Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Content

Thanks a ton for all your support this month! Now's that magical time when you hit us with your HOT TAKES, UNPOPULAR OPINIONS, and TOUGH QUESTIONS! Drop 'em in the comments below and we'll look through them later next week. Let's go!

I considered doing a topic this month, but we'll keep it general. Y'all are of course free to branch out beyond music (though know that Anthony probably can't speak on like specific movies, shows, etc), and you can submit more than one take (if they're hot lol).

In case you missed last month's episode: https://www.patreon.com/posts/lets-argue-my-is-68424683

Comments

MV Calil

of your 10/10's, I feel like TBK is the hardest to get into if you don't follow the genre closely or have an inclination to enjoy, while TPAB is the easiest even though I believe it's the most dense of them all

Daylan Berry

KayCyy is the most important XXL Freshman of the last 3 years

Kyle Cahill

Black midi is a better band than black country new road. HOWEVER, BC;NR have better albums than Black Midi

BlueZones

If nü-metal, pop punk, and emo are all coming back in terms of mainstream appeal, we’re due for a millennial indie revival any day now. The only question is: will the influence be from the best bands of that era or the insufferable ā€œwhoa-ohā€ copycats that littered the radio in the late 2000’s/early 2010’s?

Music Guy

The Sound was the greatest Post Punk band of the late 70’s and early 80’s and was unfortunately overshadowed by contemporary bands like Joy Division and The Cure.

Zach Stolpa

If we could get one more weird Al yankovic parody album are there any particular songs you’d want him to attempt? Personally I think he’d do his own great Justice to tracks like rockstar from post Malone and humble by Kendrick. Keep on rocking in the free world Anthony.

Dalton Krause

I've heard you say multiple times you don't care much for Built to Spill, I was wondering if you could elaborate?

Josh Tate

80s is its own distinct genre. Whereas 60s, 70s, 90s, etc could mean many things. When an artist says they're doing an 80s sound we have a good idea of the meaning. As a second thought, I believe it shows the lack on variety in popular music of that decade. It reminds me to a small degree of the "trap" sound found in much of today's pop music.

TheBaseballFur

It's perfectly fine to separate art from the artist, but it's hard to justify it when the art is intended to be an outlet for the abuse the artist created. The new Sweet Trip record is an example of this, I can't listen to it anymore considering it was a vessel for Robbie to creepily confess his love to the woman he would end up sexually assaulting. There's absolutely no reason to listen to it now that the true circumstances of its creation came into light

Joseph K

Is there a reason you've never reviewed an Animals as Leaders album? They are doing some new and unique things and the only time I've heard you mention them was in a YUNOREVIEW more than 8 years ago. They took 6 years for this new album, and it was a very digestible 36 minutes. Would love to hear your thoughts on their progression as of late.

fricochet

There should be more songs about cats. The late 60s had the whimsical Phenomenal Cat (Kinks), the infamous My Pal Foot Foot (The Shaggs) and the kickass Lucifer Sam (Pink Floyd). Even dogs before the mid-70s had Martha My Dear (Beatles), I Love My Dog (Cat Stevens) and Cracker Jack (Dolly). The internet is full of pet pics, there are even feature films about them. Why don't pets get the same attention in music nowadays?

liajuju

Adele and Ariana Grande both have great voices, but their music is totally overrated. Adele's lyrics are totally basic, there's nothing really special to them. Ariana's songs are...well, as meh and basic as it gets. Yet both of them receive so much credit and praise, while someone like Lucy Dacus (who might not have the most outstanding voice, but is an amazing songwriter) does not. Many times, the voice seems to be so much more important than the actual music, which is sad.

Philip Coulam-Jones

The launch of the Sex Pistols NFTs is somehow stronger proof that whatever punk energy they had left is fully gone than the fact that fucking Disney made a show glorifying them

bressig

When boiled down to its basest essence, music exists for two reasons: to match the mood one is currently in, or to put one in the mood they wish to be in

Philip Coulam-Jones

The fact that Paul McCartney wrote two of the best songs on the White Album motivated by nothing but pure spite is both not talked about enough and extremely funny

Navarrm

What is ā€œpost rapā€ or ā€œpost hip-hopā€? I hear artists labeled this recently (Injury Reserve, They Hate Change) but there is no clear definition. As hip-hop artists already fuse other genres what defines this?

goddamneddog

Why you hating on Roc Marciano maaaane

It's Boundo

Mashup music is unfairly disrespected in more "serious" music circles because of its more recent affiliation with meme culture. In reality the only distinguishing feature between it and Plunderphonics is the recognizability of the samples. Artists like Cacola, William Maranci, and of course Neil Cicierega are creating some of the best music out there today, and are totally disregarded. Hell, The Avalanches dabbled in it with GIMIX but because it's a mashup nobody remembers it.

The Olympics

What is sex like with a vasectomy? Is there truly no change? I'm considering getting one since the new Supreme Court overturned I know you made a video about it but you didn't dig too deep into that part probably because youtube guidelines n all so I'd love to know

Tyler Craig

Mainstream Death Metal may have died in the 2000’s but the movement in the underground revitalized it in a way that isn’t very much acknowledged by people in general. Some of the advancements in the underground Death Metal scene are largely felt in the newer ā€œOld School Death Metalā€ revival bands that are making waves in the current scene. Bands like Deeds of Flesh, Disgorge, Skinless, etc. need to be given more credit for moving the genre forward artistically and are largely responsible for the new generation of bands we have now.

Thomas Ratcliff

I think Peggy should cover country roads take me home

Jake Perry

Can one have TOO positive an outlook on music? I’ve got about 1,700 ratings on my RYM page and maybe 5% of them are below a 6/10. Most music just kind of hovers in the ā€œthis is okā€ area rather than actually being BAD in my opinion.

Trevor Young

Radiohead is never coming back. Everything from The Smile album could have been on a Radiohead album, but Thom & Jonny chose not to. I think that's pretty clear evidence that they're done with RH.

Slester TV

We're just a step behind from a new guitar revival, as the strokes/white stripes/libertines etc. did with the garage rock revival in, we just need a fresh sound, something that will receive interest from the alternative youth.

Slester TV

Is every classic you have reviewed certainly a 10?

Yannick Vertommen

Have you ever thought about reviewing dj-sets or mixed albums? For me, selecting the perfect tracklist and making complementing blends with various effects and techniques is one of the most creative things in music. For example albums in the FabricLive series or certain Boiler Room sets have become classics to me and I give them a spin regularly.

Nathaniel

Why does everyone I ask say they listen to a little bit of everything but, then when I ask for some artists they recommend their only answer is ever drake like multiple people at my work have only listed drake as a musician they like

Josh

Anthony's thighs are too massive, Melon are you using steroids?

Jessssssse

Julian Casablancas has a right to do whatever he wants on stage. Artists are not performing monkeys, and if he wants to psychobabble in the dark for 5 minutes between 3 minute songs that's fine. Rock and roll and unpredictability, doing what you want and spontaneity go hand in hand, people need to stop whining.

Drake Parker

You have been overdoing the zoom in edits on your face in your videos lately

MAK the Hoosier

A drummer should not be required to start a band if you can perform songs to their intended BPMs (or even transpose their tracks to a more fitting BPM during sound-check). This might be the starvation of drummers in my area talking, but it could also open doors to more sonic development blending pre-arranged tracks with post-fx with live instrumentation or even having someone there to manipulate live instrumentation alongside the drum tracks and post-fx.

Jack Darnell

The more people on the cover of a Kendrick album, the better it is.

Squanto

Sonic Youth were not one of the best noise rock bands of the 1980s. Their sound was a little too measured and lacked the rawness of other noise rock bands. While they wrote some iconic tunes, bands like Big Black or Flipper were far more essential to the development of the genre and took the genre to new extremes. Songs About Fucking or Album - Generic Flipper > Daydream Nation all day.

Squanto

No, he gave Thriller an 8 and Give Up a 9 on RYM.

Squanto

Too bad we don’t have anything in the mainstream all that fresh sounding. Just a bunch of microwaved pop punk sounds.

Espiale

JIK is actually a good album and the best of Ye's late career, including TLOP and KSG. Yes, some of the lines are cringe, but he's been like this since Yeezus. Remember that line about the "sweet and sour sauce"? I'll grant that you've been consistent, Melon, in your criticisms of Ye whenever he's been too self-absorbed, but other reviewers who have liked his arrogance in the past have no ground to stand on. The beats on JIK can go toe to toe with any other Ye album, and let's be honest, that's what most of us listen for anyways.

Herbieguy

Michael Jackson's "Bad" was a much better album than Thriller. Thriller is still a great album, of course, but even the highest highs on there could never reach the quality of Smooth Criminal, Dirty Diana, or the STEVIE WONDER duet. Michael just really hit it out of the park with that follow up.

Spencer Maples

You're too hard on Green Day's American Idiot. You cite the George Bush commentary as one of its issues, but there are only 2-3 tracks on the entire project that can be described as that. It's no masterpiece, but its ambition, cultural impact, and passion deserves more credit than you've given it.

Alex Sim

It's surprising that we've hardly seen any concept albums about the climate crisis in recent years - Plastic Beach set the bar incredibly high, but there's definitely even more to be said on the issue than there was back in 2010. Do you think the next generation of musicians (as early as today's early teens) will bring about a surge of music dealing with that anxiety/fear?

Logan Heberg

If every rapper is at 100% of their potential, then Kanye is the goat

Logan Heberg

When rating an album, do you have different standards for different artists, or are all of your albums rated on the same scale? For example, do you think that lil pumps self titled album is actually better than MBDTF, or is something like a 4 from Kanye or Kendrick significantly better than a 7 from someone like lil pump?

Logan Heberg

Ye is Kanye’s most underrated album and I cannot understand why people hate it so much. It’s my personal favorite and I feel like it’s a snapshot into the madness of Kanye for about 25 mins. The production is great and I feel like it’s one of, if not the, most personal Kanye album. Although it’s only been a couple years since the release, I think it’s aged well and will continue to age well in the future.

Haeden Newport

A DAW has become a much more important tool for a musician than a guitar or piano.

Haeden Newport

Do you think you've already heard the best song you'll ever hear? šŸ¤”

Cordelia Smith

What songs would you put in a hyperpop/bubblegum bass Weird Al medley?

I, II, II, IL

The best Incubus song is Crawling in the Dark by Hoobastank

Flamboy

Bring Me The Horizon is the most forward thinking rock band currently. They’ve never cared about opinions of others and followed their distinctive experimental route which resulted in achieving huge success in their scene, and they still manage to make music that feels very contemporary while paying homage to screamo/post punk music of the y2k era. Also, i can’t think of many other bands that manage to make really good catchy songs while still having lots of heavy elements (screams, breakdowns) in them. Don’t understand why some people hate them so much

Yannick Trapp

Kendrick Lamar's "Godspeed for women's rights" at his recent Glastonbury Performance is absolutely ridiculous considering Kodak Black, a rapist, is all over Mr. Morale.

Josh Tate

Lyrical rap is marketed to white cis males.

Nick

He thinks their music is generic indie rock. He addressed this in a let's argue called TPAB is a stupid title.

Dalton Krause

Oh damn I missed that! Thanks for the heads up. Has to be my least favorite take I've ever heard from melon though, lol.

Nick

And landfill indie in the UK!

Nick

If you were forced to erase either Stairway to Heaven or Bohemian Rhapsody from music history. Which one would you choose and why?

Andrew Shaktah

After their successful cover of Boyz-N-The Hood Dynamite Hack should’ve doubled down and just did acoustic versions of popular rap songs

Tómas Gauti Jóhannsson

Indie bands shout way too often "Hey!" in their songs. It's more clichƩ than a garage rock bands yelling "Woo!"

po gal

I think the comparison doesn't work because Sonic Youth is not going for the full on rawness of the noise rock sound in the first place. Their focus has always been "beauty disguised in noise" with the esoteric tunings and more melodic guitar riffs they employ.

po gal

Even Perfect From Now On? Damn.. That is a bad take lol

po gal

Do you have an artist or band that you've gotten bored with even if you still acknowledge it's greatness? I feel this way especially with bands that are more on the progressive side like Radiohead and Pink Floyd because their music played such an integral part in my younger years and I feel like I don't get anything new out of listening to them again.

Stefan Lal

In rym style ranking all your 9s would be 10s. Because there’s no 0, so everything between 0 and 1 would be a 1, everything between 6 and 7 would be a 7 and so on. So you have a lot more 10s in a 1-10 style ranking. Just am interesting thought

Rowe Reviews

What was the weakest year in the 2010s music-wise for you? I know you find tons of albums to love each year, but if you had to pick the weakest what would it be?

Caspa

I feel like when it comes to Rap there are cities and states that have their own sound. Unfortunately we in CT don't have our own sound because we're always striving to pull sound from New York and what's trendy from other places .

Abe Froman

Would you ever consider doing another worst to best? Or are tier lists gonna be the exclusive ranking format? I personally enjoy both, but I can see how the tiered lists can be less incendiary

membertatooine

Peter Hook is a better vocalist than Barney Sumner.

Jac

Anyone who thinks natto is weird and gross hasn't thought hard enough about cheese

MarrrditusAurelius

you might be right. I was at a party where young people kept playing Soundgarden, Alice in Chains, STP and etc. and admiring the guitars. Not sure if they did that as a troll. Been pondering this.

MarrrditusAurelius

Agreed. "Speed Demon" as a song and also as part of the Moonwalker film package is almost too perfect.

Squanto

This take… IT’S NOT GOOD

Squanto

I get they have more of an alt-rock sound, but they often get propped up as one of the best punk/noise rock bands of that era and I just see other bands as meeting that standard better. I’d rather listen to Atomizer over Goo for instance

James Carlisle

do you think there's some level of objectivity that goes into music reviewing/analysis? or do you think music is entirely a subjective thing? i ask bc sometimes i *prefer* one piece of music to another, although i would say *objectively* that the other one is better. for example, i would *objectively* say Ziggy Stardust is the best David Bowie album (in part due to its influence and cultural relevance). but my *favorite* David Bowie album is Low. it's kind of like how you ranked MBDTF second in your Kanye worst to best, although you seem to prefer a half-dozen other albums of his.

Drake Parker

What prompt would you want to put into a craiyon-esque AI for music?

Squanto

2013 had a lot of overrated hip-hop albums

Dylan Haddad

As a Lebanese-French fan of yours, I see you don't review more international music like French which is quite "popular" nowadays because it is not appealing to your general audience

Dylan Haddad

Algorithm is the reason people usually tend to listen to one particular style of music and listen to tracks rather than albums. In a way, algorithms are why people are so narrow-minded and are not able to discover new music. The recommended for you page ruins discovery.

Logan Heberg

Kodak Black - Back for Everything, is actually a pretty decent project. Sleek and futuristic production matched with some pretty catchy hooks and good bars from Kodak.

Jake Bell

There’s no artists that make party music anymore. DJs have been play the same songs since the 2000s. There’s a few artists with some hits that fit a mainly mainstream dance floor (Bruno Mars, Cardi B, Dua Lipa) but for the most part, as a DJ I’m left wanting more from these superstars.

JĆørgen

All Things Must Pass by George Harrison is not only the best post beatles solo record by any of the members, but also better than almost all of The Beatles discography.

Alex Baradarvar

do you have any plans for when you hit 3 million subscribers?

The Needle Drop

you might need to watch more youtube if you think *we* over-edit šŸ˜… but it is an interesting topic. can't speak for the ones Anthony puts in reviews, but when i do a zoom in a fantano vid it's either (most obvious) it makes sense w/ the commentary, or (less obvious) the shift in framing helps a bit if i have to make a tight cut. it's sort of an easing thing

Patrick L

Hardcore has been becoming much more prevalent in mainstream music with bands like Turnstile and Knocked Loose, and Code Orange becoming extremely commercially successful. Perhaps a new generation of heavy music is culturally due? Who knows!

Aulto

How do I discover good music from a genre im not familiar with without becoming ā€œone of those people who only listen to the hitsā€? Maybe it sounds dumb, but there are genres I want to explore but just don’t know how

jay

ska is one of the most promising revivals in recent times, and has some of the biggest room to adapt to modern music trends/ideas such as Eichlers' ability to fuse hyperpop and ska with the My Checkered Future EP.

James Carlisle

Figure 8 is a 10 and I’m tired of pretending it’s not

Andrew Shaktah

With Death Grips releasing GMATRO and lesser known/unreleased singles, do you see it as a sign that they’re closing the books for good or teasing something new?

liajuju

When is the Let's Argue coming out?