Game Design: The Purpose of Difficulty (Patreon)
Content
The difficulty of a game serves two purposes. First, it encourages engagement and poses a challenge. Dark Souls is the perfect example of this, it's a painfully difficult game, and because of that beating it feels like it has value. This can be undermined when you're defeated because of something out of your control or something that was poorly presented. Dark Souls feels like an amazingly fun, challenging game; until someone stabs you through a wall and knocks you off an edge. Then it feels like bullshit, because the game cheated to beat you.
Second, difficulty serves to change the pace of the game. In a real time strategy game a mission might be difficult because resources are limited. With limited resources, the player has to make slow, careful decisions to make the best use of them. StarCraft is a good example of this. Different levels have different amounts of resources, and can produce very different experiences even though the core mechanics of the game are the same. A map that provides plenty of easily defended resources encourages you to attack often, trading those resources for units. With fewer resources you're encourages to buy upgrades, making the most of the units you're able to build.
So where does that leave Lab Rats? We want to try and set it at a difficulty that achieves both of the above goals: It feels satisfying to complete, and sets an appropriate pace for the game. Lets start by looking at our first goal, making it satisfying to complete successfully. To do this we'll want to make sure that the gameplay throughout the game appears fair, which is achieved by making as much information available to the player as possible, and presenting it in the most easily absorbed way. This will require tweaks and additions to the UI as we go forward, but shouldn't require any special consideration beyond that.
Second, we want the difficulty to set a pace through the game that is fun. Before we can do that, we need to figure out what kind of pace seems like it will be the most enjoyable for the player. I'm going to make the following assertions about a play through of an ideal version of lab rats.
1) It is possible to "fail" and receive none of the good endings if you aren't trying. Just clicking randomly through the game should not grant success.
2) A player who is engaged by the game and attempting to make well informed decisions should be able to get one girl to 100 influence or higher by focusing on them without any knowledge of the game or how it's structured. You should be able to "win" the game on your first play through if you try.
3) A new player shouldn't be able to get a perfect (100+ with all girls) ending on their first attempt at the game. A perfect ending should require planning and forethought, with some amount of experience in the game already.
4) There are multiple strategies that are viable in the game. They may not all be equally good, but they can all result in a "win" of some sort and are one is not immediately superior to another.
5) New content is presented to the player at a comfortable pace without "grinding". I've touched on avoiding that before here: https://www.patreon.com/posts/game-design-cost-7856670
So that's our goal. An ideal version of lab rats should satisfy all those criteria above. With that in mind we can start to look at the details: the influence and resistance values, the number of scenes that we want to have, ect. I'll put up another post in a few days and we'll start dealing with some solid numbers if we can.
In other news, writing for v0.7 continues to chug along. Two of the hub scenes have been written up, and the third is under way. I'm also sketching out the systems that will be added in v0.8 (the public/private) update and seeing how it will affect the current design of the game.