. I might be too cynical but there it is.

Narciso Jaramillo

ready for jenny’s next main channel video to be a 12 hour deep dive on youtube ocs

Jacob Yeavello

I think you are looking at it the wrong way. I imagine it's more how a parent reacts to a child's creative output. Its almost condescending but supportive and delighted by the attempt and enthusiasm. I don't think it's being consumed as well made and well formed content.

Jacob Yeavello

For what its worth I loved the Barbie vid from what we saw. I often say: "if something glitters click on it!" When asked how to do something simple with no context confusing whoever I am speaking with.

OncomingStorm7

How does the guy monotonously describing episodes of DragonTales with his terribly animated avatar immediately before playing the clips he describes, have 70k+ YouTube subscribers???

Lola

Yeah I still have no idea how food club actually works, I just click the buttons on nsheng's links. It's super easy neopoints

Chark

Yes! Would LOVE to hear Jenny’s thoughts on Efteling

Harper Lee

just became a member, can’t believe i have 100 new jenny videos to watch

Ontario Traffic Man

It's 101 rambles, but there's also a handful of bonus videos so the total is around 110 or so.

Clarisse Carlson

I didn’t mind her watching it because I watched that show as a kid so it was kind of interesting seeing it again after 20ish years. I just think as a video essay that particular one was pretty lame

Lola

Absolute S-tier ramble for me, the experience of playing Hasee Bounce while watching this only for you to start playing Hasee Bounce in the vid was life changing tbh. Also, echoing everyone who says that you should make whatever video your heart desires! And count me in as definitely excited about the Barbie video if/when you decide to finish it.

Lola

Also I'm so jealous that you still have your Neopets plush from childhood, I STUPIDLY gave away my blue noil and talking babaa and am filled with so much regret.

irene

I'm always going to be so jealous of your horse-shaped trinket shelf

Steve Ray

OMG, so that's why Kylo started wearing that helmet -- he was pretending to be a train, so people would like him, just like Lord Vader with his steam-engine breathing and cowcatcher mouth!

Steve Ray

The nudges are there because 99% of modern youth have NO social skills or sense of nuance at all and need to have a printed instruction to cite before they can confront anyone on anything. Jenny showed the whole world the right way to deal with bullies -- escalation of threats, though with at least *one* chance to reform.

Steve Ray

Evidently, DrillSharkPrincess, there are more kinds of cis people, than are dreamt of in your philosophy.

Steve Ray

How has it sailed past everyone's heads that Jenny just revealed & acted out the canonical origin story of Spike the Dragon in Friendship Is Witchcraft! To-wit: Spike got so menaced and threated for being an overbearing bully that he fled the Dragon Land and kept going until he got to Equestria, where he was so traumatized by his ordeal that he was completely deferential and subservient to everyone from Fluttershy to Princess Sparkle to Applejack, all for fear of being targeted by an angry mob again.

Grethen S.

Europa Park video would be amazingg, I would finally get to hear you talk about a place I've actually been to :D Barbie video sounds incredible too. And Beanie Babies

Saracha

Jenny: "I can feel in my soul how boring this is to watch" Me, whose favorite past time as a kid was watching my big sibling play flash games and is finding this content so cozy: hahahh yeah, definitely

mizushimo

Jenny please we don't need another 5 hour monster that takes two years to make, everyone saying that the last one is too short was joking I promise, I would be more than happy if you went back to releasing 40 minute vids every few months.

The Great Quux

So refreshing to hear you say that you don’t participate in a lot of fandoms. I mean why can’t we just watch a show or read a book/comic and enjoy it for what it is? Not everything needs to be discussed to death. The only “fandom” maybe I participate in is for the band Phish and I hate most of their fans lol.

Katelyn Benson

Jenny I will never get tired of you talking about my little pony

Whitney Blaine

As someone who has had to buy the niche After Skool Hobby Jessie fan made pokemon card three times, the first two not making it to me despite the sellers claiming they were sent, I appreciated the Sandshrew rant very much. I hope one day Jenny finally gets her hands on one!

Kendawg

Furry-adjacent video!!!

lydinair

i like it when you talk about ponies!

big bird

hasseeeeeeee!

Danny

You're never boring! Which is weird for me because I never watch ramble creators. I think it's because of your passion for things I rarely think of. It transcends the medium.

Sûs

my weird brain is weirdly pleased by Jenny referencing a thing Crispy's Tavern covered (failed Neopets ttrpg drama) after multiple instances of Crispy referencing a thing Jenny Nicholson covered (failure-in-progress (at the time) Evermore Park drama)

Another Stupid Hipster

So I live really close to the site for Mattel World. The Hot Wheels coaster has been in the same state of half-done for literally 3 years. The pieces of the track that haven't been connected yet are laid out, and they haven't so much as moved them.

The Great Quux

“I bet the degenerate fans ship these two.” I died

Kathryn Rose Hunter

Was it just me or was Jenny on a roll with this video. Like so many one liners and hilarious moments in a row I was crying laughing so many times

Maerose Pepe

Jenny I just want you to know I will never get tired of hearing about ponies.

Cassidy

The pony vids have never been boring to me... they are some of my favorites of all time that I return to them frequently lol. I have been indoctrinated and am now a full ponyhead.

Steve Ray

I know nothing about NeoPets except for what I've seen on this channel, but I agree that "generic D&D" definitely includes a ton of dead-weight rules that are have been needlessly retained since D&D's origins as an [individual soldier simulator], part of the various Colleges of Wars' efforts to preserve sound military knowledge in a form the People could access, even if the current officer corps and military academies were lost, destroyed, or otherwise suppressed by Enemies Foreign or Domestic.

Libby Williams

I don't know if I said this last time you mentioned Jamba Juice, but as a Brit I definitely thought that was a made-up neopets thing, and then years later I saw it in a TV show and was like "no way the neopets people actually opened a real Jamba Juice??"

Tabby

It's the younger, more home-grown version of loving that The Incubus exists.

Andria Henry, Author

Okay, I actually enjoy when you talk about Ponies. You reignited my childhood love of them.

Jaz Mei Luo

It brings me great joy when Jenny quotes Sam Raimi's Spider-Man movies

sam

jenny commenting for the first time to say i love the pony rambles / videos we exist!!!

SourInk

I am surprised you are a collector and you have only been "scammed" like that a few times. I feel like stuff gets "lost" in the mail all the time. I would consider that pretty lucky. The "this is to short" on comments is a joke, you can see it on many creators comments, like how you always see "legendary lunch pull" its in that family of comments that is all over YouTube.

HM Newton

I'm always excited when you talk about my little pony!

Ello Asty

LunchBoxGhost is a cool username. Just here to tip my hat.

Caroline Strickland

I was one of the people who got nothing out of that Neopets Kickstarter 🥲 soo disappointed!!

xLine

nah but also i get it. it brings me so much joy that weird content like this exists. like yea it's not 'good' but there it fucking is! and I get to have my mind blown by a voiced over train OC talking shit about a kids show. digging a pit so deep in the other direction of mainstream that i couldn't even have imagined it's a thing. and still people made that and its just out there to find. idk its always the fact that its so so genuine like the insane outfits in the incubus movie. the world is so much better for having stuff like that in it frfr how boring it would be if everything was just normal and good

Carolyn Ingram

Talk about ponies. Don’t listen to the lame people

Pheebs

I have no interest in my little pony and still love it when you talk about it. I subscribe because I like hearing you talk about things that interest you. that's like... the whole point I fear. I'm sorry people are rude about it

matt pierce

Who are all these people who keep getting so critical of what Jenny talks about or whether she wears glasses or whatever? Chill out

JanitorJoey

Pretty incredible that the Lucky the Lycanroc Thomas group rant was the Avengers of Jenny childhood interests. We had Disney, Nintendo, even some Kylo energy. But when a blue Littlefoot smooched Princess Luna I just about had a heart attack from laughing!

OtterofLore

imagine my devestation at finding out people dont like jenny talking about ponies :( im over here active on the mlp forums still and i love the old video when jenny talks about her pony collection.

Wren

The people who criticize you for the type of content and topics you post are a very small portion of your viewership, I promise! They may be loud but they don’t represent the vast, VAST majority of us who subscribe to both YT and Patreon because we just enjoy your videos and thought trains and ideas. There are a few things you’ve posted about that I have no similar childhood connection to that you do (like MLP or VPD) and I still get as much enjoyment out of watching those videos as I do any of there others where to topic is familiar to me (like this one). I subscribe and follow you because I enjoy watching content YOU are excited about! Please continue to follow your heart on doing what you enjoy - that is the only criteria that matters. If you’re enjoying what you’re talking about, we’re having a good time 🥰 Anyone who isn’t doesn’t deserve a seat at this table. ❤️

Niamh Julian

My favourite Jenny videos are the pony ones :( why are people mean when she does them? We love your pony's Jenny and how passionate you are about them, I rewatch those ones the most particularly the one where you showed off your collection and I got to see all the boy ponys

Dalton

I was not expecting a guest appearance from the AI slop channel from the Big Joel/Lindsay Ellis Daniel Tiger podcast.

Wifey

Your Neopets account was definitely purged (not hacked!) if your old pets weren't around

Wifey

I will say: I am literally in a gay neopets discord group, and the general consensus there was the allegations of homophobia were extremely weak. I personally don't find the passage homophobic. And yeah, gambling, fighting, even murder aren't off brand imo if handled correctly. The issue WAS making the process extremely public, Geekify being unprofessional, not paying the people the people who were working on the project.

Lukerfuffle

When the Avengers-level OC crossover happened my jaw was on the floor, this wasn’t only a ramble it was an experience

Cúán Ó Meachair

Just 90 minutes is crazy 😭 If they want more then it's time to just watch the incubus

Laura Torlaschi

I'm really excited about either Barbie, also cool with something furry-adjacent., but just do what you're passionate about. The "only 90 minutes" thing is silly. You don't artificially inflate your videos and they're only hours long when you have that much to say. If people want more, they can sub to your Patreon.

Kevin McGee

I'll be psyched for the Barbie video no matter when it comes out lol...I feel the same way about the potential Once Upon a Time video

CloudCowboy

Jenny you can talk about ponies or anything else you want, this ruled.

Scott DePouw

Good stuff. It is fun to dive into the inner sanctum of fandoms to see how they react to new developments in their realms. Re: Latest video -- Suppose it was inevitable following Starcruiser there would be comments akin to "every subsequent video must be the same length or longer or else it's lesser. "I say -- talk about what you want to talk about for as long as you want to talk about it! Whether it's 20 minutes or 20 hours it's the quality that matters, and that quality's always present. (To say nothing about all the extra content here.) Keep it up, you're doing great. Barbie, ponies, there'll always be some folks not interested in them, and that's OK. Creators creating content they want to create is paramount in my eyes.

Ttt123

I love when you talk about ponies 🙏

DechAmim

The gathering of the rantsonas was incredible, so many little sublime details...the cricket shapeshifting into a giant purple crab, Lucina randomly chilling with a pair of dilophosauruses, the reveal of the evil train...Marvel could never.

DechAmim

And for the record, I have no affinity for my little pony, but I love listening to those rambles regardless

Jenny Nicholson

That's what it would feel like watching Infinity War without knowing about any of the Marvel characters. True fans of the universe were cheering along

Skylin.

Jenny talking about ponies is the reason why I have a collection now of 200+ My little ponies.

Skylin.

When I lived in Europe I lived for Europa park. one of my all time favorite theme parks. would be my favorite if i wasn't autistic about Epcot.

Eve Miller

oh my god the original rantsona collab channel video was removed and reuploaded because one of the members had grooming/homophobia allegations????? 😭😭😭 i need someone to do a deep dive on super origami kingdom what is going on here

The Vampires of San Francisco

I GOT A BRIO STORY!!!! back in the late 80s, early 90s, they weren’t really popular or common in the US yet, but my dad would bring us back kits from business trips. I loooved them, but as a kid I was so perplexed why some of the buildings had words on them I could read (“post”), some that seemed misspelled (“Schule”) and some that made no logical sense (“Rathaus”) Then in high school I took German all four years and it suddenly all clicked into focus 😂

Justine Wiesinger

I think people will always want more from you, because you're very entertaining! But I don't think that necessarily means they are unsatisfied with anything less than your most epic projects. I just think they would always love to hear more thoughts.

Ronia Peterson

People don't like hearing about MLP???? I looove when you talk about it. :(

Front-Back Brute

im very excited for the barbie video, but i dont comment about it because im like “i dont need to talk about it, she’s already said she’s doing it!” i have such nostalgia for it, as someone who watched a few of them many times when my sister was little. same way i liked land before time, i remembered just enough (2-3 of them) for it to be funny to learn how weird the rest were.

Kuponito

Hey Jenny! recent patron but long time youtube subscriber! Just wanted to say that we all love any topic you decide to make. If you were to ask me before you made it "do you want a video about a twilight knock off that no one knows about?" I would've said "no that sounds silly and uninteresting" but I've eaten that video up and I love it. Most of the stuff you talk about I had little interest for before I clicked the videos, but I just find them fascinating. You're like an incredibly eloquent and funny window to worlds I've never heard about and that, I think, is what most people value!

kris

jenny i love when you talk about vintage ponies :( please do it more

Jorts

EVERMORE MENTIONED This was a fun video! Idk anything about G3 ponies other than what you've said about them before but oh my god I felt your excitement when you saw that star catcher plush ❤️

Teddy

Please talk about Europa Park, i am begging you! (I live near there and i need someone to talk abt it)

Julia S

I think you should do whatever video you want next! A short one sounds great to me, if people are disappointed by the length it's probably just because they want to hear you talk for longer, but don't let that affect your schedule, you get to make the choices and we'll be delighted by them either way!

Steph Beck Fey

I'm hyped for the Barbie video, that was my childhood, but ngl I'll probably be just as hyped for whatever else comes next. Some people will always find something to be negative about, but I don't think that's how most of us feel

PurpleIsDebeste

now that i think about it, them complaining about the neopets ttrpg being combat focused is really funny. like wowwww fake neopia fans they dont even know about Neopets: The Darkest Faerie 😒

Ezra

I LOVE the idea that people who are going to use a ttrpg to roleplay sex between Neopets could possibly be deterred in any way by a rulebook.

Luis Alfonso Obregon

I thought star wars would have been a good choice for this one

Knitter? I hardly know her!

I like the ponies stuff. I have no attachment to them whatsoever but it feels like hearing about your alter ego

Mechelle Adams

Who are these villains complaining about you talking about ponies?!? Genuinely it’s alway such a treat. Hearing you talk about the old pony websites got me into collecting some ponies, and making pony art and stories with one of my best friends lol

Wifey

JENNY THERE IS A NEW SPIDER PETPET! You get it by completing the 2026 Negg fest. It’s very cute.

Rose

please dont ever stop talking about ponies

Joseph Ferrari

I feel extremely vindicated knowing you play DnD the same way I do

Viccc

Coming from someone with no nostalgia for those properties, I love hearing you talk about my little ponies and barbies and stuff! I was a major tomboy and caught a lot of grief from adults over not wanting to play with "girls toys," so I had no desire to engage with those types of properties for years, but now that I'm an adult (and a man, to boot) I really enjoy learning about them!

jess

Jenny - I want to see whatever video you’re excited about. Being bummed that a video is “just” 90 minutes is bonkers to me. It made me and my gf’s day when we saw that you dropped a new video, and I even told a friend about it before I had even watched it (I could tell from the title it would be relevant to her interests). While I do enjoy a good 2+ hour deep dive on an obscure topic, I’ve got other things going on in my life and sometimes it’s a relief to see there’s a new video that’s “just” 90 minutes lol

Deadbirdkitsch

Jenny I like your G1-3 pony content! If you wanted to go back to MLP Trading Post and click around to see what's going on in the non- horny part of pony Fandom I'd be down. I'd also much rather hear you talk about things you're excited about than a thing you've never heard of that win the poll.

Kyle Perry

Hi Jenny, I have that Sandshrew battle playset plush if you want it?

Molly

I'm surprised that people say they don't enjoy the pony content, it's literally part of what I rewatch the most, even though it's not a topic I'm personally invested in I love hearing people talk about things they care about a lot and you obviously do so I always enjoy hearing you talk about it. Also definitely interested in the barbie video whenever you are ready to continue working on it but I think something shorter makes sense, too.

RandySalacious

Omg Jenny i have nowhere else to post this Dan Olson stole your video formatting - his newest video is centered around an internet friendly numbered list! He even called it that! Sue him!

Vee Thorn

Also I would love either the furry video (getting a video sooner is great!!!) or europa park (i love your themepark content SO MUCH) - or barbie, but i totally get not wanting to pick up a Big Project.

DazeyDaisy

I tried playing neopets a few times as a kid and it (along with any other digital pet i tried) never captured me for long, but seeing Jenny's collections of themed items brought me such joy and satisfaction, i love it so much. I agree that she should just talk about whatever she wants. I've never watched Star Wars and i don't care about it, but i still enjoy the Star Wars videos

Aaron Fontes

are there patreon mirrors for all vids? i can't find one for this vid but i like them since patreon lets me run the video over my headphones even when my phone is asleep

CeCe

I remember when almost ANY paintbrush was impossibly expensive for me, so I got a little millennial thrill seeing you get a cloud paintbrush so easily. A couple of feathers in my cap: I was on the council of the star wars girls guild and got SCARY good at ice cream machine.🍦Thank you for the walk down memory lane!

calicoqueen

i, for one, love when you talk about my little pony

Addison Vallier

A 90 minute video is still long!!! I for one would be more than happy with another short video. But also, do what makes you happy- I think perhaps listening to everyone’s input can contribute to burnout, at the end of the day everyone will have something to complain about eventually, but if they really respect your work then it shouldn’t matter to them.

Duncan Adamson

It's so weird hearing Thomas the Tank Engine not narrated by Ringo Star

Axel HV

I was kinda hoping she talked about Star Wars fandom, but I guess she doesn't wanna go down that rabbit hole. And I get it.

Aaron Reese

The Sandshrew seller was incredibly rude. We should start a petition to raise $100 and get Jenny 10 Sandshrews.

Vivian Baumann

for the record i love when you talk about ponies

mandy v (gay pope)

this video forced me to finally face the music and actually contact neopets in order to have them try to salvage my 21 year old account so thank you … i haven’t been able to access that account since a little before the mandated password update of 2022. and bc it’s linked to a very old and very long inaccessible email address, i have little hope, but. fingers crossed 💀😭

Karin

You're not a true Jennyhead if you hate on pony content

DechAmim

In Canada we had both versions on different channels, so the narrator will always be a chimera of George and Ringo to me

Jorts

Watching you react to the thomas and dragon tales videos was genuinely the most I've laughed at a video in quite a while. The OCs!!! The team-up would go so hard. Also I love how you watch this stuff. Like you're laughing at it but not in a mean-spirited way. It's wholesome. Keep doing you! :)

Pippy

I don't mind "shorter" videos on the main channel, the Incubus is already one of my favorites! 90min is a perfect runtime, after all it is roughly as long as the Incubus

Rosemary

Percy was also my favorite!

Manuel Rosenstiel

Europa Park ➡️ I would love to hear your take on that one!!

hy libre

i was not ready for jenny nicholson to reinvent the past seven years of TTRPG discourse from first principles

Song-Kinsley Productions

I literally said to my wife “oh I’ve lost all my tolerance for this kind of thing from my TGWTG/CA era”

moonpie

I grew up going to Europapark. I would love a video about it. I think there is a lot of potential for an interesting video because of how much early Europark got inspired (and to an extend, even plagiarized imo) Disney.

Connor Faust

Your pony videos are an essential part of your brand imo. But I understand that could apply to a lot of your video topics for different viewers.

Tea

I think with the Neopets TTRPG, the issue wasn't that it was ethically dubious or immoral to make a 5e D&D reskin, it was that its very lazy to do that and that wasn't the kind of thing Neopets players were interested in or were promised in the campaign. As you said people are probably more interested in a rules light game that reflects the themes and gameplay of neopets, not a reskin of a set of rules that they could have done themselves in a few hours.

Tea

Also most of the safety tools, things like discussing sensitive topics before playing, are really for when you're playing with strangers or people you don't know well, rather than your friends. It's notoriously difficult to schedule TTRPG sessions so a lot of the time you'll play at clubs with people you don't know that well.

Zach Wolf

Neopets has a TCG that is really fun

B

People will always have something to complain about. It’s impossible to please everyone. Make what brings you joy!! I love your short content (the Hallmark channel video is among my all time faves), your medium content, and your long content.

Scrum Diddely Umptious

Bro idk how we got here but I'm meeting Spike in the parking lot We need to stop socialising little annoying girl dragons into fixing dumbass boy dragons, let them die lonely damn. Can't fix a yoyo, can't even pick his own plums, Im just going to say it I bet you he stole that amulet I love that guys voice ...but I truely do not know who that video was for haha

Technez

As someone who is a bit in the TTRPG community it is very blatant when something is a DnD ripoff. Especially in this type of case where the gameplay should be way different, as a lot of DnD mechanics are just around combat and violence. A more softcore system with fewer rolls and things to keep track of, more exploration/interaction focused type rules would fit better for that type of game, or else it's constantly twisting the base game to fit something it's not made for. The pony discussions are great in your videos and I think it's just the few people who don't like it that actively post comments v passively intaking it. Most of your content is nice for listening to something random you're passionate about and deep dives into things I haven't heard of before

Steve Ray

Since Hot Wheels cars would regularly fly off any track built for them at least 1/3 of the time, I think a Hot-Wheels-branded coaster would be destined for catastrophic derailings on the regular.

Gussie Ruck

i need to kill everyone who says ponies are boring. WE ALWAYS TALK ABOUT DISNEY!!! NEVER PONIES!!!

Kate

I loved the 90 minute video! I'd rather have new videos that you want to make and feel like making than you feeling forced to only make 4 hour long videos.

Kate

And! I love hearing about ponies! Who are these people with their incorrect opinions omg I'm still obsessed with that short fanfic video you did about the magic school ponies and would 1000% watch more of that. What I don't get is why people don't just go okay that's not for me I'll skip this one. Like they know they can do that right? Not everything is for everyone and that's okay. Go watch something else. It's your channel and personally I don't want you to get burnt out or anything, and I'd rather have breaks between videos and have them be a length that works for you, and have them be on topics you care about (which is what makes videos interesting to me).

Nina Røste

I think that's a fandom she's still in, though, and this video is about revisiting old fandoms she's no longer a part of.

Nina Røste

I love how invested you got in the Dragon Tales video, haha. I'm gonna be real, as a kid who was bullied relentlessly in school, I always hated these sorts of episodes growing up, where there's the mildest form of bullying ever being done by usually a fat kid, and then it ends with the bully apologising and everyone becoming friends. It's not realistic, and it feels unfair to "both sides" this issue, because the fact is, despite what many like to say, very often bullying isn't coming from a person who's in pain or has a bad home life, but just from a person who has a sadistic streak. Also, the fat kids were almost always the bullies in these sorts of shows, whereas in real life, most fat kids I knew were victims of bullying, and nearly all of the kids who bullied me were skinny. The unrealistic, sugarcoated way bullying was usually represented in kids media in the 90's really just made me feel more alone in my experience, and it's a big reason why my favourite movie was Disney's Hunchback of Notre Dame, because the way Quasimodo is treated in that movie, was a way more relatable and realistic experience of bullying and othering than what you would typically see in saturday morning cartoons.

lei

my jaw DROPPED at that beautiful mudkip collection

Pickles

Jenny providing more analysis for the Dragon Tales episode than the OC while condemning Spike to death was a great end to this ramble. Hope she got her Kid Cuisine.

a.s.

i couldn't agree more, all of her videos are perfect in their own special way <3

a.s.

the marvel/star wars fan entitlement a la the endgame video has hit the patreon

notgerardway

NOT INTERESTED IN HEARING YOU TALK ABOUT PONIES!?!?!?! BORING?!?!?!?!!! you literally sparked my own hyperfixation on g1 ponies and in mlp in general </3

Summer Tribe

maybe you need preferential voting. could be that like 40% of people are voting for MLP out of a list, but if people could order that list the remaining 60% would put MLP last or something. idk

leah

the youtube video at the end about the thomas the tank engine series where they just kept introducing new collaborators and their OCs was killing me omg. It felt like a skit from the way more OCs just kept showing up. and the way Jenny was so excited by it.

Totesnotasheep

Jenny, can you set a post to show off our plush? That would be really fun!!!

notacrazyperson

Its so impressive how pretty much any media has its small niche on the internet. Sure, sometimes the scandals of said niches seem a bit over the top but whatever, its so great that the internet enables people from all around the world to talk about that one cartoon they really love ! That avengers meeting of youtuber sonas is so cool and cute. I’m glad they have a community to talk to about the new iteration of Thomas the tank engine.

Madeline Monk

I forget why, but I know Jenny has talked about Neopets before because the last time she did I nostalgically went back and made a new Neopets account and wandered around the Flash graveyard for a while. It's amazing how little they updated or fixed while still trying to sell you an NFT equivalent currency, but it was still sweet how interacting with a digital pet used to be text descriptions and one still image of a different face for your Neopet.

lilith

i would LOVE a europa park video i visited that park as a child and it is an amazing theme park

gracie :3

:( im sad to see people complain about what you like to talk about, they knew what topics you like from the get go so i dont underdtand why they dont just find a different channel to watch? please ignore them jenny :(💓

G. D. D.

The way you describe how you play is honestly not really playing the game at all. I don't mean that in a gatekeepy "you're having fun wrong" way, just that if you aren't aware of any of the rules of the game and don't really follow them then you kind of definitionally aren't playing the game, you're just doing guided improv. Nothing wrong with that, but it does mean that you lack some of the perspective and context to understand why a game design choice like basing an RPG on D&D 5e might be suboptimal.

Pierre Forever

Fuck everybody who told jenny to stop talking about ponies you people ruined my life

Cami_Cosmos

I love hearing about the ponies, please never stop talking about them!!!

Rachel

I think it's a good idea for any ttrpg to have guides to talk through players' expectations of roleplay stuff like flirting and beyond. It's common enough for people to go to game stores to make friends via scheduled games or invite acquaintances into a campaign. Ttrpg are popular, but not necessarily popular enough that anyone would have a large pool of interested, close friends to play a campaign with. Plus I don't feel society really teaches people how to have those kinds of discussions, so a formal guide might honestly help a lot of people

Rachel

I feel like dnd is nice "make up story play" for adults who don't remember well how they did it as kids. The rules help provide support structure. It makes sense to me based on how Jenny has discussed children's toy media in the past and critiqued it for how it does or does not set up children well for a loose framework of ideas for storylines to play out, that she would be comfortable doing a free form role play and rules would be more binding for her, whereas for people like me, they're reassuring and assisstive

robin birdleirdle

the convo about d&d, about thinking of all ttrpgs as basically d&d but really just wanting to play a game where you roll some dice and do things without the mechanic overwhelm and having to look through a million books all the time, is ironically one of the exact reasons people are arguing against d&d. it's such a mechanic heavy game and there's way better systems for hanging out and storytelling with dice

PekoPekoKUMA

I'm an extremely long time MLP and neopets fan and I'm guessing one of a small percentage of your audience that is both a furry and subbed to the patreon, lol. I think I can safely say that your brony fandom video is my favorite youtube video ever made and if I just need something longer to listen to while I work, I still find it so entertaining despite having watched it many times over the years, which is a testament to how good that video is. I work from home drawing my own graphic designs for both traditional artworks to prints and stickers as well as sewing handmade fleece jester hats, cat ear beanies etc. Question 1. I wanted to ask if you actually plan to avoid more patreon topics/future youtube videos covering mlp? Question 2. and I also wanted to ask if you still plan to release the aforementioned "furry adjacent video"? I can only assume it was not scrapped and simply needs a lot of time to make, but I was curious since it hasn't come up in awhile. As an autistic person just trying to scrape by in this life, a lot of the topics you cover bring me a lot of joy and watching a content creator who also is burying themself in a pile of plush and trinkets like myself, I feel it's no surprise why I had a near instant affinity towards your body of work. Idk if you'll see or read this and I have no expectations about it, but I apologize in advance for my neurodivergent wordiness/over explaining. It causes me to find it very difficult to summarize better, but what I wanted to finish by saying is: Idk you but your content has provided me with hours upon hours of comfort, laughs and overall fun entertainment to keep me feeling good while I'm working and to share with my partner and friends as well for relaxing together. Thank you for making stuff, I hope you keeping doing it and that you can do it without too much fear of what other people think or want. As an artist I also deal with feeling tugged to avoid what i'm currently inspired or excited to make if I worry it won't sell well or that it's just not currently trendy, but I like all of your videos so, again thank you for making them. :3

Raymond Bell

Your eyes are blue!! Have you been taking Spice from the Dune movies?? Love you and you rock!! Keep up the good videos!!

wen

ive been a my little pony fan since G2 and the only pony content i consume online are your pony video essays. i just really enjoy your earnest and fun takes on it. I also think about your applejack problem video so much. i think i keep forgetting that your G5 pitch is not real because it just lives in my head rent free. if you ever talk about ponies again i would gobble it up!

mizushimo

I would personally love more frequent, shorter videos, it's rough when all of my favorite youtubers only release one video every two years

Greyson

Never expected the Thomas the train fandom to be putting out Avengers-level cinematic experiences, yet here we are and I am gleeful

J4M13

Catching up on old patreon vids and JENNY! I love the pony videos! I want to be counted among the voices that would be glad to hear you talk about ponies again!!

Ellie Paez

The dragon tales person and the Thomas the Tank Engine person with all the OCs are the two extremes of people talking about old children's media

Ellie Paez

I wonder how much money that Jamba Juice ad has made in the many years since it's rollout from millenials reminiscing on neopets

Samantha Heiman

Thank you sm Jenny for bringing me back to Neopets, I'm now on the top scorer list for Ice Cream Machine and gunning for that number one spot! Root for me @missplushiereturns

Jackson Mancuso

Anyone having trouble with the video opening when youtube is asking to sign in?

Katherine

Yes! I have no idea why this is happening.

Crispy Año

Something about the niche fandom channels "hosted" by their own OCs is so charming to me, I'm glad there are still people keeping that flame alive

Kai Vee

Okay okay OKAY. Somebody told me I had to subscribe because the pokemon part of this video might be about me and I do admit listening to it I was like IS THIS ABOUT ME? COULD IT BE? I don't think it could be BUT WHAT IF IT WAS?? DID I SCREW OVER JENNY NICHOLSON ONCE?? Well, I was a Sandshrew collector so I wasn't usually the one selling Sandshrews, but I might have sold a double now and then. I was a very active member and in the inner circle of the main mod (who is the creator behind Little Softs these days). I instantly knew exactly what Sandshrew you mean.... It's a little bit of an ugly one, an American one from the rough early days, but still charming. I did some digging to try to find the sales post you meant just to sate my curiosity but couldn't unfortunately. Either way, I am so not surprised you had a bad experience with the mods. A lot of the community members were very catty teens and the mod team was cliquey as hell. As a Sandshrew lover, I apologize on the community's behalf. (and yes I do still have all of them proudly on display)

dayy_dreamz

catching up on rambles and i’m falling to my knees wdym we could’ve gotten a g1-3 pony ramble i’d do anything for that!

Margo

This was a super great video!

Siobhan is On

Jenny's joy at watching the review group with all the OCs literally made me grin from ear to ear like an idiot in my office hahaha. That was so so so fun to watch.

Leah Ormaechea

oh my god NOTHING could have prepared me for the second AEG review video

Matthew Broatch

hang on... is the dragon tales react guy talking in that cadence TO MATCH THE ONE SPEAKING ANIMATION HE HAS FOR HIS OC???

anya k

is there a native player version of this? I know everyone likes the YouTube mirrors but they don’t ever work for me (can’t see subtitles, Picture in Picture, can’t download, etc)

LOOKOUTITSANGLE

Oh my god please do more of these Jenny I will pay you more money. I am completely obsessed with watching you go down niche internet rabbit holes in real time. I would love to watch you show your niche internet knowledge off and talk about rant sonas.

Alex Ries

do more of these!

Anna Glin

I love when you talk about ponies!

mundanemagic

I just generally like your presentation style, no matter the topic. :D I really enjoyed the one you did about commercials!

Air

Wow Hasee Bounce was a throwback. I used to get so mad at myself when I didn't max out the NP gains, young me didn't really compute the concept of RNG lol

Brittny Bush

People said they were not interested in what YOU have to say about Barbie?! Who, what, when, why, and how come? Also tired of hearing about ponies?! Are these people even Jenny Nicholson fans?! I know there is Misogyny everywhere but... 🫠

Brittny Bush

Seriously, can we pay more to be apart of a subset of fans that get access to pony and barbie content. I am so angry.

Brittny Bush

RIGHT?! I hate spiders but I will GLADLY sit through HOURS of Jenny content about every kind of spider. Even that weird flesh colored scorpion that ran through her hotel room one time. *cries*

Meagan Allred

Oh god I was a very very very involved member of the pkmncollectors lj community and was even in charge of the still running discord channel that everyone flocked to in recent times. To say that that community was the most toxic thing I've ever been part of would still be an understatement. I'm almost certain I know the member that sold you that sandshrew; it's between two people, one of which scammed me as well and I ALSO approached the owner about it and got told off. The owner was insanely biased towards about 3 members on there who were their personal friends and they frequently got away with treating the other members horribly. The 'competitive collecting' atmosphere was awful too; people were insanely toxic over who collected what pokemon and would often compete to buy up as much merch of that particular mon as possible and scheme/scam to get items out from under people. It was genuinely a traumatizing experience for me which sounds so silly but the way I and my mod team that ran the discord were treated was a whole other can of worms. It's so wild seeing this hellsite mentioned here oh my lord.

Silky

Replying a few months later, but: it's probably an AI narrating, and the reason it has views is because parents put it on for their kids as an alternative to finding or buying the original somewhere. The whole video concept is basically a way to show people episodes but add superficial "commentary" so it's legally defensible and has a low chance of getting taken down if it's not a huge IP. And videos for small children get tons of views because parents put them on to occupy their kids, so making an AI produce a ton of these videos is a very profitable business model.