Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout
haven't archived this post yet. have a subscription? use the importer!

Downloads

  • FIVEFOUR_pop culture_master.mp3
  • copy cat influencers.pdf
  • Holiday_Extravaganza_Dr... - audiogram.mp4
  • Holiday_Extravaganza_Dr... - audiogram.mp4

Missing 2 full-res photos, 2 videos, 2 files, as this post has not yet been imported.

Content

Thank you for being a subscriber! Please sit back, relax, and enjoy this premium episode, in which we discuss some of this year's hottest legal battles in pop culture. We talk rap beef, "clean girl" influencer drama, and the potential TikTok ban.

See visuals from the influencer lawsuit attached in a slide deck to this post.

Here is a link to The Verge influencer lawsuit story by Mia Sato Bad influence

5-4 is presented by Prologue Projects. This episode was produced by Dustin DeSoto. Leon Neyfakh and Andrew Parsons provide editorial support. Our website was designed by Peter Murphy. Our artwork is by Teddy Blanks at Chips NY, and our theme song is by Spatial Relations.

Follow the show at @fivefourpod on most platforms. On Twitter, find Peter @The_Law_Boy and Rhiannon @AywaRhiannon.

Files

Previews only

Comments

Crystaline

I want to know, in addition to the spreadsheet of it all, are these Amazon influencers being led to believe somehow that they’re entrepreneurs or independent contractors and therefore working with the understanding that they’re in clear competition with each other and not colleagues.

Alcoholic Synonymous

I don’t have to pretend I never liked Drake. Truth is an absolute defense. He sucks and has always sucked going back to that stupid teen soap drama show.

Taylor Schackmann

My massage therapist is from Toronto and said that everyone in Canada knows about Drake and his predilections. Like, everyone knows someone who got paid off. So, idk how he’s gonna come out of this ahead. And just as someone who did experience textbook grooming, it screams to me “I need to try to have some control of this situation,” in the same way that someone who does this to kids does.

Dr Nermal Funkenstein

I grew up in a town right next to Altoona. Shady characters, the lot of them. Which has only been further proven by sneaky goblins (or the surveillance penoptocon) in one of the most decrepit of places, an Altoona McDonalds. Altoona's saving grace is being the birthplace of Sheetz. Otherwise, nobody would've noticed if Hitler had succeeded in bombing it

Thomas Furlong

Well that was an insightful primer on influencer copyright issues... and on a completely unrelated note, I'm proud to announce my new legally distinct podcast "6-3 — Why the Supreme Court Blows by Foreword Features"

Thomas Furlong

In all seriousness though, this kind of thing is becoming such a scourge in all kinds of online spaces. Hell, in a sense Amazon itself (allegedly!) engages in a similar practice on a product level by encouraging sellers to list products on its Marketplace, using analytics to identify particularly successful third-party products, and then rushing out knock-offs onto their platform while burying the original in search. Don't get me wrong, I enjoy a legal spat between bottom-feeding affiliate marketing airheads as much as the next guy, but this is the just logical end result of platforms creating a reward system for monetizing every online interaction. There are whole content farm networks that make a living ripping off smaller creators and crowding them out with bot networks and AI-produced garbage and it's only going to get worse. Or even on an individual level, you have the whole YouTube plagiarism scandal, or white TikTok dancers copying a Black creator's original meme dance and hogging the limelight without giving credit, or the zombie hordes of bluecheck bots weaseling out a few pennies on X (The Everything App™) by rephrasing trending posts and stealing top comments. Not to mention the literal scams perpetrated by spoofing brand accounts. I have no idea where to draw the line, but left unchecked, the entire Internet is going to devolve into a feeding frenzy for grifters, gasbags, and groypers so quickly and it just sucks.

audioboy

It was an old woman who snitched at the McDonald's -- she works/worked there and bragged about it on Facebook. Forget her name now. The guy Michael was talking about was a patron witness who gave reports to News organizations, including taking about the woman who snitched.

Tierney Scoblic

"I'm jealous of people who have no dignity" perfectly sums up my thoughts on influencer culture

Shelley DeWees

I’m dying for this PDF. No notes. 😂

Meggy Parsec

I never thought minimalism could be vulgar, but here we are.

Jessica Buckland

I agree, I live in and was raised in State College. But I think it is easy to shit on Altoona, a depressed town with a drug problem, historically working class, left behind when industry left... right? But full of old conservative snitches. Sidebar: I know one of the cops who arrested him. :/

LadySwayze

Hot and stupid gets you so far though, or so I have *bitterly* witnessed. :) Fuck the snitch class AND let’s rally the Luigi support for all disabled and chronically ill comrades!

Alex Washington

Kinda surprised that you guys are choosing to ignore the manifesto that spoke to the explicitly political motivation for this killing. He might be crazy but he did this bc he was fed up with the greed and cruelty of our for profit health insurance system. That’s not a projection. They’re his own words

Duncan

Suing over a rap beef is such a huge self-own i think worse than any line in a song could possibly be

Dr Nermal Funkenstein

Hello fellow Pennsylvanian. I have a radically different perspective when I'm not completely joking. I grew up playing hockey +4 days a week and many of my teammates were from Altoona and State College. I was radically fortunate to live in Hollidaysburg and not DuBois. Even then, I grew up with kids who experienced serious poverty

Jessica Buckland

Yeah I figured. I wish Luigi had gone to state college bc wearing a surgical mask here is more typical than Altoona.

gretchen anderson

Rhi’s reminds me of 10th grade when a girl beat my ass for wearing a bandana similar to hers (and everyone else’s).

Julian

I sincerely doubt that Luigi is the guy. The manifesto sounds like cop bullshit, and I'm perfectly comfortable assuming that the cops are lying about the evidence/planted it on him. He also doesn't look like the guy from the actual shooting security footage. I'm not saying the guy who did the shooting is a genius and will never get caught, but I am saying that cops are morons and I think it's pretty likely that they snagged the wrong guy. I don't think we should be taking the cops at their word that this is the guy.

Candice Evers

Perfect amount of goofy. Thank you.

Sharkbelly

Josh Johnson’s set about the lawsuit is so good, including the bit where he echoes this sentiment.

fivefourpod

We aren’t choosing to ignore the manifesto Alex. We recorded this hours after he was named and his online profiles started getting shared. There was no published manifesto yet. Even with the manifesto, it doesn’t change a general political incoherence to the guy that is (1) demonstrative of the public at large and (2) darkly funny. So we made fun of it. The manifesto actually deepens those nuances - the first sentence praises the feds lmao. We’re not saying he didn’t have his reasons, just that he’s a complicated little weirdo just like every other person on the planet. Fuck CEO’s. Hope this helps. - Rhiannon

Sharkbelly

23:37 yeah, the discovery will be Triple-Oof for Aubrey

Roxie V

The influencer case is quite possibly the dumbest shit I've ever heard. This is what happens when you let idiots on the internet reviewing products call themselves "creators." You didn't create shit! As an artist who one day found a guy selling a t-shirt with my own artwork from college on it *right outside* of my office in SoHo, i can say influencers haven't got a clue what it takes to actually make something worth stealing

Kathryn Jones

Seriously, thank you so much for choosing to do some dumb and silly bonus episodes! I love you guys, but I am very tired and depressed and really have to throttle back my intake of current political horribleness (e.g., can't listen to your crossover with Know Your Enemy (a podcast I also love).

fivefourpod

I think (this is Rhiannon) that they believe they are business owners. And they *are* in some factual sense - like I think a lot of influencers have LLCs, build and develop their “brand” which is the vehicle through which they do their work, etc. They’re certainly not employees of Amazon, but in a fundamental sense (in this situation, for the type of influencer involved in the lawsuit) their job is marketing for Amazon. The article I pulled from, by Mia Sato at The Verge, touches more on relationships between influencers—sometimes they work together, other times cliques and feuds and grievances lead them to be more competitive or cancel their partnerships etc. These two specific influencers in fact had blocked each other long before the lawsuit, based on a couple of awkward social interactions that they kind of shrug off as a regular part of the work—you just don’t like other influencers sometimes, you block them, you move on. The copycat allegations came way later, and neither one of them alleges that it stems from those initial negative interactions. Fascinating!

Claire Gunter

More like C.R.E.A.M. Dolla dolla bills y’all

Kyle Moore

He kissed the girl on stage and commented on her breasts after she said she was 17…

Kelly Moran

“He’s fundamentally stupid in this way” 📞 Hello Kendrick get rhiannon in the booth

Olivia

Sad beige aesthetic

Kazoolhu

I love that someone thinks they deserve a copyright on being dull. Good luck, clone girl!

Vincent

Can you trademark a vibe?

Sarah

Hey! I’m just a girl in my mid to late 20s and I have a tattoo of a pot of soup on my bicep, thank you very much 😤

marie

a moment to appreciate michael‘s instant clocking of the vaguely racist undertones to the clean girl

Zachary Smith

“Courts turn their brains off when they hear ‘national security’” should be the title of a law review article. Or book.

Meghan Cloutier

If idiotic lawsuits could kill: Girl with the flower tattoo

Nicholas Donofrio

Police officers are gonna start using their "informed judgement" to start violating civil rights

Benjamin Craft-Rendon

Obviously hypocrisy means nothing, but the blessing of "1st amendment" anti-TikTok arguments vs. how Corrupt Foreign Practices Act gets treated 🤮

Alex Sarna

"AI Tupac, challenging Kendrick... to bring this stuff up, sounds like consent to me." - we live in a special timeline for sure

Angela

Visual aids made my day—thanks Rhiannon! Do more nonsense episodes please. We all need more of this!

LadySwayze

This episode also made me wonder how many Mormon influencers (wood) work specifically with Amazon, as Mormonism is founded on and advances a no-deviance, ultra refined (like the removal of character), and like y’all said, reproducible “style.” If you’ve been to Utah county, it’s a race to be both indistinguishable and exceptional. As always, very appreciative of Rhiannon, Michael, Peter, and Rachel, and any ex-mos interested in talking the Mormon/fascism overlap, I’d love to connect.

Jack Wolfe

michael continuing a streak of saying gross things (describing "the michael"), jk jk jk

genrepunk

About personal data: yeah, it's more about damage control these days. A lot of listeners probably know this, but everyone should be freezing their credit except when it's needed. https://www.usa.gov/credit-freeze (Watch out for the brazen upsell attempts on the individual bureaus' sites. You don't need to buy anything to be able to freeze or unfreeze your credit.)

Joshua Golek

Thanks All, I finally understand what what teenage daughters are talking about at the dinner table

stumblyghost

Literally subscribed just for this episode. Need more pop culture and silly law stuff please 🙏🏽

OK

Love you guys and loved this episode!!! I’ve already relistened 10x 😂

Lauren

My flower tattoo and I don't like this

Alex Nutter

Aesthetic digital labor IS labor, though, right? And influencers do work for Amazon in a sense but also for the platforms they post on. Like most of the working class in neoliberal capitalist societies, it benefits the corporations (Amazon, this case) who have an interest in putting workers - especially vulnerable ones - in direct competition with each other. They don’t want solidarity among their direct employees, and they don’t want it among contracted employees either.

notreally Stellar

micheal immediately clocking the subtle racism in the vibe and implications of the clean girl aesthetic is sending me

D G

Patent, copyright and trademark law is designed specifically to prevent competition. The only reason those laws should exist is to prevent giant/established corpos from strangling small/new companies. Sydney can defeat Alyssa by being better than her. Or, alternatively, she could try to partner up with Alyssa and profit share. Suing shows that Sydney isn't capable of competing or innovating her way to success.

Rachel

Not Guy Fieri catching strays 😭😂

Jen B

Drake, it’s so painfully Canadian to end a rap battle with suicidal litigation. it’s not even embarrassment, bc embarrassment is 🇺🇸 ,“