Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Content

Thanks so much for all your support this month! Now's that magical time when you hit us with your HOT TAKES, UNPOPULAR OPINIONS, and TOUGH QUESTIONS! Drop 'em in the comments below and we'll look through them next weekend. Let's go!

In case you missed last month's episode: https://www.patreon.com/posts/lets-argue-is-it-63109903

Comments

LIfeinthezone

Ye has reached a point where the music isn't even worth the hijinks.

Jackson Moeller

What are your thoughts on reviewing movie sound tracks. In my opinion I feel that some soundtracks like the Forrest Gump soundtrack is more of a compilation of songs from “various artists” but soundtracks like into the spider verse where the songs are made for the film itself and the black panther film where most of it is Kendrick Lamars input I consider albums as if an artist dropped an album ?

TheBaseballFur

"How to write an alt-j song" is the best musical parody every created

Dodecatron

sunshine pop revival is imminent

Preston Richey

The skits on Late Registration are significantly better than the ones on College Dropout, especially on relistens

Calum Hughes

Vaporwave is not dead! Vaporwave is life!

bressig

DJ Khaled is a talentless hack

Navarrm

Scatman John’s Scatman’s World is the 90’s version of Angelic 2 the Core.

Ryan

Jeff Rosenstock is one of the most consistent artists of all time. From his work with Bomb the Music Industry to the ASOBS to his solo material and even his duo works with laura stevenson and chris farren and more, he has maintained a timeless sound and wonderful song writing paired with unique and amazing vocals.

tar meat breadnest

Orchestral or "epic" renditions/covers of popular songs usually butcher the original song. Who the hell wants to listen to a slow, dramatic version of Smells Like Teen Spirit?

Diego Bernal

Where would Anthony Fantano be right now if he wasn't a music critic?

Loomityy

"Punk" is probably the most overused descriptor of music. Everything from grunge to metal to hard rock is punk supposedly. That's not to mention conservatives calling themselves punk 🤮

Bennett Gottesman

I’m new here by Gil Scott heron is grossly underrated in music nerd circles. New York is killing me is one of the best songs of the 2010s

Bentheath

Somebody to Love by Queen is a far more enjoyable song than Bohemian Rhapsody

Jackson Keeley

Where would Anthony Fantano be right now if he wasn't a wallet salesman?

Max Wowsick

I don’t think Epic’s acquisition of Bandcamp is going to be as bad as most people are making it out to be. It seems like they may be taking a more hand-off approach, and I think the extra funding may lead to a better Bandcamp as time goes on (yes, I know this is copium and this very well may age poorly).

Sam Pantalone

hot take: If drake actually put effort into his music in the past 5 years he could've gone down as a top 10 hip hop artist

Titas Mičiulis

What are your thoughts on a potential Anthony Fantano score AI that would provide an accurate (or somewhat similar) score on an album based on your previous reviews? Does the idea of an Anthony Fantano bot interest you as an investment for easier work? Would it continue reviewing albums even after the real TheNeedleDrop project comes to an end? Would it cause potential to ruin your career FOREVER???

Zach Stolpa

Echos silence patience and grace is one of the more underrated rock albums of the 2000’s and arguably the best foo fighters project.

Christina Kelley

This is kind of expanding on the question you answered on last month’s Let’s Argue, but would you consider it morally acceptable to continue to listen to Daughters/Alexis Marshall considering (and for legal’s sake I’ll say allegedly) Alexis was a much more active participant in his abuse and is trying to avoid taking responsibility or making things right? Personally, with time I feel like I’ll be able to one day reproach records like YWGWYW once time has past and enjoy it for its artistic merits, but the idea of listening to them now so soon after Kristen came forward makes my stomach churn and I don’t think I’ll ever be able to return to projects that were directly about abuse like “Hell Songs”

Jay Wilson

nah i agree. bandcamp being mission-focused and low-cost (ie less money for them) must mean they have a hard time competing for good tech talent. no shade to the folks who work there ofc - i’d go there in a heartbeat - but i imagine that’s why they’ve been slow to roll out impt features, like queueing and playlists. getting acquired by epic might mean they can latch on to epic’s resources, which would be huge for them.

Cat

Artists should stop putting skits in their albums. Album skits are almost never executed well, and the vast majority of times makes an album worse by including them. It is extremely difficult to pull one off without being cringey as fuck, especially when it's the artist themselves performing them (see: Something for Thee Hotties by Meg). Speeding Bullet 2 Heaven is a great example of how bad skits can be. They don't improve an album or contribute to the narrative enough to be worth the artistic risk.

Cat

Correct take

Macy M

Didn't you tweet something a while ago about a book deal? Any updates on that? Or is it all Top Secret™️?

Jasmin

Katy Perry's popularity will be viewed as a brief fad of the 2010s if she doesn't radically change her persona and musical style for her next album cycle. She was a great pop act for the era she came up in–her songs were catchy and she honed the visual-driven spectacle of a popstar–but her music was never distinct enough to prompt much long-term esteem. Her resistance to evolve as an artist the way her contemporaries (Gaga, Taylor, Rihanna, etc.) from the last decade have makes her look like a one-trick pony, and the appeal of that one trick was exhausted a long time ago.

Herbieguy

I don't care what Hip Hop Twitter says, 50 Cent was the worst thing to happen to 2000s rap music. If the D- tier Dre beats and wet cardboard personality weren't bad enough, he inspired a bunch of other equally boring, short-careered rappers of that time to flood the radios with terrible, bland club rap that was too stiff, slow, and devoid of fun to even work as party music. It's no wonder most of the best hip hop of that decade was underground.

nexus1sm

you look awful today

nexus1sm

you look great today

Jed

What do you think of this new wave of rock/post-punk in terms of its trajectory? Especially considering the rising popularity of artists such as Black Country, New Road and Wet Leg, do you think this could be a turning point in rock music and even find mainstream success, or will the trend fizzle out in a couple of years? I'm curious to know what you think.

NevadaNate

You've praised Sticky Fingers by The Rolling Stones in the past, so I have always wondered how you deal with "Brown Sugar." I have struggled for years as I love that album, and the sound of the song is great, but the lyrics are in shockingly bad taste. Mick Jagger himself seems to regret writing it and claims he was just trying to be edgy. I try to ignore it or see a greater purpose to the song, or buy into the narrative that it's critical of the protagonist, but to this day it kinda kills the vibe. What are your thoughts on it?

James Carlisle

Are there any albums you initally gave a 9 that you think are 10s now?

James Carlisle

Broke Phi Broke, We Ain’t Got It!

Zach Stolpa

Agreed unless it’s done like how for example GKMC did skits which more was to progress narrative while also staying within the boundaries of the album usually they don’t end up well

Daniel Segal

The White Stripes are the best "rock 'n' roll" band to do it since Zeppelin. btw, you should update the tier list to include Jack's solo work and The Raconteurs.

Daniel Segal

Choose one: Cocteau Twins or Beach House.

Tommy Simmonds

Nonagon Infinity is the best psych/garage rock album of the 2010s x

Drake Parker

I think people throw around the term “dick riding” so insanely loosely these days in the music discussion world. Since when is it seen as a bad thing to support and praise your favorite artists? Sometimes when you do even just the smallest bit of reaching when it comes to justifying an artist’s actions or musical decisions, people will immediately accuse you of dickriding as if you’re supposed to keep your mouth shut about everything. People have really let the meaning of fandom slip away from their minds and just they’ll throw out the word dickriding whenever someone shows even just the slightest bit of praise towards an artist.

IndieRed

never see me again by kanye being turned into somewhat of a joke that people throw around as self-deprecating humor is insanely disrespectful and proves why he never released it. even if the rumor behind that song's existence isn't true, to have such a vulnerable and potentially tragic point in someone's life boiled down to being known as "that suicidal song" is terrifying in the grander scheme of how the public views mental health and how artists are treated as human beings

Tyler Craig

Cocteau Twins by a mile. Robin was incredibly innovative with guitar effects creating atmosphere and melody’s. Liz Fraser is one of the greatest and most angelic vocalists to ever walk this Earth.

Tyler Craig

Is a 10/10 album different as a “perfect” album? Also can a “perfect”album be called that if it’s not that particular artists best work?

Tyler Craig

Who is the first artist that comes to your mind when you think about a “perfect discography”?

Jordan Mathieson

How does the other albums released around the same time effect your review process? Recent example would be the Big Thief vs Beach House. 2 double albums, but you called Big Thief an easier listen for the length vs Beach House which you said felt long. Is that distinction amplified because you are listening to both albums at the same time? Both on my early shortlist for AOTY btw.

Squanto

Supreme Balloon is massively overlooked in the Matmos catalog because it doesn’t adhere to what they are normally known for: sampling strange objects to make music. However, it has the most vibrant and colorful production to land on any Matmos record (Rainbow Flag, Polychords, Mister Mouth). It also has some of their boldest ideas (the mind blowing title track). It does all this while managing to be incredibly vast and fun sounding. Pretty overlooked album from the 2000s if you ask me (as well as a group).

j

'I am Made of Chalk' by Crystal Castles deserved to win a grammy

Hogan99

You have claimed to like "Old Kanye" more than "New Kanye", but you gave MBDTF a 6, and you have openly admitted Graduation to be one of his most dated projects, and you loved TLOP, YE, KSG, and you liked Donda. Something doesn't add up there...

Kegan Padot

What’s your favorite song by an artist you otherwise don’t enjoy?

LukeOnDemand

ever since the terms "W", "L", and, god help us, "mid", became popular on the internet, online music discussion has gone downhill. someone describing a record with these one word terms is just as bad as someone saying an album is *blank number* out of 10 and then continuing to not further explain why they gave that album that specific score

Charles Wynn

After watching Leaving Neverland, I think it's a legitimate, reasoned position to still question "how guilty" MJ was concerning his pedophilia court cases, if you really dig into researching court documents, etc. and move beyond just reading the headlines and believing current public opinion which seems ready to write him off as "definitely guilty". Also... I think Off the Wall may be his best album. At least the most singularly consistent thematically with strong material, start to finish. Thriller may have "higher highs", but also has some duds too, hence the win for OTW.

Fred Rio

The “it sounds bad because it’s SUPPOSED to sound bad” argument is so tired. I think there’s a lot of artistic value in intentionally off/ugly sounds if they’re executed properly (the songwriting/production/instrumental/etc is still good) - but a lot of people come to the defense of songs they acknowledge are bad “because the artist was trying to make a point about ~xyz~” or some other “deeper meaning” stuff. It’s all subjective at the end of the day, but a greater theme/message should never come at the cost of a quality song

Alex Sim

Should we worry that Joanna Newsom's importance to the 21st century indie scene is going to fade over time because her catalog isn't available to stream?

membertatooine

I think a lightning bolt tier list would be rad. Shed some light on a super underrated band that should be talked about more within the goat circle.

Squanto

You need him to tell you Wonderful Rainbow is S-Tier?

Squanto

Some skits add a lot of character to an album like Stankonia.

Chris Hickson

What are your thoughts on the early King Gizzard albums? If memory serves correct you started reviewing them around the time Paper Mache Dream Balloon dropped but would love to get your opinions on stuff like I’m in Your Mind Fuzz, Quarters, etc.

Dirty Randy

Once Twice Melody - I don't like it. The whole thing is just washed out and follows the exact same progression. When you finally get a break from the overbearing instrumental on Through Me in the beautiful (2 second) drum section, the grainy vocals come in again. Runaway is the only song with listening to because it actually has dynamics. If music could be shaped like an isosceles triangle this would be it.

Simon

You should review more non-english music (best example was OG Keemo's album earlier this year)

FredDenza

Some say rock is dead but fortunately any current country music apes popular rock music tropes of 15-20 years prior. So essentially, the legacy or rock and roll is perpetual Ford Truck Like A Rock Month all month longUSA

dayvan-cowboy

Sampha is massively underrated. He has a beautifully soulful voice, is an incredible producer and songwriter, appears on Kanye and Frank Ocean albums, and even has a Kanye-produced cut on his own record. Yet somehow, working with these big names hasn't brought him the attention he should have

MusicEnjoyer8

Swimming is the worst review you’ve ever done.

MusicEnjoyer8

You should give redux scores for every Kanye album.

Paul

Your non-music related tierlists are high key great. You should do more of them!

Henrry Santana

Dangerous by Michael Jackson is severely underrated.

Caspa

I seen you give praises to Ironman,Supreme Clientele and Fishscale which are excellent albums but what are your thoughts on The Pretty Toney Album?

Jackson Gibbons

Channel Orange is by far Frank Oceans best album.

TraJay

Timpanis are the 808s of classical music.

Drake Parker

The orchestral part right after the first verse of New Slaves is way better than the outro.

HidingInYourFloorboards

There are 17 missing persons cases in my hometown and they will never find enough evidence to make the charges stick

Michael Bell

Remo Drive fell off so hard. They had one of the freshest sounds in emo/indie 5 years ago with Greatest Hits. But every release after that progressively becomes more stale and uninteresting.

Alex Alcalde

The song, “Physical”, by Dua Lipa is wayyyyy better than the original version made by Olivia Newton John.

Caspa

I noticed that albums you didn't review wound up on your albums of the decade list . Are there any greats albums that have been released you couldn't cover but have album of the decade potential?

Dub McPeak

how would you rank the godspeed albums and eps?

membertatooine

bossanova is the pixies best work and should be talked about more.

Michael Bell

what have you done with CAL???!?!?!111

CurlyChunk

What's your opinion on the band "Doves"? I personally have become incredibly loving of the band and I think they deserve a bit more attention than they currently hold. "Black and White Town" and "There Goes The Fear" did blow up back when it released, but they have *so many* other good songs. Personal favorites are "M62 Song" and "Snowden" :)

Andrew Shaktah

Despite what most say about NFTs if their favorite band decided to release a new album exclusively as an NFT they’d buy it

Anonymous

Favorite James Bond theme, mine is a mix between OHMSS and Skyfall

Anonymous

Aesop Rock is just the white MF Doom without the comic book aesthetic

goddamneddog

More of a question, are you ever going to return to doing the "Worst to Best" ranking series and if so, will you ever do Pink Floyd

Ryan The Great (edited)

Comment edits

2026-10-27 04:00 Bands > Singer Songwriters
2022-03-23 18:03 Bands > Singer Songwriters

Bands > Singer Songwriters

Samantha

The tricky thing with Daughters is it's kinda hard to separate Marshall's work with the band from his actions. YWGWYW is deeply rooted in Marshall's mental instability and uglyness as a person and that's precisely why he was so horrible to Kristen. As much as I used to love YWGWYW and still think it's an incredible piece of work I have a hard time not thinking about what he did to Kristen while listening to it. Meanwhile Travis Scott's music - sans some reckless bars like "it aint mosh pit if aint no injuries" - doesn't directly relate to what he did at Astroworld, so its a bit easier to separate.

Samantha (edited)

Comment edits

2026-10-27 04:00 Aaliyah's self-titled record is one of the most important R&B albums of the past 20 years but I think it's a little underrated due to her passing and the fact that it wasn't available for streaming until very recently. Aaliyah's vocal performances are beautiful and angelic from end to end, many of the songs center around female empowerment, love and overcoming trauma, some of Timbaland's best production lands on here and while not intentional it was an amazing sendoff for Aaliyah. It's a shame her death quickly proceeded the album but its an amazing record that has gone on to influence countless R&B artists past and present. (PS I hope her posthumous record this year doesn't suck)
2022-03-28 01:44 Aaliyah's self-titled record is one of the most important R&B albums of the past 20 years but I think it's a little underrated due to her passing and the fact that it wasn't available for streaming until very recently. Aaliyah's vocal performances are beautiful and angelic from end to end, many of the songs center around female empowerment, love and overcoming trauma, some of Timbaland's best production lands on here and while not intentional it was an amazing sendoff for Aaliyah. It's a shame her death quickly proceeded the album but its an amazing record that has gone on to influence countless R&B artists past and present. (PS I hope her posthumous record this year doesn't suck)

Aaliyah's self-titled record is one of the most important R&B albums of the past 20 years but I think it's a little underrated due to her passing and the fact that it wasn't available for streaming until very recently. Aaliyah's vocal performances are beautiful and angelic from end to end, many of the songs center around female empowerment, love and overcoming trauma, some of Timbaland's best production lands on here and while not intentional it was an amazing sendoff for Aaliyah. It's a shame her death quickly proceeded the album but its an amazing record that has gone on to influence countless R&B artists past and present. (PS I hope her posthumous record this year doesn't suck)