Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Content

Thank you so much for all your support this month! Now's the magical time when you hit us with your HOT TAKES, UNPOPULAR OPINIONS, and TOUGH QUESTIONS; drop them down in the comments THIS INSTANT and we'll look through them all in a couple of weeks (so actually you can take your time cooking a little bit). Let's go!

In case you missed last month's episode: https://www.patreon.com/posts/lets-agree-cal-103691741

Comments

Alex Sim

how would U2's legacy be different if they had quit while they were ahead?

bressig

Are you looking forward to Drake's inevitable 40-song triple album about the Kendrick feud

Zach Stolpa

Green Day’s ā€œfather of allā€ is not as bad as you make it out to be. It may not be the deepest and most complex kind of project but on an honest level I get fun vibes from listening to the songs on it which can’t make me bring myself to truly not like the album.

Zach Stolpa

If you were held at gun point and were forced to sing a karaoke song for your freedom perfectly what would you choose?

Kyle Cahill

Lianne La Havas’s cover of Weird Fishes is better than the original

Dalton Krause

The best contemporary video game OST is LISA: The Painful. Not only is there a staggering amount of memorable songs, buts it's musically more diverse than any game OST I've ever heard. And there's a Toro Y Moi sample.

Trevor Young

Jazz lost its relevance when it got too experimental. While albums like Love Supreme and Bitches Brew were leaps forward musically -- they inadvertently set the genre on a path of self-destruction. Without "tunes" or anything you could feasibly include in a Real Book, jazz lost its commercial viability. Which in turn became a domino effect of generating less money and therefore creating less opportunities for future jazz artists. Whether it was bravado or a desire to progress musically, the jazz community became an ouroboros eating it's own tail.

crimkingson

Bush is overhated (the band, not the war criminal).

Patrick Pillow

NERD In Search of is one of the most important albums of the 2000's. It put artists like Pusha T and No Malice a major platform while infusing soul, R&B, and rock into a great amalgamation of sounds. Tyler the Creator frequently lists it as one of his favorite albums of all-time.

dvd_ynn

i may be missing something but ive been lead to believe that no discography is able to have multiple 10/10s because artists seem to outdo their previous or future efforts. e.g. led zeppelin 4 couldve been the opus if physical graffiti had never come out and pushed the boundary of ā€˜perfection’. sound of silver < this is happening is another example that comes to mind

Uncle Jam

Do you consider using your platform to pressure artists into releasing more shit irresponsible? I was listening to Beyond the Fleeting Gales the other day and thought, "Wait, where the fuck is Crying?" (Note: I'm mostly joking. I know I'm not owed music. BUT STILL--)

null

Jack Harlow is a better rapper than Drake.

gael

aphex twin predicted the campy hyperpop aesthetics by a decade with windowlicker's music video and sound and he should definitely be included in the proto-genesis of most internet music genres

MC Emerson

Eddie Vedder's vocals aren't nearly as warbly and un-enunciated as his haters seem to think. He just sings with his natural voice (listen to him talk). All the singers who tried to copy him (from Seven Mary Three, early Silverchair, fucking Creed, etc.) are the ones who ruined that style.

Maximof_

The Bridge is Over by Boogie Down Productions (BDP) is not only one of the first ever diss tracks to ever be created, but its one of the most important diss tracks ever that laid the foundation of countless other diss tracks to come out in the coming future in Hip-hop

Purajit Malalur

I'm loving Cal's resurgence. You've talked about it a bit, but does it feel like we pressured you into it? Particularly since you've been making sure to put him every video now.

Purajit Malalur

10/10s can still differ vastly. It's not about perfection (I don't think there's such a thing), more about enjoyment and the experience. You only have so many numbers, it's not meant to be a precise ranking of art, just a representation of what to expect.

Nicholas Murphy

Eric B. & Rakim ā€œDon’t Sweat The Techniqueā€ was the best rap album of ā€˜92

EZGames69

Space Laces is the greatest Dubstep/EDM producer out there at the moment.

dvd_ynn

I think the number is more about how significant the statement is contextually. Part of the reason I find that Pink Floyd's DSOTM probably sounded more impressive in the 70s than it did now was because the sound was outdone so many times. Its about the boundary pushing forward to me

Zach Stolpa

Wayne started in the late 90’s and is still going well today, that’s spanning 4 decades. That’s a level of longevity that only a select group of artists have.

SirVis

Do you think Kendrick would have another response by the next week, or will he respond with the rumored upcoming album.

Ananda Landenberg

What are your thoughts on some of the foreign albums like Bocanada by Gustavo Cerati or El JardĆ­n de los Presentes by Invisible?

Morgan

"The Infamous" by Mobb Deep is genuinely a top 5/top 3 hip hop album and i dont see enough people talking about it!! the performances and features are stellar (that tommy hilfiger line from tip always gets me), the songwriting and storytelling is visceral, and the production is fucking incredible. what more could you want from that album??

Gordocole666

I am echoing some other music journalists but I am getting tired of confessional, stream-of-consciousness lyrics, especially with singer/songwriters. I think a lot of artists use unfiltered thoughts and super personal stories as a crutch to make themselves more relatable when all it does is let us into personal life details that are either very boring or very self-aggrandizing (most recent example of this being Tortured Poets Department.) I'd much rather an artist create their own world and lore outside their personal lives. I think this is what makes songwriters like Destroyer and Jessica Pratt so interesting to listen to.

Herbieguy

The Rock and Roll Hall of Fame should be renamed / re-branded into just a general music hall of fame. That way it would both allow a larger array of artists to qualify, AND it would stop all the annoying semantic online arguments about what counts as 'real rock' or not. It's a win for everybody.

Herbieguy

I'd say there's multiple flaws with this argument. 1. The goal of jazz was never really meant to be super poppy or mainstream. Even during it's heyday with Post-Bop and Blue Note it was always overshadowed by acts in other genres. If artists are making albums like "Point of Departure" or "Ascension", I doubt their goal is to be blazing up the charts with The Beach Boys and Simon & Garfunkel. The genre would've existed and had plenty of opportunity for newcomers regardless of mainstream success. 2. Jazz has always been a very diverse genre. There was still plenty of straightforward and less experimental jazz being made and getting appreciation during the time those albums you cited were made. 3. There were PLENTY of albums released after the ones you cited that received tons of sales and mainstream attention (ex: Headhunters, Heavy Weather, Winelight, Breezin', Feels So Good, Street Life, Touchdown, Rise, Duotones). They even had top 40 pop hits at the time. That's not even counting the jazz inspired rock bands that were getting major success at the time like Chicago, Frank Zappa, Santana, BS&T, or Steely Dan. So saying it wasn't relevant anymore is just blatantly untrue in that regard. If you want to point to the reason jazz became 'irrelevant', it'd be the exact opposite of the one you cited; Many of the best artists in the genre had just used up all their ideas by the time the 80s came around and were releasing the worst music of their career. The creative freedom is the entire reason people were interested in jazz, so once it stagnated and became a bunch of synth cheese and weather channel music, that's when people turned away from it. If the good music is there, people will come. And even when it did become irrelevant, it eventually came back thanks to all the hip hop and R&B that was heavily inspired by it (Erykah Badu, Tribe Called Quest, The Roots, Digable Planets, Camp Lo, Guru, Pharcyde, Pete Rock, etc.)

Tuck

As someone who’s paying very close attention to the mainstream and the underground, and has a pretty decent track record of following the most cutting edge music, what sort of musical trends have you noticed throughout the 20’s so far? Anything you feel like defines the past 4 years? What about the next 6 years?

Ivan cesareo

Yeats Up 2 me > WLR. You could say that Up2me couldn’t have happened without Carti’s sound but I think yeat had better consistency

Zach Stolpa

This should really be the case

patrick

Soad is one of, if not my favorite bands of all time (beatles make it close), but a new album will only taint their legacy. Their prime is past them and not to mention Serj and Daron’s egos which will just result in making the worse, washed up alt-metal version of SpeakerBoxxx/Love Below

patrick

Also besides from him and Serj’s collaborations, I never thought Daron was that good of a songwriter, a lot of his core songs’ lyrics just come off as cheesy, edgy nonsense. Great producer and guitarist tho

Aidan Mcilhenney

Anthony! I don't think I've ever heard you talk about Type O Negative. Are you a fan? Would you consider an album like Bloody Kisses a classic?

C.

Recently the vocalist of a mall rock band paralyzed one of their fans by stage diving on top of her, despite the venue having a no stage diving rule. Artists should leave these antics in the past & discourage HxC style moshing esp when their music doesn't even call for it, it's never worth a fan becoming seriously injured

Caleb Hopkins

There is a lack of good brain melting and/or experimental electronic pop music right now, and it is incredibly dissapointing. Hyperpop, pc music, and etc could've began the next big thing in music and I was hooked, but the lack of artists pushing these subgenres forward has caused the wave to die. This should be biggest and best thing about the 2020s, and a great foundations have already been laid out by artists such as arca, Sophie, 100 gecs, and etc. Get on shit!!! Ps. Also you should talk about your thoughts psychadlic jungle by the cramps...

CraziestBoyEver

The go! Team are one of the most underrated bands ever and have never really got the reputation they deserve. I still have yet to come across a band like them.

Benjamin Lisboa

Not really a take but whenever I try to show my friends music that is critically acclaimed, that I really like, they consistently dogpile on it. Some of their favorites are WHOKILLEDXIX, Sabaton and the Hazbin Hotel Soundtrack. How do I get them to listen to new music?

Richard Long

Greatest diss track of all time Too Many Rappers Beastie Boys and Nas vs Everyone else. The SINGLE not the ALBUM version

Thomas Cridland

The average 'Drill' - 'UK - Rap' music listener nowadays just wants to have their praises sung and wants to hear their rapper flaunt their success to relate to the fan about how money will save them and is this end all be all save and grace.

Thomas Cridland

Grime and drill in allot of cases have lost their sense of purpose and are all on this kinda "IG" Clout chasing Central Cee wave. AND it SUCKS xx

bloodyM

Year Zero is a severely underappreciated NiN album, and has a very strong, well-realized concept and some of Trent's best lyrics as well. I think it's aged better than most people give it credit for.

Ley

An album can still be a 10 if 1 or 2 songs on the album are not perfect. Unless it’s a story album where each song is intertwined.

#1 amo defender

Genuine question, how are you supposed to have hope in times like this? Ever since 2020 I feel like I know way too much about the world and human nature and I keep trying to maintain hope and positivity in spite of it all but it's a battle I have to fight every day and it's very exhausting. Feels like all I can do is listen to music and enjoy the outdoors while the air is still breathable.

Ivan cesareo

Hey siri play SOFT LIVING by Jeff rosenstock lol

Dama Petrichor

Don’t crucify me but as someone who enjoys music a lot i think that if you haven’t listened to music on lsd you haven’t scratched the surface of what music can be , because its SO MUCH MORE. And question for you melon Have u ever done that? And if u did what are your favourite psychedelic music you enjoy the most on it?