Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Content

Hello everyone!

I created Patron Commission as a way to challenge myself to get out of my comfort zone and sculpt not only what I wanted, but also what my community wanted to see sculpted. Merging two awesome things. As a plus, I would be offering direct contact with the community as a way to interact.

Since I would be suspicious of judging what would be the coolest miniature to see sculpted, I let you guys decide. The Patreon poll is awesome because it opens a list of options that you guys can mark as your second, third, fourth, and so on, miniatures that you like.

I let the polls open to free subscribers, thinking that this could be a nice way to say hello to new people to know my work and help decide what miniature they wanted to see. This also opened the vote to my Tribe members; without them, I probably would have closed the doors, so I'm truly thankful.

Sadly, this only works if people are willing to play fair. Today I got complaints about a miniature getting a lot of votes in 1 day. At first, I thought nothing was wrong there; after all, it's possible.

I decided to download the results sheet and check everything with data.

The result is that we have suspicious activity:

I cannot reveal the accounts' names and e-mail addresses; this is the closest I can get. This sheet contains all account names, e-mail addresses, date of vote, and number of votes. To make everything easy, I hid all the other votes and pulled only people who voted exclusively on this miniature.

Why is it suspicious?

  • All of these are free accounts (except one); this in itself is not the reason.

  • Username: There are 3 of these accounts with the same username, meaning that this person voted 3 times, guaranteed.

  • Join Date: Many of these accounts joined on the same day as the others. But joining on the same day is not the issue by itself; if we add the fact that they voted minutes apart, it is highly likely that they were made by the same person.

Unfortunately, I cannot remove this miniature from the poll because Patreon does not let me after I publish the poll. Regardless of what the poll says, this miniature is disqualified.

With this information, I will think about what I will do from now on. I will announce my decision along with the winner's result. But things cannot stay as they are.

As mentioned by a commenter, this would create a push for other disqualifications, and it might be true. Therefore, I'm ending the poll right now with the current votes. You can see my votes, but it's the best I can do.

I don't want this to become a war of who can create more fake accounts and who can vote faster. This is the only way I can think of.

Best regards,

Ivo

Files

Comments

Jo Em

Just my two cents, disqualifying can backfire into people "vote pushing" other models to get them disqualified and increase their own chances. It sucks, but at least I wanna make this kind of manipulation visible :( But cheers for reacting so fast!

Feltyr

If I read correctly, free accounts can vote on the poll? Sorry, I was always a paid subscriber and didn’t pay attention to that fact. I don’t like this but you may need to put the poll behind a paid subscription level.

Imagine Minis

Sorry for the confusion, I just thought it would work.

Jo Em

Yeah but I kinda liked it, the reason why it is free is logical - it might generate new subs if they see a model they like gets realized. But yes, paywall seems a legit and easy way to close the pushing. And if someone is willing to create ten paid accounts to get his wish model, I sure as hell support it for Ivo :D

Jo Em

It might be cheaper to ask him what price he has to create a wish model directly though 😅

Michael S. Moran

Currently Tribe members (like me) are directed to Patreon to vote on the poll. Would it be possible to have a Triber and Patreon poll and add the results together? That might work to give both subscriber types the option to vote and also keep it secured behind a subscription

Games Played Badly

It was part of the reason I joined the Tribe (well, that, the Loyalty Reward minis, and the discount). Pity it's getting ruined by someone unable to play fairly.

Imagine Minis

Yes, it's one of the options on my mind. I don't like this because Patreon has multiple choices (that I like), while Tribes does not. But if I work with a single option, I think it will work out.

Imagine Minis

The Patron Commission will remain; the only thing is how it will work.

Carol

I appreciate the effort to keep things fair; I think this has been happening since a long time ago.

Joey D

Ooft... yeah, there is always 1 bad-actor that does something that ruins it for everyone else :( Whoever you are, poll cheater, congrats... Also... funny how even with the cheating it still doesn't pass the current top vote (the serpent form druid elf) :P But yeah... locking behind having a sub seems the simplest option. As for Tribes members... yeah, MMF only allows for single-choice polls, so it isn't ideal, but I have seen other creators hold polls on both and merge the results (with people complaining that their choice won on patreon-only results). There isn't really a great easy answer to keep it simple to manage and without arguments and the like (and no cheating...) :S

Diplomacy

I've seen this happen with other Patreons. People always figure out a way to cheat, especially on polls that are available to anyone and not just paid members.