Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Content

Thanks so much for all your support this month! Now's that magical time when you hit us with your HOT TAKES, UNPOPULAR OPINIONS, and TOUGH QUESTIONS! Drop 'em in the comments below and we'll look through them next week. Let's go!

In case you missed last month's episode: https://www.patreon.com/posts/lets-argue-harry-67104772

Comments

Wingus McDingus

Kurt Cobain is the godfather of Buttrock

Jørgen

All Things Must Pass is the best solo record by any of the Beatles, and also better than most of the Beatles best albums

Simon

RAM is better

Walter Houghton

YG deserves more credit for what he’s done for the west coast and keeping G-Funk alive. His music is consistently solid not groundbreaking but a significant contribution to that sound and not enough people bring him up in conversations about rappers in our generation.

Jacob Dickens

Do you have any albums that you consider as the standard for a rating or something you compare a new album to in the process of giving a score? Is there an album that is THE 8 album?

bressig

confidence is the main thing and perhaps the only thing needed to get ahead in show business, and the video of DJ Khaled playing Bob Marley's guitar is the proof

Dalton Krause

Amon Tobin is one of the greatest electronic musicians of all time, hands down. I just was wondering if there's a particular reason you stopped following his music, and if you have heard it what do you think of his recent stuff?

tar meat breadnest

The majority of modern hardcore punk hasn’t been hardcore since the late 90’s, early 2000’s. They all sound like the same rip offs of modern metal bands

I, II, II, IL

Eve 6’s twitter account is bringing 90’s alternative rock back into the spotlight.

Herbieguy

There is NO reason Eminem should get to be the face of 'white hip hop' over the Beastie Boys. The Beasties are a decade Em's senior, just as (if not more) influential, and have a much stronger discography. It's not perfect but there's no Revival or Encore level duds in there. It's shocking how Em has arguably twice as much fame as them at this point.

Robert Jones

“Life’s too good” by the sugarcubes is rough, but it’s also Bjorks most fun album. People need to stop sleeping on it.

Josh Timko

Radiohead Doesn’t own the Minor Scale. Just like space movies don’t own augmented chords. Imagine happening to use the same or similar chords as a Radiohead song while being different from it in virtually every other way, and people still be like “it’s good.. sounds like Radiohead Worship to me though.” No other band in existence takes up as much musical real-estate as Radiohead.

Antoine Pages

A country's capacity to share its music with a global audience is reliant on its overall level of economic productivity.

CosmicAmericanMusic

The Byrds "Mr Tambourine Man" is better than the Bob Dylan version.

tyler

While radio is on the decline in many ways (and will continue to in terms of listeners) the institution of syndicated radio shows and stations will most likely remain for generations despite younger generations interest in tuning in going down. They also do sports casts and emergency broadcasts as well. I don't ever listen to the radio but it will live for as long as it's useful

Logan Heberg

When rating an album, do you have different standards for different artists, or are all of your albums rated on the same scale? For example, do you think that lil pumps self titled album is actually better than MBDTF, or is something like a 4 from Kanye or Kendrick significantly better than a 7 from someone like lil pump?

Logan Heberg

Ye is Kanye’s most underrated album and I cannot understand why people hate it so much. It’s my personal favorite and I feel like it’s a snapshot into the madness of Kanye for about 25 mins. The production is great and I feel like it’s one of, if not the, most personal Kanye album. Although it’s only been a couple years since the release, I think it’s aged well and will continue to age well in the future.

Rom Jan

Mr. Morale & The Big Steppers is a really hard album to understand. it's more experimental than past releases, the jazz in much weird than is was on past albums (in a good way). and the album doesn't have road narrative that TPAB and DAMN got, and if all of that wasn't enough, it's 1:15 run time, makes the listening hard even to a Kendrick fan.

Will Imrie

With the recent release of FX's Pistol series, I've seen a lot of people posting online that Never Mind The Bollocks was never really that good an album. I always felt that it was considered a classic album but it seems the consensus has possibly shifted these days. I'm not sure if I'm in the minority but I think it's a classic, sure it's not the greatest punk album of all time and perhaps the talents of the band at that specific time could be questioned, but IMO it is all killer start to finish and its influence is undeniable... which I guess is why Disney has invested so much $$ into a biopic about a band that only produced 1 record!

Ilovelamp9

Purple Hearts is a bottom 5 Kendrick track whilst Crown is one of his best.

Nathan Roberts

Dawn of Chromatica is one of the best remix albums I've ever heard. Remix albums/compilations are usually no good in my opinion, but that one seems to have a ton of character and range.

Aizen

Black Country New Road have an awful pretentious sound. I find their music so unbearable and it sucks because i was originally very hopeful of them when they released Sunglasses and Athens, France (pre - first record)

Matthew Wisniewski

Not really a hot take or tough question, but I really enjoy listening to powerful and more positive songs while working out, like songs from Idles' "Joy as an Act of Resistance" and Andrew WK's "You're Not Alone". What are some other albums/songs in this same style that I can also enjoy working out to?

Jarl Wallheden

I think you've talked way to little about Nujabes, the guy has one of the best hiphop ep's / compilation of all time (luv sic) and basicly inspired the lofi sound. Hugely influential and with BANGERS like feather and luv sic pt3 he deserves to be talked about more in music. Especcialy when talking jazz-rap like father time from MMatBS!

Noah

Which is better: an album with all GOOD songs, or an album with all GREAT songs and one skip/dud?

TraJay

Your twitch chat is a toxic environment that feels like a very unwelcoming place for some people to participate in.

Jam Roly

Killing In The Name reaching Christmas no 1 in the UK (beating that year’s X factor winner) is the most important moment in British chart history since it effectively killed off the X-factor/Idol/Voice era in the eyes of the public

Adam

First Ditch Effort by NOFX has to be one of the best late career punk rock albums. They had no reason going that hard in 2016 but did it anyway. It had tight fast playing, good variety, interesting song topics and personal lyrics. It might not be a great album in the grand scheme of the genre or even their own discography but compared it to what their contemporaries were putting out around that time and it sounds like a damn classic.

Frankie P

TikTok has served as a great tool in diversifying the music taste of casual young listeners. Teens who only surf the charts now have Aphex Twin, Kate Bush and Nirvana on their playlists.

Cole

Book of Saturday is a good song but the vocals sound like Mr. Burns and it turns me off to the song

SpicySkink

Non Music Hot Take : When people say they support people with autism they only mean high functioning autistic people. I am a mid functioning autistic and people are always shocked/angry that I can't do simple stuff like cook, understand social queues, or write with a pen.

Jackson Moeller

Have you ever listened to an album while working out that you ended up reviewing it for the channel ?

NevadaNate

Additional take: so far in the 2020s, remix albums have been going a lot harder than they ever have. DoC, 1000 gecs and The Tree of Clues, Butterfly 3001...

Slester TV

Linkin park, have some underrated projects. Even though I think their early stuff are overhyped, Minutes to midnight is their magnus opus. It is a well-produced album, due to Rick Rubin and Mike Shinoda's great production. It has some of the best linkin park lyrics (the little things give you away), while bleed it out is the perfect example of rap-rock. Last but not least, the album flows from start to finish, experimenting from alt-metal to art pop, without you even realising the difference. And not to talk about a thousand suns.

Slester TV

Pop punk 2020s revival, is the worst genre to ever exist

Slester TV

Based on the 2012 rolling stone magazine's top 500 albums list, The Bends is better than Ok Computer.

Slester TV

It depends, the albums are not always judged by how good their songs are, that's why greatest hits albums aren't the artists best work.

Slester TV

I dont think so, if you considered that he gives consistently 10s and 9s to some artists (death grips) and not good or 1s to some others (mgk). This also wouldn't make sense, because this way he would just limit the artistry of an artist, like (yeah this is too good for him), something that he can't know. Tbh, I don't thing so.

Slester TV

It is a classic. Don't listen to what people say in the internet, because only people who don't thing the album is good would write something like that, and their the minority, because most people who like that album don't even consider saying that somewhere. (Sr my English are bad Ik)

Logan Heberg

If every rapper is at 100% of their potential, then Kanye is the goat

Spencer Maples

Sweet Trip's "You Will Never Know Why" is a more focused and well-rounded project than "Velocity: Design: Comfort." Though the latter is highly enjoyable, I think certain spots of it are overly long and tedious to listen to.

Nigel Robinson

Either/Or is Elliott Smith's Dark Side of the Moon IYKYK

FredDenza

IMO Kendrick Lamar knew exactly what he was doing in releasing Mr. Morale exactly as it was. He is willing to go to artistic and musical places that even his most diehard fans are afraid to follow, extending the Jesus metaphors in the direction of testing his followers, daring them to deny him. Everyone wanted a piece of art like Quentin Tarantino’s “Pulp Fiction” and instead got a piece of art like Ingmar Bergman’s “Persona.” Can we hang with that?

FredDenza

Muse’s “The Will of the People” is pretty uplifting. I can see people curling a bunch of barbells to it.

FredDenza

Agree. They also bring the middlebrow taste with a weird fury

MusicEnjoyer8

Donda has redefined what a Christian album is. Rather than providing topical insight that you would see on other Christian albums, the sounds and direction itself create a spiritual experience. Traditional gospel influences are present but he distorts them to create a surreal and fresh sound. Kanye allows his guests to tell real and gritty stories and censors them so that they can more genuinely express their encounters with faith without having to sanitize the content. It weaves commercial appeal and genuine expression of faith without putting itself in a stringent box like other Christian records.

prodbypope

Taylor swifts reputation goes from a 4/10 project to an 8/10 once you learn more of the context behind the record.

Bennett Gottesman

So this is gonna sound like a joke but I promise it isn’t. So the review Ego gives at the end of the movie ratatouille offers some really interesting perspective on the process and purpose of criticism. Ego is talking about food but I think it applies to any medium including music. I’m curious how you feel about Ego’s and if you agree with him. There are clips of it on YouTube

MusicEnjoyer8

Mac is the goat imo. Not the best technically but definitely the most versatile and the best music

Jonah Dorris

21 savage is a godly feature artist

Rom Jan

Totally agree!

buckfastbjork

I always think about this and then its why I realise that numerical ratings of music shouldn't be a science because art is not a science. You could listen to something on one day and its a 10 album and experience but then on another day it could be an 8 or a 9 out of 10 experience or enjoyment level.

buckfastbjork

Mac Miller should be the face of white hip-hop because Mac is so hip-hop it makes you realise the idea of the face of white hip-hop is dumb af, if youre a true rapper or hip-hop artist you arent a "white rapper" just a white person that raps

buckfastbjork

yeah nujabes is basically the grandfather of lofi hip-hop

buckfastbjork

especially when a lot of high functioning autistic people are mid or low functioning autistic but they just mask to fuck which is so draining and then when inevitably they don't have the energy to mask or have a meltdown suddenly others don't have the time to give them the support they actually need.

buckfastbjork

Im an ex christian but still a v spiritual person and Donda definitely should be treated with more respect and gravitas as a religious/spiritual album that as you say redefines what that can be. Christian rap was the corniest rap on the planet. Now one of the most popular and hardest tracks of 2021 is called "Praise God"

buckfastbjork

I wanna live forever till I die<3 Yeah ! I wanna live forever till I die:)

MV Calil

of your 10/10's, I feel like TBK is the hardest to get into if you don't follow the genre closely or have an inclination to enjoy, while TPAB is the easiest even though I believe it's the most dense of them all

Lousey

There is no such thing as a "clean" break up. LCD Soundsystem tried this, but even they fucked it up by getting back together 5 years later Plus, if the reason behind a breakup is ever "creative differences" you can usually assume that the band just hates each other

Benjamin Lisboa

We were Kate Bush stans before Stranger Things S4

FredDenza

Hey Anthony can start picking the monthly classic Patreon livestream yourself? I’m kind of tired of being babysat through yet another pre-approved classic you’ve already discussed and recommended. This way you get to give your thoughts about a past classic you’re excited about (and get payed for it), and we get to escape from the tyranny of the majority-rules, middle-of-the-road monthly patreon upvote. I like giving you $ so you can keep creating independent content. But I’m surprised the Patreon streams are so restrictive and “un-Anthony.” Let the canonizers do their canonizing on their own time. I’d rather see you do your own thing on here like you do on your other channels. And I bet you’ll get more patreons too bc most are here for your thoughts, not for paying customers to force you to relive your past. All the best man.

Mitch Dalzin

Due to their crazy one-take music videos, Ok Go's music often gets overlooked despite being some of the most fun pop rock of the past couple decades. None of their albums are the most consistent, but they have plenty of great songs across their catalogue (eg. Oh Lately it's so Quiet, This Too Shall Pass, Needing/Getting, The Writing's on the Wall).

Zach Stolpa

The rock and roll hall of fame needs to transition to rebranding itself as more of a just general music hall of fame given the names that are being nominated in recent years who are generally seen as non rock entities .

Nathan Weltzien

Logic is kinda like the Weezer of hip-hop

Noah Cone

Since It’s going to be an 80’s summer who did it better in the 80’s Europe or America

Squanto

AJJ’s vocalist is just a weaker, less charismatic Isaac Brock.

Squanto

Here Come the Warm Jets is actually the best Eno album. Another Green World is mainly considered his best just because he’s more known for his ambient-leaning works.

The Needle Drop

we've been doing this in October for Anthony's bday, but think it's fairer to give you guys a say in it most of the time. this month we won't pick a previously covered album

Philip Coulam-Jones

That Sex Pistols concert at the Manchester Lesser Free Trade Hall in 1976 is the most culturally significant bad performance in modern music

Samantha

This is a very intriguing take but why do you feel this way?

Samantha

Cynicism and Nihilism are ruining Gen Z and Millenials. Shits awful in America right now and I expect things will get worse before it gets better but its very disheartening to see that so many people my age have no hope for the future and would rather burn everything to the ground than try to make things better. I blame the internet for polarizing people and the media for never sharing any positive news which shows that we're not entirely doomed.

Nathan Weltzien

I think they both have a couple early albums that are like clasics, a bunch in the middle that are pretty bad or just ok, and for whatever reason a lot of their new shit goes hard. Idk i just also think they give of kinda similar vibes

Dallas Watkinson

This past century so far has been the greatest era for music in history

Dallas Watkinson

Paint it black by the rolling stones is the first ever emo song

Ryan The Great

Good lyrics and bad beats don't work, Good beats and bad lyrics do work nowadays.

goddamneddog

What about Roc Marciano turns you off so much in comparison to a similar artist like Ka or even MF DOOM to a degree? Roc has some of the best lyricism in the game and the way he flows on beats is incredibly impressive technically speaking. I'm just not sure what about Roc Marci puts you off considering his contemporaries are some of your favorite artists and they have very similar styles to what Roc puts out.

lowkeymatt

Emo pop (ala MCR, All Time Low, FOB, Taking Back Sunday etc.) will make a big come back later soon. The rise of pop punk in the mainstream, much of modern music being inspired by it, and the emotions high right now, it’s prime for a comeback. I also think people will get sick of the slow tempo, downtrodden music in favor of something more upbeat and energetic.

Squanto

I think it’s a little easy-going for Melon’s ears. I’m pretty sure he said he likes some of Nujabes stuff, but it’s not his favorite

Squanto

I agree the Beastie Boys are significantly better than Eminem, but it doesn’t surprise they aren’t as big as him. Most of their albums are artsier like Paul’s Boutique which doesn’t transfer as much to the mainstream as Eminem who has much stronger pop sensibilities.

Jack Guenther

Sublime is one of the most overlooked bands of all time. The way Brad Nowell molded elements of a multitude of different genres, and did so with such emotional and witty songwriting and delivery is remarkable. Best band of the 90s

Slester TV

Does "butt rock" have any good albums?

Kyle Cahill

Ok hear me out with this. You know the rumored jpegmafia and Danny brown collab album that may be coming out this year? How insane would a cover of feel good inc be on that album? Like, danny brown could do the first verse in his subdued voice and the other verses in his trademark yelp, and Peggy can do the choruses and peggify the beat in his own unique way. It needs to happen

Alex Soltesz

Babytron will be the ugly mane of the 2020s

Yannick Vertommen

Have you ever thought about reviewing dj-sets or mixed albums? For me, selecting the perfect tracklist and making complementing blends with various effects and techniques is one of the most creative things in music. For example albums in the FabricLive series or certain Boiler Room sets have become classics to me and I give them a spin regularly.

Aulto

Onions are severely underrated. They’re great in everything, used in most things, but when you ask people to name their favorite vegetables they never come up

Florencio

Twitter, as relevant as it is today for discussions across a broad array of topics, is one of the worst possible platforms for this. It reduces all “arguments” to a series of zingers, seeing who can bazinga the other person the hardest.

Ryan The Great

Do you think Drugs has made Artists in the past more Creative than others, Examples like David Bowie, Mac Miller, and every dad rock band that did drugs all the time.

Ryan The Great

Nujabes and J Dilla actually share the same birthday

Tyler Craig

Oooh that’s a scorching hot take. I’d say it’s Eddie Vedder

Tyler Craig

Disintegration by The Cure is the best album of the 1980’s. Not just within the context of popular mainstream music of the 80’s but across all genres. Even 40 years later, it still is one of if not the greatest album ever recorded by human beings.

Nick

If Lou Reed didn't make Lulu with Metallica. What other metal band do you think would have been a good choice for a collaboration on the record (i.e., Sunn O))), Neurosis, Kayo Dot)?

James Carlisle

i agree that Purple Hearts is a mess and that Crown is really good, but i don’t know if i can rank it alongside songs like maad city, Sing About Me, Alright or Blacker the Berry

James Carlisle

i think it can be argued that the Beastie Boys have wider appeal. they’re not just hip hop. they’ve got a lot of punk and alt rock roots as well.

James Carlisle

i don’t think i’ve ever agreed with you more than when you put Elliott Smith’s Figure 8 in the S-tier. people seem to prefer Either/Or and XO by a pretty wide margin. but i don’t think Elliott has a more well-produced or fully-realized album than Figure 8.

Larry Johnson

Kiss gets way too much unnecessary hate. Not a mega fan by any stretch and they do have a lot of duds but you can't argue with tracks like Deuce, Parasite, God Of Thunder or Creatures of the Night. They were much better at writing fun, riffy hard rock than say Guns N Roses or ACDC

Larry Johnson

I think it's just the term changing meanings. "Hardcore" to most people now mostly refers to metalcore stuff like Vein, Jesus Piece, etc. There's definitely still a lot of bands making more recognizable hardcore punk though like Spy, Soul Glo, etc.

Drake Parker

Mr Morale will go down to be Kendrick’s worst aged album because too many tracks on it live too much in the now and current events.

Slester TV

Is every classic/10 a 10/10?

Slester TV

You were a South Park kid weren't you...

Slester TV

Why albums that you gave an 8 (ex. Blonde) is on your decade lists, and not some that you gave a 9/10 (year of the snitch)? Sr it might be a dumb question but I just wanted to know.

Zavier utber

Anthony are you a Marc Bolan Cosmic Dancer type human or a Nick Cave Cosmic Dancer type human

Nick

Anthony explained this in a video but I'll explain it anyways. He didn't include Year of the Snitch and other 9's like GKMC and The Glowing Man as he didn't multiple choices to stop those artists from dominating the list (especially the top half). The rare cases where he included more than one was because he felt there was enough differences for it to not feel like the same artist (strange, I know, but I can kind of see where he was coming from).

Nick

Also, Parquet Courts and Fiona Apple were intended to make the list but were an accidental oversight due to a copy and paste error. Both most likely would've reached the Top 100 if they did.

Kieran

I dont understand the decision to delete thatistheplan, i rewatched the fader response for entertainment, and it really doesn't seem like there was anything incriminating on there, I prefered the separation from the fantano channel too, any chance of a return? Its seems like despite the vicious response, fader won