Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Content

HEY, YOU! Yeah you. You look like the type to have a HOT TAKE, UNPOPULAR OPINION, or TOUGH QUESTION. It's burning you up inside, isn't it? You'd better drop it in the comments below and we'll have a look at it next week. Let's go!

In case you missed last month's episode: https://www.patreon.com/posts/lets-argue-kanye-56650979

(Hope you're all well! Thanks for your support this month!)

Comments

Jackson Moeller

Know your onion by the shins sounds very heavily like the police.

Finn Hay

Squid game? More like MID GAME!

Garfism

What’s a song you would like to able to play on bass but is beyond your skill level?

Jordan Fairbairn

Honestly I agree with sevdeliza and sza’s take, they just worded it weirdly

Ben Galvan

Every artist who has had a long career should have a "Bootleg Series". Hearing outtakes/live shows/unreleased songs is essential to appreciating and understanding an artist.

Brayden Borrell

When it comes to heavier music right now it feels like a before and after Spiritbox type of moment. It's obviously not on the same level as a Nirvana but feels similar nonetheless.

NevadaNate

I don't. You don't need forced labor to make good art. The base idea being expressed is irredeemable tbh

Dan Stacy

Yeezus is an incredible album

Cameron Diman

Between The Downward Spiral and The Fragile by Nine Inch Nails I think The Fragile is even more of a classic. The structure, intricacies of the production and more well developed emotional nature of the music and lyrics just give it such a more cohesive and tangible sharpness that's alot less "edgy" in today's standards compared to Downard Spiral. I love both but I'm just interested on your opinions on The Fragile. Also, would love to hear your opinions on Coil! Much love melon

M

Do you think it's possible to make a contemporary proto punk album? the elements of the genre are fairly distinct but it seems to also be indicitve of a specific time. It think it should be possible but it seems like it'd just end up belong labeled indie rock/indie punk etc. Would love to hear your thoughts

Nick

weezer was never bad they just got very inconsistent. there are multiple great songs on almost every “terrible” weezer album

membertatooine

what does your patreon feed look like?

Adam mezzarone

Killer mike is awesome and a phenomenal rapper, but el p is doing like 90% of the work in run the jewels

simon

My top three favorite Eminem albums are SSLP, Relapse and MMLP in order

Jordan Fairbairn

I agree about the forced labour part but I think that no one is truly gonna be comfortable all hours throughout making a record and I don’t believe she meant forced labour as in actual forced labour

HM James

Dr Dog is a severely underrated band that makes good folk rock music. It’s more cheery and sometimes has better ballads than other indie folk bands like Bon Iver or Fleet foxes who always get good reviews yet have mostly sad, mopey ballads. The two albums FATE and Shame, Shame are albums that have some of the greatest folk ballads for the past 15 years.

Dbaziany

I think it is time to acknowledge that “peak trap” as you have called it in the past isn’t a fad and is not going anywhere soon . The use of Trap hi hats drums and booming trap bass has not only changed the way rap music fundamentally is produced (for example old school rappers embracing the sound) but it has now influenced the sound of major pop songs and artists so much that every chart topping song has those elements. plus with MGK blowing up with trap influenced pop punk and with pop country music using the same trap bass in every song, expect those rattling hi hats to stay for quite some time.

Ryan Hayes

Eminem’s Encore is vastly overrhated. Even with all the shit on it it still at least feels like Eminem is comfortable in his sound (something he lost with Relapse onward imo). It’s still got some great tracks, and when Revival exists, how people see it as his worst album is beyond me.

Isaac Furler

Why aren't you wearing in your reviews that beautiful flower shirt from weezer's worst to best no more? I think it deserves the prime place in your wardrobe (even better than yellow flannel)!

tryhard

Everyone’s always asking about your 10s and whether they hold up, but I’m wondering about your strong 9s. Would you rate any of them lower now? Or has time passing even pushed them up to a 10? For reference, I’m talking about: Swans-The Glowing Man Mount Erie-A Crow Looked At Me Ice age-Plowing Into the Field of Love Death Grips-Bottomless Pit A Tribe Called Quest-We Got It From Here
Thank You clipping.-CLPPNG

C

teens of denial is a STRONG 9

Trevor Young

It's chill to get tattoos in homage to your favorite artist/album. It's NOT chill to show those tattoos to the artists themselves backstage or wherever. It comes off too strong, the homage starts to look like obsessiveness, it quickly becomes cringey af, and the artist gets uncomfortable. Usually. Just shake their fucking hand and move on.

C

the new CALassic is the best remix album of all time

Plamen Bogdanov

Can you separate the person from the art? Should you?

Sean L Byrne

How is "...And Justice for All" poorly produced? I was listening to it just the other day, and it's great. Are we listening to the same album?

Plamen Bogdanov

Anthony himself has redone reviews of albums and changed the score. And he's said many times that his feelings towards an album changed. I think it's perfectly fine and normal.

Liam Higgins

You should do a redux review of Faces in honor of the re-release, especially since your opinion has changed on it since its release.

Jack Bayley

Which is better, Parliament or Funkadelic?

Floof Queen Emily

Dubstep (and bass music in general) is going to come back to the mainstream via hyperpop. Artists like Moore Kismet, euphorian, and the upcoming Pleeg EP all have that sound that is PERFECT for hyperpop styled music and it will be what sets off the two genres to fuse more in the future and gain a wider audience.

blackmare

Music critics will look back and call albums like Die Lit and ASTROWORLD the birth of Post-Rap, emphasizing the shift in focus from production complimenting the emcee to the emcee complimenting the production with a focus on atmosphere and "vibes".

James Carlisle

Can you do tier lists more often? Maybe even worst to best?

Dylan

Well you just released a video on this right before I left this comment lol just ignore me

Qaadir King

You’ve never even listened to music before. whole channel cap. đŸ˜€đŸ˜€đŸ˜€

maxM@x

Copyright take downs are killing the industry, so all large social media should have a scriptable copyright verification process. Aka artists write use and licencing of their works agreements and not Google, Facebook, and Tiktok. All copyrighted works should be required to be submitted to a copyright database if they want to be accepted. And when they expire they can't be claimed against like the ignobel debacle where Warner music and 16 other publishers copyright struck a 1914 recording which was likely sampled by some artist, but which they had no claim over.

Max Cheval

Although MF DOOM is one of my favorite rappers and one of the most influential rappers of all time, he only has four great albums: Operation Doomsday, MM...Food, Madvillainy, and Take me To Your Leader. All the other ones tried to get back into that style that he had, but they just fell short, and sometimes are very hard to listen to. Rest in Peace to the villain, but I just had to say it.

Jess Williams

A lot of people in this community joke about stealing you opinions, a common joke being “unfortunately I already formed my own opinion on this one melon”. While I’m sure your influence on others’s opinions is overblown, what sort of action do you take/language you use in your reviews to help minimize this (if any)?

Lousey

You said in your To Be Kind review that you perceive it as being superior to the post rock material from Soundtracks for the Blind, (and by extension the entire 2+ trilogy). In what ways has your opinion on Soundtracks changed? What do you think of so many people labeling it as Swans masterwork? PS. I am totally fishing for a future classics review :p

bressig

is it "Deftones" like "Def Jam" (so "excellent sounds") or is it actually pronounced "deft ones" and we've just been saying it wrong this whole time

Josh

The original mix of AJFA has little to no bass in the mix. This last minute decision by Lars to make the audio engineer almost completely drop the bass tracks from the album makes it sound very tinny and empty compared to Ride the Lightning or Master of Puppets, let alone the Black Album. The bass has been made slightly louder in the remaster, but it is almost entirely choked out by the rest of the band, which is really sad because Jason fucking killed that album and their s/t.

BuBullen

it’s food 3. i will not be ignored melon

Josh

Jason Newsted's bass tracks on AJFA and the Black Album are better than Cliff's on Ride the Lightning and Master of Puppets. Too bad you can't hear half of them 🙃

Sam Horton

WLR will pioneer the post rap movement.

Owen W

Will we get themed episodes of Patreon-only Let's Argue?

LIfeinthezone

Since it's october- SPOOKY MUSIC GOES HARD. Speicficially, spooky 'beeps and boops'. Fear of Music? Filled with spooky beeps and boops. one of their best albums. A lot of CLIPPINGS best stuff is FILLED with spooky beeps and boops. Billie Eilish's biggest hit is notable for its spooky beep boops.

punkish_hiphop

Without nu metal, metal would be in a worse state than now, especially when it comes to popularity. It is true that a lot of nu metal sucked in the 2000s, but also true that they significantly expanded the metal fanbase. They also contributed many new musical ideas even if they were hated by gatekeepers. Bands like Slipknot/Deftones/Linkin Park/SOAD/Korn and even Limp Bizkit really deserves credit for newer interpretations of metal for both insiders and outsiders of the genre. (i.e. Newer bands like Code Orange, and rappers like $uicideboy$) Essentially, nu metal made heaviness look cool again to an audience that was moving away from such aesthetic. For a sub genre considered to have killed everything metal, it might have provided the blueprint for the way forward from now without us even realizing it.

Dodecatron

Begin by The Millennium is hands down the greatest sunshine pop album of all time, and deserves more love and recognition outside of the RYMsphere. Really Curt Boetcher as a whole.

Ryan The Great

It was the only 6 that made it to the best decade list.

Nigel Robinson

"Bonito Generation or Time 'n' Place" is "The Blue Album vs Pinkerton" for gen Z femboys.

MC Emerson

Technical proficiency should NOT be the end-all be-all in prog rock/metal.

JADEFACE

Lloyd Banks release one of the best hip hop albums of 2020 (The Course of the Inevitable). It received so much positive reception from other major rappers and you didn’t even review it because you slept on him like most of the general audience

Herbieguy

Randy Newman doing Disney soundtracks was a huge mistake. Newman is a fantastic, witty and clever songwriter and his work has been covered by countless other great performers (including Nina Simone, Harry Nilsson, and Joe Cocker among many others.) But thanks to those god damn Disney soundtracks, most contemporary listeners are going to reduce his legacy down to just being the 'You Got a Friend in Me' guy and that is a travesty. Doing kids movie soundtracks was beneath his skill level.

Chrisp

Good takes on this thread. Here’s mine: Pitchfork is missing ANY sort of credibility when it comes to metal or heavy music in general, and I find it makes them look foolish in the grand scheme of music criticism. Similarly, the rock/metal only publications like Kerrang and Loudwire just come across as out of the loop, which makes it difficult for me personally to trust their opinion.

Herbieguy

I just feel like that song in particular isn't a song someone would want to be their signature.

ToadMan101

I gotta be honest, for a rock band to have been considered legends, I don't hear much about The Who in that regard. That band is one of my favorite bands of all time. They created such legendary songs like 'My Generation', 'Baba O'Riley', 'Won't Get Fooled Again' and 'Pinball Wizard', practically invented the rock opera with Tommy, and has performed at some of the most iconic music festivals/events of all time. (Woodstock; Isle of Wight; Monterey; Live Aid) Also, in my personal opinion, I think that Who's Next is one of the greatest albums to have ever been made. All in all, just an amazing rock band that were iconic in their own right, and it's such a shame that I don't hear many people talking about The Who on the same level as bands from their era like The Beatles and The Rolling Stones.

Jake Bell

Led Zeppelin has a lot of allegations concerning plagiarism. Personally, it doesn’t affect my listening experience because I mainly enjoy listening to Led Zeppelin because of the passion, production and overall mind melting instrumentation. What are your thoughts?

Sam Rud

Xardinal Coffee by EXUM deserved a full review. It’s a great album IMO. Arrest the Dancer is one of my favorite songs of the year.

Sam Rud

Will we ever get a Prince Worst to Best?

Vipul Konnur

I don't really see why people restrict their year end lists to "one per artist" as often as they do. If the artist has managed to make incredible music more than once then that in itself is a feat worthy of recognition.

Camden Stokes

Born to run is a classic and the fact that you haven’t done a video on it is disgraceful

raoul

joe hisaishi makes the best film music. by far

Stefan Lal

If you’re going to do a redux in the future, I think M.I.A.’s MAYA is the most deserving one for it

Eskateerr Publishing

Americans that hate country music really just hate people who grew up and live in rural areas....this can also be applied to people who live in Latin American cities.

Uncle Jam

Any album with anti-vaxxer lyrics should get a 0 on principle. (Or at least a 5.) Of course, there’s craft and aesthetics to consider, and when it comes to black artists, there’s horrifying history in America that shouldn’t be ignored. (And it’s not like you’re reviewing that much anti-vax music anyway.) But the bottom line is that these artists are using their talents to spread potentially lethal ignorance, and no degree of artistry excuses that.

Justin Scott

Tyler the Creator’s CORSO deserves Best Song of the Pandemic.. for having a bar that ends w Maxine, and NOT rhyming it with vaccine

Isaac Myers

Although obviously not better then GKMC, Macklemore’s ‘The Heist’ was honestly the second best choice out of all the other rap nominees that year đŸ€·â€â™‚ïž

Jonathan McFall

Tyler, the Creator is the true Kanye protégé, not Travis Scott. Although his style is slightly different, his execution when it comes to grandiose, larger-than-life albums (in the Hip-hop world) is almost completely unmatched. Specifically, his last three releases have been near flawless in my eyes. He is an incredibly versatile rapper and producer. Not to mention, he produces 99% of his albums himself. Besides Kanye, you'd be hard-pressed to find another rapper/producer as skilled and versatile as Tyler, the Creator. His influence on current teen culture is also relatively overlooked.

Andrew C Davey

Your interview with Lido Pimienta was a jumping off point for me to dig a lot deeper into a lot of amazing latin music both new and old. In that interview it sounded like we might be hearing a little bit more review content from that world, but I haven't seen much of anything since. Did you hear the amazing late 2020 debut project for the group Okan - Espiral? Any plans on trying to get an interview with Ivy Queen about her new podcast on the history of ReggaetĂłn?

Dylan

is there anything in ichiko aoba’s back catalogue that would’ve been a 10 (or close) had you reviewed it on release?

Austin Eli Wilke

The new Tyler record is easily his best album yet, the production is way more fun and infectious to the ear then IGOR. Along with the playful attitude in the album that always feels like it’s changing pace with new types of features and styles. But throughout all of this you can still hear him string along hints of the narrative he builds up too near the end about his experience with the girl he ends up falling for. Igor is an amazing album, but Call Me When You Get Lost is a perfect record.

Alex Gentry

Frank Ocean is the new D’Angelo. They both released two of the most beloved pop/neo soul records of their time within a 4-5 year gap in between and seemingly went on hiatus after those albums. I wouldn’t be surprised if we have to wait another 14 years for a Frank album just like we did for D’Angelo.

Sean

Hey Anthony today's my birthday

N

When are we getting the Sparks tier list?

Jon Hoskins

Mindless Self Indulgence is a significant influence on hyperpop. The electro/punk/rap music styles meshed with absurdist humor. I think it's important to acknowledge MSI's influence on modern hyperpop. Fuck Jimmy Urine tho

Anthony Showalter

Do you believe upbeat, hyperactive J-pop like Kyary Pamyu Pamyu had an influence on the current wave of hyperpop or am I trippin'?

Sam Rud

Ratchet Happy Birthday is a top 10 Drake song.

Atticus

Happy birthday!

Atticus

I know this question is asked frequently but: Have you listened to The Caretaker's "Everywhere at the end of time" yet? (I consider this a tough question because the album is tough).

Sid Mullendore

janes addiction did the alternative nirvana thing first and were just as popular and just as good the only reason history remembers the 90s as the nirvana thing is kurt died

Joshua Hartman

Van Halen is the most influential rock band post-Led Zeppelin

Drake Parker

You singlehandedly made Nav popular, even if almost all of his attention is just for trolling and memes. No one would care about Nav as an artist without your Not Good’s

Preston Richey

What do you make of the idea that honey could be considered vegan since bees are not killed in its production and are able to freely leave whenever they want? (I have no horse in this race, just genuinely curious your thoughts)

Adrian Vargas

Now that Faces is arriving to streaming services & vinyl, (which by the way, did you pre-order a copy? >.>) do you think Faces will now receive the recognition it deserves?

Kyle Cahill

As important as an album that gets a 10 is to your fan base, I feel like they underrate when an album gets a 9

Chris Hickson

Any good ideas on where to start in the Unwound discography? There seems to be a ton of diversity in the discography and I have no clue where to begin

Justin Scott

You missed a bit of the point on CMIYGL. The lack of concept and being braggadocios seemed to not strike a cord with you, but there absolutely was a concept. Tyler’s take on a traditional, braggadocios rap album. Plus having all the money, cars and things, but still can’t get the girl. Maybe WILSHIRE does feel slightly misplaced, but other than that, not giving it a 9 was a huge miss. And DJ Drama lining the walls of the album was total gold

Dylan

as a follow up question, do you think an album like ichiko’s older albums (guitar and vocals only, in a language that i’m pretty sure you don’t understand) is capable of getting a 10? would there be too little there instrumentally and/or would the language barrier prevent that?

Ryan P

Igor is a better album in my opinion. The track list is so much tighter. The features fit amazingly. The character of Igor and the whole love story behind it. The mix and beats fit perfectly with the character and the theme and the 80s style behind it. Everything just meshes perfectly. It’s like you’re listening into the world of the character he’s portraying. Call me if you get lost is much less of a concept album and that’s completely fine. He was going for a fun rap album as a one off departure from his normal concept albums. I think it honestly fits extremely well in his discography, but it isn’t as thorough as Igor.

Austin Eli Wilke

I’d slightly disagree that there isn’t as much of a concept behind Call Me, he just is no longer playing a character. Instead it tells the story of Tyler trying to surround himself in all of his money and fame after the events that transpired with the girl we learn about at the end of the album. If you look at the songs there are multiple lines that seem random and not fitting to the track that usually come down to him missing someone, which we learn is the girl. It’s true there is less of a focus on the narrative now but I still believe there is one. To me it’s always been easier sit through Call Me then Igor when it comes to enjoyment. I still really like Igor though.

simsimma

Coi Leray doesn’t deserve all the hate she is getting. Her recent tweets about feeling bullied were concerning and the internet (twitter) needs to care more about not dog piling people who are openly stating they are not handling stuff very well. Makes me feel sad- we seem to have lost our humanity just recently.

Cole

Best mr bungle album is self titled, if all the shitting and fart noises were taken out

Cole

Also Primus’ sound is defined just as much by their guitarist as their bass in my opinion

Vestrel12

Baby Be Mine is not only the best song on Thriller, it is hands down Michael Jackson's best song

IndieRed

you need to give more credit to MIKE!!! in the alchemist interview you mentioned him passingly as a member of the new wave of abstract hip hop led by earl, when in reality he plays a much bigger part than most having been the primary influence for Some Rap Songs, arguably the most definitive project for this period. regardless of the quality of his material, he's more or less the pioneer of this era in abstract rap and he deserves more attention for it

Kyle Cahill

What is your least favorite song from each of your 10/10 albums

Adrian Romero

You were a little pensive during the Don Toliver reaction. Hopefully it has grown on you, but at the end of the day, respect your opinion and love your content. Also, hopefully you recover from COVID soon, and your loved ones are doing well and safe :)

Liam J

"There's a war going on outside no man is safe from" on Mobb Deep's Survival of the Fittest is the best line referenced in songs even today. It gets used much more than any other line from a song I can think of. Off the top of my head I can name Introvert - Little Simz, Murder to Excellence - Kanye West & Jay Z and another two Jay Z songs with A Ballad For a Fallen Soldier and Welcome to New York City. There's plenty more that I can't think of right now too

Liam J

Don't Matter to Me being Michael Jackson's third most streamed song on Spotify is a crime against humanity

Squanto

You don’t like the Victor Vaughn stuff? Or Born Like This? Damn

Max Wowsick

I genuinely enjoy Welcome to the Madhouse more than Don Toliver’s new album. At least with Welcome to the Madhouse I can laugh at how technically awful it is in every single way. I’ve listened to the Don Toliver album a few times through and it is almost Nav levels of boring. He has a nice voice, but he doesn’t do anything with it on this album.

ChrisJung

Any thoughts on the first two Bruno Mars albums? I see you haven't reviewed them

ChrisJung

Also given how mediocre some of their recent output has come to be, gave a listen to Migos culture 1 and it still holds up

Drake Parker

Curious on your opinion of P!nk’s music. She’s someone you have very rarely if ever spoken about and I think she’s very under appreciated in the pop sphere

Josh

Yankee Hotel Foxtrot is not the best album from 2002. It's not even the best Wilco album.

Rowe Reviews

We need to ban sleepy acoustic closing tracks on albums (i.e. Growth off the new illuminati hotties) Songs like that are always super anticlimactic and do nothing for me. Imagine if the Black Parade ended with Gerard crying over a fingerpicked guitar, it would be weak and boring. A closer should be grand and wrap everything up in a satisfying way, but acoustic songs are too uneventful to do that.

Chris Hickson

I know you only started reviewing King Gizz when Paper Mache Dream Balloon dropped, but do you have any strong thoughts about their discography before that point (i.e. I’m in Your Mind Fuzz, Quarters, Eyes Like the Sky?)

Squanto

Some work really well. Closer to Teens of Denial and Patti Smith’s Horses are great examples

Señor C

She Wolf is a top 5 Halloween themed song

Squanto

What would the best Wilco album be then? I’ve only listen to YHF and I really liked it.

Jack Bayley

Thom Yorke makes some pretty great music, but is a super cringe guy. If you don’t believe me check out his inclusion on the UK quiz show, Big Fat Quiz Of The Year on YouTube. It really hurts to watch!

Pheeeeeeeb

Chester Bennington is an amazing singer and should be up there with the legends of the rock genre

Cameron Diman

Pitchfork giving the Nine Inch Nails album The Fragile a 2 is one of the most absurd music reviews of all time. Doesn't help that the writer was such a massive douchebag and offered no critical insight other than it being "emo" for the harsh score. You have that review as a thumbnail but never actually addressed it so I'd like to hear your opinion on it based on the lil tease alone

James Carlisle

Low is to David Bowie what Kid A is to Radiohead. They both come out of a state of mental/emotional turmoil. They’re both massive left turns into electronic and experimental territory. And they’re both pretty depressing.

VreyIsGrey

That's actually a fairly reasonable comparison, not exactly a hot take

The Needle Drop

His answer was kind of rambly (came at the very end of the shoot) so just gonna answer here: i think he avoids honey, but doesn't see a problem w/ it provided there's no mistreatment of the bees. especially considering how dependent we are on their pollination anyway. as far as his veganism goes, his main concern is the cruelty and negative environmental impact of factory farming. though he did also voice concern for colony collapses and said he's not sure of the honey industry's role in that (nor am i, sorry).

Jack Bayley

Brainiac’s Hissing Priggs in Static Couture was really ahead of its time! Lots of bands like Death From Above 1979 (who are also great) have a lot of the same DNA except happened A LOT later! Just wondering if you have heard of Brainiac and what your thoughts are? BTW the album cover is just about the most 90s thing in history!

Alex Alcalde

Shakira’s early work before she was only making pop bangers for Americans, was actually some of the best music of the 90’s.

Kyle Cahill

Would you ever put a song from reviewing your music on your best singles of the year list?

VreyIsGrey

What are your thoughts on the new Sungazer album?