Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Content

Thanks so much for all your support this month! Now's that magical time when you hit us with your HOT TAKES, UNPOPULAR OPINIONS, and TOUGH QUESTIONS! Drop 'em in the comments below and we'll look through them later next week. Let's go!

In case you missed last month's episode: https://www.patreon.com/posts/lets-argue-mgk-65565599

Comments

Daylan Berry

Gnarls Barkley dropped the 2 best albums of the 2000s decade

Nick Denhalter

The beastie boys are more influential then they will ever get credit for.

Vipul Konnur

nathan zed is the best thing to happen to music youtube in a long time

Jackson Moeller

What does cal think of your reviews does he agree most of the time or are there a lot of differences between your thoughts on albums compared to his ?

Calum Hughes

The Denis Leary song 'A**hole' is fire

Brendan James

Are you much of a traveler? Now that the pandemic has subsided, is there anywhere you're dying to go?

Zach Stolpa

80’s hair metal in the rock genre is the equivalent to the bling era in the hip hop genre

Caleb John Cushing

I know you're on record as saying a lot of the recurring jokes that pop up in your comment section/chat are ones you find annoying/unfunny, but I was wondering if you have a favorite joke or meme that has generated from your community?

Tyler Feeney

Does Kendrick cement himself as one of Hip Hop’s all time greats if he delivers on what people think is an upcoming “double album.” Double albums are hard to pull off, especially in the streaming era.

bressig

Fantasia is Disney's greatest achievement: the synthesis of groundbreaking animation with classical music still holds up to this day as the company's defining masterpiece, and it's sad to see what Disney has become in comparison to that - ie. remaking their animated classics in live-action or "photorealism" - a remake of Fantasia would be entirely terrible and pointless due to its vision and impact on cinema and music

Neo Fascination

People who say to someone "Wow your music taste is really just a fantano clone/pitchfork clone/mu clone" often times end up discouraging that person from enjoying music they actually like out of fear of being called a copy cat and I'm tired of it

Valdyr the Hyena

Blue raspberry is the best fruit that doesn't exist

Herbieguy

The reason Chris Brown doesn't deserve his career isn't for his crimes, its because he's done NOTHING for the genre. R&Bs history is littered with scumbags (ex: R. Kelly, MJ, James Brown, Ike Turner) but they all at least have some sort of essential songs, albums or influence that justify their discussion in the genre. Chris has none of that. Nothing in Chris' career has been interesting or influential enough to justify how long its lasted. Literally everything he has done musically has been overshadowed by his awful crimes, which isn't something you can say for the others listed. In the unlikely chance people DO discuss Chris in the future, its not gonna be for his music.

Alberto Satta

Given the pickiness you seem to usually have when it comes to modern progressive rock/metal albums, I thought it would be interesting to ask you: what do you think are the 5 prog albums which came out after the 80s that you enjoy the most? Clearly prog bands nowadays seem to not be nearly as consistent as they were back in the day but I still think there are a few recent projects worth praising, like frances the mute, colors etc etc. Love you, Melon.

Antoine Pages

Massive Attack's 100th Window album is underrated.

Dalton Krause

Love and Rockets is a criminally underrated band, in particular the album Sweet F.A which i can't say I've ever seen or heard a single piece of discussion about how great of an album that is, or just how great of a band L&R is. Would love to know your thoughts on them if you have any.

Trevor Young

It's shitty that the Oscars give continually less and less fucks about music and sound design. Obviously awards ceremonies suck and we shouldn't care too much about them anyways. But relegating Original Score and Best Sound to the non-televised pre-show is a slap in the face to all the musicians who worked on those films. Especially for movies like Dune, music + sound are THE key elements in elevating the work to higher echelons of cinematic quality.

Daniel Nicodemus

Britney Spears is single handedly responsible for tape delay on live TV. If she doesn’t cheat on Justin Timberlake, he doesn’t write songs like Cry Me A River and become one of the biggest stars in the world, which leads him to performing in the Super Bowl where the Janet Jackson incident occurs

Sage Reiger

Neil Cicierega’s Mouth Dreams deserves a second listen. I know you're the internet’s busiest music nerd and you don't sleep because you're a melon, but I just don’t get how you didn’t see or mention Mouth Dreams as a concept album. The extremely awkward track structure and overarching experience were made purposefully to accurately portray how weird and unpredictable our dreams are and how they connect with our memories. You brought it down to “It wasn’t funny” instead of seeing it in the way Neil was going for.

Preston Richey

The skits on Late Registration are way better than the skits on College Dropout

Josh Brown

Hi Anthony, I have noticed that the "Weekly Track Roundups" have been getting shorter and I was curious to why that is? Before they used to run between 15-20 minutes but lately it is anywhere from 12-9 minutes. It was one of my favorite segments from you because when you went in-depth like that like I got great recommendations for lesser-known songs or artists, but now it feels like you just deliver the high (or low)lights from the week. I mean, it's been months and you still haven't reviewed the new Kirin J. Callinan or Perfumer Genius tracks! I understand you have a lot of other content to focus on, I just miss the longer WTR's. Much love and respect!

Squanto

FJM’s Pure Comedy isn’t aging well. While many of the lyrical themes felt relevant at the time (and still resonate a bit today), it is not FJM’s most well-groomed album. There are some duds (Smoochie and Two Wildly Different Perspectives) and the track list could use a bit more color across it through more adventurous songwriting to make up for its length. I’d also add a lot of the political commentary just feels kind of face-value and middle brow in retrospect. Still good, but I Love You, Honeybear absolutely clears Pure Comedy.

goddamneddog

fivio fell off with that bible album, really made drill come off as formulatic and over done

Nick Denhalter

Froggy fresh (Tyler Cassidy fka crispy cream) the writer of dunked on and the baddest of them all, actually had some pretty great production. The beats on stolen bikes 2 and 3 and street rangers 2 are literally bangers. I really hope his appearance and former audience doesn’t hold him back from making some actual stuff. He’s talented as hell.

techinix

This is a freezing cold take. 20 million records, 7 platinum albums, inducted into the Rock and Roll Hall of Fame, and they are the biggest-selling rap group since Billboard began recording sales.

Nick Denhalter

They are still not taken seriously by a huge majority of punk or rap audiences. I never said their popularity was extremely prevalent, I just think their influence isn’t recognized in circles it deserves to be.

Drake Parker

I’m curious on your thoughts about Snoh Aalegra, particularly her albums. You’ve never talked about her music on your channels outside of one song in a Weekly Track Roundup that you ranked as one of the worst of that week. she was mentioned in your Grammy predictions video as she was nominated in two R&B categories at the most recent Grammys, but even still you didn’t really leave much of a comment on her music

Michael Ruhl

Liking music like Iron Maiden, Black Sabbath, and Metallica isn't inherently boomer behavior. All three of those bands are some of the best musicians to grace rock music. However, listening to bands like Lynryd Skynyrd and ACDC is grossly boomer behavior and butt rock adjacent.

CurlyChunk

Why is it that people can have such variations in music taste? Like, how can one person prefer to listen to chill music, like Jazz or Classical, while another can prefer something on the complete opposite side of the spectrum, like death / gore metal. Also, how can some specific people (like you, to a certain extent) enjoy both interchangably?

Michael Ruhl

Kendrick Lamar has the most potential of any artist currently to completely change the music industry imo. TPAB was a seismic shift in rap music and if Mr morale is anywhere close to the level it could be, it could be a real game changer. Or it could end up being a 6 we'll see...

Bzymek

It is interesting that no artist/band seems to evolve these days the way The Beatles or Bowie did in second half of 20th century. While there are plenty of musical acts that are known for versatility, few actively try to evolve and change so much, that they effectively switch genres by mere virtue of experimenting with their previous comfort zone. Once some is a conscious Hip-Hop artist, they remain Conscious Hip-Hop artist, and so on.

LukeOnDemand

i could beat you in minecraft pvp

Christian rotsch

You are too harsh on NAV. Your main arguments against him are that he is derivative, emotionless, has bad lyrics and uses too much auto tune, which in your opinion makes him unneeded in the rap game. By this logic over half of new rappers you give reviews are unneeded in the rap game. Nav’s use of auto tune is unique, his lyrics are average for his rap class, his beats follow the current trends. You over hate nav. All of his not good reviews would be 5s if it wasn’t getting you meme views to roast him.

Philip Coulam-Jones

Do you think that any other genres have their "hyperpop" (i.e. something that takes the core tropes of the genre to their maximalist extreme to create a distinctly new sound) yet? Is it even possible for some genres- what would, for example, hyper-reggae even sound like? I seem to recall reading someone call MBDTF hyper-rap at one point, which feels like it could be a step in the right direction though not all the way there yet, but I'd be interested to hear your thoughts

Cordelia Smith

Trans musicians have been making some of the best music, especially recently, and mainstream outlets have largely ignored, dismissed, or slandered their voices. The 2010s without SOPHIE or the 2020s without Black Dresses would be far lesser decades musically.

Al Allotta

Nas would be as widely recognized by the general public as 2Pac or Biggie if he were dead

Dodecatron

Post-Brexit is a dumber genre name than shoegaze

Yannick Vertommen

Have you ever thought about reviewing dj-sets or mixed albums? For me, selecting the perfect tracklist and making complementing blends with various effects and techniques is one of the most creative things in music. For example albums in the FabricLive series or certain Boiler Room sets have become classics to me and I give them a spin regularly.

FredDenza

Time for an easy layup: JPEGMAFIA.

FredDenza

Hotter take: Allegro Non Troppo is better than Fantasia

FredDenza

All the punks I’ve known run Paul’s Boutique & earlier BBoys into the ground. Jazz heads love them, reggae folks love them. Every popular outlet from Rolling Stone to Pitchfork to the Tonight Show & Steven Colbert treats them like royalty. They are internationally beloved and more or less headlined every festival they were ever a part of I’m not sure what’s left; maybe when they win the Nobel Prize for dropping the new science and kicking the new knowledge will they finally have made it?

Jonathan Nowacki

On a scale of 1-10 how many Ska albums are there?

I, II, II, IL

Big Energy is garbage. The remix is worse because the Genius of Love sample has been done to death in so many songs already, and I don’t care if it’s a reference to a Mariah Carey song.

Zach Stolpa

I think if you go into the deep cuts of the two specifically you’re more right, I’m ngl the first half of freebird and back in black are timeless tracks

Blake

The Who is the greatest live band of all time and it isn’t even close. Each of the 4 original members were always firing on all cylinders and generated a sound that no one could ever top. Live at Leeds and 1970 Isle of Wight are two great examples.

lazarusinashes

Not a tough question at all, but I'm curious what your opinion on denpa is. I've never heard you talk about it or review any of it. If you don't know what it is (which I find unlikely) or need a reference, Pinky Pop Hepburn's "はぐれメンタル" (Hagurari Mental) is a good reference.

lazarusinashes

You should also give a listen to Memex's anthemic Dear Thinking Nodes. I'm not really sure how to describe it other than anthemic alt rock with denpa undertones.

Jack

The Avett brothers are the best song writers alive

Squanto

Massive agree

Zach Stolpa

What’s your general opinion on being vegetarian vs being vegan?

Jacob Dickens

What’s your top 5 schoolhouse rock tracks?

Noah

Which is better: an album where every song is GOOD, or an album where every song is GREAT except for one that's MEH?

HM James

Even though they had some big hits, I don’t think The Prodigy are recognized enough for how groundbreaking and influential their sound was for electronic music. Their albums “The Fat of the land” and “Music for the jilted generation” are up there as one of the all time greatest electronic records ever where they made hard hitting beats and noises years before dubstep became mainstream.

Sustin

Herder, Better, Faster, Stronger by Daft Punk is a better song than Stronger by Kanye

liajuju

Lucy Dacus is the best songwriter out of boygenius

Max Isom

How do you decide what music to review? Popularity seems to partly be a factor, but there’s plenty of mediocre to amazing artists (ODESZA) that you’ve never publicly given a chance.

MusicEnjoyer8

Your Swimming review is worse than your review for Mbdtf. While I understand your complaints about MBDTF, you completely misunderstood Swimming.

Florencio

The long run times of classic hip hop albums are daunting af. Shorter albums like Madvillainy, Some Rap Songs, Kids See Ghosts finally helped me get into the genre, and I wish 1-disc albums were more the norm.

Dirty Randy

Psychedelic trap has had the least staying power of any of the recent rap offshoots. Cloud rap, emo rap and mumble rap have their own classics that still hold up, but I feel like psych trap classics like L$D or any top songs off of Astroworld are instant skips for me now.

Dirty Randy

I definitely have to disagree. Ants From Up There - for one thing. Denzel was fire, Pusha T is BACK, and lots of promising singles across the board

Jake Bell

Steven Tyler’s screeches on dream on and I don’t wanna miss a thing are fuckin annoying

John Lestrade

La Dispute & mewithoutYou would've been better off without Will Yip producing their most recent records. Will's production sands off the polish, texture & bite of previous records, it's the worst thing about the albums since 2014. I know the bands aren't trying to capture the same vibe as their earlier records, but it would be nice if they didn't sound so uniformly dreary. Still love both bands tho

Jack Doherty

I recall you previously mentioning that you regretted not reviewing Viagra Boys - Street Worms, and have praised the track Sports on numerous occasions. I wanted to hear if you had any thoughts on the album and what sort of score you would have given it if you had reviewed it.

Julian Balboa

He should be a guest on Musicalsplaining with Lindsay Ellis!

Caspa

Going back to Rap albums of the past there are certainly alot of Homophobic lyrics do you let those bars limit your enjoyment of the album or do you just say "you know what it was bad time back then and even though this is an ideology I disagree with I feel like other pros such as a production, vocal performances, and great bars pretty much make up for those flaws in the bars"

Caspa

This is pretty much what I've been saying for a while lol

anniemaxie

Despite its quirky background Brony Music (or MLP fan music) is one of the most interesting and consistently underrated subgenres/communities in the internet music, often blending hyperpop, pop punk, trance or drum and bass. I was wondering if you heard about or what you think about artists like Vylet Pony, who has come out with one of the most versatile pop albums this year in the underground.

Anthony Goodwin

Question, are you still listening to the Osees at all? They've released like 5 projects since protean threat, haven't even come up in a yunoreview

FredDenza

Have you ever had music sung in a foreign language ruined for you by reading the translated lyrics? It seems like an albums lyrics can tank an album for you. For example, I love Otoboke Beaver’s vocal harmonies, melodies and far-out delivery, however I’m never going near the translated lyrics bc I’m afraid they’ll be trite. Have you ever had a band, record, or a discography ruined for you in this way?

Mason

We need a Disney princess that listens to Chief Keef

Bentheath

A Day At the Races is a better Queen album than A Night at the Opera

Noah Cone

Injury reserved came out with an album that defies all genres last year

Noah Cone

Eminem earned his spot in the rock and roll hall of fame and the backlash is NOT GOOD 💥. However other people deserve it just as much Erykah Badu, Wu tang clan, Kate Bush, etc etc.

New Blue

I’d widen this to LGBT+ musicians in general

New Blue

Radiohead better

Tyler Craig

Disintegration by The Cure is not only the best album in the band’s discography but it is also the best album of the 1980’s. The tragically beautiful lyrical themes, the emotionally charged vocals, Robert Smith’s ethereal synth and guitar lines and the sheer creative brilliance of the band truly captures the evolution of post punk, synthwave and pop music of the time in a way that is a once in a generation type artistic feat. One of the purest expressions of art of the 80’s.

FredDenza

Kanye will try to step on Kendrick Lamar’s May 13th “Mr Morale & The Big Steppers” release date by releasing a video or new music or finished music on the same day, before or right after Kendrick does. Kanye did this type of thing with another highly anticipated release (Drakes CLB), and released a new DONDA 2 video less than 2 hours after Kendrick’s The Heart Pt. Five surprise release.

TraJay

I was wondering if you’d ever be interested in doing a series where you do a “classic review” but for very significant releases from last decade that you missed or weren’t on your radar at the time. I’m particularly interested in any thoughts you have on death’s dynamic shroud’s I’ll Try Living Like This since you have been enjoying their new stuff lately.

tarny_doilies

been thinking about nick cave a lot today in light of the unbelievable and devastating news. "one more time with feeling," the documentary shot during the recording of "skeleton tree," is one of the most powerful, somber, honest documentaries ever released about a musician and the creative process. even without the context of arthur's death, the movie has stunningly creative direction and cinematography, and the behind-the-scenes glimpse into the writing, collaboration, and kinship between nick cave and warren ellis is electric and magical. but the fact that the documentary happened to align with cave processing his recent grief captured something so fragile, so sobering, and so real that the movie transcends from a very good, artful account of an acclaimed album, to a meta masterpiece about the creative process, the purpose (or futility) of art, the inadequacy of words to explain the most extreme emotions, a revered musician continually questioning the emotional validity of his entire career, the debilitating impact of trauma, and how a person presses on after suffering the most shocking and ultimate loss. I would also argue that ghosteen is—lyrically—one of the most profound, crushing, haunting, poetic records about grief ever written, made even more so after this second loss, but my message is already very long. so, just...love and condolences to nick cave and his family 🖤

Andrew Shaktah

The man said let’s argue not let’s agree

Andrew Shaktah

(As a tv broadcast engineer) while you do have a very good point, delayed feedback/return feed delays have always existed, especially for live events for the director to find the right cameras to use, however that event definitely caused a frenzy of careful eyes and QC for profanity has gotten much more strict

Drake Parker

Tough question; would you ever positively review a diss record directed towards you if the music is genuinely good?

Samantha

I kinda feel like Jack Harlow became famous because the bar for men is so low these days (both artistically and personally). People seem to think he's really something else because he doesn't talk down to women and he takes care of himself and his appearance but in reality people are simping over the bare minimum.

Squanto

He became famous because he makes trendy Tik-Tok songs. There are plenty of famous individuals who make low-grade music. Besides, it’s not like anyone is praising him artistically (especially not recently).

NevadaNate

Just because something is purposeful doesn't mean it lands with the audience. Most art is purposeful and it either works or doesn't

NevadaNate

This is probably because you don't have to be the biggest boy band in the world in order to platform weird music anymore. Nobody has to start out bland and commercial if they don't want to.

NevadaNate

Nobody has gone far enough with it yet. The fact that Travis is the most prominent example is part of the problem, since he's also arguably doing the blandest version of it due to his popularity

NevadaNate

Yeah idk I've never heard someone say "he's really something else" people just act like he's alright

Chris Hickson

There’s not enough discourse about Unwound as there should be. Easily one of the best bands of the 90’s who ,although may not have dropped that “perfect” album during their run, had one of the most consistent run of albums especially in the rock sphere. Everything from Fake Train to Leaves is worthy of heavy praise

Rossyp

Do you ever get to leave your house for more than a day?

Alex Alcalde

Dua Lipa’s “Physical” was wayyy better than the original song by Olivia Newton John of the same name.

Jørgen

All Things Must Pass by George Harrison is not only the best solo album by any Beatle, but it’s also better than every Beatles record except maybe Sgt. Peppers.

Squanto

Sgt. Peppers isn’t the best Beatles record tho?

Jørgen

Idk which one I like best but sgt peppers is mostly seen as their best among a lot of their fans and critics alike so i just chose it as an example

James Carlisle

Figure 8 is the best Elliott Smith album and I’m tired of pretending it’s not

James Carlisle

uhhh Kanye? Tyler? Kendrick? those people evolved, dude.

James Carlisle

Sgt Pepper isnt even a top 3 Beatles album

sessu

It's easier to get a 10/10 on a short album like Kids See Ghosts than on a long album because there are more chances for dud songs

Sleepy Joe

If you were a professional wrestler, what would be your intro song?

Slester TV

I know you've mention this before, but are you still planning on making a 500 greatest albums book? I'll sure buy it.