The Lion God III: The Carrot (aka Rewards) (Patreon)
Content
Post Mortem on the expansion: here
Showdown Analysis: here
We've now looked at the Lion God as an overall entity, its position in both the mythos and the mechanical. So all that is left is to understand the carrot part of the expansion, the rewards - because what keeps a player returning to an expansion over and over is the carrot. Some monsters are too much stick, insufficient carrot (Spidicules, Lion Knight, Phoenix) while others are giant carrots with small sticks (Screaming Antelope, Flower Knight, The Hand, Manhunter); but the expansions that get it right, the ones with a fine balance between stick and carrot (punishment and reward) are the ones that trend to the top of the tier lists and become the most beloved. The Dung Beetle Knight, Sunstalker, Slenderman and Gorm are prime examples here.
The Lion God is altogether too much stick and not enough carrot, and to bring home why this is the case, we will take a look at its rewards and discuss the use of them here. This is not to say that the rewards are universally bad, they are not, but they are not worth the cost you put into getting them - and as you will see, the risk reward for the various levels is also not equal. For the exact breakdown of what you get at each level, see the Showdown Analysis article, I will be referring to it here.
The Buckets
The Basic Bucket
The Lion God cannot be critically wounded for resources, this is a huge detriment in its position as a quarry monster because most quarry monsters generate around 10-25% of their rewards via resource based critical wounds. Missing out on that means that your target should have higher core rewards, however the Lion God does not have a resource deck, so it only produces basic resources and iron. Given that the L1 Lion God is roughly equivalent to the L2 Phoenix, one would expect it to be dropping 10-12 resources and scaling up from there. It drops 8+1 Iron, then 10+2 Iron and 12+3 Iron. So for the first level, given that Iron is worth roughly 3x Scrap, this is a fair reward. But it is not exciting and it certainly is not going to entice you in for a repeat of the L1 fight.
The White Lion Bucket
The second bucket is the White Lion armor based bucket. This bucket of 4 items (1 from the Sinkhole, the other three are L1, L2 and L3 rewards) are designed to be attached to the White Lion set and 'upgrade' it to overcome the drawbacks of the White Lion Armor/Dagger/Katar setup.
The Necromancer's Eye is the L1 reward and it is clearly very much worth. A head accessory that ignores blind (even double blind) and has a 33% stronger version of the Cat Eye Circlet is a great reward for beating the L1 Lion God. However the L2 reward, the Golden Plate, which gives extra armor at the cost of evasion (attached to a hefty affinity requirement) is not at all near what you would expect when you compare it to the Eye. The L3 Reward, which is the Lion God Statue is even worse, it is a straight swap of -1 evasion for +x strength.
Now evasion is not important for a good DPS player because they should not be the target in the first place, but the sheer amount of red affinities required for these items makes them hard to stomach (outside of People of the Sun, where they shine).
Finally we have the Necropolis reward, the Ancient Lion Claws, these can be collected from the L1 Lion God and they come with the Lantern Mehndi (while also referencing either the Golden Enitity, Lost Knight, Lion God Civilisation or the Gold Smoke Knight - we're not sure which yet, it could be multiple of these, it's well written). This item overtly seeks to make the White Lion set stronger.
However, the issue with all of these items is this, they take up room on your gear grid, 3-4 spots to be precise, and with White Lion Armor already taking up 5 slots and the need for a dagger, a lantern (late game) and/or a support item. You just can't make it work well. The grid is overloaded. Just look at this:
That's a single Katar, no Necromancer's Eye and it's honestly still not a very good build.
That is because, ultimately, this reward bucket falls off into irrelevance the moment you get the Necromancer's Eye. It is trying to put a band aid onto an already irrelevant part of the game - White Lion Armor.
However, if I was going to fix this, this is how I would do it.
As is absolutely obvious without writing it here, but apparently I have to. the Outfit rule would be changed as well to accommodate this change.
I have moved the Claws and the Breastplate into the armor/outfit category (instead of item/accessory), so now they are worn instead of the relevant White Lion pieces. The 'Gains Pounce' shorthand is allowable in KDM design (see the Oxidized Ring Whip/Provoke) and the abilities of the pieces are kept. Now you can replace the arms and body on the White Lion set with straight upgraded versions, this turns the White Lion Set into a 5 armor on all locations armor set, with additional strength when attacking and an improved pounce (at the cost of -2 evasion). If you look at the grid above, you can see that the layout would stay exactly the same, but you would free up spaces 3 and 9 (top right, bottom right) and you could even run the hooked claw knife in slot 8 (moving the skirt into 9).
For the record I don't think the Lion God statue needs changes to its design at all, it's exactly fine as it is and it works well, it is just shit as an L3 reward. Beating that monster should be worth more than this, even if it is a very good strength boost.
This Bucket peaks in strength at L1.
The Necromancer Bucket
This final bucket is the most interesting of the three buckets, the journey is begun when you beat the L1 Lion God and get access to the Knowledge worm. Eventually this will result in a Necromancer being created, and this class is very different to the normal survivor. Instead of using armor (which they can do) the Necromancer can instead choose to don multiple Mehndi and gain protections via that manner.
There are also two other Mehndi in the game, the Boss Mehndi (Screaming Antelope/Stone Circle) and the Gloom Mehndi (Slenderman). However they are not symbols for some reason, hopefully this is fixed in Campaigns of Death.
Needless to say, access to all these affinities, not wearing armor, being able to automatically open Lion God strange resources without dying, having a different serious injury chart and all the other neat little things these mehndi do is a very interesting proposition. However, Necromancers are more fragile than normal survivors, having a flat 30% chance to die from most "unspecified" severe injuries (i.e. not headhunter) and not benefiting from things like Tough does not help this. But, you do get access to armor points that can be stacked with something like leyline walker or the Speaker Cult Knife, which is not to be underestimated too much.
Ultimately, to get access to this build in its full, unfettered form, you are going to have to brave the L3 Lion God, because that is the only place where the Death Mehndi can be collected. Again, if you are able to beat the L3 Lion God, then the Death Mehndi and +5 armor points for your necromancer is not going to improve your position, so you've achieved this for no gain.
This is not to say that the Mehndi are bad, far from it, they are unique and powerful, especially the Lantern, Bone Witch and Butcher's Blood ones. The Bone Witch and Butcher's Blood fuel exceptionally powerful strategies in particular. It's just, these are better used elsewhere rather than being lumped together onto one fragile survivor who occasionally pukes up iron.
This bucket peaks in strength at L2, however there is a 10% chance on the table that you can get the L2 stuff from the L1 Lion God. This becomes higher with OWL and Heiroglyphs.
You can also just use the various resources for crafting, they are mostly scrap and some of them are iron, bone or hide. Bit of a waste, but if you don't want the Mehndi then you might do it.
Summary
What does this meeeeeean?
Well, if you are going to just take the minimum number of passes at the Lion God and then move on to other content, you will fight the L1 once and the L2 once before stopping. There is diminishing returns after that and the L3 is not worth the increased risk - you're only getting 1+ extra iron, some more basic resources and potentially 2 extra rare items. That's not tempting enough considering how dangerous the L3 Lion God can be.
And this is the crux of the matter! The Lion God is very dangerous for the unprepared, and never safe even for the most careful of players. It can suddenly eliminate a survivor with an Earthquake and the design of the monster demands that you AI manipulate it multiple times a turn, which is a completely un-fun way to play. Even things like the L3 DBK don't require multiple sets of monster manipulation per turn (unless you want to).
So, after all this, we come back full circle to my initial recommendation. Hunt the L1 once, hunt the L2 once and then move on. If you do insist on farming the Lion God, the L1 has the best risk to reward ratio (if you stack OWL + Heiroglyph readings to try and max the chances of hitting the Catacombs (third level of the Necropolis).
Shame really.