Pillar Percival | A White Box Review | Kingdom Death Monster (Patreon)
Content
The original release for Percival is one of those items which has been in active rotation since its release. Like the Lonely Tree and Fade it's something with low impact that hasn't been an issue to keep around because if you do not investigate then it simply defaults to being a random hunt event due to its design.
The redesign of Percival follows the same one as Fade, with the boxed set providing updated versions of the original cards that tie closely into the Pillars design that was introduced in the Gambler's Chest and will be fully realised in Campaigns of Death.
At time of writing I believe that Percival has been shipped out to Backers and will appear in the store soon (I'm guessing at the end of October 2025), so this is an opportunity for me to go through the updates to the content ahead of release. Something I rarely get to do.
Contents
1x Hard plastic Percival plus base
1x Blackguard Style Secret Fighting Art
1x Dead Warrior Basic Hunt Event Card
1 x Pillar card
1 x Pillar card install guide
1x Large matte art print
The Model
Percival's Miniature is a fan favourite for good reason, it presents an image of Percival as she was unfathomable Lantern Years ago. This miniature is a part of the rarest kind of female fantasy model, one clad in stylish, sensible and practical armor. In truth, outside of the understandable less clothed early lantern year and settlement dwelling survivors many of the armor sets in Kingdom Death land in this category and Percival is one of the finest examples of this particular category.
In addition to that, this miniature has received a new lease of life with the advent of the Black Knight Expansion because it can also be used to represent a survivor armoured with a full set of the Marchionesse armor set. That means as of right now we have two Count Armor miniatures for male and female (Jackal is the female version of the Count Armor), one Earl Armor for male and three Marchionesse Armor sets (1 Male, 2x Female). Hopefully things are rounded out with a female survivor wearing Earl Armor soon because that is the set I tend to use the most.
This is a great miniature that shows her age, so I do think it could have been redesigned and retooled for the new release. It will be noticeable when you have her next to other survivors.
The Game Content
We have a total of three cards for the game content (plus the rules card), the first of which is the Pillar card. This one currently doesn't have much use, but will become relevant in the future. The main reason to show it here is the insight it gives into Percival and the Black Knight. Percival is shown to be an instructor, which is also reflected in the Secret Fighting Art and the Black Knight is shown scampering around in front of the training Black Guard. It's a sweet little picture and insight into a world long lost.
This is the introductory hunt event which replaces a basic hunt event card in lantern year 13, on the left is the original version and the right is the updated version found in this box (Colour differences are due to the scanning process, not the cards though all hunt cards released to date have colour matching issues that need to be solved by Adam Poots Games releasing opaque hunt event sleeves). The updates here include moving the 'random hunt event' portion to the opening text and correcting the bolding issue for “Investigate”. Also we have a doubling of the worst possible result, a correction to the injury in order to make it match the actual in game injury text and a change from gaining a generic bone for desecrating Percival's corpse to a skull. Finally the card now self-archives, becoming a normal random hunt event after it is resolved.
Before we go any further, it's worth clarifying that this is likely Percival's ultimate fate (Adam has confirmed directly that she's dead), not only is the skeleton one-handed like Percival, but it has the Black Guard instruction tablet next to her and it is protected, maybe by the Black Knight or maybe by her Phantom? . This is all quite thematic world building, though I do wonder what on earth possessed Percival to carry around an instruction tablet for a fighting style she was familiar with. I'm sure one can come up with a range of reasons, but they're all something of a stretch. She's not entombed, so she wasn't laid down to rest with a full, respectful ceremony, but maybe she bled out and one of her students left the instruction tablet with her as a mark of respect?
The lack of a barrow, tomb or even a cairn is very interesting though, her body has been left here, exposed for long enough to become a full, dry, bastard skelly and hasn't been disturbed by the Watchers despite containing knowledge from the past. She's also not been moved somewhere by her best friend (or Perhaps the unseen force is a phantom of Percival herself?) despite evidence that the Black Knight greatly mourns her passing? It's hard to say, the picture we get here is small and is full of many questions that may well never be answered. All we can say is whatever killed her didn't immediately kill any others and they were in a situation where there was no time to treat her remains with respect. She may have been the last Black Guard standing and perished on the way home.
A quick aside, why haven't we seen an Unarmored Percival? We have survival tokens for her, but we've not seen another version of her in the way that we see new versions of many other survivors, it's interesting given the existence of Percival survival tokens. I hope this is addressed in the future with a “Percival” (but not really Percival) boxed set or inclusion in the Inverted Mountain Campaign.
Overall this hunt event has always been fine, one never interacts with it unless you have a sword proficiency survivor in your hunt party and that individual is not deaf. Though it is a shame that the odds of this card doing nothing has been doubled now, because that means 20% of the time it does nothing. I'm also not clear if the card archives even if no-one Investigates, the wording seems to indicate that once you draw this card, if you do not investigate it will be gone from the campaign. Which isn't great either, the benefit of the original card is that you could leave it if there wasn't anyone suitable to gain the SFA and hope you could run into it later.
Instead it now looks like if you want this SFA you must pick it up when you see it and then train it onto the survivor you want to use it. That's a bit of a nerf, though if Team Death clarify the conditions under which this card is archived we'll be clearer on that matter.
The Secret Fighting Art is Black Guard Style and it is yet another sword focused fighting art, it has had a couple of updates since its first release though so here are both versions:
The SFA has been buffed a fair amount by the switching from Block 1 to Deflect 1, that's a meaningful upgrade because Deflect is far more flexible than Block, it's something you can “Fire and Forget” meaning it's easier to weave into a showdown and doesn't require aggressive maintenance the way that Block does. Ignoring First Strike is a very edge case buff, not all monsters have First Strike, but this is a good place to add such a marginal bonus and it's very welcome.
There is a change to this new SFA that I do not like, which is the re-framing of the artwork, the original version is more zoomed out, showing the original framing as the artist intended. The newer version is a lot closer and cropped in a way that makes it look unbalanced. This zooming and cropping did not need to happen and it has made the card a wee bit uglier.
Edit: The previous version of this review mixed up the two cards part way through the review which is due to my dyslexia and the simple truth that I'm trying to do too much at the moment with Black Friday looming next month, the YT channel and Kingdoms Forlorn taking up a large amount of time. I incorrectly applied my thoughts to the original version, this has now been amended to the section below and has impacted on my final verdict to push it from a skip to a "situational". Apologies for that.
The updated layout for the new card takes what was a sloppy job and improves upon it to both remove the typo and better balance the lines so they form a nice taper. It is pleasing to see things like this happen (especially when somehow you accidentally think that they're the other way round chronologically!)
Our big decision point here is if this will be a good fit for the campaign one is currently playing, if it is not sword heavy then it is not going to be something you want. At the moment it is not hard to ensure this is only for sword campaigns, the future depends on how the entire Pillar system shakes out. I can't really predict that at this time and that's another place suggesting that it's best to wait and see with this one.
Before moving to the final thoughts I'd like to quickly praise the mechanical storytelling in this one, the way that Black Guard Style inflicts a broken arm on the "trainer" as they pass on the SFA suggests that Percival lost her hand from training another and that's a nice piece of storytelling.
Final Thoughts
While I do like Percival and I have used this content for years now without issue I do think that this re-release does not represent Adam Poots Games at their best. In fact this product feels a bit undercooked, which is somewhat bizarre given that it is a reprint of a nearly 10 years old product (she first came out in 2016, do you feel old yet?)
I don't think I can recommend this one to every single player at this time, Fade's release felt a little bit phoned in due to the miniature but it was always a far stronger release with great content and miniature as opposed to Percival which was OK content with a great miniature.
Fade offers a wider range of decisions and difficult choices and as such Percival has always been a few steps down from Fade (especially as Percival does nothing if you do not have good mid game and late game swords). I also really do not like the new framing of the card art, but that is very much a personal opinion which you may disagree on.
All of this makes it a mid-tier release that is very dependant on how much your playgroup uses swords. It gets significantly stronger if you play with the Sunstalker, Flower Knight and Regalism for example. So while Black Guard Style has been buffed and is better than it was previously this is still very much something that you will have to decide if it fits for your campaigns. Without swords this is not going to achieve much and while there are some swords in the generic locations I don't personally find them exciting enough to make this an automatic purchase in the way that the Ringtail Vixen, White Speaker and Wanderer Candy are. This is more on the level of being good if you know you're going to be able to make effective use of it every time it turns up.