Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Content

Thank you all a bunch for your support this month! Now's that magical time when you hit us with your HOT TAKES, UNPOPULAR OPINIONS, and TOUGH QUESTIONS! Drop 'em in the comments below and we'll look through them next week. Let's go!

In case you missed last month's episode: https://www.patreon.com/posts/lets-argue-why-i-64441646

Comments

Wowisawow

animal crossing new leaf specifically has the best video game soundtrack ever

Zach Stolpa

If you had to guess what Kendrick Lamar’s possible rock influences could be what would you pick?

Navarrm

Macho Man Randy Savage dropped the best album in the world of Wrestling Hip Hop.

Jackson Moeller

I find the band rubble bucket is one of the few bands out there that started after the 1990s that I consider Had a very nice and pretty unique jam band like sound even though it’s only on rubble buckets self titled album being that might’ve have been influenced from bands like the Grateful Dead and phish. King Gizzard and the lizard wizard also comes to mine.

Jake Smith

Phish IS a good band!

Herbieguy

Billy Joel's "The Nylon Curtain" is not only his best and most underappreciated album, it is the MASTERCLASS on how to make perfect Pop music. Every note, lyric, and instrumental detail was meticulously done and the album unquestionably deserves more recognition for how well crafted and produced it was.

sessu

Kanye dropping off social media and pulling out of Coachella means he's out of his manic phase and Donda 2 won't get finished for a very long time

Hogan99

Does conservatives watching your content bother you? I love your channel, but I hold very conservative values. You really trash on conservative ideas, so does it really bother you if people who don’t see eye to eye with you watch your channel?

bressig

Machine Gun Kelly's cover of "Aerials" isn't quite as bad as Puddle of Mudd's "About a Girl" cover but it's so close that they should have a battle to the DEATH

Alex Sim

Albums that "didn't age well" (aka sound "dated") are overhated. They can be time-capsules of that particular moment even if they're hard to listen to in the present. Like - I don't think anyone is holding up Trey Songz's "Ready" as a classic, but goddamn if it doesn't capture the whole vibe of late 00s RnB (cringe and all)

tar meat breadnest

Nirvana is only revered in god-tier status because they didn't have enough time to start making medeoce-to-bad albums.

New Blue

MGK can’t ruin pop punk because pop punk was never good in the first place!! There’s 2-3 albums in the entire genre that are even decent

Yannick Vertommen

Have you ever thought about reviewing dj-sets or mixed albums? For me, selecting the perfect tracklist and making complementing blends with various effects and techniques is one of the most creative things in music. For example albums in the FabricLive series or certain Boiler Room sets have become classics to me and I give them a spin regularly.

[REDACTED]

The first two Mötley CrĂŒe albums are really good.

Aldo Hernandez

Lil Jon is the first rapper to embrace his memeness!

Preston Richey

The skits on Late Registration are way better than the ones on College Dropout, especially on re-listen

CocoBonobo

In light of the allegations that have come out about Mark Kozelek and Alexis Marshall, have the feelings towards Daughters/Sun Kil Moon records (especially the ones that ended up high on your decade list) shifted at all? Do you still view these records as great, or do these now feel more tainted?

punkish_hiphop

If liquid swords didn't happen a lot of "experimental" hiphop we hear now wouldn't exist

Emma Clark

MGK’s new album is so bad it’s good. Like a B movie. (Though he is a shitty person)

Dalton Krause

Greetings, King of Melon Flowers. My hot take is that Amon Tobin is the GOAT and its a real shame you (seemingly) stopped following his music. Would love to know what you think of his recent projects on the Nomark label like Only Child Tyrant and Figueroa, because they are absolutely fantastic and worth your time if you haven't heard them.

Zachary F Parker

Very few pieces of media use leitmotifs well. They either don't give characters/settings themes or go way too hard in the other direction and play it up to the point of absurdity. The few exceptions where they are used well (usually in indie video games) stand out above the rest.

MusicEnjoyer8

Your review of Swimming is worse than your review of MBDTF. You completely misunderstood that album.

Philip Coulam-Jones

We don't talk enough about how many popular musicians in the 80s were profoundly normal looking dudes. Prince and MJ take up a lot of the conversation (rightfully so, those are some iconic looks) but Brothers in Arms was the best selling album of that decade in the UK and good luck trying to pick Mark Knopfler out of a line-up. Album still slaps though

Caleb John Cushing

I know that no award shows inherently "mean anything", but I do feel like out of the big four (Oscars, Emmys, Tonys, Grammys), the Grammys "mean" the least. I don't know a single person IRL who takes the Grammys seriously. In your opinion, what would it take for the Grammys to regain widespread legitimacy?

Macy M

Successful musicians should not get into acting. There's only so many movies that get made, so there's a limited number of roles out there. so any job taken by an established celebrity who just wants to add 'actor' to their Wikipedia page is a job taken away from someone more dedicated to acting and more reliant on the pay who would probably give a better performance anyway. Meanwhile there's no limit to how much music can be made, so they should just stick with that

Bizarre Neon

Not really a hard question, but I am curious. What’s your opinion on Mike Park (Asian Man Records)? I’m personally a huge fan of his music and I’d love to hear your opinion!! Also your bass playing has gotten way better since I first started watching you a couple years ago!!

Spotswood Burwell

Opinion: Music industry standards are declining rapidly. I truly believe that generally, across any genre of music, we can see an overall decline in standards for musicians and their content. When artists begin to rely on artificial music rather than their own talents, the quality of their content and performances is drastically reduced. Additionally, artists releasing singles often simply because they have the resources to do so will not create thought-out, artistic music and should not be encouraged by the greater streaming / listening audience.

SenorJulian

Steal This Album! is System of a Down's best album

Guy Mendes

Did you always had an interest in indie, underground or very unique and experimental sounding music or the fact that you had to constantly review the usual "by the book" mainstream stuff of nowadays drive you to it? Think something similar to how a movie reviewer would much prefer to watch a art house movie than to review yet another mindless blockbuster. Was it always a personal preference or the burnout lead you to it?

I, II, II, IL

Pitchfork thought that the new Machine Gun Kelly album was better than The New Abormal by The Strokes. Can we just shut down Pitchfork now?

8thsinn

Depeche Mode is not worse now that Alan Wilder is not the master arranger. The process next albums (minus Sounds of the Universe!) have all had a progressive touch that improved with time.

Jonathan Nowacki

Some rappers are just better as features than they are on their own tracks. Ludacris, 2 Chainz, 21, Nicki Minaj, and Earl Sweatshirt all come to the top of my mind relatively quickly. I mean, take Luda on a track like B R Right or Earl on a track like Really Doe and compare it to almost anything on their own projects. Not to say that all of their respective projects are bad, far from it. I just think they sound better in concentrated doses.

Jonathan Nowacki

I like this. Something like DJ 慉慉慉‘s Planetary Natural Love Gas Webbin' 199999 or John Talabot’s DJ Kicks comes to mind.

Kyle P

Delusional Thomas is insanely slept on. Despite the clear Quasimoto influences, it is a truly unique mixtape. Mac's first project fully produced by himself/Larry Fisherman and you feel truly immersed in the world he creates, despite the disorienting sounds. Building on the experimental/abstract production of WMWTSO, Thomas' dark (and often shocking) lyrics paved the way to the introspection seen on Faces. Criminally underrated.

The Needle Drop

answered in previous vids. feelings on the albums haven't shifted, also criticized the last skm album for the two really tonedeaf tracks

Asher :D

Channel Orange is better than a 7

Antoine Pages

Good experimental music has been stagnating for a while now compared to the 20th century.

HotNickels

You are given the choice between TWO magical jukeboxes. #1 will play for you songs that you love but never would have had the chance to hear. #2 will play ANY song as performed by ANY artist (like a cover.) I mean what would ya choose?

Hannah

Plastic Beach is overrated and far from Gorillaz best album

FredDenza

Canonization of albums bands and songs (“best ___of all time!”) seems innocent but in reality closes minds and excludes artists from competing for space in the cultural zeitgeist. Plus it keeps almost all bands dirt poor for no reason other than loyalty & brand recognition. Why try the new Denzel when we can listen to certified classics we already know and love? Loyalty to artists who inspire us is good, but eternal GOAT lists seem to mostly breed exclusion and poverty for generations of brilliant, creative musicians of all cultural backgrounds. I know of no way to remedy this except to just keep listening.

MusicEnjoyer8

Graduation does not sound dated.

Tommy Simmonds

Paper Mùché Dream Balloon is the 3rd best King Gizzard album x

Philip Coulam-Jones

How long do you think it will be before we can look back and pinpoint where 20s music reached a sound that was definitively different from 10s music? Sometimes it's easy to identify exactly when pop-culture passes from one window to another (an easy example is that, in late September 1991, consecutive weeks saw the release of Use Your Illusion I & II followed up by Nevermind, Blood Sugar Sex Magic and Low End Theory all dropping on the same day) but the pandemic makes me wonder if that transition has been warped due to how drastically music was affected by the change in rollouts and lack of touring. It'll be interesting to see what the consensus is in 2030, assuming that we make it that far

Trym SĂžrsdal

When you review artists you’re not familiar with, do you always listen through their catalog to contextualise or do you prefer to review the material isolated?

Jarl Wallheden

Good kid on GKMC is extremely underplayed compared to Mad city which is heavily overrated. Good kid provides better lyrics, flow and vibe (THAT BASSLINE). All while mad city sounds like a walmart "aint it funny", the beat isnt even catchy. Good kid is a strong 10 while mad city is a weak 8

Nick

Tea is better than coffee, but coffee is more useful.

Squanto

While it might hurt to think about, I think Crash confirms that most of what made Charli’s music interesting was her producers and the sounds they brought to the table. Most of her best stuff exemplified the PC music aesthetic because of who she worked with. I think her older records and Crash reveal a lot of her shortcomings as a songwriter due to their more boilerplate sound.

Dirty Randy

Not a traditional unpopular opinion: but I think you deserve more credit for your casting/hosting ability. It’s impressive how in the NMF streams you manage to keep it together when faced with hearing some of the most beautiful musical moments ever for the first time. Combined with the usual buffoonery of chat, confronting such daunting opposition would bring any less of a man to his knees.

Bzymek

Jimmy Page's sleeping with a 14 y/o was not very poggers

Zach Stolpa

I apply this to a bit of the “bling era” hip hop

ToadMan101

In your opinion, which of these is the best format to listen to music on? Vinyl, Cassette, CD, or Streaming?

Tristan Noel

"Hide and Seek" by Imogen Heap is a fantastic track. Not only is it an intimate and emotional break up song, its more pop-centric approach to Laurie Anderson-esque minimalistic vocoder experimentation was ahead of the curve of what acts like James Blake and Bon Iver would do a couple years later. It's a shame it is mostly associated with memes and Jason Derulo these days

ElephantofDoom

wernher von braun by tom lehrer is the actual greatest diss track of all time not even close

Kyle Cahill

Let's Argue is a dying series. For as much as I love this series and I come back to multiple episodes very often, I feel like it has slowly run dry on interesting hot takes, unpopular opinions, and tough questions over the years. Given the consistent weekly output on the main channel turning into more of a series that happens every now and then certainly doesn't help either. I predict that this will become a patreon exclusive series or maybe the series will end altogether within the next two years

The Needle Drop

nah the series isn't going anywhere; it just should've always had this pace tbh. segments relying on audience participation are just gonna be subject to this kind of burnout (we can't expect everyone, even ourselves, to keep track of what was said in every episode). it is what it is yknow

Jordan Fairbairn

I’m surprised you haven’t really covered more Emma Ruth Rundle on your channel as she feels to me like a counterpart to Chelsea Wolfe. Who IMO she has a stronger discography than. Anyways a Nicole, Emma and Lingua collar when

Drake Parker

Symphony No. 5 in C Minor is one dimensional

Andrew Shaktah

Despite their incredibly corny bars there’s no denying the Black Eyed Peas know how to make a real banger of a song. Their intentionally radio friendly lyricism is probably the only thing that held them back from being taken seriously.

Mohmi

Justin Bieber leaving Chris Owens of Girls on read in 2012 is one of the biggest missed chances in pop music. Bieber could have stretched out into more interesting sonic territory and, via Owens' more retro tastes, beaten Tyler and Bruno to the retro-futurist phase of pop music, and Owens could have been saved from just reposting museum pics on twitter all day.

D

when are you bringing back the cal chuchesta black metal shirt from your ''Is Imagine Dragons the Worst Rock Band?'' video?

Andrew Shaktah

You criticized Anthony Kiedis for his lyrics on the latest Peps album but we all know if Ride were shouting that Aquatic Mouth Dance gibberish you’d give it a pass

Henrry Santana

Michael Jackson's dancing was just as much a part of why he was so great along with the fantastic music and music videos

New Blue

It deserves a redux review. Not that Mac’s passing changes the album but even at its harshest critique it isn’t anything less than a 5

New Blue

Only been on their website like twice but now I’m never going back

Oscar Aragon

Coldplay should’ve disbanded at the height of their career with Viva la Vida. It would put them significantly higher in greatest band lists

Drake Parker

Ye is snubbing awards from actual gospel artists. Like, how is Off The Grid nominated for top Christian song?

Nick Denhalter

Of these artists, what do you imagine the highest score they have the potential of getting from you is? (I know in a hypothetical sense all could somehow get 10s but be realistic) Macklemore Hobo Johnson Childish Gambino Aesop Rock Beck Quelle Chris Coldplay

MusicEnjoyer8

808s & heartbreak is Kanye’s best album

Jack Darnell

Do you think music can ever or has ever had a tangible effect on political struggles and events? Lately I've been wondering if a political song doesn't really do much on its own. Rather than inspire people to take steps to make change, it just becomes the soundtrack to whatever steps they're already taking (or not taking). Or the changes that it calls for are simply not something most people have any power over. Anti war songs can't seem to stop war, for example. And I get you can always send profits from a song to a fundraising campaign that will have tangible effects, or you can even put voter registration forms in with the physical album (like REM did on Out Of Time), but is that the music making the change? I don't know.

Jon Martin

King Crimson is the best progressive rock band.

Sam Horton

hip hop is still such a relatively young genre that we will likely see top 50, 25, even 10 records in the genre come out each and every year and claiming them as such is not ridiculous at all. ex: new injury reserve, LP!, simbi, etc. all in 2021.

Luis Melendez

Utopia will receive similar if not better praise than Astroworld as people forget or choose to ignore the recent tragedy

Alberto Satta

C.R.E.A.M. is the worst track off of 36 Chambers and it's extremely overrated in Wutang's discography, it's still decent but it does not reflect the group's hardcore sound at all and feels off place in the record, the beat is kinda boring and Meth, Raekwon and Deck's performances are some of the weakest in the entire album. Yes, it explores a much deeper theme than the rest of the songs on the record, but their more "conscious" songs are way better in Wu-Tang Forever which has tracks like "The City", one of the best Wu songs ever.

buckfastbjork

J. Cole a crazy example of this, when he’s on production not his own and he has someone else to rap against he suddenly becomes the amazing rapper that people laud him as for his albums, it’s also why the off season was his best project to date Also savage mode II proved 21 Savage isn’t one of these anymore

Jacob Dickens

No More Kings is the best Schoolhouse Rock song

Lousey

People need to calm down about Ringo singing some of the Beatles songs. Christ, he's not even a bad singer; if nothing else he's just different. His songs are silly sure, but can you call a single one (solo career excluded) exceptionally bad?

goddamneddog

Gwen Stefani, Akon, and Lady Gaga were the holy trinity of 2000s era Pop.

sessu

Audio quality does not automatically make music more enjoyable. I've had more meaningful memories related to music playing out of shitty car speakers than ones where I was listening to noise-canceling headphones

Squanto

90% of what he hears on stream is usually average music ngl.

Squanto

This is actually facts tbh. I find myself listening to older, more “classic” albums because I know there will be a higher chance of me liking them than newer albums.

Dirty Randy

Ik, usually it’s so painfully average or bad it’d drive me insane if I had to sit through 2 hours of it

Drake Parker

They act like two legends can’t co-exist

Zach Stolpa

County build blues is easily Kendrick Lamar’s most underrated/underplayed song.

Jackson Moeller

Your doing great man and keep doing what you do and say hi to cal for me.

James Carlisle

the whole culture of sex, drugs and rock n’ roll in the 70s was generally not very poggers

Samantha

Kanye's Graduation being dated is kind of why I love it. It really takes me back and its a fun experience overall

Samantha

Not gonna lie Crash did make me rethink a lot of my love for Charli, I have no desire to listen to her music now

Samantha

People only consider Positions by Ariana Grande a flop because its not as anthemic and inspiring as her previous two albums. Sweetener and TU,N, as amazing as they are, both came from a place of pain and trauma and I think she just wanted to move on and make something more lighthearted. While a couple tracks can be braggadocios to a fault, much of the album is about healing and trying to move forward which imo is just as compelling even if its more relaxed and pillowy. Its not a perfect album but its a lot better than people give it credit for and I think its going to age well.

FredDenza

The day Corey Feldman invites Anthony to a live show so they can have a rockinRevolution together is the the day Corey, like Samson in the Bible, loses his magic. Corey is perfect as he is, just as the art he creates is perfect as it is. Theirs is the balance of light and dark, yin and Yang, science and nature; they must remain in dynamic opposition for their respective energies to nourish us. If we ever see a picture of Corey and Anthony together we will know the dream is over.

Nathaniel Zaccagnini

KGS has lost its edge now that Ye and Cudi aren’t cool anymore

James Carlisle

screw anyone who says listening to sad music is bad for your mental health. if anything, sad music can heal. makes you feel a whole lot less alone.

Robert

David Bowie's later career output is possibly just as good as his work in the 70s, and is often incredibly overlooked. Albums like Blackstar, Outside, The Next Day, and Heathen prove that he was as groundbreaking and innovative as ever, with more mature songwriting and performances.

Noah Cone

Butter 08 is one of the best rock albums of the 90s and never gets any recognition. It has a vast array of instruments and genre fusions that always wiggle its way into your ear like a groovy slime

Jack Darnell

Hard disagree. If a successful musician is also a good actor or enjoys acting and is good enough to be hired, how is it fair to tell them they're not allowed because they're already focusing on another art form? That would be like telling Michaelangelo he's not allowed practice architecture because he's already a successful sculptor, and there are only so many buildings that get built so a less successful person should get those jobs. Never mind that Michaelangelo was an incredibly progressive and gifted architect that pushed the whole field in a new direction. "He was already doing that with sculpture, so why should he get to do it with architecture too?" That's just not fair. Yeah, there's something to be said for actors who have been working at it their whole lives who don't get a breakthrough role because the directors decided to go with some already famous celebrity instead, but the solution isn't to just lay a general bar on people from auditioning based on their existing level of fame and success. The solution would be to incentivize directors to choose the best actors for the roles rather than those with the most star power who will put butts in seats. An ideal director is going to do this anyway, you want the best possible movie to be made of course. But since we live in a world that incentivizes butts in seats, already famous people have a better chance of being cast in movies that are bound to make them more famous. So the mission needs to be to create a tangible incentive to prioritize great movies over revenue, not to ban musicians from auditioning for movies.

Jack Darnell

I think Knopfler was more of an exception to the rule though, and it's not like he didn't have a bit of visual charisma as well, though not terribly unique or ostentatious, but his songwriting and guitar playing were so great that people's ears took notice where their eyes didn't. On the other hand, hair metal: Two words that make most music nerds immediately roll their eyes, yet it was very visually stimulating, and very very popular in the 80s.

Jack Darnell

TPAB was this rock nerd's gateway into the world of hip hop. I heard a lot of Pink Floyd in that record. No idea if that's the kind of vibe he's cooking up for the new album, but that's one potential influence I would reckon.

Jack Darnell

The first one is really good. Shout At The Devil has some dull moments despite one of their best singles.