Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout
haven't archived this post yet. have a subscription? use the importer!

Downloads

  • FIVEFOUR_COURTREFORM2024 master.mp3
  • Biden_Harris_and_the_F... - audiogram.mp4
  • Biden_Harris_and_the_F... - audiogram.mp4
  • Biden_Harris_and_the_F... - audiogram.mp4

Missing 3 full-res photos, 3 videos, 1 file, as this post has not yet been imported.

Content

This is a subscriber-only episode about Biden's proposals for reforming the Supreme Court... will the hosts of 5-4 say "we do"?

Thank you to all of our Patreon supporters — it's only thanks to you that 5-4 has survived long enough to see the White House propose Supreme Court term limits.

5-4 is presented by Prologue Projects. This episode was produced by Lena Richards. Leon Neyfakh and Andrew Parsons provide editorial support. Our researcher is Jonathan DeBruin, and our website was designed by Peter Murphy. Our artwork is by Teddy Blanks at Chips NY, and our theme song is by Spatial Relations.

Follow the show at @fivefourpod on most platforms. On Twitter, find Peter @The_Law_Boy and Rhiannon @AywaRhiannon. 

Files

Previews only

Comments

Emily

What even are these posting times? Why am I awake for it?

David Jenkins

Posted for an NZST evening stroll... Appreciate 5-4 looking out for us all the way down on the periphery on the periphery.

John

Wild time to post this.

NYCM&AHole

It’s an election year so you can tell they don’t mean it and are just trying to sucker the dupes into believing something will change.

Matthew Maddock

I’ve seen this posted in different places, but this is generally how I feel about the US and UK at the moment: “Like I'm upholding my part of the social contract here and I really don't feel like I'm being met halfway by any single institution or anyone with any power whatsoever”

Holly Bauer

When you said 'Kermit Roosevelt' I immediately had to Google to see if the OG had descendants. 😂

Shugoshin

Love home ownership bs. It’s a great show.

Andrew Lenahan

I feel like I have a different concept of what “political theatre” is because the J6 and Benghazi examples are wildly different

Maggie

Make that Michael speech at the end free, I need everyone to hear it. 💜 Great episode, y'all. Appreciate your perspectives, even on the bleak realities.

Shawn Galbraith

I have been impatient about court reform for my entire adult life. I really like the 18 year term limit and 1 new every 2 years idea. I love Michael's enlightening take on that, too. They could eliminate the 9 member mandate, making unexpected vacancies a moot issue. Sometimes there might be 5, sometimes maybe a few more than 9. Once the cycle plays itself out past the sitting justices who still hold lifetime seats, since the new rule likely won't apply retroactively, 9 will become a standard, but not a requirement. Then, the pressure will be on in a good way. As we try to move past service until death, I think they should add an age limit at 75 years, too, personally. I understand the frustration with the Democratic Party. I agree they should be putting bills up and signalling their intentions, but it is also important to remember that political calculus is tricky. They might still be figuring out how best to "codify" Roe as they wait for the proper electoral moment. I don't think they are necessarily intending to expect the public to vote for them and then blaming us for not, but electoral mandates are real and divided congress is real. That being the case, it is not helpful to rail on them for lacking the power necessary to do what we want. We do have to vote them in. I also understand the frustration with institutionalists, but it is often not a positive thing when they abandon their ideals. Biden is a devout Catholic and has always been unwilling to commit wholeheartedly to the abortion issue, which most likely answers Peter's question. As for Kamala Harris, I think she wants to put forth more realistic and achievable goals. She strikes me as a practical person who is not wont to make grandiose promises she is not sure she can uphold and that don't ring true to her as a leader. She is well acquainted with the law, the legislature and the power of political capital. I think this likely explains the fact that her name was not put in the place of Biden's on the party platform docs and also her vague support for Biden's reform proposals. Keep in mind, Biden is still prez, she's still VP, and it's tricky. Being one month into a surprise candidacy, she is wisely being cautious on the policy front, no matter how hungry the insatiables are for wonky meat. Keep in mind, also, that, as governer, Walz was big on spending political capital. But they need our votes to get that. Personally, I kinda dig the blank slate nature of the Harris Walz campaign. It reminds me that we live in a democracy where a lot of ideas could matter. I hope and believe they have their ears to the ground. I am choosing to trust them. The old guard is getting old, and I believe the torch pass to Harris Walz is largely positive. As voters, I think we need to try to keep our eyes and minds on the big picture. I think electoral reform is a big deal, and Harris has been speaking loudly about that. I like the idea of ranked choice voting. Term and age limits across the board are a big deal. Nature is a big deal. The Climate is a big deal. Court Reform is a big deal. Who do you trust on these issues, if you care about any of them?

Corey Bushle

I think they just mean putting on a show so the public can see what your party thinks matters, and using it to your advantage. Benghazi was bad faith political theater about a non-issue that republicans made into a real issue. J6 was a real thing that happened but the hearings let the Democrats make the case to the public that it was planned and encouraged by trump and his advisors, not just an accident or protest gone wrong. You need public hearings to do that sort of thing generally.

Wilhelm

Well said; y’all always know how to get me pissed off at the democrats lol. I really appreciate the thoroughness of your arguments and refusal to play by their respectability politics.

Alicia Crawford

Yes, "weak on theater" is precisely the phrase I can bandy about (giving you credit) when I speak mostly incoherently about politics. And I agree 100%!!! Also worth noting, Rhiannon, your laugh is THE best!!... and one of the many reasons I love your show! Uplifting amidst grim truths!

Maggie+Al

Critical support for local government officials in their struggle against home owners

thiccclizzy

Omg the intro 😂😂😂

Spencer

Hoping for a smooth election process rather than an Election 2000 2.0

Dibs

Kinda random, I was re-listening to the Nick Wallace ep (from years ago), and that situation was kinda a test case for the current method of calling conservatives weird and laughing at them. In 2021 he nailed the fact that they want the respect and just laughing at them takes a lot of that away from them

Stephanie Velazquez

Have the raccoons been dethroned as the villains of suburban homeownership?

hannah lamberty

The cursed double edged sword of "ooh South Dakota mentioned" strikes again

Morgan Garcia

Gah, please unlock this episode! I am SO exhausted with hearing “but the Supreme Court” whenever I say I’m not excited about the election (which to be fair is about a LOT of reasons) and y’all say it so much better than I ever could!

PJ

This is really powerful

Jack Wolfe

love an episode w a fired up michael ending / rhi impressions

NYCM&AHole

They’re both deep state events. One was full of fed operatives, the other full of CIA operatives. Chris Stephens was running guns out of the embassy or the cia didn’t mind him dying because they were doing it

Jack Gleeson

I read the couldn't rewrite the platform because they had to get loads of people to vote on it before the convenion.

Quinn Darling

mama mia the exhange around 44:00 has aged… poorly since Michael’s hopes that Harris wouldn’t be lead around by the stupidest fucking advisors on earth about culture war issues seem to have been completely dashed

Peyton Drouhard

Damn, that finishing rant by Michael hits hard even after Harris lost. Dems really just want people to accept that the court is a lost cause

Kibriya Mehrban

Distracted by how crisp Peter sounds in this