Lawyer's Perspective On The Injunction (Patreon)
Content
This was lifted from Aespann Jeans, Tokkis' mortal enemy on X.
Lee Jin-ho: Some people say it was a brilliant move (a “divine move”), what do you think?
Lawyer Kim Kyung-nam: I don’t think so at all. It looks more like the worst possible move.
Lee Jin-ho: There’s an opinion in some quarters that if HYBE sues NewJeans, it will lead to a breakdown of trust. Is that true?
Lawyer Kim Kyung-nam: A lawsuit is the last resort for a citizen to claim their rights. Just because someone is asserting their rights doesn’t mean the trust relationship is necessarily broken.
Lee Jin-ho: In the case of a “declaratory judgment” (확인의소), can there be a breakdown of trust?
Lawyer Kim Kyung-nam: A declaratory judgment essentially confirms that since there is an exclusive contract, they cannot engage in activities elsewhere. If they violate this, the court would decide on a certain amount of compensation per day or per violation.
Lee Jin-ho: What happens if NewJeans ignores this and continues activities elsewhere?
Lawyer Kim Kyung-nam: They would have to pay damages. If NewJeans doesn’t fulfill their activities or performs elsewhere, ADOR (the company) can claim monetary damages based on past net income. There’s also a separate penalty clause (calculated as [previous two years of sales] x [remaining months]).
Lee Jin-ho: What is the probability that NewJeans could win in court?
Lawyer Kim Kyung-nam: About 1% to 2%. (Judges are human, so I can’t say 0%.)
Lee Jin-ho: It seems like this could become an important precedent for future entertainment agencies.
Lawyer Kim Kyung-nam: Rather than having some special significance, it would likely be a case that just reaffirms something that should be obvious.