Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout
haven't archived this post yet. have a subscription? use the importer!

Content

I'm pretty sure the monitor I use for colour grading has degraded pretty significantly over the past year or so.

The levels display well for my setup, but on phones the image seems to be far too underexposed. A quick vote offering your own experience will be a huge help for future grading:)

The attached image (intended to be very high contrast, but without any loss of visual information from blacks or white extremes) is:

Files

Previews only

Comments

Andy

Viewing on an iPhone 11 Pro Max, with 100% brightness on the screen. I don’t see any issues. The “darkest spot”, that has some loss of information, would be her socks.

Tetra

thats very helpful info, thank you! it's very possible my phone just absolutely sucks lol

JUICEfromtheBOX

Depends on what you want? Do you want viewers to see the background details? (I assume it’s raining) then it’s kinda bright for that. As for Tifa, her lighting isn’t bad if this is a dark room but compared to previous Tifa videos. She does seem darker than usual. Just depends on what you are going for with lighting.

Tetra

background details would be a matter of raising aperture; this shot at least is meant to have a particularly low depth of field. Main issue would be if the subject - tifa's body specifically - was underexposed to the point where visual detail is being lost due to extremes in the black values.

Napalm

Hmm I’m not sure if it’s underexposed as if you made it much higher the background would probably glow like a Ukrainian nuclear reactor. It looks pretty good to me, it could just be a case of the camera being positioned to face the main light source (the white rain background), maybe a dim light to light the region you think is underexposed could do well?

Tetra

I should clarify, the issue is purely based upon the lack of similitude between monitors and their display settings. I'm perfectly happy with how the colours look on my setup; my concern is how accurately that is reflected against other monitors/display devices.

TheRealEffinDeal

Just received my new monitor last night and I don't see any issues. Whites are bright, shadowy areas sufficiently dark but can still see what's happening. The only thing I could point to is the tiny fringing/fuzziness on the edge of her boob and the really bright part of the background. Granted I haven't messed with any of the color settings/profiles yet so it could be off a bit.

Tetra

Thank you for all the info! sounds to be a decent dynamic range then; the boob blur is an intended artefact that you would get with anamorphic lenses, so that one's no problem lol

TheRealEffinDeal

You fancy folk, and your fancy filmmaking terms. You thinking about upgrading your setup? This one I just picked up is my first OLED panel, the colors and the deep blacks are wild on this thing.

Tetra

Very snazzy, you've definitely got me beat on monitors; my setup must be a good half decade out of date by this point lol if you dont mind me asking, what monitor is it you went with?

Samuel Smith

Similar to what Andy said, I'm viewing the image on a Samsung Galaxy A20 with brightness at maximum and Tifa looks pretty good. Her chin and lips have some motion blur as do her boobs, the rest is still and I still her details.

TheRealEffinDeal

Went with the MSI MPG 321URX. Was a pain to get ahold of but was so worth it. Had a great price in the US, Europe not so much. I'm not really an incremental kinda upgrade person I just kinda splurge and then run with it till the wheels fall off. At least that's how I justify frivolous spending in my head.

Tetra

Christ, thing looks like an absolute unit, great buy lad I'm the exact same way, built this pc for work a year back for an egregious price, will just ride it out as many generations as I can

caput4ever

I guess I'd say Tifa looks a bit too dark. I could be wrong but it seems like her body was more "brightly lit" in the previous animations you made of her with Cloud, which I generally personally prefer since it feels like things can be seen more "clearly". But again, I could very well be mistaken

Dak Laxterby

If you're worried about specifically Tifa being underexposed in this image, then I'd say yeah probably. I think you could probably stand to bump up her shadows and midtones a bit, but just a little.

Tetra

For sure, definitely seems like my monitor displays a little brighter than default

Tetra

100%, there are definitely parts where a higher contrast will be intended in certain shots, but this seems to be reading a touch too underexposed for my taste.