Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Content

Thank you all for supporting us this month; hope you're doing well! Now's that magical time when you hit us with your HOT TAKES, UNPOPULAR OPINIONS, and TOUGH QUESTIONS! Drop 'em in the comments below and we'll take a gander next week. Let's go!

In case you missed last month's episode: https://www.patreon.com/posts/lets-argue-its-3-58051263

Comments

Adam mezzarone

Fade outs are just cop outs for when artists dont know how to end their song

James Kelly

I don’t know if I’d call it underrated but No Heroes by converge deserves to rank much higher in their discography than it usually gets credit for

Ryan The Great

Any 9s you consider to be a 10 by now

Mitchell Martin

Every version of a song titled Lets Go Brandon is proof conservatives can’t make good music!

Jackson Moeller

Do you like the original version of space girl or the one with the Chloe moriondo feature better ?

Lousey

The Lamb Lies Down On Broadway is a masterful piece of prog rock and better than The Wall.

punkish_hiphop

People defending Travis by saying festivals "are always like that" are dumb. Slipknot headlined Knotfest LA on the 6th, no injuries & great experience. If a metal band like Slipknot can pull it off, there is absolutely no reason Travis Scott couldn't have. Travis stans are valuing entertainment over human life and it is disgusting.

Paul

I missed your overrated guitarists segment, but I still would like to submit Kirk Hammett for your consideration. The influence is undeniable but most of his solos are dragged out pentatonic scales with a wah-pedal. James is the brains behind Metallica's riffs and is the best guitarist in the band by a fucking mile.

Alex

Regarding Lingua Ignota's recent comments about Alexis being abusive, does it affect your opinion of his work with Daughters? I mean it's no surprise, given how dark and crushing YWGWYW is, and it must have been based on some terrible experience. Do you fear that the band/Alexis gets "cancelled" if Kristin one day decides to come forward with allegations? P.S I love both these artists and it's a shame that it ended that way.

bressig

The only way to make good money as a musician in the streaming era is playing in a cover band

JWY

The trombone is a trash-tier wind instrument. This thing sounds like a flaccid trumpet after too many drinks. It looks like a janky medieval instrument that history was meant to be improved upon, but didn't.

Herbieguy

(I've always wanted to do this): David Bowie's "Pinups" is the most worthless album to be made by an otherwise talented musician. Every song on the album completely boring and below Bowie's skill level, and there was no reason for him to make an album that devoid of creativity. Along with that, unlike other weaker albums from Bowie (S/T 67, Never Let Me Down) it doesn't have any undeniably highlights or show his evolution and growth as an artist. And if all that weren't bad enough, it cockblocks what could have been the greatest discography streak in rock history (Space Oddity -> Scary Monsters). It is the definition of a disposable album. You would gain more listening to a 40 minute compilation of white noise. It's an album that screams "I'm out of ideas!" from a man that clearly had so many ideas still left in him. If it weren't for The Laughing Gnome, Pinups would be the most embarrassing thing his legacy left behind.

Matthew Wisniewski

Anthony, what happened to the orange flannel? The world needs to know!

ElephantofDoom

The poser bands mocked in the song "Fake Tales of San Francisco" now describes Arctic Monkeys themselves

Rom Jan

Saying: " ______ is the best album of all time" is stupid, considering no one has listened to all the albums in existence. šŸ¤·šŸ»ā€ā™‚ļø

TheBaseballFur

There have been so many east coast hip hop artists (Mach-Hommy, Armand Hammer, MIKE, Ka, Wiki, etc) that have released this year and thinking back on them there is absolutely nothing setting them apart from each other. Sure theyre perfectly fine on their own but they all follow the same formula of repetitive samples and slow and methodical rapping. Again i like these albums on their own but i wish that they did more to set themselves apart from everyone in their respective genre.

Phoebe Spence

Brockhampton acknowledging their end, and going into making the last album knowing that, is a good thing. The BH era will be well defined and they wont outlive people's interest. It might feel "too soon" to some, but if it feels like the right to them, then I'm glad they're going for it

Owen W

Can you make the hand gesture from the cover of Howl by Swain / This Routine Is Hell from memory?

Jared Ortega

The anger and hate for Travis Scott following the Astroworld tragedy is truly unfounded, or at least premature. I don’t think any of us can truly understand Travis’s perspective on stage. We cannot say what he he saw definitely and we surely cannot say how he perceived what was going on in the crowd. I’m willing to bet the powers that be were in his ear telling him to continue because the show was more than just what was happening in that location as it was being live-streamed on Apple Music. I’m giving Travis the benefit of the doubt of being between a rock and a hard place as he was probably trying to determine if what was going on was isolated events being handled by security and paramedics and being pressured by contracts and the show runners to continue the show. As of now, I place the majority of the blame on Live Nation and event organizers. I know this is Travis’s fest but he surely was not in charge of the logistics such as security and event safety. We won’t know Travis’s perspective until hearings are had (if they happen) and I think everyone jumping to conclusions is unfair. The idea that Travis had this coming because he promotes rage culture is just crazy to me too. Yes, he promotes rage culture as a part of his brand but people need to separate the aesthetic he’s branded his name with and reality. Sipping lean is commonly promoted in hip hop and has lead to multiple deaths as a result but we are not blaming Future for these deaths. At the end of the day you decide to go to a concert and rage so dangerously that people die that’s on you. Pluuuuus, there’s accounts of injections happening to people… everything is so fresh right now and I get that Travis is the face of it so he’s gonna get most of the blame but I really feel for him. He’s a human too and must feel dread at what happened that night.

Stefan Lal

Does your enjoyment or appreciation of music or other forms of art ever get influenced by reviews or opinions of others? Does Fantano get Fantanoed?

lasagna Lover

cLOUDDEAD deserve credit for making the first real cloud rap album long before the movement began.

Ryan

jeff rosenstock has such a timeless voice, even his older works with TASOB and Bomb the Music Industry feels like it could come out today and be just as kickass and make just as much sense

Hogan99

Now that John Frusciante is back in the Red Hot Chili Peppers, their next album will be a classic just like BSSM, Californication, and all the albums he has made with them

Uncle Jam

Let's Argue theme pitch: Defend a weird artist collab you think would actually work. "Billie Eilish would sound good singing a hook on a Griselda song" or something like that. (Note: That example would not actually work.)

IndieRed

what are your thoughts on parannoul? it's been interesting to see an artist with such little known about them become an indie hero of sorts in the past year, and i think it's a great example of how far internet music culture has come that a person doesn't have to build a brand for their music to be widely appreciated

Atom Weiler

Best and worse TV show theme songs, go — my favorite’s Always Sunny

Preston Richey

When it comes to TMBG albums, while both are 10s, Flood is better than Lincoln

James Carlisle

Top 5 David Bowie albums: (5) Heroes (4) Blackstar (3) Station (2) Low (1) Ziggy

Landon Smith

You should review video game soundtracks. Ori and the Will of the Wisps is a strong 10

Adrian Vargas

What artist started off strong & eventually fell from grace that you had high hopes for?

Squanto

GY!BE’s debut album is definitely not their best. It is still a T4 GY!BE, but it’s amorphous song structures can feel way more like incomplete motifs than full-on compositions. In that regard, it’s unique, but it’s certainly not as good as their more well-structured records like that of LYSF or Yanqui.

Vipul Konnur

Only Murders In the Building deserved the hype Squid Game got.

lowkeymatt

Travis Scott should never hold another concert again, at least another Astroworld. His behavior and negligence shouldn’t be encouraged by any venue/organizer

Hollis Roswell

"Hot Shower" is abysmal, but it's the kind of trainwreck-level bad that in a weird way makes it MORE listenable than the rest of the tracks on The Big Day

Gray Lefkowitz

I've been saying this since I started listening to Godspeed, except I wouldn't even put it in their top 5.

Pineal Theband

It's actually rude that you haven't done a Phil Elverum worst to best/tier list yet

Brendan James

I'm thinking about joining the bald brotherhood, what do you recommend for keeping a tight shave?

Gavin

you never talk about rush, but i will say grace under pressure is their best album. it’s front to back bangers, and a great blend of prog rock and new wave. as much as I love their 70s-Early 80s stuff, this is the album i find myself listening to on repeat the most.

D308x

Ice nine kills is breath of fresh air in modern metalcore their campy over the top cheesy horror gimmick is really working for me and it’s so fun how they pay homage to these horror movies .They’re not groundbreaking by any means but if any a genre needs some kind of levity it is metalcore

HM James

Dr Dog is a severely underrated band that makes great folk rock music. It’s more cheery and they have better ballads than other indie folk bands like Bon Iver or Fleet foxes who always get good reviews yet have mostly sad, mopey ballads. The two albums FATE and Shame, Shame are albums that have some of the greatest folk ballads for the past 15 years.

Rossyp

Vision Creation Newsun is a masterpiece and the only good album Boredoms have ever made.

Alex Alcalde

Rank the SĆŗper Smash Brothers Intro songs! Mine goes like this: 1) Melee 2) Brawl 3) Ultimate 4) Wii U 5) SĆŗper Smash N64

Reading101

Power Rangers Battle for the Grid is the best fighting game of the last decade

Sam Horton

Die Lit will be considered a classic in 10 years

MusicEnjoyer8

Donda is Kanye’s best mixed album

Dalton Krause

The St. Vincent song "Los Angeles" rips off the main riff from Love and Rockets' "Kundalini Express" and nobody cares because nobody cares about Love and Rockets, which is a damn shame.

Gray Lefkowitz

Jail Pt. 2 incriminates this comment.

Rom Jan

Melee is bottom tier, and ultimate and brawl is top šŸ¤·šŸ»ā€ā™‚ļø

Drake Parker

The current state of mainstream R&B is very tiresome. Everyone tries to stir up a ā€œT R A P S O U Lā€-esque sound and ā€œvibeā€ and it always sounds so monotonous. While I would make the argument that Bryson Tiller and that album do not receive enough credit for steering modern R&B in the direction that it currently is in, it’s not particularly a very good direction. it’s why you only get so few R&B albums as creative and as standout as Ungodly Hour for example. Bring back real vocalists and creative instrumentation that isn’t just soaking a slow trap beat in reverb for a vibe. Bring back the bridge.

Drake Parker

Bring back your bulky square glasses or I will be forced to unsubscribe unfortunately.

tryhard

James Blake’s best songs in recent years have been the ones where he takes the backseat and lets his features do their thing, especially the rappers. For this reason I’d love to see a Gorillaz-style James Blake album where he just collabs with everyone and acts as more of a producer than a lead.

Squanto

I definitely think it’s better than their recent material, but I have no clue why critics bashed on Yanqui as much as they did. To my ears, it’s barely a step down from LYSF.

Tommy Simmonds

BOOGIE IS BROCKHAMPTONS GOAT IN REGARDS TO SONGS XO

Tommy Simmonds

AMEER WAS DEFINITELY A LOSS BUT I DONT THINK ITS HAD AS BIG AN IMACT ON BH THAN ORIGINALLY THOUGHT X

Oscar Frank JĆørgensen

Joyner Lucas has really hit the bottom, i know ADHD wasn't the best, and even though evolution was a lil' better, i don't ever see him goin to do anything good ever again. Possibly the worst fall-off i've ever experienced. Oh, and i'm sure Eminem have regretted puttin' him in his top 10

Jetson

brawl and melee are tied for me 😭

Jetson

if there is one rap group that I’ve never heard anyone talk about is Jurassic 5, thoughts on J5??? Would love to hear them :)

Chris Hickson

Fuck, marry, kill: Noise, Drone, & Ambient

Drake Parker

Which running joke within your comment sections is your favorite and least favorite? (An example being ā€œNice review Anthony but you didn’t have to ā€¦ā€)

Pheeeeeeeb

Chester Bennington is a top singer ever

Pheeeeeeeb

Kendrick will end his career as the goat and it won't be close

Pheeeeeeeb

Nirvana unplugged in new York was a better live show than queen at live-aid

Cameron Ford

We use hyperbole to capture a feeling that "this is really good!" wouldn't. Like when you're sick you might say "my head is on fire." Its just colorful language my friend

Isaac Furler

I've been always interested how's your year end lists making process looks like. Do you listen to all albums you've put in your loved list playlist again and rank them, or you just look at the score?

Myles

Black Saint and the Sinner Lady is definitely better than The shape of jazz to come, tbh no other avant-garde album is as powerful and emotionally articulate

Squanto

This isn’t hot enough of a take tbh.

Proudi

the 80s revival needs to stop soon. every new artist entering into the genre just sounds like a worse and worse version of the previous. artists like jessie ware and the weeknd have done a fantastic job imo of bringing a nostalgic feeling to modern sounds but there are now way too many artists doing a meh job at trying to replicate such

R0ck3tM4n13

Metallica hasn't made a single worthwhile piece of music since the Black Album. Yes, this includes S&M. Fight me.

Atticus

Travis Scott's Astroworld incident won't hurt his career, and it may even help him.

Aaron

Unorthodox Jukebox is a pretty solid album, most of the tracks find their way to grow on you with their catchy songwriting and Bruno’s compelling vocals, it’s not doing anything original but that’s what he’s been doing for years and he’s just doing it extremely well. Can’t believe it didn’t even deserve a YUNOREVIEW from u melon😢

George Dickens

Though it's getting a bit better, the US (particularly the commercial audience) seems to have a weird aversion to UK hip-hop. The irony is the same kids that ignore it cause they 'can't understand what they're saying' are the same ones who probably only listen to Carti.

Jac

One of the great live shows of all time.

Jac

Mainstream music has lost its sense of humour. Some artists (mostly hiphop) are witty their lyrics, and a few like Weezer goof around occasionally (at least, I hope that's what they're doing) but most take themselves waaay too seriously.

Jac

Autotune is the Botox of music.

Ajay

I disagree with a lot of what Ye talked about on Drink Champs (some of which you highlighted on stream), but feel conflicted when being critical of him. As someone who has helped out in the psychiatric unit of a hospital in the past, what many patients are going through is truly incomprehensible and doesn't receive enough attention from the public. Mental health shouldn't be used as a shield to be a terrible person, but I also feel like empathy and awareness for those with mental health disorders that are truly debilitating or other parts of the brain like neurological disorders are heavily underrepresented currently. It is more accessible and relatable for people to support famous athletes or musicians behind a movement like BLM (which 100% deserves that support), but the disabled or mental health disorder community has very few public figures that have as much reach and thus has a harder time finding representation. Also, while keeping in mind it is unfair to tell someone their mental health issues aren't legitimate, mental health is often taken advantage in the public for some sort of financial/social status gain at the expense of those who really struggle with it daily further delegitimizing it and making it easy to be written off as an 'excuse' So while morally, I am put off by what Kanye does at times, if we take his word of truly being bipolar (and he exhibits most of the hallmarks of the condition), I find most of the criticism towards him usually completely ignores that and can in turn make those with similar conditions feel minimized or unheard.

Lauch1337

Letā€˜s Agree: This is a long Argument

Ajay

To clarify, I am not saying those diagnosed with conditions such as bipolar disorder, autism, tourettes, or other similar conditions which significantly affect behavior can't be criticized at all. Just that it seems the general public doesn't have much empathy towards these groups and most of the time, it feels help or encouragement for this is relegated to the confines of a doctor's office or perhaps let's medicate them to the point where they don't feel much so they don't cause issues for the 'normal' people. Hope that makes sense.

Cardsfan52

Tom Waits > Bruce Springsteen

Thomas Weighill

If you take a perfect ten album and replace one song with a stinker, the worst song the artist has ever made, what’s the most likely new score?

James Carlisle

I don’t think Hunky Dory is a top five David Bowie album. It’s a very good album but there are a few weak tracks here and there, and in the grander scheme, it’s not as influential as Ziggy, Station, Low or Heroes, nor is it as ambitious as Blackstar.

Austin Gaines

Even though it wasnt technically a single, the virality of Life Goes On by Oliver tree along with its hit music video should qualify it for the worst singles of the year list. it's one of his worst songs ever, so incessant and repetitive

Sheena

It seems like popularity plays a large part in the reception and opinion of older albums in the internet music fan communities (your community, rym, etc) when compared to newer music. Regularly often an album of the past maybe 30 years that maybe didn't sell very well is lauded and recommended. However, when it comes to the 60's and 70's, it's most commonly The Beatles, Beach Boys, Bowie, Pink Floyd, etc. Obviously there are exceptions, but I'm speaking generally. I wish there was more love for stuff like The Monks, John Fahey, Fifty Foot Hose, Blue Cheer (and lots more including many that I don't know, I'm sure). I do realise many of the reasons for this (probably age of listeners at the foremost), but it's still disappointing.

Squanto

2003 was the best year for music during the 2000s, while 2008 was the worst based off of how eventful the years were respectively.

Squanto

I think a lot this is due to the ā€œindieā€ or underground scene not being as prevalent. Nowadays, it’s much more popular to go back and listen to indie albums from the 90s and 00s because there was a properly formed scene for that type of stuff. There wasn’t really one back in the 1960s and it took decades for any of that stuff to get any attention. In a way, the internet has made people more open minded or appreciative of independent music.

Kirby of Rivia

I agree somewhat. A ton of new ideas following 2000s. Whilst the more noteworthy projects where in the former half there is still some outstanding stuff later on. (My fav album is from 2003)

Squanto

A lot of my favorite albums of that decade were from 2003.

Andrew Shaktah

I can’t be the only one who absolutely hates fake record skips/dust in songs when they’re pressed to vinyl. I’d much rather the noise is removed and is possibly replaced by my own record’s unique dust and white noise. Looking at you Avalanches. Makin my records sound dirty n shit

Squanto

He’s asking for hot takes.

Caspa

Knowing how Problematic Phil Anselmo of Pantera is do you pretty much block out his vocals and just listen to the instrumentation from the rest of the band or just discredit the song lyrics if they touch to close to Phil's ideology?

juan granados

Elucid killed JPEGMAFIA on leopards and no ones ganna mention it cause Peggy is a cool guy

Drake Parker

Jail is what Runaway wanted to be

Kimchi G

Arcane's soundtracks are overproduced and fun at the same time

Rowe Reviews

How do you feel about your Floral Shoppe review all these years later? It's funny seeing you so skeptical of vaporwave's staying power at the time when the genre as such a HUGE cult following now. I know you respect the genre now, but were you surprised to see it stick around?

Roland Webster

ā€œSo I Wanna know?ā€ Is culturally the Gen Z equivalent of ā€œCreepā€

Corey G

You addressed It's food 3, now its time for the real one: Pink Floyd Worst to Best

Mack Boswell

Drake is not a top 5 2010’s rapper/artist

Grandgregtauro

ARTISTS LIKE TION WAYNE, HEADIE ONE, DIGGA D, CENTRAL CEE FREDO AND ABRA CADABRA ETC. ARE LEADING THE WAY WITH UK DRILL AND HAVE TAKEN ADVANTAGE OF THE POPULARITY OF POP SMOKE WHO MADE THE UK DRILL SOUND MAINSTREAM IN THE STATES. WITH TION WAYNE GETTING A COMBINED 135 MILLION VIEWS ON HIS SONG BODY (and the remix) UK DRILL IS MAKING A REAL STATEMENT IN THE STATES. IN A FEW YEARS WE WILL SEE UK RAPPERS BE ESTABLISHED IN MAINSTREAM CULTURE IN THE STATES.

Samantha

Kesha's older songs are great and still slap to this day. They may just but substanceless party anthems but they're extremely catchy and fun, and Kesha was especially good at writing bridges. Your Love Is My Drug will always be my go-to Karaoke song

Joel Nay

You’ve probably answered this before, but who are some of your favorite bass players?

Leo Swan

The wiggles are the greatest artists of all time

Jordan Fairbairn

Kelela needs to make a comeback for the electronic/rnb and trip-hop genre. Like we have artists like sevdaliza, banks and eartheater dropping but if kelela drops she would kill it!!