Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Content

I've seen some creators I respect (not talking about anyone in the comic space) starting to use AI for video scripts. As well as different aspect of the creation process. Having spoken about AI before, I thought I'd take a moment to confirm that it will never be a part of the work flow, and why I don't want to use it creatively.

I debated for a while if this was even a thing that I needed to write. I wrote a bunch of this, then stopped. Figuring that I typed it out and that was good enough. I was gonna let it sit. Trying to decide if was it just in my head because of the reveal of Hank Green using AI and there being a load of response videos. But it is bigger then that.

Not just that there are other creators who are talking about it being harder and harder to not use AI in the creation process. Or being accused or using AI if they don't. Or feeling like they are going to left behind with out it. They need to use AI to keep up. They need it to compete. They need it to be seen.

There are the AI companies positioning AI as an inevitability. Corporations are trying to incorporate AI into their workflows even if it makes no sense. Some of the graphics programs I use really push their AI options as opposed to me just going to make the thing I need to make for my day job. It's not something I'm going to be able to look away from and ignore. It's present and needs to be addressed.

For myself, I can say, I don't care about any of AI can do to "improve" things for the comic and who it reaches. Obviously, I want you to come and read. I want people to enjoy my work. It's a good feeling. But this doesn't pay my rent. I'm not trying to compete with anyone. I'm not trying to go faster. If I fall behind and become unnoticed, my feelings take a hit, but nothing else changes. I'm going to keep doing this as long as it is fun for me. There is no version of things where the money I make from doing this will motivate me to compromise my ethics.

I Like Making Things

Out of the gate a very large reason AI won't be a part of things is that I like making things. I like writing. I like drawing. I like problem solving.

If I'm using AI to generate ideas or to flesh out my prose, then I'm not writing. I want to work on my word choice. I use a lot of atypical slang. I make obtuse references to Bridgerton that no one notices. My characters will make objectively ill advised choices, if not out right bad choices, because that is where the fun of the story lurks. Small choices made by the characters that may seem innocent can expand into large consequences.

Making things, writing, drawing, planning, all engage my mind. Make me think. Give me challenges. All of that is gone when using AI.

I Want to Make it My Way

That leads to the idea that the AI is never going to mimic what ever random idea that I have in my head. I don't make logical connections. Ultimately I have an idea I want to explore. I have something I would like to say. Having AI write scripts doesn't make it faster, it takes away the thing I like to do. I like the thought process and brainstorming and putting the puzzle piece of a story together.

I Want to Improve

I'm not going to pretend I'm the greatest artist in the world, but my art is mine. And I want to improve and practice. I can't do that if I don't draw the comics. Just in the pages I've been working on when I'm writing this, we are seeing new camera angles being used. I'm trying to increase the visual language. Give a sense of place and emotions.

I draw because I want to draw and tell stories and improve and grow as a creative. I like the business aspects of this with Patreon, and growing. But this isn't a business. This is a thing I like to do and want to continue to be better at.

And I'll clarify that I want to be better at making stories and comics. Not that I want to put out better looking comics. I know that sounds weird to say. But I say it because there can always be that voice out there that says it could look better if the AI makes it. But that's not the point. That doesn't make my skills better at what I'm doing. It takes me out of it.

What If I Can't Make It Anymore

Reality is a depressing thing to think about. There will easily come a day where I won't be able to make these any more. I've had pain in my hands since I was 16. It's going overwhelm me at some point. Thankfully, so far, drawing doesn't trigger the pain.

But if I get to a point where I can't draw, there are options for the future. I can collaborate with another artist. I can just write prose. Or I can just stop making stories. And I can feel good that I've made a lot of fun stuff that I enjoyed. I will do all of those options before I even consider the idea of putting AI into the workflow.

No fun comes from me adding AI into the process. I will never use AI to make the comics or art.

Files

Comments

Hank

Love your stance! Thank you for staying committed to making things!

TrueRonin88

Living in seattle I can definitely speak a lot too the corporations moving towards incorporating AI into workflows. So many people have been laid off from the once desired tech jobs. Like there was a period of time where people think they would be safe with a nice job at like a Microsoft and then boom not true anymore. I know someone who got laid off from Microsoft only to go to another big tech company with offices here. Only to get laid off again months later. Being in healthcare I keep talking to people saying it will be interesting to see how many people from the tech space wind up going back to school and enter healthcare. And we don't really want those people there because a lot of time they just want it for the job security and not because there heart is in the work.

Roseleaf Comics

It's going to be interesting with this push and pull to see where people end up. I know my day is an area that is being pushed hard against by AI, but so far it can't do the job.

Le Post de Code

I agree with what you're saying, and I try to use AI to help me with understanding certain things. I'm massively autistic and ADHD, and have difficulty sometimes with comprehension of things. What I find AI has helped me with, is breaking up some tutorials I use (I'm teaching myself to draw/sketch again, not done it for 20 years since my school days), and explain them in a way which helps me. I'll still use the tutorial, but, sometimes, the AI wording, compared to what is written, is far easier to understand. Completely get your stance, and, its something I want to stick by.

Roseleaf Comics

It's a useful tool. I hope it continues to work well with the learning process.