Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Content

Thanks so much for supporting us this month; hope you're all doing well! Now's that magical time when you hit us with your HOT TAKES, UNPOPULAR OPINIONS, and TOUGH QUESTIONS! Drop 'em in the comments below and we'll look through them later next week. Let's go!

In case you missed last month's episode: https://www.patreon.com/posts/lets-argue-best-54280326

Comments

Andy

WHATS YOUR SPOTIFY ON REPEAT PLAYLIST LOOK LIKE?? I GOTTA KNOW I GOTTA KNOW PLEASE GOD PLEASE TELL ME

Tyler Kirby

Joni Mitchell’s lyrics can go toe to toe with any of Bob Dylan’s.

Emily

The art of the music video is under appreciated. A great music video can add to the overall feel of a song. Moreover, a terrible music video can take away from the song too

Wrath

Soundtracks for the blind > lift your skinny fists

TraJay

You would rate Sex Dreams and Denim Dreams by Uffie a lot higher if it came out today.

Jackson Moeller

Do you think that somewhere there is a conversation pt 2 by Mac Miller?

Antoine Pages

Classical composers should be talked about more often, especially regarding their influence on jazz music (ex: Debussy's impact on Duke Ellington)

tryhard

As much as you’ve panned Sleigh Bells in the past, bands like 100 gecs would be nothing without them. They really paved the way for hyperpop to thrive in the mainstream scene.

Herbieguy

One group of albums stay. The others are erased from history. What's YOUR favorite color? https://i.imgur.com/u0zj1MS.jpg (You can rank them if you prefer I'm not your boss).

Alberto Satta

The Police are extremely underrated in the "music nerd" community. I hardly ever see anybody even talking about them despite them having a catalog full of classic records such as "Outlandos D'Amour" which features some really good hits and "Reggatta de Blanc". Sting's solo album "Ten Summoners' Tales" is also really good.

Johnny L

New Music Fridays is generally great, but I don't think its the best for artists who tend towards genuine experimentation to have their work thrown infront of crowds that were obviously never supposed to hear it (let alone be given a lever to pull within 30 seconds to judge whether its great or terrible) Its honestly heartbreaking sometimes to see artists who are absolutely nailing the sound and niche they're catering for get thoughtlessly insulted by randoms who think its 'trash lowkey.'

MeowmiXX

heavily influenced artists in the music industry really arent as big of a deal as you make them out to be (lil baby & gunna -> young thug, for example.) certainly its not something to be admired per se and copycat acts like greta van fleet are their own can of worms, but sometimes it seems like you come across as if an artists music is bad solely because it sounds like x other artist. to me, if the music is good i really dont care what the influence line is

Adam mezzarone

Do you ever think that describing albums the way you do in some reviews is bordering on spoiler territory and have you ever considered putting a warning in for it. For example I watched your review for TBAB before I had listened to the album and I remember when you said the spoken word passages built up to this dialogue between Kendrick and Tupac and it kind of took something away from the record for me I think. I get that watching a review before you listen is opening yourself up to that but I also think it's possible to reveal too much about a narrative without a disclaimer

Adam ODonnell

MCR’s “The Ghost of You” is if Creed’s “Higher” was good

Yuzhe Tan

You were too harsh on Pacific Daydream imo. Many of the songs are honestly not that bad like Mexican Fender and La Mancha Screwjob, which are fun songs to sing along too. While it dosent sound like classic weezer its definitely enjoyable, and overall the album is much better than Make Believe and Raditude or even Green. But I understand the Feels Like Summer hate.

Señor C

Bob Dylan wouldn’t be as beloved if he had a better singing voice. Just wouldn’t hit the same

NiccolĂČ Galliano

italian-american culture has nothing to do with italy and honestly it is kinda grotesque

Caleb John Cushing

Hey Melon, watched the new Sparks Brothers doc recently (good movie btw!), and it made me remember your Amoeba What's in my bag? video where you picked up a collection of their records. Did you ever end up doing that deep dive? Do you agree with the sentiment that Sparks is long overdue for being recognized as an incredibly important and influential part of music and the evolution of pop and rock music?

Garrett Shotts

Apple MIDI trumpet is not just the worst MIDI instrument but an absolutely useless tool. There’s almost no legitimate use for it outside of pure irony or an intentional distractingly gross effect. Little dynamics available either. Every note is variations of BLARG and BLAH. Seriously, even the guitar-keyboard sounds are better. It’s 2021 and it’s time to get access to some decent sounding horns without having to pay out the butt for a full suite of instruments I don’t need.

Finn Hay

K pop has been the result of many of the best pop songs of the last half decade or so, but have been overlooked by the music community due to their affiliation with the genre. If songs like 134340, a literal tropical jazz rap song, or TT, which has one of the best edm/electro pop production and songwriting ever, were exposed to the community more, you’d see a lot more people giving k pop a chance, but instead the majority look at bts topping the charts with butter and fans being toxic online and write all of it off

Franco del Rosario

Aside from The Beatles, can you name other famous bands and artists who were simultaneously as critically acclaimed, as they were massively commercially successful / popular with the masses during their time?

Owen W

The average positive review is more entertaining than the average negative review. Most people are more fun to listen to when they talk about something they like than when they complain. But the best negative reviews are more entertaining than the best positive reviews. Complaining compellingly is an artform that's hard to master, but amazing when done well.

Ryan The Great

Dismemberment Plan are So Underrated and deserve to be talked about nowdays especially with their LP Emergency and I being ahead of its time.

Cole

the only weird thing about Primus is Les Claypool's persona, the music itself isn't inherently weird. many people assume youre a "holds up spork" person as a primus fan when primus actually used to put out tons of bangers

membertatooine

I'm going to Connecticut in a month and need some recommendations for places to eat! 😋 😋 Can you help me antnee?

Joe Shmozo

The Golden Casket takes a few listens to get used to, but once you can embrace it for what it is and not what it isn't, it's one of the best experiences a Modest Mouse album can give you. It's super fun and weird, while there aren't a lot of their signature emotionally devastating moments on it, it's still a fantastic record just for how much fun you can have listening to it in the right setting. I wasn't a huge fan of it at first but it has slowly climbed its way into the top of my favorite Modest Mouse albums. Easily the best and most consistent thing they've done since Good News.

ginoo75

The Black Parade and Three Cheers are in desperate need of a remaster

Kyle Cahill

Noise music is only good when its fused with other genres (i.e. clipping, lingua ignota)

ginoo75

Do you let the cultural impact of an album influence its rating? I find it rather hard, as someone who was only born in 2003, to fully grasp what would warrant giving albums like TVUAN or Abbey Road, to only name a few, a 10/10. I mean, I like them, but from a modern standpoint it's just nothing special to me.

bressig

Limp Bizkit's recent surge in popularity is a post-ironic reflection on their enormous success in the late 90s and early 2000s, since just as many people are looking back on their music fondly as they are cringing at it

itll be okay

Mickey Factz's diss towards Royce was in the top 3 diss tracks of all time, alongside Ether and No Vaseline

Jonah Wooley

Third Eye Blind made the best debut album of all-time. Songs like “Semi-Charmed Life” and “Jumper” garnered fans through the radio while still having some deeper meaning to them, and songs like “Graduate”, “Thanks A Lot”, “God of Wine”, “Motorcycle Drive-by”, and more are just amazing songs to ice the cake.

Armando Abelho

Solar Power is going to be Lorde’s most creative and experimental album yet but will never get the same large scale recognition as Melodrama or Pure Heroine because of their roles in developing her fan base and nostalgia value (although being great albums regardless)

Star

Anthrax’s Sound of White Noise is one of their best albums, and features some of their best song-writing as well as some of their best instrumentation. It strikes a perfect balance between classic anthrax’s thrashy, punky sound, while also deviating into the alt-metal and grunge sounds of the 90’s to deliver a great combination of both styles. I would also like to say that John Bush’s gruff vocal deliveries add a lot as well.

C LEGO Films

I agree! It's a great album, not my favourite debut of all time but still a very good one

Matthew Wisniewski

To be honest, I never understood why people say John Bonham is a better drummer than Neil Peart. Don't get me wrong, they're both fantastic drummers, and Bonham is incredibly revolutionary for rock music. However, to me Peart seemed like the next level in drumming, with fills, beats, and solos that seemed more complex than Bonham's usual style.

Dylan Davis

Bowling for soup is the greatest pop punk band of all time and if you disagree, you are wrong

Nick Denhalter

I think when it comes to technical skill it goes to Neil, but when it comes to performance it goes to Bonham, if that makes any sense at atll

Sid Mullendore

black keys are an entirely worthless garbage white stripes rip off who went on joe rogan. you should go on joe rogan

Jonah Wooley

Potatoes are best in hash brown form

Drake Parker

An album rollout can influence how good or bad the actual album is

Michael Acierno

Boyz 2 Men is easily the most underrated R&B/Soul group

elfin priest

Master of Puppets would've made a great EP, the second half is all forgettable. Orion isn't fit to lace Call of Ktulu's boots

Gustav Olsson

What’s the best year in music?

Isaac Gadberry

Sandanista is the Clash's best album. While not as consistent as London Calling, its highs are much higher and it was really ahead of its time in terms of the myriad of genres it experimented with.

Triple 9

Best rock album of 2021: Death By Rock And Roll by The Pretty Reckless

Aaron

idk why but bruno’s sophomore album “unorthodox jukebox” deserves so much more appreciation, ofc they’re not that original but he did it so well, the songs are well crafted and catchy, it really deserved a review from melon😞

Caleb Benjamin

When you went on Sardonicast awhile ago, to discuss Dancer in the Dark, you seemed very knowledgeable about cinema. Offering great takes and even discussing things like Dogma-95. What’s some of your favorite movies? And with your recent review of Inside, do you think you’ll ever review non-musical movies?

LIfeinthezone

the Cornelius situation is extremely messed up. I feel like it's going to be hard for me to listen to Fantasma the same way again, even if it's one of my favorite albums.

Bryn Nieboer

at this point, video game scores are uniformly more inventive and boundary pushing than any movie score coming out the same year, it seems like all the best soundtracks are games (hallow knight, celeste, dark souls 2, thumper, etc)

Alex Alcalde

Shakira’s early work prior when she made the jump to make catchy pop tunes for American audiences is some of the best Latin music of the 90’s.

Austin Eli Wilke

Some songs sound better when I only listen to certain parts of them. Some songs either drag on too long to be interesting or enjoyable all the way through and others might be really long or repetitive. So it can make some songs way more enjoyable if I only listen to a certain minute or two of it and cut it off short or even entirely skip some portions. Sometimes I do this with TOOL songs like The Grudge when I’m low on time and I just want to hear the scream.

Bennett Gottesman

Gil Scott Heron’s I’m new here(the original mix) is severally under appreciated. It’s emotional and full of life. It doesn’t feel over dramatic like many similar albums do. It’s truly incredible and more people should talk about it

iScarlyXuwu

Limp Bizkit is criminally overhated. Their sound was intentionally goofy and they had a lot of great songs. The unreleased track Don't Remember would be a classic if it actually dropped and I think it would've made them be remembered more fondly.

Casey Bromage

The Beach Boys are easily better than The Beatles, and would've been the most influential group of all time if The Beatles hadn't gotten there first.

Drake Parker

Aaliyah would’ve been bigger than Beyonce if her time weren’t cut short

Guille Perez

Some posthumous albums may be terrible but at least they haven’t used impersonators to make up fake songs like they did w MJ on his 2010 ‘Michael’ album. Not him on tracks 3,5,7

Jon Erik

You need to review/ make more content about Amy Winehouse

Ryan Shaw

I think Linkin Park was unfairly hated on as they changed up their sound throughout the second half of their career. A Thousand Suns is easily their best album but was written off by fans for being “too experimental” but if you go back and listen today I think they were just ahead of the game and it can be a contender for album of that year.

Corey G

this goes for mount eerie as well.

BlueZones

I have a hard time streaming works by artists who have been accused of physical/sexual abuse, have said racist comments and haven’t apologized, other problematic behavior, etc. I feel like people should be allowed to separate the art from the artist, but should also acknowledge when they’re giving money to a bad person, even if it’s fractions of pennies. For example: I can listen to my Swans vinyl because I bought them before Michael Gira’s assalt accusations because no money is going to him directly from me spinning them, but I can’t stream his music anymore because I know that would be giving him an even minuscule amount of payment. You can’t really separate the art from the artist when you’re still helping them financially.

Rom Jan

Lil Nas and billie, are the faces of a new generation in music, and they will continue to build new ground for new faces in the indestry.

Trevor Young

Anthony Fantano is just the straight Trixie Mattel.

C A M

There is a very real possibility that Tones and I will never make an enjoyable/"good" record purely because of the vocal style she incorporates and will likely not change (which could literally require a total vocal revamp.) I seriously can't imagine any production style or genre working with those vocals.

Christian Lourenco

What are some of your favorite and least favorite James Bond theme songs? I love Goldfinger for its swanky and loud horns and its thick bass. The theme for Quantum of Solace is bad, just like the movie

Atom Weiler

Ok look idc that MBDTF’s a 6 but I can’t believe you’re not a fan of Nicki Minaj’s verse on Monster...it’s sick as fuck and I’d even call it the highlight of the song

MyNameIsJeff

Quantum is overhated. It’s not great, sure, but watch it right after Casino Royale. It makes it a lot better. It worked for me, anyway.

Josh

Biggie’s flow is even more of a trademark than his distinctive voice. To this day the smooth syllable assembly of B.I.G. is rivalled by just a few and it sets him apart from his contemporaries today as much as it did in the 90s.

Brandon Vainer

What caused rock to die, and will the same thing apply to hip hop?

Rom Jan

GINGER BY BROCKHAMPTON is 808 & heartbreak of this generation. 1. Using mainly 808 and melodies throughout the album 2. Splited thier&his(ye and BROCKHAMPTON) fanbase in half. 3. Deals with depression, and the struggle of moving on When you continue digging into it, you'll find more and more similarities...đŸ€”

Gavin

all things must pass by george harrison is the best beatles solo album by a long shot, i have no reasoning this is just a straight fact

Benjamin Lisboa

Spellling's "The Turning Wheel" will not get the appreciation it deserves because the sound of Cabral's voice is not immediately appealing to most people.

Bryan Gulotta

If the doobie brothers weren’t called the doobie brothers then they’d get the respect they deserve

Rom Jan

Silk Sonics are the OutKast of this generation

D

Thievery Corporation is one of the best electronic acts from the late 90s - early 00's. its a shame that theyre not concidered a household name yet.

Aidan Brooks

While I don’t want to believe this, I think Frank Ocean might be done making music. All of his post-blonde singles seem to be in the same vein as that album which leads me to believe that new material where he is continuing to push forward isn’t coming. Also with the launch of his new jewelry brand, it seems that he has moved on to other things.

Dylan Iwan

Back in 2016, you said that you had kind of a weird theory on David Bowie's "Blackstar." If you remember it, I would love to hear it please. Thank you

Drake Parker

Have you considered making another “Albums I’ve Changed My Mind On” vid? Or do you feel like that’s not necessary right now? Any you could name off the top of your head?

Christian Mu

the success of countless music artists is largely due to the often uncredited visual artists who created iconic imagery for them that was often more marketable and artistically valuable than the music itself. Even touring DJs are known for live shows done by unknown VJs

Squanto

Eminem does not even remotely deserve GOAT status. He put out some of the worst hip-hop albums of all time, aided in the gentrification of the genre, and helped give birth to the lyrical miracle acts we see today like Logic and Joyner Lucas. Sure, he may be influential, but was his influence actually a good thing?

Corey G

You and logic don't look THAT alike

Christian Lourenco

I just can't get past the horrific action sequences tbh. It's just so nauseating to watch for me but I do think Diamonds are Forever and You Only Live Twice are worse from the ones that I have seen.

Sean L Byrne

AGREED. He made a really great album twenty-one years ago, and he's spent almost all of the past two decades making garbage. Technically talented, but why is he still in the goat conversation??? it boggles the mind.

Jonah Wooley

This is a good one because I disagree. HARD.

Trixie

black album is peak weezer and is betetr than pinkerton

Trevor Hook

War Pigs is the best Black Sabbath song, and it's not even close.

Lousey

Genesis is a top 5 progressive rock band (at least, when they were a progressive rock band) Also The Lamb Lies Down on Broadway is a near perfect concept album and better than The Wall

Garrett Shotts

While The Beatles certainly did it at a consistency and volume rarely seen, other examples of concurrent critical and commercial success would be Bruce Springsteen, CCR, Prince, Pink Floyd, Led Zeppelin, Nirvana, Lauryn Hill, Michael Jackson, Outkast, more recently Kendrick Lamar and Beyoncé off the top of my head.

Caspa

Due to Nick Cave having multiple S tiers and still putting out Quality records in the 2010s and now with his lastest release is it safe to say his discog has surpassed Bob Dylan's in terms of Quanity of Quality albums?

Tyler Osborne

Dirt by Alice In Chains is the best album of the grunge era (also one of the best covers of all time)

808scarlett

MC Ren had the best verse on Fuck Tha Police

josh

J. Cole is definitely the most overrated rapper in mainstream rap. I mean, I get it the guy can rap as good as other people and does not only talk about cars, drugs, etc. But it is ridiculous how often he gets compared to Kendrick for example. He is not up there. PS: Please do a Oasis-Worst to Best.

Andrew Shaktah

Hey Anthony! My gf and I just did a little vacation which included parts of Connecticut, completely unaware that New Haven was the home of some of the best pizza in the country and that there is some historical significance to it. Considering you’ve worked in the pizza world like myself I wanted to know if you’ve tried “the big four” restaurants in New Haven and your controversial opinion of them. Here are my rankings of them and if you haven’t tried em I’d highly suggest it. Have fun! 1. Modern Apizza 2. BAR (their $3 by-the-slice after 10p is divine) 3. Sally’s 4. Frank Pepe’s

Sweaty Bennetty

ppl who say they don’t like any music that has harsh vocals in it are babies and they owe me their lunch money

Kyle Cahill

Since Doug Walker dropped his Wall parody album, you need to drop a dark side of the moon parody album in a similar way

Preston Richey

Flood is better than Lincoln (though both are excellent)

Amon Gus

I think most people have stopped making up their opinions based on your reviews and are now thinking for themselves