Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Content

Thank you so much for all your support this month! It's HOT TAKES, UNPOPULAR OPINIONS, and TOUGH QUESTIONS time, so drop em down in the comments and we'll look through them all in a couple of weeks. Let's go!

In case you missed last month's episode: https://www.patreon.com/posts/lets-argue-swift-107197902

Comments

Zach Stolpa

RUN or DMC having no mention in your top 55 rapper list is hip hop blasphemy, explain that if you can or how you look at what RUN DMC did for hip hop and their contributions? I feel it’s almost impossible to tell the story of hip hop without them.

Cameron Edwards

“Here, There, and Everywhere” by The Beatles should be far more consistently put as one of their best songs. I know many give it the flowers it deserves, but it’s ranked on RYM as the 36th best Beatles song which just seems way too low . It may not be as grand as “A Day in The Life”, as hard as “I Want You (She’s So Heavy)”, or as psychedelic as “Strawberry Fields Forever” but Paul’s beautiful layered vocals and poignant song writing make the song just amazing. Paul has even consistently cited it as one of his personal favorites, hell even John of all people said he really liked the song. It’s probably my favorite example of effectiveness in simplicity.

bressig

the joke in SpongeBob about how maturing means acquiring a taste for freeform jazz is accurate, as wild jazz and jazz fusion have become some of my favorite genres in adulthood. How much painful, hoe-scaring jazz do you enjoy? Trio of Doom's "Dark Prince" is a fine example of the sound I'm referring to

Tuck

I don’t even love the song that much, but Please Please Please by Sabrina Carpenter is what Kacey Musgraves should have sounded like after her pop transition

Herbieguy

[Kind of a 'lengthy' post so forgive me]: There needs to be some sort of restructuring on how bad music is discussed / analyzed on music forums. Reviewing bad art is at it's most entertaining when it's discussing forgotten oddities or failed experiments (ex: Todd in the Shadows "Trainwreckords"). But in the modern era it just seems like finding 3 or 4 artists that are easy targets and joking about them ad nauseum, and that's just not much fun. I hate Tom McDonald and Lil Dicky as much as the next guy, but at this point talking about them is like making airplane food jokes.

Christian Tom

I'm sure someone has said this already, but even prior to his Nazism, Kanye was never a good rapper

Benjamin Lisboa

AI is just another tool in music that will be appreciated in the future, like auto tune, sampling and drum machines before it.

#1 amo defender

Recently in an interview JPEGMAFIA said that “nobody respects pop music in the moment while it’s popular, they only respect it in retrospect.” I’ve been thinking about this a lot cause I think you could argue it’s true in a lot of instances (for instance how a lot of people defend Justin Bieber after looking back at how horribly he was treated at the start of his career). What’s your take on this?

Trevor Young

Everyone's music tastes were actually shaped by cable TV commercials / jingles, whether they knew it or not.

Selene Dragon

Music with “widespread appeal” is going to see a downfall soon. Algorithms have made trends become less of a societal moment and more of an in group phenomenon. It’s happened with fashion, memes, and soon it will happen to music.

Maximof_

Ive wondered about this but considering the non-stop love towards Nas recently with the KD series and Magic Albums, will you be able to make a tier list of Every Nas Project, including the Lost Tapes?

Alex Sim

Dream jazz quintet?

#1 amo defender

As someone who’s loved pop music my whole life and has been routinely made fun of for it or looked at like I enjoy “lesser music,” it very much rings true for me. There’s certainly stuff that’s universally loved at the time, but often times people treat pop (especially pop made by women) as not being cool or worth respecting in most instances. Even today this is the case, I guarantee that in 30 years people won’t be talking about Taylor Swift nearly as negatively as they do now. Even as someone who’s just a casual fan I get strong negative reactions almost every time I mention that I like her music.

Herbieguy

Binging With Babish would like to have a word with you.

Herbieguy

While I agree with this sentiment, him being so vehemently anti streaming for 15 years probably didn't help matters.

Hogan99

Curious as to why you never reviewed the new Ibibio Sound Machine record, especially given that the singles were in your “best tracks” of the week in your track roundup; I think it’s one of the best records of the year so far and was hoping to get your opinion on it.

EZGames69

If there was one album you gave a “NOT GOOD” to, but would take it back today, what would it be?

Alex Sim

oneohtrix point never ass take (love it tho)

Oscar Barroso

Do you think life would be really boring if everyone liked the exact same artist and/or genre of music?

Cameron Edwards

What do you think makes a music review valuable or impactful for both the artist and the listener?

null

Kendrick Lamar is the greatest rapper of all time. He's more well-rounded and skilled than Nas, Jay-Z or anyone else you could possibly ague for the GOAT spot.

Self-Aware Onion

Orgy's cover of Blue Monday is a great cover that still sounds futuristic to this day. I think people just write it off because it comes from an era of metal music that's looked down upon

Yuh

Ajr Isn’t even half bad

patrick

George Harrison and Ginger Baker as a duo came out with better music than any of the bands they were in. Google their self titled album “George Harrison Ginger Baker” for more!

Waffles!

I really love the guest reviews! How far are you gonna go with this? Are you starting a giant music reviewer empire?

dvd_ynn

how are you able to listen to so much music? does it get easier to ‘digest’ albums quicker over time? theres so much i want to listen to on my list but i can only manage 2-3 a week before im unable to pay attention

Paolo Masia

You're being too harsh on the Arctic Monkeys. Your analyses about their work seem lazier compared to your usually excellent work. Saying AM doesn't have any catchy guitar riffs is absurd because they are. And I understand some criticisms of The Car, but giving it a 3 is excessive. You should appreciate their courageous evolution over time. After AM, they could have replicated its success but chose to change instead. Same after the first two albums. This isn't highlighted in your videos and in my opinion should be. While Damon Albarn's claim that they're the best rock band left might be exaggerated, I believe your harshness is equally overdone.

Zach Stolpa

Me personally I think they were the bed rock of hip hop for the mid 80’s until Eric.B and Rakim came out with paid in full and it could argued that they were the first true mainstream act in hip hop which I think says a lot.

Ivan cesareo

Would you rather never listen to your favorite albums again or never listen to any new albums ever?

Htkkk

There’ll never be a band as good as the Beatles. Not like there won’t be, but there can’t be. People won’t let it happen, even if a band really comes close to their popularity and greatness no one would dare to say that. At least pitchfork won’t let that happen.but I don’t think it’s bad thing tho they deserve the crown

ripplingSun

Idk why you’re so anti-Eminem’s fast rapping. I know it’s fallen out of favor, and most rappers aren’t skilled enough to do it. But I love a good super fast rhyme. Twists was the shit and Eminem can do it better than virtually anyone.

Htkkk

I think he’s starting a label

Liaxm

Rush is underappreciated and easily one of the best progressive rock bands of the 70s and 80s. I think they should be in conversation with bands like Led Zeppelin, Pink Floyd, The Rolling Stones, etc.

Liaxm

I definitely agree. I feel like people only say other wise because he's a somewhat newer rapper and they don't wanna put him in conversation with old school rappers, which is stupid

Liaxm

Honestly I always thought even though he was a way better producer and musician, he's actually a really good rapper, especially in MBDTF, that's just my opinion tho

bunnyhop

the Artificial Intelligence compilations are the only good AI music

Kyle Cahill

Post rock bands are doomed to fail. When you look at the greats of the genre (both past and present) you notice a trend in these bands having a critical fall from grace (Sigur Ros, Explosions in the Sky), lineup changes (BC,NR), or bands going on long hiatuses (Godspeed, Swans) or breaking up the band entirely (Slint, Sprain). And while these bands may still have relevant and successful albums in today's music landscape, the minute bands put out albums like SFTB or Laughing Stock and went post rock, shit seemingly hit the fan

Swaggurai

Bring back the stinkpiece series you coward

Josh Miles

Say there’s an album that has recently released. You proceed to listen to it and after a couple times you are feeling anywhere between a 4-6 on it. Unless said album is being highly demanded of you to review it, what makes you put out that 4-6/10 review rather than throw it in the YUNO review series or short reviews? Sure, 7-10/10 albums aren’t dropping as consistently as much as 4-6/10 albums and there’s probably not as many 0-3/10 albums dropping consistently either as much as 4-6/10s. Is it purely filler reviews at that point to have a stable income or do some albums that fall in the 4-6 range you feel actually have more artistic merit and are worth more of a thorough dissection than others? (Again: all of this is only if it isn’t being highly demanded by your audience).

Guy Mendes

We should respect the side breaks when listening to albums that took into account the LP (or cassette) format. I feel like most artists took that into account and it just feels right having that break intended for flipping the tape or record, the Beatles are a major example of this approach. It especially changed my approach to double albums, suddenly I'm not dealing with 24+ tracks experience that can get very tiring or fatiguing but 4 sides with 6 songs each.

ToadMan101

Even if there was no controversy for the new Katy Perry song at all, there was just no possible way a mainstream comeback from her was ever gonna work. The only point of evidence I've heard from people who were manifesting it on social media was how her older songs were becoming viral on TikTok again. While the social media platform has become a bit of a curator these past few years, it is also not the be all, end all of musical consumption. As a counter-example, you'd think the virality of "Running Up That Hill" two years ago would've led to more Kate Bush songs going viral, or at the very least, her discography getting discovered by millions more, but no, not really. For the vast majority of people on social media who aren't huge music listeners, that's just not on their personal 'to do' list. The fact of the matter is, just because something is popular on social media, nostalgia reasons or not, doesn't automatically mean a renaissance is in the works.

Torben Juache

I would like that Anthony reviewed some Latin Rock. There are some amazing bands like Heroes del Silencio, an example of their amazing talent is a song called "Entre dos Tierras", with that spellbinding solo in the last leg of the track. Or, as well, Gustavo Cerati. He is well known in spaces such as RYM. I am latino that have always appreciated the latin inclusions in your channel like Silvana Estrada, Ondatropica and the wonderful Natalia Lafourcade.

Torben Juache

Shoutout to Las Ligas Menores, their self titled 2014 Album is amazing

Taylor B

Your Gracie Abrams review made me think about how there are not a lot of “nepo babies” in music. It seems like most children of musicians keep a lower profile than their parents or pursue a different artistic endeavor. It’s an interesting contrast compared to children of actors or film makers.

vvo

I truly don’t understand how The Lemon Twigs have such a little following, only 222K monthly listeners on Spotify for a band that’s making elite music and is getting better? I’m puzzled by this like it genuinely makes no sense because I feel like they have a lot of mass appeal as a band as well.

Drake Parker

In terms of hit singles, 2024 sucks. This is the year of the deep cuts