Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Content

Hello folks! Secret video time.

Spoiler warning for the recent odyssey movie, also content warning for various people being transphobic and racist.

ty ty

Files

Odyssey Outrage - backer video

Thanks folks! Lots of transphobia in this one, fair warning. & bigotry of other kinds also languagejones video: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=xOQCgj7FQoU

Comments

Alex

It's a Shaun video! Spoiler warnings feel kind of... I want to say... Typical? Essential? Typissential?

TRocks

Hello, and thank you.

Alex

Ah yes, the explosion of anger over casting a mythical woman from a legend with... A black person.

Mike Blackney

As a long time closeted Nolan apathy-ist I can see good reason already to keep this on patreon

lindamacintosh_

2 shaun videos within a couple months? you’re spoiling us

Izzy Killeen

You spoil us, Shaun! Love it, thanks so much 😊

TRocks

Also, This is a BANGER. you should put it on YouTube eventually for the “poors”. 😉

Karissa

the streams where we chatted about the odyssey were a genuine delight and i’m so glad this video is real, even if it’s secret. thanks shaun

Alison Ludwig

Mmm two things I love, The Odyssey and Waffles

Kinetics Video

Really lost it at the conservative slop reviewers not even attempting to read any significance into the armor, there.

MadTwiggy

Ah yes, I prefer the original Odyssey by Homer published as a hardcover book in 1985. I haven't read it yet, but I've got thoughts!

Olly

There are dozens of us. I have tried to enjoy his movies, watching Dunkirk and Interstellar to their dreary conclusions & his Batman films. I gave up on Inception maybe 10 or 15 minutes in due to the frequent rug pulling used as a proxy for plot. Of the Nolan films I've seen, all are "Curate's Egg"s: Any good parts of the respective films are also deeply compromised by the bad parts. His Batman trilogy is the absolute epitome of this i.e. it sums up to almost nothing. It's possible he's made some gems I missed but his name attached to a film is a rather dull reddish-brown flag.

Athina

Just checked the bfi imax bookings, sold out until the last available screening - Oct 1st. I'm not one for box office numbers but it will be lovely to see it break 2B (at 1.6 now).

Ctolm [the t is silent]

Real blast from the past seeing the Black Pigeon Speaks appearing in a Shaun vid. I am glad you didn't actually play any clips of him.

Ronin Fredricson

I think *MY* first reaction to hearing about Christopher Nolan's The Odyssey this spring and hearing about the various "historically inaccurate" castings of minorities like Eliott Page and Lupita Nyongo was that it almost felt a little... cruel? To them? Like it would be attention-grabbing while pretty much guaranteeing them to be hit with an absolute barage of abuse. And that if the movie HAD failed, IF it was a shit movie, it would be blamed on them. But at the same time, they're adults. They're not unknown actors desperate for their big break, unknowingly lead to slaughter. They're surely QUITE aware of what kind of attention they'd get from certain kinds of people. And they could have said no if they weren't confident it was worth it and something they could handle. And ultimately I think it WAS the right choice, for them AND the movie.

Draenog

Yum yum, an Odyssey waffle for breakfast

Victoria Borges

I've always felt so alone as a Nolan disliker, I'm so glad Shaun has brought us all together

Ειρηνη Σταμπορη

When, by the way, it is most likely there were black people in Greece at the time☠️. Crete is closer to Egypt and Libya than it is to Thessaloniki. I’m Greek, and during history in school it was always understood that black people were involved with Greece, one way or the other. I mean, not to use it as a positive example, but the slave class in the Spartan class system «Είλωτες»/“ìlotes” were often black… That class mostly consisted of prisoners of war, and they were -rarely but that’s extra information on an already way too long comment- allowed freedom. So i don’t really know why we are acting like Greece was some kind of white only nation… Edit: Just finished watching and I see Shaun brought this point up

Katherine Jennings

Can I just say that I really dislike it when people disparage films that heavily use CGI as "slop"? Yes, good practical effects and location shooting will generally look better and be harder to pull off but implying CGI effects work is just mindless slop that doesn't require large amounts of skill, effort and time is really insulting to the people that work in that field.

Klaus Morals

A woman who is canonically a human-swan hybrid born from an egg. And a trans man as Achiles, who in roman writings (Statius) was living as a woman on Skyos under the name Pyrrha when Odysseus came to recruit him to the war. Remember the movie Troy when we meet Brad Pitt in a skirt and bellytop? That was meant to be that scene.

Richard Carrier, Ph.D.

Fun fact: apropos your armor section, The Odyssey (and Iliad) have sections where the bronze arms and armor are suddenly intermixed with iron tools, arrowheads, and axes. Which is one of the reasons historians know that neither was written by a single person (Homer is a fictional post hoc nom de plume), but composed across so many centuries that it started being written in the bronze age and finished in the iron age. So the Odyssey itself is not historically consistent as to which metal things could be made of, much less movie adapters. But also, the giants in the original story didn't wear armor at all, so it's funny to see them complain about what kind of armor alien monsters might have, and not complain that they have any at all, the only actual contradiction with the "original text."

Kithara

I don't agree with Shaun’s representation of Emily Wilson's critical review of Nolan's Odyssey, An Uncomplicated Man. You can read it here: https://www.lrb.co.uk/the-paper/v48/n14/emily-wilson/an-uncomplicated-man In short, her main take on it is that Nolan has flattened out the character. Some of his most salient characteristics have been eliminated: - his tendency to storytelling - having prodigious amounts of sex with all kinds of women - his desire for glory These live alongside the weeping and the piety. Nolan characteristically creates one- or two-dimensional men, but we can be grateful for Circe, certain to be nominated for an Academy Award, as is likely Antinous's character, which Wilson characterizes deliciously as slimy and "The only one seeming to have fun on the set" I especially enjoyed her explanation of the character of Sinon being lifted from Virgil's Aeneid and that the Romans had reasons therefore to despise Odysseus. Finally, there is this delicious passage I'll quote at length: Perhaps more surprising from the director of Oppenheimer, Damon’s lummoxy Odysseus also seems to lack technological intelligence (polymēchania). He does not build a marriage bed out of a tree growing in his house (it would be a waste of effort, since he so rarely seems to sleep or have sex). The raft on which he escapes from Calypso is cobbled together from a few bits of driftwood (in contrast to the elaborate wood-chopping and shipbuilding in Homer). We don’t see the design or construction of the Trojan Horse; instead, a kitsch, poorly designed horse (with no wheels) appears on the windswept beach as if dumped there by drone. The difficulties of transporting large, unwieldy objects over difficult terrain must have been on the director’s mind as he lugged his IMAX cameras through the film’s many challenging locations.

Finn L'e

Lovely video (though I now regret spoiling the movie for myself). As an Italian, I feel the urge to mention that "Scipio" is pronounced "sheep-yo" and not "skeep-yo".

David Langrock

Memento and The Prestige are each amazing films. Not a big fan of anything else he's done -- though I don't particularly dislike his other films. They aren't anything as shit as Marvel Universe slop, for instance.

Emil Lindevall

i do think if this was a bit more structured it would make for a great "the fake outrage" video, think you should consider that in my opinion

Tasty3141

The word slop means lazy. Good CGI just like good use of AI or good use of plastic surgery even if notable in that you don't notice it and it feels natural. CGI slop is CGI that feels fake and takes you out of the movie instead of exciting you.

Katherine Jennings

Yes, I understand the distinction, but the way some people talk, and the way Shaun phrased it here, implied disdain for *all* CGI, which is what I take issue with.

sasha

you said it all of course, but also, I find it rich that they think Odysseus was a cry baby in this movie, seeing as Matt Damon basically had a singular expression of concerned bewilderment on his face for the entire performance

Izzy Killeen

I'm afraid I have to out-autism you and point out that Shaun is approximating the Classical Latin pronunciation where a C is always /k/.

Kat

If I could pick one promise for Elon to actually follow through on it would be the solving world hunger one, but I agree that lazily prompting an LLM to make a terrible movie is far more likely to occur.

dämonenfürst666

Yep this was absolutely worth the two dollars thanks shaun

Luke

I don't know how much quicker this video was to make than a normal one, but I enjoyed it basically as much as any of your others. So if it was relevantly easier then I say it's a good trade-off and I'd love to see more videos like it

Celozon

I started listening to the audiobook version of the Emily Wilson translation of the Iliad and the Odyssey and she actually discusses at length in the Iliad about how its not historically accurate (sometimes using steel weapons, etc), how the men are constantly crying (and how that wouldn't have been seen as weak or feminine), how it is a story with flaws, and essentially just pointing out that we shouldn't be expecting the story to reflect our modern sensibilities. I just find it interesting that evidently these complaints have been going on about the original stories for years, I suppose its not really surprising that a modern retelling that is trying to stay true to the core of the original would end up in the same boat.

gustavo h m álvares

Oh man, I was FUMING when I watched Tenet. I was actually so mad at the movie and its verbose moroseness, the guy-comes-in-and-sits-down-to-talk-talk-talk nature of the film. That movie was so bad it made me reevaluate how I felt about all his other movies before, and it made me a better person for demanding more from the entertainment I spend my precious little free time with.

some kind of gay cryptid

Sinon, not Achilles. But yeah, there’s still no reason he couldn’t have been trans in the context of the movie. And regardless of if the character is trans or not, he’s a man played by a man, so what’s the issue?

some kind of gay cryptid

Especially since Greece *isn’t* white, at least not Anne Hathaway/Matt Damon/Tom Holland white. Celts, Norsemen and Gauls certainly *could* have made their way to ancient Greece, but I don’t imagine there would have been very many of them. (Plus, whiteness is a made-up concept anyway; Greeks and Italians and Irish and Spaniards weren’t considered ‘white’ in the US till pretty recently, and those with darker skin still basically aren’t!) I think the only valid ethnicity critique of the movie is that there were no actual Greeks in it!

Puketapu

Oh Shaun. All your videos are hilarious but this is just so funny. Thank you

Shred Cadmium

I clicked dislike on Nolan's first-look Einstein trailer and he remade the entire film to be about I dunno Robert someone