Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout
haven't archived this post yet. have a subscription? use the importer!

Downloads

  • FIVEFOUR_Mackenzie v. Hare_MASTER_no ad.mp3
  • Mackenzie_v._Hare - audiogram.mp4
  • Mackenzie_v._Hare - audiogram.mp4

Missing 2 full-res photos, 2 videos, 1 file, as this post has not yet been imported.

Content

Think you're an American citizen just because you're born here? Think again.

Thanks for being a subscriber! We love you and have an exclusive subscriber-only episode coming next week. 

5-4 is presented by Prologue Projects. This episode was produced by Dustin DeSoto. Leon Neyfakh and Andrew Parsons provide editorial support. Our researcher is Jonathan DeBruin, and our website was designed by Peter Murphy. Our artwork is by Teddy Blanks at Chips NY, and our theme song is by Spatial Relations.

Follow the show at @fivefourpod on most platforms. On Twitter, find Peter @The_Law_Boy and Rhiannon @AywaRhiannon.

Files

Previews only

Comments

Fadil

Trump's deportation plan sounds very similar to the "Mexican Repatriation" where in the 1930s around a million people were deported to Mexico and like half of them were US citizens. Nearly 100 years later and it's the same deal again.

A.B.

I love this show so much, but I am begging the team to get an American history researcher. Nellie Grant got married in the 1870s and a steamship voyage to Britain in that time period was like 7 - 10 days, not vast months of untold hardship. By 1915, the voyage was down to 5 - 7 days, with up-to-date but luxury ships like the Titanic generally sacrificing speed and taking 6 to 7 days. A train could get from New York to California in 20 hours flat. MacKenzie and her husband could have relatively easily travelled back and forth from CA to Scotland multiple times a year, if they had the money. California was well connected to the rest of the U.S. by this point - the Oregon trail was about 75 years in the past.

David Jones

Not to take away from the extremely serious issues at the heart of this episode, but I think we need photos of Cupcake.

Nina VanHeeswijk

popping in about a minute into the episode to say, CUPCAKE! we stan a manaical queen!

Kazoolhu

I think we need photos of Cupcake BECAUSE of the serious issues in this episode! I certainly could use some cheering up now.

James Talley

Here for Cupcake, of course, but in a world of Leon, Leon, Leon, it's nice to hear Andrew's voice. Go, you unsung editorial supporter, you!

Bald Weasels Scrotal Manscaping

1. Woman marries noncitizen. 2. Simultaneously: 2A Becomes citizen of spouse's country of citizenship, but is instantanwously expatriated due to US citizenship. 2B Loses US citizenship, but is instantaneously repatriated because she was never a citizen of the spouse's country, since expatriation from that country happened simultaneously to her gaining status as a citizen of it 3. She is forever oscillating between and, effectively, simultaneously existing in all of and none of the following states at the same time: 3A. Dual citizen 3B. US citizen 3C. Citizen of spouse's country 3D. Stateless. She has become the Quantum Woman! Also literally Schroedinger's Immigrant (or Schroedinger's Expat)

Chandler

Bless you for the intro

Amy Harth

To amplify Michael’s point, ethnic cleansing is a euphemism too. It only makes sense to call it that if you think your territory is “cleaner” without certain ethnic groups present.

Rhianna79

I need to find the article, but I remember during covid; people were calling natural born citizens who weren't "patriotic enough" not true Americans. And they were advocating for them to be kicked out of the country. So I don't think it's as far fetched we hope, and I think it's an easy step once there is a second Trump Administration or similar fascist in power to deport anyone they don't like citizen or not.

SM

me, married to a Welshman, listening to this from Wales: very disappointed and unsurprised, once again, with how much the supreme court has always sucked

Maddie King

Peter: "we brought the lowly Scottish whites into the fold" and they are what is now the Scottish Fold.

Jan

Hello, I'm deliriously tired and have no clue how I got to this comment section of a podcast I've never heard of, but I just paid 5 dollars to ask for a timetable to back up that rail trip time up. Because the Shikansen couldn't pull that off if we gave it a straight and level track. Train schedules were generally better in the US then than today, but that is absolutely wild if true.

Stephanie Velazquez

Stupid question: what would happen to natural born citizens who get stripped of their citizenship? Isn’t it against int’l law to deliberately leave someone stateless? (Since, ya know, the US is known for its almost religious adherence to human rights laws.) My parents are immigrants, so I imagine I’d just get deported to their country of birth. But what if they started rounding up the communists again — what would they do with the hella white ones whose families have been here for generations? Would they have to enter another country seeking refugee status? Do they get shipped backed to Germany even though their family left two centuries ago? Or do you imagine this would be applied exclusively to non-white people?

Thomas Clements

I know I’m being a huge pedant by pointing this out, but whilst citizenship law was probably governed by some shared principles across the UK, Scotland on the one hand and England and Wales on the other are separate jurisdictions, ie. no such thing as ‘British law’. The US may not have made a distinction, but her husband being born in Scotland might have made some difference at the time.

Noriana Grande

Ah yes. Now to simplify and explain to my peers who don’t listen to 5-4

Katie Johnson

"marriage is an ancient principle of our jurisprudence" the country hadn't even been around for 150 years yet wtf are you talking about

Rachael

I'm going to gamble and say that A.B. is misremembering the length of a particular train trip. In 1915 the 20th Century Limited could make the trip between New York's Central Station and Chicago's Union Station in 20 hours. This was incredibly fast at the time and was a huge selling point and people still heard about it well into the era of talking news reels. However, the trip out to California was a different matter. There was no straight-shot train between NY and California. A trip between the coasts required multiple days and multiple trains, usually switching first in either Chicago or St. Louis, with further train changes in the mountain west states. The fastest time between NYC and San Francisco was about three days. Still, compared to the wagon trains this was all incredible speed. And further, prior to the Panama Canal opening in 1914, travelers couldn't even take a steamship from coast to coast in under a three weeks because it was necessary to go around Cape Horn. Still, A.B.'s point about the Atlantic steamship crossings is very solid.

Patsy Baloney

I know everyone hates it when we compare Trump to Hitler, but this is EXACTLY what Hitler did. Just this week, Trump said he wanted to employ the military to handle any unrest on election day (he isn't in charge on election day, but whatever) and the enemies within, which include what he called the radical left lunatics, Marxists, communists, and fascists. The first camps in Hitler's Germany were not death camps. They were concentration camps where Hitler's political enemies were sent for re-education. They were briefly imprisoned and then released, which was enough to chill dissent. Then, he went after the so-called "undesirables" which included the Jews. But it was political enemies first because that's how you pave the path and eliminate resistance for what you really want to do, which is purge "the other".

Mary E. Cygan

Just catching up on this episode today and immediately thought about the American citizen from Dearborn, MI who was killed by an Israeli airstrike in Lebanon earlier this month. When Matt Miller, the State Dept. spox was asked for a response to the death of an American he initially said the victim was not a citizen, only a legal resident -- so not requiring the same level of response. Only days later did the State Dept. admit the victim was a citizen. https://www.reuters.com/world/middle-east/american-killed-lebanon-was-us-citizen-state-dept-says-2024-10-04/

Rachel

Incredibly large, incredibly violent, Gestapo-esque. 🎯

Dana Hogg

New-ish listener. Listening to the back catalogue to present, just made it to this episode and everything you all said is exactly what happened/ is happening, it’s almost eerie