A Review of Summer Grimmory Beta | Kingdom Death: Monster (Patreon)
Content
Soak in the sun with Kingdom Death's dour renegade, dressed for the summery occasion! This exclusive version of Grimmory includes a custom palm tree, furniture, and beta rules for a never before seen type of card!
Before we start, I am somewhat concerned that this is a large scale miniature being boxed up with game content because I was under the impression that this was going to stop. So, I guess when were were told that there would be no more game content cards being released with the Painter's Scale miniatures that meant only the white boxes and there was an exception where Beta content would be concerned.
This doesn't feel good and it has a massive impact on the value that this boxed set contains, which we'll touch back to this in the Summary section. I do hope this trend doesn't continue in the future.
Contents
1x Summer Grimmory photoresin miniature diorama and base
1x Beta Rules - Install Guide card
1x Beta Rules - Solar Flares pillar card
1x Beta Rules - Heat Aggression campaign trait card
Large Matte Art Print
Character Art Card
First Run Collector's Edition: Signed and numbered authenticity note
Summer Grimmory is the first example we have seen for the upcoming Pillar Cards that are due to arrive in Campaigns of Death (Volume 1). Well first time I've seen “Volume 1” attached to Campaigns of Death, and to be honest I'm not thrilled because I'd rather see Team Death and APG move onto other parts of the Kingdom Death world once this current Monster Kickstarter is finished. KD:Labyrinth and KD:Titans both interest me more than additional stuff for KDM. I'd like to see what Team Death do with all their experience when working from the ground up rather than the current trajectory which represents constant requirements for power creep in order to keep attention on the new products. I would love to see Kingdom Death: Labyrinth in particular because I think there's a lot of potential for a modern dungeon crawler that uses the KD Gear, Monster Behaviour systems and Settlement Development systems. Still, here we get our first look at what the Pillar Cards are going to be doing and that helps inform decisions about what Campaigns of Death will be like and who it will be useful for.
The Model
I'll be brief here because this is a non-Kingdom Death version of Grimmory (probably from the Kingdom Death: High universe). It's a well sculpted, characterful piece that I am sure will be a huge hit for display painters. For the rest of us though there is very little value in this unless one has a painter friend or some other way to pass on this model without also needing the game content. It's adding around $30 to $40 onto the price of the entire release and that's a huge mark up unless you are a collector or display painter. I would have preferred this to be released with an in universe version of Grimmory, sculpted to match the artwork of Grimmory on the Heat Aggression card (see further down).
In short, there's talent here, but it is wasted being part of this release.
The Game Content
In this box alongside the miniature there are three cards; these include our first Pillar Card, the associated “Campaign Trait” card and the traditional Install Guide. Both the back of the Pillar Card and the Campaign Trait feature the blue top “ribbon” band, which is not an issue for the Campaign Trait, but it does mean that if Campaigns of Death has players drawing from randomised Pillar cards this Solar Flares card is marked and because APG still haven't released opaque backed sleeves for their Hunt Events or Pattern cards it's unlikely that you'll be able to use Solar Flares without knowing where exactly it is in the deck. This is of course solved by looking away while shuffling the cards (if that is how they are drawn, we don't know for certain at this stage), but it also simply shouldn't be the case. Integration for things like should consider how they will be merged with future releases; we shouldn't ever have the situation we are currently in where multiple decks are permanently “marked” on the back and there is no good way to cover them (Japanese size sleeves almost do the job, but they're a bit short and wide).
Worth noting the two pillars on this card, suggesting that it is an II Pillar Card because the Pillar system icon has three pillars, not two.
This is the Pillar Card's front and it is a very simple affair, we have the settlement event Heat Wave every five years until LY 20 and every showdown has the Heat Aggression campaign trait. The artwork on this card is sweet, it's a wonderful depiction of a “Sun” category Sunstalker (the oldest Sunstalkers tend to switch to being airborne most of the time as their flotation bladders are fully developed and they can then squirt gasses around to propel themselves through the air in the way that Vampire Warriors from the Necroscope series do. I've often wanted to see parts of the world where a Sun inhabits, but from a different perspective to the survivors that worship it (People of the Sun). This gives us a small peak into that, it doesn't seem to much change the light situation, but it makes the place very warm, and has occasional flares from the “Sun”.
Here is the Heat Wave SE card, so we can see what is happening every five years, and the main impact is limiting heavy/fur gear, stopping Science/Education endeavouring and offering these three options. We'll skip on the heavy/fur gear section for the moment, because due to the Campaign Trait it turns out to be irrelevant.
Because we know when these heat waves are coming, due to them being set on the timeline in advance, there's very little in the way of downside as far as this card is concerned. The meaningful innovations that are impacted are:
Bloodletting
Nightmare Training
Records
Scrap Smelting
Storytelling
Water of Life
For the majority of scenarios none of these options are a problem if you know that the Heat Wave is coming, you can plan to perform the act in the lantern year before or afterwards. Scrap Smelting is the one that is most frustrating to have limited, especially if you need to leave scrap in the settlement storage in a year before something that threatens resources in the settlement (Gorm Climate, Conviction Timeline Event or Butcher for example). Still, on the whole this is not a big deal, Heat Wave is most impactful if you don't know it is coming because it can force hunting survivors wearing fur/heavy armor to take a year off when you didn't expect that.
Heat Aggression is the Campaign Trait, and it features artwork that I personally think should have been translated into miniature form as a game piece.
This is a very simple change, we are effectively cut off from using any fur or heavy keyword armor for the entire campaign (we can possibly get away with 1 piece of that armor type, but losing 3 survival is a steep price to pay). In exchange for that all survivors gain a +1 strength token on Arrival. +1 strength is a meaningful amount to gain, especially in the early game, because it can push weapons that otherwise would not be viable due to their lack of ability to reliably wound into the bracket where they wound 60% of the time (the minimum percentage chance I want to see on a weapon). This is in the form of a Strength Token, so it also offers synergies with Gormundism and of course People of the Sun, who use Strength Tokens to fuel one of their survival actions.
The armor sets that we lose access using without penalty are:
White Lion Armor and its variants
Gorment Armor
Screaming Antelope Armor and its variants
Brawler Armor
Warlord Armor
Count Armor
Earl Armor (1 armor card, so can still be viable at -3 survival)
Marchioness Armor
Bullfrog Armor
Lantern Armor
King Armor
Green Armor (1 armor card, the boots, so this is fine due to the power of that armor set)
Note that Rolling Armor dodges this penalty because it does not have the Armor keyword. This is how it works in People of the Sun also. It also has a lot of exposed skin on that armor set, so it makes thematic sense.
This means in some campaigns the negative of this armor punishment will be close to nil because every Node has at least one Quarry monster that provides non-heavy/fur armor and we also have Rawhide plus Leather armor to support that further.
So this card does have an impact, but it is more shaping player behaviour when crafting rather than being something that really punishes them. Both the Earl Armor and Green Armor look worth using despite them having heavy boots, as -3 survival isn't too harsh a punishment. The largest limitations are being cut off from the really tanky late game armor sets (Lantern, Bullfrog and especially King), so there's a real need to run the Dung Beetle Knight in these campaigns for that late game durability (shout out to all the guys who've shared their Dung Beetle Knight miniatures on the discord recently, love seeing what other people have done with their KDM miniatures).
The concept is great, but I don't think this specific pairing of cards matters much here and I wouldn't be surprised to see them printed again in Campaigns of Death due to how Sunstalker themed they are. (This is of course speculation on my part).
Summary
It is difficult to recommend this one to anyone who isn't looking to do something with the miniature. For players (not painters or collectors) the value here is very low, so this one really depends on other factors. It is an interesting look into what the Pillar System will work like; suggesting that the greatest value for this system is going to be for players who are KDM lifestyle gamers and play lots of runs every year. These lifestyle gamers are the players who will benefit from the variation and texture that we're seeing here. I look forward to seeing how impactful the other Pillar cards will be, especially if we can have multiple ones that interact with each other in meaningful ways.
My final verdict on this one is that from a game perspective this is an easy skip, you don't need it unless you also want the miniature. I probably would have a different perspective if this was a small box release and had a normal sized Grimmory model that matched the Heat Aggression artwork.
At time of writing this was available in the shop at very low stock here: https://shop.kingdomdeath.com/products/summer-grimmory