Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Content

Today I finished the re-read of Hoard I've been doing to get myself ready to return to writing it. That took longer than it should have because I've been mired in a depressive episode all week and having a lot of trouble with concentration, but I seem to be starting to come out of that as of today, and now I'm all caught up.

Honestly, this was...disheartening.

I can't recall ever feeling so overall negative about something I've written. If this were a draft and not a serial I'd throw out most of the last ten chapters or so (at least) and re-work it all from the ground up. It just doesn't feel like Hoard after the point where Kaln and the gang come back from their pilgrimage.

It's hard to put my finger exactly on what's gone wrong, I just have the overwhelming sense that something extremely did. It feels like the story is losing cohesion, forgetting what story it is; it's unfocused and feels forced and fundamentally unsatisfying. Like filler, a lot of the time.

There are highlights: I continue to be happy with Percy's scenes and particularly her growing relationships with Pheneraxa and Izayaroa. Zhiiji has proved a good addition to the cast and I'm delighted with her contributions. The Boisverd plotting...is doing what it needs to, structurally. Kaln's scenes have all become weaker in a way I cannot quite articulate.

I've obviously got more work to do than I expected to fix this. I'm going to take the rest of today, tomorrow, and the weekend to work, either on figuring out how to fix Hoard or pivoting to another project to give myself more time on it. I'll be applying myself to these problems all weekend and by Monday I'll know what's the most viable option.

Meanwhile, Hoard fans, I would really like to hear your thoughts. What are you enjoying about the story, and more importantly, what are you not? Don't worry, I'm not writing by committee; I will always write the story that I want to write. But in my whole career as a serialist, reader feedback has proven very helpful to me in sussing out the areas where I need to focus my attention. When the core problem I'm having is that something has gone badly wrong and I just can't nail down what, outside perspectives would be very helpful.

I'm really sorry about this, gang. I always want to bring you all the very best stories I can, and I feel more disappointed and frustrated with myself over this than I ever have over needing to take time off - and a lot of you know that's really saying something.

Looking forward to hearing from you. One way or another, I'll have something new (and hopefully good) soon.

Comments

Seth

To start, all you work is great you are, imo, one of the best web serial authors to do it. That being said i agree that this one has started to lose focus a bit after the pilgrimage. I dont have any advice i just wanted to say that i believe in your ability to get it back on the track that you want.

AllenR

I haven't noticed any unravelling myself, but perhaps a bit of character/plot sprawl? It isn't problematic now, but there has been an increasing amount of screentime for multiple side characters. I have seen this get out of hand with other authors to the point the main story is ignored in favor of new characters/plotlines that should have had their own book instead.

Webwoven

I'm certain this is an unhelpful thing to hear, but simply put, there is nothing you've put in Hoard that I don't like. I love the comfy shit, I love the flirty shit, I love Percy and Kaln, I love all the dragons, I love the politics with Izzy and Boisverd. If I had to, gun to my head, pick a few things I didn't find quite as interesting, it would all be small things; stuff like the short conversations on the technicalities of magic, but even then, if I view that as setup to something that's just not yet had its payoff, then I love it all the same. I may be strange in this way, but I tend to like *authors* more than *books*. I love everything that you write because, on a micro level that transcends any specific work, I like your writing. The one, sole thing that I like less from your work, same as with *any* work, is just setup that is currently without payoff, and simply put, you're good enough at payoff that I sort of don't care about the slower setup-y parts. That is the case with every author whose work I read; if I didn't feel that way, I wouldn't read your works, and as someone who's read TGAB in whole three times over and can specifically point out the ways in which it has changed me, I most definitely do read you works. I love your art and you are an unambiguous net positive on the world around you. That's not contingent on you writing a chapter a week, it simply is the case. Do what you need to do to keep yourself healthy. If that involves re-writing ten chapters, I'm game; if that involves a pivot into producing a porn game on steam, I'm still game.

Dan B

I'm enjoying the story, especially the parts that involve Kaln! I'm not tired of Percy, but it does feel like the "someone unexpectedly does something nice for Percy" scene has been done several times in close succession, and maybe we might want to see a different aspect of her in future chapters. (sorry I posted earlier and then deleted it; Patreon does post-on-hitting-enter and I was not expecting this)

Chris Phoenix

Hoard is doing a whole lot of things at once. Many of them interact well. Some of them go in different directions. If you wrote a chapter when you were focused on prosocial modeling or character development, and when you read it you're feeling more interested in world-building and plot, that chapter may seem really off-topic. There have been a few times in Hoard where I was less interested - the political machinations of the cat-people don't grab my attention - but it's part of the story, and it will likely be an important plot point later, so I'm not complaining. I suspect that if you list all the things you've been doing with Hoard, you'll be surprised at how much you've accomplished, and maybe pleasantly surprised at how well it hangs together. Here's my partial list off the top of my head: World-building - dragon psychology, continent-scale politics, history Pro-social modeling - Izayaroya's empress-ness, Percy, Kaln, the desert goddess, and how they interact with each other and the world Harem - dragon psychology, character development, problems encountered and solved Mystery/suspense - what are the cat-people doing, anyway? Slice of life - especially Kaln and Izayaroya hanging out in the town, details of cooking, quirky enjoyable minor characters Good vs. evil - the lingering effects of Atraximos As I said, many of these "play well together" in the story. I'm _not_ recommending you ruthlessly prune the list! Just use it for perspective on what you've been up to, and what you want to be up to in the next chapters.

Too Much Sanity May Be Madness

I hadn't noticed anything wrong with recent Kaln chapters, but since you tell me there is something wrong and ask me what it is... What's the next step for Kaln? I don't mean setting up a kitchen or making sure Percy is settled in. What I mean is: he has phenomenal cosmic power and he's pissed off a god of vengeance. What is his next active step towards becoming who he needs to be to survive? Not just generic experimentation and improvement: what is his next *goal*, godling-wise? It's okay to interrupt personal progress for a crisis or to figure out what to do next, but although the reader knows there's a bunch of shoes about to drop, Kaln doesn't, and so he feels a bit directionless at the moment. If he doesn't have one, he should be in the process of *setting* a SMART (specific, measurable, achievable, relevant, time-bound) goal. The other thing I'd say is I feel that, in a story with a single clear primary protagonist like this one, bouncing around between POV characters is one of those tempo things that should increase in frequency as we get closer to a climactic confrontation between all these characters. However, I don't get a sense that a climax is particularly imminent (especially so soon after the pilgrimage), and the story has been doing a *lot* of POV bouncing, the last ten chapters or so. All of that said, I'm still very much enjoying the ride, and had not actually noticed these things until you asked me to look for them. I hope this helps!

Conrad Wong

It's interesting to get some insight into the writing process even if you feel negatively about it! I have been enjoying it but it does feel like a bit of a lull between arcs. Or setup for the next one. We see a lot of attention being focused on Kain's family. Maybe Kain will go and *do* something about it, or maybe someone in the family will act out, because they're looking for attention, or they want to solve Percy's problems, or who knows, maybe Kain will decide to come clean about what happened, and make it everyone else's problem. As long as you're having fun with it, all will be well!

Zaeron

I have actually thought a lot about this - I, as a rule, don't like to offer unsolicited advice, but I do have lots of opinions I usually keep to myself, lol. Typical disclaimer: I'm pretty blunt and I hope I don't come off as mean, all of this is said from a place of love and enjoyment of this story. So, something I think has gone off the rails a bit is that Kaln used to um, be an active participant. He might be an uninformed active participant, or a clueless one, but he was participating. More and more that feels completely unlikely. Frankly, Kaln is surrounded by hypercompetent people who are being allowed to play to their strengths and that's really bad for the story. Kaln is only a useful, equal participant in his family when they're off balance and hit with problems they aren't well suited to solving. This makes all the upcoming threats seem lame. You are setting up a huge political threat that I don't see as threatening because Kaln is literally married to a thousand year old hyper competent dragon queen. The political threat posed by some backwater losers in a shithole kingdom on the edge of the world is simply... trivial? Oh no Percy got kidnapped and her family is freaking out - a sitcom level problem we could solve with a magic phone call, but even if we don't, there are literally 3 different dragons married to Kaln who could ALL solo the entire fucking kingdom if they had to. Oh no, the dragon king of a distant empire is interested in Kaln! If only he had an incredibly extensive support structure that included one of the most powerful dragon fighters, one of the most powerful dragon spies, and an insanely competent dragon diplomat! Surely they would....... solve... that entire problem... for him.................. oops. All of the story lately feels like trying to give the other characters room to show off how competent and cool they are and the problem is they're all so much bigger than Kaln - like story weight wise. They're all so competent and so awesome that none of the threats you're setting up seem like actual threats. You've ended up with a story where Kaln, the main character, occupies the same amount of space as the like, the funny cat who likes to cook. Can Zhiiji help with problems? Sure. Does she ever HAVE to help with a problem? No. There are 3 dragons here who can do anything Zhiiji could do better. Kaln is literally in the exact same boat. Percy and the other characters are getting so much space that Kaln is getting no space at all. The problems we're seeing set up are things Kaln seems incredibly unsuited to solve, but normally that would be fine because we'd be like okay well he's the main character he'll have to learn how to solve these. But... why would he? He's surrounded by insanely competent people who could do it better and faster. Like, what are you gonna do, remove the dragons? That's dumb. The whole story is about Kaln accidentally marrying a harem of dragons. If the only way to make Kaln cool is to temporarily divorce him from his awesome dragon harem, like...... what's the point? Especially since the core themes are family and togetherness and all that fun jazz, the odds that Kaln is going to solve the problems you're setting up by like.. soloing them... that doesn't seem likely. So instead it's increasingly likely that either Kaln will be a bystander/cheerleader while an actually cool person does something actually cool and Kaln is like "look at me I'm a dad and/or husband to these dragons, isn't that sweet" which... fair but not main character shit. Or it's going to be an ass pull where a bunch of hypercompetent dragons all get a tempoary lobotomy so everyone can get blindsided by like, the human kingdom equivalent of a pack of dumb, incompetent muppets. Basically I'm not seeing the foreshadowing for how Kaln will be the main character. I think you've given everyone else so much space to be characters that you haven't left enough air in the room for Kaln to actually seem like he's going to be the main character, and if you did, it would seem forced.

Matt Roy

As built, he's already got the avengers assembled at full power, and no avengers level opponents. And kaln... is like Hawkeye. Who isnt useless, but if you get away from political things and stealth.. he can't do a lot. Kaln's powers and skill set are politics and dragons. So a political dragon opponent is relevant, the vales are a problem kaln isnt best suited for. So as built, kaln is in the back seat anytime the vales issue is on screen. Unless he's going there personally.

Taborask

I would agree with this analysis. It's a fundamental problem with the fact that outside the talents of an emotionally supportive friend/lover/father, all Kaln's power relates purely to his control over dragons. Thus, in any narrative conflict NOT related to the dragons, he has no purpose. The established talents of his family mean there are no stakes. There's a lot of ways to pivot around that problem though. The threat of the shadow could be more salient, Kaln could discover some abilities that impact the world around him more directly, or maybe some conflicts could arise that require Kalns emotional honesty, etc.

Matt Roy

And on a writing quality, it's all solid. You've unfortunately made some structural decisions that are biting you now. And it's better to get it reigned in now. Than in the future at some point. Kaln is fascinating. There are high stakes on the line for him. We just have had several chapters sequentially of arc building. Lots going on around, lots of world building without too much info dumping. That said, it's better than I can make. I've written a grand total of maybe 2 chapters in a year. So my perspective is as a poor writer. Avid reader.

Zaeron

The biggest problem is that Izayaroa is also very good at political and dragon opponents - like really, if the family did have a big knock down drag out fight with the other dragon king, why would Kaln be the one to handle it? Like unless Izayaroa is concussed or something, she's the obvious pick. Like even the skill sets Kaln does have, there's someone else in his family with an overlapping skillset that probably fits better. And while Izayaroa is clearly willing to let him take practice runs at things, you have to think in any serious conflict she wouldn't let him bungle it up, she'd just take point and let him practice on less critical stuff. I think the story actually does better when it's not trying to have any stakes or conflict because when you remove the problem of stakes or conflict, the dynamic works great. It's only when you start putting actual threats in place that it becomes kinda obvious that Kaln is useless.

Andrew Wilcox

I went back and re-read the last 10 chapters. My observation is that this is a *big* story. It's expanded to exploring all of the *ramifications* of the death of Atraximos. And there are a *lot* of ramifications. This is fun. I'm enjoying the story. One of these ramifications is that Kaln is becoming a leader. He's spending his time helping other people become successful. This is unusual in story-telling. More typically you have a king as quest giver or the general who has troops to tell what to do. In chapter 78 Kaln did a good job helping Pheneraxa understand her attraction to Percy. In chapter 82 Kaln said to Percy "Please feel free to be the center of attention from time to time." This is weak. The tension is Kaln feeling like maybe he'd prefer not to be in the center of attention *all* the time. He encourages Percy to be the center of attention when she wants to be (which is good leadership), but does it in a way that is also obliquely complaining about his own situation. A natural consequence of Kaln's failure to address his own problem is it blowing up in the future. What don't I like? Well, this may be a consequence of my reading the story serially over time instead of reading it together, but there's enough different plot threads that I'm having trouble keeping track. E.g. we've got shadow family vertical snow walker woman headed for Dragonvale... and I guess is still walking? Chapter 81 opens in the middle of a conversation between Cora and Clarent, have I forgotten what information Cora is thanking Clarent for, or is this intentionally hidden to heighten mystery? Cora has a plot to rescue Percy which involves manipulating the Lone Wolves, so she's having people spy on them... which is why she was able to show up so conveniently to rescue them from the Shadow Guild attack? Who was hired by someone who wanted something more than information from the Long Wolves, like what? But then why didn't Cora recognize Riocco, or was she just pretending? I feel like I could use more hand-holding as a reader. Like when Kaln says "The shadow won't tell me why it's helping me" that's holding up a sign for me the reader "THE SHADOW IS A MYSTERY" and then I don't have to think very hard :-D, but as the plot has expanded I'm not clear on what is intentional plot mysteries and what I'm just confused about.

Russell Todd

I’m of the mind that it isn’t about whether or not Kaln’s household can deal with a potential threat. Ultimately this a rom com dragon harem story, so approaching it like it’s a power fantasy progression novel just doesn’t work. Some of my favorite parts of this story are when those tropes get cut off at the knees.

Laurent Jerry

Ok lets see what i got : Kaln being a good dad / good husband, POV of poeple talking about others in a wow and/or appreciative way behind their back (in other countries and in the household), Vanimax clumsily becoming more social is the cutest thing. Would enjoy Kaln doing a public splash of some sort. Would enjoy that they start building alliances with other powers, maybe some regular trade. Really think a honeymoon trip with the 2 other wives is kindda due too. Would loooove to see the ghost soldiers get more humanity due to kaln telling them of course they can get some leave and play dice or something. A secondary uncanny romance (vanimax and Zhiiji ?) would be so cute. Kaln awkwarkly coaching Vanimax would be sooo cool. Having some sort of refugees establishing a campement in dragonvale, and receving dragon gardianship by one of the kid (covertly from the others, on the down low for starters, then by the whole household) Shadrach coming to visit by himself and being soo embarrassed to admit he missed being visited. The consort starting to teach each others kids. Percy making a space/astronomy breakthrough Catching a thieft in the lair and struggling to decide what to do with him. Kaln demonstrating competance in an unexpected domain (like fighting or tactics or being a general) The household openly brutally killing people that had it coming, because sometimes you just gotta stand up to aggression, and then having to deal and process how they feel about it Haktria trying to get back with kaln would be sweet Zhiiji opening a restaurant to those who dare reach it, and having vanimax and percy do the service and verbaly ripping anyone who complains about the food or percy Vadaralshi bringing an artist love interrest set on painting/sculpting everyone Having Percy become the intellingence spymaster of the household, compiling and analysing intell reports from various source Globally transition from clueless family to a mini state with considerable power (and is arguably the way things flow to)