Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout
haven't archived this post yet. have a subscription? use the importer!

Downloads

  • FIVEFOUR_Trans Rights 2024_master w cuts.mp3
  • The_Supreme_Courts_Agen... - audiogram.mp4
  • The_Supreme_Courts_Agen... - audiogram.mp4

Missing 2 full-res photos, 2 videos, 1 file, as this post has not yet been imported.

Content

Thank you to all of our subscribers — it's only through your support that 5-4 can continue to occasionally denounce listeners who disappoint us.

5-4 is presented by Prologue Projects. This episode was produced by Dustin DeSoto. Leon Neyfakh and Andrew Parsons provide editorial support. Our website was designed by Peter Murphy. Our artwork is by Teddy Blanks at Chips NY, and our theme song is by Spatial Relations.

 Follow the show at @fivefourpod on most platforms. On Twitter, find Peter @The_Law_Boy and Rhiannon @AywaRhiannon.

Files

Previews only

Comments

Ariadne Eltee

okay so like cool… hard to justify listening to this tho bc i’m trans and it’ll make me sad 😞

desdinova

The ending of the episode is how I imagine so many people want to talk to leaders in their field. I know I do.

Meggy Parsec

Enby here. Tears, listening. I don't understand how my presence causes so much hate. I vote and pay taxes and show up as an American yet am facing potential harassment every day. Sibling Ariadne - fam 💖 keep showing up. And thank you to all allied listeners - you are needed.

Toby Summerfield

We either need you comrades amplified or we need a lot more people speaking frankly about duplicitous behavior from their colleagues. Thank you for your continued vigilance and your unwavering support for the people most likely to be harmed by the court.

sallie

omg the roast at the end 💀💀💀 love it

Alexis Bakerink

Maybe the gay employee that was promoted was just better at the job than the fucking straight woman. holy shit that woman is soooo entitled.

Elaine Hall

Superb episode. 💕 to all trans siblings. Way to call out the clinic lead, what a sad little person.

Jennifer Armentrout

I know there’s more to this than fuck UVA but as someone who’s held a lifelong hatred of UVA, this rant was joyous to hear!

Helena Latimer

hey gang, long time fan. just wanted to say I'm a trans woman and I appreciate your coverage of the legal issues facing the trans community. no robes no masters

yema

ok unrelated to this episode’s topic… how old is Michael? i swear he sounds late 60s/early 70s, but when i googled him, he looks 40s???? michael explain!!

Jessica

As a trans woman it's hard not to look at the future as extremely bleak.

Jayden Lopez

As bleak as it is, can't wait to hear Chase Strangio argue the Skrmetti case!

Amy Stevens

1. This is a very serious issue and fuck the right for putting people's lives at risk. 2. I wish Rhiannon was on Cameo because I would definitely pay to have her go off on some folks.

peachfiend

another enby here. hard agree. really excited to be on the thin end of the wedge. 🤬 🏳️‍⚧️

Keynan McFedries

A roast more legendary than Steven Briar Retire Bitch!

Helena Latimer

I feel you there, but I also think the sea change in how (especially younger) cis people see us cannot be undone by these right wing freaks. they're flailing in the courts because it's all they've got. in practice, we won the culture war they started. I'm worried about IDs and HRT in the next few years but I do think the long term trend will be upwards for us 🏳️‍⚧️💜

Zafy Nightengale

State senate attack ad I get often in Michigan also pulls the 'she's using State funds for sex changes for ILLEGALS!!!!!' and plays a video of a black person with facial hair putting on eyeliner (🙀🙀🙀🙀)

charlotte

Just a small note: “gender nonconformity” is not a synonym for trans. It’s true that many trans people are gender nonconforming, but these laws also impact trans people who are entirely gender conforming. I think this is crucial to understand, particularly in relationship to youth transition, because part of what terrifies the right is that they *cant* in fact “always tell” who is trans. A trans girl who goes on hrt at 12 will never have lived either as a visibly trans person or as a man, and this idea that gender transition works, like really works, terrifies them. Even for those of us who transition later, many people, even liberals, have trouble comprehending that, e.g. we get asked when our last period was when we go to the emergency room. Obviously visibly trans people bear the brunt of the violence of a transphobic society, but I think it’s important to note that this isn’t just about “nonconformity” as such.

Saya Clarke

Trans woman from TX here. Rhiannon just spoke as a special guest at my last DSA chapter general meeting and I want to say thanks again!! It was for Palestine organizing that we are doing but just want to say thanks to Rhiannon for also being so incredibly supportive of trans people and our liberation.

Halle Johnson

I think it was more in the sense that this would also affect gender non confirming cis people. Like not every trans person is gender non conforming but everyone who doesnt fit neatly into a stereotypical binary will be impacted by this.

Steve McNamee

Lol I read this comment before I got there. It definitely lived up to my expectation. 🙌

charlotte

I think they were specific when referring to cis people. To be honest, I find the “cis people are impacted too” line of argument, while true and perhaps politically effective, to be often distasteful in the way it centers cis experiences as “this is why it actually matters.” Which, again, doesn’t mean it shouldn’t be made, but let’s keep the focus on trans people when possible (which this podcast did a good job of).

Kiernan Majerus-Collins

I suspect the straight woman's case is bullshit, but if it isn't, how is it different than RBG advancing sex discrimination law by bringing cases on behalf of men? Don't we want the Court to recognize discrimination based on sexual orientation as a legitimate cause of action?

Hannah Rose

As a queer UVA law student, I had no idea that our Supreme Court clinic was up to that shit. Thanks for the info, I’m going to reach out and try to do something about it.

A

absolutely gathered the man at the end

Dean C

That ending was quite gratifying. Eat shit man for real

LadySwayze

Just quietly crying into my ramen while Rhiannon lights this man up. <3 I hope he listens. Also anytime Utah comes up my my whole heart threatens to drop outta my butt.

Rachel Raspberry

As a trans woman from Alabama/tennessee, I really appreciate it every time you cover trans issues.

Rachel Raspberry

Also, though trans people make up a very small minority in the US, based on this comments section, we might be half the 5-4 listener base. lol

Justin S.

Here in Ohio we're getting NONSTOP Bernie Moreno ads about trans people... its so disgusting and cruel

Megan O'Shea

Hope you win! Golf has been on the decline. We don't need to be doing that nonsense when most of our wetlands have already been filled in :-(

Jay

We do, which is why it’s cool that it does already

Megan O'Shea

Here in WI, we've gotten blitzed with a nasty ad for the Republican candidate for Baldwin's senate seat. The content is along the lines of how Baldwin has become too extreme and has "allowed biological men into domestic abuse shelters." There's another counter ad that quotes Hovde (Repub candidate) complaining that women spend too much time focused on Hollywood. It's a lot. Please send help.

christine bean

Squad absolutely goin' OFF. Excellent ep

Jay

Hannah hmu I gotta talk to you for a story. Jay @ ballsandstrikes dot org

Schwappek

About 40 should be right. He has talked on the podcast about how he was radicalised by Bush v. Gore as a first-time voter

Winter

Thanks for the episode. It means a lot ❤️🩵

Lacey

“we’re starting a hurricane inside your lungs bro” sent meeee

Aunt Levant

I feel like so much of the language used to justify banning treatment of gender dysphoria is easily applicable to banning, say, conversion therapy. I mean not surprising that there’s no self reflection about that but like 🤨

audioboy

RBG's work, like with the Craig v Boren beer case, was benefiting men on it's face, while being constructed and argued with women's rights in mind. The case involving this straight woman is not written with any of those broader implications. It's kind of a moot point either way, because, as discussed in this episode, the supreme court already held in Bostock that the equal protection clause covers sexual orientation, so there's no "flip side" of this case to be advanced analogous to RBG's work. It could be argued that sort of tactic is less meaningful now than it was in RBG's lawyer days anyway, given that the court is more open about being a bunch of wishy washy partisans with no regard to precedent; a win this year may mean nothing in three years. So, given the seeming lack of any good intentions, lack of law to be affected, and lack of sane people on the bench, this case does nothing but stir up hate.

Rithya Kunnawalkam Elayavalli

Trans women from Nashville Tennessee. Thank you so much for this! 🙏 Absolutely scared shitless for what our lawmakers are going to do once they are emboldened by the ridiculous decisions (already expecting the worst)

Alyssa Fuller

You might be getting thrown off by his cadence, combined with the tone of his voice. He does what I often do when speaking, pausing in spots that aren't typically punctuated. For me, it's a speech thing, but I'm not qualified to diagnose. I never thought he was older than the others, they all make the same geriatric millennial jokes I do lol.

Alphones Armorman, suitperson

Wait, if the government can control the weather, does that mean that George Bush is responsible for Katrina?

Cami Parrish

GET HIS ASS RHI 🗣️🗣️🗣️

yema

I think it’s his pausing for sure! Also the depth of his voice too

Tytus Means

I live in Montana and Tim Sheehy (running for senate) has a joke about how his name isn’t pronouns. Ngl kinda funny but his ads are genuinely heinous. His whole thing is that he’s a “navy seal” (but at the same time supports cutting VA benefits) he’s leading in polls and it’s so fucking ridiculous. He got in big trouble for badmouthing Native Americans, calling them alcoholics and drug addicts. I’m native and grew up in up on the Crow Rez and the amount of native people who are STILL VOTING FOR HIM is beyond me. God help us. Edit to add: forgot to mention that the early ballots sent out in Montana “accidentally” left off Kamala Harris. Curious! What a weird accident! And people are seriously defending that here.

Matt Gately

Roberts is itching for that Title XII case so he can riff on one his favourite tautologies posing as wit. Some sort of remake of the 'way to stop discrimination on the basis of race is to stop discriminating on the basis of race.'

Jenni Aj

More sick lawyer burns plz

Betti Tristan

I’m so glad I finally subscribed so I can hear you flame this man up. May I lead my life such that Rhiannon would never have to tell me I’m putting a stain on my career like this.

Logan

Could the legal argument be bolstered by the fact that parents of intersex children are forced to pick an assigned gender/sex at birth and use medicine and medical care to conform to that assigned sex?

TK

DRAG HIM