Game Design - Cost vs Rewards (Patreon)
Content
So, what are we looking at today? The dynamics between the Cost of something, and the Reward it gives you (Which I shall capitalize, for empahsis throughout this post). Every good game needs a trade off to make it interesting. In Mario the Cost is all the power ups you use to beat a level, the Reward is the progress you make towards rescuing the princess. In Dark Souls, the Cost are the souls you lose when you die (a lot), the Reward is the unique soul of the boss and progress in the game.
Given that Lab Rats is a porn game, the Reward is pretty straight forward. Unlock a new scene, make a girl a little sluttier, so on and so forth. Easy.
The Cost is trickier, and if you do it wrong can really screw up a good game. One common mistake is to treat the players time like the Cost. If event A gives you 2 points, and event B gives you 4, obviously event B should take twice as much time to reach. Except that by default, that sucks. There's no interesting choice to make. All of the players time should be interesting in a good game, you shouldn't have to suffer through bad parts to get to the good. This rule holds no matter how you try and phrase it. If you have to spend gold on an item, but gold is obtained by spending time on a simple mini-game, then that item really just requires you to be bored for a while. This is fundamentally why grinding in video games sucks.
So what does this mean for Lab Rats? Well, at every turn I have to make sure that the Cost for reaching a new scene isn't just your time. The current state of the serums highlight's the problem. The "best" way to play is to cycle through a ton of days, earn a bunch of money, then make as many red serums as you can.
That's going to have to be changed in v0.4, because it just isn't fun right now. Perhaps red serums will be made to have a finite limit, and the supplies have to be found through exploration. Giving the player a way to influence their income beyond just showing up for work is also going to be important. Finally, by adding more content in the game length of 120 days will come into play. That turns an out of game cost ("My ten minutes") into an important in game cost ("Two weeks closer to the end.").
What are some events that you think are repedative, with no Cost other than your time, and where do you feel like you're paying some sort of Cost for no Reward?
tl;dr - Grinding sucks, so I'm going to try and make sure Lab Rats is stripped of any meaningless repedative tasks, and replace them with meaningful choices.