Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Downloads

Content

Shane drove towards a section of the highway that rose to a railway overpass, three kilometres out of the Winchelsea town centre. Suddenly, the car in front swerved around something. When Shane reached the same spot, a man leapt out from the darkness on the side of the road. Shane’s brother had taken his own life months earlier. Suspecting the man was trying to do the same, Shane was compelled to pull over.

Team:

Anonymous Host - narration

Erin Munro - research, writing

Milly Raso - research, writing, creative direction

Mike Migas - production, music

Andrew D.B. Joslyn - music

Files

Comments

Martina Tyers

I’ve never heard this before, and it is truly heartbreaking 💔 and to think, that poor mother has suffered abuse from strangers. There is absolutely nothing she could ever have done to that poor excuse of a man! To make him do such an horrific act, the only person to blame is him!! May those beautiful babies rest in peace 🙏

Mine du Plessis

This episode. Urg. I've read about this case in a psychology book. Breaks my heart every single time

Nicole Reyment

I live in Geelong, I’m not sure I can listen to this one :(

Cathy

Can‘t believe this story

B-randy D

Can someone down under explain the dam to me? Or a dam in general? In my mind I see a dam in a lake holding back the water., is that the same type of thing in this story?

Jon Maynes

A dam is just a small body of water dug into a paddock usually as a water source for livestock.

B-randy D

Thank you!!! I was thinking it may have something to do with irrigation or livestock

Melskiwana

Tragic. And the abuse Cindy copped from some, as if she must have caused Robert to murder their kids - despicable. A man would never be subject to victim blaming like that if roles were reversed. Great ep thanks Casefile.

hotbagels

it was fantastically written. the cold open had my mouth hanging wide open while gardening. glad she got that grave plot legally moved is all I can say. poor woman. the killer is especially whiny and detestable. it's hard to think of one you've profiled I dislike more off the top of my head and I've heard each episode.

hotbagels

nuclear family with a healthy outward appearance unknowingly adjacent to the depths of evil that men do. there is something horrific about that and it almost embodies that idea behind Twin Peaks of "what would make someone commit murder?" but instead of being possessed by evil spirits from black lodges, this man is driven solely by the intent to cause maximum damage using revenge to restore his pride.

Zana

Rosie Overell

Helen Garner’s book ‘this house of grief’ is brilliant on the kind of failed masculinity that led to this horrific crime

Rosie Overell

As kids we were always taught how quickly you can drown in a dam. They get deep very fast

Rosie Overell

All that resentment .... condensed in the repeated signifier of ‘the good car’

Maya George

Oh, I know this story, if it’s the one I’m Thinking of 💔💔💔💔

Nicci Foster

I think you'd call it a pond.

John Stoeckel

I have to say that this podcast is brilliantly written. The handling of telling these stories of depravity yet delivering a powerful message about humanity is what sets Casefile apart. I’ve scaled back on other true crime that seems to wallow in shock value of the crime without doing the hard work of investigating or any assemblance of storytelling.

Melskiwana

Well put, totally agree.

Haley

I’ve never gotten so emotional over a case that it made me cry, but this one had me crying about 20 minutes in. Great episode handled with care.

Brenda Wells

Reminds me very much of the Susan Smith case in the US in the 90s, and yeah, nobody blamed her ex-husband or her boyfriend that I remember.

Jon Maynes

It seems really strange that you'd avoid an episode for geographical reasons.

Nicole Reyment

1. Because cases involving children are particularly hard to listen to and 2. Because I live where this happened, this case hits close to home