Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Content

Thanks so much for all your support this month! Now's that magical time when you hit us with your HOT TAKES, UNPOPULAR OPINIONS, and TOUGH QUESTIONS! Drop 'em in the comments below and we'll look through them next week. Let's go!

In case you missed last month's episode: https://www.patreon.com/posts/lets-argue-edm-72667647

Comments

BlueZones

“69 Love Songs” is the best album of the nineties based on sheer capacity of quality music alone. That’s not even to mention the audacity to pull off a project that large and varied, but conceptually unified, that could’ve failed spectacularly. It truly is an indie pop marvel.

Joseph K

Can anyone be a vocalist? There have been so many strange vocalists across music, I hesitate to believe there is a voice that couldn’t work if properly directed.

bressig

First Utterance by Comus is an underappreciated gem of progressive and freak folk and could definitely connect with younger generations if rediscovered due to its unique and timeless sound

Nick Denhalter

Does being white exclude you from the rap GOAT conversation? I think my gut response would be no, but I’m not sure it doesn’t. When hearing actual discussions on different metrics for determining what qualifies someone as the GOAT I genuinely believe that Aesop Rock has a good running in every category other than mainstream success. But every time I even suggest the idea of him being in the conversation in rap circles I am not taken seriously.

Nick Denhalter

The B52s should be considered punk. They were doing the same shit DEVO and the talking heads were doing, just as good too.

Lousey

I wish you’d stop shining Drake on and just admit that he’s one of the worst modern artists

iammarcus93

Do you get burnout from listening to so much music all the time? I have to try to keep when I listen to music to when I'm alone and everything is quiet so I can actually enjoy it, having it on all the time in the background I feel like sours the experience a bit, that or I just hate the radio at work too much

goddamneddog

songs about jane is worthy of a classic review and you know it

J Fernzy

Why haven’t you addressed Toby Keith’s savage takedown of your profession in his 2003 track “the critic”

Tuck

They Might Be Giants are the most prolific, idiosyncratic, and BEST pop duo of all time, and deserve much more credit than they receive. Not to mention how forward thinking they were in terms of marketing back in the day with Dial-a-Song and their early embrace of the internet. My favorite band of all time, would love to see a classic review of your favorite TMBG record! I'm assuming Lincoln?

Tuck

I'm posting this until it gets in a video hahaha

Herbieguy

Speaking strictly on his critical reception: Drake's career would have fared much better if he just stuck to doing R&B. His 'tough guy' schtick has been a punchline used against him since day one; It's obvious nobody takes it seriously. Plus, a majority of his biggest and best hits have been the R&B centered ones anyway (ex: Take Care, Find Your Love, Just Hold On, Passionfruit). If he just stuck to being a Frank Ocean-esque crooner, he wouldn't have the giant critic-target on his back that he does now.

MV Calil

do you plan on making the 10/10 tier list like you did with 0/0's? and on that topic, would you include past 10/10's aswell for comparision purposes (like the ones you're mentioning on the decades videos)?

Tuck

While being white in hip hop doesn't exclude you from being in the conversation, and it certainly doesn't make your talent less valid, the Black experience is so significant to hip-hop's DNA, that you can't ignore what made the genre so radical and special to begin with.

J Fernzy

Do you think indie folk / Americana suffers as a genre for not having a more clearly defined sound, aesthetic, etc associated with its music and artists? As a fan of the scene I find it hard to relay how my favorite bands may seem like a mix of bluegrass, soft rock, and alternative pop/country but actually have a strong common theme between them that just doesn’t have a universally understood name.

MV Calil

rap music wouldn't reach the mainstream success it did throughout the 00's if it wasn't for Eminem, and that argument alone should qualify him to enter any hip hop GOAT conversation (besides SSLP, MMLP and TES being very good projects even though some of them didn't age that well)

Sajl Salim

How do you listen to music and continuously pay attention to it without getting distracted?

membertatooine

I think that would be pretty difficult especially after all the Daughters stuff that happened. For me, I listened to that album nonstop for the better part of three years and memorized most of the lyrics but haven't revisited it once since everything went down with Marshall. I just find that it's difficult to separate the art from the artist in that situation. Also, Anthony might feel weird with ranking YWGWYW and Sinner Get Ready in a same tier list. Idk, it's a pretty fucked situation. I'd love to see a tier list like this but just think it might be too difficult for him.

membertatooine

Can we get a New Order great to best list soon?

A Dizzy Bat

Between that interlude on the new Björk record and the recent Megan Thee Stallion track 'Scary' you've made it clear that you are really not feeling anything in the realm of tacky halloween sfx lately. Guess there'll just be more tacky shrills and shrieks for the rest of us.

NevadaNate

Green Day was never good. Half of their early singles were meme songs, their biggest era (American Idiot) was annoying and boneheaded. And then immediately they focused on creating some of the most embarrassing tracks any artist has made. Only a band as bad as Green Day would put out a song like "F*ck Time" and then somehow get worse.

Cat

Paul Jack

Yeezus is Kanye’s Pinkerton. They are both very aggressive and punchy projects that lay down all the artists flaws that get way too personal, that were panned by audiences upon release, but are now considered some of their best material by their fans.

Zach Stolpa

When it comes to the greatest drummers of all time where does taylor Hawkins land?

Robert Paul

Why is it that “Crank that (Soulja Boy)” goes so hard and makes the vibe so hyped, even though it barely has anything going on, with scant percussion and production. It’s mystifying.

Ben

To what extent do you think music is subjective, I always say there's often a deeper way to enjoy things and I personally have seperated preference and quality over-time as there are many artists I dislike listening to but still think have good music. I feel like there are so many aspects that can determine what is good/bad but I don't think it's a co-incidence that people like myself share opinions so closely with you before having even been influenced by your opinion. Usually when I disagree with you it's not over an entire track but more an element/aspect of it. Anyways, overall I don't think it's completely black or white but I think a lot of people just haven't listened to enough music to understand the relativity between artists lyrics, production, intentions etc to have a strongly formed opinion.

Owen Sidwell

In todays day and age with music being sooo easy to access, vinyl collecting is literally just hoarding, no matter how big/small the collection is. (Coming from a vinyl collector myself đŸ€“)

Alex Alcalde

Not so much of a hot take but more of a question, over your years as a music reviewer I’ve noticed you’ve been listening to more Spanish language records and albums, so have you noticed your understanding of Spanish has improved or keeps improving as you review more Spanish language albums?

Proudi

Would removing the track you put as the "least favorite" song on an album raise the overall score? I assume it varies by album but I'm curious if you think some/most of these songs are underwhelming but still key to the album.

MV Calil

you might be right, but YWGWYW and SGR aren't related as albuns (Kristin and Alexis became a couple way after the Daughters' release if i'm not mistaken) and should be analyzed on their own IMO... but yeah, i love those two records, but it's very hard for me to listen to SGR nowadays considering everything it happened

Dirty Randy

This seems like a pretty far-fetched comparison to me. The two albums basically have nothing in common other than being in the general pop sphere. Listening to the first few songs of LÉON there’s pretty much nothing attention grabbing about it and it just sounds like more of the same dreamy radio pop

Dirty Randy

Just start commenting “Lincoln” rather than typing a whole paragraph each time. In all seriousness I don’t understand your fixation with They Might be Giants. Isn’t it just a worse version of already-not-good pop duo Simon & Garfunkel?

Alex Sim

what song is making you leave the club when it comes on? (inspired by the last time i was out and 'i gotta feeling' came on. instant vibe killer and i could do nothing but limply and ironically bounce my fist in the air)

Kristofer Mc Cormack

In fashion and trustworthiness, Cal's jumper > your flannels.

Alex Sim

at the same time, it's hard to imagine him breaking into the mainstream like he did if he HADN'T been doing genre hybrids

Dbaziany

What are some of your favourite music-centric films? Could include concert films like Stop Making Sense or Documentaries like Gimme Shelter or just regular films about musicians or just the love of music

Tuck

Typing "Lincoln" would tell him nothing, because this is a Let's Argue segment where I'm trying to argue that they are the best pop duo. Also, have you even listened to TMBG? Or Simon & Garfunkel? I'm starting to think you are trolling because they don't even exist in the same realm of music. Are you okay Randy?? And the reason I'm fixated on them is because they are my favorite band of all time!

Spencer Maples

Would you ever privately critique a work in progress record? For instance, if KSI or Quadeca privately messaged you access to their next project as it was still being developed, would you be open to giving notes to improve the quality of the project before it officially releases?

Nick

Cal Chuchesta should host a Let’s Argue one day. He is an articulate and intelligent man who could easily counteract any arguments put forward in this chat. In fact, why don’t you take him for a spin right now!?

Endseeker

Lorna Shore becoming hot for a minute with a big release like Into The Hellfire and the chance to play Lollapalooza is a once in a lifetime opportunity which I don't see really happening again any time soon. They'll still get numbers and plays but metal unfortunately never gets mainstream attention unless it's mainstays like Slipknot or FFDP. I would love to see an extreme metal band like Lorna Shore or any other fantastic band the scene has to offer Reach a feat even greater than what Lorna Shore has accomplished so far but like I said. Metal doesn't get mainstream while I wish it would I can't see them topping what they have done

Gray Lefkowitz

He should also host a joke review, like for an album that might otherwise get a Not Good

Daniel H

Did you seek music from Myspace back in the day? If so, are there any artists you remember really liking, particularly ones who only released their material on the platform only for it to disappear forever when Myspace eventually purged practically everything?

tarny_doilies

Nymph sounds more like an EP than ALIAS does due to some of the songs feeling unfinished and the overall sonic incohension.

Yolooooom

Do fantano look any of the messages he gets here??? I've been trying to reach him to no avail

Jac

I miss Rizzle Kicks.

Noah

Mr. Morale has some great tracks, but it failed to live up to the premise set by The Heart Part 5. Kendrick set up a lot of interesting questions about "the culture" in that amazing teaser track, only for the album to be largely centered around Kendrick's personal psyche. It's a decent record, but it feels inconsistent in its messaging. That might be intentional but I still feel like the album is very thematically disjointed...

membertatooine

do you prep each Let's Argue response beforehand or do you have someone pick the questions for you and it's your first time reacting to them on camera?

The Needle Drop

twitter episodes: it had been mostly me, but Anthony's been picking them himself the past several months. patreon eps: still me (austen)

Caspa

Where does Radiohead rank in your list of favorite bands?

Uncle Jam

Generally speaking, producer led compilation albums don't work. There are some exceptions. (99.9% by Kaytranada and Clones by The Neptunes come to mind.) But most of the time they just feel thrown together and without any real artistic direction or purpose.

Uncle Jam

EDIT: Stuff like Louie isn't what I'm talking about. Other than basically being entirely instrumental, that feels like an album of composed music with a lot of intentionality behind it as opposed to, "Let's make a beat, throw a guest or two on it, and call it a day."

JWY

What makes an album/song "timeless"? To what extent is that even a realistic quality of music?

Drake Parker

What is the best song off of Angelic 2 The Core and what nice things can you say about it?

Zach Stolpa

Mr.morale can definitely be seen as a more personal album about Kendrick himself and with that it may be trickier to have one core message. I think also it may have been intended to just leave some stuff up for interpretation cause he doesn’t want to be the musician that is seen as like some savior to humanity that has all the answers which I totally get especially with the initial single dropped before the album.

Graham Glovka

Despite being very influential to the modern indie artists (lorde and vampire weekend to name a few) Paul Simon doesn’t get enough praise.

Purajit Malalur

Broadway isn't really culture. It has very little influence outside of its realm. No one really talked about Hamilton, even after it showed up on streaming - they mostly talked about the hype and the ticket prices, but rarely the actual play/music. It was fake hype so that Broadway could charge more and appear relevant and important, and they haven't even been able to use this attention to replicate the success - that's how separated it is from general culture. The fact that it was a hip-hop musical shows that other culture influences Broadway, but how much of culture is influenced _by_ Broadway?

zbgf

Willie Nelson doesn't quite get the respect he deserves in online music nerd circles and the general public at large. He gets plenty of love and respect, don't get me wrong, but for the man who made Phases & Stages and many other masterpieces, and has been an absolute figurehead for country music for decades, he's just been the haha funny weed man in the public's eye, and hardly talked about in music circles over more indie alt-country stuff. Which is fine, but I'm just saying, more music nerds need to blast Bloody Mary Morning

Graham Glovka

The Buckley family (Tim and Jeff) are music for people who think they like complex music but are really just pretentious. Neither of them are particularly talented but music nerds jerk them off like they’re the next coming of Christ.

Maximum Sorrell

Does David Bowie have a perfect 10? When looking at his entire body of work he's probably one of my favorite artists ever. I think he has a few albums that come really close for me but I don't think there's a "definitive" David Bowie album.

FredDenza

10/10s are a pain in the ass. No record is perfect, no performer is some kind of deity. The relentless demand for the ultimate in canonical validation is a distraction from the only thing that matters: total sonic immersion. Music evangelism is just as worthless as atheism evangelism, sports evangelism, political evangelism, etc. It’s all wasted time that could be spent discovering new music, working to earn more money to buy more new music, and then listening to all the new music humanly possible until our ears fall off.

FredDenza

Right after Raadiohead?

FredDenza

Any bikini kill single has more to say than the entirety of live through this. love is abusive, vindictive and a horrible role model with an immense amount of money and power, both of which she uses to be abusive and vindictive toward anyone in her path of destruction, including trailblazing women like Madonna for example.

FredDenza

Cool. I’d guess that the most interesting, strange & out there vocalists are almost never directed by anyone but themselves out of shear necessity; They evolved their sound in isolation. Their strangest qualities are almost always “toned down” once under direction.

Purajit Malalur

Not a fan of Drake, but _could_ his career possibly have fared any better? He's arguably, like, THE musician of the decade. Unfortunately. Anything you do at that level will be criticized by a decent number of people.

Herbieguy

Like I said I'm only referring to / focusing on his critical reception. Obviously he's not gonna be starving for money any time soon, but as evident by /certain recent events/, it's obvious the negative reception is getting to him. And I think it would have been easy for him to avoid this Nickelback-level hate crowd.

JohnnyBgood

JID is the most underappreciated rap/hip-hop artist currently.

Andrew Shaktah

King Gizzard needs to slow down a bit. I enjoy these jam session type releases but it’s gotten too hard to keep up with all the very similar sounding extended songs. Much of their recent work feels almost forgettable

Georges LaBraguette

Anaal Nathrakh is the best extreme metal band right now. Desideratum is the best album of the 2010's.

Jac

(Prompted by NMF Tallest Man on Earth + girl in red) How do you stay open to subtle music? When busy, it's easy for me to skip over tracks that don't grab my attention quickly. You're very good at sorting the heartwrenching from the schmaltz; the complex from the unstructured; the minimal from the shallow. Do you purposefully hold off judging too quickly? Cultivate attention?

Jac

Does it take longer to decide you like a track than to decide you dislike it?

Sara

Sweet Trip is pretty underrated outside their general sphere, and you don’t talk about them enough tbh

Squanto

Ziggy Stardust and Station to Station are my nominations.

Maximum Sorrell

Love both of those! Ziggy definitely comes the closest but I keep thinking if it wasn't bowie would I still love it as much just on its own? I'm not sure. I feel like I couldn't just play Ziggy Stardust and have someone see why I love Bowie. Its the same with Beck and King Gizzard.

xiu

do more skramz reviews

Drake Parker

I can’t help but feel bothered by your recent intros on the fantano channel. You never say “Hey hey hey everyone” anymore. It’s always “hey hi hello everyone” or just “hi everyone”. The “hey hey hey” is more iconic

xiu

would u be interested in starting a gay emo vegan commune with me

NevadaNate

I actually kinda disagree, I like the two new releases a lot. I also think they should focus more on extended songs and jams to keep it fresh and to avoid writing a million short "songs" where they repeat phrases over and over. They've been giving more space to the band as a whole so that it doesn't get as old.

Jac

It's catharsis via art; us bystanders are as always welcome to voice aesthetic critique but I genuinely hope it's inconsequential to its significance for Kendrick personally.

Jac

Baby Drver

Jac

No

Jac

Tucker's point is ... on point. Furthermore, Aesop Rock is a genuine artist. He is inimitable, unmistakeable, instantly identifiable, and brings something unique to the table. His chosen style of delivery is rap, at which he excels. Whether you want to call his "genre" hiphop is moot, as far as I'm concerned. Most real artists don't fit a genre neatly, so shoe-horning them into one just to criticise their authenticity is kind of bizarre. I don't give a sh*t if Aesop is hiphop enough and I hope he doesn't either. He's top tier.

Jac

@Alex Sim His career might have been less lucrative, but his external and internal validation might have been more satisfying.

Squanto

Interesting take. Personally, I feel like it is the definitive record from him during his glam era. I think Bowie’s persona is part of what makes the record stand out as much as it did during that era in time.

Squanto

I think Cal finally moved out of Anthony’s house.

Maximum Sorrell

I like that!! Tbh I do kind of fall between your take and mine but I want to know where Anthony stands xD

Nick

At this point we know for a fact that YWGWYW would probably be ranked the lowest since Anthony in a previous Let's Argue hinted that it's the 10 he would erase out of all of them.

Drake Parker

You don’t have to agree with the sentiment of a song to call it a favorite

Zavier utber

Peeing sitting down as a man should be considered as an acceptable alternative and not as an emasculating action which is an insane leap on societies part imo.

Self-Aware Onion

The 2 minute and 5 second instrumental intro in For Whom the Bell Tolls is the best intro in any piece of music ever. The ominous bells at the very start set the stage perfectly for what's to come, Cliff's distorted bass solo that follows is incredibly creative, the grimy and groovy headbanging riff after the bass solo is intense, the guitar lead that pops in at 1:16 is amazing, and the final riff of the intro (that later is restated in the chorus) leads into the verse smoothly; it is the perfect intro.

MV Calil

really? where did he do that?