Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Content

Hi everyone,

We wanted to provide a quick clarification regarding tiers and premium content, as there’s been some understandable confusion following recent changes.

For Detective tier members, nothing is changing in terms of the amount of content you receive.

In 2025, Detective tier members received 32 brand-new episodes.

In 2026, Detective tier members will again receive 32 brand-new episodes.

The only change is to how episodes are labelled.

Previously, some episodes were titled as “Premium Episodes.” These episodes were always released early on Patreon and then later made available on the main feed as numbered Casefile episodes, typically 2 to 4 months afterward. "Premium episodes" were never intended to imply exclusive long-term bonus only content, and we were always transparent about the fact that these "premium" episodes would eventually make their way to the main feed as a numbered episode. But this naming and release structure has caused ongoing confusion both for listeners and for us as well.

To simplify things and make the structure clearer, we’ve decided to remove the “Premium Episode” label entirely.

Going forward:

Detective tier members will continue to receive episodes one week early and ad-free.

All content remains the same in volume and quality. Only the titles have changed.

The only difference is that main feed listeners will now consistently be one week behind, rather than having every fourth episode delayed by several months.

The archive series releases are completely separate from all of this and do not count towards the 32 new episodes you will be receiving. They are purely extra content to mark the 10th year of Casefile.

We understand how on the surface it might feel like content has been reduced, but we want to reassure you that you are not receiving fewer episodes. This change is purely about clarity and consistency.

It’s also worth noting that the premium episodes were originally intended to be shorter releases (around 15–30 minute episodes). Very quickly, however, they evolved into full-length Casefile episodes, which further blurred the distinction and added to the confusion.

For these reasons, we’ve decided to retire the “Premium Episode” label entirely and move forward with all episodes released as standard numbered Casefile episodes.

If anyone needs any further clarification, we are happy to answer any questions you have.

Thanks as always for your continued support. We truly appreciate it.

Comments

Cristi Aikins

Do the rookie tier get access to patron only episodes?

Mr Chips

Thanks for the clarification! I am happy to know I am not the only one getting confused with the "Premium" vs "Patreon Picks" vs Regular Release names and numbers. I think this will be a good change to prevent listeners from thinking you are releasing duplicates. Cheers!

Casefile

Rookie tier gets access to the Behind the files/q and a. Not to the ad free one week early releases.

Amanda Perkin

Am I right in thinking the only difference is we get same as non payers just a week early? I'm still confused lol

Amanda Perkin

I feel like such a donut 🍩 Do we get any Patreon only exclusive episodes? Wont bother u again lol.

Annie G

When are you guys back? Miss you.

Cristi Aikins

I’m thinking the same. I have listened since day one and been a subscriber on and off. I joined again recently. Surely you get access to patreon only episodes. Extra ones. Old archive eps as well 🤔

MB

If you count behind the files and the q and a which frankly I’ve never been interested in, they are re releasing “premium” episodes so essentially keep paying if you want it a week early without ads - or drop a tier to miss those benefits but get access to behind the files and q/a - would have hoped for atleast a mid tier.

Louise

I second that inquiry! I understand paid tier/Patreon subscribers get the regular publicly released episodes/content, but we get it without commercials & a week earlier than the listening public) Y / N Patreon subscribers (Detective tier) get ~36 more or less) additional EXCLUSIVE/bonus episodes - but does the public feed get these same episodes, just (example - 4) weeks later (& w/ commercials? Or are the paid subscribers getting *New exclusive episodes (not an archive of episodes that are not new to us) Y/N Thank you! Love Casefile since ~ 2017!!! Appreciate what you do & the work effort required to research, fact check, write scripts, produce/edit, all on a demanding schedule! -"Cheers" from Wash DC USA!

Louise

I agree 100%!

Rosie Overell

Please keep doing what you are doing!

Annie G

Thanks for that, lovely!

Serena S Witzke

Honestly…all I care about is “ad-free”. Anything else is nice, but that’s not what I’m paying for. I’m satisfied, whatever you call the episodes, whenever they are released, and whoever has access to them.

Suicide Sauce

I'm also outside with the angry mob but just because I like to feel included

Casefile

The premium episodes were never Patreon only. They always became numbered episodes. The name "Premium episodes" is all we are removing. As it led to all sorts of confusion. So the only difference is that the standard feed previously got those "premium episodes" as numbered episodes a few months after the Patreon/Premium release. Now, they will always be only one week behind. It's very minimal difference. You still get 32 new episodes this year. As you got 32 new episodes last year. They will all now be one week early and add free, instead of 3 being one week early and the 4th being 2-3 months early. That is the only difference.

Bob Trenwith

That's pretty much all I care about. I have no interest at all in the other shows they do. But I have noticed in listening to old episodes that they introduce their ads, then immediately say 'thank you for listening to our ads'. Most of the ads have vanished.

Bob Trenwith

Thanks - this is the exact question I asked last week. Just checking though ... for the sake of that 32 episodes per year, do the multi-parters count as an episode or as multiple episodes?

Wishy Lynn

I’m disappointed as I joined last year whilst on holiday thinking there were Patreon only episodes. I won’t be renewing.

Lesley Fleming

This is the first time I’ve subscribed and looks like I’m on a rookie subscription. I don’t feel like that has given me any extra content and the locked episodes on Spotify are not unlocked. Could someone explain it to me? I feel like I’ve wasted my money.

Alex M

Congratulations on the 10 year anniversary! Nobody does it better.

Goats and a sheep Family

March 😭 I will have to self sooth with older episodes till then .. love you guys ❤️

Skippy From That Podcast

It's so weird how the consistently best true crime podcast can also consistently step on rake after rake when it comes to its own social media messaging.

Runningmarbles

Thank you Casefile, as your team has said before no true crime story should be locked away behind a paywall. Love listening and supporting — cheers to 10 years!

Danna Stumberg

Honestly I am Patreon because of how much I love the show and want to support it. I feel like you're already giving us so much and such a high quality production. Thank you and please continue the amazing work! I'll always be here!

Casefile

no problem, we have refunded that for you Lesley.

Casefile

We can't refund you on Patreon as you have been a subscriber for longer than three months. But DM us and we can make alternative arrangements. Happy to provide a full refund.

Susan Carruthers

It's perfectly clear what was meant in the original message. Some people just love to complain

Skippy From That Podcast

The premium episodes were a big selling point of the detective tier for a lot of people, myself included. Obviously we're still getting the same number of episodes now, but what I'm talking about are the consistent own-goals with *messaging*. We've had two two season breaks in a row where the final episodes were reposts. For numbering consistency I get that, but it was two rakes in the face in a row because it annoyed people both times. The casual mention in the last announcement that premium episodes are discontinued read at the time like just another devaluing of the detective tier (I would argue that it kind of is, but that's neither here nor there.) It was tossed out so casually without any prefacing and felt like a yank at the reins. Again, another rake in the face due to messaging and tone. I like Casefile a lot. It's the only true crime podcast I'm willing to pay for, but at the same time it's nice to have some acknowledgement that we *are* paying for it. They're not great at communicating in these announcements in a way that always sounds very mindful of that.

Madison Watt

Honestly I thought it was just about supporting the show and getting the episodes add free? Anything else is a bonus in my opinion, congrats on 10 years guys! You’re unreal 🫶🏼

Luke J Ellingsen

Stayed on a supported you guys during the break. As long as we keep getting these incredible cases ad free I’m in.

Mandy Hamer

I joined as a Patreon, to casefile just as they, went into their last break, this one does seem to be taking forever!!! , joined to support the show, but don’t know of any other true crime podcasts that take such long breaks. 🥲 But really love 💕 the show,and no adds, so for now I will be continuing to support. Role on March 🥳🎉 and keep up the good work ⭐️

Hilary Ciaravino

I’m consistently shocked at the negative comments on these posts. I’m a Patreon subscriber and would do it over 1000 times for the amazing show case file puts out. I pay for a story told in a great way without crazy 911 calls or distorted audio, or bizarre commentary from random hosts. Please never change.

Jonny

Been here since case 20 and you’ve brought so much enjoyment over the last 10 years. Thankyou Casefile. See you in March

Patrick

I’m not reading all of that but it doesn’t matter I’ve been here for a while and I’m not going anywhere. Hands down my favorite podcast. I love the consistent quality.

Jess Ashlee

Just came here to say Im a long time listener and huge fan! Thanks for the hours and hours of listening Ive been enjoying for so long 🔪❤️

Jays

I stumbled across Casefile in 2019 when I was looking for more information about "Mr Stinky" who had once resided in the tiny country town I was living in, Yarrawonga. It's been a whirlwind romance ever since. At that time I was very unwell and genuinely Didn't believe I would even be around 7 years later, still listening intently, frothing at the mouth for every new episode. So much has changed since 2019, including y'all, but change is inevitable, without change we cannot grow. Without growth we cannot remain in motion. (Also, please bring back the mental health/suicide warning, your last episode containing it was insanely triggering 😞)

Carly Millar

This is hands down the best podcast out there! I will happily continue my subscription even with no perks! Can’t wait for the next season to begin!

AR

the thing is that all of this makes perfect sense for the broader podcast listenership, which numbers in the millions and got a good deal out of both the pre-break release structure and the relabeling. if the issue is just that patreon patrons are getting shunted to the side, I think it's probably too early in the year to say that yet. we'll still be getting the same content, just packaged differently.

Cristi Aikins

Can you please cancel my membership and refund me. This is not what I thought I signed up for. I thought I would get access to back catalogue and exclusive episodes.

Frances

Hi, I'm very sorry but I'm still confused about the patron subscription. You recently have been releasing part ones of many older cases. Is it possible for me to access all parts of these cases on the patron level? If so how do I do it or do Ineed to upgrade? I am very technology challenged sadly. I have religiously listened to your content since your inception and have always appreciated your fair, well reseached and well narrated content. Long may you continue. Best regards Frances, Weymouth, UK.

Cristi Aikins

Casefile have you done this yet??

Casefile

Hi Cristi, yes. This is how eps will be released moving forward, and how this year has started.

Cristi Aikins

I asked you to cancel my membership and refund my money 2 months ago on this thread as I want getting what I had expected. You haven’t done this yet. Please do it

Casefile

Hi Cristi, sorry we missed this. It's best to DM us these sorts of requests otherwise a comment can get lost amongst all the other comments and notifications we get. We will look into this now for you.

Casefile

Hi Cristi, that full refund has now been processed for you. Thank you.