Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Content

Thank you all for supporting us this month; hope you're doing well! Now's that magical time when you hit us with your HOT TAKES, UNPOPULAR OPINIONS, and TOUGH QUESTIONS! Drop 'em in the comments below and we'll look through them next week. Let's go!

In case you missed last month's episode: https://www.patreon.com/posts/lets-argue-frank-55473977

Comments

Jackson Moeller

What’s the saddest Mac Miller song ?

Noah Eldredge

Kanye is better than Kendrick. Better albums. Better tracks. Better promotion. Come on.

James Carlisle

Sgt Pepper is to the Beatles what MBDTF is to Kanye West: Less groundbreaking than they’re made out to be and outdone by three other albums in their respective discographies.

bressig

do you ever wonder if the writers of 500 Days of Summer ever look back and think "maybe we shouldn't have used The Smiths as a major character development device"

Isaac Furler

"Donda" is "Avengers: Endgame" of Hip-hop

Grandgregtauro

Kiss Land is criminally underrated. Some of Abels best songwriting and is easily his most cohesive album aesthetically and from a production standpoint. It’s honestly a sin how under-appreciated it is in Abels Discog

StayHydrated

Is Drake's new album cover represent how many other children he's fathered? Like seriously if it wasn't for Pusha T would Adonis be 'inheriting everything' like Drake claims?

reapzzz

donda was good the first couple listens, now its boring and too long.

Jonah Wooley

Coffee is better iced, and you are a menace for thinking otherwise.

Paul

Editing out the swearing brings Donda down a peg. If Kanye wanted to make a whole album without cursing, fine. But the split-seconds in the middle of verses disrupt the flow of him and his features, and ruins the immersion for the listener. Still Kanye's best work since KSG though.

Paul

Also today (9/6, ecin) is my birthday :)

Walter Houghton

YG deserves more credit for what he’s done for West Coast G Funk and what his 4Hunnid label does keeping it alive while still paying homage to a lot of the Hispanic influences on that sound

M

How has Worry. by Jeff Rosenstock aged for you? The themes and messaging on it, to me, has aged incredibly well and is maybe even more relevant than it was at release. Musically, it remains unmatched in terms of punk music, no one has really achieved anything nearly as ambitious and executed it as well since. I was also wondering how you compare it to the rest of his discography now with a handful of new releases since it released

feejwata

Psyence Fiction by UNKLE aged wonderfully. The way DJ Shadow and James Lavelle were able to craft this amazing project filled with guests such as Kool G Rap, Richard Ashcroft of The Verve, Thom Yorke of Radiohead, Mike D of Beastie Boys, and Alice Temple feels ahead of its time. The themes and production in songs such as Bloodstain, Chaos, Rabbit In Your Headlights, and Drums of Death parts 1 and 2 are one of the best pieces of music in the 90s.

Owen W

You seem to have given more positive scores to mainstream music in the past few years than you did when you started. Have you warmed up to mainstream music, or do you think mainstream music has gotten better?

NevadaNate

Why is Kanye so often in a position where he's defending or platforming abusers / predators and canceled people? Before Donda he featured Chris Brown, went out of his way to defend XXX and 6ix9ine, and made supportive comments about Tyga's relationship with Kylie. His stans will claim he "focuses on forgiveness" but some of these times he's seeking that so fast that it seems like he doesn't care about their victims or want to see these people face any consequences.

Cason Handy

With Metallica’s massive cover project for the Black Album dropping this month, what modern day album would you to see a similar treatment by having 50+ artists picking and covering a song from said album?

Josh

Little Simz is a 10/10 rapper because she knows how to spell little.

Veble

Green Day had an incredible album run with dookie, insomniac and Nimrod.

Dalton Krause

Amon Tobin is the GOAT of electronic music and continues to break boundaries with his recent projects like Figueroa and Only Child Tyrant. Why haven't you covered an Amon Tobin project since ISAM, Melon? Much Love

Lousey

Supermodel (2014) is a sincerely great pop album. The flow is immaculate, the mix is insane, and while some tracks are weaker in comparison, the melodies and emotions are on point. I feel the album (and FTP as a whole) got kind of screwed by the indie label they were marketed as.

Ryan P

Travis Scott’s Utopia has a good chance of being better than Rodeo

SonamyEdits

Tyler, The Creator is the most growing artists out there. He went from making horrorcore and shock value rap into rapping about love and growth from him and others. He also new how to use his voice throughout his career, since he didn’t like it.

Noah

Lianne La Havas' cover of Weird Fishes is better than the original! The mixing is punchier, the vocals are way more full, and the switch in the drum groove adds a lot more dynamic impact to the high energy segments!

Yahir Rivas

2021 is one of the best years in music history. This year had 3 perfect albums, a bunch of amazing debut records, Drake, Kanye and Tyler dropped. Plus the year isn't even over yet.

SeƱor C

It’s impressive that Liz Phair managed to drop her 3rd best album almost 30 years after her debut

James Cross

Kendrick does it for the culture. Kanye does it for the music. And Drake does it for the the money. This was clear when he leaked that song featuring AndrƩ 3000

Stefan Lal

Does your enjoyment or appreciation of music ever get influenced by reviews? Does Fantano get Fantanoed?

BuBullen

we want it’s food 3

Garfism

Despite being one of the most treasured icons in music history, you have never formally talked about Bob Marley. Is there a reason for this? Have you never gotten the opportunity or are you just not crazy about the style of music he produced?

Ryan Hodgetts

A record that is derivative in nature shouldn't necessarily have that held against it. Looking at bands like Vein or Shame, its obvious those records pull from different sources of material and their influences can come off strong, but if they can pull of an exciting sound and that resonates for a lot of people, would it even matter that its derivative? It also very likely that records like these will be many younger peoples first exposure to these "older" influences, and they can use the newer record as a springboard to dive into the sounds that inspired the record. a new fan shouldn't fault that record for being derivative if they don't have a knowledge of those influences in the first place

Sid Mullendore

your minor threat tattoo is sick my friend has the same exact tattoo but he's not straight edge so it doesn't make sense. i apologize on his behalf for appropriating your culture.

Owen W

Happy birthday!

Nathaniel Zaccagnini

Jesus Lord is a better song than Runaway. the lyrics are more fulfilling (especially when ye talks about his mom) , the runtime is justified with the variety of stories told throughout the song, and I would much rather listen to larry hoover junior’s spoken word outro than Runaway’s bloated instrumental outro.

Parker

Welcome to the Madhouse should of been given a not good since it was a nonstarter

LukeOnDemand

Come to Life is Kanye's best song. Fight me

arkilig

as much as I like the surprise I hate how Kanye doesn't label features on any of his recent albums

Angie

Drake downgraded from musical artist to tiktok influencer lmfao

Matias Uhd Nielsen

How come you never talk about the dance-ability of songs?

Froggoking

How does terrible music become so popular? I cannot for the life of me understand what so many people see in bands like Creed, Nickleback, Tones & I, Imagine Dragons and all the other popular awful bands/artists who are well-known amongst the more discerning music listeners for being awful and yet they continue to chart so high for the mainstream audience. How can there continuously be such a huge discrepency between the two audiences in terms of taste.

Ajay

Going off CLB all the way back to More Life, it seems Drake is so content with his status in rap and wants to have as wide appeal as possible, that he'll likely never make a concise and focused album where he sounds hungry ever again. Using CLB as an example, I feel he wants to have an equal amount of higher energy tracks like No Friends in the Industry/You Only Live Twice and low energy/laid back ones like Girls Like Girls/In the Bible while also going for easy crossover appeal like the dancehall style of Fountains. I find CLB to be an alright album due to having some major highlights, but also some really boring/bad songs and a good portion that's easy to not have strong feelings on. I feel a big part of the blame does fall on Drake feeling like he doesn't have to take many risks and being content with that, but honestly I could understand this just being a smart business move which will guarantee he stays relevant and popular among the majority of listeners as opposed to taking a big risk with a change in sound or sticking with a theme that some of his wide audience could really dislike. After More Life, I stopped going into Drake projects with high expectations and it has allowed me to get 5-7 tracks from each album into heavy rotation without being too disappointed. Doesn't result in great albums, but helps me get the most from Drake as a consumer while focusing on other artists for more enjoyable full album experiences. As always, thanks for your hard work Melon!

Sweaty Bennetty

Buffalo sauce is the best sauce and is a great example of true american cuisine (the best buffalo sauce is made by melting a little butter in some Frank’s red hot and adding in garlic powder)

Cameron Watts

Ass eaters think they’re more supreme than normal humans.

The Real Bambi

You're supposed to eat the tail end of fried shrimp.

Carlos

The Andre 3000 verse on Life of the Party was better than anything off of CLB and Donda (lyrically)

I, II, II, IL

Drum & Bass is heavily underlooked as most people prefer house music, despite the diversity of sounds found in Drum & Bass

Patrick

Tonetta doesn't get nearly enough credit for their influence on contemp music. I've only just discovered them recently but after a few cursory listens I can already trace the lineage of taylor, ye, billie and peppa pig back to tonetta. This world is unjust and I partly blame your underwhelming review of 777 vol. 1

James W.

The 2010s was a better decade musically than the 90s

retrocalie

Brazilians should be ashamed for all of their additions to pizza. Lettuce or mayonnaise belong nowhere near a slice.

Herbieguy

One of the most common critiques of concept albums is that they're pretentious. In your opinion, where is the line? When does an album go from having an interesting concept to it being 'pretentious' or 'self-indulgent'?

Marley Turnbull

Conway is the best MC in the Griselda crew and it's not even close.

iScarlyXuwu

What do you think of my Eminem rankings 16. Re-Up 15. Encore 14. Infinite 13. Kamikaze 12. Revival 11. D12 World 10. Slim Shady LP 09. Marshall Mathers LP 08. Hell: The Sequel 07. Devil's Night 06. Music To Be Murdered By 05. Recovery 04. The Eminem Show 03. MTBMB Side B 02. MMLP2 01. Relapse & Refill

Jack Bayley

Laurie Anderson’s O Superman pretty much predicted the future of how vocals would be manipulated in the future and still somehow sounds more futuristic than the stuff in the now!

Cody Ladson

Written freestyles are more fun to listen to than an artist’s actual songs. They focus on what they are saying more

HM James

Echoes is better than Atom Heart mothers title track, while I do appreciate the orchestration in the latter, Pink Floyd did a much better job in the build up to a climax of a song and it’s interludes in Echoes

Anthony Showalter

What is your general opinion of Black Kray AKA Sickboyrari? I've never seen you talk about his music and I think he's a pioneering force in cloud rap and emo rap.

Jac

All the ones he'll never write :'(

Jac

I feel like Kanye had trouble integrating his authentic self with his aspirational self on Jesus is King, and that trying too hard screwed up his creative flow and his actual flow. On Donda he has more success expressing himself genuinely within the boundaries (or straitjacket? not even being flippant) he's made for himself.

Mitchell Martin

Missing Molars is the prefect example of how to do a deluxe album. Also Smiling With no Teeth deserved the yellow flannel.

Robojim

Not really an unpopular opinion but why is it that Drake actually tends to have decent performances when he features on other artists' tracks and phones it in so incredibly hard on his own releases?

Robojim

Long awaited but somewhat disappointing?

Robojim

I think it's the only part 2 I enjoyed on the album

Stefan Lal

Agree. Still yet to come: Young Thug, Injury Reserve, Lil Nas X, maybe Travis and Kendrick. This year is stacked

Squanto

Merriweather Post Pavillion hasn’t aged well in the context of AC’s discography

vvo

With Certified Lover Boy, do you think Drake can reach the level of corniness of Chance the Rapper? I feel like he's headed towards that path.

Drake Parker

ā€œBallin’ like *insert basketball player*ā€ is the laziest possible bar in modern rap music

Kexia_x

How are you Melon ? xxxx

BlueZones

Grunge seems to be too scantly represented to be anything more than a micro-genre. It only has a few years long heyday and everything past a certain point gets labeled as post-grunge. There’s a few stragglers with some later nineties albums by Soundgarden, Alice In Chains, and Pearl Jam but other than that it gets made to seem like a way bigger genre than it actually was. It seems like more of a time and place, mostly regional scene than a genre in and of itself.

Jacob B

Watch The Throne 2 should absolutely be made. Kanye and Jay are drastically different (and arguably better) artists than they were 10 years ago. A post-4:44 Jay and a post-"everything that has happened to Kanye these past ten years" on an album together would definitely be worth listening to, to say the least. "Jail" off of Donda further cements this point.

Jac

And Radiohead in November (compilation plus some new stuff)

Paint Clown

A Kanye produced Griselda album easily has 10/10 potential

Drake Parker

Why do some albums that you rate a 4 get a red flannel, and sometimes they don’t? For example you wore a red flannel for Scorpion, Jesus Is King, and Hot Pink. but some albums such as Afterburner, Eternal Atake, and Solar Power got normal clothing. All 4’s. Do you have some kind of internal thought process when determining what gets a red flannel or not?

Jacob Dickens

What are some of your favorite music docs or concert films?

Esau Cahue

Releasing a sequel for an album is stupid. It’s a lazy album title and never shares any similarity with the previous album

Sean.

Supreme Clientele should be appreciated WAY more in the hip-hop community. It's got incredible. forward thinking production and unmatched flows and is not as widely respected as Enter the Wu-Tang, Only Built 4 Cuban Linx, Liquid Swords or even Iron Man, when I think its vastly superior.

Preston Richey

While both are excellent and dear to my heart, the best They Might Be Giants album is Flood, not Lincoln

jusrandom.

Kanye and Drake are too big to fall (Specifically in the context of what they do with their music)

James Carlisle

i mean cumulatively, given how vast Kanye’s discog is and how influential it is, I’d agree that Kanye is the greater artist in the grander scheme. But with that said, I don’t think he’s ever put out anything as perfect from start to finish as To Pimp A Butterfly (Late Registration comes the closest IMO)

Niels Kristian Holm

Kendrick's latest features do not exactly bode well for the upcoming album.

MeowmiXX

young thug, drake, led zeppelin, & dragonforce are the mount rushmore of being copied by other artists

Belmin Hodžić

Lana is the most influential artist in Dream Pop/Folk/AltPop of this century

Ben Galvan

You should give your thoughts on the album cover of the album you are reviewing. The cover of an album is very important and while it doesn't impact the quality of the music, it is essential to it's legacy and the way people picture the album. Often a lot of thought goes into the album cover and I think it needs to be appreciated when executed well and called out when not. PS I dont think it should effect the score that you give an album, just would like to hear your thoughts.

Devon Grey

The first four Zeppelin albums are amazing. But the latter half of the zeppelin discography is very hard to enjoy due to Robert Plants rough vocal change. Houses of the holy was great but ā€œThe Crungeā€ is so hard to enjoy because of his vocal performance. He went from having this extremely powerful bluesy rock voice, to having this annoying whiny singing voice. Led Zeppelin had such a powerful sound, and it seems that in the last three albums he wasn’t able to mesh with the bands sound like he did in the first four albums.

Wombat Rob

I'm listening through the new Low record, HEY WHAT. It's very good. I still can't believe you didn't even review their last record Double Negative, there's no way you listened front to back because it ticks off a lot of boxes that usually define music you love. Will we ever get a Review of Double Negative? It makes me triple sad that we may never

Jackson Hindman

If Kendrick's verses on the new Baby Keem record are indicative of the quality of his next album, hip-hops three biggest names (Drake, Ye, and Kendrick) will have put out some of their worst work in years, marking the end of their statuses as the industry's top artists.

Strange Network

In the wake of CLB, Drake stans have really revealed how blind people can be to accepting the fact that artists who have put out all-time-classics can, and often do, end up losing steam. This is particularly highlighted with Drake, who has always been an artist of mainstream appeal and so with this 3-album run of giving into that appeal without much change, it has driven a massive wedge between hardcore Drake stans and people who enjoyed his music but ultimately see how bland and repetitive it has become.

Andrew Shaktah

Tropical Fuck Storm totally screwed up the album art on their latest release by including a picture of themselves on the front and breaking the pattern of pure ugly chaos they’ve had on their first two albums that actually helps capture what their sound is. All I can think of is Danny Brown on uknowwhatimsayin popping up behind them too

NevadaNate

It's definitely a downgrade, it looks like they pivoted to making synth pop or something

Drake Parker

That’s implying that Kanye put out one of his worst works.

Leo Swan

They arent actually listening closely to the music. They dont care, its just catchy. This is why mainstream pop is a thing. Most people dont care that much about the intricacies of music or how much depth what they are listening to has. They just want something that is catchy, which is a perfectly fine way to consume music. Everyone is different.

Leo Swan

Why would album rollout be a determining factor in this? An album could still be amazing with little to no rollout. I feel like thats kind of a separate topic and shouldnt go into assessing whether or not an artist is ā€œbetterā€ than another. Once you talk about album rollouts the line becomes blurred on what else can be a factor, ie music videos, live shows, merch, other artistic ventures. Album rollouts are a skill in and of themselves that have very little to do with the actual music

Leo Swan

I will say though I think kendrick has made a better album than any ye album in tpab but I agree overall that Kanye is the better artist given his extensive list of classic songs and albums

Leo Swan

Probably the god speed section of perfect circle / god speed or once a day or good news

Leo Swan

Let it Die is easily the best Feist album and is one of the best albums of the 2000s. Songs like gatekeeper, let it die, lonely lonely, and now at last (just to name a few) are hauntingly beautiful. The album has such a stripped back and intimate sound to it and the song writing is flawless. It has a perfectly cohesive sound and still a large enough amount of variety to make the pacing work. It sounds like a simplistic album but the instrumental choices and smaller details really elevate it to an otherworldly level. Still noticing nuances to it several years later. It strikes a perfect balance of familiarity and exploration without overdoing any element. It also has one of the best covers of the 2000s (inside and out). I would give let it die a 10/10 undoubtedly.

Leo Swan

Its obviously not the BEST but 2021 has been pretty damn good. Best year since 2016 maybe even earlier

Leo Swan

Probably kendrick coming soon as well

Ryan P

Just from the way he has been talking about it and how excited he is to come out with something. At Rolling Loud he said this: "I've been working tremendously in a black out state on my new album, I've been losing my mind going so hard on this shit and I love it. I love every fucking moment of it. I can't wait to come back and perform new music for you guys. I can't wait to bring the new rage to you guys, I can't wait to introduce you to a new formula." In another interview he said this: "I’m working with some new people and I’m just trying to expand the sound. I’ve been making beats again, rapping on my own beats and just putting everything together and trying to grow it really. That’s been one of the most fun things about working on this album. I’m evolving, collaborating with new people and delivering a whole new sound and a whole new range." On top of this he seems to be taking his time to really perfect the album (It's been more than 3 years since his last studio project, Astroworld) which is rare for most mainstream artists now. Also if there is any doubt he can release a solid project because of any singles he's recently dropped, he's explained that he's more of an album artist in another interview: "I definitely care more about making albums than just dropping songs. I like dropping songs as much as I wanna drop them, but I love albums — I grew up on them." I'm excited to see what he comes out with

Jordan Fairbairn

I actually, somewhat agree with sza’s and sevdaliza’s take on work commitments in the music industry, I just believe it may have been worded poorly. I believe that if an artist is putting extreme amount of hours it is not unfair to expect the same of others such as producers etc.

Gustav Olsson

If Drake drop more projects devoid of artistic evolution and interesting songs like CLB, he will eventually start to slowly fade away.

Ryan The Great

The B Side Section of Ziggy Stardust is better than the A Side Section

Leo Swan

Mj in every way šŸ¤·šŸ»

lazarusinashes

TOUGH QUESTION: where is It's Food, Anthony? I miss it :(

toni

mm...food

toni

People should stop forcing their opinions about which album is better than the other, and just listen to the music. If you like it, you like it... Just don't go to Twitter and try to make people agree with your opinion on music, everyone has a different taste...

Leo Swan

That will never happen. Why is it bad to discuss which album is better? Sure there could never be a true objective answer but thats the point, everyone has their own opinion. And yes many of those opinions are just regurgitations of another opinion but who cares? Not like its hurting anyone.

Trace Koziol

Calling an individual reviewer "biased" is a lame criticism because everyone is biased! Part of the appeal of individual reviewers is learning and understanding their biases and tastes. For example I know you hold high expectations for production and mixing, so if you give an album a good review it probably is mixed and produced well.

Jay Kay

saying you can't understand rap music unless your black is like saying you can't understand a female artist unles you are a female

Kyle Cahill

While the red/yellow flannel does get the most attention from viewers in terms of memorable and recognizable attire, we mustn't forget about the other iconic drip in Anthony's back catalog. The tiger shirt, Barbara Streisand shirt, misfits, kirk van Houten, and the Jean jacket vest just to name a few have been just as essential pieces of drip to fantanos brand as the yellow/red flannel

Squanto

There are people out there who say this?

Ean Garvey

The popular early post-hardcore idea that intriguing chord progressions and melodic passages are "cheap tricks to incite emotion" in the place of song structure and instrumental/vocal performance is, while admirable, still just dumb and pretentious. Bands like Portraits of Past managed to pull of some really amazing stuff with this idea but there are examples of music written and performed with the same intensity, synergy, and tension/release that also incorporate chilling/exciting melodic progressions (see Unwound, Converge, Shin Guard, Gospel) that just take the cake in any case. Don't get me wrong, I see the point and all. But it just makes the music less accessible and less fun.

Gustav Olsson

Why is it that you’ve never spoken on a song or an album as being one of the best of all time? You always seem to put it into a category of decade, genre or artist’s discography.

Lauchlan

Friendly fires are underrated

Nick Denhalter

This gonna be weird, but what would it take for an artist like Macklemore to put out an album that’s worthy of a 10. Is it even possible? Is there any artist you would feel comfortable saying they could never make a 10?

Sean.

Before and After Science is a 10 and you know it

Andy

Genuinely curious, do you find music to be more enjoyable under the influence of marijuana or alcohol? Do you consume these things in general?

Garfism

I’ve seen him make it in regards to Discovery by Daft Punk during his tier list video

Aidan Brooks

Do you have any thoughts on what you might do for classics week this upcoming season? Personally, I would love to see some for artists like swans, Pink Floyd, or spiritualized (even though you have covered these artists in the past I would love to see your opinions on their more classic albums) or even some more jazz greats.

Joel Nay

What album from the 90’s do you think would receive the most acclaim if it were released today instead of then?

Alex Gentry

The new Pink Siifu album is everything the Isaiah Rashad album should’ve been.

Justin Scott

You didn’t review ski masks Sin City tape because it was short / you have the same complaints as all of his other releases

Squanto

GY!BE’s Yanqui U.X.O. Is underrated because of it’s dryer production, but it definitely is a more consistent listen than the debut and should be considered top 2 in GY!BE discog.

shrimptech

Pink Floyd has 3 10s and DSotM is not one of them

James Carlisle

I’d say two (WYWH, Animals). I agree that DSOTM isn’t one of them, but I can’t say The Wall is a perfect album