Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Content

Thanks so much for all your support this month! Now's that magical time when you hit us with your HOT TAKES, UNPOPULAR OPINIONS, and TOUGH QUESTIONS! Drop 'em in the comments below and we'll look through them next weekend. Let's go!

For this month let's try emphasizing the TOUGH QUESTIONS part of the prompt, as those tend to yield some interesting responses. Maybe it'll end up being more like a Q&A, but that'd be fine for a change.

In case you missed last month's episode: https://www.patreon.com/posts/lets-argue-no-69785467

Comments

Lousey

Streaming has KILLED hidden tracks. There's no more charm and nuance in finding a hidden song on a record through digital means, and most artists don't even bother anymore.

Music Guy

When artists release multiple singles it’s a massive detriment to the album listening experience.

Alex Baradarvar

What made an album like Welcome to the Madhouse by Tones and I or X by Ken Carson deserving of a formal review that gets a 0 rather than a NOT GOOD?

bressig

is Duel of the Fates the only good thing to come out of the Star Wars prequels?

Herbieguy

Ok this should be a fun one: What is the most annoying and/or confusing instance of "You gave [album] a [score], but [different album] a [different score]?" that you've ever dealt with in one of your comment sections.

TheBaseballFur

Let's Argue is becoming more of a Q&A than you arguing with bad takes

adamlatif

honest and genuine question with good intention, just curious: in a recent NMF stream you queued up a song by central cee (doja) which started off with a line that I’m sure I don’t need to remind you of, you decided to skip it immediately due to its ignorance and sensitivity (correct me if I’m wrong). If that’s the case, why don’t you feel the same about music that glorifies murder, violence, and death, in extremely and purposely ignorant ways when these topics can be just as sensitive or deep-rooted to people who have suffered loss?

Enrique LG

During the 2010s you gave five albums a 10. With your new These Albums Are 10s videos, you have given us five albums from the 2000s/1990s that you think are 10s, yet you seem to imply that there are a lot more albums from those eras that are also 10s to you (the same will probably apply to 60s, 70s and 80s). Do you think that the 2010s are, at least in terms of "flawless" albums, a weaker era compared to the rest (specially since in just two years you've give two 2020s albums a 10)? Will there be "high 9" albums from the 2010s that in the future you reconsider as 10s, or do you just think that in the 2010s less "perfect" albums were made? Keep the good work up, huge fan from Spain, love your reviews, specially the positive ones.

MAK the Hoosier

Dismissing a video game soundtrack for being all licensed tracks is not fair as if done right, it can better accompany a game's pace and vibe. If the Pro Skater series just threw whatever songs together that'd be cheap over getting endorsements from Hawk (and potentially other skaters from the game), we might not have held those games in as high regard.

Stefan Lal

Does your enjoyment or appreciation of albums/songs or any other kind of art get influenced by reviews, critics or just friends’ opinions? Does fantano get fantanoed?

Jackson Keeley

How would you feel if YouTube implemented a creator-controlled option to filter video comments similar to Twitch’s subscriber only chat? I’m often disappointed by wanting to hear more relevant and genuine responses to your videos, though most are identical 6 year old memes

Arby

If you could only exist in a world with one sub-genre of metal, which would you choose?

Navarrm

Will the segment, “worst songs of my adolescence” get another installment?

Jordan Fairbairn

Artists who remove their back catalogue after getting a hit are disrespectful to the fans. While I understand if some of those songs don’t represent you anymore, it doesn’t matter as those songs aren’t yours at that point they are the fans’.

Kegan Padot

What’s your favorite song by an artist you otherwise despise the output of?

Rockstarrzz

Are there any albums that you massively respect for it's influence, or maybe it's story or concept, but don't care for it's music whatsoever?

Espiale

Would you agree that an album with half hits and half bad filler songs is better than an album of lukewarm songs, even if you give them the same score? Imo, an album with five 10/10 songs and five 4/10 songs is better than an album with ten 7/10 songs even if they have the same average. Personally, if a song is only a 7 for me, I'm only going to listen to it a few times (unless it's part of a 9/10 album or something). On the other hand, I'll play 10/10 songs hundreds of times, so I get much more mileage out of an uneven album than a mediocre one.

Dennis Vilensky

How much does the person/publication that introduces you to a new artist/song/album influence how much you end up liking it? (If at all)

Rowe Reviews

What's the worst musical performance you've witnessed at a bar/restaurant? (if any)

Cordelia Smith

You have to remove one of your 10s from existence. What album do you do this with?

Lachlan Varley

Fantano Let’s Argue While I do respect much of your reviews on electronic music I also think you very much neglect much of the music that has come out focusing more on extravagant releases through hyper-pop and glitchcore etc. avoiding focusing on artists who may not suit your needs but will very much work with your audience of listeners who would be looking for new music through artists such as DJ Rashad, Anomalie, Mid-Air Thief and KNOWER (who’s artist Louis Cole you did review), Kyoto jazz massive and more. I feel there a points like floating points where you do acknowledge this but I find electronic music is either towards popular artists or speaking about the most out there and experimental artist without reviewing people in the middle like those above machinedrum and more.

Drake Parker

Do you ever feel responsible for the success and popularity of certain artists? I feel like if it weren’t for your reviews basically sparking the memes, someone like NAV would’ve been forgotten about years ago. Does it make you feel a certain way that a lot of NAV commentary always falls back to your Not Good reviews?

Jake Bell

when was the last time you listened to an older record that you really enjoyed? It seems like there’s no new music to you besides that of which hasn’t been released anymore lol

MusicEnjoyer8

You should do redux scores for all Ye solo albums and then rank them.

I, II, II, IL

There is nothing wrong about saying your favourite song by a band/artist is one of (or their) most popular song(s) because it’s the one that got you into said band/artist. For example my favourite Jimmy Eat World song is Pain, because I discovered the band through that song.

Spencer Maples

If I were to guess, you listen to your 8’s and 9’s far more often than your 10’s

Joseph K

Hot Take: If you’ve never been moved to tears by a song before, you don’t love music.

Lauch1337

I am really curious why you did not compare the vocals of the new Chat Pile record with the vocalstyle of Alexis Marshall. Do you think that they are too different? Or do you try to not give him anymore promotion on your channel?

Zach Stolpa

Where has the worst to best series gone? Have you outright put the series on hold or just have not found other artists/acts you feel have a wide enough discography that’s warrant a worst to best video?

Nick

This modern post-punk scene coming out of Britain is a mess. For every one band you get with a fresh, interesting and unique style like BCNR, BM or Squid, another band like Yard Act or Dry Cleaning comes along with a flat and derivative style that are bogging the scene down and impeding it's innovative capabilities. I even feel like some of the artists within this movement are aware of it's shortcomings as they are moving on to other sounds, as heard with BCNR and BM this year.

lowkeymatt

I agree that streaming services should be paying artists more for their work. But, I think a lot of the conversation is coming from people that are frustrated that their music isn't doing good, either because their not putting in enough promo or it's not good.

Casey Carrington

I would’ve liked you and rick beato to touch on guitar solos. He said he wants to build the therory chops of the next generation of hit makers why spend a single second teaching guitar solos thenđŸ€”

FredDenza

If Throbbing Gristle was an up and coming band today, Genesis would already be in jail

ToadMan101

Dove Cameron is a recent example of that. I was a really big fan of two of the songs she made (Waste & LazyBaby), and I thought her biggest hit Boyfriend was okay for what it was, but it kinda left a sour taste in my mouth after finding out her older songs were no longer available on any streaming services. Then, during a later interview, she used the same “those songs don’t represent my current direction” excuse. 
Okay? People like myself still like those songs though?

ToadMan101

Co-headlining tours are always a cool thing, but you always have to make sure the lineup makes sense instead of just throwing random artists out there. Personally, one example of a tour that worked out well was the Hella Mega Tour (Weezer, Fall Out Boy, Green Day), as the three acts have relatively similar music backgrounds, have similar fanbases, and are all under the same management. What would have been the Fame Kills tour before it got cancelled however (Kanye West, Lady Gaga), doesn't really make sense to me. Sure both names did change the mainstream landscape, but that's about it in terms of similarities. But maybe that's just me not haven been aware of the music scene in 2009.

Alex Sim

people that don't get Leonard Cohen haven't heard him with post-breakup ears :(

Philip Coulam-Jones

Is it worse for a project to be bad because its creative ideas come from somewhere that is inherently unable to lead to good art or for one to have potential (based on the artist's previous work/talent) and try to say or do nothing of substance? I.E. is it worse to be a Nostalgia Critic's The Wall or an Honestly Nevermind?

Lousey

Are there any "classic" records you haven't listened to yet?

Hogan99

Why do you hate Meat Is Murder so much by the smiths??

Sam Horton

While Carti has done well and created almost a cult following around his music and tour, he doesn't get enough love for the legitimate avante-garde performance style and persona he has built. Who else can go on stage, make demonic screams, and have a crowd go that crazy? I think his performance fits the music perfectly and was certainly one the most unique concerts I have been to.

5hine

What elements make a song "new wave"? Personally, it's a very loosely-defined genre to encompass songs with synthesizers, yet there is much more depth that gets buried.

MusicEnjoyer8

Donda has redefined what a Christian album is. Rather than providing topical insight that you would see on other Christian albums, the sounds and direction itself create a spiritual experience. Traditional gospel influences are present but he distorts them to create a surreal and fresh sound. Kanye allows his guests to tell real and gritty stories and censors them so that they can more genuinely express their encounters with faith without having to sanitize the content. It weaves commercial appeal and genuine expression of faith without putting itself in a stringent box like other Christian records.

Jay Wilson

is pop music out of new ideas? some of the most popular music of today is just rehashes of old trends: ‘80s sheen and balladry (thanks abel); ‘90s/‘00s pop punk, emo, and nu metal; and huge early ‘10s synthpop. revivals have always been a thing in pop music (‘60s folk revival, swing revival), but i can think of few distinct new elements of modern pop music. looking back on this time, i think it’ll be hard to distinguish today’s throwback hits from the original hits they’re aping.

tMinozaJ

Hot take but I don’t think Alexis Marshall invented tortured screaming on a record

tMinozaJ

What’s up with the prevalence of post-punk dads who don’t listen to any rap besides Run The Jewels? Seems like there’s something going on there

Drake Parker

Why don’t you call us your Needle Drops anymore?

Larry Johnson

People unfairly shit on slam as the worst death metal subgenre, but there's quite a lot of depth to the different sounds within it, not all of it is dum dum caveman deathcore influenced stuff like Extermination Dismemberment, and the classics of slam like Devourment's Molesting The Decapitated and Internal Bleeding's Voracious Contempt hold up really well and have influenced a lot of modern death metal of all sounds. Also the average modern slam record is more fun and memorable than the average modern tech death record.

buckfastbjork

I think they just been replaced by the tierlist format

Johnny

Chance the Rapper’s upcoming album will be AOTY. A great project will make “The Big Day” fade into oblivion and leave Chance with a very solid legacy.

Rom Jan

JID will drop album of the year

X2H

What's your process for identifying the level of production on any given project? What are some aspects or elements that give a song/album high production value to you? Is it sometimes as simple as "it just sounds good"?

Chris Hickson

Black midi fans will not be satisfied until they’re given a 10. Arguably as fierce as any fanbase in rock today

Sara

Dream Pop/Shoegaze needs to see a big resurgence in the artistic scene of it, especially besides groups like Beach House, need more Sweet Trips in the world tbh.

lazarusinashes

Because you have so much influence, your reviews can give an artist a massive boost. Does it ever give you pause when an artist you have critically praised, for example Daughters, gets outed as reprehensible? Do you ever think "damn, I gave them a platform" or something like that? Or do you accept that it's part of the job that some people you praise will not be the most favorable people? I know you took down your review of a band that you realized was NSBM affiliated, so I'm curious about your thoughts, love you melon

Caspa

All these albums are great but I want you to rank them worst to best "Ghostface -Fishscale,Public Enemy-It Takes a Nation,The Roots-Things Fall Apart ,Madvillian-Madvilliany,Outkast -Stankonia

FredDenza (edited)

Comment edits

2026-10-27 04:00 Hey Anthony, In your 2012 review of Billy Woods’ “History Will Absolve Me,” you said u hated “pointless posturing” in rap & hip hop music. How has your attitude changed in the decade since you made this statement? Has aggressive MC posturing in American rap evolved to where the music benefits from genuine and/or affected bravado? Or, In your opinion, does rap have an eternal swagger problem? Thanks, keep up the good work
2022-08-17 22:22 Hey Anthony, In your 2012 review of Billy Woods’ “History Will Absolve Me,” you said u hated “pointless posturing” in rap & hip hop music. How has your attitude changed in the decade since you made this statement? Has aggressive MC posturing in American rap evolved to where the music benefits from genuine and/or affected bravado? Or, In your opinion, does rap have an eternal swagger problem? Thanks, keep up the good work

Hey Anthony, In your 2012 review of Billy Woods’ “History Will Absolve Me,” you said u hated “pointless posturing” in rap & hip hop music. How has your attitude changed in the decade since you made this statement? Has aggressive MC posturing in American rap evolved to where the music benefits from genuine and/or affected bravado? Or, In your opinion, does rap have an eternal swagger problem? Thanks, keep up the good work

Shmuffalo

Long-time listener, first time commenter. Anywho, I was in THE go-to chatroom, America Onli.. I already hate me. Bad, hot, old-man-ish, why Charlie hate take (1)... save for the singles, Stankonia, is fine. I'm a big Cadillac (22 inch dubs, of course), Atlanta, Alien, both an Aquarius and Gemini... somehow, but not a record I replay as a whole. Bad, hot, old-man-ish, why Charlie hate take (2) ... Curren$y, with a US dollar-sign, as neither pot-head, nor have a dollar sign in $hmuffalo (wait.), makes damn good music. Albeit, too much. Covert Coup, Cigarette Boats, How Fly, New Jet City, Fetti, Verde Terrace, The Marina.. I won't name 60 projects, are outstanding. Funny wordplay, mainly earlier music, but drew me in. Sigh. Bad, hot, old-man-ish, why Charlie hate take (3) I say I'll expand upon in other posts, and forget... Drake went full Inception. Finally fully embraced he's not a rapper by way of making dogscoop music, pardon the language, saying he is "[n]ot a rapper" while spending the preceding 8 years saying he is the greatest rapper. (Part 3 was written by Christopher Nolan). Paralleling Drake going fully cripple.. fuck. Bad, hot, old-man-ish, why Charlie hate take ... I will catch up on music post-2017, and make a part 4, 5, heck, may even make it to a fuller Niner. -Shmuffalo Costanza

Shmuffalo

Biscuits. Fucking Biscuits is such a damn good song.

Anonymous

The best kind of music is the stuff that makes you feel like a kid

Ryan The Great

Pitchforks Score on Back to Black is Wack despite the review being good

Zach Stolpa

Down the line would you be interested in doing content regarding video game OST’s?

James Carlisle (edited)

Comment edits

2026-10-27 04:00 Mr. Morale & The Big Steppers has grown on me the same way The Life of Pablo did. both albums are a mess production-wise, but very consistent narrative-wise. they're both incredibly eccentric. they're both brutally honest reflections of self, warts and all. i guess what i'm trying to say is, why no yellow flannel, Mr. Tano?
2022-08-24 01:50 Mr. Morale & The Big Steppers has grown on me the same way The Life of Pablo did. both albums are a mess production-wise, but very consistent narrative-wise. they're both incredibly eccentric. they're both brutally honest reflections of self, warts and all. i guess what i'm trying to say is, why no yellow flannel, Mr. Tano?

Mr. Morale & The Big Steppers has grown on me the same way The Life of Pablo did. both albums are a mess production-wise, but very consistent narrative-wise. they're both incredibly eccentric. they're both brutally honest reflections of self, warts and all. i guess what i'm trying to say is, why no yellow flannel, Mr. Tano?

Anonymous

Fandingus I went to a UK hardcore festival recently in which Injury Reserve were playing. I was very excited to see them but they had by far the smallest crowd on the stage and there were very few of the people who were there were enjoying their set. I've always thought heavier hip-hop acts like injury reserve, death grips and peggy had a lot in common with the hardcore scene. Why do you think it didn't go down well?

Tuck

They Might Be Giants are the most prolific, most idiosyncratic, versatile, and therefore BEST pop duo of all time and don't receive the credit they deserve. My fav band of all time :) Also you should do a classic review of your fav TMBG record

Samantha

Chromatica is Lady Gaga's best album in terms of flow. The Fame Monster had more iconic songs but between The Fame, The Fame Monster and the deluxe version of The Fame Monster that most streaming services default to there isn't really a canon tracklist. If you don't listen to the deluxe you don't get every essential track, but if you do listen to the deluxe its 90 minutes long and not every track is worth listening to. Chromatica is a tight 43 minutes, each song flows into the next seamlessly and it boasts the best features of any Gaga album as well. Truly the best experience Gaga has given us in album format.