Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Content

Arriving in the settlement, an ailing Goth shares her story with the settlement before it's too late.

Contents:

1x Goth hard plastic miniature

1x Goth scenic base insert

1x Kingdom Death 30mm base

5x Arc survivor record sheets

1x Divider

4x Knowledge cards

1x Fighting art card

2x Rare gear cards

2x Innovation cards

There's not much of a blurb for Goth I'm afraid, this is because Goth seems to have landed in a weird spot. Goth was originally pitched as a KDM version of Amy the Goth from the CMON game Zombicide. CMON is one of the latest companies to fall down after trying to keep its Kickstarter train running by using new kickstarters to help complete older ones. As a consequence of that CMON has sold off a lot of their intellectual properties to various other companies, Asmodee has purchased the Zombicide IP. This is of course a lesson for anyone who succeeds in a Kickstarter/Crowd funded project to learn from, but my opinion is that once you've established your brand and base games in the way that CMON had, you shouldn't be going back to the Kickstarter well, especially if you have not completed your previous projects with final distribution of the previous project in progress. I have become increasingly less and less favourable towards crowdfunded projects as time has passed for a bunch of reasons, and CMON's model was one of those driving forces. It is a shame that this has happened because some CMON games such as Rising Sun and Ankh are superb, plus I've always got a soft spot for the oddness that is The Others.

What we have now is Goth Amy being rebranded to Goth, it's hard to tell exactly why this is, even the store page that this was originally released on is lacking elements that are present on other Wanderers. The speculation would be that it is a result of CMON's IP sale and the sheer length of time it has been since Goth Amy was first pitched and any crossover IP deals were worked out. Or maybe the name was changed because Gothic Amy is a thing, who knows.

I guess the real lesson here is don't do IP crossovers because you lose control of your own products.

Regardless it is clear that Goth has been designed with Amy the Goth very much in mind, as this Wanderer is Zombicide coded at a very deep level. That means we at least have the Zombicide version of Amy to draw comparisons to so we can better understand the thematic mechanics this wanderer has.

Amy was a goth girl who hated everything; from mindless consumerism to the pointlessness of daily existence. The world Amy despised so much has crumbled, and from the rubble comes the promise of a fresh start and simpler times. Desperate zombie battles have sparked a will to live in Amy and finally given her something to care about; but she still doesn’t feel comfortable without some white foundation on. – Amy the Goth, Zombicide

Amy's signature weapon is a katana and like most survivors in Zombicide (yes Zombicide also uses Survivors as the name for its player units) she also has a “Zombivor” version that depicts what happens when she gets bitten. Now one of the core mechanics which matters for KDM comparisons is the Danger Level system, this is an experience system where each zombie is worth 1 exp when killed and the survivors increase up their “danger bar” at the top of their character sheet. Here's Amy's 1st Edition Character Sheet to highlight that progression.

As Amy levels up the danger bar you can see she gains additional abilities, extra movement, extra actions, better in combat and so on. We can also see a bit more clearly from her artwork that Amy was likely designed in tribute to NCIS's Abby Sciuto (played by Pauley Perret) who is also a goth character sporting a similar haircut. This danger bar/levelling up system and combat focus are mechanical elements that come across into Goth's story and design along with the zombie elements.

The Miniature

This is a really solid Kingdom Death take on the character, we have a form of leggings, the choker, the katana, belly piercing and the iconic haircut. Adding to the aesthetic is the transformation of the traditional stone heads into something a bit more zombie-like. The pose is also quite dynamic, though that does leave the blood splatter from the katana cut to be a little exposed and fragile during play. Not quite so visible in this image is Goth's carrying bag, lantern and a phial of liquid. Sadly the lantern is one of the S-lanterns which are my least favourite lantern design, but that is something I have to make peace with. This is a great miniature that fits both the character and her outlook on life.

It was a little tricky to assemble, mostly this is due to the base and my preference to part-paint meaning I have to leave the base unattached and mask up the connection points between the model and the base, but also there are a few delicate elements such as the pigtails, loincloth ties, the lantern and the aforementioned blood splatter. Also moving this miniature around even by the base is still going to expose elements to wear and tear because it is close to impossible to not end up touching those heads when you pick Goth up.

The Gameplay

Just like other Wanderers Goth has a lot of unique elements that make her stand out from normal survivors. She is an Arc Survivor, which means if you do not already own the Gambler's Chest you are going to miss out on the vast majority of her content and while a Fighting Art version of her Knowledge is included along with rules on playing her without Arc Survivors I am of the opinion that this is not a good investment. These Wanderers are heavily baked into the Arc Survivor system and without that they are just a shadow of what they should be.

Goth arrives with two rare gear cards, a Common Katana and the Rapture Bracelet. The Katana is a solid (2/6+4) weapon that cancels all Failure reactions as long as you do not have any noisy gear (so business as usual). The Rapture Bracelet is a head accessory that gives you a second slow attack with a melee weapon once each round. This item is the really good one, though only Goth can use it for as long as she is alive in your settlement, while she has it it really leans into the aggression that is a signature characteristic of Amy's and it also has zero downside if later combined with powerful slow weapons (or Frenzy related antics).

There are two innovations which are unlocked during Goth's story, one of which is especially nasty as it doles out the Irradiated impairment. That's not in the Online Glossary at time of writing, but the text is:

Irradiated: Unseen illness. During the Update Timeline step, before settlement events are drawn, roll 1d10. On a 5 or less you succumb to radiation poisoning. Dead.

Irradiated also appears in the Nukealope vignette, so I'll cover it in more detail there, for now I'll note that you'll probably end up wanting to run the Nukealope in some campaigns with Goth because that offers a tool to handle this otherwise settlement killing situation. It's also a bit more thematic as they both share this radiation based mechanic.

Goth's Philosophy and associated knowledge is very much in homage of Zombicide. I want to note how pleased I was to see The Cure referenced in the rank titles. Pictures of You is a song I learnt to play on guitar when I was younger, and the album that is from Disintegration is an incredible reference given Goth's circumstances. The Adrenaline knowledge adapts the levelling up system from Zombicide by having the knowledges advance via wounds and gradually unlocking more and more once per showdown options for extra activations, moves and even an all round general buff at the fourth level. The artwork on Adrenaline is also great, with each piece being unique and showcasing Goth fighting more and more Spiderlings until she's attacking a Spidicules in the final level. I haven't figured out if the appearance of Spidicules on this is related to Goth's story, or if it is just showcasing how useful Adrenaline and Goth might be in that showdown due to the Bracelet and Knowledge.

However, Goth's neurosis and various abilities/impairments make for a difficult Wanderer to employ, she departs at 0 armor points and when she returns she kills a survivor. In addition, she gets an additional 'life' each lantern year and on the second death she returns to the settlement with a disposition loss. Also she has unique Courage/Understanding Milestones, Courage being very good for her to gain and Understanding being bad for her personally. So not only are you hoping to manage her disposition but you also need to consider what to do about her understanding.

There are a bunch of little tricky points to navigate in this, but the biggest hurdle is her neurosis that has her causing -1 population on return. Goth turns up in LY4, and the benefit Wanderers all typically offer is they provide a little population boost. This can be really helpful for young settlements because population is one of the key pillars of success, starting with a good population number, pushing hard to keep that number going up (typically over 20 is what I prefer, enough depth to suffer losses without hitting a hard death spiral and not too many to manage) these are all things which matter a massive amount to a new settlement. Goth's early arrival is a blessing for exactly one hunt, after that she gains enough hunt XP (Goth has veteran for +1 Hunt XP, something shared among Wanderers to keep their stories brisk) to unlock her philosophy, knowledge and neurosis. I've found that is the moment where you are best off benching her, you now have the Knowledge in your deck and you can level it up on other survivors. Eventually you may have enough population to manage Goth's negative and she can be unbenched, but letting her complete understanding in a Graves settlement is something that needs to be avoided.

Final Thoughts

Goth is my least favourite of the four new Wanderers, though I do still prefer her over Luck because she turns up early which is a better spot for Wanderers as it increases exposure to them while also allowing them to really benefit settlements.

She is mostly detrimental to the settlement, which is deeply thematic, but it also can make for an unpleasant player experience due to the population pressures she piles on. There is a lot to like about the thematics here, the entire story is well crafted and the mechanical theming is on point. However being a thematic slam dunk doesn't mean you are also a great game experience.

For myself Goth is just too finicky to navigate and she's not helping the early game out in ways that I need. She does bring a lot of offensive firepower into the game, but that comes at the cost of an incredibly delicate resource (early population) and I found it hard to justify using her.

This is in contrast to other Wanderers who also have really well crafted stories, but they are (mostly) positive contributions to the settlement rather than the mixed trending towards negative bag that Goth represents. I think that you're better off picking up Candy & Cola, Death Drifter and Aeneas to supplement your Arc Survivor/Gambler's Chest experience. Though for players who have the experience to manage the negatives and enjoy making their game harder, Goth is a great option.

At time of writing Goth was not on the Kingdom Death Store. Wait for her to appear there if you do want her, she is not worth paying secondary market prices.

Files

Comments

Sentinel

It feels very boring and too meta/exploity to me to want to actually do, but wouldn't she be straightforwardly powerful and actually help with population quite a bit if you just kept her in the settlement and let her tank bad events that require a person to die? Tank the atnas/braal events, hand aftermath, free pariah weapons, etc

Fen

I think you could do something like that, but it's certainly I wouldn't want to spend money on buying given that population isn't that hard to generate if you can roll better than I do on average!