This is worse than I thought (Patreon)
Content
Today I finished the re-read of Hoard I've been doing to get myself ready to return to writing it. That took longer than it should have because I've been mired in a depressive episode all week and having a lot of trouble with concentration, but I seem to be starting to come out of that as of today, and now I'm all caught up.
Honestly, this was...disheartening.
I can't recall ever feeling so overall negative about something I've written. If this were a draft and not a serial I'd throw out most of the last ten chapters or so (at least) and re-work it all from the ground up. It just doesn't feel like Hoard after the point where Kaln and the gang come back from their pilgrimage.
It's hard to put my finger exactly on what's gone wrong, I just have the overwhelming sense that something extremely did. It feels like the story is losing cohesion, forgetting what story it is; it's unfocused and feels forced and fundamentally unsatisfying. Like filler, a lot of the time.
There are highlights: I continue to be happy with Percy's scenes and particularly her growing relationships with Pheneraxa and Izayaroa. Zhiiji has proved a good addition to the cast and I'm delighted with her contributions. The Boisverd plotting...is doing what it needs to, structurally. Kaln's scenes have all become weaker in a way I cannot quite articulate.
I've obviously got more work to do than I expected to fix this. I'm going to take the rest of today, tomorrow, and the weekend to work, either on figuring out how to fix Hoard or pivoting to another project to give myself more time on it. I'll be applying myself to these problems all weekend and by Monday I'll know what's the most viable option.
Meanwhile, Hoard fans, I would really like to hear your thoughts. What are you enjoying about the story, and more importantly, what are you not? Don't worry, I'm not writing by committee; I will always write the story that I want to write. But in my whole career as a serialist, reader feedback has proven very helpful to me in sussing out the areas where I need to focus my attention. When the core problem I'm having is that something has gone badly wrong and I just can't nail down what, outside perspectives would be very helpful.
I'm really sorry about this, gang. I always want to bring you all the very best stories I can, and I feel more disappointed and frustrated with myself over this than I ever have over needing to take time off - and a lot of you know that's really saying something.
Looking forward to hearing from you. One way or another, I'll have something new (and hopefully good) soon.