Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Content

Wait a second, this isn't Ready Player One

Files

The Biggest Plot Hole in The Last Jedi

Please sign my petition! https://www.change.org/p/the-walt-disney-company-have-poe-dameron-say-to-dj-in-episode-ix-it-s-weird-that-your-name-is-dj

Comments

Sikander

I'm just going to give you a few examples of real plot holes.

Quilly

This isn't a plot hole because Finn was raised with stormtroopers, and Rose was a nerd so she probably never went to any parties. Neither of them would know what a DJ was. But your solution neatly addresses things in IX, since Poe clearly has been to some bangers in his life.

Sikander

Why did Poe think Hux would take his call? Why was he right? Why gravity bombs when we know they have torpedoes? If Leia was demoting Poe for his bad judgement, why not demote him more, so that he wasn't still the ranking pilot? If they weren't going to Crait, why did they come out of hyperspace so close? If they were going to Crait, why did they come out of hyperspace so far away? Why did anyone think they could solve the problem of hyperspace tracking with a secret mission in a hyperspace vehicle? If they could do that, why not just ferry their personnel away in the transports? I could go on indefinitely.

PogieJoe

I thought the biggest plothole was that not having Jenny in Episode 8 is going to be really weird when she's introduced as Rey's sardonic sister in Episode 9.

Blue Corn

Ah, but no one ever called him DJ in the film. Disney tricked us!

TalysAlankil

There are also two Rexes in the line for Star Tours at Disneyland Paris, by the way! (Admittedly this might not surprise you since looking at the picture you showed it seems it's the exact same layout)

Alex W

They must have people who fit a 'DJ' role, but do they have discs? I can't remember seeing one. The data storage in the Star Wars universe is pretty abysmal overall. Droids are great, but I've got a thumb drive and a smartphone that handle most of their responsibilities.

Nichol Renee

How long have you carried this burden of knowledge? 😨 However long, I'm glad we can help you carry it now. Happy Easter.

Andrew Zimmer

In A New Hope, why do they travel straight from the Death Star to Yavin Base when they know there is a tracking devise on board the Millennium Falcon? Couldn't they stop somewhere in between and get a new ship before continuing on or try to find the tracking devise and disable it? Also, how is Leia the "Other" that Yoda was talking about when she was actually one of the people Luke was heading to rescue and whom Yoda said should be sacrificed if need be? And how does Obi-Wan not remember her when he was there when she was born? And have you ever thought about the mechanics of Luke's plan to rescue Han from Jabba's palace? It makes no sense whatsoever. And how did the Millennium Falcon get from Hoth to Bespin without a hyperdrive? None of these movies make any sense. They all should be decanonized!

Sarah Matthews

Maybe DJ is a nickname like DJ from Full House. Donna Jo Rex.

Sikander

Frugey: Yes, I do. But I regard Jenny's examples as unfair. You will note that none of my questions are questions of how (the answer will always be either space magic or made-up physics) but questions of why. When you are watching a space fantasy, you have to accept the world presented, or what's the point? My problem with The Last Jedi is that it doesn't make sense even in terms of itself. Now, I like Jenny as much as I can like someone I've only ever seen on a screen (I don't support her Patreon just to hurt myself) and it bothers me a little when she beclowns herself with jokes so bad they seem like something Rian Johnson would do.

Andrew Zimmer

Serious question: why do you have so many of those snakes? Do they only sell them by the dozen or something?

F W Pancakes

I'm sure there's a perfectly rational explanation. On the other hand; Rose's ring with the concealed resistance logo is complete world breaking madness: it suggests the resistance is some super secret clandestine organization rather than a large well equipped military force. They get around in a fleet of large, instantly recognizable spaceships and wear clearly identifiable uniforms but worry about a teeny tiny, insignificant, little piece of jewellery potentially identifying them to the First Order

F W Pancakes

I've cracked it, in both cases it stands for Darth Jenny; there's some Scooby Doo villain type reveals involved

dwayneotron

♫ Snake snake snake snake snake snake Snake your bedroom Snake your bedroom ♪

Shaun Cheah

I'm surprised it took this long for someone to say it.