Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Content

Thanks a ton for all your support this month! Now's that magical time when you hit us with your HOT TAKES, UNPOPULAR OPINIONS, and TOUGH QUESTIONS! Drop 'em in the comments below and we'll look through them next week. Let's go!

In case you missed last month's episode: https://www.patreon.com/posts/lets-argue-do-i-71283409

Comments

bressig

Duel of the Fates is a certified banger

Kathryn Streeter

K Flay is one of the best lyricists and most creative musicians of all time. My mind will never change about this.

8hu

EDM despite it's rampant popularity will never truly be mainstream

Nicholas Barron

Ska will never make a comeback unless it stops being a parody of 90’s third wave. Jeff Rosenstock’s Ska dream and Streetlight Manifesto are the only things pushing what ska can be and streetlight hasn’t put out an album in almost 10 years.

Joseph K

When you go into an album with high expectations, do you get worried like I do when the album art sucks? Like if it were amazing they certainly would have gotten something better right? šŸ˜…

Caleb John Cushing

"Separate the art from the artist" is a result of a culture that prioritizes entertainment's capacity to generate capital over human beings and their health and safety. The systems that uphold abuse and inequality benefit far more from this school of thought than anything else. What good does "art" as a means to understand and enhance the human experience do if the human beings themselves are subject to horrific abuse and mistreatment?

Joseph K

personally I'm a fan of his grey denim vest look.

Dan Riskey

I really like your videos when you talk about times you've changed your opinions on albums, are there any albums you didn't rate a 10 at the time of your review that became 10s over time?

Rad Antonov

You’ll regret not giving The Forever Story a 10/10, umm forever šŸ˜†

Calum Hughes

Limp Bizkit and others did great performances at Woodstock 99, some were iconic even. The responsibility for the festival falling apart were solely on the part of the organisers and upper management. Many of whom still never truly acknowledged their many failures to the attendees.

Kdotisthegoat

Relapse is really good album. Accents and cringey lyrics made people hate this album but it has very great rhymes, incredible flows and superior Dre’s beats. Much better than Recovery or other newer Em’s works.

A Dizzy Bat

Hey buddy; I think you should bring back the soft: "...track reviews" muttered refrain from the Track Reviews theme song! This change was made a while ago, but I miss mouthing along to it every time.

NevadaNate

I am in no way a fan of Sam Hunt, but I found out that the woman mentioned in Southside is his wife and that Drinking Too Much was an apology track for her, not a desperate attempt to reach out as you suspected. They were and currently are married and claim to be happy. Does this affect your view on that song or the whole album at all?

Julian Balboa

Why don't you review musicals? If you feel you would be unqualified for whatever reason to fully review a musical by yourself, maybe you could review collaborate with someone who has specialized knowledge in musicals like Sideways. I think people would be interested in that content with your extensive musical knowledge and critical thinking.

Herbieguy

Patrick Bateman actually had pretty good taste in music. I know the author intended for him to have very bland, generic 'mass appeal' taste, but frankly there was much better targets he could have picked for representing that niche. In Too Deep? Lady in Red? Greatest Love of All? I'm sorry, but those are some excellent 80s classics!

Hogan99

Do you like anything RHCP has done or have you always hated them?

Lousey

Minimalism almost always works better than maximalism when it comes to a projects core conception. My Beautiful Dark Twisted Fantasy < Silent Shout

Cole

because your baldness is a stylistic decision on your behalf, you are not considered to be part of the bald community

Spencer Maples

There are numerous albums you wish you could go back and give a 10 and Atrocity Exhibition is one of them

Duke86fan

what older albums do you think aren't 10s but deserve a mention in a fantano video?

Lousey

Additionally, this kind of attitude makes people hyper-focused on the abusers in question, to which we owe no attention. Art is a reflection of the environment it was created in, so how could you possibly separate the art from the artist?

Alex R

It might be my inner songwriter, but it feels extremely disrespectful and invasive to enjoy music that someone else wrote, especially when it's about a really deep and painful topic (thinking Mount Eerie's A Crow Looked At Me). We're looking into someone's life pretty deeply, and unless you're also putting that spotlight on yourself by performing music or poetry or something to express yourself, it feels kinda rude.

NevadaNate

You're putting a spotlight on yourself by releasing music. Period. Don't want someone to hear it = don't make it accessible

Adrian Vargas

Has any of Mac Miller's music grown on you more since your initial reviews of them & his passing?

Drake Parker

You should name any food-related Let’s Argue episodes, ā€œLettuce Argueā€ (as a bonus, you welcome our hot steaks, unpopular onions, and tough quesadillas)

Jac

I kinda think minimalism ages better too, but I have no basis for that except a vague feeling it is so

Jac

There are a few artists I really respect without wanting to regularly listen to their music. What do you do with projects that you admire artistically and technically, but just don't appeal to your personal aesthetic taste? Bonus: also stuff that's kinda rubbish but you like it anyway? Like junk-food music?

Jac

Slightly off topic but how come you've never reviewed an Ezra Furman project, even in WYNR?

tMinozaJ

Does this mean you aren’t interested in my Sublime - Waiting For My Ruca 160bpm Hardstyle OTT Blasted Remix?

tMinozaJ

Idk dude it’s kinda got a long way to evolve considering Drake just invented it this year

tMinozaJ

ā€œPatrisse Cullors Stole My Lunch Moneyā€ is the hardest track name of the year

Alex Sim

What are your picks for albums that have biggest imbalance between influence and (personal) listenability? Like I *know* the Ramones debut is important as hell but I think the last time I listened to Blitzkrieg Bop was when that Jimmy Neutron clip rudely invaded my twitter feed

Nick

Given how horribly underpaid musicians are these days. Do you think that Patreon is a good option for them to be turning to? Musicians could offer livestreams with loads of options to go from with that, tutorial videos on their respective instruments, early access to specific songs etc. All the while forming stronger bonds with their fans in the process.

Manuel Marcos GalvƔn

I think the fact that you totally overlooked the track ā€œ2007ā€ off The Forever Story really influenced your final thoughts, because it is an essential closer which completes the narrative JID brings to the table. I mean, there has been other times when you took into account songs that hadn’t made it to the streaming services (LP! of JPEGMAFIA being a recent example), and those were vital in your analysis. So, in a way, I feel like including ā€œ2007ā€ the review would’ve felt more complete; even with the album getting a 10/10.

Zach Stolpa

do you think we are at a point where artists are more expected to be on the producer side if they aren’t in the traditional band or group especially in hip hop/r&b with how beat making and the music process has evolved? you look at notable artists (Andre 3000, Kanye west, Tyler the creator, etc) and how their influence in doing that gives an impression to artists on having an approach to the full body of a song.

Josh Brown

Anthony, how do you maintain such a stoic demeanor when interviewing some of the greatest creative minds of our generation? Melon straight up listened to a first-hand account about a studio session with Kendrick and if he had creamed his pants it didn't show. Lord knows I would have just ran around the room and collapsed screaming like a awkward little goose.

Nathaniel

Great albums that require prior knowledge(Atrocity Exibition for example) to enjoy are annoying because I can't just show a song to a friend with out like doing some game of catch up or saying if you listened to this then you'd like this.

Nathaniel

He, gave it a 9 what more do you want

Amealya Hike

I cant believe goo by sonic youth wasn't mentioned in your best of the 90's let's argue video

lazarusinashes

You always say that you respond to the "best ones" in these segments, but what specifically makes a take one of the "best ones?" What, in your opinion, makes for something worth replying to (beyond the typical cold takes like "this album good" or "this artist good")? Is there a criteria, or just something you haven't heard before?

Chris Hickson

There’s a lot of conversations about best albums of all time, but what about the best EP’s of all time? Though obviously not as discussed and scrutinized as albums, I feel the topic is worth discussing. Minor Threat EP and Lil Ugly Mane’s Uneven Compromise would be two of my picks

Florencio

Writing with humor is an undervalued skill. The ability of songwriters like Stephen Merritt or David Berman (RIP) to make you laugh during a song, especially when the topic is actually quite serious or emotional, seems incredibly hard, and lands them among my favorite songwriters.

Drake Parker

I know you’re typically against doing redux reviews, but I feel like Happier Than Ever absolutely deserves a re-review. It’s not exactly because of the score, but because the review is so overly negative despite giving it a 7. Even if it isn’t as musically impressive as WWAFA, lyrically the album is very dense and pivotal to Billie’s career and I feel it deserved way more praise than what you actually gave it in the review

Zach Stolpa

Whenever you’ve talked about graduation by Kanye west you for the most part have talked about it sounding dated and a product of the music at the time. I’d honestly have to disagree given how consistent the album is (only 2 throw away tracks being Barry bonds and drunk n hot girls) and the electronic music Elements it incorporated in the productin for the most part of the album. You said the album reeked of the bling era, did you mean like with Kanye’s rapping? Do tell, thanks always.

Jack Darnell

John Williams has the best music videos if you think about it.

Aidan Brooks

Joji is only capable of making one amazing track every album cycle. With his last two albums, the big single from each (being slow dancing and run) have been head over heels the best tracks on their respective albums with nothing on the rest of the record being able to compare. While I hope my theory is proven wrong on his upcoming album, I’m scared the the phenomenal Glimpse of Us will be the clear standout track.

Paul Jack

Yellow Submarine is an overlooked album in the Beatles discography. Most people write it off immediately because the assume the whole album will sound like the title track, but the George Martin instrumentals in the second half are some of the prettiest songs ever written.

Dirty Randy

Does the inclusion of 2007 change your final rating of The Forever Story? JID has made it pretty clear that it is the true final track to the album; adding it onto the end gives the album a much stronger closing. For me, 2007 is the one of the most (if not the most) inspiring tracks I’ve ever had the pleasure of hearing and could possibly bring the rating up to a 9.9 and possibly even a 10? p.s. I don’t find the beat on Stars tedious at all. The beat, JID’s flows and themes on his verses are pretty clear nods to his inspirations and contemporaries (Kanye, Andre, Kendrick, Mac). The whole track just seems like an extremely tasteful payment of respects

Dirty Randy

A review of the complete album šŸ’€

Dirty Randy

The Peps just need a new lead singer. Perhaps one Anthony FANTANO could replace? Fans probably wouldn’t even notice the change in Tony.

Tuck

They Might Be Giants are the most prolific, idiosyncratic, and BEST pop duo of all time, and deserve much more credit than they receive. Not to mention how forward thinking they were in terms of marketing back in the day with Dial-a-Song and their early embrace of the internet. My favorite band of all time, would love to see a classic review of your favorite TMBG record! I'm assuming Lincoln?

Jack Guenther

Steve Miller Band is just a better version of The Eagles

Caspa

So I seen you give your praises to Big Daddy Kane and Biz but what are your thoughts on projects from other Juice Crew members like Masta Ace and Kool G Rap?

Alex Alcalde

Putting Nicki Minaj in your top 55 rappers list of all time but not Dr Dre amongst others, should be more criticized on.

Slester TV

Weezer's debut is pretty good, but pavement's Crooked Rain, Crooked Rain, is the real deal. It is more experimental, and more risky with better lyrics, and you can see pavement's influence on Blue Album.

goddamneddog

where is the classic review for maroon 5 songs about jane mane