Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout
haven't archived this post yet. have a subscription? use the importer!

Downloads

  • FIVEFOUR_Election Reaction_master_2.mp3
  • First_as_farce_then_as_t... - audiogram.mp4
  • First_as_farce_then_as_t... - audiogram.mp4

Missing 2 full-res photos, 2 videos, 1 file, as this post has not yet been imported.

Content

Damn you, Merrick Garland. This all could have been avoided... With the election now over, we digest what happened with our friends Jay Willis from Balls & Strikes and journalist Josie Duffy Rice.

Thank you to all our subscribers. Now more than ever, we are going to need community.

5-4 is presented by Prologue Projects. This episode was produced by Dustin DeSoto. Leon Neyfakh and Andrew Parsons provide editorial support. Our website was designed by Peter Murphy. Our artwork is by Teddy Blanks at Chips NY, and our theme song is by Spatial Relations.

Follow the show at @fivefourpod on most platforms. On Twitter, find Peter @The_Law_Boy and Rhiannon @AywaRhiannon.

Files

Previews only

Comments

Nick Z

Pish posh the real failure is you've left us alone with our feelings for a week!

Austin

First! Against the wall!!

Ben

"found them kicking puppies on the street" how did Peter know about the Noem pick

Austin

Texas will never go blue as long as Republicans can stoke the fear that Dems will come for the masses' firearms. Ethics aside, an unapologetically pro-2a left populist politician could have a shot in this state.

Fernando Rosales

I saw an electoral map breakdown if only black people voted, only Latines voted, only whites voted, etc. Trump lost with EVERY SINGLE group...except white people w/o a college education.

Robin Lehman

I signed up for your patreon (finally) to get your post election take.

Ben Schwabe

Biden's failure to do jack shit about abortion is pretty easily explained by him being an old Catholic man who always kinda thought women shouldn't be complaining all the time and just let him smell their hair. Anyway in the next couple years we'll see the press pre-censoring itself, Federal law enforcement targetting leftists and trans folk alongside immigrants, and the Democratic Party continuing to make sad noises. And then the midterms will deliver another Republican majority and we'll move into Pinochet-esque times.

Heather

I mean the democrats have consistently run people in lower offices with the pro-life pitch Peter describes. It works sometimes. That doesn’t make it cool or good strategy but like they do it.

Logan

That’s the entire strategy for house dems in Illinois

Emma G

I’ve felt so disengaged and averse to any sentiments of resilience in the past week and Rhiannon’s closing thoughts in this episode is really the first time since the election outcome that I’ve felt any semblance of optimism that the energy to continue the fight will return—for myself and for others. Thank you Rhiannon ❤️

Victoria Borges

On point as always. One thing I've found... not comforting, but maybe grounding, is the fact that we've been here the whole time. Not just because the Biden administration did basically nothing, but because Trump is the logical output of this system. Just like leftists were saying back in 2015, and everyone thought they were nuts. After all, this is the same country where Bush was handed the presidency by his brother and friends. Before that we had Reagan and Nixon. Trump is like a horrible homunculus of those three, so of course the right loves him and the centrists treat him like he's normal. Democrats are more afraid of the actual left than they are of fascists and autocrats, and they kind of always have been. Anyway, I should stop before I start really ranting. Thank you for this episode, love and solidarity to everyone. Especially Rhi and her people 🇵🇸

Sam

Where’d you find that cause that’s insane. Expected, but I want to visualize it, because wow.

Anna Jacobsen

Favorite moment was Josie saying “Shut up, Peter” 🫶🏻

Kenna

Bernies statement on how the dems abandoned the working class hit the nail on the head imo! So if we have another election one day (lol) hopefully the democrats shift to populist policies

Dean C

Joe Biden, history will scorn you

Joshua Golek

OK I'll go next. The thing I'm most looking forward to is meeting the 5-4 crew in person at the labor camps for the disloyal whist we assemble electric cars on Mars. Peter, what will you take in trade for your ration ticket?

Valerie Turcotte

Peter's remarks about being in high school were such a perfect reflection of my own I literally started crying. It's so exhausting. It was cathartic to hear though.

Pagrocrag

Thanks for this. I’m angry and so fed up with the democrats just fumbling the ball at every possible opportunity.

Marie Abbey

Yeah, tbh that group chat sounds insufferable 😂

JD

Kinda frustrating to see all of the hosts just jump right on the "Trump's turnout was down and Kamala got 15 million fewer votes than Biden" nonsense train that has been going viral. Those were numbers from when millions of votes were still uncounted -- as of today Trump has surpassed 2020 by almost 1M and Kamala is down 9M. When all votes are counted it will probably be more like Trump +3M and Kamala -5M. Not the important part of the analysis/commentary, which otherwise was great, but disappointing nonetheless. Especially since they usually make such a point of factual accuracy in analyzing court opinions.

Veronica T

They recorded the episode last Thursday, so it's understandably a little bit out of date

Matelda

She is still down 11 million votes and most of them haven't reappeared on the Trump side

Johnny 5

Yikes. More of the brain dead Bad Take Express on Gaza and voting. It’s like otherwise rational people just turn into dumbfuck toddlers.

Crystal Marie McDaniels

Everyone can say all they want, but honestly SNL said it best. We were dumb to think that rural Pennsylvanians were going to vote for a Jamaican Indian woman. She ran against a rapist felon who can't complete a thought and lost.

LT

Maybe if Ulysses S. Grant had marched to the sea we wouldn’t be in the is position

Patreothoglys-Tstll - Child of the New Book

I know you guys are joking but in all the doomering I've been doing this week, I have legit been wondering if the creators of all the podcasts I listen to will be fleeing the country or unavailable in America 😅

Andrew Lenahan

Yeah this is a skip for me. No offense but I don’t really want to listen to another podcast try to autopsy the election while they’re still counting votes. We need a moratorium on this kind of stuff

Andrew Lenahan

What was Biden supposed to do when he didn’t have the numbers in Congress and an executive order would get shot down by SCOTUS

Andrew Lenahan

I don’t want to try to rationalize this election yet. It’s not time. The only takeaway I’ve had is that a lot of Americans are extremely racist and uninformed

Ethan

Andrew, the motherfucker could've tried. How many times did the Republicans pass their dipshit repeal Obamacare bills when they only controlled the House? DO FUCKING SOMETHING.

Andrew Lenahan

I don’t know how to explain to you that I’m not forced to listen something if I don’t want to dude

Andrew Lenahan

Trump may end our democracy but I’m glad you got to pat yourself on the back about being right back in 2015. Real important right now

Andrew Lenahan

Okay well it’s not on Biden to introduce bills, it’s on Congress, so go take a high school government course before patronizing me

Andrew Lenahan

By the way, having trouble finding the rationale behind arguing the Democratic tent was too big. “If only their tent was smaller they would have won!” doesn’t make much sense to me

JD

It's not like we didn't know on Thurs that CA was only at like 30% reported and that it takes a long time to get full totals. Even today there are lots of votes still to count and simple estimates based on % reporting and the current vote split suggests that while turnout was somewhat down vs 2020, most of the Kamala-Biden gap will in fact reappear on the Trump side. It's not that hard, and using incomplete vote counts to draw conclusions is just "broken brain thinking" as Peter likes to say. There is still plenty of mostly-complete data out there on the state/county level to use in your analysis, so let's just use that and not buy into the twitter hype that there was some massive drop in voting.

Johnny 5

What’s incorrect is this lunatic discussion of voting as this moral action. It’s ridiculous. It’s just a binary choice at that point, and you vote against the person who is obviously worse. It’s especially ridiculous when Trump is very likely going to worsen the Gaza war. Talking about it like this is childish and embarrassing.

Victoria Borges

Sorry if my comment wasn't clear. I actually wasn't talking about myself, I was pretty naive at the time and I've moved much further left since then. The point I was trying to make is that we haven't been a democracy for a long time, and we would all (myself included) do well to remember that. Trump and his goons are indeed very dangerous, but they are not an aberration. Things are bleak, but they were already bleak, and the work that needs to be done is the same. Organize, build community, build alternative structures. Electoral politics alone aren't enough. We just lost an important battle, but it was never going to be the only battle.

Andrew Lenahan

“What does a vote matter if you’re voting for someone who’s bombing your people” does this guest realize Gaza is not the only marginalized group in the world? There are plenty of marginalized people here who are going to have it worse under Trump This honestly pushed me over the edge and I think I’m going to unsubscribe

LadySwayze

If I must hear football references, let us bring back Rhi’s astrology corner, please.

Victoria Borges

Hold up did you just come in here to argue with everyone? I think it's time to log off and direct that anger somewhere more productive, comrade

Alyssa Fuller

I feel like Ethan was using the bills as a way to compare the effectiveness of an exec order-- both will be blocked, but they are symbolic of the party's ethics. For the Rs, not sure how many citizens actually want ACA repeal, but abortion rights are a majority winner and an order would show support regardless of efficacy. In other words, he could've done it *for the girls.*

Maggie

Michael's anger is a balm to my soul.

Alyssa Fuller

I'm in AR and fully agree, anyone who wants to win here needs to hold a gun in their political ads. A leftist libertarian type would do better than an establishment Dem.

Lindsay Willett

The discussion of people voting to protect abortion rights and then people voting for Trump is just so mind blowing to me. One of my cousins literally said that she voted for Trump, and now that he won, it’s time to codify Roe. Like WTF???

Angelo Encapera

What message can cut through the right wing propaganda that has captured so much of the electorate? I don't think there is one. The only thing that gets through to those people is extreme suffering, and most of them will still blame democrats.

Lindsay Willett

Now that I’ve finished the episode, I have to say I am a little disappointed that there wasn’t discussion of the likelihood that Trump will not be in office long or at all - he’s an ailing 78-year-old man with a millennial Vice President. The fresh horrors will begin when it’s President Vance at the helm, not President Trump.

Eric A Gentzler

Reconstruction has long been the major failure, not how hard the south got whooped. But even then, while our problems can trace a line back to then, a lot of these problems, I feel, would still exist

Kaylyn Talkington

As an Aries I always appreciate Michael's Aries energy 🔥

Austin

I know Gaza isn’t the #1 topic of this episode, but I can’t wrap my head around voting for Kamala based on it. Congress controls the money. You three are lawyers I know you know how the government works. No president ever has had constitutional authority to decide to send weapons to another country. That’s literally the entire basis of Iran/Contra. Why tf are yall spreading right wing propaganda that Biden or any administration bears responsibility for Israel having weapons. Blaming Kamala or Biden for congresses repeated funding bills is so disgusting from this group. Blame your senator, blame your congressperson they voted for it lol

Austin

It’s because a lot of liberals would rather die on their virtue signaling hill than get an ounce of progress. Perfect is the death of progress

Jen

...you think there are marginalized people in the US that are "going to have it worse" than people in Gaza right now?

Riley MacKinnon

WHAT IS IS THE MILLION DOLLAR THING THE PEOPLE NEED TO KNOW

Jen

Yeah, you better vote from the funeral for your family members or you are a little baby! That makes sense.

Victoria Borges

Yeah, I realized that after I made my response... oh well, maybe it'll be useful to someone else

Victoria Borges

I thought they were blaming the Democrat party writ large? Of which the Democrat president is in fact the leader? Also Biden was in congress for decades before this and was a staunch supporter of Isreal since before many of us were born, so I really don't think it's "disgusting" for anyone who cares about Palestinians to be angry at him in particular. No one said he's the only one funding this genocide, but uhh... yeah he's given it material support. More than most people, in fact.

Josephine

Don't know how you got that from OPs message. I see you being a little bitch all over the comments here so I'm glad you're having fun being a cunt when people are feeling down.

Andrew Lenahan

I meant they’re going to have it worse in general, but if you want to argue in bad faith be my guest

Ben Schwabe

Iran Contra was about Congress specifically forbidding the sale of arms to one country. The executive branch has a whole lot of discretion. You may remember Biden even half-assed a threat to use it at one point.

Gretchen Sprinkle

Re: January 6th Voters' memories are not that long

NYCM&AHole

Lol Dems thought they were playing 4d chess but instead they were cutting off various fingers and limbs with knives instead.

NYCM&AHole

I honestly hate them so much I wish Trump would lock dem leadership up and execute them.

NYCM&AHole

Iran contra was about Congress cutting off funding so Reagan and the cia oversaw the sale of fucking boatloads of cocaine which was then used to purchase weapons and fund their death squads. The sale of weapons to Iran is only part of it.

Stepan Serdiukov

I'm sorry, "the economy is worse" take does not sit well with me. How do you think about Trump's first term and not remember the COVID-related collapse. Yeah, eggs were cheaper, but everything else was much worse. You do not, in fact, have to believe the Republican framing on the economy. Democrats did fail to promote their decent economic record. But I'll say this: Biden dared to invest in longer-term gains via infrastructure and industrial policy action (please on't try to memory-hole the PRO Act, murdered by the likes of Sinema and Manchin, the Republican hatchet people), and the voters repaid him thus. The most pro-labor and pro-union president since God knows when. We may resent Joe Biden for getting out of the race too late, but he was that. And the economy is better than it was in 2020.

Stepan Serdiukov

My hope is that Vance will become the Republican Kamala: too closely associated with whatever idiocies and failures that the new Trump admin will bring, and thus less popular for that reason.

Stepan Serdiukov

as someone whose main issue is Ukraine (I am a Russian living in the US), I agree with this (but I'm not unsubscribing because even a podcast is allowed one wrong take sometimes, collectively)

Stepan Serdiukov

they just did 4 years of supporting unions and labor rights but enough people cared more about the price of fucking eggs. it's the "Lisa needs braces" election

Austin

Ugh give me back my name I dont want to share it with ew 🤧

Austin

So disgusting. Is it, really? The administration bears no responsibility, whatsoever? Are you just willfully this dense? Get your fucking head out of your ass, PLEASE.

Kimberly

Feels pretty relevant also to note that Kamala Harris has been in a position of power for the last four years and did nothing to restore abortion rights. That’s actually probably most understandable “vote against your own interests,” if they mistakenly believe it will be left up to the states, they’re vote just did more for abortion access than Kamala ever did

Sean Thomson

No they didn’t. The Dems long ago abandoned the working class. It’s amazing how little you demand from them that you think Biden admin was pro labor. The guy literally blocked the railway strike. Stop dismissing economic class issues as just the ‘price of eggs’.

Steph

What could Kamala have done to restore abortion rights? She was the vice president. She couldn't sign an executive order restoring abortion rights. She couldn't appoint pro choice judges to the courts. That's Joe Bidens job! She was the first VP to visit an abortion clinic https://www.cnn.com/2024/03/13/politics/kamala-harris-planned-parenthood-minnesota/index.html. It may seem small, but it's a big deal given the fact Joe Biden couldn't even utter the word abortion. If she was elected president, I believe she would've tried to restore abortion rights, but it would've been an uphill battle. We knew the senete was going to go red no matter what. She could've done what this podcast has been advocating for and that's court reform, however that requires getting rid of the filibuster and she didn't seem to have an appetite to do that.

NYCM&AHole

I voted for stein. If my vote had cost kopmala my state, Trump would’ve been headed for a 450+ electoral college blowout anyways. How are you doing, Mr Bandera?

Andrew Lenahan

“I voted for Stein” Thank you for announcing to the world nobody should take you seriously

Steph

Yes! Thank you for saying this! When Josie was talking about how Joe Biden barely won the 2020 election and the economy was better then, I was just screaming in my car! Josie, where were you in 2020? Did you forget about the COVID-19 Pandemic and the failure of the Trump administration to do anything? Also, let not forget that one of the reasons why the economy didn't collapse and we didn't spiral into an economic downturn is because of all the stimulus money people got from the government!

Zero Gravitas

Stepan you really need to listen to the newest Citations Needed news brief to understand why the piecemeal record (better than anyone recently but when recently was nothing that's still measley), and not running on progressive promises to the people is exactly how Dems lost.

Zero Gravitas

Trump is deeply unpopular and didn't pick up new votes. Harris received an extremely low vote count. You cannot expect people to be rational en masse when they are suffering, you have to campaign on offering something substantial. Millions of jobs, free healthcare, expanded education, an executive crackdown on corporate inflation. These things are deeply popular with dem voters and will win you an election. Refer to the most recent Citations Needed news brief.

Zero Gravitas

People are not rational actors. Harris didn't run a campaign offering working people relief, and she lost on that.

NYCM&AHole

Lolol thank you for announcing you like getting shat on and that genocide is not a red line for you. Enjoy your Democrat Boston pancake.

Zero Gravitas

They don't have to do what people want, they just have to pretend they can guarantee meeting those desires. You have to campaign on providing for people, not running around with Liz Cheney and securing zero votes on "sanity" and "more of the same." Working ppl ain't listening to that shit, they've got bills, debt, no savings, and no healthcare.

Zero Gravitas

You can get a better takeaway for yourself by joining a grassroots political party or mass org and building dual power. I hope venting here will calm you down enough to get some clarity on what is to be done.

Camille Conner

there is a lot happening in this comment section, so I will just drop a collective hug for anyone who needs it.

Stepan Serdiukov

all true, I just find it necessary to push back against those who go "actually it's as bad as Trump says it is"

Zero Gravitas

They might vote for her if she campaigned on bold economic promises and lifting up unions while stomping on corporations. We will never know though, because it's a capitalist party.

NYCM&AHole

Just keep voting for [the lesser] evil and expecting things to change! I’m sure that change is right around the corner!

Kimberly

You’re right, I suppose I’m not being that specific with my language. Way less than a Kamala specific issue, it’s a massive Democratic Party issue that they couldn’t get in gear to do anything about this on a policy level instead of a PR level. Glad she visited a clinic, but it really is just an ad about her values, not her capacity to make change. Which is why we elect people.

Justin S.

Stein literally said she supported Israel in the week before the election, the same week her VP said "biological males shouldn't compete in women's sports". Congrats on getting played but nice uhh purity test or whatever

Justin S.

It's also an indictment on the average American that someone needs to be told specifically that Republicans will be worse on abortion rights. Like... that's absurd

NYCM&AHole

Don’t worry the Dem 2026 platform will be to deport trans people and to force Monsanto to restart the IG Farben division so they can make Zyklon B to use against Gaza.

Joey Riti

Maybe the next four years will be the confrontation to fascism and real danger that privileged Americans have never felt before. Maybe to understand what we can be, we have to see how far the country can fall. Or we are in the phase of the history textbooks that talks of our countries slow and painful decline.

Nick

Fucking 1,000,000% Rhiannon at 53min 22s absolutely go off. Relationship building is everything.

Nick

Scrolled through the comments just to find anyone who felt the same ❤️

Nick

Also Peter, joy as an act of resistance is a powerful message.

jbwhat

Matt Gaetz is going to be attorney general. Is that funny? I don't honestly know.

Suzanne Miller

Yes. Just bc the VP has limited positional power, she could have done quite a bit for Gaza and abortion rights - think about Dick Cheney’s influence.

Noriana Grande

I always try to embody Peter’s attitude. It has to be funny. I have to see the humor

Sean Thomson

The Dems have been using abortion rights as a fundraising tool and voter drive for decades now. If you think they sincerely care ask why they didn’t codify the right to choose when they had a supermajority. It’s frustrating to hear intelligent people like Peter & Michael discuss the problems with this elections as if it’s the voters fault and the Democrat Party is capable of reform in a leftist direction - it ain’t. Most creatures have self-preservation. But when poll after poll showed that voters wanted change from Biden, Kamala said ‘nothing comes to mind’, when poll after poll showed that 80% or more of Dem and Independents voters support a permanent cease-fire and 60% or more disapprove of more weapons to (that country that shall not be named), Kamala response “shut up Im speaking” let’s pal around with everybody favourite family The Warhawks. The Dems would rather lose than offer anything meaningful to working class, they would rather lose than challenge the powerful destructive interests they are so intent on protecting and representing , they arrogantly believe their base has no where else to go they can condescendingly talk in empty platitudes instead of anything substantive.

Shea

Rhiannon was so good in this episode. "I am not leaving. This is my homeland. I will be free here or nothing else" brought tears to my eyes for the first time since we got the results last week

Jack Wolfe

moving, thoughtful stuff, as expected. so grateful to have yall around in these times. having michael on the phone ala a pissed off radio call-in show guest seemed appropriate lol

Rodolfo A

The nail in the coffin for our political system is voter apathy Nearly half of eligible aged Americans didn’t vote Many pundits are reading this election as if America is moving towards conservative, but it’s the exact opposite Both Kamala and Trump are conservatives, though they have their obvious differences People want a future where they’re represented, not overlooked for corporate ass kissing

Rachel

avoiding the discourse™️ in the comments to say: how lucky are we to have y’all to talk through this moment with us? thank you so much for all you do and how generous you are with your insights and perspectives

zancakes

"They arrogantly believe their base has no where else to go." This is a really good and accurate read of the party.

Kathryn Fort

Thank you Rhiannon for your words.

TK

I feel like the only lesson the DNC is gonna learn is "our candidate can never be a woman again", which is a travesty. Without a major restructuring of the party, without a rejection of the oligarchy, they will never win.

David Behrens

Yeah I came here to say this a well. I was inadvertently spreading this piece of disinformation myself a couple weeks ago. Not a biggie as clearly I also fell for it, but hopefully something to be aware of for next time. Loved the episode!

Adam Wurstmann

The democratic party and learning the wrong lesson from its failures; you can't name a more iconic duo

zancakes

"Palestinians aren't the only marginalized people in the world! Sacrifice them to save the marginalized people I care about!"

Bryn Bratton Wall

I know Josie said not to be jealous of the group chat, but I am.